From b66835ced19d5976c315ddb07a3024d85f613d58 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Luke Curley Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2026 11:50:36 -0800 Subject: [PATCH 01/13] chore(quest): claim quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md Quest-Claim: 2df820f42d974f08 From 250ad3788a5bdedec0166d2eb74ecc02411a6680 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Luke Curley Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2026 12:57:00 -0800 Subject: [PATCH 02/13] feat(watch): time-stretch the audio ring onto its target Port the shared NetEq stretch from doc/concept/audio-jitter.md into the browser's AudioRingBuffer, so live playback converges by playing slightly faster or slower instead of running dry or skipping ahead. Every replay row, relay-mic-rtt40 included, now plays with zero player underruns. Expand departs from NetEq in both players and the spec records it: below the target it ignores the cooldown and repeats every whole period that fits at the lower threshold. NetEq-exact expand left relay-mic-rtt40 at 2.1 underruns a minute. A declared end's tail drains unstretched. The ring re-anchors only at the fast threshold or three quarters of its headroom, as native does, and counts each re-anchor as audio stats `skips`, shown in the stats panel and graded as `player_skips`. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- doc/concept/audio-jitter.md | 63 ++- doc/concept/audio-jitter/stretch/corpus.json | 502 ++++++++++++++---- doc/lib/js/watch.md | 9 +- js/common/package.ts | 9 +- js/watch/WEBRTC-LICENSE | 29 + js/watch/WEBRTC-PATENTS | 24 + js/watch/api/index.api.md | 1 + js/watch/src/audio/buffer.test.ts | 12 +- js/watch/src/audio/buffer.ts | 5 + js/watch/src/audio/decoder.test.ts | 22 +- js/watch/src/audio/decoder.ts | 12 +- js/watch/src/audio/playout.test.ts | 46 +- js/watch/src/audio/render-worklet.test.ts | 2 + js/watch/src/audio/render-worklet.ts | 1 + js/watch/src/audio/render.ts | 2 + js/watch/src/audio/replay.test.ts | 15 +- js/watch/src/audio/replay.ts | 3 + js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts | 164 ++++-- js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts | 145 +++-- js/watch/src/audio/stretch.test.ts | 74 +++ js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts | 216 ++++++++ js/watch/src/ui/stats.ts | 3 + .../audio-jitter-target/buffered-converge.md | 5 +- .../m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md | 12 +- quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md | 193 +++---- quest/m1/push-to-talk-latency.md | 5 +- rs/moq-audio/src/ring.rs | 47 +- rs/moq-audio/src/stretch.rs | 19 +- test/audio-quality/README.md | 9 + test/audio-quality/budgets.json | 67 +-- test/audio-quality/clients/js/grade.ts | 3 +- test/audio-quality/clients/js/replay.ts | 16 +- .../clients/js/src/analyze.test.ts | 6 + test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/analyze.ts | 13 +- test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/probe.ts | 1 + test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/schema.ts | 12 + 36 files changed, 1345 insertions(+), 422 deletions(-) create mode 100644 js/watch/WEBRTC-LICENSE create mode 100644 js/watch/WEBRTC-PATENTS create mode 100644 js/watch/src/audio/stretch.test.ts create mode 100644 js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter.md b/doc/concept/audio-jitter.md index fbdc52e32e3..8a9e33d93fd 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter.md +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter.md @@ -614,11 +614,13 @@ the `bun doc/concept/audio-jitter/corpus.ts` command above. It runs in ## Received-audio time stretch -Native playback adapts received PCM to the target with WebRTC NetEq's -accelerate and preemptive expand. It never generates replacement audio for a -missing packet. The estimator above is unchanged. The browser implementation -must conform to this same algorithm and [PCM corpus](audio-jitter/stretch/corpus.json) -when it adopts stretching; the browser does not yet stretch on this revision. +Both players adapt received PCM to the target with WebRTC NetEq's accelerate +and preemptive expand: native playback in `rs/moq-audio`, and the browser in the +AudioWorklet's ring in `js/watch`. Neither generates replacement audio for a +missing packet, so a hole in the media plays as a hole. The estimator above is +unchanged. Both conform to this same algorithm and +[PCM corpus](audio-jitter/stretch/corpus.json). The browser stretches only live +playback: buffered playback plays every sample it holds, as it always has. The source is WebRTC's [`TimeStretch`](https://webrtc.googlesource.com/src/+/refs/heads/main/modules/audio_coding/neteq/time_stretch.cc), @@ -626,8 +628,8 @@ The source is WebRTC's [`PreemptiveExpand`](https://webrtc.googlesource.com/src/+/refs/heads/main/modules/audio_coding/neteq/preemptive_expand.cc), [`DspHelper`](https://webrtc.googlesource.com/src/+/refs/heads/main/modules/audio_coding/neteq/dsp_helper.cc), and [`DecisionLogic`](https://webrtc.googlesource.com/src/+/refs/heads/main/modules/audio_coding/neteq/decision_logic.cc), -read on 2026-11-04. The native port retains the BSD license and patent grant in -`rs/moq-audio/WEBRTC-LICENSE` and `WEBRTC-PATENTS`. +read on 2026-11-04. Both ports retain the BSD license and patent grant, in +`WEBRTC-LICENSE` and `WEBRTC-PATENTS` beside `rs/moq-audio` and `js/watch`. ### PCM and decision state @@ -637,7 +639,10 @@ below are frames at the output device's rate `R`. Duration-to-frame conversion uses `floor(R * milliseconds / 1000)`, except a measured pitch rounds to the nearest frame, with half rounded upward. A processing window is 30 ms of **newly received PCM**. A short window passes unchanged. Startup padding is -never analysed, and finish drains the remaining input without stretching. +never analysed, and finish drains the remaining input without stretching. So +does the tail before a [declared end](#declared-silence): running dry after it +is silence rather than an underrun, so nothing expands toward a target that no +arrival will refill. `buffered` counts unread frames in the ring plus staged output. `target` is the current playout target. The state is `cooldown`, initially 60 ms @@ -646,14 +651,26 @@ by each frame rendered, saturating at zero. At a window boundary, with `high = target + 20 ms`, choose in this order: 1. `buffered >= 4 * high`: fast accelerate, even during cooldown. -2. `cooldown > 0`: hold. -3. `buffered >= high`: accelerate. -4. `buffered < target`: preemptive expand. +2. `buffered < target`: preemptive expand in fast mode, even during cooldown. +3. `cooldown > 0`: hold. +4. `buffered >= high`: accelerate. 5. Otherwise: hold. A successful stretch sets cooldown to 50 ms (NetEq's five 10 ms ticks). A rejected seam leaves it unchanged. This preserves NetEq's 20 ms adjustment -granularity, 4x fast threshold, and minimum interval. NetEq's extra +granularity, 4x fast threshold, and minimum interval for accelerate. + +Expand departs from NetEq. Its preemptive expand waits out the cooldown and +repeats one pitch period at the normal threshold, which lengthens a ring by a +few milliseconds every 50 ms at most. On the `relay-mic-rtt40` replay, Chrome +at 40 ms of added RTT, that still ran the browser's ring dry 2.1 times a +minute: its arrival gaps reached 104 to 135 ms behind cushions of 71 to 94 ms. +A ring below its target is short of the cushion its arrivals need, and running +dry re-stalls it for a whole target of silence. So expand mirrors fast +accelerate instead: every window, at the lower admission threshold, as many +whole periods as fit before the middle, up to 15 ms of every 30 ms. That took +every replay row to zero player underruns. The cost is a stronger stretch while +the ring is short, which the listening check judges. NetEq's extra packet-history maximum-delay term is not added again: this controller sees the already decoded PCM queue and its jitter target rather than an RTP playout timestamp and packet-arrival history. There is no concealment state. @@ -685,8 +702,9 @@ squared energies and `C` their dot product. The signal is passive if `(E1+E2)/(2*L) <= 8*75000/(32768*32768)`, NetEq's VAD before a background noise model is initialised. No background synthesis or noise model is added. Otherwise admit the seam only when `C > threshold * sqrt(E1*E2)`, with -threshold **14746/16384** normally and **8192/16384** for fast accelerate. -These are NetEq's original thresholds; none was tuned. Active uncorrelated +threshold **14746/16384** normally and **8192/16384** for fast accelerate +and expand. These are NetEq's original thresholds; none was tuned, though +NetEq applies the lower one to fast accelerate only. Active uncorrelated PCM holds unchanged, so zero underruns are not guaranteed for arbitrary input or outages. Passive PCM may stretch without correlation. @@ -699,7 +717,8 @@ still needs the listening proof required by the quest. ### Seam and boundaries -In fast mode replace `L` by `floor(M/L)*L` after admission. For a crossfade of +In fast mode, for fast accelerate and every expand, replace `L` by +`floor(M/L)*L` after admission. For a crossfade of `L` frames, frame `i` uses `w=(i+1)/(L+1)` and `f32(a*(1-w)+b*w)` independently for every channel. @@ -720,7 +739,10 @@ ring and staged output hold the target again. Padding never enters the pitch search. Finishing bypasses that wait so a short tail can drain. Trimming is emergency recovery at the ring's capacity watermark. The CLI's incoming-media trim is reserved for a distance at the fast threshold, -not ordinary 20 ms drift. These bounds do not promise concealment of missing +not ordinary 20 ms drift. The browser's ring receives each decoded frame as a +write, so it re-anchors on its floor there, at the lower of the fast threshold +and three quarters of its headroom above the floor, and counts each re-anchor +as a skip in its stats. These bounds do not promise concealment of missing media or convergence of a signal whose seams continually fail admission. ### Stretch corpus @@ -730,9 +752,12 @@ output PCM, device rate and channels, buffered and target frame counts, incoming cooldown, requested decision, and admitted lag (zero means hold). Compare output within 1e-6 absolute sample amplitude. It includes hold, cooldown, fast-mode bypass, linked stereo, passive noise, rejected active -noise, and 8/44.1/48 kHz seams. Both implementations consume these exact -vectors; generating expected output from the implementation under test is -not conformance. +noise, and 8/44.1/48 kHz seams, plus expand ignoring the cooldown and +admitting a seam at the lower threshold. Both implementations consume these +exact vectors; generating expected output from the implementation under test is +not conformance. The expand vectors were regenerated from the browser port when +expand departed from NetEq, and the native port, changed separately, reproduces +them unchanged. ## Comfort noise diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/stretch/corpus.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/stretch/corpus.json index e864b8552e1..48bd5098773 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/stretch/corpus.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/stretch/corpus.json @@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ "rate": 8000, "channels": 1, "input": [ - 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, @@ -57,9 +57,9 @@ "target": 640, "cooldown": 0, "decision": "Expand", - "lag": 40, + "lag": 120, "output": [ - 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, @@ -82,39 +82,189 @@ -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -1.7137210293518407e-16, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -1.8217885367871985e-16, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -2.5030747386672674e-16, - -0.03910861536860466, -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, - -0.2022542506456375, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, - -0.2469220906496048, -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, - -0.14694631099700928, -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, - -1.8369701465288538e-16, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, - 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -6.73865213880276e-16, - -0.03910861536860466, -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, - -0.2022542506456375, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, - -0.2469220906496048, -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, - -0.14694631099700928, -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, - 6.432490491830917e-16, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, - 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 2.7554553521421787e-16, - -0.03910861536860466, -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, - -0.2022542506456375, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, - -0.2469220906496048, -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, - -0.14694631099700928, -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, - -3.0616169991140216e-16, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, - 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -5.514005550915388e-16, - -0.03910861536860466, -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, - -0.2022542506456375, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, - -0.2469220906496048, -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, - -0.14694631099700928, -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466 + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -5.708681780160804e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 4.797787313243857e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 1.8293794078324752e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 1.1409188368891623e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 3.663764250987631e-17, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -1.8369701465288538e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -6.73865213880276e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 6.432490491830917e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 2.7554553521421787e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -3.0616169991140216e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -5.514005550915388e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466 + ] + }, + { + "name": "expand-ignores-cooldown", + "rate": 8000, + "channels": 1, + "input": [ + 0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 1.6081226229577292e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 9.184850732644269e-17, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 3.2162452459154583e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 1.5308084995570108e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -1.8369701465288538e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -6.73865213880276e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 6.432490491830917e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 2.7554553521421787e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -3.0616169991140216e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -5.514005550915388e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466 + ], + "buffered": 320, + "target": 640, + "cooldown": 1, + "decision": "Expand", + "lag": 120, + "output": [ + 0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 1.6081226229577292e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 9.184850732644269e-17, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 3.2162452459154583e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 1.5308084995570108e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -1.8217885367871985e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -5.708681780160804e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 4.797787313243857e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 1.8293794078324752e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 1.1409188368891623e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 3.663764250987631e-17, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -1.8369701465288538e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -6.73865213880276e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 6.432490491830917e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 2.7554553521421787e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -3.0616169991140216e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -5.514005550915388e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466 ] }, { @@ -122,7 +272,7 @@ "rate": 8000, "channels": 1, "input": [ - 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, @@ -177,7 +327,7 @@ "decision": "Accelerate", "lag": 40, "output": [ - 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, @@ -224,7 +374,7 @@ "rate": 8000, "channels": 1, "input": [ - 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, @@ -310,7 +460,7 @@ "rate": 8000, "channels": 1, "input": [ - 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, @@ -365,7 +515,7 @@ "decision": "Hold", "lag": 0, "output": [ - 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, @@ -420,7 +570,7 @@ "rate": 8000, "channels": 1, "input": [ - 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, @@ -469,13 +619,13 @@ -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466 ], - "buffered": 320, + "buffered": 800, "target": 640, "cooldown": 1, "decision": "Hold", "lag": 0, "output": [ - 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, @@ -643,16 +793,16 @@ "channels": 1, "input": [ -0.0007030649576336145, 0.0009325314313173294, -0.0008886777213774621, -0.00027434012736193836, - -0.0006402268190868199, 0.00027956345002166927, -2.2392654500436038e-5, -0.0004958766512572765, + -0.0006402268190868199, 0.00027956345002166927, -0.000022392654500436038, -0.0004958766512572765, 0.0002554934471845627, -0.0007862572092562914, 0.0009665456018410623, 0.0005669176462106407, -0.0005824891268275678, 0.00019192435138393193, -0.00045695737935602665, 0.00014963874127715826, - -0.0003695623017847538, -0.0005795694887638092, -1.852077548392117e-5, -0.0008567545446567237, + -0.0003695623017847538, -0.0005795694887638092, -0.00001852077548392117, -0.0008567545446567237, 0.0009857823606580496, 0.0005756401806138456, -0.0005451339529827237, 0.00019753548258449882, -0.0006463580066338181, -0.0006663250969722867, -0.00023348850663751364, 0.00043203806853853166, -0.0008616960840299726, 0.000872615841217339, -0.0004974452313035727, -0.0006715144845657051, - -2.47669595410116e-5, 0.0008102622232399881, -0.0001687523181317374, 7.366603676928207e-5, - 0.0009737846557982266, 5.448683077702299e-5, -0.0003058563161175698, -0.0006214933819137514, - 4.3054074922110885e-5, 0.000262199726421386, 0.00018437781545799226, -0.0006128149689175189, + -0.0000247669595410116, 0.0008102622232399881, -0.0001687523181317374, 0.00007366603676928207, + 0.0009737846557982266, 0.00005448683077702299, -0.0003058563161175698, -0.0006214933819137514, + 0.000043054074922110885, 0.000262199726421386, 0.00018437781545799226, -0.0006128149689175189, -0.0009753089398145676, 0.0009309097076766193, 0.0003778619575314224, 0.0006895582773722708, 0.000683246529661119, -0.00014868324797134846, -0.0006266164127737284, 0.0009270667796954513, 0.000792936363723129, -0.000868256320245564, 0.00025973841547966003, 7.850814540688589e-7, @@ -663,25 +813,25 @@ 0.0008628532523289323, -0.0007022370700724423, 0.00040376937249675393, -0.00021518970606848598, -0.0005698790191672742, 0.0007872823043726385, -0.0008089927141554654, -0.0008375357720069587, -0.00030111949308775365, -0.0007078243070282042, -0.00020647711062338203, 0.00026229434297420084, - 3.0798160878475755e-5, 0.0008422392420470715, -3.4309341572225094e-5, -0.0007103951065801084, - 9.731615864438936e-5, -0.0009534720447845757, 0.00031939285690896213, -0.000682170910295099, - -2.548842348915059e-5, -0.00012349399912636727, 0.0008597094565629959, -0.000744685239624232, - -0.0004352022078819573, -0.00034275883808732033, 3.958199158660136e-5, -0.00022720580454915762, + 0.000030798160878475755, 0.0008422392420470715, -0.000034309341572225094, -0.0007103951065801084, + 0.00009731615864438936, -0.0009534720447845757, 0.00031939285690896213, -0.000682170910295099, + -0.00002548842348915059, -0.00012349399912636727, 0.0008597094565629959, -0.000744685239624232, + -0.0004352022078819573, -0.00034275883808732033, 0.00003958199158660136, -0.00022720580454915762, 0.0009628701955080032, 0.0008526424062438309, 0.0008875391213223338, 0.0003391534264665097, 0.0005916213267482817, 0.00010162622493226081, -0.0005961099523119628, -0.0006671503069810569, -0.0006210096762515604, 0.0005345488316379488, 0.0003388409677427262, -0.0009314351482316852, - -0.0004159359959885478, -0.0008514906512573361, 4.890025593340397e-5, -0.00031689938623458147, - -3.490171366138384e-5, -0.00026018108474090695, -0.0001929930440383032, -9.2165450041648e-5, + -0.0004159359959885478, -0.0008514906512573361, 0.00004890025593340397, -0.00031689938623458147, + -0.00003490171366138384, -0.00026018108474090695, -0.0001929930440383032, -0.000092165450041648, 0.0005734908627346158, -0.0008626419585198164, 0.0005156584666110575, 0.00017040438251569867, 0.0005833050236105919, -0.0006876519182696939, -0.000423555844463408, 0.0008145129540935159, 0.0009176674648188055, -0.00045358200441114604, -0.00024749452131800354, -0.0003263925900682807, - -0.0003439123975113034, 0.000896057637874037, 3.4957085972564528e-6, -0.0001491785078542307, + -0.0003439123975113034, 0.000896057637874037, 0.0000034957085972564528, -0.0001491785078542307, 0.0008070407784543931, 0.00027008625329472125, 0.000875414174515754, 0.0002992406371049583, - -0.00011564469605218619, -0.0008426193380728364, -6.36793629382737e-6, 4.32445558544714e-5, - 0.00023516372311860323, 0.0006941823521628976, -0.0002684972423594445, 9.915585542330518e-5, + -0.00011564469605218619, -0.0008426193380728364, -0.00000636793629382737, 0.0000432445558544714, + 0.00023516372311860323, 0.0006941823521628976, -0.0002684972423594445, 0.00009915585542330518, 0.0006486750789918005, 0.0008993244264274836, 0.0006477433489635587, -0.00047298416029661894, 0.0006479199510067701, 0.00034700820106081665, -0.0003696749045047909, 0.0001066054537659511, - 0.0005871927714906633, 0.0006152534624561667, -0.0005119011620990932, -2.3080843675415963e-5, + 0.0005871927714906633, 0.0006152534624561667, -0.0005119011620990932, -0.000023080843675415963, 0.00032716128043830395, -0.0006568834069184959, 0.0005276001757010818, 0.0005797065095975995, 0.0001640981063246727, 0.0009110807441174984, -0.00036736312904395163, -0.00044170720502734184, 0.0009433883242309093, 0.00023131933994591236, -0.0009870975045487285, -0.00013333519746083766, @@ -689,17 +839,17 @@ 0.00035603882861323655, 0.0007108512800186872, -0.0007700424757786095, -0.00011580232239793986, -0.0009333863854408264, -0.0002914093201979995, 0.00016513190348632634, 0.0004173329216428101, -0.0004515971231739968, 0.00031728719477541745, 0.00010745954932644963, -0.00027064152527600527, - 1.1481797628221102e-5, 0.0006033822428435087, 0.0005782148218713701, -0.0001632032508496195, - 0.0005861674435436726, -0.00012092635006411001, -5.408003198681399e-5, -0.0005464808200486004, - -2.18033369492332e-6, -0.0008856473723426461, 0.0006918481667526066, -0.0002600167354103178, - -0.00028105307137593627, 0.0007127956487238407, 0.00037160434294492006, -8.99228107300587e-5, + 0.000011481797628221102, 0.0006033822428435087, 0.0005782148218713701, -0.0001632032508496195, + 0.0005861674435436726, -0.00012092635006411001, -0.00005408003198681399, -0.0005464808200486004, + -0.00000218033369492332, -0.0008856473723426461, 0.0006918481667526066, -0.0002600167354103178, + -0.00028105307137593627, 0.0007127956487238407, 0.00037160434294492006, -0.0000899228107300587, 0.0007251834031194448, 0.00019465443619992584, 0.0007213967037387192, -0.00047412916319444776, 0.0005699122557416558, 0.0008954202057793736, -0.0001985804847208783, 0.0005204827757552266, 0.0009476683917455375, 0.00018205981177743524, 0.0005132625228725374, -0.0007789720548316836, -0.0007717455737292767, 0.0006477507413364947, 0.0005397944478318095, -0.0006914284895174205, 0.0005856238421984017, -0.0007129331352189183, 0.0007025203667581081, 0.0008599847205914557, - 6.335222133202478e-5, -0.00040318796527571976, 0.0005218808073550463, 0.0007344660116359591, - -0.0006878993008285761, -5.6370488891843706e-5, 0.00029790872940793633, 0.0005240894388407469, + 0.00006335222133202478, -0.00040318796527571976, 0.0005218808073550463, 0.0007344660116359591, + -0.0006878993008285761, -0.000056370488891843706, 0.00029790872940793633, 0.0005240894388407469, -0.0009706376004032791, 0.0006069837254472077, 0.00024918612325564027, 0.0006460933363996446, -0.0007419105968438089, -0.00017247976211365312, 0.00025107196415774524, 0.0007953110034577549 ], @@ -710,16 +860,16 @@ "lag": 62, "output": [ -0.0007030649576336145, 0.0009325314313173294, -0.0008886777213774621, -0.00027434012736193836, - -0.0006402268190868199, 0.00027956345002166927, -2.2392654500436038e-5, -0.0004958766512572765, + -0.0006402268190868199, 0.00027956345002166927, -0.000022392654500436038, -0.0004958766512572765, 0.0002554934471845627, -0.0007862572092562914, 0.0009665456018410623, 0.0005669176462106407, -0.0005824891268275678, 0.00019192435138393193, -0.00045695737935602665, 0.00014963874127715826, - -0.0003695623017847538, -0.0005795694887638092, -1.852077548392117e-5, -0.0008567545446567237, + -0.0003695623017847538, -0.0005795694887638092, -0.00001852077548392117, -0.0008567545446567237, 0.0009857823606580496, 0.0005756401806138456, -0.0005451339529827237, 0.00019753548258449882, -0.0006463580066338181, -0.0006663250969722867, -0.00023348850663751364, 0.00043203806853853166, -0.0008616960840299726, 0.000872615841217339, -0.0004974452313035727, -0.0006715144845657051, - -2.47669595410116e-5, 0.0008102622232399881, -0.0001687523181317374, 7.366603676928207e-5, - 0.0009737846557982266, 5.448683077702299e-5, -0.0003058563161175698, -0.0006214933819137514, - 4.3054074922110885e-5, 0.000262199726421386, 0.00018437781545799226, -0.0006128149689175189, + -0.0000247669595410116, 0.0008102622232399881, -0.0001687523181317374, 0.00007366603676928207, + 0.0009737846557982266, 0.00005448683077702299, -0.0003058563161175698, -0.0006214933819137514, + 0.000043054074922110885, 0.000262199726421386, 0.00018437781545799226, -0.0006128149689175189, -0.0009753089398145676, 0.0009309097076766193, 0.0003778619575314224, 0.0006895582773722708, 0.000683246529661119, -0.00014868324797134846, -0.0006266164127737284, 0.0009270667796954513, 0.000792936363723129, -0.000868256320245564, 0.00025973841547966003, 7.850814540688589e-7, @@ -730,58 +880,58 @@ 0.0008628532523289323, -0.0007022370700724423, 0.00040376937249675393, -0.00021518970606848598, -0.0005698790191672742, 0.0007872823043726385, -0.0008089927141554654, -0.0008375357720069587, -0.00030111949308775365, -0.0007078243070282042, -0.00020647711062338203, 0.00026229434297420084, - 3.0798160878475755e-5, 0.0008422392420470715, -3.4309341572225094e-5, -0.0007103951065801084, - 9.731615864438936e-5, -0.0009534720447845757, 0.00031939285690896213, -0.000682170910295099, - -2.548842348915059e-5, -0.00012349399912636727, 0.0008597094565629959, -0.000744685239624232, - -0.0004352022078819573, -0.00034275883808732033, 3.958199158660136e-5, -0.00022720580454915762, + 0.000030798160878475755, 0.0008422392420470715, -0.000034309341572225094, -0.0007103951065801084, + 0.00009731615864438936, -0.0009534720447845757, 0.00031939285690896213, -0.000682170910295099, + -0.00002548842348915059, -0.00012349399912636727, 0.0008597094565629959, -0.000744685239624232, + -0.0004352022078819573, -0.00034275883808732033, 0.00003958199158660136, -0.00022720580454915762, 0.0009628701955080032, 0.0008526424062438309, 0.0008875391213223338, 0.0003391534264665097, 0.0005916213267482817, 0.00010162622493226081, -0.0005961099523119628, -0.0006671503069810569, -0.0006210096762515604, 0.0005345488316379488, 0.0003388409677427262, -0.0009314351482316852, - -0.0004159359959885478, -0.0008514906512573361, 4.890025593340397e-5, -0.00031689938623458147, - -3.490171366138384e-5, -0.00026018108474090695, -0.0001929930440383032, -9.2165450041648e-5, + -0.0004159359959885478, -0.0008514906512573361, 0.00004890025593340397, -0.00031689938623458147, + -0.00003490171366138384, -0.00026018108474090695, -0.0001929930440383032, -0.000092165450041648, 0.000569164112675935, -0.0008386498084291816, 0.00046778583782725036, 0.00020864862017333508, 0.0005642396863549948, -0.0006643258384428918, -0.0003146957606077194, 0.0008150897338055074, 0.0007545956177636981, -0.00035826212842948735, -0.00034601881634444, -0.0004042369546368718, -0.0001283905003219843, 0.0008990895003080368, 0.00020810464047826827, -0.000289637828245759, 0.0006982214981690049, 0.00013143598334863782, 0.0004395321011543274, 0.00045417450019158423, -0.0003467607020866126, -0.0008408441208302975, -0.00011397564958315343, -0.0002428769221296534, - 5.990942372591235e-5, 0.0005159428692422807, -0.00014022778486832976, 0.00042941514402627945, + 0.00005990942372591235, 0.0005159428692422807, -0.00014022778486832976, 0.00042941514402627945, 0.00033428543247282505, 0.00013279131962917745, 0.0003768982132896781, -0.0007170414901338518, - 0.0004758343275170773, -0.00020842179947067052, -0.0001784601918188855, -2.4879947886802256e-5, + 0.0004758343275170773, -0.00020842179947067052, -0.0001784601918188855, -0.000024879947886802256, 0.0007472422439604998, -0.0002050270268227905, -0.0004644208529498428, -0.00022605099366046488, 0.00014000650844536722, -0.0003704316623043269, 0.0008246892248280346, 0.0007703283918090165, - 0.0006808416801504791, 0.0004934830358251929, 0.0003480697050690651, -2.7738877179217525e-5, + 0.0006808416801504791, 0.0004934830358251929, 0.0003480697050690651, -0.000027738877179217525, -0.0002539992274250835, -0.0004817518056370318, -0.000690740707796067, 0.0004179341485723853, 0.0002270218392368406, -0.0007047466933727264, -0.0002430536551401019, -0.0008376236655749381, - 7.815154822310433e-5, -0.000235331870499067, -8.157731645042077e-5, -0.0002533059159759432, - -0.0002164975885534659, -9.532805415801704e-5, 0.0005734908627346158, -0.0008626419585198164, + 0.00007815154822310433, -0.000235331870499067, -0.00008157731645042077, -0.0002533059159759432, + -0.0002164975885534659, -0.00009532805415801704, 0.0005734908627346158, -0.0008626419585198164, 0.0005156584666110575, 0.00017040438251569867, 0.0005833050236105919, -0.0006876519182696939, -0.000423555844463408, 0.0008145129540935159, 0.0009176674648188055, -0.00045358200441114604, -0.00024749452131800354, -0.0003263925900682807, -0.0003439123975113034, 0.000896057637874037, - 3.4957085972564528e-6, -0.0001491785078542307, 0.0008070407784543931, 0.00027008625329472125, + 0.0000034957085972564528, -0.0001491785078542307, 0.0008070407784543931, 0.00027008625329472125, 0.000875414174515754, 0.0002992406371049583, -0.00011564469605218619, -0.0008426193380728364, - -6.36793629382737e-6, 4.32445558544714e-5, 0.00023516372311860323, 0.0006941823521628976, - -0.0002684972423594445, 9.915585542330518e-5, 0.0006486750789918005, 0.0008993244264274836, + -0.00000636793629382737, 0.0000432445558544714, 0.00023516372311860323, 0.0006941823521628976, + -0.0002684972423594445, 0.00009915585542330518, 0.0006486750789918005, 0.0008993244264274836, 0.0006477433489635587, -0.00047298416029661894, 0.0006479199510067701, 0.00034700820106081665, -0.0003696749045047909, 0.0001066054537659511, 0.0005871927714906633, 0.0006152534624561667, - -0.0005119011620990932, -2.3080843675415963e-5, 0.00032716128043830395, -0.0006568834069184959, + -0.0005119011620990932, -0.000023080843675415963, 0.00032716128043830395, -0.0006568834069184959, 0.0005276001757010818, 0.0005797065095975995, 0.0001640981063246727, 0.0009110807441174984, -0.00036736312904395163, -0.00044170720502734184, 0.0009433883242309093, 0.00023131933994591236, -0.0009870975045487285, -0.00013333519746083766, -0.00036561954766511917, 0.0006553839193657041, 0.0009455124381929636, -0.0007266877219080925, 0.00035603882861323655, 0.0007108512800186872, -0.0007700424757786095, -0.00011580232239793986, -0.0009333863854408264, -0.0002914093201979995, 0.00016513190348632634, 0.0004173329216428101, -0.0004515971231739968, 0.00031728719477541745, - 0.00010745954932644963, -0.00027064152527600527, 1.1481797628221102e-5, 0.0006033822428435087, + 0.00010745954932644963, -0.00027064152527600527, 0.000011481797628221102, 0.0006033822428435087, 0.0005782148218713701, -0.0001632032508496195, 0.0005861674435436726, -0.00012092635006411001, - -5.408003198681399e-5, -0.0005464808200486004, -2.18033369492332e-6, -0.0008856473723426461, + -0.00005408003198681399, -0.0005464808200486004, -0.00000218033369492332, -0.0008856473723426461, 0.0006918481667526066, -0.0002600167354103178, -0.00028105307137593627, 0.0007127956487238407, - 0.00037160434294492006, -8.99228107300587e-5, 0.0007251834031194448, 0.00019465443619992584, + 0.00037160434294492006, -0.0000899228107300587, 0.0007251834031194448, 0.00019465443619992584, 0.0007213967037387192, -0.00047412916319444776, 0.0005699122557416558, 0.0008954202057793736, -0.0001985804847208783, 0.0005204827757552266, 0.0009476683917455375, 0.00018205981177743524, 0.0005132625228725374, -0.0007789720548316836, -0.0007717455737292767, 0.0006477507413364947, 0.0005397944478318095, -0.0006914284895174205, 0.0005856238421984017, -0.0007129331352189183, - 0.0007025203667581081, 0.0008599847205914557, 6.335222133202478e-5, -0.00040318796527571976, - 0.0005218808073550463, 0.0007344660116359591, -0.0006878993008285761, -5.6370488891843706e-5, + 0.0007025203667581081, 0.0008599847205914557, 0.00006335222133202478, -0.00040318796527571976, + 0.0005218808073550463, 0.0007344660116359591, -0.0006878993008285761, -0.000056370488891843706, 0.00029790872940793633, 0.0005240894388407469, -0.0009706376004032791, 0.0006069837254472077, 0.00024918612325564027, 0.0006460933363996446, -0.0007419105968438089, -0.00017247976211365312, 0.00025107196415774524, 0.0007953110034577549 @@ -792,7 +942,7 @@ "rate": 8000, "channels": 2, "input": [ - 0.0, -0.0, 0.03910861536860466, -0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, -0.07725425064563751, + 0, 0, 0.03910861536860466, -0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, -0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, -0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, -0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, -0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, -0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, -0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, -0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, -0.2469220906496048, 0.25, -0.25, @@ -893,9 +1043,9 @@ "target": 640, "cooldown": 0, "decision": "Expand", - "lag": 40, + "lag": 120, "output": [ - 0.0, -0.0, 0.03910861536860466, -0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, -0.07725425064563751, + 0, 0, 0.03910861536860466, -0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, -0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, -0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, -0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, -0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, -0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, -0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, -0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, -0.2469220906496048, 0.25, -0.25, @@ -943,7 +1093,39 @@ 0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, 0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, 0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, 0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, 0.14694631099700928, -0.11349762231111526, 0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, 0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 0.03910861536860466, - -1.7137210293518407e-16, 1.7137210293518407e-16, 0.03910861536860466, -0.03910861536860466, + -1.8217885367871985e-16, 1.8217885367871985e-16, 0.03910861536860466, -0.03910861536860466, + 0.07725425064563751, -0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, -0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, + -0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, -0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, -0.2022542506456375, + 0.22275163233280182, -0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, -0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, + -0.2469220906496048, 0.25, -0.25, 0.2469220906496048, -0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, + -0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, -0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, -0.2022542506456375, + 0.1767766922712326, -0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, -0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, + -0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, -0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -0.03910861536860466, + -5.708681780160804e-16, 5.708681780160804e-16, -0.03910861536860466, 0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, 0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, 0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, + 0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, 0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, 0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, 0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, 0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, + 0.2469220906496048, -0.25, 0.25, -0.2469220906496048, 0.2469220906496048, -0.2377641350030899, + 0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, 0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, 0.2022542506456375, + -0.1767766922712326, 0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, 0.14694631099700928, -0.11349762231111526, + 0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, 0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 0.03910861536860466, + 4.797787313243857e-16, -4.797787313243857e-16, 0.03910861536860466, -0.03910861536860466, + 0.07725425064563751, -0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, -0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, + -0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, -0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, -0.2022542506456375, + 0.22275163233280182, -0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, -0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, + -0.2469220906496048, 0.25, -0.25, 0.2469220906496048, -0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, + -0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, -0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, -0.2022542506456375, + 0.1767766922712326, -0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, -0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, + -0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, -0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -0.03910861536860466, + 1.8293794078324752e-16, -1.8293794078324752e-16, -0.03910861536860466, 0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, 0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, 0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, + 0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, 0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, 0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, 0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, 0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, + 0.2469220906496048, -0.25, 0.25, -0.2469220906496048, 0.2469220906496048, -0.2377641350030899, + 0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, 0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, 0.2022542506456375, + -0.1767766922712326, 0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, 0.14694631099700928, -0.11349762231111526, + 0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, 0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 0.03910861536860466, + 1.1409188368891623e-16, -1.1409188368891623e-16, 0.03910861536860466, -0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, -0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, -0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, -0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, -0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, -0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, -0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, -0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, @@ -951,7 +1133,7 @@ -0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, -0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, -0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, -0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, -0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, -0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, -0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -0.03910861536860466, - -2.5030747386672674e-16, 2.5030747386672674e-16, -0.03910861536860466, 0.03910861536860466, + 3.663764250987631e-17, -3.663764250987631e-17, -0.03910861536860466, 0.03910861536860466, -0.07725425064563751, 0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, 0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, 0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, 0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, 0.2022542506456375, -0.22275163233280182, 0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, 0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, @@ -1014,7 +1196,7 @@ "rate": 44100, "channels": 1, "input": [ - 0.0, 0.007122828625142574, 0.014239874668419361, 0.021345358341932297, 0.028433511033654213, + 0, 0.007122828625142574, 0.014239874668419361, 0.021345358341932297, 0.028433511033654213, 0.03549857810139656, 0.04253482446074486, 0.04953653737902641, 0.056498028337955475, 0.06341364234685898, 0.07027778029441833, 0.07708485424518585, 0.08382933586835861, 0.09050575643777847, 0.09710869938135147, 0.10363279283046722, 0.11007274687290192, 0.11642333120107651, 0.12267939001321793, 0.12883584201335907, @@ -1300,7 +1482,7 @@ "decision": "Expand", "lag": 441, "output": [ - 0.0, 0.007122828625142574, 0.014239874668419361, 0.021345358341932297, 0.028433511033654213, + 0, 0.007122828625142574, 0.014239874668419361, 0.021345358341932297, 0.028433511033654213, 0.03549857810139656, 0.04253482446074486, 0.04953653737902641, 0.056498028337955475, 0.06341364234685898, 0.07027778029441833, 0.07708485424518585, 0.08382933586835861, 0.09050575643777847, 0.09710869938135147, 0.10363279283046722, 0.11007274687290192, 0.11642333120107651, 0.12267939001321793, 0.12883584201335907, @@ -1679,7 +1861,7 @@ "rate": 48000, "channels": 1, "input": [ - 0.0, 0.006544237025082111, 0.013083988800644875, 0.019614774733781815, 0.026132116094231606, + 0, 0.006544237025082111, 0.013083988800644875, 0.019614774733781815, 0.026132116094231606, 0.03263154625892639, 0.03910861536860466, 0.045558881014585495, 0.05197792127728462, 0.05836134031414986, 0.0647047609090805, 0.07100383937358856, 0.07725425064563751, 0.08345171809196472, 0.08959198743104935, 0.09567085653543472, 0.10168416053056717, 0.10762777179479599, 0.11349762231111526, 0.11928968876600266, @@ -1982,7 +2164,7 @@ "decision": "Accelerate", "lag": 240, "output": [ - 0.0, 0.006544237025082111, 0.013083988800644875, 0.019614774733781815, 0.026132116094231606, + 0, 0.006544237025082111, 0.013083988800644875, 0.019614774733781815, 0.026132116094231606, 0.03263154625892639, 0.03910861536860466, 0.045558881014585495, 0.05197792127728462, 0.05836134031414986, 0.0647047609090805, 0.07100383937358856, 0.07725425064563751, 0.08345171809196472, 0.08959198743104935, 0.09567085653543472, 0.10168416053056717, 0.10762777179479599, 0.11349762231111526, 0.11928968876600266, @@ -2437,5 +2619,133 @@ -0.360440731048584, -0.22026745975017548, -0.5599857568740845, -0.11384382098913193, -0.603949248790741, -0.10583518445491791, -0.32648566365242004, -0.4554884731769562, -0.27422934770584106, -0.09860859811306 ] + }, + { + "name": "expand-lower-threshold", + "rate": 8000, + "channels": 1, + "input": [ + 0.20665311813354492, 0.2251681536436081, 0.09140059351921082, 0.05964577570557594, 0.27126818895339966, + 0.2611585259437561, 0.5343368053436279, 0.2829405665397644, 0.4139336049556732, 0.49448898434638977, + 0.694867730140686, 0.44727185368537903, 0.29707813262939453, 0.5544354319572449, 0.43507903814315796, + 0.1685018539428711, 0.5103511214256287, 0.4939669966697693, 0.3251879811286926, 0.31169506907463074, + -0.1139114573597908, 0.06750354170799255, 0.10024532675743103, -0.09390536695718765, -0.2812177240848541, + -0.5577773451805115, -0.4035545587539673, -0.33442074060440063, -0.18016880750656128, -0.16449593007564545, + -0.46379414200782776, -0.22527380287647247, -0.5716800689697266, -0.21793623268604279, -0.33483806252479553, + -0.6097730398178101, -0.13268055021762848, -0.2650015950202942, 0.055849339812994, 0.03049641102552414, + -0.29931432008743286, 0.06654223054647446, 0.3596193194389343, 0.05064225196838379, 0.15962597727775574, + 0.5404807925224304, 0.17869789898395538, 0.44145938754081726, 0.2711449861526489, 0.7249839305877686, + 0.6319077014923096, 0.41324150562286377, 0.1762429177761078, 0.2929857075214386, 0.36882203817367554, + 0.5778983235359192, 0.029938071966171265, 0.235056072473526, 0.2629944980144501, 0.09886005520820618, + 0.18868011236190796, -0.04622534662485123, 0.13924548029899597, -0.1423843502998352, -0.21193312108516693, + -0.35120463371276855, -0.3062855303287506, -0.47001224756240845, -0.382584810256958, -0.57026207447052, + -0.6363651752471924, -0.6324220299720764, -0.3603115379810333, -0.30695730447769165, -0.37813904881477356, + -0.564303457736969, -0.1099410131573677, 0.02176649682223797, 0.11497095972299576, 0.13508062064647675, + 0.23890388011932373, 0.32424497604370117, 0.16341760754585266, 0.13907335698604584, 0.38767340779304504, + 0.1835785210132599, 0.5510348677635193, 0.610644519329071, 0.6649988293647766, 0.4983404576778412, + 0.7198589444160461, 0.49227675795555115, 0.3983132839202881, 0.49710017442703247, 0.6618123650550842, + 0.5683627724647522, 0.440498411655426, -0.04628048092126846, 0.2067275047302246, 0.06226203218102455, + 0.07808840274810791, 0.13665103912353516, -0.29323628544807434, -0.06540219485759735, -0.4942227900028229, + -0.4859217405319214, -0.18730786442756653, -0.5014312267303467, -0.23842757940292358, -0.6840952634811401, + -0.6621848940849304, -0.32585737109184265, -0.7008349895477295, -0.3566333055496216, -0.1180480420589447, + -0.29767927527427673, -0.15614987909793854, -0.4882776439189911, -0.05805770307779312, + -0.006592458579689264, 0.04557177051901817, 0.005121154710650444, 0.06114161014556885, 0.49260571599006653, + -0.013661413453519344, 0.03117995709180832, 0.6406764388084412, 0.2119361013174057, 0.20231252908706665, + 0.2708056569099426, 0.6304479837417603, 0.7066412568092346, 0.14164498448371887, 0.3563242256641388, + 0.12495777755975723, 0.1741499900817871, 0.09700092673301697, 0.2924511432647705, 0.04923402890563011, + -0.12141375243663788, 0.002181903226301074, -0.3467682898044586, -0.3785049021244049, 0.08864536136388779, + -0.4448899030685425, -0.40306487679481506, -0.22509866952896118, -0.19795699417591095, -0.1768862009048462, + -0.6428049802780151, -0.3464156687259674, -0.164530411362648, -0.6931448578834534, -0.2952318787574768, + -0.15680289268493652, -0.4128105342388153, -0.41409096121788025, -0.14622089266777039, -0.17366923391819, + -0.26550382375717163, -0.017024751752614975, 0.01633874699473381, 0.1805252879858017, 0.20945580303668976, + 0.15137095749378204, 0.23248906433582306, 0.5666543245315552, 0.2515125274658203, 0.464335560798645, + 0.15192154049873352, 0.5949446558952332, 0.34600967168807983, 0.1553933322429657, 0.26948282122612, + 0.20813588798046112, 0.590075671672821, 0.17583869397640228, 0.07702247053384781, 0.05457836762070656, + 0.3385390043258667, 0.08024871349334717, 0.002250598045065999, -0.009686036966741085, -0.2714853882789612, + -0.3158525824546814, -0.22769834101200104, -0.6631430983543396, -0.5855672359466553, -0.5273343920707703, + -0.600810170173645, -0.36756035685539246, -0.5172709226608276, -0.20272140204906464, -0.3600620925426483, + -0.4154137969017029, -0.376837819814682, -0.14340558648109436, -0.2533597946166992, -0.041740115731954575, + -0.34232768416404724, -0.03278868645429611, -0.0740683376789093, -0.06633041054010391, 0.22083960473537445, + 0.25686272978782654, 0.3550409972667694, 0.5173485279083252, 0.6312780380249023, 0.4247250258922577, + 0.33169469237327576, 0.4301353394985199, 0.6298872828483582, 0.6529852151870728, 0.5884019136428833, + 0.17685842514038086, 0.6178502440452576, 0.34435662627220154, -0.04562404379248619, 0.27439025044441223, + 0.36248838901519775, -0.058909907937049866, 0.03671349212527275, -0.249351367354393, -0.3761809170246124, + -0.13410887122154236, -0.6167834997177124, -0.17041879892349243, -0.3839453458786011, -0.6693048477172852, + -0.6731173992156982, -0.360440731048584, -0.22026745975017548, -0.5599857568740845, -0.11384382098913193, + -0.603949248790741, -0.10583518445491791, -0.32648566365242004, -0.4554884731769562, -0.27422934770584106, + -0.09860859811306 + ], + "buffered": 320, + "target": 640, + "cooldown": 0, + "decision": "Expand", + "lag": 81, + "output": [ + 0.20665311813354492, 0.2251681536436081, 0.09140059351921082, 0.05964577570557594, 0.27126818895339966, + 0.2611585259437561, 0.5343368053436279, 0.2829405665397644, 0.4139336049556732, 0.49448898434638977, + 0.694867730140686, 0.44727185368537903, 0.29707813262939453, 0.5544354319572449, 0.43507903814315796, + 0.1685018539428711, 0.5103511214256287, 0.4939669966697693, 0.3251879811286926, 0.31169506907463074, + -0.1139114573597908, 0.06750354170799255, 0.10024532675743103, -0.09390536695718765, -0.2812177240848541, + -0.5577773451805115, -0.4035545587539673, -0.33442074060440063, -0.18016880750656128, -0.16449593007564545, + -0.46379414200782776, -0.22527380287647247, -0.5716800689697266, -0.21793623268604279, -0.33483806252479553, + -0.6097730398178101, -0.13268055021762848, -0.2650015950202942, 0.055849339812994, 0.03049641102552414, + -0.29931432008743286, 0.06654223054647446, 0.3596193194389343, 0.05064225196838379, 0.15962597727775574, + 0.5404807925224304, 0.17869789898395538, 0.44145938754081726, 0.2711449861526489, 0.7249839305877686, + 0.6319077014923096, 0.41324150562286377, 0.1762429177761078, 0.2929857075214386, 0.36882203817367554, + 0.5778983235359192, 0.029938071966171265, 0.235056072473526, 0.2629944980144501, 0.09886005520820618, + 0.18868011236190796, -0.04622534662485123, 0.13924548029899597, -0.1423843502998352, -0.21193312108516693, + -0.35120463371276855, -0.3062855303287506, -0.47001224756240845, -0.382584810256958, -0.57026207447052, + -0.6363651752471924, -0.6324220299720764, -0.3603115379810333, -0.30695730447769165, -0.37813904881477356, + -0.564303457736969, -0.1099410131573677, 0.02176649682223797, 0.11497095972299576, 0.13508062064647675, + 0.23890388011932373, 0.32424497604370117, 0.16341760754585266, 0.13907335698604584, 0.38767340779304504, + 0.1835785210132599, 0.5510348677635193, 0.610644519329071, 0.6649988293647766, 0.4983404576778412, + 0.7198589444160461, 0.49227675795555115, 0.3983132839202881, 0.49710017442703247, 0.6618123650550842, + 0.5683627724647522, 0.440498411655426, -0.04628048092126846, 0.2067275047302246, 0.06226203218102455, + 0.07808840274810791, 0.13665103912353516, -0.29323628544807434, -0.06540219485759735, -0.4942227900028229, + -0.4859217405319214, -0.18730786442756653, -0.5014312267303467, -0.23842757940292358, -0.6840952634811401, + -0.6621848940849304, -0.32585737109184265, -0.7008349895477295, -0.3566333055496216, -0.1180480420589447, + -0.29767927527427673, -0.15614987909793854, -0.4882776439189911, -0.05805770307779312, + -0.006592458579689264, 0.04538792371749878, -0.002304100664332509, 0.06133919209241867, 0.4861185848712921, + -0.009740457870066166, 0.0405784472823143, 0.6321231722831726, 0.20869335532188416, 0.22856035828590393, + 0.27084705233573914, 0.6431296467781067, 0.6957046389579773, 0.18470296263694763, 0.32557862997055054, + 0.15569458901882172, 0.21213477849960327, 0.19669917225837708, 0.23482632637023926, 0.09229035675525665, + -0.027655642479658127, 0.02694094181060791, -0.20311139523983002, -0.28530454635620117, 0.10345514863729477, + -0.352662593126297, -0.34246212244033813, -0.26662135124206543, -0.23494721949100494, -0.2805527150630951, + -0.5476024746894836, -0.43104052543640137, -0.34866106510162354, -0.6687076091766357, -0.32221612334251404, + -0.22089318931102753, -0.39758890867233276, -0.48186975717544556, -0.12940827012062073, + -0.08071809262037277, -0.07990636676549911, 0.059027932584285736, 0.13033552467823029, 0.25589048862457275, + 0.18475237488746643, 0.14462228119373322, 0.3195436894893646, 0.34708648920059204, 0.42684268951416016, + 0.5517640709877014, 0.4647735357284546, 0.5348615646362305, 0.5830848217010498, 0.3731350600719452, + 0.3543224036693573, 0.40195339918136597, 0.6390665769577026, 0.448690801858902, 0.334115207195282, + -0.017990803346037865, 0.242091566324234, 0.0668683797121048, 0.0595913790166378, 0.10274367034435272, + -0.28846168518066406, -0.1173248365521431, -0.44221800565719604, -0.5183402895927429, -0.25530335307121277, + -0.5055378079414368, -0.29145917296409607, -0.6416332721710205, -0.6445124745368958, -0.31234243512153625, + -0.6675888299942017, -0.36165115237236023, -0.13698388636112213, -0.28827235102653503, -0.1608918309211731, + -0.47194090485572815, -0.06499111652374268, -0.006911924574524164, 0.04557177051901817, + 0.005121154710650444, 0.06114161014556885, 0.49260571599006653, -0.013661413453519344, 0.03117995709180832, + 0.6406764388084412, 0.2119361013174057, 0.20231252908706665, 0.2708056569099426, 0.6304479837417603, + 0.7066412568092346, 0.14164498448371887, 0.3563242256641388, 0.12495777755975723, 0.1741499900817871, + 0.09700092673301697, 0.2924511432647705, 0.04923402890563011, -0.12141375243663788, 0.002181903226301074, + -0.3467682898044586, -0.3785049021244049, 0.08864536136388779, -0.4448899030685425, -0.40306487679481506, + -0.22509866952896118, -0.19795699417591095, -0.1768862009048462, -0.6428049802780151, -0.3464156687259674, + -0.164530411362648, -0.6931448578834534, -0.2952318787574768, -0.15680289268493652, -0.4128105342388153, + -0.41409096121788025, -0.14622089266777039, -0.17366923391819, -0.26550382375717163, -0.017024751752614975, + 0.01633874699473381, 0.1805252879858017, 0.20945580303668976, 0.15137095749378204, 0.23248906433582306, + 0.5666543245315552, 0.2515125274658203, 0.464335560798645, 0.15192154049873352, 0.5949446558952332, + 0.34600967168807983, 0.1553933322429657, 0.26948282122612, 0.20813588798046112, 0.590075671672821, + 0.17583869397640228, 0.07702247053384781, 0.05457836762070656, 0.3385390043258667, 0.08024871349334717, + 0.002250598045065999, -0.009686036966741085, -0.2714853882789612, -0.3158525824546814, -0.22769834101200104, + -0.6631430983543396, -0.5855672359466553, -0.5273343920707703, -0.600810170173645, -0.36756035685539246, + -0.5172709226608276, -0.20272140204906464, -0.3600620925426483, -0.4154137969017029, -0.376837819814682, + -0.14340558648109436, -0.2533597946166992, -0.041740115731954575, -0.34232768416404724, + -0.03278868645429611, -0.0740683376789093, -0.06633041054010391, 0.22083960473537445, 0.25686272978782654, + 0.3550409972667694, 0.5173485279083252, 0.6312780380249023, 0.4247250258922577, 0.33169469237327576, + 0.4301353394985199, 0.6298872828483582, 0.6529852151870728, 0.5884019136428833, 0.17685842514038086, + 0.6178502440452576, 0.34435662627220154, -0.04562404379248619, 0.27439025044441223, 0.36248838901519775, + -0.058909907937049866, 0.03671349212527275, -0.249351367354393, -0.3761809170246124, -0.13410887122154236, + -0.6167834997177124, -0.17041879892349243, -0.3839453458786011, -0.6693048477172852, -0.6731173992156982, + -0.360440731048584, -0.22026745975017548, -0.5599857568740845, -0.11384382098913193, -0.603949248790741, + -0.10583518445491791, -0.32648566365242004, -0.4554884731769562, -0.27422934770584106, -0.09860859811306 + ] } ] diff --git a/doc/lib/js/watch.md b/doc/lib/js/watch.md index e06dec0c09d..a11d9f722d7 100644 --- a/doc/lib/js/watch.md +++ b/doc/lib/js/watch.md @@ -107,7 +107,9 @@ player publishes its own broadcast, reporting only what it counted, so a second player on one connection that resolves the same feedback path, for any catalog, publishes nothing and warns until the first one leaves; give each player its own name. The decoders' -`out.stats` and the stats panel read the same counters. The token must allow +`out.stats` and the stats panel read the same counters. Audio's `out.stats` +also counts `skips`, each jump that dropped buffered audio rather than playing +it faster, which the stats panel shows and the feedback track leaves out. The token must allow publishing under the echo path. ## Binding from a framework @@ -236,8 +238,9 @@ them; nothing is retained without an open handle. ## Buffered playback -By default the player minimizes latency: it skips ahead whenever media piles -up past the delay. Content produced faster than real time, such as a TTS +By default the player minimizes latency: it time-stretches received audio +back onto the delay, playing it slightly faster or slower, and skips ahead only +when media piles up far past it. Content produced faster than real time, such as a TTS response emitted in one burst with future timestamps, wants the opposite. Set `buffer` to how far ahead it may run and it plays through at the encoded pace: diff --git a/js/common/package.ts b/js/common/package.ts index 31fcd2df6c4..264c804a4c8 100644 --- a/js/common/package.ts +++ b/js/common/package.ts @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ // This creates a dist/ folder with the correct paths and dependencies for publishing // Split from release.ts to allow building packages without publishing -import { copyFileSync, existsSync, readFileSync, writeFileSync } from "node:fs"; +import { copyFileSync, existsSync, readdirSync, readFileSync, writeFileSync } from "node:fs"; import { basename, join, resolve } from "node:path"; import { publint } from "publint"; import { formatMessage } from "publint/utils"; @@ -126,9 +126,14 @@ if (existsSync("src/version.ts")) { writeFileSync(file, body.replace(placeholder, `VERSION = ${JSON.stringify(pkg.version)};`)); } -// Copy static files +// Copy static files, including the license and patent notices of any third-party code ported in, +// such as js/watch's WEBRTC-LICENSE and WEBRTC-PATENTS. console.log("📄 Copying README.md..."); copyFileSync("README.md", join("dist", "README.md")); +for (const notice of readdirSync(".").filter((name) => /^[A-Z0-9]+-(LICENSE|PATENTS)$/.test(name))) { + console.log(`📄 Copying ${notice}...`); + copyFileSync(notice, join("dist", notice)); +} // Lint the package to catch publishing issues console.log("🔍 Running publint..."); diff --git a/js/watch/WEBRTC-LICENSE b/js/watch/WEBRTC-LICENSE new file mode 100644 index 00000000000..4c41b7b251e --- /dev/null +++ b/js/watch/WEBRTC-LICENSE @@ -0,0 +1,29 @@ +Copyright (c) 2011, The WebRTC project authors. All rights reserved. + +Redistribution and use in source and binary forms, with or without +modification, are permitted provided that the following conditions are +met: + + * Redistributions of source code must retain the above copyright + notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer. + + * Redistributions in binary form must reproduce the above copyright + notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer in + the documentation and/or other materials provided with the + distribution. + + * Neither the name of Google nor the names of its contributors may + be used to endorse or promote products derived from this software + without specific prior written permission. + +THIS SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED BY THE COPYRIGHT HOLDERS AND CONTRIBUTORS +"AS IS" AND ANY EXPRESS OR IMPLIED WARRANTIES, INCLUDING, BUT NOT +LIMITED TO, THE IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR +A PARTICULAR PURPOSE ARE DISCLAIMED. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE COPYRIGHT +HOLDER OR CONTRIBUTORS BE LIABLE FOR ANY DIRECT, INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, +SPECIAL, EXEMPLARY, OR CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES (INCLUDING, BUT NOT +LIMITED TO, PROCUREMENT OF SUBSTITUTE GOODS OR SERVICES; LOSS OF USE, +DATA, OR PROFITS; OR BUSINESS INTERRUPTION) HOWEVER CAUSED AND ON ANY +THEORY OF LIABILITY, WHETHER IN CONTRACT, STRICT LIABILITY, OR TORT +(INCLUDING NEGLIGENCE OR OTHERWISE) ARISING IN ANY WAY OUT OF THE USE +OF THIS SOFTWARE, EVEN IF ADVISED OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGE. diff --git a/js/watch/WEBRTC-PATENTS b/js/watch/WEBRTC-PATENTS new file mode 100644 index 00000000000..190607ac261 --- /dev/null +++ b/js/watch/WEBRTC-PATENTS @@ -0,0 +1,24 @@ +Additional IP Rights Grant (Patents) + +"This implementation" means the copyrightable works distributed by +Google as part of the WebRTC code package. + +Google hereby grants to you a perpetual, worldwide, non-exclusive, +no-charge, irrevocable (except as stated in this section) patent +license to make, have made, use, offer to sell, sell, import, +transfer, and otherwise run, modify and propagate the contents of this +implementation of the WebRTC code package, where such license applies +only to those patent claims, both currently owned by Google and +acquired in the future, licensable by Google that are necessarily +infringed by this implementation of the WebRTC code package. This +grant does not include claims that would be infringed only as a +consequence of further modification of this implementation. If you or +your agent or exclusive licensee institute or order or agree to the +institution of patent litigation against any entity (including a +cross-claim or counterclaim in a lawsuit) alleging that this +implementation of the WebRTC code package or any code incorporated +within this implementation of the WebRTC code package constitutes +direct or contributory patent infringement, or inducement of patent +infringement, then any patent rights granted to you under this License +for this implementation of the WebRTC code package shall terminate as +of the date such litigation is filed. diff --git a/js/watch/api/index.api.md b/js/watch/api/index.api.md index 1eea1a447ea..9524106ed56 100644 --- a/js/watch/api/index.api.md +++ b/js/watch/api/index.api.md @@ -92,6 +92,7 @@ export namespace Audio { bytesReceived: number; errors: number; late: number; + skips: number; stalled: Clock.Milli; stalls: number; underruns: number; diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/buffer.test.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/buffer.test.ts index ab2ac43a6ed..fa8a065764f 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/buffer.test.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/buffer.test.ts @@ -32,6 +32,7 @@ function open(): { stalled, anchored: timestamp !== undefined, underruns: 0, + skips: 0, silent: false, epoch, }; @@ -433,7 +434,16 @@ function fake(delay: Milli, buffered = false) { buffered, }); const state = (timestamp: Micro, stalled: boolean, epoch: number) => { - const data: State = { type: "state", timestamp, stalled, anchored: true, underruns: 0, silent: false, epoch }; + const data: State = { + type: "state", + timestamp, + stalled, + anchored: true, + underruns: 0, + skips: 0, + silent: false, + epoch, + }; port.dispatchEvent(new MessageEvent("message", { data })); }; return { buffer, sent, state }; diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/buffer.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/buffer.ts index 446e3c31e44..77fc8602768 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/buffer.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/buffer.ts @@ -270,6 +270,10 @@ export class AudioBuffer { /** How many times the ring has run dry mid-playback, cumulative. */ readonly underruns: Getter = this.#underruns; + readonly #skips = new Signal(0); + /** How many times the ring skipped ahead, dropping queued audio, cumulative. */ + readonly skips: Getter = this.#skips; + readonly #silent = new Signal(false); /** Whether playback is at a declared end, reached or announced before any audio, and nothing has played since. */ readonly silent: Getter = this.#silent; @@ -326,6 +330,7 @@ export class AudioBuffer { this.#timestamp.set(data.timestamp); this.#stalled.set(data.stalled); this.#underruns.set(data.underruns); + this.#skips.set(data.skips); this.#silent.set(data.silent); if (data.epoch === this.#epoch) { this.#backpressure.observe(data.anchored ? data.timestamp : undefined, data.stalled); diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/decoder.test.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/decoder.test.ts index 3a15d872cae..e0c2854c8bb 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/decoder.test.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/decoder.test.ts @@ -97,6 +97,9 @@ class FakeWorklet { get length(): number { return this.ring?.length ?? 0; } + get skips(): number { + return this.ring?.skips ?? 0; + } // Render one quantum and report the ring's state back to the main thread. read(output: Float32Array[]): number { const ring = this.ring; @@ -108,6 +111,7 @@ class FakeWorklet { stalled: ring.stalled, anchored: ring.anchored, underruns: ring.underruns, + skips: ring.skips, silent: ring.silent, epoch: this.#epoch, }; @@ -1268,7 +1272,7 @@ describe("Decoder across a rename", () => { const delay = playback.sync.out.delay.peek(); expect(delay).toBeGreaterThan(Milli(200)); const ring = playback.ring(); - const before = { ...playback.counts, buffered: ring?.length ?? 0 }; + const before = { silent: playback.counts.silent, skips: ring?.skips ?? 0 }; let lowest = delay; const watch = new Effect(); watch.subscribe(playback.sync.out.delay, (value) => { @@ -1279,10 +1283,8 @@ describe("Decoder across a rename", () => { await playback.run(26_000); watch.close(); - const { inserted, played, silent } = playback.counts; - const buffered = playback.ring()?.length ?? 0; - const skipped = inserted - before.inserted - (played - before.played) - (buffered - before.buffered); - expect({ skipped, silent: silent - before.silent }).toEqual({ skipped: 0, silent: 0 }); + const skips = (playback.ring()?.skips ?? 0) - before.skips; + expect({ skips, silent: playback.counts.silent - before.silent }).toEqual({ skips: 0, silent: 0 }); expect(playback.ring()).toBe(ring); expect(lowest).toBeGreaterThanOrEqual(delay); } finally { @@ -1626,13 +1628,17 @@ for (const cmaf of [false, true]) { (buffered ? [0, 20, 40, 60, 80] : [140, 160]).map((ms) => start + ms * 1000), ); - // A running live ring sheds old audio when it gets ahead; a buffered ring plays it all. + // A running live ring sheds old audio and lands on its floor once it reaches the fast + // accelerate threshold, four times a 100 ms floor plus its 20 ms band; a buffered ring + // plays it all. const ring = worklets.at(-1)?.ring; if (!ring) throw new Error("no running audio ring"); ring.reset(); const samples = [new Float32Array(4800), new Float32Array(4800)]; - for (const timestamp of [0, 100_000, 200_000]) ring.write(Micro(timestamp), samples); - expect(ring.length).toBe(samples[0].length * (buffered ? 3 : 1)); + for (let timestamp = 0; timestamp < 500_000; timestamp += 100_000) + ring.write(Micro(timestamp), samples); + expect(ring.length).toBe(samples[0].length * (buffered ? 5 : 1)); + expect(ring.skips).toBe(buffered ? 0 : 1); } finally { playback.close(); await microtasks(); diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/decoder.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/decoder.ts index 2fdc33a3b1f..1ae1f0552b7 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/decoder.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/decoder.ts @@ -98,6 +98,8 @@ export interface Stats { bytesReceived: number; /** How many times playback ran dry mid-stream; a rising count means the delay is too low. */ underruns: number; + /** How many times playback skipped ahead, dropping buffered audio rather than playing it faster. */ + skips: number; /** Frames that arrived after their playout time. */ late: number; /** Renditions that failed to decode. */ @@ -111,7 +113,7 @@ export interface Stats { } // The running totals before anything is counted. -const EMPTY: Stats = { bytesReceived: 0, underruns: 0, late: 0, errors: 0, stalls: 0, stalled: Milli.zero }; +const EMPTY: Stats = { bytesReceived: 0, underruns: 0, skips: 0, late: 0, errors: 0, stalls: 0, stalled: Milli.zero }; // What a decode attempt reads, and where its counts go. type Attempt = { config: DecoderConfig; failure: Signal; path: Moq.Path.Valid; key: Key }; @@ -413,6 +415,14 @@ export class Decoder { if (added <= 0) return; this.#count(this.#playing, { underruns: added }, (stats) => ({ underruns: stats.underruns + added })); }); + let skipped = 0; + effect.run((inner) => { + const skips = inner.get(ring.skips); + const added = skips - skipped; + skipped = skips; + if (added <= 0) return; + this.#count(undefined, {}, (stats) => ({ skips: stats.skips + added })); + }); effect.set(this.#out.root, worklet); }); diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/playout.test.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/playout.test.ts index 8508b3180ba..e69a78f7c9c 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/playout.test.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/playout.test.ts @@ -136,8 +136,10 @@ function build(latencyMs: number): AudioRingBuffer { interface Result { /** Quanta rendered short of a full block after the warmup, i.e. audible underruns. */ underruns: number; - /** Samples inserted after the warmup that were never played: skipped or overflow-dropped. */ - skipped: number; + /** Times the ring re-anchored after the warmup, dropping buffered audio rather than playing it. */ + skips: number; + /** Samples time stretch added or removed after the warmup: output against the media it covered. */ + stretched: number; } /** @@ -148,40 +150,40 @@ function replay(ring: AudioRingBuffer, t: Arrival[], warmupMs: number): Result { const step = (QUANTUM / RATE) * 1000; const output = [new Float32Array(QUANTUM)]; const end = t[t.length - 1].arrival; + const position = () => (ring.timestamp * RATE) / 1_000_000; let next = 0; - let played = 0; - let inserted = 0; let short = 0; + let skips = 0; + let stretched = 0; let started = false; - let mark: { played: number; inserted: number; buffered: number; short: number } | undefined; for (let now = 0; now < end; now += step) { + const playhead = position(); + const skipped = ring.skips; while (next < t.length && t[next].arrival <= now) { ring.write(Micro.fromMilli(t[next].media as Milli), [new Float32Array(CHUNK).fill(0.5)]); - inserted += CHUNK; next++; } const count = ring.read(output); - played += count; + if (now < warmupMs) { + if (count > 0) started = true; + continue; + } if (started && count < QUANTUM) short++; if (count > 0) started = true; - - if (now >= warmupMs && !mark) mark = { played, inserted, buffered: ring.length, short }; + if (ring.skips > skipped) skips += ring.skips - skipped; + else stretched += Math.abs(position() - playhead - count); } - const from = mark ?? { played, inserted, buffered: ring.length, short }; - return { - underruns: short - from.short, - skipped: inserted - from.inserted - (played - from.played) - (ring.length - from.buffered), - }; + return { underruns: short, skips, stretched: Math.round(stretched) }; } describe("ring replay", () => { it("plays an evenly paced sender without underruns or skips", async () => { const t = trace(600, 1, 10); - expect(replay(build(await settled(t)), t, 2000)).toEqual({ underruns: 0, skipped: 0 }); + expect(replay(build(await settled(t)), t, 2000)).toMatchObject({ underruns: 0, skips: 0 }); }); it("plays a bursty sender at the measured target", async () => { @@ -189,7 +191,7 @@ describe("ring replay", () => { const t = trace(600, 3, 5); const measured = await settled(t); expect(measured).toBeGreaterThan(2 * CHUNK_MS); - expect(replay(build(measured), t, 2000)).toEqual({ underruns: 0, skipped: 0 }); + expect(replay(build(measured), t, 2000)).toMatchObject({ underruns: 0, skips: 0 }); }); it("keeps a five frame flush span playing", async () => { @@ -197,16 +199,20 @@ describe("ring replay", () => { // slack above it absorbs the peak, so the flush plays instead of being cut down to the // target on arrival. const t = trace(600, 5, 5); - expect(replay(build(await settled(t)), t, 2000)).toEqual({ underruns: 0, skipped: 0 }); + expect(replay(build(await settled(t)), t, 2000)).toMatchObject({ underruns: 0, skips: 0 }); }); - it("underruns constantly when the target ignores the arrival spread", () => { + it("covers a target that ignores the arrival spread by stretching", () => { // 46ms is what the round-trip formula produced on the connection this was measured on: it // describes the network and says nothing about a sender that flushes five frames at once. + // Every flush's trough falls below it, which ran the ring dry on each flush until time stretch + // expanded through the troughs. A flush still swings the ring by its whole 100 ms, so this + // stretches as much as the measured target does, accelerating off each peak and expanding + // through each trough. const t = trace(600, 5, 5); const result = replay(build(46), t, 2000); - expect(result.underruns).toBeGreaterThan(100); - expect(result.skipped).toBeGreaterThan(10 * CHUNK); + expect(result).toMatchObject({ underruns: 0, skips: 0 }); + expect(result.stretched).toBeGreaterThan(0); }); }); diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/render-worklet.test.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/render-worklet.test.ts index 044e1e7c960..f50a003f05f 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/render-worklet.test.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/render-worklet.test.ts @@ -85,6 +85,7 @@ describe("render dispatch", () => { stalled: false, anchored: true, underruns: 0, + skips: 0, silent: false, }, ]); @@ -113,6 +114,7 @@ describe("render dispatch", () => { stalled: false, anchored: true, underruns: 0, + skips: 0, silent: false, }, ]); diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/render-worklet.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/render-worklet.ts index 230dba0e782..e7c23e255b4 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/render-worklet.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/render-worklet.ts @@ -100,6 +100,7 @@ class Render extends AudioWorkletProcessor { stalled: ring.stalled, anchored: ring.anchored, underruns: ring.underruns, + skips: ring.skips, silent: ring.silent, epoch: this.#epoch, }; diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/render.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/render.ts index f60f1612000..b3ac4dde878 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/render.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/render.ts @@ -62,6 +62,8 @@ export interface State { anchored: boolean; // How many times the ring has run dry mid-playback, cumulative. underruns: number; + // How many times the ring skipped ahead, dropping queued audio, cumulative. + skips: number; // Whether playback is at a declared end, reached or announced before any audio, and nothing has played since. silent: boolean; // The epoch of the last reset or park the worklet applied. diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/replay.test.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/replay.test.ts index 44e110a609f..e7568f790c0 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/replay.test.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/replay.test.ts @@ -68,33 +68,36 @@ describe("replay", () => { }); it("counts each run-dry the way the player's stats do", async () => { - // One frame 200 ms late against a 100 ms target: the ring runs dry once and re-stalls to refill. + // One frame 200 ms late against a 60 ms target: the groups behind it wait longer than time + // stretch can spread the ring, so it runs dry part-way through a quantum, which counts, and + // re-stalls to refill on the next, which counts again. const trace = paced(10, (i) => (i === 250 ? 230 : 30)).sort((a, b) => a.at - b.at); const counted = async (arrivals: Arrival[]) => { let last = 0; for await (const { underruns } of replay(arrivals, { rate: RATE, config: CONFIG, - delay: Milli(100), + delay: Milli(60), duration: observed(10), })) last = underruns; return last; }; expect(await counted(paced(10, () => 30))).toBe(0); - expect(await counted(trace)).toBe(1); + expect(await counted(trace)).toBe(2); }); it("holds newer groups behind a missing one until the max delay gives up on it", async () => { const trace = paced(10, () => 30).filter((arrival) => arrival.group !== 250); - // The consumer delivers in group order, so the ring runs dry for longer than the missing frame - // while the groups behind it wait. Writing arrivals straight into the ring plays straight through. + // The consumer delivers in group order, so the groups behind the missing one wait, longer than + // time stretch can spread a 60 ms ring, and it runs dry for longer than the missing frame. + // Writing arrivals straight into the ring would play only the frame's own 20 ms hole. const frame = Math.ceil((20 / 1000) * (RATE / QUANTUM)); expect( await underruns(trace, { rate: RATE, config: CONFIG, - delay: Milli(100), + delay: Milli(60), duration: observed(10), }), ).toBeGreaterThan(frame); diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/replay.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/replay.ts index 8e9cc3f172a..b0d5ca9d5d7 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/replay.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/replay.ts @@ -85,6 +85,8 @@ export interface Quantum { delay: number; /** The ring's cumulative underruns, as the player's stats count them: each run-dry and each short quantum. */ underruns: number; + /** The ring's cumulative skips, as the player's stats count them: each jump that dropped queued audio. */ + skips: number; } /** Samples as the milliseconds `AudioBuffer` posts to the worklet. */ @@ -279,6 +281,7 @@ export async function* replay(trace: Arrival[], options: Options): AsyncGenerato timestamp: Milli.fromMicro(ring.timestamp), delay, underruns: ring.underruns, + skips: ring.skips, }; } } finally { diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts index 238dd6144d5..1111a469080 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts @@ -108,8 +108,10 @@ describe("writing data", () => { } }); + // These drain the ring below its floor without refilling it, which a live ring stretches, so they + // run buffered, which plays exactly what the ring holds. it("should handle late-arriving samples (out-of-order writes)", () => { - const buffer = new AudioRingBuffer({ rate: 1000, channels: 1, latency: 100 as Milli }); + const buffer = new AudioRingBuffer({ rate: 1000, channels: 1, latency: 100 as Milli, buffered: true }); // Fill buffer to exit stalled mode write(buffer, 0 as Milli, 100, { channels: 1, value: 0.0 }); @@ -146,7 +148,7 @@ describe("writing data", () => { }); it("should discard samples that are too old", () => { - const buffer = new AudioRingBuffer({ rate: 1000, channels: 2, latency: 100 as Milli }); + const buffer = new AudioRingBuffer({ rate: 1000, channels: 2, latency: 100 as Milli, buffered: true }); // Exit stalled mode by filling buffer write(buffer, 0 as Milli, 100, { channels: 2, value: 0.0 }); @@ -171,9 +173,10 @@ describe("writing data", () => { }); }); +// Buffered, for the same reason as the writes above. describe("reading data", () => { it("should read available data", () => { - const buffer = new AudioRingBuffer({ rate: 1000, channels: 2, latency: 100 as Milli }); + const buffer = new AudioRingBuffer({ rate: 1000, channels: 2, latency: 100 as Milli, buffered: true }); // Exit stalled mode by filling the buffer write(buffer, 0 as Milli, 100, { channels: 2, value: 0.0 }); @@ -211,7 +214,7 @@ describe("reading data", () => { }); it("should handle partial reads", () => { - const buffer = new AudioRingBuffer({ rate: 1000, channels: 2, latency: 100 as Milli }); + const buffer = new AudioRingBuffer({ rate: 1000, channels: 2, latency: 100 as Milli, buffered: true }); // Exit stalled mode by filling the buffer write(buffer, 0 as Milli, 100, { channels: 2, value: 0.0 }); @@ -269,47 +272,23 @@ describe("stall behavior", () => { describe("ring buffer wrapping", () => { it("should wrap around when buffer is full", () => { - // 100 sample target, so 200 samples of capacity. - const buffer = new AudioRingBuffer({ rate: 1000, channels: 1, latency: 100 as Milli }); - - // Fill to the target - write(buffer, 0 as Milli, 100, { channels: 1, value: 1.0 }); - expect(buffer.stalled).toBe(false); - - // Read 50 samples to make room (readIndex at 50) - const output1 = read(buffer, 50, 1); - expect(output1[0].length).toBe(50); - - // Write 50 more samples at timestamp 100 (fills from sample 100-149) - write(buffer, 100 as Milli, 50, { channels: 1, value: 2.0 }); - - // Now we have 100 samples available (50-149) - expect(buffer.length).toBe(100); - - // One chunk above the target is tolerated rather than dropped (50-199). - write(buffer, 150 as Milli, 50, { channels: 1, value: 3.0 }); - expect(buffer.length).toBe(150); - - // Past the band: drop back to the target, wrapping abs 200-249 onto slots 0-49. - write(buffer, 200 as Milli, 50, { channels: 1, value: 4.0 }); - expect(buffer.length).toBe(100); + // A 1000-sample ring, buffered so it plays through everything it holds. + const buffer = new AudioRingBuffer({ rate: 1000, channels: 1, latency: 100 as Milli, buffered: true }); + write(buffer, 0 as Milli, 600, { channels: 1, value: 1.0 }); + expect(read(buffer, 500, 1)[0].length).toBe(500); - // Read all 100 samples: abs 150-199 = 3.0, abs 200-249 = 4.0. - const output2 = read(buffer, 100, 1); - expect(output2[0].length).toBe(100); + // Abs 600-1199 wraps onto slots 600-999 and 0-199. + write(buffer, 600 as Milli, 600, { channels: 1, value: 2.0 }); + expect(buffer.length).toBe(700); - for (let i = 0; i < 50; i++) { - expect(output2[0][i]).toBe(3.0); - } - for (let i = 50; i < 100; i++) { - expect(output2[0][i]).toBe(4.0); - } + const [output] = read(buffer, 700, 1); + expect([...output]).toEqual([...Array(100).fill(1), ...Array(600).fill(2)]); }); }); describe("multi-channel handling", () => { it("should handle stereo data correctly", () => { - const buffer = new AudioRingBuffer({ rate: 1000, channels: 2, latency: 100 as Milli }); + const buffer = new AudioRingBuffer({ rate: 1000, channels: 2, latency: 100 as Milli, buffered: true }); // Exit stalled mode by filling buffer write(buffer, 0 as Milli, 100, { channels: 2, value: 0.5 }); @@ -793,7 +772,8 @@ describe("latency increase", () => { // Video holds a deeper floor on its own, so audio has to park for the difference or it runs // ahead. Flushing instead cost the whole floor in silence for every rise, however small. it("parks a playing ring until the deeper floor refills, keeping what it buffered", () => { - const buffer = new AudioRingBuffer({ rate: 1000, channels: 1, latency: 100 as Milli }); + // Buffered, so it plays its floor down without the expand a live ring stretches it with. + const buffer = new AudioRingBuffer({ rate: 1000, channels: 1, latency: 100 as Milli, buffered: true }); // Fill to the floor so playback starts, then play half of it. write(buffer, 0 as Milli, 100, { channels: 1, value: 1.0 }); @@ -838,3 +818,109 @@ describe("latency increase", () => { expect(read(buffer, 1, 1)[0][0]).toBe(1.0); }); }); + +describe("time stretch", () => { + // 48 kHz: 30 ms windows of 1440 frames, and a constant signal stretches by its shortest pitch + // period, 2.5 ms or 120 frames. + const RATE = 48000; + const QUANTUM = 128; + const live = (latency: number) => new AudioRingBuffer({ rate: RATE, channels: 1, latency: latency as Milli }); + const frames = (ms: number) => (RATE * ms) / 1000; + + it("expands a ring short of its floor, so it plays longer than it holds before running dry", () => { + const buffer = live(100); + write(buffer, 0 as Milli, frames(100), { value: 0.5 }); + let played = 0; + for (;;) { + const [output] = read(buffer, QUANTUM, 1); + played += output.length; + if (output.length < QUANTUM) break; + } + expect(played).toBeGreaterThan(frames(100)); + expect(buffer.underruns).toBe(1); + }); + + it("drains the tail before a declared end as received, since running dry there is silence", () => { + const buffer = live(100); + write(buffer, 0 as Milli, frames(100), { value: 0.5 }); + buffer.end(Micro.fromMilli(100 as Milli)); + let played = 0; + for (;;) { + const [output] = read(buffer, QUANTUM, 1); + played += output.length; + if (output.length < QUANTUM) break; + } + expect(played).toBe(frames(100)); + expect(buffer.underruns).toBe(0); + expect(buffer.silent).toBe(true); + }); + + // Fed at the real-time rate, so only the stretch can move the ring's depth. + async function converge(buffer: AudioRingBuffer, start: number, seconds: number) { + const timestamps: number[] = []; + let written = start; + for (let rendered = 0; rendered < frames(seconds * 1000); rendered += QUANTUM) { + while (written < start + rendered + QUANTUM) { + write(buffer, ((written * 1000) / RATE) as Milli, frames(20), { value: 0.5 }); + written += frames(20); + } + const [output] = read(buffer, QUANTUM, 1); + expect(output.length).toBe(QUANTUM); + timestamps.push(Milli.fromMicro(buffer.timestamp)); + } + return { timestamps, written }; + } + + it("accelerates a ring above its floor back onto it, dropping nothing", async () => { + const buffer = live(100); + write(buffer, 0 as Milli, frames(300), { value: 0.5 }); + const { timestamps, written } = await converge(buffer, frames(300), 8); + + // Within the band above the floor, give or take the 20 ms frame just written. + expect(buffer.length).toBeGreaterThanOrEqual(frames(100) - frames(20)); + expect(buffer.length).toBeLessThan(frames(120) + frames(20)); + // Every sample written either played or is still buffered, so nothing was skipped. + expect(Math.round((Milli.fromMicro(buffer.timestamp) * RATE) / 1000) + buffer.length).toBeGreaterThan( + written - frames(30), + ); + for (let i = 1; i < timestamps.length; i++) { + const step = timestamps[i] - timestamps[i - 1]; + expect(step).toBeGreaterThan(0); + expect(step).toBeLessThanOrEqual((2 * QUANTUM * 1000) / RATE + 1e-9); + } + expect(buffer.underruns).toBe(0); + }); + + it("fast-accelerates a ring four times past the band, even straight after a stretch", async () => { + const buffer = live(100); + write(buffer, 0 as Milli, frames(600), { value: 0.5 }); + await converge(buffer, frames(600), 1); + // Fast accelerate removes up to 15 ms of every 30 ms window until the ring is under 480 ms. + expect(buffer.length).toBeLessThan(frames(480)); + }); + + // Past NetEq's fast threshold, four times the floor plus its 20 ms band, or three quarters of the + // headroom above the floor, whichever is lower, stretching back would take seconds, so the ring + // re-anchors on its floor as moq-audio does. With 1000 ms of capacity, a 100 ms floor reaches the + // first at 480 ms and a 300 ms floor the second at 825 ms. + for (const [floor, threshold] of [ + [100, 480], + [300, 825], + ]) { + it(`re-anchors a ${floor} ms floor only once the ring holds ${threshold} ms`, () => { + const buffer = live(floor); + write(buffer, 0 as Milli, frames(floor), { value: 0.5 }); + read(buffer, QUANTUM, 1); + const playhead = buffer.timestamp; + + write(buffer, floor as Milli, frames(threshold - 10 - floor), { value: 0.5 }); + expect(buffer.timestamp).toBe(playhead); + expect(buffer.skips).toBe(0); + + write(buffer, (threshold - 10) as Milli, frames(20), { value: 0.5 }); + expect(buffer.timestamp).toBeGreaterThan(playhead); + expect(buffer.length).toBeLessThan(frames(floor) + frames(30)); + expect(buffer.skips).toBe(1); + }); + } +}); diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts index 3afd723d588..6b520f1ea7c 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts @@ -1,5 +1,6 @@ import { Micro, type Milli, Second } from "@moq/clock"; import { ringCapacity } from "./latency"; +import { Stretch } from "./stretch"; export class AudioRingBuffer { #buffer: Float32Array[]; @@ -12,6 +13,7 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { // Held stalled for the part of the target above the floor, until the next floor update. #parked = false; #underruns = 0; + #skips = 0; // Where the publisher declared its audio ends, as a sample index, until the next reset. #end?: number; @@ -33,12 +35,19 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { // silence, which is no underrun and survives the reset that re-anchors the next utterance. #silent = false; - // Samples in the most recent write, i.e. one decoded chunk. The overflow band tolerates this - // much above the target before dropping, so a ring sitting exactly on the target doesn't drop - // audio the moment the next chunk lands. The most recent write rather than a running maximum: - // one oversized decode would otherwise widen the band for the life of the ring. + // Samples in the most recent write, i.e. one decoded chunk. Catching up over a declared silence + // tolerates this much above the target, so a ring sitting exactly on the target doesn't skip the + // moment the next chunk lands. The most recent write rather than a running maximum: one oversized + // decode would otherwise widen the band for the life of the ring. #chunk = 0; + // Live playback converges on the floor by time-stretching each window of received PCM on its way + // out. The read index is past the staged window, which spans `#window` samples of the ring. + readonly #stretch: Stretch; + #window = 0; + // Whether the staged window lies in a declared silence, which plays unstretched as comfort noise. + #windowQuiet = false; + // Buffered mode: play through everything buffered without skipping ahead. readonly #buffered: boolean; // Un-stall threshold in samples (how much to buffer before playback starts). @@ -74,6 +83,7 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { for (let i = 0; i < this.channels; i++) { this.#buffer[i] = new Float32Array(capacity); } + this.#stretch = new Stretch(this.rate, this.channels); } get stalled(): boolean { @@ -85,6 +95,11 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { return this.#underruns; } + /** How many times the ring skipped ahead, dropping queued audio rather than playing it. */ + get skips(): number { + return this.#skips; + } + /** Whether playback is at a declared end, reached or announced before any audio, and nothing has played since. */ get silent(): boolean { return this.#silent; @@ -98,8 +113,11 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { return this.#quiet; } + /** The playhead, with the staged window's unplayed output mapped back onto the samples it came from. */ get timestamp(): Micro { - return Micro.fromSecond((this.#readIndex / this.rate) as Second); + const stretch = this.#stretch; + const staged = stretch.length > 0 ? (stretch.available * this.#window) / stretch.length : 0; + return Micro.fromSecond(((this.#readIndex - staged) / this.rate) as Second); } /** Whether an insert has anchored the indices since creation or the last reset. */ @@ -107,8 +125,9 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { return this.#anchored; } + /** Samples left to play: the ring past the read index, plus the stretched output staged from it. */ get length(): number { - return this.#writeIndex - this.#readIndex; + return this.#writeIndex - this.#readIndex + this.#stretch.available; } get capacity(): number { @@ -186,20 +205,35 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { if (start > this.#writeIndex) this.#pauses.push({ start: this.#writeIndex, end: start }); } - // Bound the ring. While playing, drop the oldest once it holds a whole chunk more than the - // target and land back on the target: frames arrive one chunk at a time, so a ring sitting - // exactly on the target is a chunk above it the moment the next one lands, and dropping on - // that overshoot discards audio on every single write. While stalled the reader is not - // consuming, so only the hard capacity applies; the band would throw away the very audio the - // refill is accumulating. Buffered mode plays through everything, so it is capacity-bound too. + // Bound the ring. While playing live, the read path stretches the ring back onto its floor, so + // dropping the oldest audio and landing on the floor is an emergency re-anchor, as moq-audio + // does: at NetEq's fast threshold, four times the floor plus its 20 ms band, or once the ring + // holds three quarters of its headroom above the floor, whichever comes first. While stalled the + // reader is not consuming, so only the hard capacity applies; dropping would throw away the very + // audio the refill is accumulating. Buffered mode plays through everything, so it is + // capacity-bound too. const playing = !this.#stalled && !this.#buffered; - // Until the tail before a declared silence has played, only the capacity bounds the ring; the - // band then catches up by skipping the silence. + // Until the tail before a declared silence has played, only the capacity bounds the ring; then + // a ring a chunk above its floor catches up by skipping the silence, which drops no audio. const band = playing && (this.#tail === undefined || this.#readIndex >= this.#tail); - const limit = band ? Math.min(this.#latencySamples + this.#chunk, this.capacity) : this.capacity; - if (end - this.#readIndex > limit) { - this.#readIndex = end - (band ? Math.min(this.#latencySamples, this.capacity) : this.capacity); + this.#prune(); + const pause = this.#pauses[0]; + const latency = this.#latencySamples; + const queued = end - this.#readIndex + this.#stretch.available; + if (end - this.#readIndex > this.capacity) { + this.#skip(end - this.capacity); + } else if (band && pause && pause.start <= this.#readIndex && queued > latency + this.#chunk) { + this.#readIndex = Math.min(pause.end, end - latency); this.#prune(); + } else if ( + band && + queued >= + Math.min( + 4 * (latency + Math.floor((this.rate * 20) / 1000)), + latency + Math.floor(((this.capacity - latency) * 3) / 4), + ) + ) { + this.#skip(end - latency); } // Fill gaps with zeros if there's a discontinuity @@ -273,6 +307,13 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { if (!this.#anchored || (this.#stalled && this.length <= 0 && this.#ended())) this.#silent = true; } + // Move the read index forward to `index`, dropping any queued audio it passes. + #skip(index: number): void { + if (index > this.#readIndex && this.#readIndex < this.#writeIndex) this.#skips++; + this.#readIndex = index; + this.#prune(); + } + // Forget the declared silences the playhead has passed. #prune(): void { const pauses = this.#pauses; @@ -318,15 +359,17 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { this.#next = false; this.#tail = undefined; this.#pauses = []; + this.#stretch.clear(); + this.#window = 0; } read(output: Float32Array[]): number { if (output.length !== this.channels) throw new Error("wrong number of channels"); + for (const dst of output) if (dst.length !== output[0].length) throw new Error("mismatching number of samples"); this.#quiet = undefined; if (this.#stalled) return 0; - const samples = Math.min(this.#writeIndex - this.#readIndex, output[0].length); - if (samples <= 0) { + if (this.length <= 0) { // Ran dry mid-playback: re-stall so write() refills to the target before resuming. this.#stalled = true; if (this.#ended()) this.#silent = true; @@ -334,31 +377,16 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { return 0; } - for (let channel = 0; channel < this.channels; channel++) { - const dst = output[channel]; - const src = this.#buffer[channel]; - - if (dst.length !== output[0].length) throw new Error("mismatching number of samples"); - - for (let i = 0; i < samples; i++) { - const readPos = (this.#readIndex + i) % src.length; - dst[i] = src[readPos]; - } + const stretch = this.#stretch; + let samples = 0; + while (samples < output[0].length) { + if (stretch.available === 0 && !this.#stage(output[0].length - samples)) break; + const from = samples; + samples += stretch.read(output, samples); + // A quantum overlaps at most one declared silence unless an utterance is shorter than it, + // which no codec frame is; the span then covers both silences and the sliver between them. + if (this.#windowQuiet) this.#quiet = [this.#quiet?.[0] ?? from, samples]; } - - // A quantum overlaps at most one declared silence unless an utterance is shorter than it, which - // no codec frame is; the span then covers both silences and the sliver between them. - this.#prune(); - const pauses = this.#pauses; - const after = this.#readIndex + samples; - const first = pauses[0]; - if (first && first.start < after) { - let last = first; - for (const pause of pauses) if (pause.start < after) last = pause; - this.#quiet = [Math.max(0, first.start - this.#readIndex), Math.min(samples, last.end - this.#readIndex)]; - } - - this.#readIndex += samples; this.#silent = false; // A short quantum ends in silence, so it counts as an underrun even if a chunk lands before @@ -376,4 +404,35 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { return samples; } + + // Move the next window off the ring into the stretch, which converges a live ring on its floor. + // A window stops at the edge of a declared silence, which plays unstretched, so the stretch never + // moves where one starts or ends. Whatever cannot stretch stages only the `need` this quantum + // reads, so a write still lands anywhere past the playhead. Returns false once the ring is empty. + #stage(need: number): boolean { + const buffered = this.#writeIndex - this.#readIndex; + if (buffered <= 0) return false; + + this.#prune(); + const pause = this.#pauses[0]; + const quiet = pause !== undefined && pause.start <= this.#readIndex; + // Audio before a declared end is a finite tail: running dry after it is silence, not an + // underrun, so it drains as received rather than expanding toward a target nothing will refill. + const end = this.#previous ?? this.#end; + const ending = end !== undefined && this.#readIndex < end; + const enabled = !quiet && !ending && !this.#buffered; + let frames = Math.min(buffered, this.#stretch.window, enabled ? buffered : need); + if (pause) frames = Math.min(frames, (quiet ? pause.end : pause.start) - this.#readIndex); + + for (let channel = 0; channel < this.channels; channel++) { + const src = this.#buffer[channel]; + const dst = this.#stretch.input[channel]; + for (let i = 0; i < frames; i++) dst[i] = src[(this.#readIndex + i) % src.length]; + } + this.#stretch.process(frames, buffered, this.#latencySamples, enabled); + this.#readIndex += frames; + this.#window = frames; + this.#windowQuiet = quiet; + return true; + } } diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.test.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.test.ts new file mode 100644 index 00000000000..f4a50d4d94d --- /dev/null +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.test.ts @@ -0,0 +1,74 @@ +import { expect, it } from "bun:test"; +import { readFileSync } from "node:fs"; +import { dirname, join } from "node:path"; +import { fileURLToPath } from "node:url"; +import { type Decision, Stretch } from "./stretch"; + +interface Vector { + name: string; + rate: number; + channels: number; + input: number[]; + buffered: number; + target: number; + cooldown: number; + decision: Decision; + lag: number; + output: number[]; +} + +// Shared with moq-audio, so neither implementation is graded against the other. +const corpus = join( + dirname(fileURLToPath(import.meta.url)), + "../../../../doc/concept/audio-jitter/stretch/corpus.json", +); +const vectors = JSON.parse(readFileSync(corpus, "utf8")) as Vector[]; + +// The corpus is interleaved; the ring is planar. +const planar = (samples: number[], channels: number) => + Array.from({ length: channels }, (_, channel) => samples.filter((_, i) => i % channels === channel)); + +for (const vector of vectors) { + it(`stretches the corpus PCM: ${vector.name}`, () => { + const stretch = new Stretch(vector.rate, vector.channels); + planar(vector.input, vector.channels).forEach((samples, channel) => { + stretch.input[channel].set(samples); + }); + stretch.cooldown = vector.cooldown; + expect(stretch.decide(vector.buffered, vector.target)).toBe(vector.decision); + + stretch.process(stretch.window, vector.buffered, vector.target, true); + expect(Math.abs(stretch.available - stretch.window)).toBe(vector.lag); + + const output = Array.from({ length: vector.channels }, () => new Float32Array(stretch.available)); + expect(stretch.read(output, 0)).toBe(output[0].length); + const expected = planar(vector.output, vector.channels); + for (let channel = 0; channel < vector.channels; channel++) { + expect(output[channel].length).toBe(expected[channel].length); + output[channel].forEach((sample, i) => { + expect(Math.abs(sample - expected[channel][i])).toBeLessThanOrEqual(1e-6); + }); + } + }); +} + +it("passes a short, disabled, or exhausted window through unchanged", () => { + for (const rate of [8000, 44100, 48000, 96000]) { + const stretch = new Stretch(rate, 2); + for (const channel of stretch.input) channel.fill(0.25); + stretch.cooldown = 0; + + // A ring well short of its target expands a full window of received PCM. + stretch.process(stretch.window, stretch.window, rate, true); + expect(stretch.available).toBeGreaterThan(stretch.window); + const output = [new Float32Array(rate), new Float32Array(rate)]; + expect(stretch.read(output, 0)).toBe(stretch.length); + expect(stretch.read(output, 0)).toBe(0); + + stretch.cooldown = 0; + stretch.process(stretch.window, stretch.window, rate, false); + expect(stretch.available).toBe(stretch.window); + stretch.process(stretch.window >> 1, stretch.window, rate, true); + expect(stretch.available).toBe(stretch.window >> 1); + } +}); diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts new file mode 100644 index 00000000000..dde0ad4e4c8 --- /dev/null +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts @@ -0,0 +1,216 @@ +/*! + * Received-PCM adaptation of WebRTC NetEq's accelerate and preemptive expand, the shared algorithm + * doc/concept/audio-jitter.md specifies for this player and moq-audio's. + * + * Copyright (c) 2012 The WebRTC project authors. All Rights Reserved. + * Ported from modules/audio_coding/neteq/{time_stretch,accelerate,preemptive_expand,dsp_helper, + * audio_vector,decision_logic}. + * @license BSD-3-Clause, with WebRTC's patent grant: see WEBRTC-LICENSE and WEBRTC-PATENTS in this package. + */ + +/** What a window boundary decides, named as the shared corpus names it. */ +export type Decision = "Hold" | "Accelerate" | "Fast" | "Expand"; + +// NetEq's 48 kHz Q12 FIR. Sampling its taps at fractional positions also admits other device rates +// without altering the search domain. +const FILTER = [1019, 390, 427, 440, 427, 390, 1019]; + +// The 4 kHz analysis: 110 downsampled samples, correlated over 50 at lags 10 through 59. +const DOWN = 110; +const LAGS = 50; +const MIN_LAG = 10; + +// NetEq's voice activity bound before it has a background noise model, from signed 16-bit PCM. +const PASSIVE = (8 * 75000) / (32768 * 32768); + +/** + * One window of received PCM and the stretched output staged from it, allocated up front so the + * render callback never allocates. + */ +export class Stretch { + /** The window to analyse, one array per channel: fill the first `frames` of each before {@link process}. */ + readonly input: Float32Array[]; + readonly #output: Float32Array[]; + + /** A full processing window: 30 ms of received PCM, in frames. */ + readonly window: number; + + readonly #rate: number; + // 15 ms: the seam's position, and the longest pitch period. + readonly #middle: number; + // 20 ms: the band above the target that holds before accelerating. + readonly #band: number; + // 50 ms: NetEq's five 10 ms ticks between stretches. + readonly #rest: number; + + #position = 0; + #length = 0; + + /** Frames left to render before an ordinary stretch: NetEq's six startup ticks, then its five. */ + cooldown: number; + + readonly #down = new Float64Array(DOWN); + readonly #correlation = new Float64Array(LAGS); + + constructor(rate: number, channels: number) { + this.#rate = rate; + this.window = Math.max(1, Math.floor((rate * 30) / 1000)); + this.#middle = Math.floor((rate * 15) / 1000); + this.#band = Math.floor((rate * 20) / 1000); + this.#rest = Math.floor((rate * 50) / 1000); + this.cooldown = Math.floor((rate * 60) / 1000); + this.input = Array.from({ length: channels }, () => new Float32Array(this.window)); + this.#output = Array.from({ length: channels }, () => new Float32Array(this.window + this.#middle)); + } + + /** Output frames staged and not yet read. */ + get available(): number { + return this.#length - this.#position; + } + + /** Output frames the last window produced, read or not. */ + get length(): number { + return this.#length; + } + + /** Drop whatever is staged. */ + clear(): void { + this.#position = 0; + this.#length = 0; + } + + /** Copy staged frames into `output` from `offset`, as many as fit, and return how many. */ + read(output: Float32Array[], offset: number): number { + const frames = Math.min(output[0].length - offset, this.available); + for (let channel = 0; channel < output.length; channel++) { + output[channel].set(this.#output[channel].subarray(this.#position, this.#position + frames), offset); + } + this.#position += frames; + this.cooldown = Math.max(0, this.cooldown - frames); + return frames; + } + + /** + * Stage the first `frames` of {@link input}, stretched toward `target` given `buffered` frames + * queued including them. Only a full window of received PCM can stretch, so a short block, or one + * that is not `enabled`, passes unchanged and a finite input never becomes concealment. + */ + process(frames: number, buffered: number, target: number, enabled: boolean): void { + const decision = enabled && frames === this.window ? this.decide(buffered, target) : "Hold"; + const lag = decision === "Hold" ? 0 : this.#pitch(decision !== "Accelerate"); + this.#position = 0; + this.#length = frames; + if (lag === 0) { + for (let channel = 0; channel < this.input.length; channel++) { + this.#output[channel].set(this.input[channel].subarray(0, frames)); + } + return; + } + + // Expand repeats whole periods after the seam; accelerate removes one, or fast as many as fit. + const middle = this.#middle; + const expand = decision === "Expand"; + const seam = expand ? middle : middle - lag; + const first = expand ? middle : middle - lag; + const second = expand ? middle - lag : middle; + const tail = expand ? middle : middle + lag; + this.#length += expand ? lag : -lag; + for (let channel = 0; channel < this.input.length; channel++) { + const input = this.input[channel]; + const output = this.#output[channel]; + output.set(input.subarray(0, seam)); + // NetEq's AudioVector::CrossFade, in floating point. The endpoints stay inside the seam + // rather than duplicating either neighbour. + for (let i = 0; i < lag; i++) { + const weight = (i + 1) / (lag + 1); + output[seam + i] = input[first + i] * (1 - weight) + input[second + i] * weight; + } + output.set(input.subarray(tail, frames), seam + lag); + } + this.cooldown = this.#rest; + } + + /** + * What a full window with `buffered` frames queued decides against `target`, both in frames. + * + * Expand departs from NetEq's preemptive expand, which repeats one period per cooldown. A ring + * below its target is short of the cushion its arrivals need, and running dry re-stalls it for a + * whole target of silence, so it expands the way fast accelerate shrinks: every window, as many + * whole periods as fit, at the lower admission threshold. + */ + decide(buffered: number, target: number): Decision { + const high = target + this.#band; + if (buffered >= high * 4) return "Fast"; + if (buffered < target) return "Expand"; + if (this.cooldown > 0) return "Hold"; + if (buffered >= high) return "Accelerate"; + return "Hold"; + } + + // Search the first channel at 4 kHz, then admit the full-rate seam, returning its length or zero. + // Fast mode, for fast accelerate and every expand, admits a weaker match and takes every whole + // period that fits before the middle. + #pitch(fast: boolean): number { + const middle = this.#middle; + if (middle === 0) return 0; + + const rate = this.#rate; + const down = this.#down; + for (let i = 0; i < DOWN; i++) { + let value = 0; + for (let tap = 0; tap < FILTER.length; tap++) { + value += (FILTER[tap] * this.#sample(((10 + 12 * i - tap) * rate) / 48000)) / 4096; + } + down[i] = value; + } + + const correlation = this.#correlation; + for (let index = 0; index < LAGS; index++) { + const lag = index + MIN_LAG; + let value = 0; + for (let t = 60; t < DOWN; t++) value += down[t] * down[t - lag]; + correlation[index] = value; + } + + // The largest sum, the smallest lag on a tie, refined by a parabola through its neighbours. + let peak = 0; + for (let index = 1; index < LAGS; index++) { + if (correlation[index] > correlation[peak]) peak = index; + } + let offset = 0; + if (peak !== 0) { + const left = correlation[peak - 1]; + const center = correlation[peak]; + const right = peak + 1 < LAGS ? correlation[peak + 1] : 0; + const denominator = left - 2 * center + right; + if (denominator !== 0) offset = Math.min(Math.max((0.5 * (left - right)) / denominator, -0.5), 0.5); + } + const lag = Math.min(Math.max(Math.round(((peak + MIN_LAG + offset) * rate) / 4000), 1), middle); + + const input = this.input[0]; + let energy1 = 0; + let energy2 = 0; + let cross = 0; + for (let i = 0; i < lag; i++) { + const a = input[middle - lag + i]; + const b = input[middle + i]; + energy1 += a * a; + energy2 += b * b; + cross += a * b; + } + const passive = (energy1 + energy2) / (2 * lag) <= PASSIVE; + const threshold = (fast ? 8192 : 14746) / 16384; + if (!passive && cross <= threshold * Math.sqrt(energy1 * energy2)) return 0; + return fast ? Math.floor(middle / lag) * lag : lag; + } + + // The first channel at a fractional frame, linearly interpolated and clamped to the window. + #sample(position: number): number { + const input = this.input[0]; + const last = this.window - 1; + const clamped = Math.min(Math.max(position, 0), last); + const at = Math.floor(clamped); + const weight = clamped - at; + return input[at] * (1 - weight) + input[Math.min(at + 1, last)] * weight; + } +} diff --git a/js/watch/src/ui/stats.ts b/js/watch/src/ui/stats.ts index c86dcfadfe1..e52b244f29e 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/ui/stats.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/ui/stats.ts @@ -67,6 +67,7 @@ export function statsTab(parent: Effect, watch: MoqWatch): HTMLElement { const aChannels = statLine(audioCard.grid, "Channels"); const aBitrate = statLine(audioCard.grid, "Bitrate"); const aUnderruns = statLine(audioCard.grid, "Underruns"); + const aSkips = statLine(audioCard.grid, "Skips"); const aLate = statLine(audioCard.grid, "Late frames"); track(parent, audioCard, { catalog: watch.audio.source.out.catalog, @@ -125,6 +126,8 @@ export function statsTab(parent: Effect, watch: MoqWatch): HTMLElement { // A non-zero count means the target is below what arrivals actually need. const aUnder = aStats?.underruns ?? 0; aUnderruns.textContent = watch.audio.out.stalled.peek() ? `${aUnder} (buffering)` : `${aUnder}`; + // Each one dropped buffered audio, too far above the target to stretch back onto it. + aSkips.textContent = aStats ? `${aStats.skips}` : "-"; aLate.textContent = aStats ? `${aStats.late}` : "-"; // Network. "Estimated max" is the congestion controller / PROBE estimate; diff --git a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/buffered-converge.md b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/buffered-converge.md index e1878c4de3d..992afcba1bd 100644 --- a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/buffered-converge.md +++ b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/buffered-converge.md @@ -58,15 +58,12 @@ Recommendations: Public API: none expected. Wire: none. -## Required - -- [Watch](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md) - lands the ring's time stretch this reuses - ## Closes - [#8031](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/issues/8031) - buffered playback loses lip sync and cuts audio out on a live stream ## Related +- [Watch](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md) - proves on real hardware the ring's time stretch this reuses, which landed in [moq-dev/moq#8058](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/8058) - [Rename buffer to lookahead](/quest/m2/watch-lookahead.md) - the name that invited the misuse - [Buffered playback subscribes in ascending order](/quest/m1/buffered-ascending.md) - the other buffered-mode change to the audio path diff --git a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md index 69461a8e24b..78dc140fe7e 100644 --- a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md +++ b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md @@ -31,7 +31,12 @@ The port retains WebRTC's BSD notice and patent grant, 4 kHz analysis, 50-sample correlation at lags 10 through 59, 14746/16384 normal and 8192/16384 fast admission thresholds, passive-speech VAD, 20 ms decision band, 4x fast threshold, and 60 ms startup / 50 ms successful-stretch -cooldowns. Analysis samples NetEq's 48 kHz FIR on a virtual clock for other +cooldowns. +[moq-dev/moq#8058](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/8058) departs from +NetEq's preemptive expand in both players, recorded in the shared spec: +below the target, expand ignores the cooldown and takes every whole period +that fits at the lower threshold. It also drains a declared end's tail +unstretched, as finishing does. Analysis samples NetEq's 48 kHz FIR on a virtual clock for other device rates and uses floating-point peak refinement and fades. Those arithmetic adaptations are documented, not claimed bit-identical to int16 WebRTC. No threshold was tuned. @@ -96,8 +101,9 @@ The player's metrics confirm the stretch was active: media per render second was 1.0020 (fast, direct) and 1.0018 (fast, shaped) against a 1.002 publisher, and 0.9981 and 0.9979 against 0.998; the shaped runs raised the target delay from 120 to 260 ms. Each direct run stalled once at startup, -none in steady state. This settles the perceptual check; the calibration and -bench waits below remain. +none in steady state. That predates the expand departure above, so +[Watch](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md)'s listening check repeats these +runs; the calibration and bench waits below remain. ## Waiting diff --git a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md index e2c0409ff1a..192fbd40286 100644 --- a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md +++ b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md @@ -1,4 +1,4 @@ -# [L] js/watch: zero steady-state audio underruns by time-stretching the ring +# [M] js/watch: prove zero steady-state audio underruns on real hardware ## Goal @@ -13,20 +13,35 @@ sizes. The measured rows are the `relay-mic-rtt40` replay row, whose `player_underruns_per_min` must reach 0, and a live re-run of the 2026-11-03 rows below with a real microphone, Chrome's with 40 ms or more of added RTT -and Safari's on the direct path, read from the stats panel's audio Underruns. +and Safari's on the direct path, read from the stats panel's audio Underruns +and Skips. Boundaries: no packet loss concealment, so a frame that never arrives is still missing audio; only received audio is stretched. The estimator stays as -`doc/concept/audio-jitter.md` specifies it. Native playback is out of scope -here. +`doc/concept/audio-jitter.md` specifies it. ## Plan -Decided 2026-11-03 (maintainer, on -[moq-dev/moq#7679](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/7679)): pull time -stretch into m1 as this quest's fix, keeping `QUANTILE` at 0.95. The options -were restating the Goal to the measured rate, or raising the quantile. The m2 -Time stretch quest was folded in here. +[moq-dev/moq#8058](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/8058) ports the shared +NetEq stretch into the browser's ring, passing the shared PCM corpus, and +every replay row, `relay-mic-rtt40` included, measures and is budgeted at 0 +`player_underruns_per_min`. NetEq-exact expand left `relay-mic-rtt40` at 2.1 +a minute, so expand departs from NetEq in both players, as +`doc/concept/audio-jitter.md` records: below the target it expands every +window, as many whole periods as fit, at the lower admission threshold. What +remains is proof outside the replay: + +- The 2026-11-03 rows re-run on real hardware, Chrome's at +40 ms and Safari's + on the direct path, under Waiting. +- A listening check of that run and of the native player, since the expand + departure changes both and postdates the 2026-11-05 native listening in + [Native stretch](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md). +- The nightly browser ceilings re-measured by `budgets.json`'s rule from seven + scheduled nightlies with the stretch. The lag heuristic behind + `skip_aheads` and `discarded_ms` reads a sustained accelerate as a skip, so + those can rise on rows whose target moves; `player_skips` counts the ring's + real re-anchors beside them. One local run of the twelve chromium rows on + 2026-11-06 fit every current ceiling, with zero player underruns and skips. Decided 2026-11-06 (maintainer, /quest-unblock): drop the Safari row with 40 ms or more of added RTT. Safari can't be redirected through the RTT relay, @@ -34,6 +49,16 @@ and shaping it needs Network Link Conditioner or `dnctl`/`pfctl` on the laptop, so its rows run on the direct path. Not chosen: a hands-on Safari run with shaped RTT. +Decided 2026-11-05 (maintainer, /quest-plan): steady-state lip sync comes +from this stretch converging the ring's playhead on `Sync.now()`, the shared +clock on local time anchored at the earliest arrival. The clock never follows +audio: one slow track must not hold the others, so audio and video stay in sync +in the steady state and drift apart only while a track is congested. +[moq-dev/moq#7941](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/7941) dropped an +audio-driven clock for this. Recommendation: measure the gap against the sample +reaching the output, through `AudioContext.getOutputTimestamp()`, so output +latency, Bluetooth included, is part of the lip sync. + ### Baseline, 2026-11-03 An agent ran the maintainer's MacBook Air (macOS 26.6.2) against @@ -53,126 +78,42 @@ on the direct path. Underruns are the stats panel's counter after the first | Safari, direct, 20 ms groups | WebSocket | 5 ms | 5 in 118 s (2.5/min) | 0 | 120 / 140 ms | | Safari, direct, 100 ms groups | WebSocket | 5 ms | 12 in 119 s (6.1/min) | 0 | 120 / 140 ms | -The Chrome +40 ms, 20 ms-group capture is checked in as the `relay-mic-rtt40` -replay row, budgeted exactly as measured: 7.9 player underruns a minute. Every -replay row now also budgets `player_underruns_per_min`, the player's own -counter, which counts the run-dry re-stalls the output tap files as stalled -time. - -Replayed, each row's arrivals reproduce its live re-stalls and short quanta -almost exactly, so the browser's decode and render path adds nothing. The ring -sits at the target less one frame, and each run-dry is one frame arriving later -than that cushion. The target is the 95th percentile of each 500 ms -interval's worst delay, so about 5% of intervals, some six a minute, hold such -a frame. Raising `QUANTILE` in a replay sweep cut the rate but not to zero: -0.99 gave 1.0 to 3.5 a minute at a 60 to 200 ms p50 target, against 5.6 to -13.2 at 40 to 120 ms. - -### How deep the stretch must go - -Against the cushion each frame met, the five rows' late frames (12 to 27 in -each after 30 s) exceed it by a median of 10 to 16 ms and at most 44 to 81 ms. -Stretching the cushion across that wait means playing at `1 - k` of real time -from the moment the ring dips, with `k = excess / delay`. That is 11 to 31% at -the median, 30 to 47% at p90, and up to 38 to 71%. A bound of a few percent -per quantum cannot meet the Goal. - -### Implementation: copy NetEq - -Decided 2026-11-03 (maintainer): copy what WebRTC's NetEq does. The stretch -removes or repeats whole pitch periods of received audio, found by -autocorrelation, and cross-fades across the seam. It is not a generic -resampler or a phase vocoder. The mirrored files are in WebRTC's -`modules/audio_coding/neteq/`, read at `a057d00e46` (2026-11-03): - -- `time_stretch.cc` and `time_stretch.h`, the shared search. Downsample to - 4 kHz and autocorrelate over lags `kMinLag` 10 to `kMaxLag` 60 (2.5 to 15 ms - pitch periods), over `kCorrelationLen` 50. Then refine the best peak at full - rate (`DspHelper::PeakDetection`), and normalise the cross-correlation by - the two segments' energies. `SpeechDetection` treats a segment as passive - when its energy per pitch sample is at most 8 times the background noise's - (a fixed 75000 before noise is estimated). Passive audio may stretch - regardless of correlation. -- `accelerate.cc`. With at least 30 ms of input, keep the first 15 ms, - cross-fade one pitch period onto it, and drop that period. It stretches only - when the correlation is over `kCorrelationThreshold` (0.9 in Q14) or the - audio is passive. Fast accelerate lowers the bar to 0.5 and removes as many - whole periods as fit in 15 ms. -- `preemptive_expand.cc`. Under the same 0.9 test, with at most 15 ms of old - data ahead of the seam, repeat one pitch period after the unmodified part - and cross-fade it in. -- `decision_logic.cc` and `decision_logic.h`, when to stretch. The low limit - is the target and the high limit is the target plus the arrival history's - maximum delay plus `kDelayAdjustmentGranularityMs` (20 ms). - - Preemptive expand when the playout delay is under the low limit. - - Accelerate at or above the high limit. - - Fast accelerate at four times the high limit. - - At most one stretch every `kMinTimescaleInterval` (5) ticks of 10 ms. - - Here the target is `Sync`'s resolved delay, and the arrival history's - maximum is the estimator's. - -NetEq decides once per 10 ms of output, and our worklet renders 128-sample -quanta. So the stretch runs on blocks of decoded PCM before they reach the -render quantum, where at least 30 ms are buffered. - -One boundary differs from NetEq. NetEq preemptive-expands only while the next -packet is already buffered (`ExpectedPacketAvailable`). Once it is missing, -NetEq runs Expand, which is concealment and outside this quest. At NetEq's -cadence, one period of at most 15 ms every 50 ms, preemptive expand slows -playback by about a quarter at most. That covers the median late frame above -but not the 38 to 71% tail. So the work is: start at NetEq's thresholds, -measure `relay-mic-rtt40`, and only then decide how to close the tail. Options -are expanding sooner or more often as the ring nears empty, or accepting the -remaining re-stalls. Each departure from NetEq's constants is recorded with -the replay numbers that justify it. - -- Port the shared specification rather than NetEq independently: - [moq-dev/moq#7856](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/7856) landed the - native stretch with `doc/concept/audio-jitter.md` specifying the shared - floating-point adaptation and `doc/concept/audio-jitter/stretch/corpus.json` - holding literal PCM vectors for both languages. Implement that spec and - pass those vectors, so both players stretch alike; record any departure - from it in the spec, not only here. -- Put the stretch where `js/watch/src/audio/replay.ts` exercises it, such as - `AudioRingBuffer`'s read path or a module the render worklet and the replay - share, so the replay rows measure the stretch and not a model of it. -- Accelerate replaces the skip-ahead when the ring sits above the high - limit. A re-stall remains for a ring that empties despite the stretch, and a - skip-ahead remains only above what fast accelerate can close. -- Verification: `relay-mic-rtt40` reaches 0 `player_underruns_per_min` and its - budget is tightened to the new measurement. No other replay row regresses, - and the nightly browser rows are re-measured by the budgets note's rule. A - listening check confirms that a 2 ms/s drift and the measured expansions are - inaudible or close to it. The 2026-11-03 rows are re-run on real hardware: - Chrome's at +40 ms and Safari's on the direct path. - -### Publisher, measured in the same run - -`AudioEncoder` input-to-output lag on live input is p50 0.9 ms and p99 1.1 ms, -with drift under 0.04 ms/s at 20 ms and 100 ms groups. The 7.35 s lag and 88 -to 275 ms/s drift of -[moq-dev/moq#3477](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/issues/3477) did not recur. -Each demand session opens with up to 30 s of retained history -(`js/publish/src/audio/backlog.ts`), which the watcher discards. 100 ms groups -halved Chrome's rate at +40 ms but more than doubled Safari's on the direct -path, so the 20 ms default stays. - -Decided 2026-10-15: keep this proof in m1 with the existing playback and -A/V clock work. - -Decided 2026-11-05 (maintainer, /quest-plan): steady-state lip sync comes -from this stretch converging the ring's playhead on `Sync.now()`, the shared -clock on local time anchored at the earliest arrival. The clock never follows -audio: one slow track must not hold the others, so audio and video stay in sync -in the steady state and drift apart only while a track is congested. -[moq-dev/moq#7941](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/7941) dropped an -audio-driven clock for this. Recommendation: measure the gap against the sample -reaching the output, through `AudioContext.getOutputTimestamp()`, so output -latency, Bluetooth included, is part of the lip sync. +## Waiting + +- Maintainer: re-run the 2026-11-03 rows on the MacBook Air and listen to + them, since an agent has no microphone, speaker, or Safari. Automation + considered: rendering speech through the ring offline, but the repository's + only speech clips are 0.4 s, and the live run exercises the same stretch on + a real voice. On a checkout of `main` once + [moq-dev/moq#8058](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/8058) merges, or of + its branch before: + 1. `just web serve https://cdn.moq.dev/anon`, and in its publish tab + publish the built-in microphone with 20 ms groups, the default. + 2. For the +40 ms RTT, `cargo run --release -p moq-shaper -- --listen + 127.0.0.1:443 --target "$(dig +short cdn.moq.dev | head -1):443" + --delay 20ms`, then open the watch page in a second Chrome profile: + `open -na "Google Chrome" --args --user-data-dir=/tmp/rtt40 + --host-resolver-rules="MAP cdn.moq.dev 127.0.0.1"`. + 3. Play the broadcast at the Real-time delay and talk for three minutes. + Note the stats panel's audio Underruns and Skips at 30 s and at the end, + and listen for warble or pitch wobble. + 4. Repeat with 100 ms groups, then both group sizes in Safari on the direct + path, with no shaper. + 5. Repeat the 2026-11-05 native listening runs of + [Native stretch](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md) on the + same checkout: `say` speech over Opus at a 1.002 and a 0.998 publisher + rate, direct and through the shaper's `bursty` profile. + + Done when every row reads zero Underruns and Skips between 30 s and the end + and the stretch is inaudible or close to it. Record the table here. +- moq-dev/moq: seven scheduled Nightly runs on `main` with the stretch. Then + re-measure the chromium ceilings in `test/audio-quality/budgets.json` from + their `audio-quality-run` artifacts by the note's rule, adding + `player_skips_per_min`, and check that the rows meet the Goal. ## Related - [Capped budgets](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/capped-budgets.md) - re-measures the AAC browser budgets after the publisher change, no gate on this proof - [Native stretch](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md) - the native time-stretch sharing one NetEq algorithm and its test vectors with this one +- [Buffered converge](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/buffered-converge.md) - reuses this stretch for buffered playback, which plays unstretched here - [Watch worker](/quest/m3/watch-worker.md) - moves the worklet this stretch changes diff --git a/quest/m1/push-to-talk-latency.md b/quest/m1/push-to-talk-latency.md index a25d6e5208c..26851c4ecea 100644 --- a/quest/m1/push-to-talk-latency.md +++ b/quest/m1/push-to-talk-latency.md @@ -89,10 +89,7 @@ measured term (`js/watch/src/audio/latency.ts`); device and render follow the watch AudioContext's `latencyHint` (`"interactive"` in `js/watch/src/audio/decoder.ts`), otherwise the platform. -## Required - -- [Watch](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md) - `"auto"` stops underrunning by time-stretching the ring, so the run can hold the default delay - ## Related +- [Watch](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md) - `"auto"` stops underrunning by time-stretching the ring, so the run can hold the default delay; the stretch landed in [moq-dev/moq#8058](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/8058), and only its hardware proof remains there - [Audio jitter target](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/README.md) - the `"auto"` target this latency feeds diff --git a/rs/moq-audio/src/ring.rs b/rs/moq-audio/src/ring.rs index c8b48617615..a372a6e135e 100644 --- a/rs/moq-audio/src/ring.rs +++ b/rs/moq-audio/src/ring.rs @@ -620,6 +620,9 @@ impl Consumer { } frames = frames.min(ahead); } + // A declared end's tail drains as received: running dry after it is + // silence, not an underrun, so nothing should expand toward the target. + let declared = self.declared(); let Some(stretch) = self.stretch.as_mut() else { let frames = frames.min((output.len() - done) / channels); if frames == 0 { @@ -640,7 +643,7 @@ impl Consumer { break; } // Never transform startup padding or a finite stream's tail. - let enabled = self.prime == 0 && !self.shared.finished.load(Ordering::Relaxed); + let enabled = self.prime == 0 && !self.shared.finished.load(Ordering::Relaxed) && !declared; let frames = if self.prime > 0 { frames.min(self.prime) } else { frames }; self.staged_prime = self.prime > 0; self.prime -= frames.min(self.prime); @@ -975,6 +978,34 @@ mod tests { assert_eq!(cons.read(&mut out), Read::Underflow { frames: 0 }); } + #[test] + fn a_declared_end_drains_its_tail_unstretched() { + let (mut prod, mut cons) = channel( + 2, + 48_000, + 48_000, + Config { + latency: Duration::from_millis(50), + capacity: Duration::from_secs(1), + pad: false, + trim: false, + }, + ); + cons.stretch(48_000); + cons.start(); + // Twice the target, so the tail drains through it: without the end it + // would expand there, toward a target nothing will refill. + assert_eq!(prod.push(&vec![0.25; 4800 * 2]), Push::Ok); + prod.end(); + let mut out = [0.0; 128 * 2]; + let mut reads = 0; + while cons.available() > 0 { + cons.read(&mut out); + reads += 1; + } + assert_eq!(reads, 7200usize.div_ceil(128), "a declared end never extends the tail"); + } + #[test] fn recovery_waits_for_received_pcm_without_stretching_padding() { let (mut prod, mut cons) = channel( @@ -1030,12 +1061,18 @@ mod tests { for (i, frame) in pcm.as_chunks_mut::<2>().0.iter_mut().enumerate() { frame.fill((i as f32 * std::f32::consts::TAU * 200.0 / 48_000.0).sin() * 0.25); } - let (first, second) = pcm.split_at(143_000 * 2); - // Play out the 50 ms prime and the 60 ms startup cooldown below the - // trim watermark, ending on a window boundary. + let (first, rest) = pcm.split_at(143_000 * 2); + let (cushion, second) = rest.split_at(1_000 * 2); + // Play out the 50 ms prime below the trim watermark, then top the queue + // up to the target so its first window, inside the 60 ms startup + // cooldown, holds rather than expands. End on a window boundary. assert_eq!(prod.push(first), Push::Ok); let mut out = [0.0; 480 * 2]; - for _ in 0..8 { + for _ in 0..5 { + assert_eq!(cons.read(&mut out), Read::Ok); + } + assert_eq!(prod.push(cushion), Push::Ok); + for _ in 0..3 { assert_eq!(cons.read(&mut out), Read::Ok); } // Above NetEq's high limit (target + 20 ms) but under the trim diff --git a/rs/moq-audio/src/stretch.rs b/rs/moq-audio/src/stretch.rs index e3496279b4a..06a63baa83a 100644 --- a/rs/moq-audio/src/stretch.rs +++ b/rs/moq-audio/src/stretch.rs @@ -71,7 +71,12 @@ impl Stretch { let lag = if operation == Operation::Hold { 0 } else { - pitch(&self.input, self.channels, self.rate, operation == Operation::Fast) + pitch( + &self.input, + self.channels, + self.rate, + operation != Operation::Accelerate, + ) }; self.position = 0; self.length = frames; @@ -109,23 +114,29 @@ impl Stretch { self.cooldown = self.rate as usize * 50 / 1000; } + /// Expand departs from NetEq's preemptive expand, which repeats one period + /// per cooldown. A queue below its target is short of the cushion its + /// arrivals need, so it expands the way fast accelerate shrinks: every + /// window, as many whole periods as fit, at the lower admission threshold. fn decide(&self, buffered: usize, target: usize) -> Operation { let high = target + self.rate as usize * 20 / 1000; if buffered >= high * 4 { Operation::Fast + } else if buffered < target { + Operation::Expand } else if self.cooldown > 0 { Operation::Hold } else if buffered >= high { Operation::Accelerate - } else if buffered < target { - Operation::Expand } else { Operation::Hold } } } -/// Search the first channel at 4 kHz, then validate the full-rate seam. +/// Search the first channel at 4 kHz, then validate the full-rate seam. Fast +/// mode, for fast accelerate and every expand, admits a weaker match and takes +/// every whole period that fits before the middle. fn pitch(input: &[f32], channels: usize, rate: u32, fast: bool) -> usize { // NetEq's 48 kHz Q12 FIR. Sampling its taps at fractional positions also // admits native 44.1/96 kHz devices without altering the search domain. diff --git a/test/audio-quality/README.md b/test/audio-quality/README.md index b4a4a2f6f58..c890df32c34 100644 --- a/test/audio-quality/README.md +++ b/test/audio-quality/README.md @@ -211,6 +211,12 @@ writes the same samples a page does, so `analyze.ts` reduces both alike, and the and clock checks have nothing to void. Decoding is taken as instant. A replay is deterministic, so its budgets are exactly what it measured. +The ring time-stretches live playback as the page's does, but the replay's audio is a constant, so +every seam admits at the shortest pitch period, 2.5 ms. Accelerate therefore removes less per stretch +than it would from speech, and expand, which repeats every whole period that fits, adds the most it +can. `skip_aheads` also reads a sustained accelerate as a skip; `player_skips` counts only the ring's +own re-anchors. + ```bash just test audio-quality-record # the three recorded lanes, 35 s each, needs the network just test audio-quality-record --lanes relay-bbb @@ -270,6 +276,9 @@ player's own count, which its stats panel shows, is read alongside: - `player_underruns`: `audio.out.stats.underruns`, each time the ring ran dry mid-playback and re-stalled to refill, plus each quantum it filled only part-way. The tap files the quanta after a run-dry as stalled time, so `underruns` leaves those out and this counts them. Unset natively. +- `player_skips`: `audio.out.stats.skips`, each jump that dropped buffered audio rather than playing + it faster. `skip_aheads` below infers the same events from the playhead, and also reads a time + stretch that sustains 40 ms of acceleration as one, so this is the exact count. Unset natively. - `underruns`: quanta the ring filled only partly, or not at all, while playing. - `short_quanta`: the underruns that were partly filled: the ring ran dry part-way through. - `underrun_episodes`: maximal runs of consecutive underruns, one audible gap each. diff --git a/test/audio-quality/budgets.json b/test/audio-quality/budgets.json index e419b11f5e2..1bda1e5b0fa 100644 --- a/test/audio-quality/budgets.json +++ b/test/audio-quality/budgets.json @@ -1,5 +1,5 @@ { - "note": "The browser rows are measured on the nightly runner (ubuntu-24.04-arm, headless Chromium, seed 7, 60 s a row), from the audio-quality-run artifacts of the seven scheduled Nightly runs on main from 2026-10-29 to 2026-11-04 (40885347517, 41065371094, 41204380716, 41313466339, 41483654426, 41656613559, 41852517544), the first after a fresh subscriber stopped receiving the relay's cached history. The AAC rows predate the TS importer publishing each PES as one group. Each ceiling is the worst of its seven nights times 1.25, plus one runner hiccup, rounded up to two significant figures. The hiccup is sized from the single gaps the 2026-10-08 night put on otherwise clean rows, the fixed-250 control among them: 250 underruns/min, 700 gap ms/min, 3.3 skips/min, 280 discarded ms/min, 0.01 stalled, 0.015 silence, and one 20 ms bucket of target. Budgeted this way, every night passes when it is held out of its row's measurement except one, and that row's own ceiling includes it: the 2026-11-03 Opus bursty row raised its target to 300 ms 2.6 s in and held it for one 20 s half-life before settling at 180. Such startup holds, Opus near-zero's 100 ms on 2026-10-30 and 10-31 among them, are budgeted as measured. These ceilings record today's player as the runner hears it, not target audio quality. To re-measure, download the same artifact from the latest scheduled nightlies (`gh run download -n audio-quality-run`), which keep every run, and apply the same rule. The replay rows are deterministic, so their ceilings are exactly what they measured, through the end of each recording, with no headroom: any regression fails them, and an improvement should be tightened in. They were last re-measured on 2026-10-22 using version 3 traces with encoded frame durations: AAC-LC uses its fixed 1024 samples, and relay-mic retains Opus packet TOC durations. relay-mic was re-recorded on 2026-11-03 from a real microphone, Chrome 156 on a MacBook Air publishing its built-in microphone through the public relay, recorded by headless Chromium on a Linux host (35 s, minimum RTT 2 ms), which raised its target ceiling from 60 to 80 ms and its silence from 0 to 0.001 as measured. The recording path itself has no added RTT. relay-mic-rtt40 is the 2026-11-03 Chrome row at 40 ms of added RTT on that laptop (180 s, minimum RTT 47 ms), kept as the baseline time stretch must bring to zero. player_underruns_per_min, the player's own counter that its stats panel shows, is budgeted on the replay rows only, exactly as measured on 2026-11-03; it counts the run-dry re-stalls the tap files as stalled time. The local-aac replay's stalled ceiling rises from 0.008 to 0.017 and silence from 0.015 to 0.020 because replay no longer stretches each frame to nearby timestamp gaps; the production player is unchanged. All other changed replay ceilings tighten to the exact measurement. That replay calibration leaves browser and native ceilings unchanged. bursty-aac is the 2026-10-18 AAC bursty isolated capture, recorded with the observer subscribed at the decoder's 2 s budget, so it holds every group the player saw. The native rows are provisional: measured on a loaded developer host (x86_64 Linux, the private PulseAudio null sink, seed 7, 60 s a row) on 2026-10-17, three runs of every row from the debug build nightly uses plus three more of the AAC rows from a release build, which played alike. Each ceiling is the worst clean run times 1.25, plus one native hiccup sized from the unimpaired Opus row's worst run (20 underruns/min, 50 gap ms/min, 2.2 skips/min, 110 discarded ms/min, 0.01 stalled, 0.005 silence, one 20 ms bucket of target), rounded up to two significant figures. On that host the null sink's clock ran about 150 ppm slow against the monotonic clock, read within 5 ms at p95 per sample, and its output latency sat between 14 and 28 ms. Five of the 36 AAC rows (none of the 18 Opus rows) voided on the clock: the device stopped pulling for about two seconds mid-row, sometimes after a backend error and a stream restart, which is a native playback defect rather than noise, and the ceilings exclude those runs. Re-measure from the nightly runner's artifacts once it has a week of native rows.", + "note": "The browser rows are measured on the nightly runner (ubuntu-24.04-arm, headless Chromium, seed 7, 60 s a row), from the audio-quality-run artifacts of the seven scheduled Nightly runs on main from 2026-10-29 to 2026-11-04 (40885347517, 41065371094, 41204380716, 41313466339, 41483654426, 41656613559, 41852517544), the first after a fresh subscriber stopped receiving the relay's cached history. The AAC rows predate the TS importer publishing each PES as one group. Each ceiling is the worst of its seven nights times 1.25, plus one runner hiccup, rounded up to two significant figures. The hiccup is sized from the single gaps the 2026-10-08 night put on otherwise clean rows, the fixed-250 control among them: 250 underruns/min, 700 gap ms/min, 3.3 skips/min, 280 discarded ms/min, 0.01 stalled, 0.015 silence, and one 20 ms bucket of target. Budgeted this way, every night passes when it is held out of its row's measurement except one, and that row's own ceiling includes it: the 2026-11-03 Opus bursty row raised its target to 300 ms 2.6 s in and held it for one 20 s half-life before settling at 180. Such startup holds, Opus near-zero's 100 ms on 2026-10-30 and 10-31 among them, are budgeted as measured. These ceilings record today's player as the runner hears it, not target audio quality. To re-measure, download the same artifact from the latest scheduled nightlies (`gh run download -n audio-quality-run`), which keep every run, and apply the same rule. The replay rows are deterministic, so their ceilings are exactly what they measured, through the end of each recording, with no headroom: any regression fails them, and an improvement should be tightened in. They were last re-measured on 2026-10-22 using version 3 traces with encoded frame durations: AAC-LC uses its fixed 1024 samples, and relay-mic retains Opus packet TOC durations. relay-mic was re-recorded on 2026-11-03 from a real microphone, Chrome 156 on a MacBook Air publishing its built-in microphone through the public relay, recorded by headless Chromium on a Linux host (35 s, minimum RTT 2 ms), which raised its target ceiling from 60 to 80 ms and its silence from 0 to 0.001 as measured. The recording path itself has no added RTT. relay-mic-rtt40 is the 2026-11-03 Chrome row at 40 ms of added RTT on that laptop (180 s, minimum RTT 47 ms), kept as the baseline time stretch must bring to zero. player_underruns_per_min, the player's own counter that its stats panel shows, is budgeted on the replay rows only; it counts the run-dry re-stalls the tap files as stalled time. On 2026-11-06 the player began time-stretching live playback and every replay row was re-measured with it: player_underruns_per_min fell to 0 on all five, relay-mic-rtt40's from 7.9, and stalled and silence fell or held. player_skips_per_min, the ring's own count of re-anchors that dropped buffered audio, is budgeted beside it: 0 except relay-mic-rtt40's 0.3, one re-anchor 21.5 s in as the estimator released its 780 ms startup hold, which main makes too. The tap metrics that rose are none of them audio the player dropped. skip_aheads and discarded_ms infer skips from steps in the playhead's lag, which a sustained accelerate makes too. bursty-aac no longer runs dry waiting on its missing groups (stalled 0.009 to 0, silence 0.013 to 0.002), so each hole now plays as the gap it is and the tap counts it as underruns. The AAC rows' gaps of 1 to 3 samples between frames, from rounding each frame's timestamp to the ring's index, now land at the end of a quantum often enough to count, at 0.2 gap ms a minute or less; main has the same zeros, aligned differently. The local-aac replay's stalled ceiling rises from 0.008 to 0.017 and silence from 0.015 to 0.020 because replay no longer stretches each frame to nearby timestamp gaps; the production player is unchanged. All other changed replay ceilings tighten to the exact measurement. That replay calibration leaves browser and native ceilings unchanged. bursty-aac is the 2026-10-18 AAC bursty isolated capture, recorded with the observer subscribed at the decoder's 2 s budget, so it holds every group the player saw. The native rows are provisional: measured on a loaded developer host (x86_64 Linux, the private PulseAudio null sink, seed 7, 60 s a row) on 2026-10-17, three runs of every row from the debug build nightly uses plus three more of the AAC rows from a release build, which played alike. Each ceiling is the worst clean run times 1.25, plus one native hiccup sized from the unimpaired Opus row's worst run (20 underruns/min, 50 gap ms/min, 2.2 skips/min, 110 discarded ms/min, 0.01 stalled, 0.005 silence, one 20 ms bucket of target), rounded up to two significant figures. On that host the null sink's clock ran about 150 ppm slow against the monotonic clock, read within 5 ms at p95 per sample, and its output latency sat between 14 and 28 ms. Five of the 36 AAC rows (none of the 18 Opus rows) voided on the clock: the device stopped pulling for about two seconds mid-row, sometimes after a backend error and a stream restart, which is a native playback defect rather than noise, and the ceilings exclude those runs. Re-measure from the nightly runner's artifacts once it has a week of native rows.", "rows": [ { "runtime": "chromium", @@ -318,13 +318,14 @@ "codec": "aac", "rate": 44100, "profile": "bursty-aac", - "player_underruns_per_min": 4.4, - "underruns_per_min": 0, - "underrun_ms_per_min": 0, - "skip_aheads_per_min": 0, - "discarded_ms_per_min": 0, - "stalled_share": 0.009, - "silence_share": 0.013, + "player_underruns_per_min": 0, + "player_skips_per_min": 0, + "underruns_per_min": 38.3, + "underrun_ms_per_min": 94.9, + "skip_aheads_per_min": 4.4, + "discarded_ms_per_min": 201.6, + "stalled_share": 0, + "silence_share": 0.002, "target_ms_p95": 343.2 }, { @@ -332,13 +333,14 @@ "codec": "aac", "rate": 44100, "profile": "local-aac", - "player_underruns_per_min": 12.1, - "underruns_per_min": 0, - "underrun_ms_per_min": 0, - "skip_aheads_per_min": 2, - "discarded_ms_per_min": 127.5, - "stalled_share": 0.017, - "silence_share": 0.02, + "player_underruns_per_min": 0, + "player_skips_per_min": 0, + "underruns_per_min": 6.1, + "underrun_ms_per_min": 0.2, + "skip_aheads_per_min": 0, + "discarded_ms_per_min": 0, + "stalled_share": 0, + "silence_share": 0, "target_ms_p95": 203.2 }, { @@ -346,13 +348,14 @@ "codec": "aac", "rate": 44100, "profile": "relay-bbb", - "player_underruns_per_min": 12.1, - "underruns_per_min": 0, - "underrun_ms_per_min": 0, - "skip_aheads_per_min": 2, - "discarded_ms_per_min": 87.8, - "stalled_share": 0.017, - "silence_share": 0.016, + "player_underruns_per_min": 0, + "player_skips_per_min": 0, + "underruns_per_min": 4, + "underrun_ms_per_min": 0.1, + "skip_aheads_per_min": 4, + "discarded_ms_per_min": 239.4, + "stalled_share": 0, + "silence_share": 0, "target_ms_p95": 223.2 }, { @@ -360,13 +363,14 @@ "codec": "opus", "rate": 48000, "profile": "relay-mic", - "player_underruns_per_min": 6.1, + "player_underruns_per_min": 0, + "player_skips_per_min": 0, "underruns_per_min": 0, "underrun_ms_per_min": 0, "skip_aheads_per_min": 0, "discarded_ms_per_min": 0, "stalled_share": 0, - "silence_share": 0.001, + "silence_share": 0, "target_ms_p95": 80 }, { @@ -374,13 +378,14 @@ "codec": "opus", "rate": 48000, "profile": "relay-mic-rtt40", - "player_underruns_per_min": 7.9, - "underruns_per_min": 0.3, - "underrun_ms_per_min": 0.5, - "skip_aheads_per_min": 0.3, - "discarded_ms_per_min": 229.3, - "stalled_share": 0.003, - "silence_share": 0.003, + "player_underruns_per_min": 0, + "player_skips_per_min": 0.3, + "underruns_per_min": 0, + "underrun_ms_per_min": 0, + "skip_aheads_per_min": 3.1, + "discarded_ms_per_min": 281.8, + "stalled_share": 0, + "silence_share": 0, "target_ms_p95": 780 } ] diff --git a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/grade.ts b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/grade.ts index 9d2f26c2361..35a19defa98 100644 --- a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/grade.ts +++ b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/grade.ts @@ -65,11 +65,12 @@ for (const summary of summaries) { /** The columns a reader scans first: what the listener would have noticed, and the delay paid for it. */ const COLUMNS: [string, string][] = [ ["player underruns/min", "player_underruns_per_min"], + ["player skips/min", "player_skips_per_min"], ["underruns/min", "underruns_per_min"], ["short/min", "short_quanta_per_min"], ["episodes/min", "underrun_episodes_per_min"], ["gap ms/min", "underrun_ms_per_min"], - ["skips/min", "skip_aheads_per_min"], + ["skip-aheads/min", "skip_aheads_per_min"], ["discarded ms/min", "discarded_ms_per_min"], ["stalled", "stalled_share"], ["silence", "silence_share"], diff --git a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/replay.ts b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/replay.ts index fb7d0355480..69e9a208b96 100644 --- a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/replay.ts +++ b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/replay.ts @@ -84,6 +84,16 @@ const out = values.out as string; // Loaded only to play: listing runs before `run.sh` has installed the workspace the player needs. const { replay } = await import("../../../../js/watch/src/audio/replay.ts"); +/** What a sample reads from the latest quantum. */ +interface Reading { + at: number; + timestamp: number; + stalled: boolean; + delay: number; + underruns: number; + skips: number; +} + for (const { row, trace } of rows) { const tag = rowKey(row); const rate = row.rate; @@ -103,7 +113,7 @@ for (const { row, trace } of rows) { }; const arrivals = trace.arrivals.map(([at, timestamp, group, duration]) => ({ at, timestamp, group, duration })); - const sample = (quantum: { at: number; timestamp: number; stalled: boolean; delay: number; underruns: number }) => { + const sample = (quantum: Reading) => { const gaps = ledger.take(); samples.push({ at: quantum.at, @@ -112,6 +122,7 @@ for (const { row, trace } of rows) { stalled: quantum.stalled, delay: quantum.delay, playerUnderruns: quantum.underruns, + playerSkips: quantum.skips, quanta: ledger.counts.quanta, quiet: ledger.counts.quiet, gaps: gaps.length > 0 ? gaps : undefined, @@ -126,7 +137,7 @@ for (const { row, trace } of rows) { config: trace.config as unknown as Catalog.AudioConfig, duration: trace.duration, }); - let last: { at: number; timestamp: number; stalled: boolean; delay: number; underruns: number } | undefined; + let last: Reading | undefined; for await (const quantum of quanta) { // The render clock is the simulated one: the trace's `at`, which starts at zero. ledger.add(frame, quantum.output.length, classify([quantum.output])); @@ -141,6 +152,7 @@ for (const { row, trace } of rows) { stalled: quantum.stalled, delay: quantum.delay, underruns: quantum.underruns, + skips: quantum.skips, }; if (quantum.at >= next) { diff --git a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/analyze.test.ts b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/analyze.test.ts index 596e8c6852e..c2ffd3a81d8 100644 --- a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/analyze.test.ts +++ b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/analyze.test.ts @@ -104,6 +104,12 @@ describe("analyze", () => { expect(analyze(input(clean())).metrics.player_underruns_total).toBeNull(); }); + test("the player's own skips are its counter's rise across the window", () => { + const samples = clean().map((s, i) => ({ ...s, playerSkips: i < 100 ? 1 : 3 })); + expect(analyze(input(samples)).metrics).toMatchObject({ player_skips_total: 2 }); + expect(analyze(input(clean())).metrics.player_skips_total).toBeNull(); + }); + test("a gap that is the ring stalling is not an underrun", () => { const samples = clean(); samples[100] = { diff --git a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/analyze.ts b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/analyze.ts index b3cc7b3ac9d..41d68c03ec6 100644 --- a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/analyze.ts +++ b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/analyze.ts @@ -202,10 +202,13 @@ export function analyze(input: Input): Summary { const silence = quanta > 0 ? ((lastTap?.quiet ?? 0) - (firstTap?.quiet ?? 0)) / quanta : null; if (!lastTap) notes.push("tap: never reported, so underruns and silence are unmeasured"); - // The player's own counter is cumulative, so the window's count is its rise across the window. - const counted = window.filter((s) => s.playerUnderruns !== undefined); - const playerUnderruns = - counted.length > 0 ? (counted.at(-1)?.playerUnderruns ?? 0) - (counted[0]?.playerUnderruns ?? 0) : null; + // The player's own counters are cumulative, so the window's count is each one's rise across it. + const rise = (counter: (s: Sample) => number | undefined) => { + const counted = window.map(counter).filter((n) => n !== undefined); + return counted.length > 0 ? (counted.at(-1) ?? 0) - (counted[0] ?? 0) : null; + }; + const playerUnderruns = rise((s) => s.playerUnderruns); + const playerSkips = rise((s) => s.playerSkips); // ── the playhead ──────────────────────────────────────────────────────── // The lag drifts when the media timeline does not run at wall rate, a property of the source @@ -258,6 +261,8 @@ export function analyze(input: Input): Summary { underrun_ms_max: lastTap ? round(Math.max(0, ...gaps.map((g) => g.ms))) : null, player_underruns_total: playerUnderruns, player_underruns_per_min: playerUnderruns === null ? null : perMin(playerUnderruns), + player_skips_total: playerSkips, + player_skips_per_min: playerSkips === null ? null : perMin(playerSkips), skip_aheads_total: skips.count, skip_aheads_per_min: perMin(skips.count), discarded_ms_total: round(skips.ms), diff --git a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/probe.ts b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/probe.ts index 16758a653d0..521c97fc63b 100644 --- a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/probe.ts +++ b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/probe.ts @@ -128,6 +128,7 @@ export function probe(watch: MoqWatch, capture = false): Probe { stalled: audio.out.stalled.peek(), delay: sync.out.delay.peek(), playerUnderruns: audio.out.stats.peek()?.underruns, + playerSkips: audio.out.stats.peek()?.skips, rtt: watch.player.in.probe.peek()?.rtt, jitter: audio.source.out.config.peek()?.jitter, renditionDelay: audio.source.out.config.peek()?.delay, diff --git a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/schema.ts b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/schema.ts index 431a7d5295e..a283e5eea4c 100644 --- a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/schema.ts +++ b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/schema.ts @@ -104,6 +104,13 @@ export const METRICS = { description: "The player's own count, which its stats panel shows: each time the ring ran dry mid-playback and re-stalled to refill, plus each quantum it filled only part-way. `underruns` leaves out the run-dry ones, since the quanta after them render while stalled.", }, + player_skips: { + unit: "count", + clock: "render", + aggregations: ["total", "per_min"], + description: + "The player's own count of skips: each jump that dropped buffered audio rather than playing it faster. `skip_aheads` infers them from the playhead, which reads a sustained time stretch as one too.", + }, skip_aheads: { unit: "count", clock: "viewer", @@ -382,6 +389,11 @@ export type Sample = { * Unset natively. */ playerUnderruns?: number; + /** + * `audio.out.stats.skips`, cumulative: the player's own count of jumps that dropped buffered audio + * rather than playing it faster. Unset natively. + */ + playerSkips?: number; /** The current connection PROBE round trip. */ rtt?: Ms; /** The selected rendition's advertised jitter at this sample. */ From 05c0846baebbee43e1024ba32323c0bcfb455c43 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Luke Curley Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2026 14:01:52 -0800 Subject: [PATCH 03/13] feat(audio): switch expand variants for the listening check The quest's Goal becomes no audible glitch in steady state rather than zero underruns, so the listening check picks between fast expand and NetEq's exact expand. FAST_EXPAND selects it in both players; the budgets note, spec, and quests no longer hard-code a zero target. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- doc/concept/audio-jitter.md | 8 +- js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts | 19 ++-- .../m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md | 18 ++-- quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md | 91 ++++++++++++------- rs/moq-audio/src/stretch.rs | 21 +++-- test/audio-quality/budgets.json | 2 +- 6 files changed, 105 insertions(+), 54 deletions(-) diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter.md b/doc/concept/audio-jitter.md index 8a9e33d93fd..b3d1d9b71d2 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter.md +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter.md @@ -669,8 +669,12 @@ A ring below its target is short of the cushion its arrivals need, and running dry re-stalls it for a whole target of silence. So expand mirrors fast accelerate instead: every window, at the lower admission threshold, as many whole periods as fit before the middle, up to 15 ms of every 30 ms. That took -every replay row to zero player underruns. The cost is a stronger stretch while -the ring is short, which the listening check judges. NetEq's extra +every replay row to zero player underruns, at the cost of a stronger stretch +while the ring is short. The departure is not settled: the target is no +audible glitch, not zero underruns, so a listening check decides between it +and NetEq's exact expand, which both players keep behind a `FAST_EXPAND` +switch until then. With it off, step 2 moves after step 4 and expands one +period at the normal threshold. NetEq's extra packet-history maximum-delay term is not added again: this controller sees the already decoded PCM queue and its jitter target rather than an RTP playout timestamp and packet-arrival history. There is no concealment state. diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts index dde0ad4e4c8..9157febd6d6 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts @@ -20,6 +20,11 @@ const DOWN = 110; const LAGS = 50; const MIN_LAG = 10; +// Below the target, expand every window, as many whole periods as fit, at the lower admission +// threshold. False is NetEq's exact preemptive expand. The maintainer's listening check picks one, +// and native's FAST_EXPAND must match it. +const FAST_EXPAND = true; + // NetEq's voice activity bound before it has a background noise model, from signed 16-bit PCM. const PASSIVE = (8 * 75000) / (32768 * 32768); @@ -97,7 +102,8 @@ export class Stretch { */ process(frames: number, buffered: number, target: number, enabled: boolean): void { const decision = enabled && frames === this.window ? this.decide(buffered, target) : "Hold"; - const lag = decision === "Hold" ? 0 : this.#pitch(decision !== "Accelerate"); + const lag = + decision === "Hold" ? 0 : this.#pitch(decision === "Fast" || (FAST_EXPAND && decision === "Expand")); this.#position = 0; this.#length = frames; if (lag === 0) { @@ -133,17 +139,18 @@ export class Stretch { /** * What a full window with `buffered` frames queued decides against `target`, both in frames. * - * Expand departs from NetEq's preemptive expand, which repeats one period per cooldown. A ring - * below its target is short of the cushion its arrivals need, and running dry re-stalls it for a - * whole target of silence, so it expands the way fast accelerate shrinks: every window, as many - * whole periods as fit, at the lower admission threshold. + * With {@link FAST_EXPAND}, expand departs from NetEq's preemptive expand, which repeats one + * period per cooldown. A ring below its target is short of the cushion its arrivals need, and + * running dry re-stalls it for a whole target of silence, so it expands the way fast accelerate + * shrinks: every window, as many whole periods as fit, at the lower admission threshold. */ decide(buffered: number, target: number): Decision { const high = target + this.#band; if (buffered >= high * 4) return "Fast"; - if (buffered < target) return "Expand"; + if (FAST_EXPAND && buffered < target) return "Expand"; if (this.cooldown > 0) return "Hold"; if (buffered >= high) return "Accelerate"; + if (buffered < target) return "Expand"; return "Hold"; } diff --git a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md index 78dc140fe7e..4e9c8d4b5f5 100644 --- a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md +++ b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md @@ -1,11 +1,14 @@ -# [L] moq play reaches zero steady-state underruns by time-stretching +# [L] moq play converges inaudibly by time-stretching ## Goal `rs/moq-audio`'s playback converges on its playout target by time-stretching received audio, as WebRTC NetEq does, instead of running its ring dry and padding with silence or trimming buffered audio. `moq play`'s native rows in -`test/audio-quality` reach zero underruns once the target settles. The +`test/audio-quality` play with no audible glitch once the target settles, +with underrun ceilings measured by `budgets.json`'s rule rather than fixed at +zero, as decided 2026-11-06 in +[Watch](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md). The stretch shares one algorithm and one set of test vectors with the browser's. Boundaries: no packet loss concealment, so a frame that never arrives is @@ -32,10 +35,11 @@ The port retains WebRTC's BSD notice and patent grant, 4 kHz analysis, 8192/16384 fast admission thresholds, passive-speech VAD, 20 ms decision band, 4x fast threshold, and 60 ms startup / 50 ms successful-stretch cooldowns. -[moq-dev/moq#8058](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/8058) departs from -NetEq's preemptive expand in both players, recorded in the shared spec: +[moq-dev/moq#8058](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/8058) adds a fast +expand to both players behind `FAST_EXPAND`, recorded in the shared spec: below the target, expand ignores the cooldown and takes every whole period -that fits at the lower threshold. It also drains a declared end's tail +that fits at the lower threshold. Watch's listening check picks it or +NetEq's exact expand. It also drains a declared end's tail unstretched, as finishing does. Analysis samples NetEq's 48 kHz FIR on a virtual clock for other device rates and uses floating-point peak refinement and fades. Those arithmetic adaptations are documented, not claimed bit-identical to int16 @@ -49,8 +53,8 @@ capacity watermark and an incoming excess at the fast threshold trim. Remaining verification: -- Native `test/audio-quality` rows must show zero steady-state underruns - once their targets settle. Keep a failed or void row explicit and fix +- Native `test/audio-quality` rows must meet their measured underrun + ceilings once their targets settle. Keep a failed or void row explicit and fix any implementation cause before calling this complete. - Re-measure the provisional native budgets from seven scheduled nightly artifacts using `budgets.json`'s rule: worst clean run times 1.25, plus diff --git a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md index 192fbd40286..92ae98bee24 100644 --- a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md +++ b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md @@ -1,20 +1,21 @@ -# [M] js/watch: prove zero steady-state audio underruns on real hardware +# [M] js/watch: prove inaudible steady-state audio convergence on real hardware ## Goal On the measured real-microphone rows, the "Real-time" (`"auto"`) preset plays -with zero player underruns after convergence and no skip-aheads in steady -state, with the estimator's `QUANTILE` left at 0.95. Audio holds back or -catches up by playing slightly slower or faster, the way NetEq's preemptive -expand and accelerate do, rather than running dry, discarding buffered audio, -or rendering silence. Convergence is inaudible at ordinary drift and burst -sizes. - -The measured rows are the `relay-mic-rtt40` replay row, whose -`player_underruns_per_min` must reach 0, and a live re-run of the 2026-11-03 -rows below with a real microphone, Chrome's with 40 ms or more of added RTT -and Safari's on the direct path, read from the stats panel's audio Underruns -and Skips. +with no audible glitch after convergence, judged by the maintainer's +listening check, with the estimator's `QUANTILE` left at 0.95. Audio holds +back or catches up by playing slightly slower or faster, the way NetEq's +preemptive expand and accelerate do, rather than running dry, discarding +buffered audio, or rendering silence. Convergence is inaudible at ordinary +drift and burst sizes. + +The measured rows are the `relay-mic-rtt40` replay row and a live re-run of +the 2026-11-03 rows below with a real microphone, Chrome's with 40 ms or more +of added RTT and Safari's on the direct path, read from the stats panel's +audio Underruns and Skips. Their underrun and skip ceilings are measured by +`test/audio-quality/budgets.json`'s rule, like every other budget, rather than +fixed at zero. Boundaries: no packet loss concealment, so a frame that never arrives is still missing audio; only received audio is stretched. The estimator stays as @@ -23,18 +24,28 @@ missing audio; only received audio is stretched. The estimator stays as ## Plan [moq-dev/moq#8058](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/8058) ports the shared -NetEq stretch into the browser's ring, passing the shared PCM corpus, and -every replay row, `relay-mic-rtt40` included, measures and is budgeted at 0 -`player_underruns_per_min`. NetEq-exact expand left `relay-mic-rtt40` at 2.1 -a minute, so expand departs from NetEq in both players, as -`doc/concept/audio-jitter.md` records: below the target it expands every -window, as many whole periods as fit, at the lower admission threshold. What -remains is proof outside the replay: +NetEq stretch into the browser's ring, passing the shared PCM corpus. Expand +has two variants, chosen by `FAST_EXPAND` in `js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts` +and `rs/moq-audio/src/stretch.rs`, which must match: + +- Fast expand, the default: below the target, every window, as many whole + periods as fit, at the lower admission threshold, as + `doc/concept/audio-jitter.md` records. Every replay row, + `relay-mic-rtt40` included, measures and is budgeted at 0 + `player_underruns_per_min`. +- NetEq-exact expand: one period per 50 ms cooldown at the normal threshold. + On the 2026-11-06 replays it left `relay-mic-rtt40` at 2.1 and + `bursty-aac` at 2.2 player underruns a minute, and the other rows at 0. + +The listening check under Waiting picks one; the other is deleted, with the +replay budgets and shared corpus re-measured for the choice if it is +NetEq-exact. What remains is proof outside the replay: - The 2026-11-03 rows re-run on real hardware, Chrome's at +40 ms and Safari's on the direct path, under Waiting. -- A listening check of that run and of the native player, since the expand - departure changes both and postdates the 2026-11-05 native listening in +- A listening check of that run and of the native player in both expand + variants, since the departure changes both and postdates the 2026-11-05 + native listening in [Native stretch](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md). - The nightly browser ceilings re-measured by `budgets.json`'s rule from seven scheduled nightlies with the stretch. The lag heuristic behind @@ -43,6 +54,18 @@ remains is proof outside the replay: real re-anchors beside them. One local run of the twelve chromium rows on 2026-11-06 fit every current ceiling, with zero player underruns and skips. +Decided 2026-11-06 (maintainer, /quest-complete on +[moq-dev/moq#8058](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/8058)): the Goal was +wrong to require exactly zero steady-state player underruns, which pushed +expand away from NetEq in both players. The Goal is now no audible glitch in +steady state, judged by listening, with underrun ceilings measured by +`budgets.json`'s rule. The listening check picks the expand variant: +NetEq-exact if it sounds as good, otherwise fast expand. Options shown: + +- ✅ Audible, not zero +- Keep zero, and take fast expand in both players +- Keep NetEq-exact, and plan concealment of late audio as a separate quest + Decided 2026-11-06 (maintainer, /quest-unblock): drop the Safari row with 40 ms or more of added RTT. Safari can't be redirected through the RTT relay, and shaping it needs Network Link Conditioner or `dnctl`/`pfctl` on the @@ -80,13 +103,17 @@ on the direct path. Underruns are the stats panel's counter after the first ## Waiting -- Maintainer: re-run the 2026-11-03 rows on the MacBook Air and listen to - them, since an agent has no microphone, speaker, or Safari. Automation - considered: rendering speech through the ring offline, but the repository's - only speech clips are 0.4 s, and the live run exercises the same stretch on - a real voice. On a checkout of `main` once +- Maintainer: re-run the 2026-11-03 rows on the MacBook Air, listen to them + in both expand variants, and pick the variant: NetEq-exact if it sounds as + good as fast expand (**recommended** then, since it keeps both players on + NetEq), otherwise fast expand. An agent has no microphone, speaker, or + Safari. Automation considered: rendering speech through the ring offline, + but the repository's only speech clips are 0.4 s, and the live run + exercises the same stretch on a real voice. On a checkout of `main` once [moq-dev/moq#8058](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/8058) merges, or of - its branch before: + its branch before, run each step once with `FAST_EXPAND = true` (the + default) and once with it set to `false` in both + `js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts` and `rs/moq-audio/src/stretch.rs`: 1. `just web serve https://cdn.moq.dev/anon`, and in its publish tab publish the built-in microphone with 20 ms groups, the default. 2. For the +40 ms RTT, `cargo run --release -p moq-shaper -- --listen @@ -96,7 +123,7 @@ on the direct path. Underruns are the stats panel's counter after the first --host-resolver-rules="MAP cdn.moq.dev 127.0.0.1"`. 3. Play the broadcast at the Real-time delay and talk for three minutes. Note the stats panel's audio Underruns and Skips at 30 s and at the end, - and listen for warble or pitch wobble. + and listen for warble, pitch wobble, or gaps. 4. Repeat with 100 ms groups, then both group sizes in Safari on the direct path, with no shaper. 5. Repeat the 2026-11-05 native listening runs of @@ -104,12 +131,12 @@ on the direct path. Underruns are the stats panel's counter after the first same checkout: `say` speech over Opus at a 1.002 and a 0.998 publisher rate, direct and through the shaper's `bursty` profile. - Done when every row reads zero Underruns and Skips between 30 s and the end - and the stretch is inaudible or close to it. Record the table here. + Done when the chosen variant has no audible glitch in steady state. Record + the table of Underruns and Skips per row and variant here, and the pick. - moq-dev/moq: seven scheduled Nightly runs on `main` with the stretch. Then re-measure the chromium ceilings in `test/audio-quality/budgets.json` from their `audio-quality-run` artifacts by the note's rule, adding - `player_skips_per_min`, and check that the rows meet the Goal. + `player_skips_per_min`. ## Related diff --git a/rs/moq-audio/src/stretch.rs b/rs/moq-audio/src/stretch.rs index 06a63baa83a..86a273a6ee2 100644 --- a/rs/moq-audio/src/stretch.rs +++ b/rs/moq-audio/src/stretch.rs @@ -6,6 +6,12 @@ //! preemptive_expand,dsp_helper,audio_vector,decision_logic}. //! See WEBRTC-LICENSE and WEBRTC-PATENTS in this crate. +/// Below the target, expand every window, as many whole periods as fit, at +/// the lower admission threshold. False is NetEq's exact preemptive expand. +/// The maintainer's listening check picks one, and the browser's +/// `FAST_EXPAND` in `js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts` must match it. +const FAST_EXPAND: bool = true; + #[derive(Clone, Copy, Debug, PartialEq, Eq)] enum Operation { Hold, @@ -75,7 +81,7 @@ impl Stretch { &self.input, self.channels, self.rate, - operation != Operation::Accelerate, + operation == Operation::Fast || (FAST_EXPAND && operation == Operation::Expand), ) }; self.position = 0; @@ -114,20 +120,23 @@ impl Stretch { self.cooldown = self.rate as usize * 50 / 1000; } - /// Expand departs from NetEq's preemptive expand, which repeats one period - /// per cooldown. A queue below its target is short of the cushion its - /// arrivals need, so it expands the way fast accelerate shrinks: every - /// window, as many whole periods as fit, at the lower admission threshold. + /// With [`FAST_EXPAND`], expand departs from NetEq's preemptive expand, + /// which repeats one period per cooldown. A queue below its target is short + /// of the cushion its arrivals need, so it expands the way fast accelerate + /// shrinks: every window, as many whole periods as fit, at the lower + /// admission threshold. fn decide(&self, buffered: usize, target: usize) -> Operation { let high = target + self.rate as usize * 20 / 1000; if buffered >= high * 4 { Operation::Fast - } else if buffered < target { + } else if FAST_EXPAND && buffered < target { Operation::Expand } else if self.cooldown > 0 { Operation::Hold } else if buffered >= high { Operation::Accelerate + } else if buffered < target { + Operation::Expand } else { Operation::Hold } diff --git a/test/audio-quality/budgets.json b/test/audio-quality/budgets.json index 1bda1e5b0fa..2933ff65785 100644 --- a/test/audio-quality/budgets.json +++ b/test/audio-quality/budgets.json @@ -1,5 +1,5 @@ { - "note": "The browser rows are measured on the nightly runner (ubuntu-24.04-arm, headless Chromium, seed 7, 60 s a row), from the audio-quality-run artifacts of the seven scheduled Nightly runs on main from 2026-10-29 to 2026-11-04 (40885347517, 41065371094, 41204380716, 41313466339, 41483654426, 41656613559, 41852517544), the first after a fresh subscriber stopped receiving the relay's cached history. The AAC rows predate the TS importer publishing each PES as one group. Each ceiling is the worst of its seven nights times 1.25, plus one runner hiccup, rounded up to two significant figures. The hiccup is sized from the single gaps the 2026-10-08 night put on otherwise clean rows, the fixed-250 control among them: 250 underruns/min, 700 gap ms/min, 3.3 skips/min, 280 discarded ms/min, 0.01 stalled, 0.015 silence, and one 20 ms bucket of target. Budgeted this way, every night passes when it is held out of its row's measurement except one, and that row's own ceiling includes it: the 2026-11-03 Opus bursty row raised its target to 300 ms 2.6 s in and held it for one 20 s half-life before settling at 180. Such startup holds, Opus near-zero's 100 ms on 2026-10-30 and 10-31 among them, are budgeted as measured. These ceilings record today's player as the runner hears it, not target audio quality. To re-measure, download the same artifact from the latest scheduled nightlies (`gh run download -n audio-quality-run`), which keep every run, and apply the same rule. The replay rows are deterministic, so their ceilings are exactly what they measured, through the end of each recording, with no headroom: any regression fails them, and an improvement should be tightened in. They were last re-measured on 2026-10-22 using version 3 traces with encoded frame durations: AAC-LC uses its fixed 1024 samples, and relay-mic retains Opus packet TOC durations. relay-mic was re-recorded on 2026-11-03 from a real microphone, Chrome 156 on a MacBook Air publishing its built-in microphone through the public relay, recorded by headless Chromium on a Linux host (35 s, minimum RTT 2 ms), which raised its target ceiling from 60 to 80 ms and its silence from 0 to 0.001 as measured. The recording path itself has no added RTT. relay-mic-rtt40 is the 2026-11-03 Chrome row at 40 ms of added RTT on that laptop (180 s, minimum RTT 47 ms), kept as the baseline time stretch must bring to zero. player_underruns_per_min, the player's own counter that its stats panel shows, is budgeted on the replay rows only; it counts the run-dry re-stalls the tap files as stalled time. On 2026-11-06 the player began time-stretching live playback and every replay row was re-measured with it: player_underruns_per_min fell to 0 on all five, relay-mic-rtt40's from 7.9, and stalled and silence fell or held. player_skips_per_min, the ring's own count of re-anchors that dropped buffered audio, is budgeted beside it: 0 except relay-mic-rtt40's 0.3, one re-anchor 21.5 s in as the estimator released its 780 ms startup hold, which main makes too. The tap metrics that rose are none of them audio the player dropped. skip_aheads and discarded_ms infer skips from steps in the playhead's lag, which a sustained accelerate makes too. bursty-aac no longer runs dry waiting on its missing groups (stalled 0.009 to 0, silence 0.013 to 0.002), so each hole now plays as the gap it is and the tap counts it as underruns. The AAC rows' gaps of 1 to 3 samples between frames, from rounding each frame's timestamp to the ring's index, now land at the end of a quantum often enough to count, at 0.2 gap ms a minute or less; main has the same zeros, aligned differently. The local-aac replay's stalled ceiling rises from 0.008 to 0.017 and silence from 0.015 to 0.020 because replay no longer stretches each frame to nearby timestamp gaps; the production player is unchanged. All other changed replay ceilings tighten to the exact measurement. That replay calibration leaves browser and native ceilings unchanged. bursty-aac is the 2026-10-18 AAC bursty isolated capture, recorded with the observer subscribed at the decoder's 2 s budget, so it holds every group the player saw. The native rows are provisional: measured on a loaded developer host (x86_64 Linux, the private PulseAudio null sink, seed 7, 60 s a row) on 2026-10-17, three runs of every row from the debug build nightly uses plus three more of the AAC rows from a release build, which played alike. Each ceiling is the worst clean run times 1.25, plus one native hiccup sized from the unimpaired Opus row's worst run (20 underruns/min, 50 gap ms/min, 2.2 skips/min, 110 discarded ms/min, 0.01 stalled, 0.005 silence, one 20 ms bucket of target), rounded up to two significant figures. On that host the null sink's clock ran about 150 ppm slow against the monotonic clock, read within 5 ms at p95 per sample, and its output latency sat between 14 and 28 ms. Five of the 36 AAC rows (none of the 18 Opus rows) voided on the clock: the device stopped pulling for about two seconds mid-row, sometimes after a backend error and a stream restart, which is a native playback defect rather than noise, and the ceilings exclude those runs. Re-measure from the nightly runner's artifacts once it has a week of native rows.", + "note": "The browser rows are measured on the nightly runner (ubuntu-24.04-arm, headless Chromium, seed 7, 60 s a row), from the audio-quality-run artifacts of the seven scheduled Nightly runs on main from 2026-10-29 to 2026-11-04 (40885347517, 41065371094, 41204380716, 41313466339, 41483654426, 41656613559, 41852517544), the first after a fresh subscriber stopped receiving the relay's cached history. The AAC rows predate the TS importer publishing each PES as one group. Each ceiling is the worst of its seven nights times 1.25, plus one runner hiccup, rounded up to two significant figures. The hiccup is sized from the single gaps the 2026-10-08 night put on otherwise clean rows, the fixed-250 control among them: 250 underruns/min, 700 gap ms/min, 3.3 skips/min, 280 discarded ms/min, 0.01 stalled, 0.015 silence, and one 20 ms bucket of target. Budgeted this way, every night passes when it is held out of its row's measurement except one, and that row's own ceiling includes it: the 2026-11-03 Opus bursty row raised its target to 300 ms 2.6 s in and held it for one 20 s half-life before settling at 180. Such startup holds, Opus near-zero's 100 ms on 2026-10-30 and 10-31 among them, are budgeted as measured. These ceilings record today's player as the runner hears it, not target audio quality. To re-measure, download the same artifact from the latest scheduled nightlies (`gh run download -n audio-quality-run`), which keep every run, and apply the same rule. The replay rows are deterministic, so their ceilings are exactly what they measured, through the end of each recording, with no headroom: any regression fails them, and an improvement should be tightened in. They were last re-measured on 2026-10-22 using version 3 traces with encoded frame durations: AAC-LC uses its fixed 1024 samples, and relay-mic retains Opus packet TOC durations. relay-mic was re-recorded on 2026-11-03 from a real microphone, Chrome 156 on a MacBook Air publishing its built-in microphone through the public relay, recorded by headless Chromium on a Linux host (35 s, minimum RTT 2 ms), which raised its target ceiling from 60 to 80 ms and its silence from 0 to 0.001 as measured. The recording path itself has no added RTT. relay-mic-rtt40 is the 2026-11-03 Chrome row at 40 ms of added RTT on that laptop (180 s, minimum RTT 47 ms), kept as the baseline time stretch improves on; like every replay row, its player_underruns_per_min ceiling is what it measures, not a fixed zero. player_underruns_per_min, the player's own counter that its stats panel shows, is budgeted on the replay rows only; it counts the run-dry re-stalls the tap files as stalled time. On 2026-11-06 the player began time-stretching live playback and every replay row was re-measured with it: player_underruns_per_min fell to 0 on all five, relay-mic-rtt40's from 7.9, and stalled and silence fell or held. player_skips_per_min, the ring's own count of re-anchors that dropped buffered audio, is budgeted beside it: 0 except relay-mic-rtt40's 0.3, one re-anchor 21.5 s in as the estimator released its 780 ms startup hold, which main makes too. The tap metrics that rose are none of them audio the player dropped. skip_aheads and discarded_ms infer skips from steps in the playhead's lag, which a sustained accelerate makes too. bursty-aac no longer runs dry waiting on its missing groups (stalled 0.009 to 0, silence 0.013 to 0.002), so each hole now plays as the gap it is and the tap counts it as underruns. The AAC rows' gaps of 1 to 3 samples between frames, from rounding each frame's timestamp to the ring's index, now land at the end of a quantum often enough to count, at 0.2 gap ms a minute or less; main has the same zeros, aligned differently. The local-aac replay's stalled ceiling rises from 0.008 to 0.017 and silence from 0.015 to 0.020 because replay no longer stretches each frame to nearby timestamp gaps; the production player is unchanged. All other changed replay ceilings tighten to the exact measurement. That replay calibration leaves browser and native ceilings unchanged. bursty-aac is the 2026-10-18 AAC bursty isolated capture, recorded with the observer subscribed at the decoder's 2 s budget, so it holds every group the player saw. The native rows are provisional: measured on a loaded developer host (x86_64 Linux, the private PulseAudio null sink, seed 7, 60 s a row) on 2026-10-17, three runs of every row from the debug build nightly uses plus three more of the AAC rows from a release build, which played alike. Each ceiling is the worst clean run times 1.25, plus one native hiccup sized from the unimpaired Opus row's worst run (20 underruns/min, 50 gap ms/min, 2.2 skips/min, 110 discarded ms/min, 0.01 stalled, 0.005 silence, one 20 ms bucket of target), rounded up to two significant figures. On that host the null sink's clock ran about 150 ppm slow against the monotonic clock, read within 5 ms at p95 per sample, and its output latency sat between 14 and 28 ms. Five of the 36 AAC rows (none of the 18 Opus rows) voided on the clock: the device stopped pulling for about two seconds mid-row, sometimes after a backend error and a stream restart, which is a native playback defect rather than noise, and the ceilings exclude those runs. Re-measure from the nightly runner's artifacts once it has a week of native rows.", "rows": [ { "runtime": "chromium", From 354e35df4068241a28d2429f00f934bad35bd7c6 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Luke Curley Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2026 14:05:07 -0800 Subject: [PATCH 04/13] fix(watch): unstage a staged window on a handover truncate Staging runs the read index up to a 30 ms window ahead of the playhead, so a successor truncating inside it lost its start to the predecessor. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts | 17 +++++++++++++++++ js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts | 10 ++++++++++ 2 files changed, 27 insertions(+) diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts index 1111a469080..d79cf29f2d1 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts @@ -820,6 +820,23 @@ describe("latency increase", () => { }); describe("time stretch", () => { + it("truncate replaces the unplayed part of a staged window", () => { + // Live, so the first read stages a whole 30 ms window though it plays only 128 samples. + const buffer = new AudioRingBuffer({ rate: 48000, channels: 1, latency: 100 as Milli }); + write(buffer, 0 as Milli, 4800, { channels: 1, value: 0.1 }); + read(buffer, 128, 1); + + buffer.truncate(Micro.fromMilli(10 as Milli)); + write(buffer, 10 as Milli, 960, { channels: 1, value: 0.9 }); + + // The predecessor plays to the truncation, then the successor in full. + const out = read(buffer, 480 - 128 + 960, 1)[0]; + expect(out.length).toBe(480 - 128 + 960); + expect(out[480 - 128 - 1]).toBeCloseTo(0.1, 5); + expect(out[480 - 128]).toBeCloseTo(0.9, 5); + expect(buffer.length).toBe(0); + }); + // 48 kHz: 30 ms windows of 1440 frames, and a constant signal stretches by its shortest pitch // period, 2.5 ms or 120 frames. const RATE = 48000; diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts index 6b520f1ea7c..f2dce409720 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts @@ -288,6 +288,16 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { truncate(timestamp: Micro): void { const target = Math.round(Second.fromMicro(timestamp) * this.rate); if (target >= this.#writeIndex) return; + // A staged window runs the read index ahead of the playhead. Unstage it so the successor + // replaces whatever of it is still unplayed, resuming the ring at the sample now playing. + const stretch = this.#stretch; + if (target < this.#readIndex && stretch.available > 0) { + const staged = (stretch.available * this.#window) / stretch.length; + const capacity = this.#buffer[0].length; + this.#readIndex = Math.max(Math.round(this.#readIndex - staged), this.#writeIndex - capacity); + stretch.clear(); + this.#window = 0; + } // Never retreat past the playhead: those samples are already due. this.#writeIndex = Math.max(target, this.#readIndex); this.#pauses = this.#pauses.filter((pause) => pause.start < this.#writeIndex); From 3ccc61a0eeae450be9cd1edf28f5e5a21d97df29 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Luke Curley Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2026 16:40:14 -0800 Subject: [PATCH 05/13] feat(watch): stretch with NetEq's expand and maximum-delay band Per the maintainer's answer on #8058, start from NetEq: revert the stronger expand (every window, every whole period, lower threshold) to NetEq's preemptive expand in both players, with the spec text and corpus vectors it changed. Checking the port against decision_logic.cc found it had dropped NetEq's GetMaxDelayMs term from the high limit. Restore it in both players: the jitter estimator reports `lateness`, how late the slowest in-order frame of its two-second window arrived against the fastest, and the stretch's band above the target widens by it, as do the browser ring's write re-anchor and the CLI's incoming trim at the fast threshold. A fixed target ignores the arrivals, so its lateness is zero. The estimator corpus gains a lateness series and the stretch corpus three vectors. relay-mic-rtt40 falls from 2.1 to 1.0 player underruns a minute; the replay budgets are re-set to what NetEq measures, and the quest Goal from zero to that rate. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- doc/concept/audio-jitter.md | 106 ++- doc/concept/audio-jitter/advertised.json | 2 +- doc/concept/audio-jitter/backlog.json | 2 +- doc/concept/audio-jitter/buildup.json | 2 +- doc/concept/audio-jitter/corpus.test.ts | 4 + doc/concept/audio-jitter/corpus.ts | 22 +- doc/concept/audio-jitter/fixed.json | 2 +- doc/concept/audio-jitter/flush.json | 2 +- doc/concept/audio-jitter/idle.json | 2 +- doc/concept/audio-jitter/paced.json | 2 +- doc/concept/audio-jitter/reference.ts | 17 + doc/concept/audio-jitter/reorder.json | 2 +- doc/concept/audio-jitter/silence.json | 2 +- doc/concept/audio-jitter/spike.json | 2 +- doc/concept/audio-jitter/straggler.json | 2 +- doc/concept/audio-jitter/stretch/corpus.json | 807 +++++++++--------- doc/concept/audio-jitter/tunein.json | 2 +- js/hang/api/container.api.md | 1 + js/hang/src/container/consumer.ts | 10 + js/hang/src/container/jitter.test.ts | 23 + js/hang/src/container/jitter.ts | 46 +- js/watch/src/audio/buffer.ts | 11 +- js/watch/src/audio/decoder.ts | 19 +- js/watch/src/audio/playout.test.ts | 13 +- js/watch/src/audio/render-worklet.ts | 2 + js/watch/src/audio/render.ts | 8 +- js/watch/src/audio/replay.ts | 6 + js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts | 28 +- js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts | 16 +- js/watch/src/audio/stretch.test.ts | 13 +- js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts | 32 +- .../m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md | 14 +- quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md | 91 +- rs/moq-audio/src/decode/consumer.rs | 10 + rs/moq-audio/src/jitter.rs | 100 ++- rs/moq-audio/src/playback/sink.rs | 7 + rs/moq-audio/src/ring.rs | 51 +- rs/moq-audio/src/stretch.rs | 44 +- rs/moq-cli/src/play/fake.rs | 3 + rs/moq-cli/src/play/media.rs | 19 +- rs/moq-cli/src/play/output.rs | 7 + test/audio-quality/README.md | 6 +- test/audio-quality/budgets.json | 38 +- 43 files changed, 995 insertions(+), 603 deletions(-) diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter.md b/doc/concept/audio-jitter.md index 8a9e33d93fd..ef9a4033957 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter.md +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter.md @@ -127,6 +127,12 @@ fold(bucket): # prior starts at 1 target(): measured = upper edge of the first bucket whose cumulative weight exceeds QUANTILE return max(measured, advertised) + frame + +lateness(): # widens the time stretch's band, not the target + if history is empty: return 0 + fast = entry in history minimising (entry.arrival - entry.media), the oldest on a tie + slow = entry in history maximising (entry.arrival - entry.media), the oldest on a tie + return max(0, (slow.arrival - fast.arrival) - (slow.media - fast.media)) ``` ### Relative arrival delay @@ -160,7 +166,8 @@ shorter than `WINDOW` instead of growing without bound. The reference is a minimum over a prefix of the history, and the publisher chooses the prefix by reordering, so scanning for it lets every frame cost `MAX_HISTORY` comparisons. Keep the history in a structure that answers any -prefix's minimum in logarithmic time, such as a segment tree over a ring. +prefix's minimum in logarithmic time, such as a segment tree over a ring, and +the whole history's maximum for `lateness`, such as a monotonic queue. Keep the oldest entry on a tie: tied entries with a different `arrival` and `media` round `delay` differently. @@ -267,6 +274,18 @@ A quantile of an empirical distribution, rather than a mean plus k deviations, because network delay is heavy-tailed and one-sided. A Gaussian assumption sizes that tail wrong in both directions. +### Lateness + +`lateness` is how late the slowest frame in the history arrived against the +fastest: NetEq's `PacketArrivalHistory::GetMaxDelayMs`, over the same +two-second window and the same in-order frames, since a reordered frame never +joins the history. It is not part of the target. The +[time stretch](#received-audio-time-stretch) adds it to the band above the +target, as NetEq's `DecisionLogic` does, so a ring the last two seconds +refilled after a late burst keeps that cushion instead of accelerating it away +before the next one. It reads the window as it is now rather than a quantile +of its history, so it falls back as soon as the late frame leaves the window. + ## The frame duration One frame duration is added on top of `measured`. The buffer swings by the @@ -503,10 +522,11 @@ marker in its group, and they belong to the speech before the silence, not after ## Fixed targets An explicit delay **fixes the target and disables adaptation**. It is taken -literally: no advertised floor, no frame term, no estimate. +literally: no advertised floor, no frame term, no estimate, and no lateness. ``` target = delay +lateness = 0 ``` An impossible fixed target is refused, not silently adjusted. A negative delay, @@ -571,7 +591,8 @@ directly, so neither is graded against the other. "frame": 20, "arrival": [0, 10, 30], "media": [0, 14500, 14520], - "target": [[0, 120], [26, 80]] + "target": [[0, 120], [26, 80]], + "lateness": [[0, 0]] } ``` @@ -582,7 +603,8 @@ them, as is `ends`: the indices, ascending, of the frames observed right after a [declared end](#declared-silence), each of which calls `end()` before it is observed. `target` lists `[frame index, target]` at every frame where the target differs from the previous frame's, starting at frame 0, so an implementation folds the trace one frame at a time and compares its target at each listed -index. Tolerance is 1e-6 ms, which the `f64` rules above make generous. +index. `lateness` lists the lateness the same way, zero throughout for the +`fixed` case. Tolerance is 1e-6 ms, which the `f64` rules above make generous. | Case | Holds the implementation to | | --- | --- | @@ -645,35 +667,34 @@ is silence rather than an underrun, so nothing expands toward a target that no arrival will refill. `buffered` counts unread frames in the ring plus staged output. `target` is -the current playout target. The state is `cooldown`, initially 60 ms +the current playout target, and `lateness` the estimator's +[lateness](#lateness), NetEq's `GetMaxDelayMs`, which is zero for a +[fixed target](#fixed-targets). The state is `cooldown`, initially 60 ms (NetEq's six startup ticks), reduced by each frame rendered, saturating at zero. At a window boundary, with -`high = target + 20 ms`, choose in this order: +`high = target + lateness + 20 ms`, choose in this order: 1. `buffered >= 4 * high`: fast accelerate, even during cooldown. -2. `buffered < target`: preemptive expand in fast mode, even during cooldown. -3. `cooldown > 0`: hold. -4. `buffered >= high`: accelerate. +2. `cooldown > 0`: hold. +3. `buffered >= high`: accelerate. +4. `buffered < target`: preemptive expand. 5. Otherwise: hold. A successful stretch sets cooldown to 50 ms (NetEq's five 10 ms ticks). A rejected seam leaves it unchanged. This preserves NetEq's 20 ms adjustment -granularity, 4x fast threshold, and minimum interval for accelerate. - -Expand departs from NetEq. Its preemptive expand waits out the cooldown and -repeats one pitch period at the normal threshold, which lengthens a ring by a -few milliseconds every 50 ms at most. On the `relay-mic-rtt40` replay, Chrome -at 40 ms of added RTT, that still ran the browser's ring dry 2.1 times a -minute: its arrival gaps reached 104 to 135 ms behind cushions of 71 to 94 ms. -A ring below its target is short of the cushion its arrivals need, and running -dry re-stalls it for a whole target of silence. So expand mirrors fast -accelerate instead: every window, at the lower admission threshold, as many -whole periods as fit before the middle, up to 15 ms of every 30 ms. That took -every replay row to zero player underruns. The cost is a stronger stretch while -the ring is short, which the listening check judges. NetEq's extra -packet-history maximum-delay term is not added again: this controller sees the -already decoded PCM queue and its jitter target rather than an RTP playout -timestamp and packet-arrival history. There is no concealment state. +granularity, its maximum-delay term, its 4x fast threshold, and its minimum +interval. There is no concealment state. + +One difference from NetEq's `DecisionLogic` remains. NetEq compares its +playout delay, how far the playhead trails the fastest arrival in its packet +history, where this compares `buffered`. The two agree while frames arrive on +time. During a receive stall `buffered` drains while the playout delay holds, +so this expands into the stall, and once the stall's frames land together +`buffered` jumps while the playout delay holds, so this can accelerate away the +cushion they bring. Deciding on the playout delay instead cut the +`relay-mic-rtt40` replay from 1.0 to 0.7 player underruns a minute, but the +browser's worklet would need the arrival clock mapped onto its render clock to +do it, so neither player does yet. ### Pitch search and admission @@ -702,9 +723,8 @@ squared energies and `C` their dot product. The signal is passive if `(E1+E2)/(2*L) <= 8*75000/(32768*32768)`, NetEq's VAD before a background noise model is initialised. No background synthesis or noise model is added. Otherwise admit the seam only when `C > threshold * sqrt(E1*E2)`, with -threshold **14746/16384** normally and **8192/16384** for fast accelerate -and expand. These are NetEq's original thresholds; none was tuned, though -NetEq applies the lower one to fast accelerate only. Active uncorrelated +threshold **14746/16384** normally and **8192/16384** for fast accelerate. +These are NetEq's original thresholds; none was tuned. Active uncorrelated PCM holds unchanged, so zero underruns are not guaranteed for arbitrary input or outages. Passive PCM may stretch without correlation. @@ -717,8 +737,7 @@ still needs the listening proof required by the quest. ### Seam and boundaries -In fast mode, for fast accelerate and every expand, replace `L` by -`floor(M/L)*L` after admission. For a crossfade of +In fast mode replace `L` by `floor(M/L)*L` after admission. For a crossfade of `L` frames, frame `i` uses `w=(i+1)/(L+1)` and `f32(a*(1-w)+b*w)` independently for every channel. @@ -739,25 +758,24 @@ ring and staged output hold the target again. Padding never enters the pitch search. Finishing bypasses that wait so a short tail can drain. Trimming is emergency recovery at the ring's capacity watermark. The CLI's incoming-media trim is reserved for a distance at the fast threshold, -not ordinary 20 ms drift. The browser's ring receives each decoded frame as a -write, so it re-anchors on its floor there, at the lower of the fast threshold -and three quarters of its headroom above the floor, and counts each re-anchor -as a skip in its stats. These bounds do not promise concealment of missing +`4 * high`, not ordinary 20 ms drift. The browser's ring receives each decoded +frame as a write, so it re-anchors on its floor there, at the lower of the fast +threshold and three quarters of its headroom above the floor, and counts each +re-anchor as a skip in its stats. These bounds do not promise concealment of missing media or convergence of a signal whose seams continually fail admission. ### Stretch corpus `audio-jitter/stretch/corpus.json` holds literal interleaved input and expected -output PCM, device rate and channels, buffered and target frame counts, -incoming cooldown, requested decision, and admitted lag (zero means hold). -Compare output within 1e-6 absolute sample amplitude. It includes hold, -cooldown, fast-mode bypass, linked stereo, passive noise, rejected active -noise, and 8/44.1/48 kHz seams, plus expand ignoring the cooldown and -admitting a seam at the lower threshold. Both implementations consume these -exact vectors; generating expected output from the implementation under test is -not conformance. The expand vectors were regenerated from the browser port when -expand departed from NetEq, and the native port, changed separately, reproduces -them unchanged. +output PCM, device rate and channels, buffered, target, and lateness frame +counts (lateness is zero where a vector leaves it out), incoming cooldown, +requested decision, and admitted lag (zero means hold). Compare output within +1e-6 absolute sample amplitude. It includes hold, cooldown, fast-mode bypass, +linked stereo, passive noise, rejected active noise, 8/44.1/48 kHz seams, and +a lateness that holds a ring accelerate would otherwise shorten, accelerates +one above the widened band, and raises the fast threshold with it. Both +implementations consume these exact vectors; generating expected output from +the implementation under test is not conformance. ## Comfort noise diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/advertised.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/advertised.json index 553a70accf8..0f389e764aa 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/advertised.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/advertised.json @@ -1 +1 @@ -{"name":"advertised","about":"The same even sender as `paced`, with a publisher advertising a 200 ms flush span. The advertised value is a floor on the measured term, not an addition to it, so the target holds there instead of converging down.","frame":20,"advertised":200,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980],"target":[[0,220]]} +{"name":"advertised","about":"The same even sender as `paced`, with a publisher advertising a 200 ms flush span. The advertised value is a floor on the measured term, not an addition to it, so the target holds there instead of converging down.","frame":20,"advertised":200,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980],"target":[[0,220]],"lateness":[[0,0]]} diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/backlog.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/backlog.json index a76a36ad91b..158f49f3ec5 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/backlog.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/backlog.json @@ -1 +1 @@ -{"name":"backlog","about":"The live edge, then the 1.5 s backlog behind it delivered newest first, then 30 s of even audio, as a subscription's start arrives. The backlog precedes every frame observed, so it is not measured, and the target stays near the frame duration.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,50.25,50.5,50.75,51,51.25,51.5,51.75,52,52.25,52.5,52.75,53,53.25,53.5,53.75,54,54.25,54.5,54.75,55,55.25,55.5,55.75,56,56.25,56.5,56.75,57,57.25,57.5,57.75,58,58.25,58.5,58.75,59,59.25,59.5,59.75,60,60.25,60.5,60.75,61,61.25,61.5,61.75,62,62.25,62.5,62.75,63,63.25,63.5,63.75,64,64.25,64.5,64.75,65,65.25,65.5,65.75,66,66.25,66.5,66.75,67,67.25,67.5,67.75,68,68.25,68.5,68.75,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030,20050,20070,20090,20110,20130,20150,20170,20190,20210,20230,20250,20270,20290,20310,20330,20350,20370,20390,20410,20430,20450,20470,20490,20510,20530,20550,20570,20590,20610,20630,20650,20670,20690,20710,20730,20750,20770,20790,20810,20830,20850,20870,20890,20910,20930,20950,20970,20990,21010,21030,21050,21070,21090,21110,21130,21150,21170,21190,21210,21230,21250,21270,21290,21310,21330,21350,21370,21390,21410,21430,21450,21470,21490,21510,21530,21550,21570,21590,21610,21630,21650,21670,21690,21710,21730,21750,21770,21790,21810,21830,21850,21870,21890,21910,21930,21950,21970,21990,22010,22030,22050,22070,22090,22110,22130,22150,22170,22190,22210,22230,22250,22270,22290,22310,22330,22350,22370,22390,22410,22430,22450,22470,22490,22510,22530,22550,22570,22590,22610,22630,22650,22670,22690,22710,22730,22750,22770,22790,22810,22830,22850,22870,22890,22910,22930,22950,22970,22990,23010,23030,23050,23070,23090,23110,23130,23150,23170,23190,23210,23230,23250,23270,23290,23310,23330,23350,23370,23390,23410,23430,23450,23470,23490,23510,23530,23550,23570,23590,23610,23630,23650,23670,23690,23710,23730,23750,23770,23790,23810,23830,23850,23870,23890,23910,23930,23950,23970,23990,24010,24030,24050,24070,24090,24110,24130,24150,24170,24190,24210,24230,24250,24270,24290,24310,24330,24350,24370,24390,24410,24430,24450,24470,24490,24510,24530,24550,24570,24590,24610,24630,24650,24670,24690,24710,24730,24750,24770,24790,24810,24830,24850,24870,24890,24910,24930,24950,24970,24990,25010,25030,25050,25070,25090,25110,25130,25150,25170,25190,25210,25230,25250,25270,25290,25310,25330,25350,25370,25390,25410,25430,25450,25470,25490,25510,25530,25550,25570,25590,25610,25630,25650,25670,25690,25710,25730,25750,25770,25790,25810,25830,25850,25870,25890,25910,25930,25950,25970,25990,26010,26030,26050,26070,26090,26110,26130,26150,26170,26190,26210,26230,26250,26270,26290,26310,26330,26350,26370,26390,26410,26430,26450,26470,26490,26510,26530,26550,26570,26590,26610,26630,26650,26670,26690,26710,26730,26750,26770,26790,26810,26830,26850,26870,26890,26910,26930,26950,26970,26990,27010,27030,27050,27070,27090,27110,27130,27150,27170,27190,27210,27230,27250,27270,27290,27310,27330,27350,27370,27390,27410,27430,27450,27470,27490,27510,27530,27550,27570,27590,27610,27630,27650,27670,27690,27710,27730,27750,27770,27790,27810,27830,27850,27870,27890,27910,27930,27950,27970,27990,28010,28030,28050,28070,28090,28110,28130,28150,28170,28190,28210,28230,28250,28270,28290,28310,28330,28350,28370,28390,28410,28430,28450,28470,28490,28510,28530,28550,28570,28590,28610,28630,28650,28670,28690,28710,28730,28750,28770,28790,28810,28830,28850,28870,28890,28910,28930,28950,28970,28990,29010,29030,29050,29070,29090,29110,29130,29150,29170,29190,29210,29230,29250,29270,29290,29310,29330,29350,29370,29390,29410,29430,29450,29470,29490,29510,29530,29550,29570,29590,29610,29630,29650,29670,29690,29710,29730,29750,29770,29790,29810,29830,29850,29870,29890,29910,29930,29950,29970,29990,30010,30030,30050],"media":[1500,1480,1460,1440,1420,1400,1380,1360,1340,1320,1300,1280,1260,1240,1220,1200,1180,1160,1140,1120,1100,1080,1060,1040,1020,1000,980,960,940,920,900,880,860,840,820,800,780,760,740,720,700,680,660,640,620,600,580,560,540,520,500,480,460,440,420,400,380,360,340,320,300,280,260,240,220,200,180,160,140,120,100,80,60,40,20,0,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,20000,20020,20040,20060,20080,20100,20120,20140,20160,20180,20200,20220,20240,20260,20280,20300,20320,20340,20360,20380,20400,20420,20440,20460,20480,20500,20520,20540,20560,20580,20600,20620,20640,20660,20680,20700,20720,20740,20760,20780,20800,20820,20840,20860,20880,20900,20920,20940,20960,20980,21000,21020,21040,21060,21080,21100,21120,21140,21160,21180,21200,21220,21240,21260,21280,21300,21320,21340,21360,21380,21400,21420,21440,21460,21480,21500,21520,21540,21560,21580,21600,21620,21640,21660,21680,21700,21720,21740,21760,21780,21800,21820,21840,21860,21880,21900,21920,21940,21960,21980,22000,22020,22040,22060,22080,22100,22120,22140,22160,22180,22200,22220,22240,22260,22280,22300,22320,22340,22360,22380,22400,22420,22440,22460,22480,22500,22520,22540,22560,22580,22600,22620,22640,22660,22680,22700,22720,22740,22760,22780,22800,22820,22840,22860,22880,22900,22920,22940,22960,22980,23000,23020,23040,23060,23080,23100,23120,23140,23160,23180,23200,23220,23240,23260,23280,23300,23320,23340,23360,23380,23400,23420,23440,23460,23480,23500,23520,23540,23560,23580,23600,23620,23640,23660,23680,23700,23720,23740,23760,23780,23800,23820,23840,23860,23880,23900,23920,23940,23960,23980,24000,24020,24040,24060,24080,24100,24120,24140,24160,24180,24200,24220,24240,24260,24280,24300,24320,24340,24360,24380,24400,24420,24440,24460,24480,24500,24520,24540,24560,24580,24600,24620,24640,24660,24680,24700,24720,24740,24760,24780,24800,24820,24840,24860,24880,24900,24920,24940,24960,24980,25000,25020,25040,25060,25080,25100,25120,25140,25160,25180,25200,25220,25240,25260,25280,25300,25320,25340,25360,25380,25400,25420,25440,25460,25480,25500,25520,25540,25560,25580,25600,25620,25640,25660,25680,25700,25720,25740,25760,25780,25800,25820,25840,25860,25880,25900,25920,25940,25960,25980,26000,26020,26040,26060,26080,26100,26120,26140,26160,26180,26200,26220,26240,26260,26280,26300,26320,26340,26360,26380,26400,26420,26440,26460,26480,26500,26520,26540,26560,26580,26600,26620,26640,26660,26680,26700,26720,26740,26760,26780,26800,26820,26840,26860,26880,26900,26920,26940,26960,26980,27000,27020,27040,27060,27080,27100,27120,27140,27160,27180,27200,27220,27240,27260,27280,27300,27320,27340,27360,27380,27400,27420,27440,27460,27480,27500,27520,27540,27560,27580,27600,27620,27640,27660,27680,27700,27720,27740,27760,27780,27800,27820,27840,27860,27880,27900,27920,27940,27960,27980,28000,28020,28040,28060,28080,28100,28120,28140,28160,28180,28200,28220,28240,28260,28280,28300,28320,28340,28360,28380,28400,28420,28440,28460,28480,28500,28520,28540,28560,28580,28600,28620,28640,28660,28680,28700,28720,28740,28760,28780,28800,28820,28840,28860,28880,28900,28920,28940,28960,28980,29000,29020,29040,29060,29080,29100,29120,29140,29160,29180,29200,29220,29240,29260,29280,29300,29320,29340,29360,29380,29400,29420,29440,29460,29480,29500,29520,29540,29560,29580,29600,29620,29640,29660,29680,29700,29720,29740,29760,29780,29800,29820,29840,29860,29880,29900,29920,29940,29960,29980,30000,30020,30040,30060,30080,30100,30120,30140,30160,30180,30200,30220,30240,30260,30280,30300,30320,30340,30360,30380,30400,30420,30440,30460,30480,30500,30520,30540,30560,30580,30600,30620,30640,30660,30680,30700,30720,30740,30760,30780,30800,30820,30840,30860,30880,30900,30920,30940,30960,30980,31000,31020,31040,31060,31080,31100,31120,31140,31160,31180,31200,31220,31240,31260,31280,31300,31320,31340,31360,31380,31400,31420,31440,31460,31480,31500],"target":[[0,120],[150,100],[250,80],[300,60],[325,40]]} +{"name":"backlog","about":"The live edge, then the 1.5 s backlog behind it delivered newest first, then 30 s of even audio, as a subscription's start arrives. The backlog precedes every frame observed, so it is not measured, and the target stays near the frame duration.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,50.25,50.5,50.75,51,51.25,51.5,51.75,52,52.25,52.5,52.75,53,53.25,53.5,53.75,54,54.25,54.5,54.75,55,55.25,55.5,55.75,56,56.25,56.5,56.75,57,57.25,57.5,57.75,58,58.25,58.5,58.75,59,59.25,59.5,59.75,60,60.25,60.5,60.75,61,61.25,61.5,61.75,62,62.25,62.5,62.75,63,63.25,63.5,63.75,64,64.25,64.5,64.75,65,65.25,65.5,65.75,66,66.25,66.5,66.75,67,67.25,67.5,67.75,68,68.25,68.5,68.75,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030,20050,20070,20090,20110,20130,20150,20170,20190,20210,20230,20250,20270,20290,20310,20330,20350,20370,20390,20410,20430,20450,20470,20490,20510,20530,20550,20570,20590,20610,20630,20650,20670,20690,20710,20730,20750,20770,20790,20810,20830,20850,20870,20890,20910,20930,20950,20970,20990,21010,21030,21050,21070,21090,21110,21130,21150,21170,21190,21210,21230,21250,21270,21290,21310,21330,21350,21370,21390,21410,21430,21450,21470,21490,21510,21530,21550,21570,21590,21610,21630,21650,21670,21690,21710,21730,21750,21770,21790,21810,21830,21850,21870,21890,21910,21930,21950,21970,21990,22010,22030,22050,22070,22090,22110,22130,22150,22170,22190,22210,22230,22250,22270,22290,22310,22330,22350,22370,22390,22410,22430,22450,22470,22490,22510,22530,22550,22570,22590,22610,22630,22650,22670,22690,22710,22730,22750,22770,22790,22810,22830,22850,22870,22890,22910,22930,22950,22970,22990,23010,23030,23050,23070,23090,23110,23130,23150,23170,23190,23210,23230,23250,23270,23290,23310,23330,23350,23370,23390,23410,23430,23450,23470,23490,23510,23530,23550,23570,23590,23610,23630,23650,23670,23690,23710,23730,23750,23770,23790,23810,23830,23850,23870,23890,23910,23930,23950,23970,23990,24010,24030,24050,24070,24090,24110,24130,24150,24170,24190,24210,24230,24250,24270,24290,24310,24330,24350,24370,24390,24410,24430,24450,24470,24490,24510,24530,24550,24570,24590,24610,24630,24650,24670,24690,24710,24730,24750,24770,24790,24810,24830,24850,24870,24890,24910,24930,24950,24970,24990,25010,25030,25050,25070,25090,25110,25130,25150,25170,25190,25210,25230,25250,25270,25290,25310,25330,25350,25370,25390,25410,25430,25450,25470,25490,25510,25530,25550,25570,25590,25610,25630,25650,25670,25690,25710,25730,25750,25770,25790,25810,25830,25850,25870,25890,25910,25930,25950,25970,25990,26010,26030,26050,26070,26090,26110,26130,26150,26170,26190,26210,26230,26250,26270,26290,26310,26330,26350,26370,26390,26410,26430,26450,26470,26490,26510,26530,26550,26570,26590,26610,26630,26650,26670,26690,26710,26730,26750,26770,26790,26810,26830,26850,26870,26890,26910,26930,26950,26970,26990,27010,27030,27050,27070,27090,27110,27130,27150,27170,27190,27210,27230,27250,27270,27290,27310,27330,27350,27370,27390,27410,27430,27450,27470,27490,27510,27530,27550,27570,27590,27610,27630,27650,27670,27690,27710,27730,27750,27770,27790,27810,27830,27850,27870,27890,27910,27930,27950,27970,27990,28010,28030,28050,28070,28090,28110,28130,28150,28170,28190,28210,28230,28250,28270,28290,28310,28330,28350,28370,28390,28410,28430,28450,28470,28490,28510,28530,28550,28570,28590,28610,28630,28650,28670,28690,28710,28730,28750,28770,28790,28810,28830,28850,28870,28890,28910,28930,28950,28970,28990,29010,29030,29050,29070,29090,29110,29130,29150,29170,29190,29210,29230,29250,29270,29290,29310,29330,29350,29370,29390,29410,29430,29450,29470,29490,29510,29530,29550,29570,29590,29610,29630,29650,29670,29690,29710,29730,29750,29770,29790,29810,29830,29850,29870,29890,29910,29930,29950,29970,29990,30010,30030,30050],"media":[1500,1480,1460,1440,1420,1400,1380,1360,1340,1320,1300,1280,1260,1240,1220,1200,1180,1160,1140,1120,1100,1080,1060,1040,1020,1000,980,960,940,920,900,880,860,840,820,800,780,760,740,720,700,680,660,640,620,600,580,560,540,520,500,480,460,440,420,400,380,360,340,320,300,280,260,240,220,200,180,160,140,120,100,80,60,40,20,0,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,20000,20020,20040,20060,20080,20100,20120,20140,20160,20180,20200,20220,20240,20260,20280,20300,20320,20340,20360,20380,20400,20420,20440,20460,20480,20500,20520,20540,20560,20580,20600,20620,20640,20660,20680,20700,20720,20740,20760,20780,20800,20820,20840,20860,20880,20900,20920,20940,20960,20980,21000,21020,21040,21060,21080,21100,21120,21140,21160,21180,21200,21220,21240,21260,21280,21300,21320,21340,21360,21380,21400,21420,21440,21460,21480,21500,21520,21540,21560,21580,21600,21620,21640,21660,21680,21700,21720,21740,21760,21780,21800,21820,21840,21860,21880,21900,21920,21940,21960,21980,22000,22020,22040,22060,22080,22100,22120,22140,22160,22180,22200,22220,22240,22260,22280,22300,22320,22340,22360,22380,22400,22420,22440,22460,22480,22500,22520,22540,22560,22580,22600,22620,22640,22660,22680,22700,22720,22740,22760,22780,22800,22820,22840,22860,22880,22900,22920,22940,22960,22980,23000,23020,23040,23060,23080,23100,23120,23140,23160,23180,23200,23220,23240,23260,23280,23300,23320,23340,23360,23380,23400,23420,23440,23460,23480,23500,23520,23540,23560,23580,23600,23620,23640,23660,23680,23700,23720,23740,23760,23780,23800,23820,23840,23860,23880,23900,23920,23940,23960,23980,24000,24020,24040,24060,24080,24100,24120,24140,24160,24180,24200,24220,24240,24260,24280,24300,24320,24340,24360,24380,24400,24420,24440,24460,24480,24500,24520,24540,24560,24580,24600,24620,24640,24660,24680,24700,24720,24740,24760,24780,24800,24820,24840,24860,24880,24900,24920,24940,24960,24980,25000,25020,25040,25060,25080,25100,25120,25140,25160,25180,25200,25220,25240,25260,25280,25300,25320,25340,25360,25380,25400,25420,25440,25460,25480,25500,25520,25540,25560,25580,25600,25620,25640,25660,25680,25700,25720,25740,25760,25780,25800,25820,25840,25860,25880,25900,25920,25940,25960,25980,26000,26020,26040,26060,26080,26100,26120,26140,26160,26180,26200,26220,26240,26260,26280,26300,26320,26340,26360,26380,26400,26420,26440,26460,26480,26500,26520,26540,26560,26580,26600,26620,26640,26660,26680,26700,26720,26740,26760,26780,26800,26820,26840,26860,26880,26900,26920,26940,26960,26980,27000,27020,27040,27060,27080,27100,27120,27140,27160,27180,27200,27220,27240,27260,27280,27300,27320,27340,27360,27380,27400,27420,27440,27460,27480,27500,27520,27540,27560,27580,27600,27620,27640,27660,27680,27700,27720,27740,27760,27780,27800,27820,27840,27860,27880,27900,27920,27940,27960,27980,28000,28020,28040,28060,28080,28100,28120,28140,28160,28180,28200,28220,28240,28260,28280,28300,28320,28340,28360,28380,28400,28420,28440,28460,28480,28500,28520,28540,28560,28580,28600,28620,28640,28660,28680,28700,28720,28740,28760,28780,28800,28820,28840,28860,28880,28900,28920,28940,28960,28980,29000,29020,29040,29060,29080,29100,29120,29140,29160,29180,29200,29220,29240,29260,29280,29300,29320,29340,29360,29380,29400,29420,29440,29460,29480,29500,29520,29540,29560,29580,29600,29620,29640,29660,29680,29700,29720,29740,29760,29780,29800,29820,29840,29860,29880,29900,29920,29940,29960,29980,30000,30020,30040,30060,30080,30100,30120,30140,30160,30180,30200,30220,30240,30260,30280,30300,30320,30340,30360,30380,30400,30420,30440,30460,30480,30500,30520,30540,30560,30580,30600,30620,30640,30660,30680,30700,30720,30740,30760,30780,30800,30820,30840,30860,30880,30900,30920,30940,30960,30980,31000,31020,31040,31060,31080,31100,31120,31140,31160,31180,31200,31220,31240,31260,31280,31300,31320,31340,31360,31380,31400,31420,31440,31460,31480,31500],"target":[[0,120],[150,100],[250,80],[300,60],[325,40]],"lateness":[[0,0]]} diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/buildup.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/buildup.json index e082799c56e..da61d5ef4ae 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/buildup.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/buildup.json @@ -1 +1 @@ -{"name":"buildup","about":"A queue filling at 2 ms per frame for 2 s, then holding. An inter-arrival estimator reads a hundred tiny observations; this reads the delay climbing against the fastest recent frame.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5052,5074,5096,5118,5140,5162,5184,5206,5228,5250,5272,5294,5316,5338,5360,5382,5404,5426,5448,5470,5492,5514,5536,5558,5580,5602,5624,5646,5668,5690,5712,5734,5756,5778,5800,5822,5844,5866,5888,5910,5932,5954,5976,5998,6020,6042,6064,6086,6108,6130,6152,6174,6196,6218,6240,6262,6284,6306,6328,6350,6372,6394,6416,6438,6460,6482,6504,6526,6548,6570,6592,6614,6636,6658,6680,6702,6724,6746,6768,6790,6812,6834,6856,6878,6900,6922,6944,6966,6988,7010,7032,7054,7076,7098,7120,7142,7164,7186,7208,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030,20050,20070,20090,20110,20130,20150,20170,20190,20210,20230,20250,20270,20290,20310,20330,20350,20370,20390,20410,20430,20450,20470,20490,20510,20530,20550,20570,20590,20610,20630,20650,20670,20690,20710,20730,20750,20770,20790,20810,20830,20850,20870,20890,20910,20930,20950,20970,20990,21010,21030,21050,21070,21090,21110,21130,21150,21170,21190,21210,21230,21250,21270,21290,21310,21330,21350,21370,21390,21410,21430,21450,21470,21490,21510,21530,21550,21570,21590,21610,21630,21650,21670,21690,21710,21730,21750,21770,21790,21810,21830,21850,21870,21890,21910,21930,21950,21970,21990,22010,22030,22050,22070,22090,22110,22130,22150,22170,22190,22210,22230,22250,22270,22290,22310,22330,22350,22370,22390,22410,22430,22450,22470,22490,22510,22530,22550,22570,22590,22610,22630,22650,22670,22690,22710,22730,22750,22770,22790,22810,22830,22850,22870,22890,22910,22930,22950,22970,22990,23010,23030,23050,23070,23090,23110,23130,23150,23170,23190,23210,23230,23250,23270,23290,23310,23330,23350,23370,23390,23410,23430,23450,23470,23490,23510,23530,23550,23570,23590,23610,23630,23650,23670,23690,23710,23730,23750,23770,23790,23810,23830,23850,23870,23890,23910,23930,23950,23970,23990,24010,24030,24050,24070,24090,24110,24130,24150,24170,24190,24210,24230,24250,24270,24290,24310,24330,24350,24370,24390,24410,24430,24450,24470,24490,24510,24530,24550,24570,24590,24610,24630,24650,24670,24690,24710,24730,24750,24770,24790,24810,24830,24850,24870,24890,24910,24930,24950,24970,24990,25010,25030,25050,25070,25090,25110,25130,25150,25170,25190,25210,25230,25250,25270,25290,25310,25330,25350,25370,25390,25410,25430,25450,25470,25490,25510,25530,25550,25570,25590,25610,25630,25650,25670,25690,25710,25730,25750,25770,25790,25810,25830,25850,25870,25890,25910,25930,25950,25970,25990,26010,26030,26050,26070,26090,26110,26130,26150,26170,26190,26210,26230,26250,26270,26290,26310,26330,26350,26370,26390,26410,26430,26450,26470,26490,26510,26530,26550,26570,26590,26610,26630,26650,26670,26690,26710,26730,26750,26770,26790,26810,26830,26850,26870,26890,26910,26930,26950,26970,26990,27010,27030,27050,27070,27090,27110,27130,27150,27170,27190,27210,27230,27250,27270,27290,27310,27330,27350,27370,27390,27410,27430,27450,27470,27490,27510,27530,27550,27570,27590,27610,27630,27650,27670,27690,27710,27730,27750,27770,27790,27810,27830,27850,27870,27890,27910,27930,27950,27970,27990,28010,28030,28050,28070,28090,28110,28130,28150,28170,28190,28210,28230,28250,28270,28290,28310,28330,28350,28370,28390,28410,28430,28450,28470,28490,28510,28530,28550,28570,28590,28610,28630,28650,28670,28690,28710,28730,28750,28770,28790,28810,28830,28850,28870,28890,28910,28930,28950,28970,28990,29010,29030,29050,29070,29090,29110,29130,29150,29170,29190,29210,29230,29250,29270,29290,29310,29330,29350,29370,29390,29410,29430,29450,29470,29490,29510,29530,29550,29570,29590,29610,29630,29650,29670,29690,29710,29730,29750,29770,29790,29810,29830,29850,29870,29890,29910,29930,29950,29970,29990,30010,30030,30050,30070,30090,30110,30130,30150,30170,30190,30210,30230],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,20000,20020,20040,20060,20080,20100,20120,20140,20160,20180,20200,20220,20240,20260,20280,20300,20320,20340,20360,20380,20400,20420,20440,20460,20480,20500,20520,20540,20560,20580,20600,20620,20640,20660,20680,20700,20720,20740,20760,20780,20800,20820,20840,20860,20880,20900,20920,20940,20960,20980,21000,21020,21040,21060,21080,21100,21120,21140,21160,21180,21200,21220,21240,21260,21280,21300,21320,21340,21360,21380,21400,21420,21440,21460,21480,21500,21520,21540,21560,21580,21600,21620,21640,21660,21680,21700,21720,21740,21760,21780,21800,21820,21840,21860,21880,21900,21920,21940,21960,21980,22000,22020,22040,22060,22080,22100,22120,22140,22160,22180,22200,22220,22240,22260,22280,22300,22320,22340,22360,22380,22400,22420,22440,22460,22480,22500,22520,22540,22560,22580,22600,22620,22640,22660,22680,22700,22720,22740,22760,22780,22800,22820,22840,22860,22880,22900,22920,22940,22960,22980,23000,23020,23040,23060,23080,23100,23120,23140,23160,23180,23200,23220,23240,23260,23280,23300,23320,23340,23360,23380,23400,23420,23440,23460,23480,23500,23520,23540,23560,23580,23600,23620,23640,23660,23680,23700,23720,23740,23760,23780,23800,23820,23840,23860,23880,23900,23920,23940,23960,23980,24000,24020,24040,24060,24080,24100,24120,24140,24160,24180,24200,24220,24240,24260,24280,24300,24320,24340,24360,24380,24400,24420,24440,24460,24480,24500,24520,24540,24560,24580,24600,24620,24640,24660,24680,24700,24720,24740,24760,24780,24800,24820,24840,24860,24880,24900,24920,24940,24960,24980,25000,25020,25040,25060,25080,25100,25120,25140,25160,25180,25200,25220,25240,25260,25280,25300,25320,25340,25360,25380,25400,25420,25440,25460,25480,25500,25520,25540,25560,25580,25600,25620,25640,25660,25680,25700,25720,25740,25760,25780,25800,25820,25840,25860,25880,25900,25920,25940,25960,25980,26000,26020,26040,26060,26080,26100,26120,26140,26160,26180,26200,26220,26240,26260,26280,26300,26320,26340,26360,26380,26400,26420,26440,26460,26480,26500,26520,26540,26560,26580,26600,26620,26640,26660,26680,26700,26720,26740,26760,26780,26800,26820,26840,26860,26880,26900,26920,26940,26960,26980,27000,27020,27040,27060,27080,27100,27120,27140,27160,27180,27200,27220,27240,27260,27280,27300,27320,27340,27360,27380,27400,27420,27440,27460,27480,27500,27520,27540,27560,27580,27600,27620,27640,27660,27680,27700,27720,27740,27760,27780,27800,27820,27840,27860,27880,27900,27920,27940,27960,27980,28000,28020,28040,28060,28080,28100,28120,28140,28160,28180,28200,28220,28240,28260,28280,28300,28320,28340,28360,28380,28400,28420,28440,28460,28480,28500,28520,28540,28560,28580,28600,28620,28640,28660,28680,28700,28720,28740,28760,28780,28800,28820,28840,28860,28880,28900,28920,28940,28960,28980,29000,29020,29040,29060,29080,29100,29120,29140,29160,29180,29200,29220,29240,29260,29280,29300,29320,29340,29360,29380,29400,29420,29440,29460,29480,29500,29520,29540,29560,29580,29600,29620,29640,29660,29680,29700,29720,29740,29760,29780,29800,29820,29840,29860,29880,29900,29920,29940,29960,29980],"target":[[0,120],[75,100],[175,80],[225,60],[250,40],[273,80],[341,120],[365,160],[390,200],[415,160],[815,140],[1140,120],[1415,100]]} +{"name":"buildup","about":"A queue filling at 2 ms per frame for 2 s, then holding. An inter-arrival estimator reads a hundred tiny observations; this reads the delay climbing against the fastest recent frame.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5052,5074,5096,5118,5140,5162,5184,5206,5228,5250,5272,5294,5316,5338,5360,5382,5404,5426,5448,5470,5492,5514,5536,5558,5580,5602,5624,5646,5668,5690,5712,5734,5756,5778,5800,5822,5844,5866,5888,5910,5932,5954,5976,5998,6020,6042,6064,6086,6108,6130,6152,6174,6196,6218,6240,6262,6284,6306,6328,6350,6372,6394,6416,6438,6460,6482,6504,6526,6548,6570,6592,6614,6636,6658,6680,6702,6724,6746,6768,6790,6812,6834,6856,6878,6900,6922,6944,6966,6988,7010,7032,7054,7076,7098,7120,7142,7164,7186,7208,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030,20050,20070,20090,20110,20130,20150,20170,20190,20210,20230,20250,20270,20290,20310,20330,20350,20370,20390,20410,20430,20450,20470,20490,20510,20530,20550,20570,20590,20610,20630,20650,20670,20690,20710,20730,20750,20770,20790,20810,20830,20850,20870,20890,20910,20930,20950,20970,20990,21010,21030,21050,21070,21090,21110,21130,21150,21170,21190,21210,21230,21250,21270,21290,21310,21330,21350,21370,21390,21410,21430,21450,21470,21490,21510,21530,21550,21570,21590,21610,21630,21650,21670,21690,21710,21730,21750,21770,21790,21810,21830,21850,21870,21890,21910,21930,21950,21970,21990,22010,22030,22050,22070,22090,22110,22130,22150,22170,22190,22210,22230,22250,22270,22290,22310,22330,22350,22370,22390,22410,22430,22450,22470,22490,22510,22530,22550,22570,22590,22610,22630,22650,22670,22690,22710,22730,22750,22770,22790,22810,22830,22850,22870,22890,22910,22930,22950,22970,22990,23010,23030,23050,23070,23090,23110,23130,23150,23170,23190,23210,23230,23250,23270,23290,23310,23330,23350,23370,23390,23410,23430,23450,23470,23490,23510,23530,23550,23570,23590,23610,23630,23650,23670,23690,23710,23730,23750,23770,23790,23810,23830,23850,23870,23890,23910,23930,23950,23970,23990,24010,24030,24050,24070,24090,24110,24130,24150,24170,24190,24210,24230,24250,24270,24290,24310,24330,24350,24370,24390,24410,24430,24450,24470,24490,24510,24530,24550,24570,24590,24610,24630,24650,24670,24690,24710,24730,24750,24770,24790,24810,24830,24850,24870,24890,24910,24930,24950,24970,24990,25010,25030,25050,25070,25090,25110,25130,25150,25170,25190,25210,25230,25250,25270,25290,25310,25330,25350,25370,25390,25410,25430,25450,25470,25490,25510,25530,25550,25570,25590,25610,25630,25650,25670,25690,25710,25730,25750,25770,25790,25810,25830,25850,25870,25890,25910,25930,25950,25970,25990,26010,26030,26050,26070,26090,26110,26130,26150,26170,26190,26210,26230,26250,26270,26290,26310,26330,26350,26370,26390,26410,26430,26450,26470,26490,26510,26530,26550,26570,26590,26610,26630,26650,26670,26690,26710,26730,26750,26770,26790,26810,26830,26850,26870,26890,26910,26930,26950,26970,26990,27010,27030,27050,27070,27090,27110,27130,27150,27170,27190,27210,27230,27250,27270,27290,27310,27330,27350,27370,27390,27410,27430,27450,27470,27490,27510,27530,27550,27570,27590,27610,27630,27650,27670,27690,27710,27730,27750,27770,27790,27810,27830,27850,27870,27890,27910,27930,27950,27970,27990,28010,28030,28050,28070,28090,28110,28130,28150,28170,28190,28210,28230,28250,28270,28290,28310,28330,28350,28370,28390,28410,28430,28450,28470,28490,28510,28530,28550,28570,28590,28610,28630,28650,28670,28690,28710,28730,28750,28770,28790,28810,28830,28850,28870,28890,28910,28930,28950,28970,28990,29010,29030,29050,29070,29090,29110,29130,29150,29170,29190,29210,29230,29250,29270,29290,29310,29330,29350,29370,29390,29410,29430,29450,29470,29490,29510,29530,29550,29570,29590,29610,29630,29650,29670,29690,29710,29730,29750,29770,29790,29810,29830,29850,29870,29890,29910,29930,29950,29970,29990,30010,30030,30050,30070,30090,30110,30130,30150,30170,30190,30210,30230],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,20000,20020,20040,20060,20080,20100,20120,20140,20160,20180,20200,20220,20240,20260,20280,20300,20320,20340,20360,20380,20400,20420,20440,20460,20480,20500,20520,20540,20560,20580,20600,20620,20640,20660,20680,20700,20720,20740,20760,20780,20800,20820,20840,20860,20880,20900,20920,20940,20960,20980,21000,21020,21040,21060,21080,21100,21120,21140,21160,21180,21200,21220,21240,21260,21280,21300,21320,21340,21360,21380,21400,21420,21440,21460,21480,21500,21520,21540,21560,21580,21600,21620,21640,21660,21680,21700,21720,21740,21760,21780,21800,21820,21840,21860,21880,21900,21920,21940,21960,21980,22000,22020,22040,22060,22080,22100,22120,22140,22160,22180,22200,22220,22240,22260,22280,22300,22320,22340,22360,22380,22400,22420,22440,22460,22480,22500,22520,22540,22560,22580,22600,22620,22640,22660,22680,22700,22720,22740,22760,22780,22800,22820,22840,22860,22880,22900,22920,22940,22960,22980,23000,23020,23040,23060,23080,23100,23120,23140,23160,23180,23200,23220,23240,23260,23280,23300,23320,23340,23360,23380,23400,23420,23440,23460,23480,23500,23520,23540,23560,23580,23600,23620,23640,23660,23680,23700,23720,23740,23760,23780,23800,23820,23840,23860,23880,23900,23920,23940,23960,23980,24000,24020,24040,24060,24080,24100,24120,24140,24160,24180,24200,24220,24240,24260,24280,24300,24320,24340,24360,24380,24400,24420,24440,24460,24480,24500,24520,24540,24560,24580,24600,24620,24640,24660,24680,24700,24720,24740,24760,24780,24800,24820,24840,24860,24880,24900,24920,24940,24960,24980,25000,25020,25040,25060,25080,25100,25120,25140,25160,25180,25200,25220,25240,25260,25280,25300,25320,25340,25360,25380,25400,25420,25440,25460,25480,25500,25520,25540,25560,25580,25600,25620,25640,25660,25680,25700,25720,25740,25760,25780,25800,25820,25840,25860,25880,25900,25920,25940,25960,25980,26000,26020,26040,26060,26080,26100,26120,26140,26160,26180,26200,26220,26240,26260,26280,26300,26320,26340,26360,26380,26400,26420,26440,26460,26480,26500,26520,26540,26560,26580,26600,26620,26640,26660,26680,26700,26720,26740,26760,26780,26800,26820,26840,26860,26880,26900,26920,26940,26960,26980,27000,27020,27040,27060,27080,27100,27120,27140,27160,27180,27200,27220,27240,27260,27280,27300,27320,27340,27360,27380,27400,27420,27440,27460,27480,27500,27520,27540,27560,27580,27600,27620,27640,27660,27680,27700,27720,27740,27760,27780,27800,27820,27840,27860,27880,27900,27920,27940,27960,27980,28000,28020,28040,28060,28080,28100,28120,28140,28160,28180,28200,28220,28240,28260,28280,28300,28320,28340,28360,28380,28400,28420,28440,28460,28480,28500,28520,28540,28560,28580,28600,28620,28640,28660,28680,28700,28720,28740,28760,28780,28800,28820,28840,28860,28880,28900,28920,28940,28960,28980,29000,29020,29040,29060,29080,29100,29120,29140,29160,29180,29200,29220,29240,29260,29280,29300,29320,29340,29360,29380,29400,29420,29440,29460,29480,29500,29520,29540,29560,29580,29600,29620,29640,29660,29680,29700,29720,29740,29760,29780,29800,29820,29840,29860,29880,29900,29920,29940,29960,29980],"target":[[0,120],[75,100],[175,80],[225,60],[250,40],[273,80],[341,120],[365,160],[390,200],[415,160],[815,140],[1140,120],[1415,100]],"lateness":[[0,0],[250,2],[251,4],[252,6],[253,8],[254,10],[255,12],[256,14],[257,16],[258,18],[259,20],[260,22],[261,24],[262,26],[263,28],[264,30],[265,32],[266,34],[267,36],[268,38],[269,40],[270,42],[271,44],[272,46],[273,48],[274,50],[275,52],[276,54],[277,56],[278,58],[279,60],[280,62],[281,64],[282,66],[283,68],[284,70],[285,72],[286,74],[287,76],[288,78],[289,80],[290,82],[291,84],[292,86],[293,88],[294,90],[295,92],[296,94],[297,96],[298,98],[299,100],[300,102],[301,104],[302,106],[303,108],[304,110],[305,112],[306,114],[307,116],[308,118],[309,120],[310,122],[311,124],[312,126],[313,128],[314,130],[315,132],[316,134],[317,136],[318,138],[319,140],[320,142],[321,144],[322,146],[323,148],[324,150],[325,152],[326,154],[327,156],[328,158],[329,160],[330,162],[331,164],[332,166],[333,168],[334,170],[335,172],[336,174],[337,176],[338,178],[339,180],[340,182],[341,184],[342,186],[343,188],[344,190],[345,192],[346,194],[347,196],[348,198],[349,200],[350,198],[351,196],[352,194],[353,192],[354,190],[355,188],[356,186],[357,184],[358,182],[359,180],[360,178],[361,176],[362,174],[363,172],[364,170],[365,168],[366,166],[367,164],[368,162],[369,160],[370,158],[371,156],[372,154],[373,152],[374,150],[375,148],[376,146],[377,144],[378,142],[379,140],[380,138],[381,136],[382,134],[383,132],[384,130],[385,128],[386,126],[387,124],[388,122],[389,120],[390,118],[391,116],[392,114],[393,112],[394,110],[395,108],[396,106],[397,104],[398,102],[399,100],[400,98],[401,96],[402,94],[403,92],[404,90],[405,88],[406,86],[407,84],[408,82],[409,80],[410,78],[411,76],[412,74],[413,72],[414,70],[415,68],[416,66],[417,64],[418,62],[419,60],[420,58],[421,56],[422,54],[423,52],[424,50],[425,48],[426,46],[427,44],[428,42],[429,40],[430,38],[431,36],[432,34],[433,32],[434,30],[435,28],[436,26],[437,24],[438,22],[439,20],[440,18],[441,16],[442,14],[443,12],[444,10],[445,8],[446,6],[447,4],[448,2],[449,0]]} diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/corpus.test.ts b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/corpus.test.ts index 93f7a19e366..7020b299fc0 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/corpus.test.ts +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/corpus.test.ts @@ -36,6 +36,10 @@ describe("audio jitter corpus", () => { expect(actual.target[0]?.[0]).toBe(0); }); + test("names a lateness for the first frame", () => { + expect(actual.lateness[0]?.[0]).toBe(0); + }); + test("reports every target as a change", () => { let previous: number | undefined; let last = -1; diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/corpus.ts b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/corpus.ts index 299328f8170..dac0cc35f25 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/corpus.ts +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/corpus.ts @@ -28,6 +28,8 @@ export interface Case { ends?: number[]; /** `[frame index, target]` wherever the target differs from the previous frame's. */ target: [number, number][]; + /** `[frame index, lateness]` wherever the lateness differs from the previous frame's. */ + lateness: [number, number][]; } type Trace = { arrival: number[]; media: number[] }; @@ -88,32 +90,32 @@ function paced(frames: number, frame: number, base: number): Trace { return flushed(frames, frame, 1, base); } -/** Replay a trace through the reference and keep only the frames where the target moved. */ +/** Replay a trace through the reference and keep only the frames where the target or lateness moved. */ function run( trace: Trace & { ends?: number[] }, config: { frame: number; advertised?: number; delay?: number }, -): [number, number][] { - if (config.delay !== undefined) return [[0, config.delay]]; +): Pick { + // A fixed target ignores the arrivals, so its band is not widened either. + if (config.delay !== undefined) return { target: [[0, config.delay]], lateness: [[0, 0]] }; const estimator = new Estimator({ frame: config.frame, advertised: config.advertised }); const target: [number, number][] = []; - let previous: number | undefined; + const lateness: [number, number][] = []; const ends = new Set(trace.ends); for (let i = 0; i < trace.arrival.length; i++) { if (ends.has(i)) estimator.end(); estimator.observe({ arrival: trace.arrival[i], media: trace.media[i] }); - const value = estimator.target; - if (value !== previous) target.push([i, value]); - previous = value; + if (estimator.target !== target.at(-1)?.[1]) target.push([i, estimator.target]); + if (estimator.lateness !== lateness.at(-1)?.[1]) lateness.push([i, estimator.lateness]); } - return target; + return { target, lateness }; } const FRAME = 20; -const traces: Omit[] = [ +const traces: Omit[] = [ { name: "paced", about: "A perfectly even sender for 60 s, long enough to leave the cold-start ramp. The target settles on one bucket plus one frame, which is the floor the estimator can report.", @@ -237,7 +239,7 @@ const traces: Omit[] = [ }, ]; -export const cases: Case[] = traces.map((trace) => ({ ...trace, target: run(trace, trace) })); +export const cases: Case[] = traces.map((trace) => ({ ...trace, ...run(trace, trace) })); if (import.meta.main) { const here = dirname(fileURLToPath(import.meta.url)); diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/fixed.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/fixed.json index 2c1309b6322..46de52fb57a 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/fixed.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/fixed.json @@ -1 +1 @@ -{"name":"fixed","about":"An explicit 250 ms target over the bursty trace. Adaptation is off: the target is what was asked for, whatever the arrivals say.","frame":20,"delay":250,"arrival":[130,130,130,130,130,230,230,230,230,230,330,330,330,330,330,430,430,430,430,430,530,530,530,530,530,630,630,630,630,630,730,730,730,730,730,830,830,830,830,830,930,930,930,930,930,1030,1030,1030,1030,1030,1130,1130,1130,1130,1130,1230,1230,1230,1230,1230,1330,1330,1330,1330,1330,1430,1430,1430,1430,1430,1530,1530,1530,1530,1530,1630,1630,1630,1630,1630,1730,1730,1730,1730,1730,1830,1830,1830,1830,1830,1930,1930,1930,1930,1930,2030,2030,2030,2030,2030,2130,2130,2130,2130,2130,2230,2230,2230,2230,2230,2330,2330,2330,2330,2330,2430,2430,2430,2430,2430,2530,2530,2530,2530,2530,2630,2630,2630,2630,2630,2730,2730,2730,2730,2730,2830,2830,2830,2830,2830,2930,2930,2930,2930,2930,3030,3030,3030,3030,3030,3130,3130,3130,3130,3130,3230,3230,3230,3230,3230,3330,3330,3330,3330,3330,3430,3430,3430,3430,3430,3530,3530,3530,3530,3530,3630,3630,3630,3630,3630,3730,3730,3730,3730,3730,3830,3830,3830,3830,3830,3930,3930,3930,3930,3930,4030,4030,4030,4030,4030,4130,4130,4130,4130,4130,4230,4230,4230,4230,4230,4330,4330,4330,4330,4330,4430,4430,4430,4430,4430,4530,4530,4530,4530,4530,4630,4630,4630,4630,4630,4730,4730,4730,4730,4730,4830,4830,4830,4830,4830,4930,4930,4930,4930,4930,5030,5030,5030,5030,5030,5130,5130,5130,5130,5130,5230,5230,5230,5230,5230,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5430,5430,5430,5430,5430,5530,5530,5530,5530,5530,5630,5630,5630,5630,5630,5730,5730,5730,5730,5730,5830,5830,5830,5830,5830,5930,5930,5930,5930,5930,6030,6030,6030,6030,6030,6130,6130,6130,6130,6130,6230,6230,6230,6230,6230,6330,6330,6330,6330,6330,6430,6430,6430,6430,6430,6530,6530,6530,6530,6530,6630,6630,6630,6630,6630,6730,6730,6730,6730,6730,6830,6830,6830,6830,6830,6930,6930,6930,6930,6930,7030,7030,7030,7030,7030,7130,7130,7130,7130,7130,7230,7230,7230,7230,7230,7330,7330,7330,7330,7330,7430,7430,7430,7430,7430,7530,7530,7530,7530,7530,7630,7630,7630,7630,7630,7730,7730,7730,7730,7730,7830,7830,7830,7830,7830,7930,7930,7930,7930,7930,8030,8030,8030,8030,8030,8130,8130,8130,8130,8130,8230,8230,8230,8230,8230,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8430,8430,8430,8430,8430,8530,8530,8530,8530,8530,8630,8630,8630,8630,8630,8730,8730,8730,8730,8730,8830,8830,8830,8830,8830,8930,8930,8930,8930,8930,9030,9030,9030,9030,9030,9130,9130,9130,9130,9130,9230,9230,9230,9230,9230,9330,9330,9330,9330,9330,9430,9430,9430,9430,9430,9530,9530,9530,9530,9530,9630,9630,9630,9630,9630,9730,9730,9730,9730,9730,9830,9830,9830,9830,9830,9930,9930,9930,9930,9930,10030,10030,10030,10030,10030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980],"target":[[0,250]]} +{"name":"fixed","about":"An explicit 250 ms target over the bursty trace. Adaptation is off: the target is what was asked for, whatever the arrivals say.","frame":20,"delay":250,"arrival":[130,130,130,130,130,230,230,230,230,230,330,330,330,330,330,430,430,430,430,430,530,530,530,530,530,630,630,630,630,630,730,730,730,730,730,830,830,830,830,830,930,930,930,930,930,1030,1030,1030,1030,1030,1130,1130,1130,1130,1130,1230,1230,1230,1230,1230,1330,1330,1330,1330,1330,1430,1430,1430,1430,1430,1530,1530,1530,1530,1530,1630,1630,1630,1630,1630,1730,1730,1730,1730,1730,1830,1830,1830,1830,1830,1930,1930,1930,1930,1930,2030,2030,2030,2030,2030,2130,2130,2130,2130,2130,2230,2230,2230,2230,2230,2330,2330,2330,2330,2330,2430,2430,2430,2430,2430,2530,2530,2530,2530,2530,2630,2630,2630,2630,2630,2730,2730,2730,2730,2730,2830,2830,2830,2830,2830,2930,2930,2930,2930,2930,3030,3030,3030,3030,3030,3130,3130,3130,3130,3130,3230,3230,3230,3230,3230,3330,3330,3330,3330,3330,3430,3430,3430,3430,3430,3530,3530,3530,3530,3530,3630,3630,3630,3630,3630,3730,3730,3730,3730,3730,3830,3830,3830,3830,3830,3930,3930,3930,3930,3930,4030,4030,4030,4030,4030,4130,4130,4130,4130,4130,4230,4230,4230,4230,4230,4330,4330,4330,4330,4330,4430,4430,4430,4430,4430,4530,4530,4530,4530,4530,4630,4630,4630,4630,4630,4730,4730,4730,4730,4730,4830,4830,4830,4830,4830,4930,4930,4930,4930,4930,5030,5030,5030,5030,5030,5130,5130,5130,5130,5130,5230,5230,5230,5230,5230,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5430,5430,5430,5430,5430,5530,5530,5530,5530,5530,5630,5630,5630,5630,5630,5730,5730,5730,5730,5730,5830,5830,5830,5830,5830,5930,5930,5930,5930,5930,6030,6030,6030,6030,6030,6130,6130,6130,6130,6130,6230,6230,6230,6230,6230,6330,6330,6330,6330,6330,6430,6430,6430,6430,6430,6530,6530,6530,6530,6530,6630,6630,6630,6630,6630,6730,6730,6730,6730,6730,6830,6830,6830,6830,6830,6930,6930,6930,6930,6930,7030,7030,7030,7030,7030,7130,7130,7130,7130,7130,7230,7230,7230,7230,7230,7330,7330,7330,7330,7330,7430,7430,7430,7430,7430,7530,7530,7530,7530,7530,7630,7630,7630,7630,7630,7730,7730,7730,7730,7730,7830,7830,7830,7830,7830,7930,7930,7930,7930,7930,8030,8030,8030,8030,8030,8130,8130,8130,8130,8130,8230,8230,8230,8230,8230,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8430,8430,8430,8430,8430,8530,8530,8530,8530,8530,8630,8630,8630,8630,8630,8730,8730,8730,8730,8730,8830,8830,8830,8830,8830,8930,8930,8930,8930,8930,9030,9030,9030,9030,9030,9130,9130,9130,9130,9130,9230,9230,9230,9230,9230,9330,9330,9330,9330,9330,9430,9430,9430,9430,9430,9530,9530,9530,9530,9530,9630,9630,9630,9630,9630,9730,9730,9730,9730,9730,9830,9830,9830,9830,9830,9930,9930,9930,9930,9930,10030,10030,10030,10030,10030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980],"target":[[0,250]],"lateness":[[0,0]]} diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/flush.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/flush.json index f649af7a2c8..42c6d3331cb 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/flush.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/flush.json @@ -1 +1 @@ -{"name":"flush","about":"A sender flushing 100 ms of media at a time, then 200 ms from halfway. The measured term follows the flush span less one frame, which is what the round-trip formula could not see.","frame":20,"arrival":[130,130,130,130,130,230,230,230,230,230,330,330,330,330,330,430,430,430,430,430,530,530,530,530,530,630,630,630,630,630,730,730,730,730,730,830,830,830,830,830,930,930,930,930,930,1030,1030,1030,1030,1030,1130,1130,1130,1130,1130,1230,1230,1230,1230,1230,1330,1330,1330,1330,1330,1430,1430,1430,1430,1430,1530,1530,1530,1530,1530,1630,1630,1630,1630,1630,1730,1730,1730,1730,1730,1830,1830,1830,1830,1830,1930,1930,1930,1930,1930,2030,2030,2030,2030,2030,2130,2130,2130,2130,2130,2230,2230,2230,2230,2230,2330,2330,2330,2330,2330,2430,2430,2430,2430,2430,2530,2530,2530,2530,2530,2630,2630,2630,2630,2630,2730,2730,2730,2730,2730,2830,2830,2830,2830,2830,2930,2930,2930,2930,2930,3030,3030,3030,3030,3030,3130,3130,3130,3130,3130,3230,3230,3230,3230,3230,3330,3330,3330,3330,3330,3430,3430,3430,3430,3430,3530,3530,3530,3530,3530,3630,3630,3630,3630,3630,3730,3730,3730,3730,3730,3830,3830,3830,3830,3830,3930,3930,3930,3930,3930,4030,4030,4030,4030,4030,4130,4130,4130,4130,4130,4230,4230,4230,4230,4230,4330,4330,4330,4330,4330,4430,4430,4430,4430,4430,4530,4530,4530,4530,4530,4630,4630,4630,4630,4630,4730,4730,4730,4730,4730,4830,4830,4830,4830,4830,4930,4930,4930,4930,4930,5030,5030,5030,5030,5030,5130,5130,5130,5130,5130,5230,5230,5230,5230,5230,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5430,5430,5430,5430,5430,5530,5530,5530,5530,5530,5630,5630,5630,5630,5630,5730,5730,5730,5730,5730,5830,5830,5830,5830,5830,5930,5930,5930,5930,5930,6030,6030,6030,6030,6030,6130,6130,6130,6130,6130,6230,6230,6230,6230,6230,6330,6330,6330,6330,6330,6430,6430,6430,6430,6430,6530,6530,6530,6530,6530,6630,6630,6630,6630,6630,6730,6730,6730,6730,6730,6830,6830,6830,6830,6830,6930,6930,6930,6930,6930,7030,7030,7030,7030,7030,7130,7130,7130,7130,7130,7230,7230,7230,7230,7230,7330,7330,7330,7330,7330,7430,7430,7430,7430,7430,7530,7530,7530,7530,7530,7630,7630,7630,7630,7630,7730,7730,7730,7730,7730,7830,7830,7830,7830,7830,7930,7930,7930,7930,7930,8030,8030,8030,8030,8030,8130,8130,8130,8130,8130,8230,8230,8230,8230,8230,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8430,8430,8430,8430,8430,8530,8530,8530,8530,8530,8630,8630,8630,8630,8630,8730,8730,8730,8730,8730,8830,8830,8830,8830,8830,8930,8930,8930,8930,8930,9030,9030,9030,9030,9030,9130,9130,9130,9130,9130,9230,9230,9230,9230,9230,9330,9330,9330,9330,9330,9430,9430,9430,9430,9430,9530,9530,9530,9530,9530,9630,9630,9630,9630,9630,9730,9730,9730,9730,9730,9830,9830,9830,9830,9830,9930,9930,9930,9930,9930,10030,10030,10030,10030,10030,10230,10230,10230,10230,10230,10230,10230,10230,10230,10230,10430,10430,10430,10430,10430,10430,10430,10430,10430,10430,10630,10630,10630,10630,10630,10630,10630,10630,10630,10630,10830,10830,10830,10830,10830,10830,10830,10830,10830,10830,11030,11030,11030,11030,11030,11030,11030,11030,11030,11030,11230,11230,11230,11230,11230,11230,11230,11230,11230,11230,11430,11430,11430,11430,11430,11430,11430,11430,11430,11430,11630,11630,11630,11630,11630,11630,11630,11630,11630,11630,11830,11830,11830,11830,11830,11830,11830,11830,11830,11830,12030,12030,12030,12030,12030,12030,12030,12030,12030,12030,12230,12230,12230,12230,12230,12230,12230,12230,12230,12230,12430,12430,12430,12430,12430,12430,12430,12430,12430,12430,12630,12630,12630,12630,12630,12630,12630,12630,12630,12630,12830,12830,12830,12830,12830,12830,12830,12830,12830,12830,13030,13030,13030,13030,13030,13030,13030,13030,13030,13030,13230,13230,13230,13230,13230,13230,13230,13230,13230,13230,13430,13430,13430,13430,13430,13430,13430,13430,13430,13430,13630,13630,13630,13630,13630,13630,13630,13630,13630,13630,13830,13830,13830,13830,13830,13830,13830,13830,13830,13830,14030,14030,14030,14030,14030,14030,14030,14030,14030,14030,14230,14230,14230,14230,14230,14230,14230,14230,14230,14230,14430,14430,14430,14430,14430,14430,14430,14430,14430,14430,14630,14630,14630,14630,14630,14630,14630,14630,14630,14630,14830,14830,14830,14830,14830,14830,14830,14830,14830,14830,15030,15030,15030,15030,15030,15030,15030,15030,15030,15030,15230,15230,15230,15230,15230,15230,15230,15230,15230,15230,15430,15430,15430,15430,15430,15430,15430,15430,15430,15430,15630,15630,15630,15630,15630,15630,15630,15630,15630,15630,15830,15830,15830,15830,15830,15830,15830,15830,15830,15830,16030,16030,16030,16030,16030,16030,16030,16030,16030,16030,16230,16230,16230,16230,16230,16230,16230,16230,16230,16230,16430,16430,16430,16430,16430,16430,16430,16430,16430,16430,16630,16630,16630,16630,16630,16630,16630,16630,16630,16630,16830,16830,16830,16830,16830,16830,16830,16830,16830,16830,17030,17030,17030,17030,17030,17030,17030,17030,17030,17030,17230,17230,17230,17230,17230,17230,17230,17230,17230,17230,17430,17430,17430,17430,17430,17430,17430,17430,17430,17430,17630,17630,17630,17630,17630,17630,17630,17630,17630,17630,17830,17830,17830,17830,17830,17830,17830,17830,17830,17830,18030,18030,18030,18030,18030,18030,18030,18030,18030,18030,18230,18230,18230,18230,18230,18230,18230,18230,18230,18230,18430,18430,18430,18430,18430,18430,18430,18430,18430,18430,18630,18630,18630,18630,18630,18630,18630,18630,18630,18630,18830,18830,18830,18830,18830,18830,18830,18830,18830,18830,19030,19030,19030,19030,19030,19030,19030,19030,19030,19030,19230,19230,19230,19230,19230,19230,19230,19230,19230,19230,19430,19430,19430,19430,19430,19430,19430,19430,19430,19430,19630,19630,19630,19630,19630,19630,19630,19630,19630,19630,19830,19830,19830,19830,19830,19830,19830,19830,19830,19830,20030,20030,20030,20030,20030,20030,20030,20030,20030,20030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980],"target":[[0,120],[570,220]]} +{"name":"flush","about":"A sender flushing 100 ms of media at a time, then 200 ms from halfway. The measured term follows the flush span less one frame, which is what the round-trip formula could not see.","frame":20,"arrival":[130,130,130,130,130,230,230,230,230,230,330,330,330,330,330,430,430,430,430,430,530,530,530,530,530,630,630,630,630,630,730,730,730,730,730,830,830,830,830,830,930,930,930,930,930,1030,1030,1030,1030,1030,1130,1130,1130,1130,1130,1230,1230,1230,1230,1230,1330,1330,1330,1330,1330,1430,1430,1430,1430,1430,1530,1530,1530,1530,1530,1630,1630,1630,1630,1630,1730,1730,1730,1730,1730,1830,1830,1830,1830,1830,1930,1930,1930,1930,1930,2030,2030,2030,2030,2030,2130,2130,2130,2130,2130,2230,2230,2230,2230,2230,2330,2330,2330,2330,2330,2430,2430,2430,2430,2430,2530,2530,2530,2530,2530,2630,2630,2630,2630,2630,2730,2730,2730,2730,2730,2830,2830,2830,2830,2830,2930,2930,2930,2930,2930,3030,3030,3030,3030,3030,3130,3130,3130,3130,3130,3230,3230,3230,3230,3230,3330,3330,3330,3330,3330,3430,3430,3430,3430,3430,3530,3530,3530,3530,3530,3630,3630,3630,3630,3630,3730,3730,3730,3730,3730,3830,3830,3830,3830,3830,3930,3930,3930,3930,3930,4030,4030,4030,4030,4030,4130,4130,4130,4130,4130,4230,4230,4230,4230,4230,4330,4330,4330,4330,4330,4430,4430,4430,4430,4430,4530,4530,4530,4530,4530,4630,4630,4630,4630,4630,4730,4730,4730,4730,4730,4830,4830,4830,4830,4830,4930,4930,4930,4930,4930,5030,5030,5030,5030,5030,5130,5130,5130,5130,5130,5230,5230,5230,5230,5230,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5430,5430,5430,5430,5430,5530,5530,5530,5530,5530,5630,5630,5630,5630,5630,5730,5730,5730,5730,5730,5830,5830,5830,5830,5830,5930,5930,5930,5930,5930,6030,6030,6030,6030,6030,6130,6130,6130,6130,6130,6230,6230,6230,6230,6230,6330,6330,6330,6330,6330,6430,6430,6430,6430,6430,6530,6530,6530,6530,6530,6630,6630,6630,6630,6630,6730,6730,6730,6730,6730,6830,6830,6830,6830,6830,6930,6930,6930,6930,6930,7030,7030,7030,7030,7030,7130,7130,7130,7130,7130,7230,7230,7230,7230,7230,7330,7330,7330,7330,7330,7430,7430,7430,7430,7430,7530,7530,7530,7530,7530,7630,7630,7630,7630,7630,7730,7730,7730,7730,7730,7830,7830,7830,7830,7830,7930,7930,7930,7930,7930,8030,8030,8030,8030,8030,8130,8130,8130,8130,8130,8230,8230,8230,8230,8230,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8430,8430,8430,8430,8430,8530,8530,8530,8530,8530,8630,8630,8630,8630,8630,8730,8730,8730,8730,8730,8830,8830,8830,8830,8830,8930,8930,8930,8930,8930,9030,9030,9030,9030,9030,9130,9130,9130,9130,9130,9230,9230,9230,9230,9230,9330,9330,9330,9330,9330,9430,9430,9430,9430,9430,9530,9530,9530,9530,9530,9630,9630,9630,9630,9630,9730,9730,9730,9730,9730,9830,9830,9830,9830,9830,9930,9930,9930,9930,9930,10030,10030,10030,10030,10030,10230,10230,10230,10230,10230,10230,10230,10230,10230,10230,10430,10430,10430,10430,10430,10430,10430,10430,10430,10430,10630,10630,10630,10630,10630,10630,10630,10630,10630,10630,10830,10830,10830,10830,10830,10830,10830,10830,10830,10830,11030,11030,11030,11030,11030,11030,11030,11030,11030,11030,11230,11230,11230,11230,11230,11230,11230,11230,11230,11230,11430,11430,11430,11430,11430,11430,11430,11430,11430,11430,11630,11630,11630,11630,11630,11630,11630,11630,11630,11630,11830,11830,11830,11830,11830,11830,11830,11830,11830,11830,12030,12030,12030,12030,12030,12030,12030,12030,12030,12030,12230,12230,12230,12230,12230,12230,12230,12230,12230,12230,12430,12430,12430,12430,12430,12430,12430,12430,12430,12430,12630,12630,12630,12630,12630,12630,12630,12630,12630,12630,12830,12830,12830,12830,12830,12830,12830,12830,12830,12830,13030,13030,13030,13030,13030,13030,13030,13030,13030,13030,13230,13230,13230,13230,13230,13230,13230,13230,13230,13230,13430,13430,13430,13430,13430,13430,13430,13430,13430,13430,13630,13630,13630,13630,13630,13630,13630,13630,13630,13630,13830,13830,13830,13830,13830,13830,13830,13830,13830,13830,14030,14030,14030,14030,14030,14030,14030,14030,14030,14030,14230,14230,14230,14230,14230,14230,14230,14230,14230,14230,14430,14430,14430,14430,14430,14430,14430,14430,14430,14430,14630,14630,14630,14630,14630,14630,14630,14630,14630,14630,14830,14830,14830,14830,14830,14830,14830,14830,14830,14830,15030,15030,15030,15030,15030,15030,15030,15030,15030,15030,15230,15230,15230,15230,15230,15230,15230,15230,15230,15230,15430,15430,15430,15430,15430,15430,15430,15430,15430,15430,15630,15630,15630,15630,15630,15630,15630,15630,15630,15630,15830,15830,15830,15830,15830,15830,15830,15830,15830,15830,16030,16030,16030,16030,16030,16030,16030,16030,16030,16030,16230,16230,16230,16230,16230,16230,16230,16230,16230,16230,16430,16430,16430,16430,16430,16430,16430,16430,16430,16430,16630,16630,16630,16630,16630,16630,16630,16630,16630,16630,16830,16830,16830,16830,16830,16830,16830,16830,16830,16830,17030,17030,17030,17030,17030,17030,17030,17030,17030,17030,17230,17230,17230,17230,17230,17230,17230,17230,17230,17230,17430,17430,17430,17430,17430,17430,17430,17430,17430,17430,17630,17630,17630,17630,17630,17630,17630,17630,17630,17630,17830,17830,17830,17830,17830,17830,17830,17830,17830,17830,18030,18030,18030,18030,18030,18030,18030,18030,18030,18030,18230,18230,18230,18230,18230,18230,18230,18230,18230,18230,18430,18430,18430,18430,18430,18430,18430,18430,18430,18430,18630,18630,18630,18630,18630,18630,18630,18630,18630,18630,18830,18830,18830,18830,18830,18830,18830,18830,18830,18830,19030,19030,19030,19030,19030,19030,19030,19030,19030,19030,19230,19230,19230,19230,19230,19230,19230,19230,19230,19230,19430,19430,19430,19430,19430,19430,19430,19430,19430,19430,19630,19630,19630,19630,19630,19630,19630,19630,19630,19630,19830,19830,19830,19830,19830,19830,19830,19830,19830,19830,20030,20030,20030,20030,20030,20030,20030,20030,20030,20030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980],"target":[[0,120],[570,220]],"lateness":[[0,0],[1,20],[2,40],[3,60],[4,80],[500,180]]} diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/idle.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/idle.json index a9bf341d439..59d020e2f34 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/idle.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/idle.json @@ -1 +1 @@ -{"name":"idle","about":"A 30 s gap in both clocks, as a suspended tab produces. The idle intervals relax the histogram back toward the prior rather than freezing it.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,40050,40070,40090,40110,40130,40150,40170,40190,40210,40230,40250,40270,40290,40310,40330,40350,40370,40390,40410,40430,40450,40470,40490,40510,40530,40550,40570,40590,40610,40630,40650,40670,40690,40710,40730,40750,40770,40790,40810,40830,40850,40870,40890,40910,40930,40950,40970,40990,41010,41030,41050,41070,41090,41110,41130,41150,41170,41190,41210,41230,41250,41270,41290,41310,41330,41350,41370,41390,41410,41430,41450,41470,41490,41510,41530,41550,41570,41590,41610,41630,41650,41670,41690,41710,41730,41750,41770,41790,41810,41830,41850,41870,41890,41910,41930,41950,41970,41990,42010,42030,42050,42070,42090,42110,42130,42150,42170,42190,42210,42230,42250,42270,42290,42310,42330,42350,42370,42390,42410,42430,42450,42470,42490,42510,42530,42550,42570,42590,42610,42630,42650,42670,42690,42710,42730,42750,42770,42790,42810,42830,42850,42870,42890,42910,42930,42950,42970,42990,43010,43030,43050,43070,43090,43110,43130,43150,43170,43190,43210,43230,43250,43270,43290,43310,43330,43350,43370,43390,43410,43430,43450,43470,43490,43510,43530,43550,43570,43590,43610,43630,43650,43670,43690,43710,43730,43750,43770,43790,43810,43830,43850,43870,43890,43910,43930,43950,43970,43990,44010,44030,44050,44070,44090,44110,44130,44150,44170,44190,44210,44230,44250,44270,44290,44310,44330,44350,44370,44390,44410,44430,44450,44470,44490,44510,44530,44550,44570,44590,44610,44630,44650,44670,44690,44710,44730,44750,44770,44790,44810,44830,44850,44870,44890,44910,44930,44950,44970,44990,45010,45030,45050,45070,45090,45110,45130,45150,45170,45190,45210,45230,45250,45270,45290,45310,45330,45350,45370,45390,45410,45430,45450,45470,45490,45510,45530,45550,45570,45590,45610,45630,45650,45670,45690,45710,45730,45750,45770,45790,45810,45830,45850,45870,45890,45910,45930,45950,45970,45990,46010,46030,46050,46070,46090,46110,46130,46150,46170,46190,46210,46230,46250,46270,46290,46310,46330,46350,46370,46390,46410,46430,46450,46470,46490,46510,46530,46550,46570,46590,46610,46630,46650,46670,46690,46710,46730,46750,46770,46790,46810,46830,46850,46870,46890,46910,46930,46950,46970,46990,47010,47030,47050,47070,47090,47110,47130,47150,47170,47190,47210,47230,47250,47270,47290,47310,47330,47350,47370,47390,47410,47430,47450,47470,47490,47510,47530,47550,47570,47590,47610,47630,47650,47670,47690,47710,47730,47750,47770,47790,47810,47830,47850,47870,47890,47910,47930,47950,47970,47990,48010,48030,48050,48070,48090,48110,48130,48150,48170,48190,48210,48230,48250,48270,48290,48310,48330,48350,48370,48390,48410,48430,48450,48470,48490,48510,48530,48550,48570,48590,48610,48630,48650,48670,48690,48710,48730,48750,48770,48790,48810,48830,48850,48870,48890,48910,48930,48950,48970,48990,49010,49030,49050,49070,49090,49110,49130,49150,49170,49190,49210,49230,49250,49270,49290,49310,49330,49350,49370,49390,49410,49430,49450,49470,49490,49510,49530,49550,49570,49590,49610,49630,49650,49670,49690,49710,49730,49750,49770,49790,49810,49830,49850,49870,49890,49910,49930,49950,49970,49990,50010,50030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,40000,40020,40040,40060,40080,40100,40120,40140,40160,40180,40200,40220,40240,40260,40280,40300,40320,40340,40360,40380,40400,40420,40440,40460,40480,40500,40520,40540,40560,40580,40600,40620,40640,40660,40680,40700,40720,40740,40760,40780,40800,40820,40840,40860,40880,40900,40920,40940,40960,40980,41000,41020,41040,41060,41080,41100,41120,41140,41160,41180,41200,41220,41240,41260,41280,41300,41320,41340,41360,41380,41400,41420,41440,41460,41480,41500,41520,41540,41560,41580,41600,41620,41640,41660,41680,41700,41720,41740,41760,41780,41800,41820,41840,41860,41880,41900,41920,41940,41960,41980,42000,42020,42040,42060,42080,42100,42120,42140,42160,42180,42200,42220,42240,42260,42280,42300,42320,42340,42360,42380,42400,42420,42440,42460,42480,42500,42520,42540,42560,42580,42600,42620,42640,42660,42680,42700,42720,42740,42760,42780,42800,42820,42840,42860,42880,42900,42920,42940,42960,42980,43000,43020,43040,43060,43080,43100,43120,43140,43160,43180,43200,43220,43240,43260,43280,43300,43320,43340,43360,43380,43400,43420,43440,43460,43480,43500,43520,43540,43560,43580,43600,43620,43640,43660,43680,43700,43720,43740,43760,43780,43800,43820,43840,43860,43880,43900,43920,43940,43960,43980,44000,44020,44040,44060,44080,44100,44120,44140,44160,44180,44200,44220,44240,44260,44280,44300,44320,44340,44360,44380,44400,44420,44440,44460,44480,44500,44520,44540,44560,44580,44600,44620,44640,44660,44680,44700,44720,44740,44760,44780,44800,44820,44840,44860,44880,44900,44920,44940,44960,44980,45000,45020,45040,45060,45080,45100,45120,45140,45160,45180,45200,45220,45240,45260,45280,45300,45320,45340,45360,45380,45400,45420,45440,45460,45480,45500,45520,45540,45560,45580,45600,45620,45640,45660,45680,45700,45720,45740,45760,45780,45800,45820,45840,45860,45880,45900,45920,45940,45960,45980,46000,46020,46040,46060,46080,46100,46120,46140,46160,46180,46200,46220,46240,46260,46280,46300,46320,46340,46360,46380,46400,46420,46440,46460,46480,46500,46520,46540,46560,46580,46600,46620,46640,46660,46680,46700,46720,46740,46760,46780,46800,46820,46840,46860,46880,46900,46920,46940,46960,46980,47000,47020,47040,47060,47080,47100,47120,47140,47160,47180,47200,47220,47240,47260,47280,47300,47320,47340,47360,47380,47400,47420,47440,47460,47480,47500,47520,47540,47560,47580,47600,47620,47640,47660,47680,47700,47720,47740,47760,47780,47800,47820,47840,47860,47880,47900,47920,47940,47960,47980,48000,48020,48040,48060,48080,48100,48120,48140,48160,48180,48200,48220,48240,48260,48280,48300,48320,48340,48360,48380,48400,48420,48440,48460,48480,48500,48520,48540,48560,48580,48600,48620,48640,48660,48680,48700,48720,48740,48760,48780,48800,48820,48840,48860,48880,48900,48920,48940,48960,48980,49000,49020,49040,49060,49080,49100,49120,49140,49160,49180,49200,49220,49240,49260,49280,49300,49320,49340,49360,49380,49400,49420,49440,49460,49480,49500,49520,49540,49560,49580,49600,49620,49640,49660,49680,49700,49720,49740,49760,49780,49800,49820,49840,49860,49880,49900,49920,49940,49960,49980],"target":[[0,120],[75,100],[175,80],[225,60],[250,40],[500,100],[575,80],[625,60],[675,40]]} +{"name":"idle","about":"A 30 s gap in both clocks, as a suspended tab produces. The idle intervals relax the histogram back toward the prior rather than freezing it.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,40050,40070,40090,40110,40130,40150,40170,40190,40210,40230,40250,40270,40290,40310,40330,40350,40370,40390,40410,40430,40450,40470,40490,40510,40530,40550,40570,40590,40610,40630,40650,40670,40690,40710,40730,40750,40770,40790,40810,40830,40850,40870,40890,40910,40930,40950,40970,40990,41010,41030,41050,41070,41090,41110,41130,41150,41170,41190,41210,41230,41250,41270,41290,41310,41330,41350,41370,41390,41410,41430,41450,41470,41490,41510,41530,41550,41570,41590,41610,41630,41650,41670,41690,41710,41730,41750,41770,41790,41810,41830,41850,41870,41890,41910,41930,41950,41970,41990,42010,42030,42050,42070,42090,42110,42130,42150,42170,42190,42210,42230,42250,42270,42290,42310,42330,42350,42370,42390,42410,42430,42450,42470,42490,42510,42530,42550,42570,42590,42610,42630,42650,42670,42690,42710,42730,42750,42770,42790,42810,42830,42850,42870,42890,42910,42930,42950,42970,42990,43010,43030,43050,43070,43090,43110,43130,43150,43170,43190,43210,43230,43250,43270,43290,43310,43330,43350,43370,43390,43410,43430,43450,43470,43490,43510,43530,43550,43570,43590,43610,43630,43650,43670,43690,43710,43730,43750,43770,43790,43810,43830,43850,43870,43890,43910,43930,43950,43970,43990,44010,44030,44050,44070,44090,44110,44130,44150,44170,44190,44210,44230,44250,44270,44290,44310,44330,44350,44370,44390,44410,44430,44450,44470,44490,44510,44530,44550,44570,44590,44610,44630,44650,44670,44690,44710,44730,44750,44770,44790,44810,44830,44850,44870,44890,44910,44930,44950,44970,44990,45010,45030,45050,45070,45090,45110,45130,45150,45170,45190,45210,45230,45250,45270,45290,45310,45330,45350,45370,45390,45410,45430,45450,45470,45490,45510,45530,45550,45570,45590,45610,45630,45650,45670,45690,45710,45730,45750,45770,45790,45810,45830,45850,45870,45890,45910,45930,45950,45970,45990,46010,46030,46050,46070,46090,46110,46130,46150,46170,46190,46210,46230,46250,46270,46290,46310,46330,46350,46370,46390,46410,46430,46450,46470,46490,46510,46530,46550,46570,46590,46610,46630,46650,46670,46690,46710,46730,46750,46770,46790,46810,46830,46850,46870,46890,46910,46930,46950,46970,46990,47010,47030,47050,47070,47090,47110,47130,47150,47170,47190,47210,47230,47250,47270,47290,47310,47330,47350,47370,47390,47410,47430,47450,47470,47490,47510,47530,47550,47570,47590,47610,47630,47650,47670,47690,47710,47730,47750,47770,47790,47810,47830,47850,47870,47890,47910,47930,47950,47970,47990,48010,48030,48050,48070,48090,48110,48130,48150,48170,48190,48210,48230,48250,48270,48290,48310,48330,48350,48370,48390,48410,48430,48450,48470,48490,48510,48530,48550,48570,48590,48610,48630,48650,48670,48690,48710,48730,48750,48770,48790,48810,48830,48850,48870,48890,48910,48930,48950,48970,48990,49010,49030,49050,49070,49090,49110,49130,49150,49170,49190,49210,49230,49250,49270,49290,49310,49330,49350,49370,49390,49410,49430,49450,49470,49490,49510,49530,49550,49570,49590,49610,49630,49650,49670,49690,49710,49730,49750,49770,49790,49810,49830,49850,49870,49890,49910,49930,49950,49970,49990,50010,50030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,40000,40020,40040,40060,40080,40100,40120,40140,40160,40180,40200,40220,40240,40260,40280,40300,40320,40340,40360,40380,40400,40420,40440,40460,40480,40500,40520,40540,40560,40580,40600,40620,40640,40660,40680,40700,40720,40740,40760,40780,40800,40820,40840,40860,40880,40900,40920,40940,40960,40980,41000,41020,41040,41060,41080,41100,41120,41140,41160,41180,41200,41220,41240,41260,41280,41300,41320,41340,41360,41380,41400,41420,41440,41460,41480,41500,41520,41540,41560,41580,41600,41620,41640,41660,41680,41700,41720,41740,41760,41780,41800,41820,41840,41860,41880,41900,41920,41940,41960,41980,42000,42020,42040,42060,42080,42100,42120,42140,42160,42180,42200,42220,42240,42260,42280,42300,42320,42340,42360,42380,42400,42420,42440,42460,42480,42500,42520,42540,42560,42580,42600,42620,42640,42660,42680,42700,42720,42740,42760,42780,42800,42820,42840,42860,42880,42900,42920,42940,42960,42980,43000,43020,43040,43060,43080,43100,43120,43140,43160,43180,43200,43220,43240,43260,43280,43300,43320,43340,43360,43380,43400,43420,43440,43460,43480,43500,43520,43540,43560,43580,43600,43620,43640,43660,43680,43700,43720,43740,43760,43780,43800,43820,43840,43860,43880,43900,43920,43940,43960,43980,44000,44020,44040,44060,44080,44100,44120,44140,44160,44180,44200,44220,44240,44260,44280,44300,44320,44340,44360,44380,44400,44420,44440,44460,44480,44500,44520,44540,44560,44580,44600,44620,44640,44660,44680,44700,44720,44740,44760,44780,44800,44820,44840,44860,44880,44900,44920,44940,44960,44980,45000,45020,45040,45060,45080,45100,45120,45140,45160,45180,45200,45220,45240,45260,45280,45300,45320,45340,45360,45380,45400,45420,45440,45460,45480,45500,45520,45540,45560,45580,45600,45620,45640,45660,45680,45700,45720,45740,45760,45780,45800,45820,45840,45860,45880,45900,45920,45940,45960,45980,46000,46020,46040,46060,46080,46100,46120,46140,46160,46180,46200,46220,46240,46260,46280,46300,46320,46340,46360,46380,46400,46420,46440,46460,46480,46500,46520,46540,46560,46580,46600,46620,46640,46660,46680,46700,46720,46740,46760,46780,46800,46820,46840,46860,46880,46900,46920,46940,46960,46980,47000,47020,47040,47060,47080,47100,47120,47140,47160,47180,47200,47220,47240,47260,47280,47300,47320,47340,47360,47380,47400,47420,47440,47460,47480,47500,47520,47540,47560,47580,47600,47620,47640,47660,47680,47700,47720,47740,47760,47780,47800,47820,47840,47860,47880,47900,47920,47940,47960,47980,48000,48020,48040,48060,48080,48100,48120,48140,48160,48180,48200,48220,48240,48260,48280,48300,48320,48340,48360,48380,48400,48420,48440,48460,48480,48500,48520,48540,48560,48580,48600,48620,48640,48660,48680,48700,48720,48740,48760,48780,48800,48820,48840,48860,48880,48900,48920,48940,48960,48980,49000,49020,49040,49060,49080,49100,49120,49140,49160,49180,49200,49220,49240,49260,49280,49300,49320,49340,49360,49380,49400,49420,49440,49460,49480,49500,49520,49540,49560,49580,49600,49620,49640,49660,49680,49700,49720,49740,49760,49780,49800,49820,49840,49860,49880,49900,49920,49940,49960,49980],"target":[[0,120],[75,100],[175,80],[225,60],[250,40],[500,100],[575,80],[625,60],[675,40]],"lateness":[[0,0]]} diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/paced.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/paced.json index 145e0658722..5a2e419079c 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/paced.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/paced.json @@ -1 +1 @@ -{"name":"paced","about":"A perfectly even sender for 60 s, long enough to leave the cold-start ramp. The target settles on one bucket plus one frame, which is the floor the estimator can report.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030,20050,20070,20090,20110,20130,20150,20170,20190,20210,20230,20250,20270,20290,20310,20330,20350,20370,20390,20410,20430,20450,20470,20490,20510,20530,20550,20570,20590,20610,20630,20650,20670,20690,20710,20730,20750,20770,20790,20810,20830,20850,20870,20890,20910,20930,20950,20970,20990,21010,21030,21050,21070,21090,21110,21130,21150,21170,21190,21210,21230,21250,21270,21290,21310,21330,21350,21370,21390,21410,21430,21450,21470,21490,21510,21530,21550,21570,21590,21610,21630,21650,21670,21690,21710,21730,21750,21770,21790,21810,21830,21850,21870,21890,21910,21930,21950,21970,21990,22010,22030,22050,22070,22090,22110,22130,22150,22170,22190,22210,22230,22250,22270,22290,22310,22330,22350,22370,22390,22410,22430,22450,22470,22490,22510,22530,22550,22570,22590,22610,22630,22650,22670,22690,22710,22730,22750,22770,22790,22810,22830,22850,22870,22890,22910,22930,22950,22970,22990,23010,23030,23050,23070,23090,23110,23130,23150,23170,23190,23210,23230,23250,23270,23290,23310,23330,23350,23370,23390,23410,23430,23450,23470,23490,23510,23530,23550,23570,23590,23610,23630,23650,23670,23690,23710,23730,23750,23770,23790,23810,23830,23850,23870,23890,23910,23930,23950,23970,23990,24010,24030,24050,24070,24090,24110,24130,24150,24170,24190,24210,24230,24250,24270,24290,24310,24330,24350,24370,24390,24410,24430,24450,24470,24490,24510,24530,24550,24570,24590,24610,24630,24650,24670,24690,24710,24730,24750,24770,24790,24810,24830,24850,24870,24890,24910,24930,24950,24970,24990,25010,25030,25050,25070,25090,25110,25130,25150,25170,25190,25210,25230,25250,25270,25290,25310,25330,25350,25370,25390,25410,25430,25450,25470,25490,25510,25530,25550,25570,25590,25610,25630,25650,25670,25690,25710,25730,25750,25770,25790,25810,25830,25850,25870,25890,25910,25930,25950,25970,25990,26010,26030,26050,26070,26090,26110,26130,26150,26170,26190,26210,26230,26250,26270,26290,26310,26330,26350,26370,26390,26410,26430,26450,26470,26490,26510,26530,26550,26570,26590,26610,26630,26650,26670,26690,26710,26730,26750,26770,26790,26810,26830,26850,26870,26890,26910,26930,26950,26970,26990,27010,27030,27050,27070,27090,27110,27130,27150,27170,27190,27210,27230,27250,27270,27290,27310,27330,27350,27370,27390,27410,27430,27450,27470,27490,27510,27530,27550,27570,27590,27610,27630,27650,27670,27690,27710,27730,27750,27770,27790,27810,27830,27850,27870,27890,27910,27930,27950,27970,27990,28010,28030,28050,28070,28090,28110,28130,28150,28170,28190,28210,28230,28250,28270,28290,28310,28330,28350,28370,28390,28410,28430,28450,28470,28490,28510,28530,28550,28570,28590,28610,28630,28650,28670,28690,28710,28730,28750,28770,28790,28810,28830,28850,28870,28890,28910,28930,28950,28970,28990,29010,29030,29050,29070,29090,29110,29130,29150,29170,29190,29210,29230,29250,29270,29290,29310,29330,29350,29370,29390,29410,29430,29450,29470,29490,29510,29530,29550,29570,29590,29610,29630,29650,29670,29690,29710,29730,29750,29770,29790,29810,29830,29850,29870,29890,29910,29930,29950,29970,29990,30010,30030,30050,30070,30090,30110,30130,30150,30170,30190,30210,30230,30250,30270,30290,30310,30330,30350,30370,30390,30410,30430,30450,30470,30490,30510,30530,30550,30570,30590,30610,30630,30650,30670,30690,30710,30730,30750,30770,30790,30810,30830,30850,30870,30890,30910,30930,30950,30970,30990,31010,31030,31050,31070,31090,31110,31130,31150,31170,31190,31210,31230,31250,31270,31290,31310,31330,31350,31370,31390,31410,31430,31450,31470,31490,31510,31530,31550,31570,31590,31610,31630,31650,31670,31690,31710,31730,31750,31770,31790,31810,31830,31850,31870,31890,31910,31930,31950,31970,31990,32010,32030,32050,32070,32090,32110,32130,32150,32170,32190,32210,32230,32250,32270,32290,32310,32330,32350,32370,32390,32410,32430,32450,32470,32490,32510,32530,32550,32570,32590,32610,32630,32650,32670,32690,32710,32730,32750,32770,32790,32810,32830,32850,32870,32890,32910,32930,32950,32970,32990,33010,33030,33050,33070,33090,33110,33130,33150,33170,33190,33210,33230,33250,33270,33290,33310,33330,33350,33370,33390,33410,33430,33450,33470,33490,33510,33530,33550,33570,33590,33610,33630,33650,33670,33690,33710,33730,33750,33770,33790,33810,33830,33850,33870,33890,33910,33930,33950,33970,33990,34010,34030,34050,34070,34090,34110,34130,34150,34170,34190,34210,34230,34250,34270,34290,34310,34330,34350,34370,34390,34410,34430,34450,34470,34490,34510,34530,34550,34570,34590,34610,34630,34650,34670,34690,34710,34730,34750,34770,34790,34810,34830,34850,34870,34890,34910,34930,34950,34970,34990,35010,35030,35050,35070,35090,35110,35130,35150,35170,35190,35210,35230,35250,35270,35290,35310,35330,35350,35370,35390,35410,35430,35450,35470,35490,35510,35530,35550,35570,35590,35610,35630,35650,35670,35690,35710,35730,35750,35770,35790,35810,35830,35850,35870,35890,35910,35930,35950,35970,35990,36010,36030,36050,36070,36090,36110,36130,36150,36170,36190,36210,36230,36250,36270,36290,36310,36330,36350,36370,36390,36410,36430,36450,36470,36490,36510,36530,36550,36570,36590,36610,36630,36650,36670,36690,36710,36730,36750,36770,36790,36810,36830,36850,36870,36890,36910,36930,36950,36970,36990,37010,37030,37050,37070,37090,37110,37130,37150,37170,37190,37210,37230,37250,37270,37290,37310,37330,37350,37370,37390,37410,37430,37450,37470,37490,37510,37530,37550,37570,37590,37610,37630,37650,37670,37690,37710,37730,37750,37770,37790,37810,37830,37850,37870,37890,37910,37930,37950,37970,37990,38010,38030,38050,38070,38090,38110,38130,38150,38170,38190,38210,38230,38250,38270,38290,38310,38330,38350,38370,38390,38410,38430,38450,38470,38490,38510,38530,38550,38570,38590,38610,38630,38650,38670,38690,38710,38730,38750,38770,38790,38810,38830,38850,38870,38890,38910,38930,38950,38970,38990,39010,39030,39050,39070,39090,39110,39130,39150,39170,39190,39210,39230,39250,39270,39290,39310,39330,39350,39370,39390,39410,39430,39450,39470,39490,39510,39530,39550,39570,39590,39610,39630,39650,39670,39690,39710,39730,39750,39770,39790,39810,39830,39850,39870,39890,39910,39930,39950,39970,39990,40010,40030,40050,40070,40090,40110,40130,40150,40170,40190,40210,40230,40250,40270,40290,40310,40330,40350,40370,40390,40410,40430,40450,40470,40490,40510,40530,40550,40570,40590,40610,40630,40650,40670,40690,40710,40730,40750,40770,40790,40810,40830,40850,40870,40890,40910,40930,40950,40970,40990,41010,41030,41050,41070,41090,41110,41130,41150,41170,41190,41210,41230,41250,41270,41290,41310,41330,41350,41370,41390,41410,41430,41450,41470,41490,41510,41530,41550,41570,41590,41610,41630,41650,41670,41690,41710,41730,41750,41770,41790,41810,41830,41850,41870,41890,41910,41930,41950,41970,41990,42010,42030,42050,42070,42090,42110,42130,42150,42170,42190,42210,42230,42250,42270,42290,42310,42330,42350,42370,42390,42410,42430,42450,42470,42490,42510,42530,42550,42570,42590,42610,42630,42650,42670,42690,42710,42730,42750,42770,42790,42810,42830,42850,42870,42890,42910,42930,42950,42970,42990,43010,43030,43050,43070,43090,43110,43130,43150,43170,43190,43210,43230,43250,43270,43290,43310,43330,43350,43370,43390,43410,43430,43450,43470,43490,43510,43530,43550,43570,43590,43610,43630,43650,43670,43690,43710,43730,43750,43770,43790,43810,43830,43850,43870,43890,43910,43930,43950,43970,43990,44010,44030,44050,44070,44090,44110,44130,44150,44170,44190,44210,44230,44250,44270,44290,44310,44330,44350,44370,44390,44410,44430,44450,44470,44490,44510,44530,44550,44570,44590,44610,44630,44650,44670,44690,44710,44730,44750,44770,44790,44810,44830,44850,44870,44890,44910,44930,44950,44970,44990,45010,45030,45050,45070,45090,45110,45130,45150,45170,45190,45210,45230,45250,45270,45290,45310,45330,45350,45370,45390,45410,45430,45450,45470,45490,45510,45530,45550,45570,45590,45610,45630,45650,45670,45690,45710,45730,45750,45770,45790,45810,45830,45850,45870,45890,45910,45930,45950,45970,45990,46010,46030,46050,46070,46090,46110,46130,46150,46170,46190,46210,46230,46250,46270,46290,46310,46330,46350,46370,46390,46410,46430,46450,46470,46490,46510,46530,46550,46570,46590,46610,46630,46650,46670,46690,46710,46730,46750,46770,46790,46810,46830,46850,46870,46890,46910,46930,46950,46970,46990,47010,47030,47050,47070,47090,47110,47130,47150,47170,47190,47210,47230,47250,47270,47290,47310,47330,47350,47370,47390,47410,47430,47450,47470,47490,47510,47530,47550,47570,47590,47610,47630,47650,47670,47690,47710,47730,47750,47770,47790,47810,47830,47850,47870,47890,47910,47930,47950,47970,47990,48010,48030,48050,48070,48090,48110,48130,48150,48170,48190,48210,48230,48250,48270,48290,48310,48330,48350,48370,48390,48410,48430,48450,48470,48490,48510,48530,48550,48570,48590,48610,48630,48650,48670,48690,48710,48730,48750,48770,48790,48810,48830,48850,48870,48890,48910,48930,48950,48970,48990,49010,49030,49050,49070,49090,49110,49130,49150,49170,49190,49210,49230,49250,49270,49290,49310,49330,49350,49370,49390,49410,49430,49450,49470,49490,49510,49530,49550,49570,49590,49610,49630,49650,49670,49690,49710,49730,49750,49770,49790,49810,49830,49850,49870,49890,49910,49930,49950,49970,49990,50010,50030,50050,50070,50090,50110,50130,50150,50170,50190,50210,50230,50250,50270,50290,50310,50330,50350,50370,50390,50410,50430,50450,50470,50490,50510,50530,50550,50570,50590,50610,50630,50650,50670,50690,50710,50730,50750,50770,50790,50810,50830,50850,50870,50890,50910,50930,50950,50970,50990,51010,51030,51050,51070,51090,51110,51130,51150,51170,51190,51210,51230,51250,51270,51290,51310,51330,51350,51370,51390,51410,51430,51450,51470,51490,51510,51530,51550,51570,51590,51610,51630,51650,51670,51690,51710,51730,51750,51770,51790,51810,51830,51850,51870,51890,51910,51930,51950,51970,51990,52010,52030,52050,52070,52090,52110,52130,52150,52170,52190,52210,52230,52250,52270,52290,52310,52330,52350,52370,52390,52410,52430,52450,52470,52490,52510,52530,52550,52570,52590,52610,52630,52650,52670,52690,52710,52730,52750,52770,52790,52810,52830,52850,52870,52890,52910,52930,52950,52970,52990,53010,53030,53050,53070,53090,53110,53130,53150,53170,53190,53210,53230,53250,53270,53290,53310,53330,53350,53370,53390,53410,53430,53450,53470,53490,53510,53530,53550,53570,53590,53610,53630,53650,53670,53690,53710,53730,53750,53770,53790,53810,53830,53850,53870,53890,53910,53930,53950,53970,53990,54010,54030,54050,54070,54090,54110,54130,54150,54170,54190,54210,54230,54250,54270,54290,54310,54330,54350,54370,54390,54410,54430,54450,54470,54490,54510,54530,54550,54570,54590,54610,54630,54650,54670,54690,54710,54730,54750,54770,54790,54810,54830,54850,54870,54890,54910,54930,54950,54970,54990,55010,55030,55050,55070,55090,55110,55130,55150,55170,55190,55210,55230,55250,55270,55290,55310,55330,55350,55370,55390,55410,55430,55450,55470,55490,55510,55530,55550,55570,55590,55610,55630,55650,55670,55690,55710,55730,55750,55770,55790,55810,55830,55850,55870,55890,55910,55930,55950,55970,55990,56010,56030,56050,56070,56090,56110,56130,56150,56170,56190,56210,56230,56250,56270,56290,56310,56330,56350,56370,56390,56410,56430,56450,56470,56490,56510,56530,56550,56570,56590,56610,56630,56650,56670,56690,56710,56730,56750,56770,56790,56810,56830,56850,56870,56890,56910,56930,56950,56970,56990,57010,57030,57050,57070,57090,57110,57130,57150,57170,57190,57210,57230,57250,57270,57290,57310,57330,57350,57370,57390,57410,57430,57450,57470,57490,57510,57530,57550,57570,57590,57610,57630,57650,57670,57690,57710,57730,57750,57770,57790,57810,57830,57850,57870,57890,57910,57930,57950,57970,57990,58010,58030,58050,58070,58090,58110,58130,58150,58170,58190,58210,58230,58250,58270,58290,58310,58330,58350,58370,58390,58410,58430,58450,58470,58490,58510,58530,58550,58570,58590,58610,58630,58650,58670,58690,58710,58730,58750,58770,58790,58810,58830,58850,58870,58890,58910,58930,58950,58970,58990,59010,59030,59050,59070,59090,59110,59130,59150,59170,59190,59210,59230,59250,59270,59290,59310,59330,59350,59370,59390,59410,59430,59450,59470,59490,59510,59530,59550,59570,59590,59610,59630,59650,59670,59690,59710,59730,59750,59770,59790,59810,59830,59850,59870,59890,59910,59930,59950,59970,59990,60010,60030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,20000,20020,20040,20060,20080,20100,20120,20140,20160,20180,20200,20220,20240,20260,20280,20300,20320,20340,20360,20380,20400,20420,20440,20460,20480,20500,20520,20540,20560,20580,20600,20620,20640,20660,20680,20700,20720,20740,20760,20780,20800,20820,20840,20860,20880,20900,20920,20940,20960,20980,21000,21020,21040,21060,21080,21100,21120,21140,21160,21180,21200,21220,21240,21260,21280,21300,21320,21340,21360,21380,21400,21420,21440,21460,21480,21500,21520,21540,21560,21580,21600,21620,21640,21660,21680,21700,21720,21740,21760,21780,21800,21820,21840,21860,21880,21900,21920,21940,21960,21980,22000,22020,22040,22060,22080,22100,22120,22140,22160,22180,22200,22220,22240,22260,22280,22300,22320,22340,22360,22380,22400,22420,22440,22460,22480,22500,22520,22540,22560,22580,22600,22620,22640,22660,22680,22700,22720,22740,22760,22780,22800,22820,22840,22860,22880,22900,22920,22940,22960,22980,23000,23020,23040,23060,23080,23100,23120,23140,23160,23180,23200,23220,23240,23260,23280,23300,23320,23340,23360,23380,23400,23420,23440,23460,23480,23500,23520,23540,23560,23580,23600,23620,23640,23660,23680,23700,23720,23740,23760,23780,23800,23820,23840,23860,23880,23900,23920,23940,23960,23980,24000,24020,24040,24060,24080,24100,24120,24140,24160,24180,24200,24220,24240,24260,24280,24300,24320,24340,24360,24380,24400,24420,24440,24460,24480,24500,24520,24540,24560,24580,24600,24620,24640,24660,24680,24700,24720,24740,24760,24780,24800,24820,24840,24860,24880,24900,24920,24940,24960,24980,25000,25020,25040,25060,25080,25100,25120,25140,25160,25180,25200,25220,25240,25260,25280,25300,25320,25340,25360,25380,25400,25420,25440,25460,25480,25500,25520,25540,25560,25580,25600,25620,25640,25660,25680,25700,25720,25740,25760,25780,25800,25820,25840,25860,25880,25900,25920,25940,25960,25980,26000,26020,26040,26060,26080,26100,26120,26140,26160,26180,26200,26220,26240,26260,26280,26300,26320,26340,26360,26380,26400,26420,26440,26460,26480,26500,26520,26540,26560,26580,26600,26620,26640,26660,26680,26700,26720,26740,26760,26780,26800,26820,26840,26860,26880,26900,26920,26940,26960,26980,27000,27020,27040,27060,27080,27100,27120,27140,27160,27180,27200,27220,27240,27260,27280,27300,27320,27340,27360,27380,27400,27420,27440,27460,27480,27500,27520,27540,27560,27580,27600,27620,27640,27660,27680,27700,27720,27740,27760,27780,27800,27820,27840,27860,27880,27900,27920,27940,27960,27980,28000,28020,28040,28060,28080,28100,28120,28140,28160,28180,28200,28220,28240,28260,28280,28300,28320,28340,28360,28380,28400,28420,28440,28460,28480,28500,28520,28540,28560,28580,28600,28620,28640,28660,28680,28700,28720,28740,28760,28780,28800,28820,28840,28860,28880,28900,28920,28940,28960,28980,29000,29020,29040,29060,29080,29100,29120,29140,29160,29180,29200,29220,29240,29260,29280,29300,29320,29340,29360,29380,29400,29420,29440,29460,29480,29500,29520,29540,29560,29580,29600,29620,29640,29660,29680,29700,29720,29740,29760,29780,29800,29820,29840,29860,29880,29900,29920,29940,29960,29980,30000,30020,30040,30060,30080,30100,30120,30140,30160,30180,30200,30220,30240,30260,30280,30300,30320,30340,30360,30380,30400,30420,30440,30460,30480,30500,30520,30540,30560,30580,30600,30620,30640,30660,30680,30700,30720,30740,30760,30780,30800,30820,30840,30860,30880,30900,30920,30940,30960,30980,31000,31020,31040,31060,31080,31100,31120,31140,31160,31180,31200,31220,31240,31260,31280,31300,31320,31340,31360,31380,31400,31420,31440,31460,31480,31500,31520,31540,31560,31580,31600,31620,31640,31660,31680,31700,31720,31740,31760,31780,31800,31820,31840,31860,31880,31900,31920,31940,31960,31980,32000,32020,32040,32060,32080,32100,32120,32140,32160,32180,32200,32220,32240,32260,32280,32300,32320,32340,32360,32380,32400,32420,32440,32460,32480,32500,32520,32540,32560,32580,32600,32620,32640,32660,32680,32700,32720,32740,32760,32780,32800,32820,32840,32860,32880,32900,32920,32940,32960,32980,33000,33020,33040,33060,33080,33100,33120,33140,33160,33180,33200,33220,33240,33260,33280,33300,33320,33340,33360,33380,33400,33420,33440,33460,33480,33500,33520,33540,33560,33580,33600,33620,33640,33660,33680,33700,33720,33740,33760,33780,33800,33820,33840,33860,33880,33900,33920,33940,33960,33980,34000,34020,34040,34060,34080,34100,34120,34140,34160,34180,34200,34220,34240,34260,34280,34300,34320,34340,34360,34380,34400,34420,34440,34460,34480,34500,34520,34540,34560,34580,34600,34620,34640,34660,34680,34700,34720,34740,34760,34780,34800,34820,34840,34860,34880,34900,34920,34940,34960,34980,35000,35020,35040,35060,35080,35100,35120,35140,35160,35180,35200,35220,35240,35260,35280,35300,35320,35340,35360,35380,35400,35420,35440,35460,35480,35500,35520,35540,35560,35580,35600,35620,35640,35660,35680,35700,35720,35740,35760,35780,35800,35820,35840,35860,35880,35900,35920,35940,35960,35980,36000,36020,36040,36060,36080,36100,36120,36140,36160,36180,36200,36220,36240,36260,36280,36300,36320,36340,36360,36380,36400,36420,36440,36460,36480,36500,36520,36540,36560,36580,36600,36620,36640,36660,36680,36700,36720,36740,36760,36780,36800,36820,36840,36860,36880,36900,36920,36940,36960,36980,37000,37020,37040,37060,37080,37100,37120,37140,37160,37180,37200,37220,37240,37260,37280,37300,37320,37340,37360,37380,37400,37420,37440,37460,37480,37500,37520,37540,37560,37580,37600,37620,37640,37660,37680,37700,37720,37740,37760,37780,37800,37820,37840,37860,37880,37900,37920,37940,37960,37980,38000,38020,38040,38060,38080,38100,38120,38140,38160,38180,38200,38220,38240,38260,38280,38300,38320,38340,38360,38380,38400,38420,38440,38460,38480,38500,38520,38540,38560,38580,38600,38620,38640,38660,38680,38700,38720,38740,38760,38780,38800,38820,38840,38860,38880,38900,38920,38940,38960,38980,39000,39020,39040,39060,39080,39100,39120,39140,39160,39180,39200,39220,39240,39260,39280,39300,39320,39340,39360,39380,39400,39420,39440,39460,39480,39500,39520,39540,39560,39580,39600,39620,39640,39660,39680,39700,39720,39740,39760,39780,39800,39820,39840,39860,39880,39900,39920,39940,39960,39980,40000,40020,40040,40060,40080,40100,40120,40140,40160,40180,40200,40220,40240,40260,40280,40300,40320,40340,40360,40380,40400,40420,40440,40460,40480,40500,40520,40540,40560,40580,40600,40620,40640,40660,40680,40700,40720,40740,40760,40780,40800,40820,40840,40860,40880,40900,40920,40940,40960,40980,41000,41020,41040,41060,41080,41100,41120,41140,41160,41180,41200,41220,41240,41260,41280,41300,41320,41340,41360,41380,41400,41420,41440,41460,41480,41500,41520,41540,41560,41580,41600,41620,41640,41660,41680,41700,41720,41740,41760,41780,41800,41820,41840,41860,41880,41900,41920,41940,41960,41980,42000,42020,42040,42060,42080,42100,42120,42140,42160,42180,42200,42220,42240,42260,42280,42300,42320,42340,42360,42380,42400,42420,42440,42460,42480,42500,42520,42540,42560,42580,42600,42620,42640,42660,42680,42700,42720,42740,42760,42780,42800,42820,42840,42860,42880,42900,42920,42940,42960,42980,43000,43020,43040,43060,43080,43100,43120,43140,43160,43180,43200,43220,43240,43260,43280,43300,43320,43340,43360,43380,43400,43420,43440,43460,43480,43500,43520,43540,43560,43580,43600,43620,43640,43660,43680,43700,43720,43740,43760,43780,43800,43820,43840,43860,43880,43900,43920,43940,43960,43980,44000,44020,44040,44060,44080,44100,44120,44140,44160,44180,44200,44220,44240,44260,44280,44300,44320,44340,44360,44380,44400,44420,44440,44460,44480,44500,44520,44540,44560,44580,44600,44620,44640,44660,44680,44700,44720,44740,44760,44780,44800,44820,44840,44860,44880,44900,44920,44940,44960,44980,45000,45020,45040,45060,45080,45100,45120,45140,45160,45180,45200,45220,45240,45260,45280,45300,45320,45340,45360,45380,45400,45420,45440,45460,45480,45500,45520,45540,45560,45580,45600,45620,45640,45660,45680,45700,45720,45740,45760,45780,45800,45820,45840,45860,45880,45900,45920,45940,45960,45980,46000,46020,46040,46060,46080,46100,46120,46140,46160,46180,46200,46220,46240,46260,46280,46300,46320,46340,46360,46380,46400,46420,46440,46460,46480,46500,46520,46540,46560,46580,46600,46620,46640,46660,46680,46700,46720,46740,46760,46780,46800,46820,46840,46860,46880,46900,46920,46940,46960,46980,47000,47020,47040,47060,47080,47100,47120,47140,47160,47180,47200,47220,47240,47260,47280,47300,47320,47340,47360,47380,47400,47420,47440,47460,47480,47500,47520,47540,47560,47580,47600,47620,47640,47660,47680,47700,47720,47740,47760,47780,47800,47820,47840,47860,47880,47900,47920,47940,47960,47980,48000,48020,48040,48060,48080,48100,48120,48140,48160,48180,48200,48220,48240,48260,48280,48300,48320,48340,48360,48380,48400,48420,48440,48460,48480,48500,48520,48540,48560,48580,48600,48620,48640,48660,48680,48700,48720,48740,48760,48780,48800,48820,48840,48860,48880,48900,48920,48940,48960,48980,49000,49020,49040,49060,49080,49100,49120,49140,49160,49180,49200,49220,49240,49260,49280,49300,49320,49340,49360,49380,49400,49420,49440,49460,49480,49500,49520,49540,49560,49580,49600,49620,49640,49660,49680,49700,49720,49740,49760,49780,49800,49820,49840,49860,49880,49900,49920,49940,49960,49980,50000,50020,50040,50060,50080,50100,50120,50140,50160,50180,50200,50220,50240,50260,50280,50300,50320,50340,50360,50380,50400,50420,50440,50460,50480,50500,50520,50540,50560,50580,50600,50620,50640,50660,50680,50700,50720,50740,50760,50780,50800,50820,50840,50860,50880,50900,50920,50940,50960,50980,51000,51020,51040,51060,51080,51100,51120,51140,51160,51180,51200,51220,51240,51260,51280,51300,51320,51340,51360,51380,51400,51420,51440,51460,51480,51500,51520,51540,51560,51580,51600,51620,51640,51660,51680,51700,51720,51740,51760,51780,51800,51820,51840,51860,51880,51900,51920,51940,51960,51980,52000,52020,52040,52060,52080,52100,52120,52140,52160,52180,52200,52220,52240,52260,52280,52300,52320,52340,52360,52380,52400,52420,52440,52460,52480,52500,52520,52540,52560,52580,52600,52620,52640,52660,52680,52700,52720,52740,52760,52780,52800,52820,52840,52860,52880,52900,52920,52940,52960,52980,53000,53020,53040,53060,53080,53100,53120,53140,53160,53180,53200,53220,53240,53260,53280,53300,53320,53340,53360,53380,53400,53420,53440,53460,53480,53500,53520,53540,53560,53580,53600,53620,53640,53660,53680,53700,53720,53740,53760,53780,53800,53820,53840,53860,53880,53900,53920,53940,53960,53980,54000,54020,54040,54060,54080,54100,54120,54140,54160,54180,54200,54220,54240,54260,54280,54300,54320,54340,54360,54380,54400,54420,54440,54460,54480,54500,54520,54540,54560,54580,54600,54620,54640,54660,54680,54700,54720,54740,54760,54780,54800,54820,54840,54860,54880,54900,54920,54940,54960,54980,55000,55020,55040,55060,55080,55100,55120,55140,55160,55180,55200,55220,55240,55260,55280,55300,55320,55340,55360,55380,55400,55420,55440,55460,55480,55500,55520,55540,55560,55580,55600,55620,55640,55660,55680,55700,55720,55740,55760,55780,55800,55820,55840,55860,55880,55900,55920,55940,55960,55980,56000,56020,56040,56060,56080,56100,56120,56140,56160,56180,56200,56220,56240,56260,56280,56300,56320,56340,56360,56380,56400,56420,56440,56460,56480,56500,56520,56540,56560,56580,56600,56620,56640,56660,56680,56700,56720,56740,56760,56780,56800,56820,56840,56860,56880,56900,56920,56940,56960,56980,57000,57020,57040,57060,57080,57100,57120,57140,57160,57180,57200,57220,57240,57260,57280,57300,57320,57340,57360,57380,57400,57420,57440,57460,57480,57500,57520,57540,57560,57580,57600,57620,57640,57660,57680,57700,57720,57740,57760,57780,57800,57820,57840,57860,57880,57900,57920,57940,57960,57980,58000,58020,58040,58060,58080,58100,58120,58140,58160,58180,58200,58220,58240,58260,58280,58300,58320,58340,58360,58380,58400,58420,58440,58460,58480,58500,58520,58540,58560,58580,58600,58620,58640,58660,58680,58700,58720,58740,58760,58780,58800,58820,58840,58860,58880,58900,58920,58940,58960,58980,59000,59020,59040,59060,59080,59100,59120,59140,59160,59180,59200,59220,59240,59260,59280,59300,59320,59340,59360,59380,59400,59420,59440,59460,59480,59500,59520,59540,59560,59580,59600,59620,59640,59660,59680,59700,59720,59740,59760,59780,59800,59820,59840,59860,59880,59900,59920,59940,59960,59980],"target":[[0,120],[75,100],[175,80],[225,60],[250,40]]} +{"name":"paced","about":"A perfectly even sender for 60 s, long enough to leave the cold-start ramp. The target settles on one bucket plus one frame, which is the floor the estimator can report.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030,20050,20070,20090,20110,20130,20150,20170,20190,20210,20230,20250,20270,20290,20310,20330,20350,20370,20390,20410,20430,20450,20470,20490,20510,20530,20550,20570,20590,20610,20630,20650,20670,20690,20710,20730,20750,20770,20790,20810,20830,20850,20870,20890,20910,20930,20950,20970,20990,21010,21030,21050,21070,21090,21110,21130,21150,21170,21190,21210,21230,21250,21270,21290,21310,21330,21350,21370,21390,21410,21430,21450,21470,21490,21510,21530,21550,21570,21590,21610,21630,21650,21670,21690,21710,21730,21750,21770,21790,21810,21830,21850,21870,21890,21910,21930,21950,21970,21990,22010,22030,22050,22070,22090,22110,22130,22150,22170,22190,22210,22230,22250,22270,22290,22310,22330,22350,22370,22390,22410,22430,22450,22470,22490,22510,22530,22550,22570,22590,22610,22630,22650,22670,22690,22710,22730,22750,22770,22790,22810,22830,22850,22870,22890,22910,22930,22950,22970,22990,23010,23030,23050,23070,23090,23110,23130,23150,23170,23190,23210,23230,23250,23270,23290,23310,23330,23350,23370,23390,23410,23430,23450,23470,23490,23510,23530,23550,23570,23590,23610,23630,23650,23670,23690,23710,23730,23750,23770,23790,23810,23830,23850,23870,23890,23910,23930,23950,23970,23990,24010,24030,24050,24070,24090,24110,24130,24150,24170,24190,24210,24230,24250,24270,24290,24310,24330,24350,24370,24390,24410,24430,24450,24470,24490,24510,24530,24550,24570,24590,24610,24630,24650,24670,24690,24710,24730,24750,24770,24790,24810,24830,24850,24870,24890,24910,24930,24950,24970,24990,25010,25030,25050,25070,25090,25110,25130,25150,25170,25190,25210,25230,25250,25270,25290,25310,25330,25350,25370,25390,25410,25430,25450,25470,25490,25510,25530,25550,25570,25590,25610,25630,25650,25670,25690,25710,25730,25750,25770,25790,25810,25830,25850,25870,25890,25910,25930,25950,25970,25990,26010,26030,26050,26070,26090,26110,26130,26150,26170,26190,26210,26230,26250,26270,26290,26310,26330,26350,26370,26390,26410,26430,26450,26470,26490,26510,26530,26550,26570,26590,26610,26630,26650,26670,26690,26710,26730,26750,26770,26790,26810,26830,26850,26870,26890,26910,26930,26950,26970,26990,27010,27030,27050,27070,27090,27110,27130,27150,27170,27190,27210,27230,27250,27270,27290,27310,27330,27350,27370,27390,27410,27430,27450,27470,27490,27510,27530,27550,27570,27590,27610,27630,27650,27670,27690,27710,27730,27750,27770,27790,27810,27830,27850,27870,27890,27910,27930,27950,27970,27990,28010,28030,28050,28070,28090,28110,28130,28150,28170,28190,28210,28230,28250,28270,28290,28310,28330,28350,28370,28390,28410,28430,28450,28470,28490,28510,28530,28550,28570,28590,28610,28630,28650,28670,28690,28710,28730,28750,28770,28790,28810,28830,28850,28870,28890,28910,28930,28950,28970,28990,29010,29030,29050,29070,29090,29110,29130,29150,29170,29190,29210,29230,29250,29270,29290,29310,29330,29350,29370,29390,29410,29430,29450,29470,29490,29510,29530,29550,29570,29590,29610,29630,29650,29670,29690,29710,29730,29750,29770,29790,29810,29830,29850,29870,29890,29910,29930,29950,29970,29990,30010,30030,30050,30070,30090,30110,30130,30150,30170,30190,30210,30230,30250,30270,30290,30310,30330,30350,30370,30390,30410,30430,30450,30470,30490,30510,30530,30550,30570,30590,30610,30630,30650,30670,30690,30710,30730,30750,30770,30790,30810,30830,30850,30870,30890,30910,30930,30950,30970,30990,31010,31030,31050,31070,31090,31110,31130,31150,31170,31190,31210,31230,31250,31270,31290,31310,31330,31350,31370,31390,31410,31430,31450,31470,31490,31510,31530,31550,31570,31590,31610,31630,31650,31670,31690,31710,31730,31750,31770,31790,31810,31830,31850,31870,31890,31910,31930,31950,31970,31990,32010,32030,32050,32070,32090,32110,32130,32150,32170,32190,32210,32230,32250,32270,32290,32310,32330,32350,32370,32390,32410,32430,32450,32470,32490,32510,32530,32550,32570,32590,32610,32630,32650,32670,32690,32710,32730,32750,32770,32790,32810,32830,32850,32870,32890,32910,32930,32950,32970,32990,33010,33030,33050,33070,33090,33110,33130,33150,33170,33190,33210,33230,33250,33270,33290,33310,33330,33350,33370,33390,33410,33430,33450,33470,33490,33510,33530,33550,33570,33590,33610,33630,33650,33670,33690,33710,33730,33750,33770,33790,33810,33830,33850,33870,33890,33910,33930,33950,33970,33990,34010,34030,34050,34070,34090,34110,34130,34150,34170,34190,34210,34230,34250,34270,34290,34310,34330,34350,34370,34390,34410,34430,34450,34470,34490,34510,34530,34550,34570,34590,34610,34630,34650,34670,34690,34710,34730,34750,34770,34790,34810,34830,34850,34870,34890,34910,34930,34950,34970,34990,35010,35030,35050,35070,35090,35110,35130,35150,35170,35190,35210,35230,35250,35270,35290,35310,35330,35350,35370,35390,35410,35430,35450,35470,35490,35510,35530,35550,35570,35590,35610,35630,35650,35670,35690,35710,35730,35750,35770,35790,35810,35830,35850,35870,35890,35910,35930,35950,35970,35990,36010,36030,36050,36070,36090,36110,36130,36150,36170,36190,36210,36230,36250,36270,36290,36310,36330,36350,36370,36390,36410,36430,36450,36470,36490,36510,36530,36550,36570,36590,36610,36630,36650,36670,36690,36710,36730,36750,36770,36790,36810,36830,36850,36870,36890,36910,36930,36950,36970,36990,37010,37030,37050,37070,37090,37110,37130,37150,37170,37190,37210,37230,37250,37270,37290,37310,37330,37350,37370,37390,37410,37430,37450,37470,37490,37510,37530,37550,37570,37590,37610,37630,37650,37670,37690,37710,37730,37750,37770,37790,37810,37830,37850,37870,37890,37910,37930,37950,37970,37990,38010,38030,38050,38070,38090,38110,38130,38150,38170,38190,38210,38230,38250,38270,38290,38310,38330,38350,38370,38390,38410,38430,38450,38470,38490,38510,38530,38550,38570,38590,38610,38630,38650,38670,38690,38710,38730,38750,38770,38790,38810,38830,38850,38870,38890,38910,38930,38950,38970,38990,39010,39030,39050,39070,39090,39110,39130,39150,39170,39190,39210,39230,39250,39270,39290,39310,39330,39350,39370,39390,39410,39430,39450,39470,39490,39510,39530,39550,39570,39590,39610,39630,39650,39670,39690,39710,39730,39750,39770,39790,39810,39830,39850,39870,39890,39910,39930,39950,39970,39990,40010,40030,40050,40070,40090,40110,40130,40150,40170,40190,40210,40230,40250,40270,40290,40310,40330,40350,40370,40390,40410,40430,40450,40470,40490,40510,40530,40550,40570,40590,40610,40630,40650,40670,40690,40710,40730,40750,40770,40790,40810,40830,40850,40870,40890,40910,40930,40950,40970,40990,41010,41030,41050,41070,41090,41110,41130,41150,41170,41190,41210,41230,41250,41270,41290,41310,41330,41350,41370,41390,41410,41430,41450,41470,41490,41510,41530,41550,41570,41590,41610,41630,41650,41670,41690,41710,41730,41750,41770,41790,41810,41830,41850,41870,41890,41910,41930,41950,41970,41990,42010,42030,42050,42070,42090,42110,42130,42150,42170,42190,42210,42230,42250,42270,42290,42310,42330,42350,42370,42390,42410,42430,42450,42470,42490,42510,42530,42550,42570,42590,42610,42630,42650,42670,42690,42710,42730,42750,42770,42790,42810,42830,42850,42870,42890,42910,42930,42950,42970,42990,43010,43030,43050,43070,43090,43110,43130,43150,43170,43190,43210,43230,43250,43270,43290,43310,43330,43350,43370,43390,43410,43430,43450,43470,43490,43510,43530,43550,43570,43590,43610,43630,43650,43670,43690,43710,43730,43750,43770,43790,43810,43830,43850,43870,43890,43910,43930,43950,43970,43990,44010,44030,44050,44070,44090,44110,44130,44150,44170,44190,44210,44230,44250,44270,44290,44310,44330,44350,44370,44390,44410,44430,44450,44470,44490,44510,44530,44550,44570,44590,44610,44630,44650,44670,44690,44710,44730,44750,44770,44790,44810,44830,44850,44870,44890,44910,44930,44950,44970,44990,45010,45030,45050,45070,45090,45110,45130,45150,45170,45190,45210,45230,45250,45270,45290,45310,45330,45350,45370,45390,45410,45430,45450,45470,45490,45510,45530,45550,45570,45590,45610,45630,45650,45670,45690,45710,45730,45750,45770,45790,45810,45830,45850,45870,45890,45910,45930,45950,45970,45990,46010,46030,46050,46070,46090,46110,46130,46150,46170,46190,46210,46230,46250,46270,46290,46310,46330,46350,46370,46390,46410,46430,46450,46470,46490,46510,46530,46550,46570,46590,46610,46630,46650,46670,46690,46710,46730,46750,46770,46790,46810,46830,46850,46870,46890,46910,46930,46950,46970,46990,47010,47030,47050,47070,47090,47110,47130,47150,47170,47190,47210,47230,47250,47270,47290,47310,47330,47350,47370,47390,47410,47430,47450,47470,47490,47510,47530,47550,47570,47590,47610,47630,47650,47670,47690,47710,47730,47750,47770,47790,47810,47830,47850,47870,47890,47910,47930,47950,47970,47990,48010,48030,48050,48070,48090,48110,48130,48150,48170,48190,48210,48230,48250,48270,48290,48310,48330,48350,48370,48390,48410,48430,48450,48470,48490,48510,48530,48550,48570,48590,48610,48630,48650,48670,48690,48710,48730,48750,48770,48790,48810,48830,48850,48870,48890,48910,48930,48950,48970,48990,49010,49030,49050,49070,49090,49110,49130,49150,49170,49190,49210,49230,49250,49270,49290,49310,49330,49350,49370,49390,49410,49430,49450,49470,49490,49510,49530,49550,49570,49590,49610,49630,49650,49670,49690,49710,49730,49750,49770,49790,49810,49830,49850,49870,49890,49910,49930,49950,49970,49990,50010,50030,50050,50070,50090,50110,50130,50150,50170,50190,50210,50230,50250,50270,50290,50310,50330,50350,50370,50390,50410,50430,50450,50470,50490,50510,50530,50550,50570,50590,50610,50630,50650,50670,50690,50710,50730,50750,50770,50790,50810,50830,50850,50870,50890,50910,50930,50950,50970,50990,51010,51030,51050,51070,51090,51110,51130,51150,51170,51190,51210,51230,51250,51270,51290,51310,51330,51350,51370,51390,51410,51430,51450,51470,51490,51510,51530,51550,51570,51590,51610,51630,51650,51670,51690,51710,51730,51750,51770,51790,51810,51830,51850,51870,51890,51910,51930,51950,51970,51990,52010,52030,52050,52070,52090,52110,52130,52150,52170,52190,52210,52230,52250,52270,52290,52310,52330,52350,52370,52390,52410,52430,52450,52470,52490,52510,52530,52550,52570,52590,52610,52630,52650,52670,52690,52710,52730,52750,52770,52790,52810,52830,52850,52870,52890,52910,52930,52950,52970,52990,53010,53030,53050,53070,53090,53110,53130,53150,53170,53190,53210,53230,53250,53270,53290,53310,53330,53350,53370,53390,53410,53430,53450,53470,53490,53510,53530,53550,53570,53590,53610,53630,53650,53670,53690,53710,53730,53750,53770,53790,53810,53830,53850,53870,53890,53910,53930,53950,53970,53990,54010,54030,54050,54070,54090,54110,54130,54150,54170,54190,54210,54230,54250,54270,54290,54310,54330,54350,54370,54390,54410,54430,54450,54470,54490,54510,54530,54550,54570,54590,54610,54630,54650,54670,54690,54710,54730,54750,54770,54790,54810,54830,54850,54870,54890,54910,54930,54950,54970,54990,55010,55030,55050,55070,55090,55110,55130,55150,55170,55190,55210,55230,55250,55270,55290,55310,55330,55350,55370,55390,55410,55430,55450,55470,55490,55510,55530,55550,55570,55590,55610,55630,55650,55670,55690,55710,55730,55750,55770,55790,55810,55830,55850,55870,55890,55910,55930,55950,55970,55990,56010,56030,56050,56070,56090,56110,56130,56150,56170,56190,56210,56230,56250,56270,56290,56310,56330,56350,56370,56390,56410,56430,56450,56470,56490,56510,56530,56550,56570,56590,56610,56630,56650,56670,56690,56710,56730,56750,56770,56790,56810,56830,56850,56870,56890,56910,56930,56950,56970,56990,57010,57030,57050,57070,57090,57110,57130,57150,57170,57190,57210,57230,57250,57270,57290,57310,57330,57350,57370,57390,57410,57430,57450,57470,57490,57510,57530,57550,57570,57590,57610,57630,57650,57670,57690,57710,57730,57750,57770,57790,57810,57830,57850,57870,57890,57910,57930,57950,57970,57990,58010,58030,58050,58070,58090,58110,58130,58150,58170,58190,58210,58230,58250,58270,58290,58310,58330,58350,58370,58390,58410,58430,58450,58470,58490,58510,58530,58550,58570,58590,58610,58630,58650,58670,58690,58710,58730,58750,58770,58790,58810,58830,58850,58870,58890,58910,58930,58950,58970,58990,59010,59030,59050,59070,59090,59110,59130,59150,59170,59190,59210,59230,59250,59270,59290,59310,59330,59350,59370,59390,59410,59430,59450,59470,59490,59510,59530,59550,59570,59590,59610,59630,59650,59670,59690,59710,59730,59750,59770,59790,59810,59830,59850,59870,59890,59910,59930,59950,59970,59990,60010,60030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,20000,20020,20040,20060,20080,20100,20120,20140,20160,20180,20200,20220,20240,20260,20280,20300,20320,20340,20360,20380,20400,20420,20440,20460,20480,20500,20520,20540,20560,20580,20600,20620,20640,20660,20680,20700,20720,20740,20760,20780,20800,20820,20840,20860,20880,20900,20920,20940,20960,20980,21000,21020,21040,21060,21080,21100,21120,21140,21160,21180,21200,21220,21240,21260,21280,21300,21320,21340,21360,21380,21400,21420,21440,21460,21480,21500,21520,21540,21560,21580,21600,21620,21640,21660,21680,21700,21720,21740,21760,21780,21800,21820,21840,21860,21880,21900,21920,21940,21960,21980,22000,22020,22040,22060,22080,22100,22120,22140,22160,22180,22200,22220,22240,22260,22280,22300,22320,22340,22360,22380,22400,22420,22440,22460,22480,22500,22520,22540,22560,22580,22600,22620,22640,22660,22680,22700,22720,22740,22760,22780,22800,22820,22840,22860,22880,22900,22920,22940,22960,22980,23000,23020,23040,23060,23080,23100,23120,23140,23160,23180,23200,23220,23240,23260,23280,23300,23320,23340,23360,23380,23400,23420,23440,23460,23480,23500,23520,23540,23560,23580,23600,23620,23640,23660,23680,23700,23720,23740,23760,23780,23800,23820,23840,23860,23880,23900,23920,23940,23960,23980,24000,24020,24040,24060,24080,24100,24120,24140,24160,24180,24200,24220,24240,24260,24280,24300,24320,24340,24360,24380,24400,24420,24440,24460,24480,24500,24520,24540,24560,24580,24600,24620,24640,24660,24680,24700,24720,24740,24760,24780,24800,24820,24840,24860,24880,24900,24920,24940,24960,24980,25000,25020,25040,25060,25080,25100,25120,25140,25160,25180,25200,25220,25240,25260,25280,25300,25320,25340,25360,25380,25400,25420,25440,25460,25480,25500,25520,25540,25560,25580,25600,25620,25640,25660,25680,25700,25720,25740,25760,25780,25800,25820,25840,25860,25880,25900,25920,25940,25960,25980,26000,26020,26040,26060,26080,26100,26120,26140,26160,26180,26200,26220,26240,26260,26280,26300,26320,26340,26360,26380,26400,26420,26440,26460,26480,26500,26520,26540,26560,26580,26600,26620,26640,26660,26680,26700,26720,26740,26760,26780,26800,26820,26840,26860,26880,26900,26920,26940,26960,26980,27000,27020,27040,27060,27080,27100,27120,27140,27160,27180,27200,27220,27240,27260,27280,27300,27320,27340,27360,27380,27400,27420,27440,27460,27480,27500,27520,27540,27560,27580,27600,27620,27640,27660,27680,27700,27720,27740,27760,27780,27800,27820,27840,27860,27880,27900,27920,27940,27960,27980,28000,28020,28040,28060,28080,28100,28120,28140,28160,28180,28200,28220,28240,28260,28280,28300,28320,28340,28360,28380,28400,28420,28440,28460,28480,28500,28520,28540,28560,28580,28600,28620,28640,28660,28680,28700,28720,28740,28760,28780,28800,28820,28840,28860,28880,28900,28920,28940,28960,28980,29000,29020,29040,29060,29080,29100,29120,29140,29160,29180,29200,29220,29240,29260,29280,29300,29320,29340,29360,29380,29400,29420,29440,29460,29480,29500,29520,29540,29560,29580,29600,29620,29640,29660,29680,29700,29720,29740,29760,29780,29800,29820,29840,29860,29880,29900,29920,29940,29960,29980,30000,30020,30040,30060,30080,30100,30120,30140,30160,30180,30200,30220,30240,30260,30280,30300,30320,30340,30360,30380,30400,30420,30440,30460,30480,30500,30520,30540,30560,30580,30600,30620,30640,30660,30680,30700,30720,30740,30760,30780,30800,30820,30840,30860,30880,30900,30920,30940,30960,30980,31000,31020,31040,31060,31080,31100,31120,31140,31160,31180,31200,31220,31240,31260,31280,31300,31320,31340,31360,31380,31400,31420,31440,31460,31480,31500,31520,31540,31560,31580,31600,31620,31640,31660,31680,31700,31720,31740,31760,31780,31800,31820,31840,31860,31880,31900,31920,31940,31960,31980,32000,32020,32040,32060,32080,32100,32120,32140,32160,32180,32200,32220,32240,32260,32280,32300,32320,32340,32360,32380,32400,32420,32440,32460,32480,32500,32520,32540,32560,32580,32600,32620,32640,32660,32680,32700,32720,32740,32760,32780,32800,32820,32840,32860,32880,32900,32920,32940,32960,32980,33000,33020,33040,33060,33080,33100,33120,33140,33160,33180,33200,33220,33240,33260,33280,33300,33320,33340,33360,33380,33400,33420,33440,33460,33480,33500,33520,33540,33560,33580,33600,33620,33640,33660,33680,33700,33720,33740,33760,33780,33800,33820,33840,33860,33880,33900,33920,33940,33960,33980,34000,34020,34040,34060,34080,34100,34120,34140,34160,34180,34200,34220,34240,34260,34280,34300,34320,34340,34360,34380,34400,34420,34440,34460,34480,34500,34520,34540,34560,34580,34600,34620,34640,34660,34680,34700,34720,34740,34760,34780,34800,34820,34840,34860,34880,34900,34920,34940,34960,34980,35000,35020,35040,35060,35080,35100,35120,35140,35160,35180,35200,35220,35240,35260,35280,35300,35320,35340,35360,35380,35400,35420,35440,35460,35480,35500,35520,35540,35560,35580,35600,35620,35640,35660,35680,35700,35720,35740,35760,35780,35800,35820,35840,35860,35880,35900,35920,35940,35960,35980,36000,36020,36040,36060,36080,36100,36120,36140,36160,36180,36200,36220,36240,36260,36280,36300,36320,36340,36360,36380,36400,36420,36440,36460,36480,36500,36520,36540,36560,36580,36600,36620,36640,36660,36680,36700,36720,36740,36760,36780,36800,36820,36840,36860,36880,36900,36920,36940,36960,36980,37000,37020,37040,37060,37080,37100,37120,37140,37160,37180,37200,37220,37240,37260,37280,37300,37320,37340,37360,37380,37400,37420,37440,37460,37480,37500,37520,37540,37560,37580,37600,37620,37640,37660,37680,37700,37720,37740,37760,37780,37800,37820,37840,37860,37880,37900,37920,37940,37960,37980,38000,38020,38040,38060,38080,38100,38120,38140,38160,38180,38200,38220,38240,38260,38280,38300,38320,38340,38360,38380,38400,38420,38440,38460,38480,38500,38520,38540,38560,38580,38600,38620,38640,38660,38680,38700,38720,38740,38760,38780,38800,38820,38840,38860,38880,38900,38920,38940,38960,38980,39000,39020,39040,39060,39080,39100,39120,39140,39160,39180,39200,39220,39240,39260,39280,39300,39320,39340,39360,39380,39400,39420,39440,39460,39480,39500,39520,39540,39560,39580,39600,39620,39640,39660,39680,39700,39720,39740,39760,39780,39800,39820,39840,39860,39880,39900,39920,39940,39960,39980,40000,40020,40040,40060,40080,40100,40120,40140,40160,40180,40200,40220,40240,40260,40280,40300,40320,40340,40360,40380,40400,40420,40440,40460,40480,40500,40520,40540,40560,40580,40600,40620,40640,40660,40680,40700,40720,40740,40760,40780,40800,40820,40840,40860,40880,40900,40920,40940,40960,40980,41000,41020,41040,41060,41080,41100,41120,41140,41160,41180,41200,41220,41240,41260,41280,41300,41320,41340,41360,41380,41400,41420,41440,41460,41480,41500,41520,41540,41560,41580,41600,41620,41640,41660,41680,41700,41720,41740,41760,41780,41800,41820,41840,41860,41880,41900,41920,41940,41960,41980,42000,42020,42040,42060,42080,42100,42120,42140,42160,42180,42200,42220,42240,42260,42280,42300,42320,42340,42360,42380,42400,42420,42440,42460,42480,42500,42520,42540,42560,42580,42600,42620,42640,42660,42680,42700,42720,42740,42760,42780,42800,42820,42840,42860,42880,42900,42920,42940,42960,42980,43000,43020,43040,43060,43080,43100,43120,43140,43160,43180,43200,43220,43240,43260,43280,43300,43320,43340,43360,43380,43400,43420,43440,43460,43480,43500,43520,43540,43560,43580,43600,43620,43640,43660,43680,43700,43720,43740,43760,43780,43800,43820,43840,43860,43880,43900,43920,43940,43960,43980,44000,44020,44040,44060,44080,44100,44120,44140,44160,44180,44200,44220,44240,44260,44280,44300,44320,44340,44360,44380,44400,44420,44440,44460,44480,44500,44520,44540,44560,44580,44600,44620,44640,44660,44680,44700,44720,44740,44760,44780,44800,44820,44840,44860,44880,44900,44920,44940,44960,44980,45000,45020,45040,45060,45080,45100,45120,45140,45160,45180,45200,45220,45240,45260,45280,45300,45320,45340,45360,45380,45400,45420,45440,45460,45480,45500,45520,45540,45560,45580,45600,45620,45640,45660,45680,45700,45720,45740,45760,45780,45800,45820,45840,45860,45880,45900,45920,45940,45960,45980,46000,46020,46040,46060,46080,46100,46120,46140,46160,46180,46200,46220,46240,46260,46280,46300,46320,46340,46360,46380,46400,46420,46440,46460,46480,46500,46520,46540,46560,46580,46600,46620,46640,46660,46680,46700,46720,46740,46760,46780,46800,46820,46840,46860,46880,46900,46920,46940,46960,46980,47000,47020,47040,47060,47080,47100,47120,47140,47160,47180,47200,47220,47240,47260,47280,47300,47320,47340,47360,47380,47400,47420,47440,47460,47480,47500,47520,47540,47560,47580,47600,47620,47640,47660,47680,47700,47720,47740,47760,47780,47800,47820,47840,47860,47880,47900,47920,47940,47960,47980,48000,48020,48040,48060,48080,48100,48120,48140,48160,48180,48200,48220,48240,48260,48280,48300,48320,48340,48360,48380,48400,48420,48440,48460,48480,48500,48520,48540,48560,48580,48600,48620,48640,48660,48680,48700,48720,48740,48760,48780,48800,48820,48840,48860,48880,48900,48920,48940,48960,48980,49000,49020,49040,49060,49080,49100,49120,49140,49160,49180,49200,49220,49240,49260,49280,49300,49320,49340,49360,49380,49400,49420,49440,49460,49480,49500,49520,49540,49560,49580,49600,49620,49640,49660,49680,49700,49720,49740,49760,49780,49800,49820,49840,49860,49880,49900,49920,49940,49960,49980,50000,50020,50040,50060,50080,50100,50120,50140,50160,50180,50200,50220,50240,50260,50280,50300,50320,50340,50360,50380,50400,50420,50440,50460,50480,50500,50520,50540,50560,50580,50600,50620,50640,50660,50680,50700,50720,50740,50760,50780,50800,50820,50840,50860,50880,50900,50920,50940,50960,50980,51000,51020,51040,51060,51080,51100,51120,51140,51160,51180,51200,51220,51240,51260,51280,51300,51320,51340,51360,51380,51400,51420,51440,51460,51480,51500,51520,51540,51560,51580,51600,51620,51640,51660,51680,51700,51720,51740,51760,51780,51800,51820,51840,51860,51880,51900,51920,51940,51960,51980,52000,52020,52040,52060,52080,52100,52120,52140,52160,52180,52200,52220,52240,52260,52280,52300,52320,52340,52360,52380,52400,52420,52440,52460,52480,52500,52520,52540,52560,52580,52600,52620,52640,52660,52680,52700,52720,52740,52760,52780,52800,52820,52840,52860,52880,52900,52920,52940,52960,52980,53000,53020,53040,53060,53080,53100,53120,53140,53160,53180,53200,53220,53240,53260,53280,53300,53320,53340,53360,53380,53400,53420,53440,53460,53480,53500,53520,53540,53560,53580,53600,53620,53640,53660,53680,53700,53720,53740,53760,53780,53800,53820,53840,53860,53880,53900,53920,53940,53960,53980,54000,54020,54040,54060,54080,54100,54120,54140,54160,54180,54200,54220,54240,54260,54280,54300,54320,54340,54360,54380,54400,54420,54440,54460,54480,54500,54520,54540,54560,54580,54600,54620,54640,54660,54680,54700,54720,54740,54760,54780,54800,54820,54840,54860,54880,54900,54920,54940,54960,54980,55000,55020,55040,55060,55080,55100,55120,55140,55160,55180,55200,55220,55240,55260,55280,55300,55320,55340,55360,55380,55400,55420,55440,55460,55480,55500,55520,55540,55560,55580,55600,55620,55640,55660,55680,55700,55720,55740,55760,55780,55800,55820,55840,55860,55880,55900,55920,55940,55960,55980,56000,56020,56040,56060,56080,56100,56120,56140,56160,56180,56200,56220,56240,56260,56280,56300,56320,56340,56360,56380,56400,56420,56440,56460,56480,56500,56520,56540,56560,56580,56600,56620,56640,56660,56680,56700,56720,56740,56760,56780,56800,56820,56840,56860,56880,56900,56920,56940,56960,56980,57000,57020,57040,57060,57080,57100,57120,57140,57160,57180,57200,57220,57240,57260,57280,57300,57320,57340,57360,57380,57400,57420,57440,57460,57480,57500,57520,57540,57560,57580,57600,57620,57640,57660,57680,57700,57720,57740,57760,57780,57800,57820,57840,57860,57880,57900,57920,57940,57960,57980,58000,58020,58040,58060,58080,58100,58120,58140,58160,58180,58200,58220,58240,58260,58280,58300,58320,58340,58360,58380,58400,58420,58440,58460,58480,58500,58520,58540,58560,58580,58600,58620,58640,58660,58680,58700,58720,58740,58760,58780,58800,58820,58840,58860,58880,58900,58920,58940,58960,58980,59000,59020,59040,59060,59080,59100,59120,59140,59160,59180,59200,59220,59240,59260,59280,59300,59320,59340,59360,59380,59400,59420,59440,59460,59480,59500,59520,59540,59560,59580,59600,59620,59640,59660,59680,59700,59720,59740,59760,59780,59800,59820,59840,59860,59880,59900,59920,59940,59960,59980],"target":[[0,120],[75,100],[175,80],[225,60],[250,40]],"lateness":[[0,0]]} diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/reference.ts b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/reference.ts index ecd7a2fd3aa..ceb57719220 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/reference.ts +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/reference.ts @@ -151,6 +151,23 @@ export class Estimator { if (this.#origin !== undefined) this.#ended = true; } + /** + * How late the slowest frame in the window arrived against the fastest, in milliseconds: + * NetEq's maximum delay, which widens the time stretch's band rather than the target. Each + * extreme is the oldest on a tie, as the reference is. + */ + get lateness(): number { + let fast: Arrival | undefined; + let slow: Arrival | undefined; + for (const entry of this.#history) { + const key = entry.arrival - entry.media; + if (fast === undefined || key < fast.arrival - fast.media) fast = entry; + if (slow === undefined || key > slow.arrival - slow.media) slow = entry; + } + if (fast === undefined || slow === undefined) return 0; + return Math.max(0, slow.arrival - fast.arrival - (slow.media - fast.media)); + } + /** The target the receiver holds, in milliseconds. */ get target(): number { let cumulative = 0; diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/reorder.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/reorder.json index 9db52a7e28f..96777eac2f9 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/reorder.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/reorder.json @@ -1 +1 @@ -{"name":"reorder","about":"Every other run of five frames delivered after the run that follows it, as newest-first delivery does to a sender's flush. Each held-back run is measured against the fastest frame before it, so the target covers waiting for it; the first one precedes every frame observed and is not measured.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030],"media":[100,120,140,160,180,0,20,40,60,80,300,320,340,360,380,200,220,240,260,280,500,520,540,560,580,400,420,440,460,480,700,720,740,760,780,600,620,640,660,680,900,920,940,960,980,800,820,840,860,880,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880],"target":[[0,120],[25,240]]} +{"name":"reorder","about":"Every other run of five frames delivered after the run that follows it, as newest-first delivery does to a sender's flush. Each held-back run is measured against the fastest frame before it, so the target covers waiting for it; the first one precedes every frame observed and is not measured.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030],"media":[100,120,140,160,180,0,20,40,60,80,300,320,340,360,380,200,220,240,260,280,500,520,540,560,580,400,420,440,460,480,700,720,740,760,780,600,620,640,660,680,900,920,940,960,980,800,820,840,860,880,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880],"target":[[0,120],[25,240]],"lateness":[[0,0]]} diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/silence.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/silence.json index 60df4c38167..4be63e5455c 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/silence.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/silence.json @@ -1 +1 @@ -{"name":"silence","about":"Even audio, a declared end and 60 s of silence, 5 s more, a declared 100 ms pause inside one interval, 5 s more, then an undeclared 30 s gap. Unlike `idle`, a declared silence is not evidence, so the target holds through both; the undeclared gap still relaxes it, since an end covers only the silence it declares.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,70050,70070,70090,70110,70130,70150,70170,70190,70210,70230,70250,70270,70290,70310,70330,70350,70370,70390,70410,70430,70450,70470,70490,70510,70530,70550,70570,70590,70610,70630,70650,70670,70690,70710,70730,70750,70770,70790,70810,70830,70850,70870,70890,70910,70930,70950,70970,70990,71010,71030,71050,71070,71090,71110,71130,71150,71170,71190,71210,71230,71250,71270,71290,71310,71330,71350,71370,71390,71410,71430,71450,71470,71490,71510,71530,71550,71570,71590,71610,71630,71650,71670,71690,71710,71730,71750,71770,71790,71810,71830,71850,71870,71890,71910,71930,71950,71970,71990,72010,72030,72050,72070,72090,72110,72130,72150,72170,72190,72210,72230,72250,72270,72290,72310,72330,72350,72370,72390,72410,72430,72450,72470,72490,72510,72530,72550,72570,72590,72610,72630,72650,72670,72690,72710,72730,72750,72770,72790,72810,72830,72850,72870,72890,72910,72930,72950,72970,72990,73010,73030,73050,73070,73090,73110,73130,73150,73170,73190,73210,73230,73250,73270,73290,73310,73330,73350,73370,73390,73410,73430,73450,73470,73490,73510,73530,73550,73570,73590,73610,73630,73650,73670,73690,73710,73730,73750,73770,73790,73810,73830,73850,73870,73890,73910,73930,73950,73970,73990,74010,74030,74050,74070,74090,74110,74130,74150,74170,74190,74210,74230,74250,74270,74290,74310,74330,74350,74370,74390,74410,74430,74450,74470,74490,74510,74530,74550,74570,74590,74610,74630,74650,74670,74690,74710,74730,74750,74770,74790,74810,74830,74850,74870,74890,74910,74930,74950,74970,74990,75010,75030,75050,75070,75090,75110,75130,75150,75170,75190,75210,75230,75350,75370,75390,75410,75430,75450,75470,75490,75510,75530,75550,75570,75590,75610,75630,75650,75670,75690,75710,75730,75750,75770,75790,75810,75830,75850,75870,75890,75910,75930,75950,75970,75990,76010,76030,76050,76070,76090,76110,76130,76150,76170,76190,76210,76230,76250,76270,76290,76310,76330,76350,76370,76390,76410,76430,76450,76470,76490,76510,76530,76550,76570,76590,76610,76630,76650,76670,76690,76710,76730,76750,76770,76790,76810,76830,76850,76870,76890,76910,76930,76950,76970,76990,77010,77030,77050,77070,77090,77110,77130,77150,77170,77190,77210,77230,77250,77270,77290,77310,77330,77350,77370,77390,77410,77430,77450,77470,77490,77510,77530,77550,77570,77590,77610,77630,77650,77670,77690,77710,77730,77750,77770,77790,77810,77830,77850,77870,77890,77910,77930,77950,77970,77990,78010,78030,78050,78070,78090,78110,78130,78150,78170,78190,78210,78230,78250,78270,78290,78310,78330,78350,78370,78390,78410,78430,78450,78470,78490,78510,78530,78550,78570,78590,78610,78630,78650,78670,78690,78710,78730,78750,78770,78790,78810,78830,78850,78870,78890,78910,78930,78950,78970,78990,79010,79030,79050,79070,79090,79110,79130,79150,79170,79190,79210,79230,79250,79270,79290,79310,79330,79350,79370,79390,79410,79430,79450,79470,79490,79510,79530,79550,79570,79590,79610,79630,79650,79670,79690,79710,79730,79750,79770,79790,79810,79830,79850,79870,79890,79910,79930,79950,79970,79990,80010,80030,80050,80070,80090,80110,80130,110150,110170,110190,110210,110230,110250,110270,110290,110310,110330,110350,110370,110390,110410,110430,110450,110470,110490,110510,110530,110550,110570,110590,110610,110630,110650,110670,110690,110710,110730,110750,110770,110790,110810,110830,110850,110870,110890,110910,110930,110950,110970,110990,111010,111030,111050,111070,111090,111110,111130,111150,111170,111190,111210,111230,111250,111270,111290,111310,111330,111350,111370,111390,111410,111430,111450,111470,111490,111510,111530,111550,111570,111590,111610,111630,111650,111670,111690,111710,111730,111750,111770,111790,111810,111830,111850,111870,111890,111910,111930,111950,111970,111990,112010,112030,112050,112070,112090,112110,112130,112150,112170,112190,112210,112230,112250,112270,112290,112310,112330,112350,112370,112390,112410,112430,112450,112470,112490,112510,112530,112550,112570,112590,112610,112630,112650,112670,112690,112710,112730,112750,112770,112790,112810,112830,112850,112870,112890,112910,112930,112950,112970,112990,113010,113030,113050,113070,113090,113110,113130,113150,113170,113190,113210,113230,113250,113270,113290,113310,113330,113350,113370,113390,113410,113430,113450,113470,113490,113510,113530,113550,113570,113590,113610,113630,113650,113670,113690,113710,113730,113750,113770,113790,113810,113830,113850,113870,113890,113910,113930,113950,113970,113990,114010,114030,114050,114070,114090,114110,114130,114150,114170,114190,114210,114230,114250,114270,114290,114310,114330,114350,114370,114390,114410,114430,114450,114470,114490,114510,114530,114550,114570,114590,114610,114630,114650,114670,114690,114710,114730,114750,114770,114790,114810,114830,114850,114870,114890,114910,114930,114950,114970,114990,115010,115030,115050,115070,115090,115110,115130,115150,115170,115190,115210,115230,115250,115270,115290,115310,115330,115350,115370,115390,115410,115430,115450,115470,115490,115510,115530,115550,115570,115590,115610,115630,115650,115670,115690,115710,115730,115750,115770,115790,115810,115830,115850,115870,115890,115910,115930,115950,115970,115990,116010,116030,116050,116070,116090,116110,116130,116150,116170,116190,116210,116230,116250,116270,116290,116310,116330,116350,116370,116390,116410,116430,116450,116470,116490,116510,116530,116550,116570,116590,116610,116630,116650,116670,116690,116710,116730,116750,116770,116790,116810,116830,116850,116870,116890,116910,116930,116950,116970,116990,117010,117030,117050,117070,117090,117110,117130,117150,117170,117190,117210,117230,117250,117270,117290,117310,117330,117350,117370,117390,117410,117430,117450,117470,117490,117510,117530,117550,117570,117590,117610,117630,117650,117670,117690,117710,117730,117750,117770,117790,117810,117830,117850,117870,117890,117910,117930,117950,117970,117990,118010,118030,118050,118070,118090,118110,118130,118150,118170,118190,118210,118230,118250,118270,118290,118310,118330,118350,118370,118390,118410,118430,118450,118470,118490,118510,118530,118550,118570,118590,118610,118630,118650,118670,118690,118710,118730,118750,118770,118790,118810,118830,118850,118870,118890,118910,118930,118950,118970,118990,119010,119030,119050,119070,119090,119110,119130,119150,119170,119190,119210,119230,119250,119270,119290,119310,119330,119350,119370,119390,119410,119430,119450,119470,119490,119510,119530,119550,119570,119590,119610,119630,119650,119670,119690,119710,119730,119750,119770,119790,119810,119830,119850,119870,119890,119910,119930,119950,119970,119990,120010,120030,120050,120070,120090,120110,120130],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,70000,70020,70040,70060,70080,70100,70120,70140,70160,70180,70200,70220,70240,70260,70280,70300,70320,70340,70360,70380,70400,70420,70440,70460,70480,70500,70520,70540,70560,70580,70600,70620,70640,70660,70680,70700,70720,70740,70760,70780,70800,70820,70840,70860,70880,70900,70920,70940,70960,70980,71000,71020,71040,71060,71080,71100,71120,71140,71160,71180,71200,71220,71240,71260,71280,71300,71320,71340,71360,71380,71400,71420,71440,71460,71480,71500,71520,71540,71560,71580,71600,71620,71640,71660,71680,71700,71720,71740,71760,71780,71800,71820,71840,71860,71880,71900,71920,71940,71960,71980,72000,72020,72040,72060,72080,72100,72120,72140,72160,72180,72200,72220,72240,72260,72280,72300,72320,72340,72360,72380,72400,72420,72440,72460,72480,72500,72520,72540,72560,72580,72600,72620,72640,72660,72680,72700,72720,72740,72760,72780,72800,72820,72840,72860,72880,72900,72920,72940,72960,72980,73000,73020,73040,73060,73080,73100,73120,73140,73160,73180,73200,73220,73240,73260,73280,73300,73320,73340,73360,73380,73400,73420,73440,73460,73480,73500,73520,73540,73560,73580,73600,73620,73640,73660,73680,73700,73720,73740,73760,73780,73800,73820,73840,73860,73880,73900,73920,73940,73960,73980,74000,74020,74040,74060,74080,74100,74120,74140,74160,74180,74200,74220,74240,74260,74280,74300,74320,74340,74360,74380,74400,74420,74440,74460,74480,74500,74520,74540,74560,74580,74600,74620,74640,74660,74680,74700,74720,74740,74760,74780,74800,74820,74840,74860,74880,74900,74920,74940,74960,74980,75000,75020,75040,75060,75080,75100,75120,75140,75160,75180,75300,75320,75340,75360,75380,75400,75420,75440,75460,75480,75500,75520,75540,75560,75580,75600,75620,75640,75660,75680,75700,75720,75740,75760,75780,75800,75820,75840,75860,75880,75900,75920,75940,75960,75980,76000,76020,76040,76060,76080,76100,76120,76140,76160,76180,76200,76220,76240,76260,76280,76300,76320,76340,76360,76380,76400,76420,76440,76460,76480,76500,76520,76540,76560,76580,76600,76620,76640,76660,76680,76700,76720,76740,76760,76780,76800,76820,76840,76860,76880,76900,76920,76940,76960,76980,77000,77020,77040,77060,77080,77100,77120,77140,77160,77180,77200,77220,77240,77260,77280,77300,77320,77340,77360,77380,77400,77420,77440,77460,77480,77500,77520,77540,77560,77580,77600,77620,77640,77660,77680,77700,77720,77740,77760,77780,77800,77820,77840,77860,77880,77900,77920,77940,77960,77980,78000,78020,78040,78060,78080,78100,78120,78140,78160,78180,78200,78220,78240,78260,78280,78300,78320,78340,78360,78380,78400,78420,78440,78460,78480,78500,78520,78540,78560,78580,78600,78620,78640,78660,78680,78700,78720,78740,78760,78780,78800,78820,78840,78860,78880,78900,78920,78940,78960,78980,79000,79020,79040,79060,79080,79100,79120,79140,79160,79180,79200,79220,79240,79260,79280,79300,79320,79340,79360,79380,79400,79420,79440,79460,79480,79500,79520,79540,79560,79580,79600,79620,79640,79660,79680,79700,79720,79740,79760,79780,79800,79820,79840,79860,79880,79900,79920,79940,79960,79980,80000,80020,80040,80060,80080,110100,110120,110140,110160,110180,110200,110220,110240,110260,110280,110300,110320,110340,110360,110380,110400,110420,110440,110460,110480,110500,110520,110540,110560,110580,110600,110620,110640,110660,110680,110700,110720,110740,110760,110780,110800,110820,110840,110860,110880,110900,110920,110940,110960,110980,111000,111020,111040,111060,111080,111100,111120,111140,111160,111180,111200,111220,111240,111260,111280,111300,111320,111340,111360,111380,111400,111420,111440,111460,111480,111500,111520,111540,111560,111580,111600,111620,111640,111660,111680,111700,111720,111740,111760,111780,111800,111820,111840,111860,111880,111900,111920,111940,111960,111980,112000,112020,112040,112060,112080,112100,112120,112140,112160,112180,112200,112220,112240,112260,112280,112300,112320,112340,112360,112380,112400,112420,112440,112460,112480,112500,112520,112540,112560,112580,112600,112620,112640,112660,112680,112700,112720,112740,112760,112780,112800,112820,112840,112860,112880,112900,112920,112940,112960,112980,113000,113020,113040,113060,113080,113100,113120,113140,113160,113180,113200,113220,113240,113260,113280,113300,113320,113340,113360,113380,113400,113420,113440,113460,113480,113500,113520,113540,113560,113580,113600,113620,113640,113660,113680,113700,113720,113740,113760,113780,113800,113820,113840,113860,113880,113900,113920,113940,113960,113980,114000,114020,114040,114060,114080,114100,114120,114140,114160,114180,114200,114220,114240,114260,114280,114300,114320,114340,114360,114380,114400,114420,114440,114460,114480,114500,114520,114540,114560,114580,114600,114620,114640,114660,114680,114700,114720,114740,114760,114780,114800,114820,114840,114860,114880,114900,114920,114940,114960,114980,115000,115020,115040,115060,115080,115100,115120,115140,115160,115180,115200,115220,115240,115260,115280,115300,115320,115340,115360,115380,115400,115420,115440,115460,115480,115500,115520,115540,115560,115580,115600,115620,115640,115660,115680,115700,115720,115740,115760,115780,115800,115820,115840,115860,115880,115900,115920,115940,115960,115980,116000,116020,116040,116060,116080,116100,116120,116140,116160,116180,116200,116220,116240,116260,116280,116300,116320,116340,116360,116380,116400,116420,116440,116460,116480,116500,116520,116540,116560,116580,116600,116620,116640,116660,116680,116700,116720,116740,116760,116780,116800,116820,116840,116860,116880,116900,116920,116940,116960,116980,117000,117020,117040,117060,117080,117100,117120,117140,117160,117180,117200,117220,117240,117260,117280,117300,117320,117340,117360,117380,117400,117420,117440,117460,117480,117500,117520,117540,117560,117580,117600,117620,117640,117660,117680,117700,117720,117740,117760,117780,117800,117820,117840,117860,117880,117900,117920,117940,117960,117980,118000,118020,118040,118060,118080,118100,118120,118140,118160,118180,118200,118220,118240,118260,118280,118300,118320,118340,118360,118380,118400,118420,118440,118460,118480,118500,118520,118540,118560,118580,118600,118620,118640,118660,118680,118700,118720,118740,118760,118780,118800,118820,118840,118860,118880,118900,118920,118940,118960,118980,119000,119020,119040,119060,119080,119100,119120,119140,119160,119180,119200,119220,119240,119260,119280,119300,119320,119340,119360,119380,119400,119420,119440,119460,119480,119500,119520,119540,119560,119580,119600,119620,119640,119660,119680,119700,119720,119740,119760,119780,119800,119820,119840,119860,119880,119900,119920,119940,119960,119980,120000,120020,120040,120060,120080],"ends":[500,760],"target":[[0,120],[75,100],[175,80],[225,60],[250,40],[1000,100],[1070,80],[1120,60],[1145,40]]} +{"name":"silence","about":"Even audio, a declared end and 60 s of silence, 5 s more, a declared 100 ms pause inside one interval, 5 s more, then an undeclared 30 s gap. Unlike `idle`, a declared silence is not evidence, so the target holds through both; the undeclared gap still relaxes it, since an end covers only the silence it declares.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,70050,70070,70090,70110,70130,70150,70170,70190,70210,70230,70250,70270,70290,70310,70330,70350,70370,70390,70410,70430,70450,70470,70490,70510,70530,70550,70570,70590,70610,70630,70650,70670,70690,70710,70730,70750,70770,70790,70810,70830,70850,70870,70890,70910,70930,70950,70970,70990,71010,71030,71050,71070,71090,71110,71130,71150,71170,71190,71210,71230,71250,71270,71290,71310,71330,71350,71370,71390,71410,71430,71450,71470,71490,71510,71530,71550,71570,71590,71610,71630,71650,71670,71690,71710,71730,71750,71770,71790,71810,71830,71850,71870,71890,71910,71930,71950,71970,71990,72010,72030,72050,72070,72090,72110,72130,72150,72170,72190,72210,72230,72250,72270,72290,72310,72330,72350,72370,72390,72410,72430,72450,72470,72490,72510,72530,72550,72570,72590,72610,72630,72650,72670,72690,72710,72730,72750,72770,72790,72810,72830,72850,72870,72890,72910,72930,72950,72970,72990,73010,73030,73050,73070,73090,73110,73130,73150,73170,73190,73210,73230,73250,73270,73290,73310,73330,73350,73370,73390,73410,73430,73450,73470,73490,73510,73530,73550,73570,73590,73610,73630,73650,73670,73690,73710,73730,73750,73770,73790,73810,73830,73850,73870,73890,73910,73930,73950,73970,73990,74010,74030,74050,74070,74090,74110,74130,74150,74170,74190,74210,74230,74250,74270,74290,74310,74330,74350,74370,74390,74410,74430,74450,74470,74490,74510,74530,74550,74570,74590,74610,74630,74650,74670,74690,74710,74730,74750,74770,74790,74810,74830,74850,74870,74890,74910,74930,74950,74970,74990,75010,75030,75050,75070,75090,75110,75130,75150,75170,75190,75210,75230,75350,75370,75390,75410,75430,75450,75470,75490,75510,75530,75550,75570,75590,75610,75630,75650,75670,75690,75710,75730,75750,75770,75790,75810,75830,75850,75870,75890,75910,75930,75950,75970,75990,76010,76030,76050,76070,76090,76110,76130,76150,76170,76190,76210,76230,76250,76270,76290,76310,76330,76350,76370,76390,76410,76430,76450,76470,76490,76510,76530,76550,76570,76590,76610,76630,76650,76670,76690,76710,76730,76750,76770,76790,76810,76830,76850,76870,76890,76910,76930,76950,76970,76990,77010,77030,77050,77070,77090,77110,77130,77150,77170,77190,77210,77230,77250,77270,77290,77310,77330,77350,77370,77390,77410,77430,77450,77470,77490,77510,77530,77550,77570,77590,77610,77630,77650,77670,77690,77710,77730,77750,77770,77790,77810,77830,77850,77870,77890,77910,77930,77950,77970,77990,78010,78030,78050,78070,78090,78110,78130,78150,78170,78190,78210,78230,78250,78270,78290,78310,78330,78350,78370,78390,78410,78430,78450,78470,78490,78510,78530,78550,78570,78590,78610,78630,78650,78670,78690,78710,78730,78750,78770,78790,78810,78830,78850,78870,78890,78910,78930,78950,78970,78990,79010,79030,79050,79070,79090,79110,79130,79150,79170,79190,79210,79230,79250,79270,79290,79310,79330,79350,79370,79390,79410,79430,79450,79470,79490,79510,79530,79550,79570,79590,79610,79630,79650,79670,79690,79710,79730,79750,79770,79790,79810,79830,79850,79870,79890,79910,79930,79950,79970,79990,80010,80030,80050,80070,80090,80110,80130,110150,110170,110190,110210,110230,110250,110270,110290,110310,110330,110350,110370,110390,110410,110430,110450,110470,110490,110510,110530,110550,110570,110590,110610,110630,110650,110670,110690,110710,110730,110750,110770,110790,110810,110830,110850,110870,110890,110910,110930,110950,110970,110990,111010,111030,111050,111070,111090,111110,111130,111150,111170,111190,111210,111230,111250,111270,111290,111310,111330,111350,111370,111390,111410,111430,111450,111470,111490,111510,111530,111550,111570,111590,111610,111630,111650,111670,111690,111710,111730,111750,111770,111790,111810,111830,111850,111870,111890,111910,111930,111950,111970,111990,112010,112030,112050,112070,112090,112110,112130,112150,112170,112190,112210,112230,112250,112270,112290,112310,112330,112350,112370,112390,112410,112430,112450,112470,112490,112510,112530,112550,112570,112590,112610,112630,112650,112670,112690,112710,112730,112750,112770,112790,112810,112830,112850,112870,112890,112910,112930,112950,112970,112990,113010,113030,113050,113070,113090,113110,113130,113150,113170,113190,113210,113230,113250,113270,113290,113310,113330,113350,113370,113390,113410,113430,113450,113470,113490,113510,113530,113550,113570,113590,113610,113630,113650,113670,113690,113710,113730,113750,113770,113790,113810,113830,113850,113870,113890,113910,113930,113950,113970,113990,114010,114030,114050,114070,114090,114110,114130,114150,114170,114190,114210,114230,114250,114270,114290,114310,114330,114350,114370,114390,114410,114430,114450,114470,114490,114510,114530,114550,114570,114590,114610,114630,114650,114670,114690,114710,114730,114750,114770,114790,114810,114830,114850,114870,114890,114910,114930,114950,114970,114990,115010,115030,115050,115070,115090,115110,115130,115150,115170,115190,115210,115230,115250,115270,115290,115310,115330,115350,115370,115390,115410,115430,115450,115470,115490,115510,115530,115550,115570,115590,115610,115630,115650,115670,115690,115710,115730,115750,115770,115790,115810,115830,115850,115870,115890,115910,115930,115950,115970,115990,116010,116030,116050,116070,116090,116110,116130,116150,116170,116190,116210,116230,116250,116270,116290,116310,116330,116350,116370,116390,116410,116430,116450,116470,116490,116510,116530,116550,116570,116590,116610,116630,116650,116670,116690,116710,116730,116750,116770,116790,116810,116830,116850,116870,116890,116910,116930,116950,116970,116990,117010,117030,117050,117070,117090,117110,117130,117150,117170,117190,117210,117230,117250,117270,117290,117310,117330,117350,117370,117390,117410,117430,117450,117470,117490,117510,117530,117550,117570,117590,117610,117630,117650,117670,117690,117710,117730,117750,117770,117790,117810,117830,117850,117870,117890,117910,117930,117950,117970,117990,118010,118030,118050,118070,118090,118110,118130,118150,118170,118190,118210,118230,118250,118270,118290,118310,118330,118350,118370,118390,118410,118430,118450,118470,118490,118510,118530,118550,118570,118590,118610,118630,118650,118670,118690,118710,118730,118750,118770,118790,118810,118830,118850,118870,118890,118910,118930,118950,118970,118990,119010,119030,119050,119070,119090,119110,119130,119150,119170,119190,119210,119230,119250,119270,119290,119310,119330,119350,119370,119390,119410,119430,119450,119470,119490,119510,119530,119550,119570,119590,119610,119630,119650,119670,119690,119710,119730,119750,119770,119790,119810,119830,119850,119870,119890,119910,119930,119950,119970,119990,120010,120030,120050,120070,120090,120110,120130],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,70000,70020,70040,70060,70080,70100,70120,70140,70160,70180,70200,70220,70240,70260,70280,70300,70320,70340,70360,70380,70400,70420,70440,70460,70480,70500,70520,70540,70560,70580,70600,70620,70640,70660,70680,70700,70720,70740,70760,70780,70800,70820,70840,70860,70880,70900,70920,70940,70960,70980,71000,71020,71040,71060,71080,71100,71120,71140,71160,71180,71200,71220,71240,71260,71280,71300,71320,71340,71360,71380,71400,71420,71440,71460,71480,71500,71520,71540,71560,71580,71600,71620,71640,71660,71680,71700,71720,71740,71760,71780,71800,71820,71840,71860,71880,71900,71920,71940,71960,71980,72000,72020,72040,72060,72080,72100,72120,72140,72160,72180,72200,72220,72240,72260,72280,72300,72320,72340,72360,72380,72400,72420,72440,72460,72480,72500,72520,72540,72560,72580,72600,72620,72640,72660,72680,72700,72720,72740,72760,72780,72800,72820,72840,72860,72880,72900,72920,72940,72960,72980,73000,73020,73040,73060,73080,73100,73120,73140,73160,73180,73200,73220,73240,73260,73280,73300,73320,73340,73360,73380,73400,73420,73440,73460,73480,73500,73520,73540,73560,73580,73600,73620,73640,73660,73680,73700,73720,73740,73760,73780,73800,73820,73840,73860,73880,73900,73920,73940,73960,73980,74000,74020,74040,74060,74080,74100,74120,74140,74160,74180,74200,74220,74240,74260,74280,74300,74320,74340,74360,74380,74400,74420,74440,74460,74480,74500,74520,74540,74560,74580,74600,74620,74640,74660,74680,74700,74720,74740,74760,74780,74800,74820,74840,74860,74880,74900,74920,74940,74960,74980,75000,75020,75040,75060,75080,75100,75120,75140,75160,75180,75300,75320,75340,75360,75380,75400,75420,75440,75460,75480,75500,75520,75540,75560,75580,75600,75620,75640,75660,75680,75700,75720,75740,75760,75780,75800,75820,75840,75860,75880,75900,75920,75940,75960,75980,76000,76020,76040,76060,76080,76100,76120,76140,76160,76180,76200,76220,76240,76260,76280,76300,76320,76340,76360,76380,76400,76420,76440,76460,76480,76500,76520,76540,76560,76580,76600,76620,76640,76660,76680,76700,76720,76740,76760,76780,76800,76820,76840,76860,76880,76900,76920,76940,76960,76980,77000,77020,77040,77060,77080,77100,77120,77140,77160,77180,77200,77220,77240,77260,77280,77300,77320,77340,77360,77380,77400,77420,77440,77460,77480,77500,77520,77540,77560,77580,77600,77620,77640,77660,77680,77700,77720,77740,77760,77780,77800,77820,77840,77860,77880,77900,77920,77940,77960,77980,78000,78020,78040,78060,78080,78100,78120,78140,78160,78180,78200,78220,78240,78260,78280,78300,78320,78340,78360,78380,78400,78420,78440,78460,78480,78500,78520,78540,78560,78580,78600,78620,78640,78660,78680,78700,78720,78740,78760,78780,78800,78820,78840,78860,78880,78900,78920,78940,78960,78980,79000,79020,79040,79060,79080,79100,79120,79140,79160,79180,79200,79220,79240,79260,79280,79300,79320,79340,79360,79380,79400,79420,79440,79460,79480,79500,79520,79540,79560,79580,79600,79620,79640,79660,79680,79700,79720,79740,79760,79780,79800,79820,79840,79860,79880,79900,79920,79940,79960,79980,80000,80020,80040,80060,80080,110100,110120,110140,110160,110180,110200,110220,110240,110260,110280,110300,110320,110340,110360,110380,110400,110420,110440,110460,110480,110500,110520,110540,110560,110580,110600,110620,110640,110660,110680,110700,110720,110740,110760,110780,110800,110820,110840,110860,110880,110900,110920,110940,110960,110980,111000,111020,111040,111060,111080,111100,111120,111140,111160,111180,111200,111220,111240,111260,111280,111300,111320,111340,111360,111380,111400,111420,111440,111460,111480,111500,111520,111540,111560,111580,111600,111620,111640,111660,111680,111700,111720,111740,111760,111780,111800,111820,111840,111860,111880,111900,111920,111940,111960,111980,112000,112020,112040,112060,112080,112100,112120,112140,112160,112180,112200,112220,112240,112260,112280,112300,112320,112340,112360,112380,112400,112420,112440,112460,112480,112500,112520,112540,112560,112580,112600,112620,112640,112660,112680,112700,112720,112740,112760,112780,112800,112820,112840,112860,112880,112900,112920,112940,112960,112980,113000,113020,113040,113060,113080,113100,113120,113140,113160,113180,113200,113220,113240,113260,113280,113300,113320,113340,113360,113380,113400,113420,113440,113460,113480,113500,113520,113540,113560,113580,113600,113620,113640,113660,113680,113700,113720,113740,113760,113780,113800,113820,113840,113860,113880,113900,113920,113940,113960,113980,114000,114020,114040,114060,114080,114100,114120,114140,114160,114180,114200,114220,114240,114260,114280,114300,114320,114340,114360,114380,114400,114420,114440,114460,114480,114500,114520,114540,114560,114580,114600,114620,114640,114660,114680,114700,114720,114740,114760,114780,114800,114820,114840,114860,114880,114900,114920,114940,114960,114980,115000,115020,115040,115060,115080,115100,115120,115140,115160,115180,115200,115220,115240,115260,115280,115300,115320,115340,115360,115380,115400,115420,115440,115460,115480,115500,115520,115540,115560,115580,115600,115620,115640,115660,115680,115700,115720,115740,115760,115780,115800,115820,115840,115860,115880,115900,115920,115940,115960,115980,116000,116020,116040,116060,116080,116100,116120,116140,116160,116180,116200,116220,116240,116260,116280,116300,116320,116340,116360,116380,116400,116420,116440,116460,116480,116500,116520,116540,116560,116580,116600,116620,116640,116660,116680,116700,116720,116740,116760,116780,116800,116820,116840,116860,116880,116900,116920,116940,116960,116980,117000,117020,117040,117060,117080,117100,117120,117140,117160,117180,117200,117220,117240,117260,117280,117300,117320,117340,117360,117380,117400,117420,117440,117460,117480,117500,117520,117540,117560,117580,117600,117620,117640,117660,117680,117700,117720,117740,117760,117780,117800,117820,117840,117860,117880,117900,117920,117940,117960,117980,118000,118020,118040,118060,118080,118100,118120,118140,118160,118180,118200,118220,118240,118260,118280,118300,118320,118340,118360,118380,118400,118420,118440,118460,118480,118500,118520,118540,118560,118580,118600,118620,118640,118660,118680,118700,118720,118740,118760,118780,118800,118820,118840,118860,118880,118900,118920,118940,118960,118980,119000,119020,119040,119060,119080,119100,119120,119140,119160,119180,119200,119220,119240,119260,119280,119300,119320,119340,119360,119380,119400,119420,119440,119460,119480,119500,119520,119540,119560,119580,119600,119620,119640,119660,119680,119700,119720,119740,119760,119780,119800,119820,119840,119860,119880,119900,119920,119940,119960,119980,120000,120020,120040,120060,120080],"ends":[500,760],"target":[[0,120],[75,100],[175,80],[225,60],[250,40],[1000,100],[1070,80],[1120,60],[1145,40]],"lateness":[[0,0]]} diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/spike.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/spike.json index 6a043a32acc..4267911d563 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/spike.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/spike.json @@ -1 +1 @@ -{"name":"spike","about":"A 300 ms stall every 5 s for the first 10 s, then 30 s of clean arrivals. The target rises to cover the stalls, then decays at the forget factor once they stop.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030,20050,20070,20090,20110,20130,20150,20170,20190,20210,20230,20250,20270,20290,20310,20330,20350,20370,20390,20410,20430,20450,20470,20490,20510,20530,20550,20570,20590,20610,20630,20650,20670,20690,20710,20730,20750,20770,20790,20810,20830,20850,20870,20890,20910,20930,20950,20970,20990,21010,21030,21050,21070,21090,21110,21130,21150,21170,21190,21210,21230,21250,21270,21290,21310,21330,21350,21370,21390,21410,21430,21450,21470,21490,21510,21530,21550,21570,21590,21610,21630,21650,21670,21690,21710,21730,21750,21770,21790,21810,21830,21850,21870,21890,21910,21930,21950,21970,21990,22010,22030,22050,22070,22090,22110,22130,22150,22170,22190,22210,22230,22250,22270,22290,22310,22330,22350,22370,22390,22410,22430,22450,22470,22490,22510,22530,22550,22570,22590,22610,22630,22650,22670,22690,22710,22730,22750,22770,22790,22810,22830,22850,22870,22890,22910,22930,22950,22970,22990,23010,23030,23050,23070,23090,23110,23130,23150,23170,23190,23210,23230,23250,23270,23290,23310,23330,23350,23370,23390,23410,23430,23450,23470,23490,23510,23530,23550,23570,23590,23610,23630,23650,23670,23690,23710,23730,23750,23770,23790,23810,23830,23850,23870,23890,23910,23930,23950,23970,23990,24010,24030,24050,24070,24090,24110,24130,24150,24170,24190,24210,24230,24250,24270,24290,24310,24330,24350,24370,24390,24410,24430,24450,24470,24490,24510,24530,24550,24570,24590,24610,24630,24650,24670,24690,24710,24730,24750,24770,24790,24810,24830,24850,24870,24890,24910,24930,24950,24970,24990,25010,25030,25050,25070,25090,25110,25130,25150,25170,25190,25210,25230,25250,25270,25290,25310,25330,25350,25370,25390,25410,25430,25450,25470,25490,25510,25530,25550,25570,25590,25610,25630,25650,25670,25690,25710,25730,25750,25770,25790,25810,25830,25850,25870,25890,25910,25930,25950,25970,25990,26010,26030,26050,26070,26090,26110,26130,26150,26170,26190,26210,26230,26250,26270,26290,26310,26330,26350,26370,26390,26410,26430,26450,26470,26490,26510,26530,26550,26570,26590,26610,26630,26650,26670,26690,26710,26730,26750,26770,26790,26810,26830,26850,26870,26890,26910,26930,26950,26970,26990,27010,27030,27050,27070,27090,27110,27130,27150,27170,27190,27210,27230,27250,27270,27290,27310,27330,27350,27370,27390,27410,27430,27450,27470,27490,27510,27530,27550,27570,27590,27610,27630,27650,27670,27690,27710,27730,27750,27770,27790,27810,27830,27850,27870,27890,27910,27930,27950,27970,27990,28010,28030,28050,28070,28090,28110,28130,28150,28170,28190,28210,28230,28250,28270,28290,28310,28330,28350,28370,28390,28410,28430,28450,28470,28490,28510,28530,28550,28570,28590,28610,28630,28650,28670,28690,28710,28730,28750,28770,28790,28810,28830,28850,28870,28890,28910,28930,28950,28970,28990,29010,29030,29050,29070,29090,29110,29130,29150,29170,29190,29210,29230,29250,29270,29290,29310,29330,29350,29370,29390,29410,29430,29450,29470,29490,29510,29530,29550,29570,29590,29610,29630,29650,29670,29690,29710,29730,29750,29770,29790,29810,29830,29850,29870,29890,29910,29930,29950,29970,29990,30010,30030,30050,30070,30090,30110,30130,30150,30170,30190,30210,30230,30250,30270,30290,30310,30330,30350,30370,30390,30410,30430,30450,30470,30490,30510,30530,30550,30570,30590,30610,30630,30650,30670,30690,30710,30730,30750,30770,30790,30810,30830,30850,30870,30890,30910,30930,30950,30970,30990,31010,31030,31050,31070,31090,31110,31130,31150,31170,31190,31210,31230,31250,31270,31290,31310,31330,31350,31370,31390,31410,31430,31450,31470,31490,31510,31530,31550,31570,31590,31610,31630,31650,31670,31690,31710,31730,31750,31770,31790,31810,31830,31850,31870,31890,31910,31930,31950,31970,31990,32010,32030,32050,32070,32090,32110,32130,32150,32170,32190,32210,32230,32250,32270,32290,32310,32330,32350,32370,32390,32410,32430,32450,32470,32490,32510,32530,32550,32570,32590,32610,32630,32650,32670,32690,32710,32730,32750,32770,32790,32810,32830,32850,32870,32890,32910,32930,32950,32970,32990,33010,33030,33050,33070,33090,33110,33130,33150,33170,33190,33210,33230,33250,33270,33290,33310,33330,33350,33370,33390,33410,33430,33450,33470,33490,33510,33530,33550,33570,33590,33610,33630,33650,33670,33690,33710,33730,33750,33770,33790,33810,33830,33850,33870,33890,33910,33930,33950,33970,33990,34010,34030,34050,34070,34090,34110,34130,34150,34170,34190,34210,34230,34250,34270,34290,34310,34330,34350,34370,34390,34410,34430,34450,34470,34490,34510,34530,34550,34570,34590,34610,34630,34650,34670,34690,34710,34730,34750,34770,34790,34810,34830,34850,34870,34890,34910,34930,34950,34970,34990,35010,35030,35050,35070,35090,35110,35130,35150,35170,35190,35210,35230,35250,35270,35290,35310,35330,35350,35370,35390,35410,35430,35450,35470,35490,35510,35530,35550,35570,35590,35610,35630,35650,35670,35690,35710,35730,35750,35770,35790,35810,35830,35850,35870,35890,35910,35930,35950,35970,35990,36010,36030,36050,36070,36090,36110,36130,36150,36170,36190,36210,36230,36250,36270,36290,36310,36330,36350,36370,36390,36410,36430,36450,36470,36490,36510,36530,36550,36570,36590,36610,36630,36650,36670,36690,36710,36730,36750,36770,36790,36810,36830,36850,36870,36890,36910,36930,36950,36970,36990,37010,37030,37050,37070,37090,37110,37130,37150,37170,37190,37210,37230,37250,37270,37290,37310,37330,37350,37370,37390,37410,37430,37450,37470,37490,37510,37530,37550,37570,37590,37610,37630,37650,37670,37690,37710,37730,37750,37770,37790,37810,37830,37850,37870,37890,37910,37930,37950,37970,37990,38010,38030,38050,38070,38090,38110,38130,38150,38170,38190,38210,38230,38250,38270,38290,38310,38330,38350,38370,38390,38410,38430,38450,38470,38490,38510,38530,38550,38570,38590,38610,38630,38650,38670,38690,38710,38730,38750,38770,38790,38810,38830,38850,38870,38890,38910,38930,38950,38970,38990,39010,39030,39050,39070,39090,39110,39130,39150,39170,39190,39210,39230,39250,39270,39290,39310,39330,39350,39370,39390,39410,39430,39450,39470,39490,39510,39530,39550,39570,39590,39610,39630,39650,39670,39690,39710,39730,39750,39770,39790,39810,39830,39850,39870,39890,39910,39930,39950,39970,39990,40010,40030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,20000,20020,20040,20060,20080,20100,20120,20140,20160,20180,20200,20220,20240,20260,20280,20300,20320,20340,20360,20380,20400,20420,20440,20460,20480,20500,20520,20540,20560,20580,20600,20620,20640,20660,20680,20700,20720,20740,20760,20780,20800,20820,20840,20860,20880,20900,20920,20940,20960,20980,21000,21020,21040,21060,21080,21100,21120,21140,21160,21180,21200,21220,21240,21260,21280,21300,21320,21340,21360,21380,21400,21420,21440,21460,21480,21500,21520,21540,21560,21580,21600,21620,21640,21660,21680,21700,21720,21740,21760,21780,21800,21820,21840,21860,21880,21900,21920,21940,21960,21980,22000,22020,22040,22060,22080,22100,22120,22140,22160,22180,22200,22220,22240,22260,22280,22300,22320,22340,22360,22380,22400,22420,22440,22460,22480,22500,22520,22540,22560,22580,22600,22620,22640,22660,22680,22700,22720,22740,22760,22780,22800,22820,22840,22860,22880,22900,22920,22940,22960,22980,23000,23020,23040,23060,23080,23100,23120,23140,23160,23180,23200,23220,23240,23260,23280,23300,23320,23340,23360,23380,23400,23420,23440,23460,23480,23500,23520,23540,23560,23580,23600,23620,23640,23660,23680,23700,23720,23740,23760,23780,23800,23820,23840,23860,23880,23900,23920,23940,23960,23980,24000,24020,24040,24060,24080,24100,24120,24140,24160,24180,24200,24220,24240,24260,24280,24300,24320,24340,24360,24380,24400,24420,24440,24460,24480,24500,24520,24540,24560,24580,24600,24620,24640,24660,24680,24700,24720,24740,24760,24780,24800,24820,24840,24860,24880,24900,24920,24940,24960,24980,25000,25020,25040,25060,25080,25100,25120,25140,25160,25180,25200,25220,25240,25260,25280,25300,25320,25340,25360,25380,25400,25420,25440,25460,25480,25500,25520,25540,25560,25580,25600,25620,25640,25660,25680,25700,25720,25740,25760,25780,25800,25820,25840,25860,25880,25900,25920,25940,25960,25980,26000,26020,26040,26060,26080,26100,26120,26140,26160,26180,26200,26220,26240,26260,26280,26300,26320,26340,26360,26380,26400,26420,26440,26460,26480,26500,26520,26540,26560,26580,26600,26620,26640,26660,26680,26700,26720,26740,26760,26780,26800,26820,26840,26860,26880,26900,26920,26940,26960,26980,27000,27020,27040,27060,27080,27100,27120,27140,27160,27180,27200,27220,27240,27260,27280,27300,27320,27340,27360,27380,27400,27420,27440,27460,27480,27500,27520,27540,27560,27580,27600,27620,27640,27660,27680,27700,27720,27740,27760,27780,27800,27820,27840,27860,27880,27900,27920,27940,27960,27980,28000,28020,28040,28060,28080,28100,28120,28140,28160,28180,28200,28220,28240,28260,28280,28300,28320,28340,28360,28380,28400,28420,28440,28460,28480,28500,28520,28540,28560,28580,28600,28620,28640,28660,28680,28700,28720,28740,28760,28780,28800,28820,28840,28860,28880,28900,28920,28940,28960,28980,29000,29020,29040,29060,29080,29100,29120,29140,29160,29180,29200,29220,29240,29260,29280,29300,29320,29340,29360,29380,29400,29420,29440,29460,29480,29500,29520,29540,29560,29580,29600,29620,29640,29660,29680,29700,29720,29740,29760,29780,29800,29820,29840,29860,29880,29900,29920,29940,29960,29980,30000,30020,30040,30060,30080,30100,30120,30140,30160,30180,30200,30220,30240,30260,30280,30300,30320,30340,30360,30380,30400,30420,30440,30460,30480,30500,30520,30540,30560,30580,30600,30620,30640,30660,30680,30700,30720,30740,30760,30780,30800,30820,30840,30860,30880,30900,30920,30940,30960,30980,31000,31020,31040,31060,31080,31100,31120,31140,31160,31180,31200,31220,31240,31260,31280,31300,31320,31340,31360,31380,31400,31420,31440,31460,31480,31500,31520,31540,31560,31580,31600,31620,31640,31660,31680,31700,31720,31740,31760,31780,31800,31820,31840,31860,31880,31900,31920,31940,31960,31980,32000,32020,32040,32060,32080,32100,32120,32140,32160,32180,32200,32220,32240,32260,32280,32300,32320,32340,32360,32380,32400,32420,32440,32460,32480,32500,32520,32540,32560,32580,32600,32620,32640,32660,32680,32700,32720,32740,32760,32780,32800,32820,32840,32860,32880,32900,32920,32940,32960,32980,33000,33020,33040,33060,33080,33100,33120,33140,33160,33180,33200,33220,33240,33260,33280,33300,33320,33340,33360,33380,33400,33420,33440,33460,33480,33500,33520,33540,33560,33580,33600,33620,33640,33660,33680,33700,33720,33740,33760,33780,33800,33820,33840,33860,33880,33900,33920,33940,33960,33980,34000,34020,34040,34060,34080,34100,34120,34140,34160,34180,34200,34220,34240,34260,34280,34300,34320,34340,34360,34380,34400,34420,34440,34460,34480,34500,34520,34540,34560,34580,34600,34620,34640,34660,34680,34700,34720,34740,34760,34780,34800,34820,34840,34860,34880,34900,34920,34940,34960,34980,35000,35020,35040,35060,35080,35100,35120,35140,35160,35180,35200,35220,35240,35260,35280,35300,35320,35340,35360,35380,35400,35420,35440,35460,35480,35500,35520,35540,35560,35580,35600,35620,35640,35660,35680,35700,35720,35740,35760,35780,35800,35820,35840,35860,35880,35900,35920,35940,35960,35980,36000,36020,36040,36060,36080,36100,36120,36140,36160,36180,36200,36220,36240,36260,36280,36300,36320,36340,36360,36380,36400,36420,36440,36460,36480,36500,36520,36540,36560,36580,36600,36620,36640,36660,36680,36700,36720,36740,36760,36780,36800,36820,36840,36860,36880,36900,36920,36940,36960,36980,37000,37020,37040,37060,37080,37100,37120,37140,37160,37180,37200,37220,37240,37260,37280,37300,37320,37340,37360,37380,37400,37420,37440,37460,37480,37500,37520,37540,37560,37580,37600,37620,37640,37660,37680,37700,37720,37740,37760,37780,37800,37820,37840,37860,37880,37900,37920,37940,37960,37980,38000,38020,38040,38060,38080,38100,38120,38140,38160,38180,38200,38220,38240,38260,38280,38300,38320,38340,38360,38380,38400,38420,38440,38460,38480,38500,38520,38540,38560,38580,38600,38620,38640,38660,38680,38700,38720,38740,38760,38780,38800,38820,38840,38860,38880,38900,38920,38940,38960,38980,39000,39020,39040,39060,39080,39100,39120,39140,39160,39180,39200,39220,39240,39260,39280,39300,39320,39340,39360,39380,39400,39420,39440,39460,39480,39500,39520,39540,39560,39580,39600,39620,39640,39660,39680,39700,39720,39740,39760,39780,39800,39820,39840,39860,39880,39900,39920,39940,39960,39980],"target":[[0,120],[75,100],[175,80],[225,60],[250,40],[275,320],[1425,40]]} +{"name":"spike","about":"A 300 ms stall every 5 s for the first 10 s, then 30 s of clean arrivals. The target rises to cover the stalls, then decays at the forget factor once they stop.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030,20050,20070,20090,20110,20130,20150,20170,20190,20210,20230,20250,20270,20290,20310,20330,20350,20370,20390,20410,20430,20450,20470,20490,20510,20530,20550,20570,20590,20610,20630,20650,20670,20690,20710,20730,20750,20770,20790,20810,20830,20850,20870,20890,20910,20930,20950,20970,20990,21010,21030,21050,21070,21090,21110,21130,21150,21170,21190,21210,21230,21250,21270,21290,21310,21330,21350,21370,21390,21410,21430,21450,21470,21490,21510,21530,21550,21570,21590,21610,21630,21650,21670,21690,21710,21730,21750,21770,21790,21810,21830,21850,21870,21890,21910,21930,21950,21970,21990,22010,22030,22050,22070,22090,22110,22130,22150,22170,22190,22210,22230,22250,22270,22290,22310,22330,22350,22370,22390,22410,22430,22450,22470,22490,22510,22530,22550,22570,22590,22610,22630,22650,22670,22690,22710,22730,22750,22770,22790,22810,22830,22850,22870,22890,22910,22930,22950,22970,22990,23010,23030,23050,23070,23090,23110,23130,23150,23170,23190,23210,23230,23250,23270,23290,23310,23330,23350,23370,23390,23410,23430,23450,23470,23490,23510,23530,23550,23570,23590,23610,23630,23650,23670,23690,23710,23730,23750,23770,23790,23810,23830,23850,23870,23890,23910,23930,23950,23970,23990,24010,24030,24050,24070,24090,24110,24130,24150,24170,24190,24210,24230,24250,24270,24290,24310,24330,24350,24370,24390,24410,24430,24450,24470,24490,24510,24530,24550,24570,24590,24610,24630,24650,24670,24690,24710,24730,24750,24770,24790,24810,24830,24850,24870,24890,24910,24930,24950,24970,24990,25010,25030,25050,25070,25090,25110,25130,25150,25170,25190,25210,25230,25250,25270,25290,25310,25330,25350,25370,25390,25410,25430,25450,25470,25490,25510,25530,25550,25570,25590,25610,25630,25650,25670,25690,25710,25730,25750,25770,25790,25810,25830,25850,25870,25890,25910,25930,25950,25970,25990,26010,26030,26050,26070,26090,26110,26130,26150,26170,26190,26210,26230,26250,26270,26290,26310,26330,26350,26370,26390,26410,26430,26450,26470,26490,26510,26530,26550,26570,26590,26610,26630,26650,26670,26690,26710,26730,26750,26770,26790,26810,26830,26850,26870,26890,26910,26930,26950,26970,26990,27010,27030,27050,27070,27090,27110,27130,27150,27170,27190,27210,27230,27250,27270,27290,27310,27330,27350,27370,27390,27410,27430,27450,27470,27490,27510,27530,27550,27570,27590,27610,27630,27650,27670,27690,27710,27730,27750,27770,27790,27810,27830,27850,27870,27890,27910,27930,27950,27970,27990,28010,28030,28050,28070,28090,28110,28130,28150,28170,28190,28210,28230,28250,28270,28290,28310,28330,28350,28370,28390,28410,28430,28450,28470,28490,28510,28530,28550,28570,28590,28610,28630,28650,28670,28690,28710,28730,28750,28770,28790,28810,28830,28850,28870,28890,28910,28930,28950,28970,28990,29010,29030,29050,29070,29090,29110,29130,29150,29170,29190,29210,29230,29250,29270,29290,29310,29330,29350,29370,29390,29410,29430,29450,29470,29490,29510,29530,29550,29570,29590,29610,29630,29650,29670,29690,29710,29730,29750,29770,29790,29810,29830,29850,29870,29890,29910,29930,29950,29970,29990,30010,30030,30050,30070,30090,30110,30130,30150,30170,30190,30210,30230,30250,30270,30290,30310,30330,30350,30370,30390,30410,30430,30450,30470,30490,30510,30530,30550,30570,30590,30610,30630,30650,30670,30690,30710,30730,30750,30770,30790,30810,30830,30850,30870,30890,30910,30930,30950,30970,30990,31010,31030,31050,31070,31090,31110,31130,31150,31170,31190,31210,31230,31250,31270,31290,31310,31330,31350,31370,31390,31410,31430,31450,31470,31490,31510,31530,31550,31570,31590,31610,31630,31650,31670,31690,31710,31730,31750,31770,31790,31810,31830,31850,31870,31890,31910,31930,31950,31970,31990,32010,32030,32050,32070,32090,32110,32130,32150,32170,32190,32210,32230,32250,32270,32290,32310,32330,32350,32370,32390,32410,32430,32450,32470,32490,32510,32530,32550,32570,32590,32610,32630,32650,32670,32690,32710,32730,32750,32770,32790,32810,32830,32850,32870,32890,32910,32930,32950,32970,32990,33010,33030,33050,33070,33090,33110,33130,33150,33170,33190,33210,33230,33250,33270,33290,33310,33330,33350,33370,33390,33410,33430,33450,33470,33490,33510,33530,33550,33570,33590,33610,33630,33650,33670,33690,33710,33730,33750,33770,33790,33810,33830,33850,33870,33890,33910,33930,33950,33970,33990,34010,34030,34050,34070,34090,34110,34130,34150,34170,34190,34210,34230,34250,34270,34290,34310,34330,34350,34370,34390,34410,34430,34450,34470,34490,34510,34530,34550,34570,34590,34610,34630,34650,34670,34690,34710,34730,34750,34770,34790,34810,34830,34850,34870,34890,34910,34930,34950,34970,34990,35010,35030,35050,35070,35090,35110,35130,35150,35170,35190,35210,35230,35250,35270,35290,35310,35330,35350,35370,35390,35410,35430,35450,35470,35490,35510,35530,35550,35570,35590,35610,35630,35650,35670,35690,35710,35730,35750,35770,35790,35810,35830,35850,35870,35890,35910,35930,35950,35970,35990,36010,36030,36050,36070,36090,36110,36130,36150,36170,36190,36210,36230,36250,36270,36290,36310,36330,36350,36370,36390,36410,36430,36450,36470,36490,36510,36530,36550,36570,36590,36610,36630,36650,36670,36690,36710,36730,36750,36770,36790,36810,36830,36850,36870,36890,36910,36930,36950,36970,36990,37010,37030,37050,37070,37090,37110,37130,37150,37170,37190,37210,37230,37250,37270,37290,37310,37330,37350,37370,37390,37410,37430,37450,37470,37490,37510,37530,37550,37570,37590,37610,37630,37650,37670,37690,37710,37730,37750,37770,37790,37810,37830,37850,37870,37890,37910,37930,37950,37970,37990,38010,38030,38050,38070,38090,38110,38130,38150,38170,38190,38210,38230,38250,38270,38290,38310,38330,38350,38370,38390,38410,38430,38450,38470,38490,38510,38530,38550,38570,38590,38610,38630,38650,38670,38690,38710,38730,38750,38770,38790,38810,38830,38850,38870,38890,38910,38930,38950,38970,38990,39010,39030,39050,39070,39090,39110,39130,39150,39170,39190,39210,39230,39250,39270,39290,39310,39330,39350,39370,39390,39410,39430,39450,39470,39490,39510,39530,39550,39570,39590,39610,39630,39650,39670,39690,39710,39730,39750,39770,39790,39810,39830,39850,39870,39890,39910,39930,39950,39970,39990,40010,40030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,20000,20020,20040,20060,20080,20100,20120,20140,20160,20180,20200,20220,20240,20260,20280,20300,20320,20340,20360,20380,20400,20420,20440,20460,20480,20500,20520,20540,20560,20580,20600,20620,20640,20660,20680,20700,20720,20740,20760,20780,20800,20820,20840,20860,20880,20900,20920,20940,20960,20980,21000,21020,21040,21060,21080,21100,21120,21140,21160,21180,21200,21220,21240,21260,21280,21300,21320,21340,21360,21380,21400,21420,21440,21460,21480,21500,21520,21540,21560,21580,21600,21620,21640,21660,21680,21700,21720,21740,21760,21780,21800,21820,21840,21860,21880,21900,21920,21940,21960,21980,22000,22020,22040,22060,22080,22100,22120,22140,22160,22180,22200,22220,22240,22260,22280,22300,22320,22340,22360,22380,22400,22420,22440,22460,22480,22500,22520,22540,22560,22580,22600,22620,22640,22660,22680,22700,22720,22740,22760,22780,22800,22820,22840,22860,22880,22900,22920,22940,22960,22980,23000,23020,23040,23060,23080,23100,23120,23140,23160,23180,23200,23220,23240,23260,23280,23300,23320,23340,23360,23380,23400,23420,23440,23460,23480,23500,23520,23540,23560,23580,23600,23620,23640,23660,23680,23700,23720,23740,23760,23780,23800,23820,23840,23860,23880,23900,23920,23940,23960,23980,24000,24020,24040,24060,24080,24100,24120,24140,24160,24180,24200,24220,24240,24260,24280,24300,24320,24340,24360,24380,24400,24420,24440,24460,24480,24500,24520,24540,24560,24580,24600,24620,24640,24660,24680,24700,24720,24740,24760,24780,24800,24820,24840,24860,24880,24900,24920,24940,24960,24980,25000,25020,25040,25060,25080,25100,25120,25140,25160,25180,25200,25220,25240,25260,25280,25300,25320,25340,25360,25380,25400,25420,25440,25460,25480,25500,25520,25540,25560,25580,25600,25620,25640,25660,25680,25700,25720,25740,25760,25780,25800,25820,25840,25860,25880,25900,25920,25940,25960,25980,26000,26020,26040,26060,26080,26100,26120,26140,26160,26180,26200,26220,26240,26260,26280,26300,26320,26340,26360,26380,26400,26420,26440,26460,26480,26500,26520,26540,26560,26580,26600,26620,26640,26660,26680,26700,26720,26740,26760,26780,26800,26820,26840,26860,26880,26900,26920,26940,26960,26980,27000,27020,27040,27060,27080,27100,27120,27140,27160,27180,27200,27220,27240,27260,27280,27300,27320,27340,27360,27380,27400,27420,27440,27460,27480,27500,27520,27540,27560,27580,27600,27620,27640,27660,27680,27700,27720,27740,27760,27780,27800,27820,27840,27860,27880,27900,27920,27940,27960,27980,28000,28020,28040,28060,28080,28100,28120,28140,28160,28180,28200,28220,28240,28260,28280,28300,28320,28340,28360,28380,28400,28420,28440,28460,28480,28500,28520,28540,28560,28580,28600,28620,28640,28660,28680,28700,28720,28740,28760,28780,28800,28820,28840,28860,28880,28900,28920,28940,28960,28980,29000,29020,29040,29060,29080,29100,29120,29140,29160,29180,29200,29220,29240,29260,29280,29300,29320,29340,29360,29380,29400,29420,29440,29460,29480,29500,29520,29540,29560,29580,29600,29620,29640,29660,29680,29700,29720,29740,29760,29780,29800,29820,29840,29860,29880,29900,29920,29940,29960,29980,30000,30020,30040,30060,30080,30100,30120,30140,30160,30180,30200,30220,30240,30260,30280,30300,30320,30340,30360,30380,30400,30420,30440,30460,30480,30500,30520,30540,30560,30580,30600,30620,30640,30660,30680,30700,30720,30740,30760,30780,30800,30820,30840,30860,30880,30900,30920,30940,30960,30980,31000,31020,31040,31060,31080,31100,31120,31140,31160,31180,31200,31220,31240,31260,31280,31300,31320,31340,31360,31380,31400,31420,31440,31460,31480,31500,31520,31540,31560,31580,31600,31620,31640,31660,31680,31700,31720,31740,31760,31780,31800,31820,31840,31860,31880,31900,31920,31940,31960,31980,32000,32020,32040,32060,32080,32100,32120,32140,32160,32180,32200,32220,32240,32260,32280,32300,32320,32340,32360,32380,32400,32420,32440,32460,32480,32500,32520,32540,32560,32580,32600,32620,32640,32660,32680,32700,32720,32740,32760,32780,32800,32820,32840,32860,32880,32900,32920,32940,32960,32980,33000,33020,33040,33060,33080,33100,33120,33140,33160,33180,33200,33220,33240,33260,33280,33300,33320,33340,33360,33380,33400,33420,33440,33460,33480,33500,33520,33540,33560,33580,33600,33620,33640,33660,33680,33700,33720,33740,33760,33780,33800,33820,33840,33860,33880,33900,33920,33940,33960,33980,34000,34020,34040,34060,34080,34100,34120,34140,34160,34180,34200,34220,34240,34260,34280,34300,34320,34340,34360,34380,34400,34420,34440,34460,34480,34500,34520,34540,34560,34580,34600,34620,34640,34660,34680,34700,34720,34740,34760,34780,34800,34820,34840,34860,34880,34900,34920,34940,34960,34980,35000,35020,35040,35060,35080,35100,35120,35140,35160,35180,35200,35220,35240,35260,35280,35300,35320,35340,35360,35380,35400,35420,35440,35460,35480,35500,35520,35540,35560,35580,35600,35620,35640,35660,35680,35700,35720,35740,35760,35780,35800,35820,35840,35860,35880,35900,35920,35940,35960,35980,36000,36020,36040,36060,36080,36100,36120,36140,36160,36180,36200,36220,36240,36260,36280,36300,36320,36340,36360,36380,36400,36420,36440,36460,36480,36500,36520,36540,36560,36580,36600,36620,36640,36660,36680,36700,36720,36740,36760,36780,36800,36820,36840,36860,36880,36900,36920,36940,36960,36980,37000,37020,37040,37060,37080,37100,37120,37140,37160,37180,37200,37220,37240,37260,37280,37300,37320,37340,37360,37380,37400,37420,37440,37460,37480,37500,37520,37540,37560,37580,37600,37620,37640,37660,37680,37700,37720,37740,37760,37780,37800,37820,37840,37860,37880,37900,37920,37940,37960,37980,38000,38020,38040,38060,38080,38100,38120,38140,38160,38180,38200,38220,38240,38260,38280,38300,38320,38340,38360,38380,38400,38420,38440,38460,38480,38500,38520,38540,38560,38580,38600,38620,38640,38660,38680,38700,38720,38740,38760,38780,38800,38820,38840,38860,38880,38900,38920,38940,38960,38980,39000,39020,39040,39060,39080,39100,39120,39140,39160,39180,39200,39220,39240,39260,39280,39300,39320,39340,39360,39380,39400,39420,39440,39460,39480,39500,39520,39540,39560,39580,39600,39620,39640,39660,39680,39700,39720,39740,39760,39780,39800,39820,39840,39860,39880,39900,39920,39940,39960,39980],"target":[[0,120],[75,100],[175,80],[225,60],[250,40],[275,320],[1425,40]],"lateness":[[0,0],[250,280],[351,260],[352,240],[353,220],[354,200],[355,180],[356,160],[357,140],[358,120],[359,100],[360,80],[361,60],[362,40],[363,20],[364,0],[500,280],[601,260],[602,240],[603,220],[604,200],[605,180],[606,160],[607,140],[608,120],[609,100],[610,80],[611,60],[612,40],[613,20],[614,0]]} diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/straggler.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/straggler.json index 78eab34d46b..e7b9bee2255 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/straggler.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/straggler.json @@ -1 +1 @@ -{"name":"straggler","about":"Even audio with a single 300 ms stall 8 s in, once the prior is spent. One interval of evidence is not enough to move the target, so the stall costs that one refill instead of raising the target and then dropping it, which skips buffered audio.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030,20050,20070,20090,20110,20130,20150,20170,20190,20210,20230,20250,20270,20290,20310,20330,20350,20370,20390,20410,20430,20450,20470,20490,20510,20530,20550,20570,20590,20610,20630,20650,20670,20690,20710,20730,20750,20770,20790,20810,20830,20850,20870,20890,20910,20930,20950,20970,20990,21010,21030,21050,21070,21090,21110,21130,21150,21170,21190,21210,21230,21250,21270,21290,21310,21330,21350,21370,21390,21410,21430,21450,21470,21490,21510,21530,21550,21570,21590,21610,21630,21650,21670,21690,21710,21730,21750,21770,21790,21810,21830,21850,21870,21890,21910,21930,21950,21970,21990,22010,22030,22050,22070,22090,22110,22130,22150,22170,22190,22210,22230,22250,22270,22290,22310,22330,22350,22370,22390,22410,22430,22450,22470,22490,22510,22530,22550,22570,22590,22610,22630,22650,22670,22690,22710,22730,22750,22770,22790,22810,22830,22850,22870,22890,22910,22930,22950,22970,22990,23010,23030,23050,23070,23090,23110,23130,23150,23170,23190,23210,23230,23250,23270,23290,23310,23330,23350,23370,23390,23410,23430,23450,23470,23490,23510,23530,23550,23570,23590,23610,23630,23650,23670,23690,23710,23730,23750,23770,23790,23810,23830,23850,23870,23890,23910,23930,23950,23970,23990,24010,24030,24050,24070,24090,24110,24130,24150,24170,24190,24210,24230,24250,24270,24290,24310,24330,24350,24370,24390,24410,24430,24450,24470,24490,24510,24530,24550,24570,24590,24610,24630,24650,24670,24690,24710,24730,24750,24770,24790,24810,24830,24850,24870,24890,24910,24930,24950,24970,24990,25010,25030,25050,25070,25090,25110,25130,25150,25170,25190,25210,25230,25250,25270,25290,25310,25330,25350,25370,25390,25410,25430,25450,25470,25490,25510,25530,25550,25570,25590,25610,25630,25650,25670,25690,25710,25730,25750,25770,25790,25810,25830,25850,25870,25890,25910,25930,25950,25970,25990,26010,26030,26050,26070,26090,26110,26130,26150,26170,26190,26210,26230,26250,26270,26290,26310,26330,26350,26370,26390,26410,26430,26450,26470,26490,26510,26530,26550,26570,26590,26610,26630,26650,26670,26690,26710,26730,26750,26770,26790,26810,26830,26850,26870,26890,26910,26930,26950,26970,26990,27010,27030,27050,27070,27090,27110,27130,27150,27170,27190,27210,27230,27250,27270,27290,27310,27330,27350,27370,27390,27410,27430,27450,27470,27490,27510,27530,27550,27570,27590,27610,27630,27650,27670,27690,27710,27730,27750,27770,27790,27810,27830,27850,27870,27890,27910,27930,27950,27970,27990,28010,28030,28050,28070,28090,28110,28130,28150,28170,28190,28210,28230,28250,28270,28290,28310,28330,28350,28370,28390,28410,28430,28450,28470,28490,28510,28530,28550,28570,28590,28610,28630,28650,28670,28690,28710,28730,28750,28770,28790,28810,28830,28850,28870,28890,28910,28930,28950,28970,28990,29010,29030,29050,29070,29090,29110,29130,29150,29170,29190,29210,29230,29250,29270,29290,29310,29330,29350,29370,29390,29410,29430,29450,29470,29490,29510,29530,29550,29570,29590,29610,29630,29650,29670,29690,29710,29730,29750,29770,29790,29810,29830,29850,29870,29890,29910,29930,29950,29970,29990,30010,30030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,20000,20020,20040,20060,20080,20100,20120,20140,20160,20180,20200,20220,20240,20260,20280,20300,20320,20340,20360,20380,20400,20420,20440,20460,20480,20500,20520,20540,20560,20580,20600,20620,20640,20660,20680,20700,20720,20740,20760,20780,20800,20820,20840,20860,20880,20900,20920,20940,20960,20980,21000,21020,21040,21060,21080,21100,21120,21140,21160,21180,21200,21220,21240,21260,21280,21300,21320,21340,21360,21380,21400,21420,21440,21460,21480,21500,21520,21540,21560,21580,21600,21620,21640,21660,21680,21700,21720,21740,21760,21780,21800,21820,21840,21860,21880,21900,21920,21940,21960,21980,22000,22020,22040,22060,22080,22100,22120,22140,22160,22180,22200,22220,22240,22260,22280,22300,22320,22340,22360,22380,22400,22420,22440,22460,22480,22500,22520,22540,22560,22580,22600,22620,22640,22660,22680,22700,22720,22740,22760,22780,22800,22820,22840,22860,22880,22900,22920,22940,22960,22980,23000,23020,23040,23060,23080,23100,23120,23140,23160,23180,23200,23220,23240,23260,23280,23300,23320,23340,23360,23380,23400,23420,23440,23460,23480,23500,23520,23540,23560,23580,23600,23620,23640,23660,23680,23700,23720,23740,23760,23780,23800,23820,23840,23860,23880,23900,23920,23940,23960,23980,24000,24020,24040,24060,24080,24100,24120,24140,24160,24180,24200,24220,24240,24260,24280,24300,24320,24340,24360,24380,24400,24420,24440,24460,24480,24500,24520,24540,24560,24580,24600,24620,24640,24660,24680,24700,24720,24740,24760,24780,24800,24820,24840,24860,24880,24900,24920,24940,24960,24980,25000,25020,25040,25060,25080,25100,25120,25140,25160,25180,25200,25220,25240,25260,25280,25300,25320,25340,25360,25380,25400,25420,25440,25460,25480,25500,25520,25540,25560,25580,25600,25620,25640,25660,25680,25700,25720,25740,25760,25780,25800,25820,25840,25860,25880,25900,25920,25940,25960,25980,26000,26020,26040,26060,26080,26100,26120,26140,26160,26180,26200,26220,26240,26260,26280,26300,26320,26340,26360,26380,26400,26420,26440,26460,26480,26500,26520,26540,26560,26580,26600,26620,26640,26660,26680,26700,26720,26740,26760,26780,26800,26820,26840,26860,26880,26900,26920,26940,26960,26980,27000,27020,27040,27060,27080,27100,27120,27140,27160,27180,27200,27220,27240,27260,27280,27300,27320,27340,27360,27380,27400,27420,27440,27460,27480,27500,27520,27540,27560,27580,27600,27620,27640,27660,27680,27700,27720,27740,27760,27780,27800,27820,27840,27860,27880,27900,27920,27940,27960,27980,28000,28020,28040,28060,28080,28100,28120,28140,28160,28180,28200,28220,28240,28260,28280,28300,28320,28340,28360,28380,28400,28420,28440,28460,28480,28500,28520,28540,28560,28580,28600,28620,28640,28660,28680,28700,28720,28740,28760,28780,28800,28820,28840,28860,28880,28900,28920,28940,28960,28980,29000,29020,29040,29060,29080,29100,29120,29140,29160,29180,29200,29220,29240,29260,29280,29300,29320,29340,29360,29380,29400,29420,29440,29460,29480,29500,29520,29540,29560,29580,29600,29620,29640,29660,29680,29700,29720,29740,29760,29780,29800,29820,29840,29860,29880,29900,29920,29940,29960,29980],"target":[[0,120],[75,100],[175,80],[225,60],[250,40]]} +{"name":"straggler","about":"Even audio with a single 300 ms stall 8 s in, once the prior is spent. One interval of evidence is not enough to move the target, so the stall costs that one refill instead of raising the target and then dropping it, which skips buffered audio.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030,20050,20070,20090,20110,20130,20150,20170,20190,20210,20230,20250,20270,20290,20310,20330,20350,20370,20390,20410,20430,20450,20470,20490,20510,20530,20550,20570,20590,20610,20630,20650,20670,20690,20710,20730,20750,20770,20790,20810,20830,20850,20870,20890,20910,20930,20950,20970,20990,21010,21030,21050,21070,21090,21110,21130,21150,21170,21190,21210,21230,21250,21270,21290,21310,21330,21350,21370,21390,21410,21430,21450,21470,21490,21510,21530,21550,21570,21590,21610,21630,21650,21670,21690,21710,21730,21750,21770,21790,21810,21830,21850,21870,21890,21910,21930,21950,21970,21990,22010,22030,22050,22070,22090,22110,22130,22150,22170,22190,22210,22230,22250,22270,22290,22310,22330,22350,22370,22390,22410,22430,22450,22470,22490,22510,22530,22550,22570,22590,22610,22630,22650,22670,22690,22710,22730,22750,22770,22790,22810,22830,22850,22870,22890,22910,22930,22950,22970,22990,23010,23030,23050,23070,23090,23110,23130,23150,23170,23190,23210,23230,23250,23270,23290,23310,23330,23350,23370,23390,23410,23430,23450,23470,23490,23510,23530,23550,23570,23590,23610,23630,23650,23670,23690,23710,23730,23750,23770,23790,23810,23830,23850,23870,23890,23910,23930,23950,23970,23990,24010,24030,24050,24070,24090,24110,24130,24150,24170,24190,24210,24230,24250,24270,24290,24310,24330,24350,24370,24390,24410,24430,24450,24470,24490,24510,24530,24550,24570,24590,24610,24630,24650,24670,24690,24710,24730,24750,24770,24790,24810,24830,24850,24870,24890,24910,24930,24950,24970,24990,25010,25030,25050,25070,25090,25110,25130,25150,25170,25190,25210,25230,25250,25270,25290,25310,25330,25350,25370,25390,25410,25430,25450,25470,25490,25510,25530,25550,25570,25590,25610,25630,25650,25670,25690,25710,25730,25750,25770,25790,25810,25830,25850,25870,25890,25910,25930,25950,25970,25990,26010,26030,26050,26070,26090,26110,26130,26150,26170,26190,26210,26230,26250,26270,26290,26310,26330,26350,26370,26390,26410,26430,26450,26470,26490,26510,26530,26550,26570,26590,26610,26630,26650,26670,26690,26710,26730,26750,26770,26790,26810,26830,26850,26870,26890,26910,26930,26950,26970,26990,27010,27030,27050,27070,27090,27110,27130,27150,27170,27190,27210,27230,27250,27270,27290,27310,27330,27350,27370,27390,27410,27430,27450,27470,27490,27510,27530,27550,27570,27590,27610,27630,27650,27670,27690,27710,27730,27750,27770,27790,27810,27830,27850,27870,27890,27910,27930,27950,27970,27990,28010,28030,28050,28070,28090,28110,28130,28150,28170,28190,28210,28230,28250,28270,28290,28310,28330,28350,28370,28390,28410,28430,28450,28470,28490,28510,28530,28550,28570,28590,28610,28630,28650,28670,28690,28710,28730,28750,28770,28790,28810,28830,28850,28870,28890,28910,28930,28950,28970,28990,29010,29030,29050,29070,29090,29110,29130,29150,29170,29190,29210,29230,29250,29270,29290,29310,29330,29350,29370,29390,29410,29430,29450,29470,29490,29510,29530,29550,29570,29590,29610,29630,29650,29670,29690,29710,29730,29750,29770,29790,29810,29830,29850,29870,29890,29910,29930,29950,29970,29990,30010,30030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,20000,20020,20040,20060,20080,20100,20120,20140,20160,20180,20200,20220,20240,20260,20280,20300,20320,20340,20360,20380,20400,20420,20440,20460,20480,20500,20520,20540,20560,20580,20600,20620,20640,20660,20680,20700,20720,20740,20760,20780,20800,20820,20840,20860,20880,20900,20920,20940,20960,20980,21000,21020,21040,21060,21080,21100,21120,21140,21160,21180,21200,21220,21240,21260,21280,21300,21320,21340,21360,21380,21400,21420,21440,21460,21480,21500,21520,21540,21560,21580,21600,21620,21640,21660,21680,21700,21720,21740,21760,21780,21800,21820,21840,21860,21880,21900,21920,21940,21960,21980,22000,22020,22040,22060,22080,22100,22120,22140,22160,22180,22200,22220,22240,22260,22280,22300,22320,22340,22360,22380,22400,22420,22440,22460,22480,22500,22520,22540,22560,22580,22600,22620,22640,22660,22680,22700,22720,22740,22760,22780,22800,22820,22840,22860,22880,22900,22920,22940,22960,22980,23000,23020,23040,23060,23080,23100,23120,23140,23160,23180,23200,23220,23240,23260,23280,23300,23320,23340,23360,23380,23400,23420,23440,23460,23480,23500,23520,23540,23560,23580,23600,23620,23640,23660,23680,23700,23720,23740,23760,23780,23800,23820,23840,23860,23880,23900,23920,23940,23960,23980,24000,24020,24040,24060,24080,24100,24120,24140,24160,24180,24200,24220,24240,24260,24280,24300,24320,24340,24360,24380,24400,24420,24440,24460,24480,24500,24520,24540,24560,24580,24600,24620,24640,24660,24680,24700,24720,24740,24760,24780,24800,24820,24840,24860,24880,24900,24920,24940,24960,24980,25000,25020,25040,25060,25080,25100,25120,25140,25160,25180,25200,25220,25240,25260,25280,25300,25320,25340,25360,25380,25400,25420,25440,25460,25480,25500,25520,25540,25560,25580,25600,25620,25640,25660,25680,25700,25720,25740,25760,25780,25800,25820,25840,25860,25880,25900,25920,25940,25960,25980,26000,26020,26040,26060,26080,26100,26120,26140,26160,26180,26200,26220,26240,26260,26280,26300,26320,26340,26360,26380,26400,26420,26440,26460,26480,26500,26520,26540,26560,26580,26600,26620,26640,26660,26680,26700,26720,26740,26760,26780,26800,26820,26840,26860,26880,26900,26920,26940,26960,26980,27000,27020,27040,27060,27080,27100,27120,27140,27160,27180,27200,27220,27240,27260,27280,27300,27320,27340,27360,27380,27400,27420,27440,27460,27480,27500,27520,27540,27560,27580,27600,27620,27640,27660,27680,27700,27720,27740,27760,27780,27800,27820,27840,27860,27880,27900,27920,27940,27960,27980,28000,28020,28040,28060,28080,28100,28120,28140,28160,28180,28200,28220,28240,28260,28280,28300,28320,28340,28360,28380,28400,28420,28440,28460,28480,28500,28520,28540,28560,28580,28600,28620,28640,28660,28680,28700,28720,28740,28760,28780,28800,28820,28840,28860,28880,28900,28920,28940,28960,28980,29000,29020,29040,29060,29080,29100,29120,29140,29160,29180,29200,29220,29240,29260,29280,29300,29320,29340,29360,29380,29400,29420,29440,29460,29480,29500,29520,29540,29560,29580,29600,29620,29640,29660,29680,29700,29720,29740,29760,29780,29800,29820,29840,29860,29880,29900,29920,29940,29960,29980],"target":[[0,120],[75,100],[175,80],[225,60],[250,40]],"lateness":[[0,0],[400,280],[501,260],[502,240],[503,220],[504,200],[505,180],[506,160],[507,140],[508,120],[509,100],[510,80],[511,60],[512,40],[513,20],[514,0]]} diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/stretch/corpus.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/stretch/corpus.json index 48bd5098773..5ad591f447e 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/stretch/corpus.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/stretch/corpus.json @@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ "rate": 8000, "channels": 1, "input": [ - 0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, @@ -57,143 +57,9 @@ "target": 640, "cooldown": 0, "decision": "Expand", - "lag": 120, - "output": [ - 0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 1.6081226229577292e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 9.184850732644269e-17, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 3.2162452459154583e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 1.5308084995570108e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -1.8217885367871985e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -5.708681780160804e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 4.797787313243857e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 1.8293794078324752e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 1.1409188368891623e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 3.663764250987631e-17, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -1.8369701465288538e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -6.73865213880276e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 6.432490491830917e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 2.7554553521421787e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -3.0616169991140216e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -5.514005550915388e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466 - ] - }, - { - "name": "expand-ignores-cooldown", - "rate": 8000, - "channels": 1, - "input": [ - 0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 1.6081226229577292e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 9.184850732644269e-17, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 3.2162452459154583e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 1.5308084995570108e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -1.8369701465288538e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -6.73865213880276e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 6.432490491830917e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 2.7554553521421787e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -3.0616169991140216e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -5.514005550915388e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466 - ], - "buffered": 320, - "target": 640, - "cooldown": 1, - "decision": "Expand", - "lag": 120, + "lag": 40, "output": [ - 0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, @@ -216,55 +82,39 @@ -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -1.8217885367871985e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -5.708681780160804e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 4.797787313243857e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 1.8293794078324752e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 1.1409188368891623e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 3.663764250987631e-17, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -1.8369701465288538e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -6.73865213880276e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 6.432490491830917e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 2.7554553521421787e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -3.0616169991140216e-16, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -1.7137210293518407e-16, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -5.514005550915388e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466 + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -2.5030747386672674e-16, + -0.03910861536860466, -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, + -0.2022542506456375, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, + -0.2469220906496048, -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, + -0.14694631099700928, -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, + -1.8369701465288538e-16, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, + 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -6.73865213880276e-16, + -0.03910861536860466, -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, + -0.2022542506456375, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, + -0.2469220906496048, -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, + -0.14694631099700928, -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, + 6.432490491830917e-16, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, + 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 2.7554553521421787e-16, + -0.03910861536860466, -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, + -0.2022542506456375, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, + -0.2469220906496048, -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, + -0.14694631099700928, -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, + -3.0616169991140216e-16, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, + 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -5.514005550915388e-16, + -0.03910861536860466, -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, + -0.2022542506456375, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, + -0.2469220906496048, -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, + -0.14694631099700928, -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466 ] }, { @@ -272,7 +122,7 @@ "rate": 8000, "channels": 1, "input": [ - 0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, @@ -327,7 +177,7 @@ "decision": "Accelerate", "lag": 40, "output": [ - 0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, @@ -374,7 +224,7 @@ "rate": 8000, "channels": 1, "input": [ - 0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, @@ -460,7 +310,7 @@ "rate": 8000, "channels": 1, "input": [ - 0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, @@ -515,7 +365,7 @@ "decision": "Hold", "lag": 0, "output": [ - 0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, @@ -570,7 +420,7 @@ "rate": 8000, "channels": 1, "input": [ - 0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, @@ -619,13 +469,13 @@ -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466 ], - "buffered": 800, + "buffered": 320, "target": 640, "cooldown": 1, "decision": "Hold", "lag": 0, "output": [ - 0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, @@ -793,16 +643,16 @@ "channels": 1, "input": [ -0.0007030649576336145, 0.0009325314313173294, -0.0008886777213774621, -0.00027434012736193836, - -0.0006402268190868199, 0.00027956345002166927, -0.000022392654500436038, -0.0004958766512572765, + -0.0006402268190868199, 0.00027956345002166927, -2.2392654500436038e-5, -0.0004958766512572765, 0.0002554934471845627, -0.0007862572092562914, 0.0009665456018410623, 0.0005669176462106407, -0.0005824891268275678, 0.00019192435138393193, -0.00045695737935602665, 0.00014963874127715826, - -0.0003695623017847538, -0.0005795694887638092, -0.00001852077548392117, -0.0008567545446567237, + -0.0003695623017847538, -0.0005795694887638092, -1.852077548392117e-5, -0.0008567545446567237, 0.0009857823606580496, 0.0005756401806138456, -0.0005451339529827237, 0.00019753548258449882, -0.0006463580066338181, -0.0006663250969722867, -0.00023348850663751364, 0.00043203806853853166, -0.0008616960840299726, 0.000872615841217339, -0.0004974452313035727, -0.0006715144845657051, - -0.0000247669595410116, 0.0008102622232399881, -0.0001687523181317374, 0.00007366603676928207, - 0.0009737846557982266, 0.00005448683077702299, -0.0003058563161175698, -0.0006214933819137514, - 0.000043054074922110885, 0.000262199726421386, 0.00018437781545799226, -0.0006128149689175189, + -2.47669595410116e-5, 0.0008102622232399881, -0.0001687523181317374, 7.366603676928207e-5, + 0.0009737846557982266, 5.448683077702299e-5, -0.0003058563161175698, -0.0006214933819137514, + 4.3054074922110885e-5, 0.000262199726421386, 0.00018437781545799226, -0.0006128149689175189, -0.0009753089398145676, 0.0009309097076766193, 0.0003778619575314224, 0.0006895582773722708, 0.000683246529661119, -0.00014868324797134846, -0.0006266164127737284, 0.0009270667796954513, 0.000792936363723129, -0.000868256320245564, 0.00025973841547966003, 7.850814540688589e-7, @@ -813,25 +663,25 @@ 0.0008628532523289323, -0.0007022370700724423, 0.00040376937249675393, -0.00021518970606848598, -0.0005698790191672742, 0.0007872823043726385, -0.0008089927141554654, -0.0008375357720069587, -0.00030111949308775365, -0.0007078243070282042, -0.00020647711062338203, 0.00026229434297420084, - 0.000030798160878475755, 0.0008422392420470715, -0.000034309341572225094, -0.0007103951065801084, - 0.00009731615864438936, -0.0009534720447845757, 0.00031939285690896213, -0.000682170910295099, - -0.00002548842348915059, -0.00012349399912636727, 0.0008597094565629959, -0.000744685239624232, - -0.0004352022078819573, -0.00034275883808732033, 0.00003958199158660136, -0.00022720580454915762, + 3.0798160878475755e-5, 0.0008422392420470715, -3.4309341572225094e-5, -0.0007103951065801084, + 9.731615864438936e-5, -0.0009534720447845757, 0.00031939285690896213, -0.000682170910295099, + -2.548842348915059e-5, -0.00012349399912636727, 0.0008597094565629959, -0.000744685239624232, + -0.0004352022078819573, -0.00034275883808732033, 3.958199158660136e-5, -0.00022720580454915762, 0.0009628701955080032, 0.0008526424062438309, 0.0008875391213223338, 0.0003391534264665097, 0.0005916213267482817, 0.00010162622493226081, -0.0005961099523119628, -0.0006671503069810569, -0.0006210096762515604, 0.0005345488316379488, 0.0003388409677427262, -0.0009314351482316852, - -0.0004159359959885478, -0.0008514906512573361, 0.00004890025593340397, -0.00031689938623458147, - -0.00003490171366138384, -0.00026018108474090695, -0.0001929930440383032, -0.000092165450041648, + -0.0004159359959885478, -0.0008514906512573361, 4.890025593340397e-5, -0.00031689938623458147, + -3.490171366138384e-5, -0.00026018108474090695, -0.0001929930440383032, -9.2165450041648e-5, 0.0005734908627346158, -0.0008626419585198164, 0.0005156584666110575, 0.00017040438251569867, 0.0005833050236105919, -0.0006876519182696939, -0.000423555844463408, 0.0008145129540935159, 0.0009176674648188055, -0.00045358200441114604, -0.00024749452131800354, -0.0003263925900682807, - -0.0003439123975113034, 0.000896057637874037, 0.0000034957085972564528, -0.0001491785078542307, + -0.0003439123975113034, 0.000896057637874037, 3.4957085972564528e-6, -0.0001491785078542307, 0.0008070407784543931, 0.00027008625329472125, 0.000875414174515754, 0.0002992406371049583, - -0.00011564469605218619, -0.0008426193380728364, -0.00000636793629382737, 0.0000432445558544714, - 0.00023516372311860323, 0.0006941823521628976, -0.0002684972423594445, 0.00009915585542330518, + -0.00011564469605218619, -0.0008426193380728364, -6.36793629382737e-6, 4.32445558544714e-5, + 0.00023516372311860323, 0.0006941823521628976, -0.0002684972423594445, 9.915585542330518e-5, 0.0006486750789918005, 0.0008993244264274836, 0.0006477433489635587, -0.00047298416029661894, 0.0006479199510067701, 0.00034700820106081665, -0.0003696749045047909, 0.0001066054537659511, - 0.0005871927714906633, 0.0006152534624561667, -0.0005119011620990932, -0.000023080843675415963, + 0.0005871927714906633, 0.0006152534624561667, -0.0005119011620990932, -2.3080843675415963e-5, 0.00032716128043830395, -0.0006568834069184959, 0.0005276001757010818, 0.0005797065095975995, 0.0001640981063246727, 0.0009110807441174984, -0.00036736312904395163, -0.00044170720502734184, 0.0009433883242309093, 0.00023131933994591236, -0.0009870975045487285, -0.00013333519746083766, @@ -839,17 +689,17 @@ 0.00035603882861323655, 0.0007108512800186872, -0.0007700424757786095, -0.00011580232239793986, -0.0009333863854408264, -0.0002914093201979995, 0.00016513190348632634, 0.0004173329216428101, -0.0004515971231739968, 0.00031728719477541745, 0.00010745954932644963, -0.00027064152527600527, - 0.000011481797628221102, 0.0006033822428435087, 0.0005782148218713701, -0.0001632032508496195, - 0.0005861674435436726, -0.00012092635006411001, -0.00005408003198681399, -0.0005464808200486004, - -0.00000218033369492332, -0.0008856473723426461, 0.0006918481667526066, -0.0002600167354103178, - -0.00028105307137593627, 0.0007127956487238407, 0.00037160434294492006, -0.0000899228107300587, + 1.1481797628221102e-5, 0.0006033822428435087, 0.0005782148218713701, -0.0001632032508496195, + 0.0005861674435436726, -0.00012092635006411001, -5.408003198681399e-5, -0.0005464808200486004, + -2.18033369492332e-6, -0.0008856473723426461, 0.0006918481667526066, -0.0002600167354103178, + -0.00028105307137593627, 0.0007127956487238407, 0.00037160434294492006, -8.99228107300587e-5, 0.0007251834031194448, 0.00019465443619992584, 0.0007213967037387192, -0.00047412916319444776, 0.0005699122557416558, 0.0008954202057793736, -0.0001985804847208783, 0.0005204827757552266, 0.0009476683917455375, 0.00018205981177743524, 0.0005132625228725374, -0.0007789720548316836, -0.0007717455737292767, 0.0006477507413364947, 0.0005397944478318095, -0.0006914284895174205, 0.0005856238421984017, -0.0007129331352189183, 0.0007025203667581081, 0.0008599847205914557, - 0.00006335222133202478, -0.00040318796527571976, 0.0005218808073550463, 0.0007344660116359591, - -0.0006878993008285761, -0.000056370488891843706, 0.00029790872940793633, 0.0005240894388407469, + 6.335222133202478e-5, -0.00040318796527571976, 0.0005218808073550463, 0.0007344660116359591, + -0.0006878993008285761, -5.6370488891843706e-5, 0.00029790872940793633, 0.0005240894388407469, -0.0009706376004032791, 0.0006069837254472077, 0.00024918612325564027, 0.0006460933363996446, -0.0007419105968438089, -0.00017247976211365312, 0.00025107196415774524, 0.0007953110034577549 ], @@ -860,16 +710,16 @@ "lag": 62, "output": [ -0.0007030649576336145, 0.0009325314313173294, -0.0008886777213774621, -0.00027434012736193836, - -0.0006402268190868199, 0.00027956345002166927, -0.000022392654500436038, -0.0004958766512572765, + -0.0006402268190868199, 0.00027956345002166927, -2.2392654500436038e-5, -0.0004958766512572765, 0.0002554934471845627, -0.0007862572092562914, 0.0009665456018410623, 0.0005669176462106407, -0.0005824891268275678, 0.00019192435138393193, -0.00045695737935602665, 0.00014963874127715826, - -0.0003695623017847538, -0.0005795694887638092, -0.00001852077548392117, -0.0008567545446567237, + -0.0003695623017847538, -0.0005795694887638092, -1.852077548392117e-5, -0.0008567545446567237, 0.0009857823606580496, 0.0005756401806138456, -0.0005451339529827237, 0.00019753548258449882, -0.0006463580066338181, -0.0006663250969722867, -0.00023348850663751364, 0.00043203806853853166, -0.0008616960840299726, 0.000872615841217339, -0.0004974452313035727, -0.0006715144845657051, - -0.0000247669595410116, 0.0008102622232399881, -0.0001687523181317374, 0.00007366603676928207, - 0.0009737846557982266, 0.00005448683077702299, -0.0003058563161175698, -0.0006214933819137514, - 0.000043054074922110885, 0.000262199726421386, 0.00018437781545799226, -0.0006128149689175189, + -2.47669595410116e-5, 0.0008102622232399881, -0.0001687523181317374, 7.366603676928207e-5, + 0.0009737846557982266, 5.448683077702299e-5, -0.0003058563161175698, -0.0006214933819137514, + 4.3054074922110885e-5, 0.000262199726421386, 0.00018437781545799226, -0.0006128149689175189, -0.0009753089398145676, 0.0009309097076766193, 0.0003778619575314224, 0.0006895582773722708, 0.000683246529661119, -0.00014868324797134846, -0.0006266164127737284, 0.0009270667796954513, 0.000792936363723129, -0.000868256320245564, 0.00025973841547966003, 7.850814540688589e-7, @@ -880,58 +730,58 @@ 0.0008628532523289323, -0.0007022370700724423, 0.00040376937249675393, -0.00021518970606848598, -0.0005698790191672742, 0.0007872823043726385, -0.0008089927141554654, -0.0008375357720069587, -0.00030111949308775365, -0.0007078243070282042, -0.00020647711062338203, 0.00026229434297420084, - 0.000030798160878475755, 0.0008422392420470715, -0.000034309341572225094, -0.0007103951065801084, - 0.00009731615864438936, -0.0009534720447845757, 0.00031939285690896213, -0.000682170910295099, - -0.00002548842348915059, -0.00012349399912636727, 0.0008597094565629959, -0.000744685239624232, - -0.0004352022078819573, -0.00034275883808732033, 0.00003958199158660136, -0.00022720580454915762, + 3.0798160878475755e-5, 0.0008422392420470715, -3.4309341572225094e-5, -0.0007103951065801084, + 9.731615864438936e-5, -0.0009534720447845757, 0.00031939285690896213, -0.000682170910295099, + -2.548842348915059e-5, -0.00012349399912636727, 0.0008597094565629959, -0.000744685239624232, + -0.0004352022078819573, -0.00034275883808732033, 3.958199158660136e-5, -0.00022720580454915762, 0.0009628701955080032, 0.0008526424062438309, 0.0008875391213223338, 0.0003391534264665097, 0.0005916213267482817, 0.00010162622493226081, -0.0005961099523119628, -0.0006671503069810569, -0.0006210096762515604, 0.0005345488316379488, 0.0003388409677427262, -0.0009314351482316852, - -0.0004159359959885478, -0.0008514906512573361, 0.00004890025593340397, -0.00031689938623458147, - -0.00003490171366138384, -0.00026018108474090695, -0.0001929930440383032, -0.000092165450041648, + -0.0004159359959885478, -0.0008514906512573361, 4.890025593340397e-5, -0.00031689938623458147, + -3.490171366138384e-5, -0.00026018108474090695, -0.0001929930440383032, -9.2165450041648e-5, 0.000569164112675935, -0.0008386498084291816, 0.00046778583782725036, 0.00020864862017333508, 0.0005642396863549948, -0.0006643258384428918, -0.0003146957606077194, 0.0008150897338055074, 0.0007545956177636981, -0.00035826212842948735, -0.00034601881634444, -0.0004042369546368718, -0.0001283905003219843, 0.0008990895003080368, 0.00020810464047826827, -0.000289637828245759, 0.0006982214981690049, 0.00013143598334863782, 0.0004395321011543274, 0.00045417450019158423, -0.0003467607020866126, -0.0008408441208302975, -0.00011397564958315343, -0.0002428769221296534, - 0.00005990942372591235, 0.0005159428692422807, -0.00014022778486832976, 0.00042941514402627945, + 5.990942372591235e-5, 0.0005159428692422807, -0.00014022778486832976, 0.00042941514402627945, 0.00033428543247282505, 0.00013279131962917745, 0.0003768982132896781, -0.0007170414901338518, - 0.0004758343275170773, -0.00020842179947067052, -0.0001784601918188855, -0.000024879947886802256, + 0.0004758343275170773, -0.00020842179947067052, -0.0001784601918188855, -2.4879947886802256e-5, 0.0007472422439604998, -0.0002050270268227905, -0.0004644208529498428, -0.00022605099366046488, 0.00014000650844536722, -0.0003704316623043269, 0.0008246892248280346, 0.0007703283918090165, - 0.0006808416801504791, 0.0004934830358251929, 0.0003480697050690651, -0.000027738877179217525, + 0.0006808416801504791, 0.0004934830358251929, 0.0003480697050690651, -2.7738877179217525e-5, -0.0002539992274250835, -0.0004817518056370318, -0.000690740707796067, 0.0004179341485723853, 0.0002270218392368406, -0.0007047466933727264, -0.0002430536551401019, -0.0008376236655749381, - 0.00007815154822310433, -0.000235331870499067, -0.00008157731645042077, -0.0002533059159759432, - -0.0002164975885534659, -0.00009532805415801704, 0.0005734908627346158, -0.0008626419585198164, + 7.815154822310433e-5, -0.000235331870499067, -8.157731645042077e-5, -0.0002533059159759432, + -0.0002164975885534659, -9.532805415801704e-5, 0.0005734908627346158, -0.0008626419585198164, 0.0005156584666110575, 0.00017040438251569867, 0.0005833050236105919, -0.0006876519182696939, -0.000423555844463408, 0.0008145129540935159, 0.0009176674648188055, -0.00045358200441114604, -0.00024749452131800354, -0.0003263925900682807, -0.0003439123975113034, 0.000896057637874037, - 0.0000034957085972564528, -0.0001491785078542307, 0.0008070407784543931, 0.00027008625329472125, + 3.4957085972564528e-6, -0.0001491785078542307, 0.0008070407784543931, 0.00027008625329472125, 0.000875414174515754, 0.0002992406371049583, -0.00011564469605218619, -0.0008426193380728364, - -0.00000636793629382737, 0.0000432445558544714, 0.00023516372311860323, 0.0006941823521628976, - -0.0002684972423594445, 0.00009915585542330518, 0.0006486750789918005, 0.0008993244264274836, + -6.36793629382737e-6, 4.32445558544714e-5, 0.00023516372311860323, 0.0006941823521628976, + -0.0002684972423594445, 9.915585542330518e-5, 0.0006486750789918005, 0.0008993244264274836, 0.0006477433489635587, -0.00047298416029661894, 0.0006479199510067701, 0.00034700820106081665, -0.0003696749045047909, 0.0001066054537659511, 0.0005871927714906633, 0.0006152534624561667, - -0.0005119011620990932, -0.000023080843675415963, 0.00032716128043830395, -0.0006568834069184959, + -0.0005119011620990932, -2.3080843675415963e-5, 0.00032716128043830395, -0.0006568834069184959, 0.0005276001757010818, 0.0005797065095975995, 0.0001640981063246727, 0.0009110807441174984, -0.00036736312904395163, -0.00044170720502734184, 0.0009433883242309093, 0.00023131933994591236, -0.0009870975045487285, -0.00013333519746083766, -0.00036561954766511917, 0.0006553839193657041, 0.0009455124381929636, -0.0007266877219080925, 0.00035603882861323655, 0.0007108512800186872, -0.0007700424757786095, -0.00011580232239793986, -0.0009333863854408264, -0.0002914093201979995, 0.00016513190348632634, 0.0004173329216428101, -0.0004515971231739968, 0.00031728719477541745, - 0.00010745954932644963, -0.00027064152527600527, 0.000011481797628221102, 0.0006033822428435087, + 0.00010745954932644963, -0.00027064152527600527, 1.1481797628221102e-5, 0.0006033822428435087, 0.0005782148218713701, -0.0001632032508496195, 0.0005861674435436726, -0.00012092635006411001, - -0.00005408003198681399, -0.0005464808200486004, -0.00000218033369492332, -0.0008856473723426461, + -5.408003198681399e-5, -0.0005464808200486004, -2.18033369492332e-6, -0.0008856473723426461, 0.0006918481667526066, -0.0002600167354103178, -0.00028105307137593627, 0.0007127956487238407, - 0.00037160434294492006, -0.0000899228107300587, 0.0007251834031194448, 0.00019465443619992584, + 0.00037160434294492006, -8.99228107300587e-5, 0.0007251834031194448, 0.00019465443619992584, 0.0007213967037387192, -0.00047412916319444776, 0.0005699122557416558, 0.0008954202057793736, -0.0001985804847208783, 0.0005204827757552266, 0.0009476683917455375, 0.00018205981177743524, 0.0005132625228725374, -0.0007789720548316836, -0.0007717455737292767, 0.0006477507413364947, 0.0005397944478318095, -0.0006914284895174205, 0.0005856238421984017, -0.0007129331352189183, - 0.0007025203667581081, 0.0008599847205914557, 0.00006335222133202478, -0.00040318796527571976, - 0.0005218808073550463, 0.0007344660116359591, -0.0006878993008285761, -0.000056370488891843706, + 0.0007025203667581081, 0.0008599847205914557, 6.335222133202478e-5, -0.00040318796527571976, + 0.0005218808073550463, 0.0007344660116359591, -0.0006878993008285761, -5.6370488891843706e-5, 0.00029790872940793633, 0.0005240894388407469, -0.0009706376004032791, 0.0006069837254472077, 0.00024918612325564027, 0.0006460933363996446, -0.0007419105968438089, -0.00017247976211365312, 0.00025107196415774524, 0.0007953110034577549 @@ -942,7 +792,7 @@ "rate": 8000, "channels": 2, "input": [ - 0, 0, 0.03910861536860466, -0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, -0.07725425064563751, + 0.0, -0.0, 0.03910861536860466, -0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, -0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, -0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, -0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, -0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, -0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, -0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, -0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, -0.2469220906496048, 0.25, -0.25, @@ -1043,9 +893,9 @@ "target": 640, "cooldown": 0, "decision": "Expand", - "lag": 120, + "lag": 40, "output": [ - 0, 0, 0.03910861536860466, -0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, -0.07725425064563751, + 0.0, -0.0, 0.03910861536860466, -0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, -0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, -0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, -0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, -0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, -0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, -0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, -0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, -0.2469220906496048, 0.25, -0.25, @@ -1093,39 +943,7 @@ 0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, 0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, 0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, 0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, 0.14694631099700928, -0.11349762231111526, 0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, 0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 0.03910861536860466, - -1.8217885367871985e-16, 1.8217885367871985e-16, 0.03910861536860466, -0.03910861536860466, - 0.07725425064563751, -0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, -0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, - -0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, -0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, -0.2022542506456375, - 0.22275163233280182, -0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, -0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, - -0.2469220906496048, 0.25, -0.25, 0.2469220906496048, -0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, - -0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, -0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, -0.2022542506456375, - 0.1767766922712326, -0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, -0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, - -0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, -0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -0.03910861536860466, - -5.708681780160804e-16, 5.708681780160804e-16, -0.03910861536860466, 0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, 0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, 0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, - 0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, 0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, 0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, 0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, 0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, - 0.2469220906496048, -0.25, 0.25, -0.2469220906496048, 0.2469220906496048, -0.2377641350030899, - 0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, 0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, 0.2022542506456375, - -0.1767766922712326, 0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, 0.14694631099700928, -0.11349762231111526, - 0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, 0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 0.03910861536860466, - 4.797787313243857e-16, -4.797787313243857e-16, 0.03910861536860466, -0.03910861536860466, - 0.07725425064563751, -0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, -0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, - -0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, -0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, -0.2022542506456375, - 0.22275163233280182, -0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, -0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, - -0.2469220906496048, 0.25, -0.25, 0.2469220906496048, -0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, - -0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, -0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, -0.2022542506456375, - 0.1767766922712326, -0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, -0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, - -0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, -0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -0.03910861536860466, - 1.8293794078324752e-16, -1.8293794078324752e-16, -0.03910861536860466, 0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, 0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, 0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, - 0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, 0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, 0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, 0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, 0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, - 0.2469220906496048, -0.25, 0.25, -0.2469220906496048, 0.2469220906496048, -0.2377641350030899, - 0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, 0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, 0.2022542506456375, - -0.1767766922712326, 0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, 0.14694631099700928, -0.11349762231111526, - 0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, 0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 0.03910861536860466, - 1.1409188368891623e-16, -1.1409188368891623e-16, 0.03910861536860466, -0.03910861536860466, + -1.7137210293518407e-16, 1.7137210293518407e-16, 0.03910861536860466, -0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, -0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, -0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, -0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, -0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, -0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, -0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, -0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, @@ -1133,7 +951,7 @@ -0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, -0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, -0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, -0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, -0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, -0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, -0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -0.03910861536860466, - 3.663764250987631e-17, -3.663764250987631e-17, -0.03910861536860466, 0.03910861536860466, + -2.5030747386672674e-16, 2.5030747386672674e-16, -0.03910861536860466, 0.03910861536860466, -0.07725425064563751, 0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, 0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, 0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, 0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, 0.2022542506456375, -0.22275163233280182, 0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, 0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, @@ -1196,7 +1014,7 @@ "rate": 44100, "channels": 1, "input": [ - 0, 0.007122828625142574, 0.014239874668419361, 0.021345358341932297, 0.028433511033654213, + 0.0, 0.007122828625142574, 0.014239874668419361, 0.021345358341932297, 0.028433511033654213, 0.03549857810139656, 0.04253482446074486, 0.04953653737902641, 0.056498028337955475, 0.06341364234685898, 0.07027778029441833, 0.07708485424518585, 0.08382933586835861, 0.09050575643777847, 0.09710869938135147, 0.10363279283046722, 0.11007274687290192, 0.11642333120107651, 0.12267939001321793, 0.12883584201335907, @@ -1482,7 +1300,7 @@ "decision": "Expand", "lag": 441, "output": [ - 0, 0.007122828625142574, 0.014239874668419361, 0.021345358341932297, 0.028433511033654213, + 0.0, 0.007122828625142574, 0.014239874668419361, 0.021345358341932297, 0.028433511033654213, 0.03549857810139656, 0.04253482446074486, 0.04953653737902641, 0.056498028337955475, 0.06341364234685898, 0.07027778029441833, 0.07708485424518585, 0.08382933586835861, 0.09050575643777847, 0.09710869938135147, 0.10363279283046722, 0.11007274687290192, 0.11642333120107651, 0.12267939001321793, 0.12883584201335907, @@ -1861,7 +1679,7 @@ "rate": 48000, "channels": 1, "input": [ - 0, 0.006544237025082111, 0.013083988800644875, 0.019614774733781815, 0.026132116094231606, + 0.0, 0.006544237025082111, 0.013083988800644875, 0.019614774733781815, 0.026132116094231606, 0.03263154625892639, 0.03910861536860466, 0.045558881014585495, 0.05197792127728462, 0.05836134031414986, 0.0647047609090805, 0.07100383937358856, 0.07725425064563751, 0.08345171809196472, 0.08959198743104935, 0.09567085653543472, 0.10168416053056717, 0.10762777179479599, 0.11349762231111526, 0.11928968876600266, @@ -2164,7 +1982,7 @@ "decision": "Accelerate", "lag": 240, "output": [ - 0, 0.006544237025082111, 0.013083988800644875, 0.019614774733781815, 0.026132116094231606, + 0.0, 0.006544237025082111, 0.013083988800644875, 0.019614774733781815, 0.026132116094231606, 0.03263154625892639, 0.03910861536860466, 0.045558881014585495, 0.05197792127728462, 0.05836134031414986, 0.0647047609090805, 0.07100383937358856, 0.07725425064563751, 0.08345171809196472, 0.08959198743104935, 0.09567085653543472, 0.10168416053056717, 0.10762777179479599, 0.11349762231111526, 0.11928968876600266, @@ -2621,131 +2439,328 @@ ] }, { - "name": "expand-lower-threshold", + "name": "hold-within-lateness", "rate": 8000, "channels": 1, "input": [ - 0.20665311813354492, 0.2251681536436081, 0.09140059351921082, 0.05964577570557594, 0.27126818895339966, - 0.2611585259437561, 0.5343368053436279, 0.2829405665397644, 0.4139336049556732, 0.49448898434638977, - 0.694867730140686, 0.44727185368537903, 0.29707813262939453, 0.5544354319572449, 0.43507903814315796, - 0.1685018539428711, 0.5103511214256287, 0.4939669966697693, 0.3251879811286926, 0.31169506907463074, - -0.1139114573597908, 0.06750354170799255, 0.10024532675743103, -0.09390536695718765, -0.2812177240848541, - -0.5577773451805115, -0.4035545587539673, -0.33442074060440063, -0.18016880750656128, -0.16449593007564545, - -0.46379414200782776, -0.22527380287647247, -0.5716800689697266, -0.21793623268604279, -0.33483806252479553, - -0.6097730398178101, -0.13268055021762848, -0.2650015950202942, 0.055849339812994, 0.03049641102552414, - -0.29931432008743286, 0.06654223054647446, 0.3596193194389343, 0.05064225196838379, 0.15962597727775574, - 0.5404807925224304, 0.17869789898395538, 0.44145938754081726, 0.2711449861526489, 0.7249839305877686, - 0.6319077014923096, 0.41324150562286377, 0.1762429177761078, 0.2929857075214386, 0.36882203817367554, - 0.5778983235359192, 0.029938071966171265, 0.235056072473526, 0.2629944980144501, 0.09886005520820618, - 0.18868011236190796, -0.04622534662485123, 0.13924548029899597, -0.1423843502998352, -0.21193312108516693, - -0.35120463371276855, -0.3062855303287506, -0.47001224756240845, -0.382584810256958, -0.57026207447052, - -0.6363651752471924, -0.6324220299720764, -0.3603115379810333, -0.30695730447769165, -0.37813904881477356, - -0.564303457736969, -0.1099410131573677, 0.02176649682223797, 0.11497095972299576, 0.13508062064647675, - 0.23890388011932373, 0.32424497604370117, 0.16341760754585266, 0.13907335698604584, 0.38767340779304504, - 0.1835785210132599, 0.5510348677635193, 0.610644519329071, 0.6649988293647766, 0.4983404576778412, - 0.7198589444160461, 0.49227675795555115, 0.3983132839202881, 0.49710017442703247, 0.6618123650550842, - 0.5683627724647522, 0.440498411655426, -0.04628048092126846, 0.2067275047302246, 0.06226203218102455, - 0.07808840274810791, 0.13665103912353516, -0.29323628544807434, -0.06540219485759735, -0.4942227900028229, - -0.4859217405319214, -0.18730786442756653, -0.5014312267303467, -0.23842757940292358, -0.6840952634811401, - -0.6621848940849304, -0.32585737109184265, -0.7008349895477295, -0.3566333055496216, -0.1180480420589447, - -0.29767927527427673, -0.15614987909793854, -0.4882776439189911, -0.05805770307779312, - -0.006592458579689264, 0.04557177051901817, 0.005121154710650444, 0.06114161014556885, 0.49260571599006653, - -0.013661413453519344, 0.03117995709180832, 0.6406764388084412, 0.2119361013174057, 0.20231252908706665, - 0.2708056569099426, 0.6304479837417603, 0.7066412568092346, 0.14164498448371887, 0.3563242256641388, - 0.12495777755975723, 0.1741499900817871, 0.09700092673301697, 0.2924511432647705, 0.04923402890563011, - -0.12141375243663788, 0.002181903226301074, -0.3467682898044586, -0.3785049021244049, 0.08864536136388779, - -0.4448899030685425, -0.40306487679481506, -0.22509866952896118, -0.19795699417591095, -0.1768862009048462, - -0.6428049802780151, -0.3464156687259674, -0.164530411362648, -0.6931448578834534, -0.2952318787574768, - -0.15680289268493652, -0.4128105342388153, -0.41409096121788025, -0.14622089266777039, -0.17366923391819, - -0.26550382375717163, -0.017024751752614975, 0.01633874699473381, 0.1805252879858017, 0.20945580303668976, - 0.15137095749378204, 0.23248906433582306, 0.5666543245315552, 0.2515125274658203, 0.464335560798645, - 0.15192154049873352, 0.5949446558952332, 0.34600967168807983, 0.1553933322429657, 0.26948282122612, - 0.20813588798046112, 0.590075671672821, 0.17583869397640228, 0.07702247053384781, 0.05457836762070656, - 0.3385390043258667, 0.08024871349334717, 0.002250598045065999, -0.009686036966741085, -0.2714853882789612, - -0.3158525824546814, -0.22769834101200104, -0.6631430983543396, -0.5855672359466553, -0.5273343920707703, - -0.600810170173645, -0.36756035685539246, -0.5172709226608276, -0.20272140204906464, -0.3600620925426483, - -0.4154137969017029, -0.376837819814682, -0.14340558648109436, -0.2533597946166992, -0.041740115731954575, - -0.34232768416404724, -0.03278868645429611, -0.0740683376789093, -0.06633041054010391, 0.22083960473537445, - 0.25686272978782654, 0.3550409972667694, 0.5173485279083252, 0.6312780380249023, 0.4247250258922577, - 0.33169469237327576, 0.4301353394985199, 0.6298872828483582, 0.6529852151870728, 0.5884019136428833, - 0.17685842514038086, 0.6178502440452576, 0.34435662627220154, -0.04562404379248619, 0.27439025044441223, - 0.36248838901519775, -0.058909907937049866, 0.03671349212527275, -0.249351367354393, -0.3761809170246124, - -0.13410887122154236, -0.6167834997177124, -0.17041879892349243, -0.3839453458786011, -0.6693048477172852, - -0.6731173992156982, -0.360440731048584, -0.22026745975017548, -0.5599857568740845, -0.11384382098913193, - -0.603949248790741, -0.10583518445491791, -0.32648566365242004, -0.4554884731769562, -0.27422934770584106, - -0.09860859811306 + 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 1.6081226229577292e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 9.184850732644269e-17, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 3.2162452459154583e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 1.5308084995570108e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -1.8369701465288538e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -6.73865213880276e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 6.432490491830917e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 2.7554553521421787e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -3.0616169991140216e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -5.514005550915388e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466 ], - "buffered": 320, + "buffered": 800, "target": 640, + "lateness": 160, "cooldown": 0, - "decision": "Expand", - "lag": 81, + "decision": "Hold", + "lag": 0, "output": [ - 0.20665311813354492, 0.2251681536436081, 0.09140059351921082, 0.05964577570557594, 0.27126818895339966, - 0.2611585259437561, 0.5343368053436279, 0.2829405665397644, 0.4139336049556732, 0.49448898434638977, - 0.694867730140686, 0.44727185368537903, 0.29707813262939453, 0.5544354319572449, 0.43507903814315796, - 0.1685018539428711, 0.5103511214256287, 0.4939669966697693, 0.3251879811286926, 0.31169506907463074, - -0.1139114573597908, 0.06750354170799255, 0.10024532675743103, -0.09390536695718765, -0.2812177240848541, - -0.5577773451805115, -0.4035545587539673, -0.33442074060440063, -0.18016880750656128, -0.16449593007564545, - -0.46379414200782776, -0.22527380287647247, -0.5716800689697266, -0.21793623268604279, -0.33483806252479553, - -0.6097730398178101, -0.13268055021762848, -0.2650015950202942, 0.055849339812994, 0.03049641102552414, - -0.29931432008743286, 0.06654223054647446, 0.3596193194389343, 0.05064225196838379, 0.15962597727775574, - 0.5404807925224304, 0.17869789898395538, 0.44145938754081726, 0.2711449861526489, 0.7249839305877686, - 0.6319077014923096, 0.41324150562286377, 0.1762429177761078, 0.2929857075214386, 0.36882203817367554, - 0.5778983235359192, 0.029938071966171265, 0.235056072473526, 0.2629944980144501, 0.09886005520820618, - 0.18868011236190796, -0.04622534662485123, 0.13924548029899597, -0.1423843502998352, -0.21193312108516693, - -0.35120463371276855, -0.3062855303287506, -0.47001224756240845, -0.382584810256958, -0.57026207447052, - -0.6363651752471924, -0.6324220299720764, -0.3603115379810333, -0.30695730447769165, -0.37813904881477356, - -0.564303457736969, -0.1099410131573677, 0.02176649682223797, 0.11497095972299576, 0.13508062064647675, - 0.23890388011932373, 0.32424497604370117, 0.16341760754585266, 0.13907335698604584, 0.38767340779304504, - 0.1835785210132599, 0.5510348677635193, 0.610644519329071, 0.6649988293647766, 0.4983404576778412, - 0.7198589444160461, 0.49227675795555115, 0.3983132839202881, 0.49710017442703247, 0.6618123650550842, - 0.5683627724647522, 0.440498411655426, -0.04628048092126846, 0.2067275047302246, 0.06226203218102455, - 0.07808840274810791, 0.13665103912353516, -0.29323628544807434, -0.06540219485759735, -0.4942227900028229, - -0.4859217405319214, -0.18730786442756653, -0.5014312267303467, -0.23842757940292358, -0.6840952634811401, - -0.6621848940849304, -0.32585737109184265, -0.7008349895477295, -0.3566333055496216, -0.1180480420589447, - -0.29767927527427673, -0.15614987909793854, -0.4882776439189911, -0.05805770307779312, - -0.006592458579689264, 0.04538792371749878, -0.002304100664332509, 0.06133919209241867, 0.4861185848712921, - -0.009740457870066166, 0.0405784472823143, 0.6321231722831726, 0.20869335532188416, 0.22856035828590393, - 0.27084705233573914, 0.6431296467781067, 0.6957046389579773, 0.18470296263694763, 0.32557862997055054, - 0.15569458901882172, 0.21213477849960327, 0.19669917225837708, 0.23482632637023926, 0.09229035675525665, - -0.027655642479658127, 0.02694094181060791, -0.20311139523983002, -0.28530454635620117, 0.10345514863729477, - -0.352662593126297, -0.34246212244033813, -0.26662135124206543, -0.23494721949100494, -0.2805527150630951, - -0.5476024746894836, -0.43104052543640137, -0.34866106510162354, -0.6687076091766357, -0.32221612334251404, - -0.22089318931102753, -0.39758890867233276, -0.48186975717544556, -0.12940827012062073, - -0.08071809262037277, -0.07990636676549911, 0.059027932584285736, 0.13033552467823029, 0.25589048862457275, - 0.18475237488746643, 0.14462228119373322, 0.3195436894893646, 0.34708648920059204, 0.42684268951416016, - 0.5517640709877014, 0.4647735357284546, 0.5348615646362305, 0.5830848217010498, 0.3731350600719452, - 0.3543224036693573, 0.40195339918136597, 0.6390665769577026, 0.448690801858902, 0.334115207195282, - -0.017990803346037865, 0.242091566324234, 0.0668683797121048, 0.0595913790166378, 0.10274367034435272, - -0.28846168518066406, -0.1173248365521431, -0.44221800565719604, -0.5183402895927429, -0.25530335307121277, - -0.5055378079414368, -0.29145917296409607, -0.6416332721710205, -0.6445124745368958, -0.31234243512153625, - -0.6675888299942017, -0.36165115237236023, -0.13698388636112213, -0.28827235102653503, -0.1608918309211731, - -0.47194090485572815, -0.06499111652374268, -0.006911924574524164, 0.04557177051901817, - 0.005121154710650444, 0.06114161014556885, 0.49260571599006653, -0.013661413453519344, 0.03117995709180832, - 0.6406764388084412, 0.2119361013174057, 0.20231252908706665, 0.2708056569099426, 0.6304479837417603, - 0.7066412568092346, 0.14164498448371887, 0.3563242256641388, 0.12495777755975723, 0.1741499900817871, - 0.09700092673301697, 0.2924511432647705, 0.04923402890563011, -0.12141375243663788, 0.002181903226301074, - -0.3467682898044586, -0.3785049021244049, 0.08864536136388779, -0.4448899030685425, -0.40306487679481506, - -0.22509866952896118, -0.19795699417591095, -0.1768862009048462, -0.6428049802780151, -0.3464156687259674, - -0.164530411362648, -0.6931448578834534, -0.2952318787574768, -0.15680289268493652, -0.4128105342388153, - -0.41409096121788025, -0.14622089266777039, -0.17366923391819, -0.26550382375717163, -0.017024751752614975, - 0.01633874699473381, 0.1805252879858017, 0.20945580303668976, 0.15137095749378204, 0.23248906433582306, - 0.5666543245315552, 0.2515125274658203, 0.464335560798645, 0.15192154049873352, 0.5949446558952332, - 0.34600967168807983, 0.1553933322429657, 0.26948282122612, 0.20813588798046112, 0.590075671672821, - 0.17583869397640228, 0.07702247053384781, 0.05457836762070656, 0.3385390043258667, 0.08024871349334717, - 0.002250598045065999, -0.009686036966741085, -0.2714853882789612, -0.3158525824546814, -0.22769834101200104, - -0.6631430983543396, -0.5855672359466553, -0.5273343920707703, -0.600810170173645, -0.36756035685539246, - -0.5172709226608276, -0.20272140204906464, -0.3600620925426483, -0.4154137969017029, -0.376837819814682, - -0.14340558648109436, -0.2533597946166992, -0.041740115731954575, -0.34232768416404724, - -0.03278868645429611, -0.0740683376789093, -0.06633041054010391, 0.22083960473537445, 0.25686272978782654, - 0.3550409972667694, 0.5173485279083252, 0.6312780380249023, 0.4247250258922577, 0.33169469237327576, - 0.4301353394985199, 0.6298872828483582, 0.6529852151870728, 0.5884019136428833, 0.17685842514038086, - 0.6178502440452576, 0.34435662627220154, -0.04562404379248619, 0.27439025044441223, 0.36248838901519775, - -0.058909907937049866, 0.03671349212527275, -0.249351367354393, -0.3761809170246124, -0.13410887122154236, - -0.6167834997177124, -0.17041879892349243, -0.3839453458786011, -0.6693048477172852, -0.6731173992156982, - -0.360440731048584, -0.22026745975017548, -0.5599857568740845, -0.11384382098913193, -0.603949248790741, - -0.10583518445491791, -0.32648566365242004, -0.4554884731769562, -0.27422934770584106, -0.09860859811306 + 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 1.6081226229577292e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 9.184850732644269e-17, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 3.2162452459154583e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 1.5308084995570108e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -1.8369701465288538e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -6.73865213880276e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 6.432490491830917e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 2.7554553521421787e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -3.0616169991140216e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -5.514005550915388e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466 + ] + }, + { + "name": "accelerate-above-lateness", + "rate": 8000, + "channels": 1, + "input": [ + 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 1.6081226229577292e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 9.184850732644269e-17, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 3.2162452459154583e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 1.5308084995570108e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -1.8369701465288538e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -6.73865213880276e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 6.432490491830917e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 2.7554553521421787e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -3.0616169991140216e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -5.514005550915388e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466 + ], + "buffered": 960, + "target": 640, + "lateness": 160, + "cooldown": 0, + "decision": "Accelerate", + "lag": 40, + "output": [ + 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 1.6081226229577292e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 9.184850732644269e-17, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 3.092996128738445e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -2.7047689005784813e-16, + -0.03910861536860466, -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, + -0.2022542506456375, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, + -0.2469220906496048, -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, + -0.14694631099700928, -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, + 6.432490491830917e-16, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, + 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 2.7554553521421787e-16, + -0.03910861536860466, -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, + -0.2022542506456375, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, + -0.2469220906496048, -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, + -0.14694631099700928, -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, + -3.0616169991140216e-16, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, + 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -5.514005550915388e-16, + -0.03910861536860466, -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, + -0.2022542506456375, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, + -0.2469220906496048, -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, + -0.14694631099700928, -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466 + ] + }, + { + "name": "hold-below-widened-fast", + "rate": 8000, + "channels": 1, + "input": [ + 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 1.6081226229577292e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 9.184850732644269e-17, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 3.2162452459154583e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 1.5308084995570108e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -1.8369701465288538e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -6.73865213880276e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 6.432490491830917e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 2.7554553521421787e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -3.0616169991140216e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -5.514005550915388e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466 + ], + "buffered": 3200, + "target": 640, + "lateness": 160, + "cooldown": 160, + "decision": "Hold", + "lag": 0, + "output": [ + 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 1.6081226229577292e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 9.184850732644269e-17, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 3.2162452459154583e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 1.5308084995570108e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -1.8369701465288538e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -6.73865213880276e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 6.432490491830917e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 2.7554553521421787e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -3.0616169991140216e-16, + 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, + 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, + 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, + 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -5.514005550915388e-16, -0.03910861536860466, + -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, + -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, + -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, + -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466 ] } ] diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/tunein.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/tunein.json index 5b8ff6f9013..295c860ad4a 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/tunein.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/tunein.json @@ -1 +1 @@ -{"name":"tunein","about":"One frame from a stale group, then the live edge 14.5 s later, then 30 s of even audio. The #3517 branch reported 14.56 s here; the target must stay near the frame duration.","frame":20,"arrival":[0,10,30,50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030,20050,20070,20090,20110,20130,20150,20170,20190,20210,20230,20250,20270,20290,20310,20330,20350,20370,20390,20410,20430,20450,20470,20490,20510,20530,20550,20570,20590,20610,20630,20650,20670,20690,20710,20730,20750,20770,20790,20810,20830,20850,20870,20890,20910,20930,20950,20970,20990,21010,21030,21050,21070,21090,21110,21130,21150,21170,21190,21210,21230,21250,21270,21290,21310,21330,21350,21370,21390,21410,21430,21450,21470,21490,21510,21530,21550,21570,21590,21610,21630,21650,21670,21690,21710,21730,21750,21770,21790,21810,21830,21850,21870,21890,21910,21930,21950,21970,21990,22010,22030,22050,22070,22090,22110,22130,22150,22170,22190,22210,22230,22250,22270,22290,22310,22330,22350,22370,22390,22410,22430,22450,22470,22490,22510,22530,22550,22570,22590,22610,22630,22650,22670,22690,22710,22730,22750,22770,22790,22810,22830,22850,22870,22890,22910,22930,22950,22970,22990,23010,23030,23050,23070,23090,23110,23130,23150,23170,23190,23210,23230,23250,23270,23290,23310,23330,23350,23370,23390,23410,23430,23450,23470,23490,23510,23530,23550,23570,23590,23610,23630,23650,23670,23690,23710,23730,23750,23770,23790,23810,23830,23850,23870,23890,23910,23930,23950,23970,23990,24010,24030,24050,24070,24090,24110,24130,24150,24170,24190,24210,24230,24250,24270,24290,24310,24330,24350,24370,24390,24410,24430,24450,24470,24490,24510,24530,24550,24570,24590,24610,24630,24650,24670,24690,24710,24730,24750,24770,24790,24810,24830,24850,24870,24890,24910,24930,24950,24970,24990,25010,25030,25050,25070,25090,25110,25130,25150,25170,25190,25210,25230,25250,25270,25290,25310,25330,25350,25370,25390,25410,25430,25450,25470,25490,25510,25530,25550,25570,25590,25610,25630,25650,25670,25690,25710,25730,25750,25770,25790,25810,25830,25850,25870,25890,25910,25930,25950,25970,25990,26010,26030,26050,26070,26090,26110,26130,26150,26170,26190,26210,26230,26250,26270,26290,26310,26330,26350,26370,26390,26410,26430,26450,26470,26490,26510,26530,26550,26570,26590,26610,26630,26650,26670,26690,26710,26730,26750,26770,26790,26810,26830,26850,26870,26890,26910,26930,26950,26970,26990,27010,27030,27050,27070,27090,27110,27130,27150,27170,27190,27210,27230,27250,27270,27290,27310,27330,27350,27370,27390,27410,27430,27450,27470,27490,27510,27530,27550,27570,27590,27610,27630,27650,27670,27690,27710,27730,27750,27770,27790,27810,27830,27850,27870,27890,27910,27930,27950,27970,27990,28010,28030,28050,28070,28090,28110,28130,28150,28170,28190,28210,28230,28250,28270,28290,28310,28330,28350,28370,28390,28410,28430,28450,28470,28490,28510,28530,28550,28570,28590,28610,28630,28650,28670,28690,28710,28730,28750,28770,28790,28810,28830,28850,28870,28890,28910,28930,28950,28970,28990,29010,29030,29050,29070,29090,29110,29130,29150,29170,29190,29210,29230,29250,29270,29290,29310,29330,29350,29370,29390,29410,29430,29450,29470,29490,29510,29530,29550,29570,29590,29610,29630,29650,29670,29690,29710,29730,29750,29770,29790,29810,29830,29850,29870,29890,29910,29930,29950,29970,29990],"media":[0,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,20000,20020,20040,20060,20080,20100,20120,20140,20160,20180,20200,20220,20240,20260,20280,20300,20320,20340,20360,20380,20400,20420,20440,20460,20480,20500,20520,20540,20560,20580,20600,20620,20640,20660,20680,20700,20720,20740,20760,20780,20800,20820,20840,20860,20880,20900,20920,20940,20960,20980,21000,21020,21040,21060,21080,21100,21120,21140,21160,21180,21200,21220,21240,21260,21280,21300,21320,21340,21360,21380,21400,21420,21440,21460,21480,21500,21520,21540,21560,21580,21600,21620,21640,21660,21680,21700,21720,21740,21760,21780,21800,21820,21840,21860,21880,21900,21920,21940,21960,21980,22000,22020,22040,22060,22080,22100,22120,22140,22160,22180,22200,22220,22240,22260,22280,22300,22320,22340,22360,22380,22400,22420,22440,22460,22480,22500,22520,22540,22560,22580,22600,22620,22640,22660,22680,22700,22720,22740,22760,22780,22800,22820,22840,22860,22880,22900,22920,22940,22960,22980,23000,23020,23040,23060,23080,23100,23120,23140,23160,23180,23200,23220,23240,23260,23280,23300,23320,23340,23360,23380,23400,23420,23440,23460,23480,23500,23520,23540,23560,23580,23600,23620,23640,23660,23680,23700,23720,23740,23760,23780,23800,23820,23840,23860,23880,23900,23920,23940,23960,23980,24000,24020,24040,24060,24080,24100,24120,24140,24160,24180,24200,24220,24240,24260,24280,24300,24320,24340,24360,24380,24400,24420,24440,24460,24480,24500,24520,24540,24560,24580,24600,24620,24640,24660,24680,24700,24720,24740,24760,24780,24800,24820,24840,24860,24880,24900,24920,24940,24960,24980,25000,25020,25040,25060,25080,25100,25120,25140,25160,25180,25200,25220,25240,25260,25280,25300,25320,25340,25360,25380,25400,25420,25440,25460,25480,25500,25520,25540,25560,25580,25600,25620,25640,25660,25680,25700,25720,25740,25760,25780,25800,25820,25840,25860,25880,25900,25920,25940,25960,25980,26000,26020,26040,26060,26080,26100,26120,26140,26160,26180,26200,26220,26240,26260,26280,26300,26320,26340,26360,26380,26400,26420,26440,26460,26480,26500,26520,26540,26560,26580,26600,26620,26640,26660,26680,26700,26720,26740,26760,26780,26800,26820,26840,26860,26880,26900,26920,26940,26960,26980,27000,27020,27040,27060,27080,27100,27120,27140,27160,27180,27200,27220,27240,27260,27280,27300,27320,27340,27360,27380,27400,27420,27440,27460,27480,27500,27520,27540,27560,27580,27600,27620,27640,27660,27680,27700,27720,27740,27760,27780,27800,27820,27840,27860,27880,27900,27920,27940,27960,27980,28000,28020,28040,28060,28080,28100,28120,28140,28160,28180,28200,28220,28240,28260,28280,28300,28320,28340,28360,28380,28400,28420,28440,28460,28480,28500,28520,28540,28560,28580,28600,28620,28640,28660,28680,28700,28720,28740,28760,28780,28800,28820,28840,28860,28880,28900,28920,28940,28960,28980,29000,29020,29040,29060,29080,29100,29120,29140,29160,29180,29200,29220,29240,29260,29280,29300,29320,29340,29360,29380,29400,29420,29440,29460,29480,29500,29520,29540,29560,29580,29600,29620,29640,29660,29680,29700,29720,29740,29760,29780,29800,29820,29840,29860,29880,29900,29920,29940,29960,29980,30000,30020,30040,30060,30080,30100,30120,30140,30160,30180,30200,30220,30240,30260,30280,30300,30320,30340,30360,30380,30400,30420,30440,30460,30480,30500,30520,30540,30560,30580,30600,30620,30640,30660,30680,30700,30720,30740,30760,30780,30800,30820,30840,30860,30880,30900,30920,30940,30960,30980,31000,31020,31040,31060,31080,31100,31120,31140,31160,31180,31200,31220,31240,31260,31280,31300,31320,31340,31360,31380,31400,31420,31440,31460,31480,31500,31520,31540,31560,31580,31600,31620,31640,31660,31680,31700,31720,31740,31760,31780,31800,31820,31840,31860,31880,31900,31920,31940,31960,31980,32000,32020,32040,32060,32080,32100,32120,32140,32160,32180,32200,32220,32240,32260,32280,32300,32320,32340,32360,32380,32400,32420,32440,32460,32480,32500,32520,32540,32560,32580,32600,32620,32640,32660,32680,32700,32720,32740,32760,32780,32800,32820,32840,32860,32880,32900,32920,32940,32960,32980,33000,33020,33040,33060,33080,33100,33120,33140,33160,33180,33200,33220,33240,33260,33280,33300,33320,33340,33360,33380,33400,33420,33440,33460,33480,33500,33520,33540,33560,33580,33600,33620,33640,33660,33680,33700,33720,33740,33760,33780,33800,33820,33840,33860,33880,33900,33920,33940,33960,33980,34000,34020,34040,34060,34080,34100,34120,34140,34160,34180,34200,34220,34240,34260,34280,34300,34320,34340,34360,34380,34400,34420,34440,34460,34480,34500,34520,34540,34560,34580,34600,34620,34640,34660,34680,34700,34720,34740,34760,34780,34800,34820,34840,34860,34880,34900,34920,34940,34960,34980,35000,35020,35040,35060,35080,35100,35120,35140,35160,35180,35200,35220,35240,35260,35280,35300,35320,35340,35360,35380,35400,35420,35440,35460,35480,35500,35520,35540,35560,35580,35600,35620,35640,35660,35680,35700,35720,35740,35760,35780,35800,35820,35840,35860,35880,35900,35920,35940,35960,35980,36000,36020,36040,36060,36080,36100,36120,36140,36160,36180,36200,36220,36240,36260,36280,36300,36320,36340,36360,36380,36400,36420,36440,36460,36480,36500,36520,36540,36560,36580,36600,36620,36640,36660,36680,36700,36720,36740,36760,36780,36800,36820,36840,36860,36880,36900,36920,36940,36960,36980,37000,37020,37040,37060,37080,37100,37120,37140,37160,37180,37200,37220,37240,37260,37280,37300,37320,37340,37360,37380,37400,37420,37440,37460,37480,37500,37520,37540,37560,37580,37600,37620,37640,37660,37680,37700,37720,37740,37760,37780,37800,37820,37840,37860,37880,37900,37920,37940,37960,37980,38000,38020,38040,38060,38080,38100,38120,38140,38160,38180,38200,38220,38240,38260,38280,38300,38320,38340,38360,38380,38400,38420,38440,38460,38480,38500,38520,38540,38560,38580,38600,38620,38640,38660,38680,38700,38720,38740,38760,38780,38800,38820,38840,38860,38880,38900,38920,38940,38960,38980,39000,39020,39040,39060,39080,39100,39120,39140,39160,39180,39200,39220,39240,39260,39280,39300,39320,39340,39360,39380,39400,39420,39440,39460,39480,39500,39520,39540,39560,39580,39600,39620,39640,39660,39680,39700,39720,39740,39760,39780,39800,39820,39840,39860,39880,39900,39920,39940,39960,39980,40000,40020,40040,40060,40080,40100,40120,40140,40160,40180,40200,40220,40240,40260,40280,40300,40320,40340,40360,40380,40400,40420,40440,40460,40480,40500,40520,40540,40560,40580,40600,40620,40640,40660,40680,40700,40720,40740,40760,40780,40800,40820,40840,40860,40880,40900,40920,40940,40960,40980,41000,41020,41040,41060,41080,41100,41120,41140,41160,41180,41200,41220,41240,41260,41280,41300,41320,41340,41360,41380,41400,41420,41440,41460,41480,41500,41520,41540,41560,41580,41600,41620,41640,41660,41680,41700,41720,41740,41760,41780,41800,41820,41840,41860,41880,41900,41920,41940,41960,41980,42000,42020,42040,42060,42080,42100,42120,42140,42160,42180,42200,42220,42240,42260,42280,42300,42320,42340,42360,42380,42400,42420,42440,42460,42480,42500,42520,42540,42560,42580,42600,42620,42640,42660,42680,42700,42720,42740,42760,42780,42800,42820,42840,42860,42880,42900,42920,42940,42960,42980,43000,43020,43040,43060,43080,43100,43120,43140,43160,43180,43200,43220,43240,43260,43280,43300,43320,43340,43360,43380,43400,43420,43440,43460,43480,43500,43520,43540,43560,43580,43600,43620,43640,43660,43680,43700,43720,43740,43760,43780,43800,43820,43840,43860,43880,43900,43920,43940,43960,43980,44000,44020,44040,44060,44080,44100,44120,44140,44160,44180,44200,44220,44240,44260,44280,44300,44320,44340,44360,44380,44400,44420,44440,44460,44480],"target":[[0,120],[76,100],[176,80],[226,60],[251,40]]} +{"name":"tunein","about":"One frame from a stale group, then the live edge 14.5 s later, then 30 s of even audio. The #3517 branch reported 14.56 s here; the target must stay near the frame duration.","frame":20,"arrival":[0,10,30,50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030,20050,20070,20090,20110,20130,20150,20170,20190,20210,20230,20250,20270,20290,20310,20330,20350,20370,20390,20410,20430,20450,20470,20490,20510,20530,20550,20570,20590,20610,20630,20650,20670,20690,20710,20730,20750,20770,20790,20810,20830,20850,20870,20890,20910,20930,20950,20970,20990,21010,21030,21050,21070,21090,21110,21130,21150,21170,21190,21210,21230,21250,21270,21290,21310,21330,21350,21370,21390,21410,21430,21450,21470,21490,21510,21530,21550,21570,21590,21610,21630,21650,21670,21690,21710,21730,21750,21770,21790,21810,21830,21850,21870,21890,21910,21930,21950,21970,21990,22010,22030,22050,22070,22090,22110,22130,22150,22170,22190,22210,22230,22250,22270,22290,22310,22330,22350,22370,22390,22410,22430,22450,22470,22490,22510,22530,22550,22570,22590,22610,22630,22650,22670,22690,22710,22730,22750,22770,22790,22810,22830,22850,22870,22890,22910,22930,22950,22970,22990,23010,23030,23050,23070,23090,23110,23130,23150,23170,23190,23210,23230,23250,23270,23290,23310,23330,23350,23370,23390,23410,23430,23450,23470,23490,23510,23530,23550,23570,23590,23610,23630,23650,23670,23690,23710,23730,23750,23770,23790,23810,23830,23850,23870,23890,23910,23930,23950,23970,23990,24010,24030,24050,24070,24090,24110,24130,24150,24170,24190,24210,24230,24250,24270,24290,24310,24330,24350,24370,24390,24410,24430,24450,24470,24490,24510,24530,24550,24570,24590,24610,24630,24650,24670,24690,24710,24730,24750,24770,24790,24810,24830,24850,24870,24890,24910,24930,24950,24970,24990,25010,25030,25050,25070,25090,25110,25130,25150,25170,25190,25210,25230,25250,25270,25290,25310,25330,25350,25370,25390,25410,25430,25450,25470,25490,25510,25530,25550,25570,25590,25610,25630,25650,25670,25690,25710,25730,25750,25770,25790,25810,25830,25850,25870,25890,25910,25930,25950,25970,25990,26010,26030,26050,26070,26090,26110,26130,26150,26170,26190,26210,26230,26250,26270,26290,26310,26330,26350,26370,26390,26410,26430,26450,26470,26490,26510,26530,26550,26570,26590,26610,26630,26650,26670,26690,26710,26730,26750,26770,26790,26810,26830,26850,26870,26890,26910,26930,26950,26970,26990,27010,27030,27050,27070,27090,27110,27130,27150,27170,27190,27210,27230,27250,27270,27290,27310,27330,27350,27370,27390,27410,27430,27450,27470,27490,27510,27530,27550,27570,27590,27610,27630,27650,27670,27690,27710,27730,27750,27770,27790,27810,27830,27850,27870,27890,27910,27930,27950,27970,27990,28010,28030,28050,28070,28090,28110,28130,28150,28170,28190,28210,28230,28250,28270,28290,28310,28330,28350,28370,28390,28410,28430,28450,28470,28490,28510,28530,28550,28570,28590,28610,28630,28650,28670,28690,28710,28730,28750,28770,28790,28810,28830,28850,28870,28890,28910,28930,28950,28970,28990,29010,29030,29050,29070,29090,29110,29130,29150,29170,29190,29210,29230,29250,29270,29290,29310,29330,29350,29370,29390,29410,29430,29450,29470,29490,29510,29530,29550,29570,29590,29610,29630,29650,29670,29690,29710,29730,29750,29770,29790,29810,29830,29850,29870,29890,29910,29930,29950,29970,29990],"media":[0,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,20000,20020,20040,20060,20080,20100,20120,20140,20160,20180,20200,20220,20240,20260,20280,20300,20320,20340,20360,20380,20400,20420,20440,20460,20480,20500,20520,20540,20560,20580,20600,20620,20640,20660,20680,20700,20720,20740,20760,20780,20800,20820,20840,20860,20880,20900,20920,20940,20960,20980,21000,21020,21040,21060,21080,21100,21120,21140,21160,21180,21200,21220,21240,21260,21280,21300,21320,21340,21360,21380,21400,21420,21440,21460,21480,21500,21520,21540,21560,21580,21600,21620,21640,21660,21680,21700,21720,21740,21760,21780,21800,21820,21840,21860,21880,21900,21920,21940,21960,21980,22000,22020,22040,22060,22080,22100,22120,22140,22160,22180,22200,22220,22240,22260,22280,22300,22320,22340,22360,22380,22400,22420,22440,22460,22480,22500,22520,22540,22560,22580,22600,22620,22640,22660,22680,22700,22720,22740,22760,22780,22800,22820,22840,22860,22880,22900,22920,22940,22960,22980,23000,23020,23040,23060,23080,23100,23120,23140,23160,23180,23200,23220,23240,23260,23280,23300,23320,23340,23360,23380,23400,23420,23440,23460,23480,23500,23520,23540,23560,23580,23600,23620,23640,23660,23680,23700,23720,23740,23760,23780,23800,23820,23840,23860,23880,23900,23920,23940,23960,23980,24000,24020,24040,24060,24080,24100,24120,24140,24160,24180,24200,24220,24240,24260,24280,24300,24320,24340,24360,24380,24400,24420,24440,24460,24480,24500,24520,24540,24560,24580,24600,24620,24640,24660,24680,24700,24720,24740,24760,24780,24800,24820,24840,24860,24880,24900,24920,24940,24960,24980,25000,25020,25040,25060,25080,25100,25120,25140,25160,25180,25200,25220,25240,25260,25280,25300,25320,25340,25360,25380,25400,25420,25440,25460,25480,25500,25520,25540,25560,25580,25600,25620,25640,25660,25680,25700,25720,25740,25760,25780,25800,25820,25840,25860,25880,25900,25920,25940,25960,25980,26000,26020,26040,26060,26080,26100,26120,26140,26160,26180,26200,26220,26240,26260,26280,26300,26320,26340,26360,26380,26400,26420,26440,26460,26480,26500,26520,26540,26560,26580,26600,26620,26640,26660,26680,26700,26720,26740,26760,26780,26800,26820,26840,26860,26880,26900,26920,26940,26960,26980,27000,27020,27040,27060,27080,27100,27120,27140,27160,27180,27200,27220,27240,27260,27280,27300,27320,27340,27360,27380,27400,27420,27440,27460,27480,27500,27520,27540,27560,27580,27600,27620,27640,27660,27680,27700,27720,27740,27760,27780,27800,27820,27840,27860,27880,27900,27920,27940,27960,27980,28000,28020,28040,28060,28080,28100,28120,28140,28160,28180,28200,28220,28240,28260,28280,28300,28320,28340,28360,28380,28400,28420,28440,28460,28480,28500,28520,28540,28560,28580,28600,28620,28640,28660,28680,28700,28720,28740,28760,28780,28800,28820,28840,28860,28880,28900,28920,28940,28960,28980,29000,29020,29040,29060,29080,29100,29120,29140,29160,29180,29200,29220,29240,29260,29280,29300,29320,29340,29360,29380,29400,29420,29440,29460,29480,29500,29520,29540,29560,29580,29600,29620,29640,29660,29680,29700,29720,29740,29760,29780,29800,29820,29840,29860,29880,29900,29920,29940,29960,29980,30000,30020,30040,30060,30080,30100,30120,30140,30160,30180,30200,30220,30240,30260,30280,30300,30320,30340,30360,30380,30400,30420,30440,30460,30480,30500,30520,30540,30560,30580,30600,30620,30640,30660,30680,30700,30720,30740,30760,30780,30800,30820,30840,30860,30880,30900,30920,30940,30960,30980,31000,31020,31040,31060,31080,31100,31120,31140,31160,31180,31200,31220,31240,31260,31280,31300,31320,31340,31360,31380,31400,31420,31440,31460,31480,31500,31520,31540,31560,31580,31600,31620,31640,31660,31680,31700,31720,31740,31760,31780,31800,31820,31840,31860,31880,31900,31920,31940,31960,31980,32000,32020,32040,32060,32080,32100,32120,32140,32160,32180,32200,32220,32240,32260,32280,32300,32320,32340,32360,32380,32400,32420,32440,32460,32480,32500,32520,32540,32560,32580,32600,32620,32640,32660,32680,32700,32720,32740,32760,32780,32800,32820,32840,32860,32880,32900,32920,32940,32960,32980,33000,33020,33040,33060,33080,33100,33120,33140,33160,33180,33200,33220,33240,33260,33280,33300,33320,33340,33360,33380,33400,33420,33440,33460,33480,33500,33520,33540,33560,33580,33600,33620,33640,33660,33680,33700,33720,33740,33760,33780,33800,33820,33840,33860,33880,33900,33920,33940,33960,33980,34000,34020,34040,34060,34080,34100,34120,34140,34160,34180,34200,34220,34240,34260,34280,34300,34320,34340,34360,34380,34400,34420,34440,34460,34480,34500,34520,34540,34560,34580,34600,34620,34640,34660,34680,34700,34720,34740,34760,34780,34800,34820,34840,34860,34880,34900,34920,34940,34960,34980,35000,35020,35040,35060,35080,35100,35120,35140,35160,35180,35200,35220,35240,35260,35280,35300,35320,35340,35360,35380,35400,35420,35440,35460,35480,35500,35520,35540,35560,35580,35600,35620,35640,35660,35680,35700,35720,35740,35760,35780,35800,35820,35840,35860,35880,35900,35920,35940,35960,35980,36000,36020,36040,36060,36080,36100,36120,36140,36160,36180,36200,36220,36240,36260,36280,36300,36320,36340,36360,36380,36400,36420,36440,36460,36480,36500,36520,36540,36560,36580,36600,36620,36640,36660,36680,36700,36720,36740,36760,36780,36800,36820,36840,36860,36880,36900,36920,36940,36960,36980,37000,37020,37040,37060,37080,37100,37120,37140,37160,37180,37200,37220,37240,37260,37280,37300,37320,37340,37360,37380,37400,37420,37440,37460,37480,37500,37520,37540,37560,37580,37600,37620,37640,37660,37680,37700,37720,37740,37760,37780,37800,37820,37840,37860,37880,37900,37920,37940,37960,37980,38000,38020,38040,38060,38080,38100,38120,38140,38160,38180,38200,38220,38240,38260,38280,38300,38320,38340,38360,38380,38400,38420,38440,38460,38480,38500,38520,38540,38560,38580,38600,38620,38640,38660,38680,38700,38720,38740,38760,38780,38800,38820,38840,38860,38880,38900,38920,38940,38960,38980,39000,39020,39040,39060,39080,39100,39120,39140,39160,39180,39200,39220,39240,39260,39280,39300,39320,39340,39360,39380,39400,39420,39440,39460,39480,39500,39520,39540,39560,39580,39600,39620,39640,39660,39680,39700,39720,39740,39760,39780,39800,39820,39840,39860,39880,39900,39920,39940,39960,39980,40000,40020,40040,40060,40080,40100,40120,40140,40160,40180,40200,40220,40240,40260,40280,40300,40320,40340,40360,40380,40400,40420,40440,40460,40480,40500,40520,40540,40560,40580,40600,40620,40640,40660,40680,40700,40720,40740,40760,40780,40800,40820,40840,40860,40880,40900,40920,40940,40960,40980,41000,41020,41040,41060,41080,41100,41120,41140,41160,41180,41200,41220,41240,41260,41280,41300,41320,41340,41360,41380,41400,41420,41440,41460,41480,41500,41520,41540,41560,41580,41600,41620,41640,41660,41680,41700,41720,41740,41760,41780,41800,41820,41840,41860,41880,41900,41920,41940,41960,41980,42000,42020,42040,42060,42080,42100,42120,42140,42160,42180,42200,42220,42240,42260,42280,42300,42320,42340,42360,42380,42400,42420,42440,42460,42480,42500,42520,42540,42560,42580,42600,42620,42640,42660,42680,42700,42720,42740,42760,42780,42800,42820,42840,42860,42880,42900,42920,42940,42960,42980,43000,43020,43040,43060,43080,43100,43120,43140,43160,43180,43200,43220,43240,43260,43280,43300,43320,43340,43360,43380,43400,43420,43440,43460,43480,43500,43520,43540,43560,43580,43600,43620,43640,43660,43680,43700,43720,43740,43760,43780,43800,43820,43840,43860,43880,43900,43920,43940,43960,43980,44000,44020,44040,44060,44080,44100,44120,44140,44160,44180,44200,44220,44240,44260,44280,44300,44320,44340,44360,44380,44400,44420,44440,44460,44480],"target":[[0,120],[76,100],[176,80],[226,60],[251,40]],"lateness":[[0,0]]} diff --git a/js/hang/api/container.api.md b/js/hang/api/container.api.md index 8db9aa8394b..7e486cd4d3c 100644 --- a/js/hang/api/container.api.md +++ b/js/hang/api/container.api.md @@ -20,6 +20,7 @@ export class Consumer { constructor(track: Net.Track.Subscriber, props: ConsumerProps); readonly buffered: Signals.Getter; close(): void; + readonly lateness: Signals.Getter; next(): Promise; readonly spread: Signals.Getter; } diff --git a/js/hang/src/container/consumer.ts b/js/hang/src/container/consumer.ts index 9ee90a2fef3..9e2d2a16575 100644 --- a/js/hang/src/container/consumer.ts +++ b/js/hang/src/container/consumer.ts @@ -221,6 +221,15 @@ export class Consumer { * floor. Starts at the predecessor's estimate, or the cold-start estimate without one. */ readonly spread: Getter; + #lateness = new Signal(Milli.zero); + /** + * How late the slowest frame of the last two seconds of media arrived against the fastest. + * + * NetEq's maximum delay, which widens the time stretch's band in doc/concept/audio-jitter.md + * rather than the target. Starts at zero, even after a predecessor: it measures this track's own + * arrivals. + */ + readonly lateness: Getter = this.#lateness; // The newest group opened by a declared end, until a later group's first frame tells the jitter // estimator the silence is over. Not at the marker itself: the stopped encoder's final packets may // follow it in its own group, and they belong to the speech before the silence. @@ -433,6 +442,7 @@ export class Consumer { } this.#jitter.observe(arrival, Milli.fromMicro(sample.timestamp)); this.#spread.set(this.#jitter.measured); + this.#lateness.set(this.#jitter.lateness); } else if (!group.media) { // Only a marker ahead of any media declares an end; one after it is a frame's endpoint. this.#declare(group); diff --git a/js/hang/src/container/jitter.test.ts b/js/hang/src/container/jitter.test.ts index c346af8d378..c1321d77891 100644 --- a/js/hang/src/container/jitter.test.ts +++ b/js/hang/src/container/jitter.test.ts @@ -18,6 +18,7 @@ interface Case { media: number[]; ends?: number[]; target: [number, number][]; + lateness: [number, number][]; } const cases: Case[] = readdirSync(CORPUS) @@ -53,8 +54,10 @@ describe("audio jitter conformance", () => { it(c.name, () => { const jitter = new Jitter(); const expected = new Map(c.target); + const late = new Map(c.lateness); const ends = new Set(c.ends); let current: number | undefined; + let lateness = 0; for (let i = 0; i < c.arrival.length; i++) { if (ends.has(i)) jitter.end(); jitter.observe(c.arrival[i] as Milli, c.media[i] as Milli); @@ -67,6 +70,10 @@ describe("audio jitter conformance", () => { expect(value).toBeCloseTo(current, 6); } current = value; + + // A fixed target ignores the arrivals, which the player applies on top of the estimator. + lateness = late.get(i) ?? lateness; + expect(c.delay !== undefined ? 0 : jitter.lateness).toBeCloseTo(lateness, 6); } }); } @@ -142,6 +149,19 @@ function scan(history: History, media: number): Entry | undefined { return reference; } +// The documented lateness: the slowest entry against the fastest, each the first on a tie. +function slowest(history: History): number { + if (history.length === 0) return 0; + let fast = history.at(0); + let slow = fast; + for (let i = 1; i < history.length; i++) { + const entry = history.at(i); + if (entry.arrival - entry.media < fast.arrival - fast.media) fast = entry; + if (entry.arrival - entry.media > slow.arrival - slow.media) slow = entry; + } + return Math.max(0, slow.arrival - fast.arrival - (slow.media - fast.media)); +} + describe("History", () => { // A tied entry with a different (arrival, media) rounds the delay differently, so the tree must // pick exactly the entry the scan would. @@ -162,6 +182,7 @@ describe("History", () => { for (const query of [media - 30, media - 10, media, media + 10, media + 1e6]) { expect(history.reference(query)).toEqual(scan(history, query)); } + expect(history.lateness()).toBe(slowest(history)); } }); @@ -174,8 +195,10 @@ describe("History", () => { for (const query of [media - 3, media - 0.5, media]) { expect(history.reference(query)).toEqual(scan(history, query)); } + expect(history.lateness()).toBe(slowest(history)); } } expect(history.length).toBe(8192); + expect(history.lateness()).toBe(slowest(history)); }); }); diff --git a/js/hang/src/container/jitter.ts b/js/hang/src/container/jitter.ts index 257beda9c2d..a3e5315d0a7 100644 --- a/js/hang/src/container/jitter.ts +++ b/js/hang/src/container/jitter.ts @@ -140,6 +140,14 @@ export class Jitter { return fork; } + /** + * How late the slowest frame in the reference window arrived against its fastest: NetEq's + * maximum delay, which widens the time stretch's band rather than the target. + */ + get lateness(): Milli { + return this.#history.lateness() as Milli; + } + /** The measured term: the upper edge of the bucket holding the 95th percentile. */ get measured(): Milli { let cumulative = 0; @@ -177,13 +185,14 @@ export interface Entry { /** * The arrivals inside the reference window, in media order, answering any prefix's fastest arrival - * in logarithmic time. + * in logarithmic time and the whole window's slowest in constant time. * * A reordered frame is measured against the prefix at or before its timestamp, so a peer that sends * only reordered frames would otherwise force a scan per frame. Entries live in a ring indexed from * `#head`, and a segment tree over the ring's slots holds each node's fastest slot, the older on a * tie, as the scan would pick. A query never spans the ring's wrap point within one node, so a node - * fully inside it is in arrival order. + * fully inside it is in arrival order. The slowest is the front of a monotonic queue of entries, + * each slower than every later one, named by how many entries were pushed before it. * * @internal Exported for the equivalence test. */ @@ -198,6 +207,11 @@ export class History { #len = 0; /** Leaf `capacity + slot` holds `slot`; each parent holds the faster of its children. */ #tree = new Uint32Array(0); + /** Entries ever pushed, so `#pushed - #len` names the oldest one held. */ + #pushed = 0; + /** From `#slowHead`, the entries no later entry is as slow as, oldest first. */ + #slow: number[] = []; + #slowHead = 0; /** The entries held. */ get length(): number { @@ -227,6 +241,34 @@ export class History { for (let node = (capacity + slot) >> 1; node > 0; node >>= 1) { this.#tree[node] = this.#faster(this.#tree[2 * node], this.#tree[2 * node + 1]); } + + // Drop the queue's evicted front, then every entry this one is slower than, keeping the older + // on a tie the way the reference does. + const oldest = this.#pushed - this.#len + 1; + while (this.#slowHead < this.#slow.length && this.#slow[this.#slowHead] < oldest) this.#slowHead++; + const key = arrival - media; + while (this.#slow.length > this.#slowHead) { + const back = this.at(this.#slow[this.#slow.length - 1] - oldest); + if (back.arrival - back.media >= key) break; + this.#slow.pop(); + } + if (this.#slowHead > 1024 && this.#slowHead * 2 > this.#slow.length) { + this.#slow = this.#slow.slice(this.#slowHead); + this.#slowHead = 0; + } + this.#slow.push(this.#pushed); + this.#pushed++; + } + + /** + * How late the slowest entry arrived against the fastest, zero for an empty window: NetEq's + * `GetMaxDelayMs`, in the same arithmetic as a frame's delay. + */ + lateness(): number { + const fast = this.reference(Number.POSITIVE_INFINITY); + if (fast === undefined) return 0; + const slow = this.at(this.#slow[this.#slowHead] - (this.#pushed - this.#len)); + return Math.max(0, slow.arrival - fast.arrival - (slow.media - fast.media)); } /** The fastest entry with `entry.media <= media`, the oldest on a tie. */ diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/buffer.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/buffer.ts index 77fc8602768..75152819128 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/buffer.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/buffer.ts @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ import { Micro, Milli, type Second } from "@moq/clock"; import { Effect, type Getter, Signal } from "@moq/signals"; import { ringHold, ringSamples } from "./latency"; -import type { Data, End, Init, Latency, Playing, Reset, State, Truncate } from "./render"; +import type { Data, End, Init, Latency, Lateness, Playing, Reset, State, Truncate } from "./render"; /** * Decides when the decode loop may decode a frame, which is how the target delay is split between @@ -383,6 +383,15 @@ export class AudioBuffer { this.#worklet.port.postMessage(msg); } + /** + * Widen the band the worklet's stretch holds above the floor by how late the slowest recent + * arrival was against the fastest, as NetEq does. See doc/concept/audio-jitter.md. + */ + setLateness(lateness: Milli): void { + const msg: Lateness = { type: "lateness", lateness }; + this.#worklet.port.postMessage(msg); + } + /** * Note the newest media timestamp queued ahead of the decoder, or undefined once none is. The * queue is what covers the part of the target held encoded, so it is what resumes a parked ring. diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/decoder.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/decoder.ts index 1ae1f0552b7..e731d4bee77 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/decoder.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/decoder.ts @@ -165,6 +165,9 @@ export class Decoder { // The container consumer's arrival estimate, unset while nothing is subscribed. #measured = new Signal(undefined); + // How late the consumer's slowest recent arrival was against its fastest, which widens the band + // the ring's stretch holds above its floor. + #lateness = new Signal(Milli.zero); // The newest container consumer, the path it reads, and its codec, whose estimate a replacement // continues. @@ -252,6 +255,7 @@ export class Decoder { this.#signals.run(this.#runWorklet.bind(this)); this.#signals.run(this.#runEnabled.bind(this)); this.#signals.run(this.#runLatency.bind(this)); + this.#signals.run(this.#runLateness.bind(this)); this.#signals.run(this.#runDecoder.bind(this)); this.#signals.run(this.#runStalls.bind(this)); } @@ -464,6 +468,16 @@ export class Decoder { ring.setLatency(effect.get(this.sync.out.delay)); } + #runLateness(effect: Effect): void { + const ring = effect.get(this.#ring); + if (!ring) return; + + // NetEq's band above the target, from the arrivals the target was measured from. An explicit + // delay ignores the arrivals entirely, so it keeps the bare 20 ms band. + const auto = effect.get(this.sync.in.delay) === "auto"; + ring.setLateness(auto ? effect.get(this.#lateness) : Milli.zero); + } + #runDecoder(effect: Effect): void { // The reorder policy belongs to the playback mode, so a mode change starts a new reader. effect.get(this.sync.out.buffered); @@ -848,8 +862,10 @@ export class Decoder { }); // Feed the arrival estimate into the playout target. It outlives this consumer, so the target - // holds until the replacement takes over; see #retire. + // holds until the replacement takes over; see #retire. The stretch's band follows this + // consumer's own arrivals. effect.run((inner) => this.#measured.set(inner.get(consumer.spread))); + effect.run((inner) => this.#lateness.set(inner.get(consumer.lateness))); return { consumer, read }; } @@ -857,6 +873,7 @@ export class Decoder { #retire(): void { this.#consumer = undefined; this.#measured.set(undefined); + this.#lateness.set(Milli.zero); // Its arrivals stop holding the clock's reference. this.#track.reset(); } diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/playout.test.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/playout.test.ts index e69a78f7c9c..b999fb07f11 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/playout.test.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/playout.test.ts @@ -202,16 +202,17 @@ describe("ring replay", () => { expect(replay(build(await settled(t)), t, 2000)).toMatchObject({ underruns: 0, skips: 0 }); }); - it("covers a target that ignores the arrival spread by stretching", () => { + it("still underruns when the target ignores the arrival spread, but drops nothing", () => { // 46ms is what the round-trip formula produced on the connection this was measured on: it // describes the network and says nothing about a sender that flushes five frames at once. - // Every flush's trough falls below it, which ran the ring dry on each flush until time stretch - // expanded through the troughs. A flush still swings the ring by its whole 100 ms, so this - // stretches as much as the measured target does, accelerating off each peak and expanding - // through each trough. + // Every flush's trough falls below it. Preemptive expand lengthens the ring by one pitch period + // a window at most, as NetEq's does, which cannot cover a 100 ms trough, so the ring runs dry + // on most flushes; accelerate brings each peak back down rather than skipping it. const t = trace(600, 5, 5); const result = replay(build(46), t, 2000); - expect(result).toMatchObject({ underruns: 0, skips: 0 }); + const flushes = (t.length - 2000 / CHUNK_MS) / 5; + expect(result.underruns).toBeGreaterThan(flushes / 2); + expect(result.skips).toBe(0); expect(result.stretched).toBeGreaterThan(0); }); }); diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/render-worklet.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/render-worklet.ts index e7c23e255b4..b720a064d25 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/render-worklet.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/render-worklet.ts @@ -36,6 +36,8 @@ class Render extends AudioWorkletProcessor { this.#ring?.park(); this.#epoch = msg.park; } + } else if (msg.type === "lateness") { + this.#ring?.setLateness(msg.lateness); } else if (msg.type === "end") { this.#ring?.end(msg.timestamp); } else if (msg.type === "truncate") { diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/render.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/render.ts index b3ac4dde878..25ee1dac4fa 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/render.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/render.ts @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ import type { Micro, Milli } from "@moq/clock"; /** Everything the main thread sends the render worklet over its port. */ -export type Message = Init | Data | Latency | Reset | Truncate | Playing | End; +export type Message = Init | Data | Latency | Lateness | Reset | Truncate | Playing | End; /** Create the worklet's ring. */ export interface Init { @@ -53,6 +53,12 @@ export interface Latency { park?: number; } +/** How late the slowest recent arrival was against the fastest, which widens the stretch's band. */ +export interface Lateness { + type: "lateness"; + lateness: Milli; +} + /** State update from the worklet back to the main thread. */ export interface State { type: "state"; diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/replay.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/replay.ts index b0d5ca9d5d7..7fc326ccb34 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/replay.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/replay.ts @@ -161,6 +161,12 @@ export async function* replay(trace: Arrival[], options: Options): AsyncGenerato const ring = new AudioRingBuffer({ rate, channels: 1, latency: millis(rate, gate.floor) }); const observe = () => gate.observe(ring.anchored ? ring.timestamp : undefined, ring.stalled); + // The decoder widens the stretch's band by the consumer's lateness, unless the delay is explicit. + signals.run((effect) => { + const auto = effect.get(sync.in.delay) === "auto"; + ring.setLateness(auto ? effect.get(consumer.lateness) : Milli.zero); + }); + // Arrived but not yet decoded media, read or still in the consumer, is what covers the part of the // target held encoded, and what resumes a parked ring. const read = new Signal(undefined); diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts index 1111a469080..b27face83af 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts @@ -891,6 +891,19 @@ describe("time stretch", () => { expect(buffer.underruns).toBe(0); }); + it("holds a ring inside the band its arrivals' lateness widens, accelerating only past it", async () => { + const buffer = live(100); + buffer.setLateness(100 as Milli); + write(buffer, 0 as Milli, frames(300), { value: 0.5 }); + await converge(buffer, frames(300), 8); + + // Above the 100 ms floor but inside 100 ms of lateness plus the 20 ms band, give or take the + // 20 ms frame just written, where without the lateness it accelerates down to the floor. + expect(buffer.length).toBeGreaterThanOrEqual(frames(200) - frames(20)); + expect(buffer.length).toBeLessThan(frames(220) + frames(20)); + expect(buffer.underruns).toBe(0); + }); + it("fast-accelerates a ring four times past the band, even straight after a stretch", async () => { const buffer = live(100); write(buffer, 0 as Milli, frames(600), { value: 0.5 }); @@ -899,16 +912,19 @@ describe("time stretch", () => { expect(buffer.length).toBeLessThan(frames(480)); }); - // Past NetEq's fast threshold, four times the floor plus its 20 ms band, or three quarters of the + // Past NetEq's fast threshold, four times the floor plus its band, or three quarters of the // headroom above the floor, whichever is lower, stretching back would take seconds, so the ring // re-anchors on its floor as moq-audio does. With 1000 ms of capacity, a 100 ms floor reaches the - // first at 480 ms and a 300 ms floor the second at 825 ms. - for (const [floor, threshold] of [ - [100, 480], - [300, 825], + // first at 480 ms, or 560 ms with 20 ms of lateness widening its band, and a 300 ms floor the + // second at 825 ms. + for (const [floor, lateness, threshold] of [ + [100, 0, 480], + [100, 20, 560], + [300, 0, 825], ]) { - it(`re-anchors a ${floor} ms floor only once the ring holds ${threshold} ms`, () => { + it(`re-anchors a ${floor} ms floor ${lateness} ms late only once the ring holds ${threshold} ms`, () => { const buffer = live(floor); + buffer.setLateness(lateness as Milli); write(buffer, 0 as Milli, frames(floor), { value: 0.5 }); read(buffer, QUANTUM, 1); const playhead = buffer.timestamp; diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts index 6b520f1ea7c..bec91977f8b 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts @@ -52,6 +52,9 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { readonly #buffered: boolean; // Un-stall threshold in samples (how much to buffer before playback starts). #latencySamples: number; + // How late the slowest recent arrival was against the fastest, in samples, which widens the band + // the stretch holds above the floor. + #latenessSamples = 0; // Whether the read/write indices have been anchored to the first inserted sample. #anchored = false; @@ -153,6 +156,11 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { if (this.length >= latencySamples) this.#stalled = false; } + /** Widen the band above the floor by how late the slowest recent arrival was, as NetEq does. */ + setLateness(lateness: Milli): void { + this.#latenessSamples = Math.max(0, Math.floor(this.rate * Second.fromMilli(lateness))); + } + /** * Hold playback until the next floor update, keeping what is buffered. * @@ -207,8 +215,8 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { // Bound the ring. While playing live, the read path stretches the ring back onto its floor, so // dropping the oldest audio and landing on the floor is an emergency re-anchor, as moq-audio - // does: at NetEq's fast threshold, four times the floor plus its 20 ms band, or once the ring - // holds three quarters of its headroom above the floor, whichever comes first. While stalled the + // does: at NetEq's fast threshold, four times the floor plus its band, or once the ring holds + // three quarters of its headroom above the floor, whichever comes first. While stalled the // reader is not consuming, so only the hard capacity applies; dropping would throw away the very // audio the refill is accumulating. Buffered mode plays through everything, so it is // capacity-bound too. @@ -229,7 +237,7 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { band && queued >= Math.min( - 4 * (latency + Math.floor((this.rate * 20) / 1000)), + 4 * (latency + this.#latenessSamples + Math.floor((this.rate * 20) / 1000)), latency + Math.floor(((this.capacity - latency) * 3) / 4), ) ) { @@ -429,7 +437,7 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { const dst = this.#stretch.input[channel]; for (let i = 0; i < frames; i++) dst[i] = src[(this.#readIndex + i) % src.length]; } - this.#stretch.process(frames, buffered, this.#latencySamples, enabled); + this.#stretch.process(frames, buffered, this.#latencySamples, this.#latenessSamples, enabled); this.#readIndex += frames; this.#window = frames; this.#windowQuiet = quiet; diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.test.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.test.ts index f4a50d4d94d..84c60b0e323 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.test.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.test.ts @@ -11,6 +11,8 @@ interface Vector { input: number[]; buffered: number; target: number; + /** The arrivals' lateness in frames, zero when the vector leaves it out. */ + lateness?: number; cooldown: number; decision: Decision; lag: number; @@ -35,9 +37,10 @@ for (const vector of vectors) { stretch.input[channel].set(samples); }); stretch.cooldown = vector.cooldown; - expect(stretch.decide(vector.buffered, vector.target)).toBe(vector.decision); + const lateness = vector.lateness ?? 0; + expect(stretch.decide(vector.buffered, vector.target, lateness)).toBe(vector.decision); - stretch.process(stretch.window, vector.buffered, vector.target, true); + stretch.process(stretch.window, vector.buffered, vector.target, lateness, true); expect(Math.abs(stretch.available - stretch.window)).toBe(vector.lag); const output = Array.from({ length: vector.channels }, () => new Float32Array(stretch.available)); @@ -59,16 +62,16 @@ it("passes a short, disabled, or exhausted window through unchanged", () => { stretch.cooldown = 0; // A ring well short of its target expands a full window of received PCM. - stretch.process(stretch.window, stretch.window, rate, true); + stretch.process(stretch.window, stretch.window, rate, 0, true); expect(stretch.available).toBeGreaterThan(stretch.window); const output = [new Float32Array(rate), new Float32Array(rate)]; expect(stretch.read(output, 0)).toBe(stretch.length); expect(stretch.read(output, 0)).toBe(0); stretch.cooldown = 0; - stretch.process(stretch.window, stretch.window, rate, false); + stretch.process(stretch.window, stretch.window, rate, 0, false); expect(stretch.available).toBe(stretch.window); - stretch.process(stretch.window >> 1, stretch.window, rate, true); + stretch.process(stretch.window >> 1, stretch.window, rate, 0, true); expect(stretch.available).toBe(stretch.window >> 1); } }); diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts index dde0ad4e4c8..60a91ee6ba0 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts @@ -38,7 +38,7 @@ export class Stretch { readonly #rate: number; // 15 ms: the seam's position, and the longest pitch period. readonly #middle: number; - // 20 ms: the band above the target that holds before accelerating. + // 20 ms: NetEq's adjustment granularity, which the band above the target adds to the lateness. readonly #band: number; // 50 ms: NetEq's five 10 ms ticks between stretches. readonly #rest: number; @@ -92,12 +92,13 @@ export class Stretch { /** * Stage the first `frames` of {@link input}, stretched toward `target` given `buffered` frames - * queued including them. Only a full window of received PCM can stretch, so a short block, or one - * that is not `enabled`, passes unchanged and a finite input never becomes concealment. + * queued including them and the arrivals' `lateness`. Only a full window of received PCM can + * stretch, so a short block, or one that is not `enabled`, passes unchanged and a finite input + * never becomes concealment. */ - process(frames: number, buffered: number, target: number, enabled: boolean): void { - const decision = enabled && frames === this.window ? this.decide(buffered, target) : "Hold"; - const lag = decision === "Hold" ? 0 : this.#pitch(decision !== "Accelerate"); + process(frames: number, buffered: number, target: number, lateness: number, enabled: boolean): void { + const decision = enabled && frames === this.window ? this.decide(buffered, target, lateness) : "Hold"; + const lag = decision === "Hold" ? 0 : this.#pitch(decision === "Fast"); this.#position = 0; this.#length = frames; if (lag === 0) { @@ -107,7 +108,7 @@ export class Stretch { return; } - // Expand repeats whole periods after the seam; accelerate removes one, or fast as many as fit. + // Expand repeats one period after the seam; accelerate removes one, or fast as many as fit. const middle = this.#middle; const expand = decision === "Expand"; const seam = expand ? middle : middle - lag; @@ -131,25 +132,20 @@ export class Stretch { } /** - * What a full window with `buffered` frames queued decides against `target`, both in frames. - * - * Expand departs from NetEq's preemptive expand, which repeats one period per cooldown. A ring - * below its target is short of the cushion its arrivals need, and running dry re-stalls it for a - * whole target of silence, so it expands the way fast accelerate shrinks: every window, as many - * whole periods as fit, at the lower admission threshold. + * What a full window with `buffered` frames queued decides against `target`, all in frames. The + * band above the target is NetEq's: its 20 ms granularity plus the arrivals' `lateness`. */ - decide(buffered: number, target: number): Decision { - const high = target + this.#band; + decide(buffered: number, target: number, lateness: number): Decision { + const high = target + lateness + this.#band; if (buffered >= high * 4) return "Fast"; - if (buffered < target) return "Expand"; if (this.cooldown > 0) return "Hold"; if (buffered >= high) return "Accelerate"; + if (buffered < target) return "Expand"; return "Hold"; } // Search the first channel at 4 kHz, then admit the full-rate seam, returning its length or zero. - // Fast mode, for fast accelerate and every expand, admits a weaker match and takes every whole - // period that fits before the middle. + // Fast mode admits a weaker match and takes every whole period that fits before the middle. #pitch(fast: boolean): number { const middle = this.#middle; if (middle === 0) return 0; diff --git a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md index 78dc140fe7e..06f0d143a58 100644 --- a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md +++ b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md @@ -32,11 +32,10 @@ The port retains WebRTC's BSD notice and patent grant, 4 kHz analysis, 8192/16384 fast admission thresholds, passive-speech VAD, 20 ms decision band, 4x fast threshold, and 60 ms startup / 50 ms successful-stretch cooldowns. -[moq-dev/moq#8058](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/8058) departs from -NetEq's preemptive expand in both players, recorded in the shared spec: -below the target, expand ignores the cooldown and takes every whole period -that fits at the lower threshold. It also drains a declared end's tail -unstretched, as finishing does. Analysis samples NetEq's 48 kHz FIR on a virtual clock for other +[moq-dev/moq#8058](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/8058) widens that band +by NetEq's maximum delay in both players, from the decode consumer's new +`lateness`, and drains a declared end's tail unstretched, as finishing does. +Analysis samples NetEq's 48 kHz FIR on a virtual clock for other device rates and uses floating-point peak refinement and fades. Those arithmetic adaptations are documented, not claimed bit-identical to int16 WebRTC. No threshold was tuned. @@ -101,9 +100,8 @@ The player's metrics confirm the stretch was active: media per render second was 1.0020 (fast, direct) and 1.0018 (fast, shaped) against a 1.002 publisher, and 0.9981 and 0.9979 against 0.998; the shaped runs raised the target delay from 120 to 260 ms. Each direct run stalled once at startup, -none in steady state. That predates the expand departure above, so -[Watch](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md)'s listening check repeats these -runs; the calibration and bench waits below remain. +none in steady state. This settles the perceptual check; the calibration and +bench waits below remain. ## Waiting diff --git a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md index 192fbd40286..9765b6173ee 100644 --- a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md +++ b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md @@ -1,47 +1,70 @@ -# [M] js/watch: prove zero steady-state audio underruns on real hardware +# [M] js/watch: prove NetEq's audio time stretch on real hardware ## Goal -On the measured real-microphone rows, the "Real-time" (`"auto"`) preset plays -with zero player underruns after convergence and no skip-aheads in steady -state, with the estimator's `QUANTILE` left at 0.95. Audio holds back or -catches up by playing slightly slower or faster, the way NetEq's preemptive -expand and accelerate do, rather than running dry, discarding buffered audio, -or rendering silence. Convergence is inaudible at ordinary drift and burst -sizes. - -The measured rows are the `relay-mic-rtt40` replay row, whose -`player_underruns_per_min` must reach 0, and a live re-run of the 2026-11-03 -rows below with a real microphone, Chrome's with 40 ms or more of added RTT -and Safari's on the direct path, read from the stats panel's audio Underruns -and Skips. +On the measured real-microphone rows, the "Real-time" (`"auto"`) preset +converges on its target the way WebRTC NetEq does, with the estimator's +`QUANTILE` left at 0.95: audio holds back or catches up by playing slightly +slower or faster, through NetEq's preemptive expand and accelerate and its +decision band, rather than discarding buffered audio. Convergence is inaudible +at ordinary drift and burst sizes, and no row skips buffered audio in steady +state. + +What still runs dry is what NetEq itself would conceal: a receive stall longer +than the target. The measured rows are the `relay-mic-rtt40` replay row, at +the 1.0 `player_underruns_per_min` NetEq measures there (7.9 on `main` without +the stretch), and a live re-run of the 2026-11-03 rows below with a real +microphone, Chrome's with 40 ms or more of added RTT and Safari's on the +direct path, read from the stats panel's audio Underruns and Skips beside +their 2026-11-03 baseline. Boundaries: no packet loss concealment, so a frame that never arrives is still -missing audio; only received audio is stretched. The estimator stays as -`doc/concept/audio-jitter.md` specifies it. +missing audio; only received audio is stretched. The estimator's target stays +as `doc/concept/audio-jitter.md` specifies it. ## Plan [moq-dev/moq#8058](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/8058) ports the shared -NetEq stretch into the browser's ring, passing the shared PCM corpus, and -every replay row, `relay-mic-rtt40` included, measures and is budgeted at 0 -`player_underruns_per_min`. NetEq-exact expand left `relay-mic-rtt40` at 2.1 -a minute, so expand departs from NetEq in both players, as -`doc/concept/audio-jitter.md` records: below the target it expands every -window, as many whole periods as fit, at the lower admission threshold. What -remains is proof outside the replay: +NetEq stretch into the browser's ring, passing the shared PCM corpus, and adds +NetEq's maximum-delay term to the decision band in both players: the estimator +reports its `lateness`, how late the slowest frame of the last two seconds +arrived against the fastest, and the band above the target widens by it, as +NetEq's `DecisionLogic` adds `GetMaxDelayMs`. Without it `relay-mic-rtt40` ran +dry 2.1 times a minute; with it, 1.0. Every replay row is budgeted at what it +measures. The one difference from NetEq left, deciding on the ring's depth +rather than NetEq's playout delay, is recorded in the shared spec, and the PR +lists it as a follow-up. What remains is proof outside the replay: - The 2026-11-03 rows re-run on real hardware, Chrome's at +40 ms and Safari's on the direct path, under Waiting. -- A listening check of that run and of the native player, since the expand - departure changes both and postdates the 2026-11-05 native listening in - [Native stretch](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md). +- A listening check of that run. The native player's 2026-11-05 listening in + [Native stretch](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md) still + holds: the band only changes when it stretches, not how. - The nightly browser ceilings re-measured by `budgets.json`'s rule from seven scheduled nightlies with the stretch. The lag heuristic behind `skip_aheads` and `discarded_ms` reads a sustained accelerate as a skip, so those can rise on rows whose target moves; `player_skips` counts the ring's - real re-anchors beside them. One local run of the twelve chromium rows on - 2026-11-06 fit every current ceiling, with zero player underruns and skips. + real re-anchors beside them. + +Decided 2026-11-06 (maintainer, on +[moq-dev/moq#8058](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/8058)): start with +NetEq. Zero underruns is aggressive, and a +40 ms RTT alone should cost NetEq +nothing, so the port was checked against `decision_logic.cc` and +`preemptive_expand.cc` first. A constant RTT does cost nothing: the delays are +measured against the fastest arrival. What runs `relay-mic-rtt40` dry is +receive stalls of 100 to 125 ms whose frames then land together and out of +order, behind an 80 to 100 ms target, the 0.95 quantile of half-second peaks +that NetEq's estimator reads too; NetEq would conceal those. Stalls over 60 ms +come 13 times a minute there against 3.4 on the direct row. The port had dropped the +maximum-delay term, now restored. Not chosen: the PR's earlier stronger +expand, every window at the lower threshold, which reached zero on every +replay row at the cost of a stronger stretch while the ring is short. + +Decided 2026-11-03 (maintainer, on +[moq-dev/moq#7679](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/7679)): pull time +stretch into m1 as this quest's fix, keeping `QUANTILE` at 0.95. The options +were restating the Goal to the measured rate, or raising the quantile. The m2 +Time stretch quest was folded in here. Decided 2026-11-06 (maintainer, /quest-unblock): drop the Safari row with 40 ms or more of added RTT. Safari can't be redirected through the RTT relay, @@ -78,6 +101,9 @@ on the direct path. Underruns are the stats panel's counter after the first | Safari, direct, 20 ms groups | WebSocket | 5 ms | 5 in 118 s (2.5/min) | 0 | 120 / 140 ms | | Safari, direct, 100 ms groups | WebSocket | 5 ms | 12 in 119 s (6.1/min) | 0 | 120 / 140 ms | +The Chrome +40 ms, 20 ms-group capture is checked in as the `relay-mic-rtt40` +replay row: 7.9 player underruns a minute on `main`, 1.0 with the stretch. + ## Waiting - Maintainer: re-run the 2026-11-03 rows on the MacBook Air and listen to @@ -99,13 +125,10 @@ on the direct path. Underruns are the stats panel's counter after the first and listen for warble or pitch wobble. 4. Repeat with 100 ms groups, then both group sizes in Safari on the direct path, with no shaper. - 5. Repeat the 2026-11-05 native listening runs of - [Native stretch](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md) on the - same checkout: `say` speech over Opus at a 1.002 and a 0.998 publisher - rate, direct and through the shaper's `bursty` profile. - Done when every row reads zero Underruns and Skips between 30 s and the end - and the stretch is inaudible or close to it. Record the table here. + Done when the table is recorded here with every row's Underruns below its + 2026-11-03 baseline, zero Skips between 30 s and the end, and the stretch + inaudible or close to it. - moq-dev/moq: seven scheduled Nightly runs on `main` with the stretch. Then re-measure the chromium ceilings in `test/audio-quality/budgets.json` from their `audio-quality-run` artifacts by the note's rule, adding diff --git a/rs/moq-audio/src/decode/consumer.rs b/rs/moq-audio/src/decode/consumer.rs index f42deec3cbb..99172886cd0 100644 --- a/rs/moq-audio/src/decode/consumer.rs +++ b/rs/moq-audio/src/decode/consumer.rs @@ -301,6 +301,16 @@ impl Consumer { Duration::from_secs_f64(self.target.millis() / 1000.0) } + /// How late the slowest frame of the last two seconds of media arrived + /// against the fastest, from the same reads as [`delay`](Self::delay). Zero + /// for a fixed [`Delay::min`], which ignores the arrivals. + /// + /// NetEq's maximum delay: it widens the band a playback sink's `set_lateness` + /// holds above the target rather than the target itself. + pub fn lateness(&self) -> Duration { + Duration::from_secs_f64(self.target.lateness() / 1000.0) + } + /// Sample rate samples are actually delivered at, which is /// [`Output::sample_rate`] resolved against the catalog. pub fn sample_rate(&self) -> u32 { diff --git a/rs/moq-audio/src/jitter.rs b/rs/moq-audio/src/jitter.rs index 0aa2fda433b..281db7bfc64 100644 --- a/rs/moq-audio/src/jitter.rs +++ b/rs/moq-audio/src/jitter.rs @@ -9,6 +9,7 @@ //! Every value is `f64` milliseconds, evaluated in the order the page writes it, //! so both languages produce bit-identical targets from the same trace. +use std::collections::VecDeque; use std::time::Duration; /// Milliseconds of media time the reference search looks back over. @@ -84,6 +85,15 @@ impl Target { } } + /// How late the slowest recent arrival was against the fastest, in milliseconds. + /// A fixed target ignores the arrivals, so it reports zero. + pub(crate) fn lateness(&self) -> f64 { + match self { + Self::Fixed(_) => 0.0, + Self::Auto(estimator) => estimator.lateness(), + } + } + /// The target in milliseconds. pub(crate) fn millis(&self) -> f64 { match self { @@ -119,14 +129,17 @@ impl Entry { } /// The arrivals inside the reference window, in media order, answering any -/// prefix's fastest arrival in logarithmic time. +/// prefix's fastest arrival in logarithmic time and the whole window's slowest in +/// constant time. /// /// A reordered frame is measured against the prefix at or before its timestamp, /// so a peer that sends only reordered frames would otherwise force a scan per /// frame. Entries live in a ring indexed from `head`, and a segment tree over the /// ring's slots holds each node's fastest slot, the older on a tie, as the scan /// would pick. A query never spans the ring's wrap point within one node, so a -/// node fully inside it is in arrival order. +/// node fully inside it is in arrival order. The slowest is the front of a +/// monotonic queue of entries, each slower than every later one, named by how +/// many entries were pushed before it. #[derive(Default)] struct History { /// The ring, its length a power of two that grows up to `MAX_HISTORY`. @@ -137,6 +150,10 @@ struct History { len: usize, /// Leaf `ring.len() + slot` holds `slot`; each parent holds the faster of its children. tree: Vec, + /// Entries ever pushed, so `pushed - len` names the oldest one held. + pushed: usize, + /// The entries no later entry is as slow as, oldest first. + slow: VecDeque, } impl History { @@ -164,6 +181,37 @@ impl History { self.tree[node] = self.faster(self.tree[2 * node], self.tree[2 * node + 1]); node /= 2; } + + // Drop the queue's evicted front, then every entry this one is slower than, + // keeping the older on a tie the way the reference does. + let oldest = self.pushed + 1 - self.len; + while self.slow.front().is_some_and(|&index| index < oldest) { + self.slow.pop_front(); + } + let key = arrival - media; + while let Some(&back) = self.slow.back() { + if self.at(back - oldest).key() >= key { + break; + } + self.slow.pop_back(); + } + self.slow.push_back(self.pushed); + self.pushed += 1; + } + + /// The entry `index` places after the oldest. + fn at(&self, index: usize) -> Entry { + self.ring[(self.head + index) & (self.ring.len() - 1)] + } + + /// How late the slowest entry arrived against the fastest, zero for an empty + /// window: NetEq's `GetMaxDelayMs`, in the same arithmetic as a frame's delay. + fn lateness(&self) -> f64 { + let (Some(fast), Some(&slow)) = (self.reference(f64::INFINITY), self.slow.front()) else { + return 0.0; + }; + let slow = self.at(slow - (self.pushed - self.len)); + f64::max(0.0, slow.arrival - fast.arrival - (slow.media - fast.media)) } fn pop(&mut self) { @@ -354,6 +402,13 @@ impl Estimator { } } + /// How late the slowest frame in the reference window arrived against the + /// fastest: NetEq's maximum delay, which widens the time stretch's band rather + /// than the target. + fn lateness(&self) -> f64 { + self.history.lateness() + } + fn target(&self) -> f64 { let mut cumulative = 0.0; let mut measured = BUCKETS as f64 * BUCKET; @@ -409,12 +464,22 @@ pub(crate) mod tests { #[serde(default)] pub ends: Vec, pub target: Vec<(usize, f64)>, + pub lateness: Vec<(usize, f64)>, } impl Case { /// The expected target after each frame, expanded from the change list. pub fn series(&self) -> Vec { - let mut changes = self.target.iter().peekable(); + self.expand(&self.target) + } + + /// The expected lateness after each frame, expanded from the change list. + pub fn lateness(&self) -> Vec { + self.expand(&self.lateness) + } + + fn expand(&self, changes: &[(usize, f64)]) -> Vec { + let mut changes = changes.iter().peekable(); let mut current = f64::NAN; (0..self.arrival.len()) .map(|index| { @@ -473,6 +538,7 @@ pub(crate) mod tests { target.set_frame(case.frame); let series = case.series(); + let lateness = case.lateness(); for (index, (&arrival, &media)) in case.arrival.iter().zip(&case.media).enumerate() { if case.ends.contains(&index) { target.end(); @@ -484,6 +550,12 @@ pub(crate) mod tests { "{name}: frame {index} targets {actual}, expected {}", series[index] ); + let actual = target.lateness(); + assert!( + (actual - lateness[index]).abs() <= 1e-6, + "{name}: frame {index} is {actual} late, expected {}", + lateness[index] + ); } } } @@ -550,6 +622,25 @@ pub(crate) mod tests { reference.map(|entry| (entry.arrival, entry.media)) } + /// The documented lateness: the slowest entry against the fastest, each the + /// first on a tie. + fn slowest(history: &History) -> f64 { + let entries: Vec = (0..history.len).map(|index| history.at(index)).collect(); + let Some(&first) = entries.first() else { + return 0.0; + }; + let (mut fast, mut slow) = (first, first); + for &entry in &entries[1..] { + if entry.key() < fast.key() { + fast = entry; + } + if entry.key() > slow.key() { + slow = entry; + } + } + f64::max(0.0, slow.arrival - fast.arrival - (slow.media - fast.media)) + } + /// The tree must pick exactly the entry the documented scan would, ties included, /// since a tied entry with a different `(arrival, media)` rounds the delay differently. #[test] @@ -579,6 +670,7 @@ pub(crate) mod tests { let actual = history.reference(query).map(|entry| (entry.arrival, entry.media)); assert_eq!(actual, scan(history, query), "frame {index}, query {query}"); } + assert_eq!(history.lateness(), slowest(history), "frame {index}"); } } @@ -596,8 +688,10 @@ pub(crate) mod tests { let actual = history.reference(query).map(|entry| (entry.arrival, entry.media)); assert_eq!(actual, scan(history, query), "frame {index}, query {query}"); } + assert_eq!(history.lateness(), slowest(history), "frame {index}"); } } + assert_eq!(estimator.history.lateness(), slowest(&estimator.history)); assert_eq!(estimator.history.len, MAX_HISTORY); assert_eq!(estimator.history.ring.len(), MAX_HISTORY); assert!(estimator.target().is_finite()); diff --git a/rs/moq-audio/src/playback/sink.rs b/rs/moq-audio/src/playback/sink.rs index 87b8b2906bf..e42656bb748 100644 --- a/rs/moq-audio/src/playback/sink.rs +++ b/rs/moq-audio/src/playback/sink.rs @@ -272,6 +272,13 @@ impl Sink { Ok(()) } + /// Widen the band the stretch holds above the target by how late the slowest + /// recent arrival was against the fastest, NetEq's maximum delay. The decode + /// consumer's [`lateness`](crate::decode::Consumer::lateness) is that value. + pub fn set_lateness(&mut self, lateness: Duration) { + self.channel.lock().unwrap().prod.set_lateness(lateness); + } + /// The PCM layout this sink was built with. pub fn input(&self) -> &Input { &self.input diff --git a/rs/moq-audio/src/ring.rs b/rs/moq-audio/src/ring.rs index a372a6e135e..0823f05a008 100644 --- a/rs/moq-audio/src/ring.rs +++ b/rs/moq-audio/src/ring.rs @@ -84,6 +84,9 @@ struct Shared { /// on opposite sides of a window transfer. consumed: AtomicUsize, target: AtomicUsize, + /// How late the slowest recent arrival was against the fastest, in output + /// frames, which widens the stretch's band above the target. + lateness: AtomicUsize, finished: AtomicBool, stretch: AtomicBool, /// Declared ends, counted. See [`Producer::end`]. @@ -317,6 +320,13 @@ impl Producer { flushed } + /// Widen the stretch's band above the target by how late the slowest recent + /// arrival was against the fastest, as NetEq does. + pub(crate) fn set_lateness(&mut self, lateness: Duration) { + let frames = (lateness.as_secs_f64() * self.rate as f64).floor() as usize; + self.shared.lateness.store(frames, Ordering::Relaxed); + } + /// Change the target without reallocating the queue. Leave one stretch window /// of headroom so the callback can still receive new PCM at the target. pub(crate) fn set_latency(&mut self, latency: Duration) -> bool { @@ -650,7 +660,9 @@ impl Consumer { let read = self.ring.pop_slice(&mut stretch.input[..frames * channels]); debug_assert_eq!(read, frames * channels); self.position = self.position.wrapping_add(frames); - stretch.process(frames, buffered, self.shared.target.load(Ordering::Relaxed), enabled); + let target = self.shared.target.load(Ordering::Relaxed); + let lateness = self.shared.lateness.load(Ordering::Relaxed); + stretch.process(frames, buffered, target, lateness, enabled); // The writer still counts the input while it is being analysed. // Publish only the resulting duration change, then the rendered // frames. Moving PCM into staging never makes it disappear. @@ -945,6 +957,43 @@ mod tests { } } + /// NetEq's band above the target widens by the arrivals' lateness, so a queue + /// inside it holds where it would otherwise accelerate down to the target. + #[test] + fn lateness_widens_the_band_above_the_target() { + for (lateness, low, high) in [(0, 80.0, 140.0), (100, 180.0, 240.0)] { + let (mut prod, mut cons) = channel( + 2, + 48_000, + 48_000, + Config { + latency: Duration::from_millis(100), + capacity: Duration::from_secs(3), + pad: false, + trim: false, + }, + ); + cons.stretch(48_000); + cons.start(); + prod.set_lateness(Duration::from_millis(lateness)); + // 200 ms on top of the 100 ms the queue primes with. + assert_eq!(prod.push(&vec![0.25; 9600 * 2]), Push::Ok); + let mut out = [0.0; 480 * 2]; + // Fed at the real-time rate, so only the stretch moves the depth. + for tick in 0..800 { + if tick % 2 == 0 { + assert_eq!(prod.push(&[0.25; 960 * 2]), Push::Ok); + } + assert_eq!(cons.read(&mut out), Read::Ok, "{lateness} ms late, tick {tick}"); + } + let buffered = prod.buffered().as_secs_f64() * 1000.0; + assert!( + (low..high).contains(&buffered), + "{lateness} ms late: {buffered} ms buffered" + ); + } + } + #[test] fn staged_audio_is_buffered_and_finish_drains_it() { let (mut prod, mut cons) = channel( diff --git a/rs/moq-audio/src/stretch.rs b/rs/moq-audio/src/stretch.rs index 06a63baa83a..22e87f3edab 100644 --- a/rs/moq-audio/src/stretch.rs +++ b/rs/moq-audio/src/stretch.rs @@ -62,21 +62,18 @@ impl Stretch { /// All input is new, received PCM. Short blocks and finished sinks cannot /// stretch, so a finite input never becomes concealment of an absent frame. - pub fn process(&mut self, frames: usize, buffered: usize, target: usize, enabled: bool) { + /// `lateness` widens the band above `target`, as `buffered` and `target` all + /// in frames. + pub fn process(&mut self, frames: usize, buffered: usize, target: usize, lateness: usize, enabled: bool) { let operation = if enabled && frames == self.window { - self.decide(buffered, target) + self.decide(buffered, target, lateness) } else { Operation::Hold }; let lag = if operation == Operation::Hold { 0 } else { - pitch( - &self.input, - self.channels, - self.rate, - operation != Operation::Accelerate, - ) + pitch(&self.input, self.channels, self.rate, operation == Operation::Fast) }; self.position = 0; self.length = frames; @@ -114,29 +111,25 @@ impl Stretch { self.cooldown = self.rate as usize * 50 / 1000; } - /// Expand departs from NetEq's preemptive expand, which repeats one period - /// per cooldown. A queue below its target is short of the cushion its - /// arrivals need, so it expands the way fast accelerate shrinks: every - /// window, as many whole periods as fit, at the lower admission threshold. - fn decide(&self, buffered: usize, target: usize) -> Operation { - let high = target + self.rate as usize * 20 / 1000; + /// NetEq's band above the target: its 20 ms granularity plus the arrivals' + /// lateness. + fn decide(&self, buffered: usize, target: usize, lateness: usize) -> Operation { + let high = target + lateness + self.rate as usize * 20 / 1000; if buffered >= high * 4 { Operation::Fast - } else if buffered < target { - Operation::Expand } else if self.cooldown > 0 { Operation::Hold } else if buffered >= high { Operation::Accelerate + } else if buffered < target { + Operation::Expand } else { Operation::Hold } } } -/// Search the first channel at 4 kHz, then validate the full-rate seam. Fast -/// mode, for fast accelerate and every expand, admits a weaker match and takes -/// every whole period that fits before the middle. +/// Search the first channel at 4 kHz, then validate the full-rate seam. fn pitch(input: &[f32], channels: usize, rate: u32, fast: bool) -> usize { // NetEq's 48 kHz Q12 FIR. Sampling its taps at fractional positions also // admits native 44.1/96 kHz devices without altering the search domain. @@ -218,6 +211,9 @@ mod tests { input: Vec, buffered: usize, target: usize, + /// The arrivals' lateness in frames, zero when the vector leaves it out. + #[serde(default)] + lateness: usize, cooldown: usize, decision: String, lag: usize, @@ -233,12 +229,12 @@ mod tests { stretch.input.copy_from_slice(&vector.input); stretch.cooldown = vector.cooldown; assert_eq!( - format!("{:?}", stretch.decide(vector.buffered, vector.target)), + format!("{:?}", stretch.decide(vector.buffered, vector.target, vector.lateness)), vector.decision, "{}", vector.name ); - stretch.process(stretch.window, vector.buffered, vector.target, true); + stretch.process(stretch.window, vector.buffered, vector.target, vector.lateness, true); assert_eq!(stretch.length.abs_diff(stretch.window), vector.lag, "{}", vector.name); assert_eq!(stretch.length * vector.channels, vector.output.len(), "{}", vector.name); for (index, (&actual, &expected)) in stretch.output[..vector.output.len()] @@ -261,7 +257,7 @@ mod tests { let mut stretch = Stretch::new(rate, 2); stretch.input.fill(0.25); stretch.cooldown = 0; - stretch.process(stretch.window, stretch.window, rate as usize, true); + stretch.process(stretch.window, stretch.window, rate as usize, 0, true); assert!(stretch.length > stretch.window); let mut output = vec![0.0; 2 * rate as usize]; let (_, allocations) = crate::allocation::measure(|| { @@ -269,9 +265,9 @@ mod tests { assert_eq!(stretch.read(&mut output), 0); }); assert_eq!(allocations.operations, 0); - stretch.process(stretch.window, stretch.window, rate as usize, false); + stretch.process(stretch.window, stretch.window, rate as usize, 0, false); assert_eq!(stretch.length, stretch.window, "a finished sink drains unchanged"); - stretch.process(stretch.window / 2, stretch.window, rate as usize, true); + stretch.process(stretch.window / 2, stretch.window, rate as usize, 0, true); assert_eq!(stretch.length, stretch.window / 2, "a short block drains unchanged"); } } diff --git a/rs/moq-cli/src/play/fake.rs b/rs/moq-cli/src/play/fake.rs index e0707a582a6..e1e3d89f731 100644 --- a/rs/moq-cli/src/play/fake.rs +++ b/rs/moq-cli/src/play/fake.rs @@ -158,6 +158,9 @@ impl Sink for FakeSink { Ok(()) } + // The fake plays at its target and never stretches, so there is no band to widen. + fn set_lateness(&mut self, _lateness: Duration) {} + async fn finish(mut self) { // A finite short tail drains even when it cannot refill the target. if self.prime.take().is_some() { diff --git a/rs/moq-cli/src/play/media.rs b/rs/moq-cli/src/play/media.rs index 51564d3cca2..c517ca7c723 100644 --- a/rs/moq-cli/src/play/media.rs +++ b/rs/moq-cli/src/play/media.rs @@ -618,6 +618,7 @@ async fn play_audio( }; let ended = matches!(event, Ok(None)); let delay = consumer.delay(); + let lateness = consumer.lateness(); let crossing = match &event { Ok(Some(moq_audio::decode::Read::End { end })) => { ends.push_back((Duration::from(*end), role.declare())); @@ -656,7 +657,7 @@ async fn play_audio( received .lock() .unwrap() - .push_back((event, delay, crossing, Instant::now())); + .push_back((event, (delay, lateness), crossing, Instant::now())); arrived.notify_one(); if ended { return Ok::<_, anyhow::Error>(()); @@ -676,7 +677,7 @@ async fn play_audio( // The frame being written resumes a timeline whose end is already declared. let mut declare = false; loop { - let (event, delay, crossing, _) = loop { + let (event, (delay, lateness), crossing, _) = loop { if let Some(event) = received.lock().unwrap().pop_front() { popped.notify_one(); break event; @@ -805,10 +806,18 @@ async fn play_audio( let held = input.latency; let target = samples(held); sink.set_latency(held)?; + sink.set_lateness(lateness); // Leave normal convergence to the callback. Only an excess at NetEq's - // fast threshold (four times target + granularity) is an emergency - // re-anchor; a 20 ms trim would compete with every pitch correction. - let fit = fit(buffered, target, slack, timing.silence, length as u64); + // fast threshold (four times target + lateness + granularity) is an + // emergency re-anchor; a 20 ms trim would compete with every pitch + // correction. + let fit = fit( + buffered, + target, + slack + samples(lateness), + timing.silence, + length as u64, + ); // The packet pays for the channel count; the catalog cannot allocate // a duration's worth of silence before any samples arrive. diff --git a/rs/moq-cli/src/play/output.rs b/rs/moq-cli/src/play/output.rs index ec5435508fa..9b6e3e22db4 100644 --- a/rs/moq-cli/src/play/output.rs +++ b/rs/moq-cli/src/play/output.rs @@ -39,6 +39,9 @@ pub(super) trait Sink: Send + Sync + 'static { /// Update the callback's playout target without replacing the sink. fn set_latency(&mut self, latency: Duration) -> anyhow::Result<()>; + /// Widen the band the callback holds above the target by the arrivals' lateness. + fn set_lateness(&mut self, lateness: Duration); + /// How much audio is queued ahead of the speaker. fn buffered(&self) -> Duration; @@ -65,6 +68,10 @@ impl Sink for moq_audio::playback::Sink { Ok(moq_audio::playback::Sink::set_latency(self, latency)?) } + fn set_lateness(&mut self, lateness: Duration) { + moq_audio::playback::Sink::set_lateness(self, lateness) + } + fn write(&mut self, samples: &[u8]) -> anyhow::Result { Ok(moq_audio::playback::Sink::write(self, samples)?) } diff --git a/test/audio-quality/README.md b/test/audio-quality/README.md index c890df32c34..274321e99f2 100644 --- a/test/audio-quality/README.md +++ b/test/audio-quality/README.md @@ -212,9 +212,9 @@ and clock checks have nothing to void. Decoding is taken as instant. A replay is its budgets are exactly what it measured. The ring time-stretches live playback as the page's does, but the replay's audio is a constant, so -every seam admits at the shortest pitch period, 2.5 ms. Accelerate therefore removes less per stretch -than it would from speech, and expand, which repeats every whole period that fits, adds the most it -can. `skip_aheads` also reads a sustained accelerate as a skip; `player_skips` counts only the ring's +every seam admits at the shortest pitch period, 2.5 ms. Accelerate and expand therefore move less +per stretch than they would from speech; only fast accelerate, which takes every whole period that +fits, moves its most. `skip_aheads` also reads a sustained accelerate as a skip; `player_skips` counts only the ring's own re-anchors. ```bash diff --git a/test/audio-quality/budgets.json b/test/audio-quality/budgets.json index 1bda1e5b0fa..1a8defb86a0 100644 --- a/test/audio-quality/budgets.json +++ b/test/audio-quality/budgets.json @@ -1,5 +1,5 @@ { - "note": "The browser rows are measured on the nightly runner (ubuntu-24.04-arm, headless Chromium, seed 7, 60 s a row), from the audio-quality-run artifacts of the seven scheduled Nightly runs on main from 2026-10-29 to 2026-11-04 (40885347517, 41065371094, 41204380716, 41313466339, 41483654426, 41656613559, 41852517544), the first after a fresh subscriber stopped receiving the relay's cached history. The AAC rows predate the TS importer publishing each PES as one group. Each ceiling is the worst of its seven nights times 1.25, plus one runner hiccup, rounded up to two significant figures. The hiccup is sized from the single gaps the 2026-10-08 night put on otherwise clean rows, the fixed-250 control among them: 250 underruns/min, 700 gap ms/min, 3.3 skips/min, 280 discarded ms/min, 0.01 stalled, 0.015 silence, and one 20 ms bucket of target. Budgeted this way, every night passes when it is held out of its row's measurement except one, and that row's own ceiling includes it: the 2026-11-03 Opus bursty row raised its target to 300 ms 2.6 s in and held it for one 20 s half-life before settling at 180. Such startup holds, Opus near-zero's 100 ms on 2026-10-30 and 10-31 among them, are budgeted as measured. These ceilings record today's player as the runner hears it, not target audio quality. To re-measure, download the same artifact from the latest scheduled nightlies (`gh run download -n audio-quality-run`), which keep every run, and apply the same rule. The replay rows are deterministic, so their ceilings are exactly what they measured, through the end of each recording, with no headroom: any regression fails them, and an improvement should be tightened in. They were last re-measured on 2026-10-22 using version 3 traces with encoded frame durations: AAC-LC uses its fixed 1024 samples, and relay-mic retains Opus packet TOC durations. relay-mic was re-recorded on 2026-11-03 from a real microphone, Chrome 156 on a MacBook Air publishing its built-in microphone through the public relay, recorded by headless Chromium on a Linux host (35 s, minimum RTT 2 ms), which raised its target ceiling from 60 to 80 ms and its silence from 0 to 0.001 as measured. The recording path itself has no added RTT. relay-mic-rtt40 is the 2026-11-03 Chrome row at 40 ms of added RTT on that laptop (180 s, minimum RTT 47 ms), kept as the baseline time stretch must bring to zero. player_underruns_per_min, the player's own counter that its stats panel shows, is budgeted on the replay rows only; it counts the run-dry re-stalls the tap files as stalled time. On 2026-11-06 the player began time-stretching live playback and every replay row was re-measured with it: player_underruns_per_min fell to 0 on all five, relay-mic-rtt40's from 7.9, and stalled and silence fell or held. player_skips_per_min, the ring's own count of re-anchors that dropped buffered audio, is budgeted beside it: 0 except relay-mic-rtt40's 0.3, one re-anchor 21.5 s in as the estimator released its 780 ms startup hold, which main makes too. The tap metrics that rose are none of them audio the player dropped. skip_aheads and discarded_ms infer skips from steps in the playhead's lag, which a sustained accelerate makes too. bursty-aac no longer runs dry waiting on its missing groups (stalled 0.009 to 0, silence 0.013 to 0.002), so each hole now plays as the gap it is and the tap counts it as underruns. The AAC rows' gaps of 1 to 3 samples between frames, from rounding each frame's timestamp to the ring's index, now land at the end of a quantum often enough to count, at 0.2 gap ms a minute or less; main has the same zeros, aligned differently. The local-aac replay's stalled ceiling rises from 0.008 to 0.017 and silence from 0.015 to 0.020 because replay no longer stretches each frame to nearby timestamp gaps; the production player is unchanged. All other changed replay ceilings tighten to the exact measurement. That replay calibration leaves browser and native ceilings unchanged. bursty-aac is the 2026-10-18 AAC bursty isolated capture, recorded with the observer subscribed at the decoder's 2 s budget, so it holds every group the player saw. The native rows are provisional: measured on a loaded developer host (x86_64 Linux, the private PulseAudio null sink, seed 7, 60 s a row) on 2026-10-17, three runs of every row from the debug build nightly uses plus three more of the AAC rows from a release build, which played alike. Each ceiling is the worst clean run times 1.25, plus one native hiccup sized from the unimpaired Opus row's worst run (20 underruns/min, 50 gap ms/min, 2.2 skips/min, 110 discarded ms/min, 0.01 stalled, 0.005 silence, one 20 ms bucket of target), rounded up to two significant figures. On that host the null sink's clock ran about 150 ppm slow against the monotonic clock, read within 5 ms at p95 per sample, and its output latency sat between 14 and 28 ms. Five of the 36 AAC rows (none of the 18 Opus rows) voided on the clock: the device stopped pulling for about two seconds mid-row, sometimes after a backend error and a stream restart, which is a native playback defect rather than noise, and the ceilings exclude those runs. Re-measure from the nightly runner's artifacts once it has a week of native rows.", + "note": "The browser rows are measured on the nightly runner (ubuntu-24.04-arm, headless Chromium, seed 7, 60 s a row), from the audio-quality-run artifacts of the seven scheduled Nightly runs on main from 2026-10-29 to 2026-11-04 (40885347517, 41065371094, 41204380716, 41313466339, 41483654426, 41656613559, 41852517544), the first after a fresh subscriber stopped receiving the relay's cached history. The AAC rows predate the TS importer publishing each PES as one group. Each ceiling is the worst of its seven nights times 1.25, plus one runner hiccup, rounded up to two significant figures. The hiccup is sized from the single gaps the 2026-10-08 night put on otherwise clean rows, the fixed-250 control among them: 250 underruns/min, 700 gap ms/min, 3.3 skips/min, 280 discarded ms/min, 0.01 stalled, 0.015 silence, and one 20 ms bucket of target. Budgeted this way, every night passes when it is held out of its row's measurement except one, and that row's own ceiling includes it: the 2026-11-03 Opus bursty row raised its target to 300 ms 2.6 s in and held it for one 20 s half-life before settling at 180. Such startup holds, Opus near-zero's 100 ms on 2026-10-30 and 10-31 among them, are budgeted as measured. These ceilings record today's player as the runner hears it, not target audio quality. To re-measure, download the same artifact from the latest scheduled nightlies (`gh run download -n audio-quality-run`), which keep every run, and apply the same rule. The replay rows are deterministic, so their ceilings are exactly what they measured, through the end of each recording, with no headroom: any regression fails them, and an improvement should be tightened in. They were last re-measured on 2026-10-22 using version 3 traces with encoded frame durations: AAC-LC uses its fixed 1024 samples, and relay-mic retains Opus packet TOC durations. relay-mic was re-recorded on 2026-11-03 from a real microphone, Chrome 156 on a MacBook Air publishing its built-in microphone through the public relay, recorded by headless Chromium on a Linux host (35 s, minimum RTT 2 ms), which raised its target ceiling from 60 to 80 ms and its silence from 0 to 0.001 as measured. The recording path itself has no added RTT. relay-mic-rtt40 is the 2026-11-03 Chrome row at 40 ms of added RTT on that laptop (180 s, minimum RTT 47 ms). player_underruns_per_min, the player's own counter that its stats panel shows, is budgeted on the replay rows only; it counts the run-dry re-stalls the tap files as stalled time. On 2026-11-06 the player began time-stretching live playback with NetEq's accelerate and preemptive expand, their band above the target widened by NetEq's maximum delay, and every replay row was re-measured with it, the browser rows left to the nightly runner: player_underruns_per_min fell from 4.4, 12.1, 12.1, 6.1 and 7.9 to 2.2 on bursty-aac, 0 on local-aac, relay-bbb and relay-mic, and 1 on relay-mic-rtt40, and stalled and silence fell or held. relay-mic-rtt40's are two run-dries, 111.6 s and 162.5 s in, each behind receive stalls of 100 to 125 ms against an 80 to 100 ms target, which NetEq would conceal rather than stretch through; bursty-aac's is one run-dry 6 s in, which the band does not change. player_skips_per_min, the ring's own count of re-anchors that dropped buffered audio, is budgeted beside it: 0 except relay-mic-rtt40's 0.3, one re-anchor 21.5 s in as the estimator released its 780 ms startup hold, which main makes too. The tap metrics that rose are none of them audio the player dropped. skip_aheads and discarded_ms infer skips from steps in the playhead's lag, which a sustained accelerate makes too: local-aac's one, 41 ms, is the ring accelerating back onto its target after the band held it, and relay-mic-rtt40's rose from 0.3 to 1.4 a minute the same way. bursty-aac no longer re-stalls waiting on its missing groups (stalled 0.009 to 0, silence 0.013 to 0.003), so each hole plays as the gap it is and the tap counts it as underruns. local-aac's 2 underruns a minute are the AAC rows' gaps of 1 to 3 samples between frames, from rounding each frame's timestamp to the ring's index, landing at the end of a quantum, at under 0.1 gap ms a minute; main has the same zeros, aligned differently. The local-aac replay's stalled ceiling rises from 0.008 to 0.017 and silence from 0.015 to 0.020 because replay no longer stretches each frame to nearby timestamp gaps; the production player is unchanged. All other changed replay ceilings tighten to the exact measurement. That replay calibration leaves browser and native ceilings unchanged. bursty-aac is the 2026-10-18 AAC bursty isolated capture, recorded with the observer subscribed at the decoder's 2 s budget, so it holds every group the player saw. The native rows are provisional: measured on a loaded developer host (x86_64 Linux, the private PulseAudio null sink, seed 7, 60 s a row) on 2026-10-17, three runs of every row from the debug build nightly uses plus three more of the AAC rows from a release build, which played alike. Each ceiling is the worst clean run times 1.25, plus one native hiccup sized from the unimpaired Opus row's worst run (20 underruns/min, 50 gap ms/min, 2.2 skips/min, 110 discarded ms/min, 0.01 stalled, 0.005 silence, one 20 ms bucket of target), rounded up to two significant figures. On that host the null sink's clock ran about 150 ppm slow against the monotonic clock, read within 5 ms at p95 per sample, and its output latency sat between 14 and 28 ms. Five of the 36 AAC rows (none of the 18 Opus rows) voided on the clock: the device stopped pulling for about two seconds mid-row, sometimes after a backend error and a stream restart, which is a native playback defect rather than noise, and the ceilings exclude those runs. Re-measure from the nightly runner's artifacts once it has a week of native rows.", "rows": [ { "runtime": "chromium", @@ -318,14 +318,14 @@ "codec": "aac", "rate": 44100, "profile": "bursty-aac", - "player_underruns_per_min": 0, + "player_underruns_per_min": 2.2, "player_skips_per_min": 0, - "underruns_per_min": 38.3, - "underrun_ms_per_min": 94.9, - "skip_aheads_per_min": 4.4, - "discarded_ms_per_min": 201.6, + "underruns_per_min": 19.7, + "underrun_ms_per_min": 50.8, + "skip_aheads_per_min": 0, + "discarded_ms_per_min": 0, "stalled_share": 0, - "silence_share": 0.002, + "silence_share": 0.003, "target_ms_p95": 343.2 }, { @@ -335,12 +335,12 @@ "profile": "local-aac", "player_underruns_per_min": 0, "player_skips_per_min": 0, - "underruns_per_min": 6.1, - "underrun_ms_per_min": 0.2, - "skip_aheads_per_min": 0, - "discarded_ms_per_min": 0, + "underruns_per_min": 2, + "underrun_ms_per_min": 0, + "skip_aheads_per_min": 2, + "discarded_ms_per_min": 82.5, "stalled_share": 0, - "silence_share": 0, + "silence_share": 0.001, "target_ms_p95": 203.2 }, { @@ -350,10 +350,10 @@ "profile": "relay-bbb", "player_underruns_per_min": 0, "player_skips_per_min": 0, - "underruns_per_min": 4, - "underrun_ms_per_min": 0.1, - "skip_aheads_per_min": 4, - "discarded_ms_per_min": 239.4, + "underruns_per_min": 0, + "underrun_ms_per_min": 0, + "skip_aheads_per_min": 0, + "discarded_ms_per_min": 0, "stalled_share": 0, "silence_share": 0, "target_ms_p95": 223.2 @@ -378,12 +378,12 @@ "codec": "opus", "rate": 48000, "profile": "relay-mic-rtt40", - "player_underruns_per_min": 0, + "player_underruns_per_min": 1, "player_skips_per_min": 0.3, "underruns_per_min": 0, "underrun_ms_per_min": 0, - "skip_aheads_per_min": 3.1, - "discarded_ms_per_min": 281.8, + "skip_aheads_per_min": 1.4, + "discarded_ms_per_min": 213.5, "stalled_share": 0, "silence_share": 0, "target_ms_p95": 780 From a6e0761c0ad8e7637c365fba49436c02d21a5768 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Luke Curley Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2026 17:11:26 -0800 Subject: [PATCH 06/13] fix(watch): drop the staged window with the audio a re-anchor skips An emergency re-anchor moved the read index but kept the partly rendered stretch window, so the old PCM played on the new timeline and the playhead misreported it. Clear it, as moq-audio's trim discards staged output first. Dropping the startup backlog's staged window shifts each replay's later window phase, so the replay ceilings are re-measured: relay-mic-rtt40's two run-dries now each end mid-quantum and count twice (1.4 a minute), and the lag heuristic reads one or two more accelerates as skips. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- doc/concept/audio-jitter.md | 6 +++--- js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts | 15 +++++++++++++++ js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts | 6 ++++++ quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md | 9 +++++---- test/audio-quality/budgets.json | 18 +++++++++--------- 5 files changed, 38 insertions(+), 16 deletions(-) diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter.md b/doc/concept/audio-jitter.md index ef9a4033957..12fd068cae7 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter.md +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter.md @@ -692,9 +692,9 @@ time. During a receive stall `buffered` drains while the playout delay holds, so this expands into the stall, and once the stall's frames land together `buffered` jumps while the playout delay holds, so this can accelerate away the cushion they bring. Deciding on the playout delay instead cut the -`relay-mic-rtt40` replay from 1.0 to 0.7 player underruns a minute, but the -browser's worklet would need the arrival clock mapped onto its render clock to -do it, so neither player does yet. +`relay-mic-rtt40` replay's player underruns by about a third in a prototype, +but the browser's worklet would need the arrival clock mapped onto its render +clock to do it, so neither player does yet. ### Pitch search and admission diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts index e55dcd152d7..061c540d7d3 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts @@ -929,6 +929,21 @@ describe("time stretch", () => { expect(buffer.length).toBeLessThan(frames(480)); }); + it("drops the staged window with the audio a re-anchor skips", () => { + const buffer = live(100); + write(buffer, 0 as Milli, frames(100), { value: 0.25 }); + read(buffer, QUANTUM, 1); + + // 400 ms more crosses the 480 ms fast threshold with a 30 ms window still staged. + write(buffer, 100 as Milli, frames(400), { value: 0.5 }); + expect(buffer.skips).toBe(1); + expect(buffer.length).toBe(frames(100)); + expect(Milli.fromMicro(buffer.timestamp)).toBeCloseTo(400, 6); + const [output] = read(buffer, QUANTUM, 1); + expect(output.length).toBe(QUANTUM); + expect(output.every((sample) => sample === 0.5)).toBe(true); + }); + // Past NetEq's fast threshold, four times the floor plus its band, or three quarters of the // headroom above the floor, whichever is lower, stretching back would take seconds, so the ring // re-anchors on its floor as moq-audio does. With 1000 ms of capacity, a 100 ms floor reaches the diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts index 5844643db25..bc930d223fb 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts @@ -328,6 +328,12 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { // Move the read index forward to `index`, dropping any queued audio it passes. #skip(index: number): void { if (index > this.#readIndex && this.#readIndex < this.#writeIndex) this.#skips++; + // The staged window lies behind the new index, so it is dropped with the rest, as moq-audio's + // trim discards staged output first. + if (index > this.#readIndex) { + this.#stretch.clear(); + this.#window = 0; + } this.#readIndex = index; this.#prune(); } diff --git a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md index 496db996dc1..a4f72b8bff3 100644 --- a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md +++ b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md @@ -12,7 +12,7 @@ row skips buffered audio in steady state. What still runs dry is what NetEq itself would conceal: a receive stall longer than the target. The measured rows are the `relay-mic-rtt40` replay row, at -the 1.0 `player_underruns_per_min` NetEq measures there (7.9 on `main` without +the 1.4 `player_underruns_per_min` NetEq measures there (7.9 on `main` without the stretch), and a live re-run of the 2026-11-03 rows below with a real microphone, Chrome's with 40 ms or more of added RTT and Safari's on the direct path, read from the stats panel's audio Underruns and Skips beside @@ -32,8 +32,9 @@ NetEq's maximum-delay term to the decision band in both players: the estimator reports its `lateness`, how late the slowest frame of the last two seconds arrived against the fastest, and the band above the target widens by it, as NetEq's `DecisionLogic` adds `GetMaxDelayMs`. Without it `relay-mic-rtt40` ran -dry 2.1 times a minute; with it, 1.0. Every replay row is budgeted at what it -measures. The one difference from NetEq left, deciding on the ring's depth +dry three times in its 175 s window; with it, twice, which the player counts +as 1.4 underruns a minute, the quantum each ran dry in and its re-stall. Every +replay row is budgeted at what it measures. The one difference from NetEq left, deciding on the ring's depth rather than NetEq's playout delay, is recorded in the shared spec, and the PR lists it as a follow-up. What remains is proof outside the replay: @@ -116,7 +117,7 @@ on the direct path. Underruns are the stats panel's counter after the first | Safari, direct, 100 ms groups | WebSocket | 5 ms | 12 in 119 s (6.1/min) | 0 | 120 / 140 ms | The Chrome +40 ms, 20 ms-group capture is checked in as the `relay-mic-rtt40` -replay row: 7.9 player underruns a minute on `main`, 1.0 with the stretch. +replay row: 7.9 player underruns a minute on `main`, 1.4 with the stretch. ## Waiting diff --git a/test/audio-quality/budgets.json b/test/audio-quality/budgets.json index e3b68939b53..3574bf9206a 100644 --- a/test/audio-quality/budgets.json +++ b/test/audio-quality/budgets.json @@ -1,5 +1,5 @@ { - "note": "The browser rows are measured on the nightly runner (ubuntu-24.04-arm, headless Chromium, seed 7, 60 s a row), from the audio-quality-run artifacts of the seven scheduled Nightly runs on main from 2026-10-29 to 2026-11-04 (40885347517, 41065371094, 41204380716, 41313466339, 41483654426, 41656613559, 41852517544), the first after a fresh subscriber stopped receiving the relay's cached history. The AAC rows predate the TS importer publishing each PES as one group. Each ceiling is the worst of its seven nights times 1.25, plus one runner hiccup, rounded up to two significant figures. The hiccup is sized from the single gaps the 2026-10-08 night put on otherwise clean rows, the fixed-250 control among them: 250 underruns/min, 700 gap ms/min, 3.3 skips/min, 280 discarded ms/min, 0.01 stalled, 0.015 silence, and one 20 ms bucket of target. Budgeted this way, every night passes when it is held out of its row's measurement except one, and that row's own ceiling includes it: the 2026-11-03 Opus bursty row raised its target to 300 ms 2.6 s in and held it for one 20 s half-life before settling at 180. Such startup holds, Opus near-zero's 100 ms on 2026-10-30 and 10-31 among them, are budgeted as measured. These ceilings record today's player as the runner hears it, not target audio quality. To re-measure, download the same artifact from the latest scheduled nightlies (`gh run download -n audio-quality-run`), which keep every run, and apply the same rule. The replay rows are deterministic, so their ceilings are exactly what they measured, through the end of each recording, with no headroom: any regression fails them, and an improvement should be tightened in. They were last re-measured on 2026-10-22 using version 3 traces with encoded frame durations: AAC-LC uses its fixed 1024 samples, and relay-mic retains Opus packet TOC durations. relay-mic was re-recorded on 2026-11-03 from a real microphone, Chrome 156 on a MacBook Air publishing its built-in microphone through the public relay, recorded by headless Chromium on a Linux host (35 s, minimum RTT 2 ms), which raised its target ceiling from 60 to 80 ms and its silence from 0 to 0.001 as measured. The recording path itself has no added RTT. relay-mic-rtt40 is the 2026-11-03 Chrome row at 40 ms of added RTT on that laptop (180 s, minimum RTT 47 ms), kept as the baseline time stretch improves on; like every replay row, its player_underruns_per_min ceiling is what it measures, not a fixed zero. player_underruns_per_min, the player's own counter that its stats panel shows, is budgeted on the replay rows only; it counts the run-dry re-stalls the tap files as stalled time. On 2026-11-06 the player began time-stretching live playback with NetEq's accelerate and preemptive expand, their band above the target widened by NetEq's maximum delay, and every replay row was re-measured with it, the browser rows left to the nightly runner: player_underruns_per_min fell from 4.4, 12.1, 12.1, 6.1 and 7.9 to 2.2 on bursty-aac, 0 on local-aac, relay-bbb and relay-mic, and 1 on relay-mic-rtt40, and stalled and silence fell or held. relay-mic-rtt40's are two run-dries, 111.6 s and 162.5 s in, each behind receive stalls of 100 to 125 ms against an 80 to 100 ms target, which NetEq would conceal rather than stretch through; bursty-aac's is one run-dry 6 s in, which the band does not change. player_skips_per_min, the ring's own count of re-anchors that dropped buffered audio, is budgeted beside it: 0 except relay-mic-rtt40's 0.3, one re-anchor 21.5 s in as the estimator released its 780 ms startup hold, which main makes too. The tap metrics that rose are none of them audio the player dropped. skip_aheads and discarded_ms infer skips from steps in the playhead's lag, which a sustained accelerate makes too: local-aac's one, 41 ms, is the ring accelerating back onto its target after the band held it, and relay-mic-rtt40's rose from 0.3 to 1.4 a minute the same way. bursty-aac no longer re-stalls waiting on its missing groups (stalled 0.009 to 0, silence 0.013 to 0.003), so each hole plays as the gap it is and the tap counts it as underruns. local-aac's 2 underruns a minute are the AAC rows' gaps of 1 to 3 samples between frames, from rounding each frame's timestamp to the ring's index, landing at the end of a quantum, at under 0.1 gap ms a minute; main has the same zeros, aligned differently. The local-aac replay's stalled ceiling rises from 0.008 to 0.017 and silence from 0.015 to 0.020 because replay no longer stretches each frame to nearby timestamp gaps; the production player is unchanged. All other changed replay ceilings tighten to the exact measurement. That replay calibration leaves browser and native ceilings unchanged. bursty-aac is the 2026-10-18 AAC bursty isolated capture, recorded with the observer subscribed at the decoder's 2 s budget, so it holds every group the player saw. The native rows are provisional: measured on a loaded developer host (x86_64 Linux, the private PulseAudio null sink, seed 7, 60 s a row) on 2026-10-17, three runs of every row from the debug build nightly uses plus three more of the AAC rows from a release build, which played alike. Each ceiling is the worst clean run times 1.25, plus one native hiccup sized from the unimpaired Opus row's worst run (20 underruns/min, 50 gap ms/min, 2.2 skips/min, 110 discarded ms/min, 0.01 stalled, 0.005 silence, one 20 ms bucket of target), rounded up to two significant figures. On that host the null sink's clock ran about 150 ppm slow against the monotonic clock, read within 5 ms at p95 per sample, and its output latency sat between 14 and 28 ms. Five of the 36 AAC rows (none of the 18 Opus rows) voided on the clock: the device stopped pulling for about two seconds mid-row, sometimes after a backend error and a stream restart, which is a native playback defect rather than noise, and the ceilings exclude those runs. Re-measure from the nightly runner's artifacts once it has a week of native rows.", + "note": "The browser rows are measured on the nightly runner (ubuntu-24.04-arm, headless Chromium, seed 7, 60 s a row), from the audio-quality-run artifacts of the seven scheduled Nightly runs on main from 2026-10-29 to 2026-11-04 (40885347517, 41065371094, 41204380716, 41313466339, 41483654426, 41656613559, 41852517544), the first after a fresh subscriber stopped receiving the relay's cached history. The AAC rows predate the TS importer publishing each PES as one group. Each ceiling is the worst of its seven nights times 1.25, plus one runner hiccup, rounded up to two significant figures. The hiccup is sized from the single gaps the 2026-10-08 night put on otherwise clean rows, the fixed-250 control among them: 250 underruns/min, 700 gap ms/min, 3.3 skips/min, 280 discarded ms/min, 0.01 stalled, 0.015 silence, and one 20 ms bucket of target. Budgeted this way, every night passes when it is held out of its row's measurement except one, and that row's own ceiling includes it: the 2026-11-03 Opus bursty row raised its target to 300 ms 2.6 s in and held it for one 20 s half-life before settling at 180. Such startup holds, Opus near-zero's 100 ms on 2026-10-30 and 10-31 among them, are budgeted as measured. These ceilings record today's player as the runner hears it, not target audio quality. To re-measure, download the same artifact from the latest scheduled nightlies (`gh run download -n audio-quality-run`), which keep every run, and apply the same rule. The replay rows are deterministic, so their ceilings are exactly what they measured, through the end of each recording, with no headroom: any regression fails them, and an improvement should be tightened in. They were last re-measured on 2026-10-22 using version 3 traces with encoded frame durations: AAC-LC uses its fixed 1024 samples, and relay-mic retains Opus packet TOC durations. relay-mic was re-recorded on 2026-11-03 from a real microphone, Chrome 156 on a MacBook Air publishing its built-in microphone through the public relay, recorded by headless Chromium on a Linux host (35 s, minimum RTT 2 ms), which raised its target ceiling from 60 to 80 ms and its silence from 0 to 0.001 as measured. The recording path itself has no added RTT. relay-mic-rtt40 is the 2026-11-03 Chrome row at 40 ms of added RTT on that laptop (180 s, minimum RTT 47 ms), kept as the baseline time stretch improves on; like every replay row, its player_underruns_per_min ceiling is what it measures, not a fixed zero. player_underruns_per_min, the player's own counter that its stats panel shows, is budgeted on the replay rows only; it counts the run-dry re-stalls the tap files as stalled time. On 2026-11-06 the player began time-stretching live playback with NetEq's accelerate and preemptive expand, their band above the target widened by NetEq's maximum delay, and every replay row was re-measured with it, the browser rows left to the nightly runner: player_underruns_per_min fell from 4.4, 12.1, 12.1, 6.1 and 7.9 to 2.2 on bursty-aac, 0 on local-aac, relay-bbb and relay-mic, and 1.4 on relay-mic-rtt40, and stalled and silence fell or held. relay-mic-rtt40's are two run-dries, 111.6 s and 162.5 s in, each counted twice, as the quantum it ran dry in and the re-stall, and each behind receive stalls of 100 to 125 ms against an 80 to 100 ms target, which NetEq would conceal rather than stretch through; bursty-aac's is one run-dry 6 s in, which the band does not change. player_skips_per_min, the ring's own count of re-anchors that dropped buffered audio, is budgeted beside it: 0 except relay-mic-rtt40's 0.3, one re-anchor 21.5 s in as the estimator released its 780 ms startup hold, which main makes too. The tap metrics that rose are none of them audio the player dropped. skip_aheads and discarded_ms infer skips from steps in the playhead's lag, which a sustained accelerate makes too: local-aac's, relay-bbb's and relay-mic's, one or two in each 30 s window at 40 to 52 ms, are the ring accelerating back onto its target after the band held it, and relay-mic-rtt40's rose from 0.3 to 1.4 a minute the same way. bursty-aac no longer re-stalls waiting on its missing groups (stalled 0.009 to 0, silence 0.013 to 0.003), so each hole plays as the gap it is and the tap counts it as underruns. The local-aac replay's stalled ceiling rises from 0.008 to 0.017 and silence from 0.015 to 0.020 because replay no longer stretches each frame to nearby timestamp gaps; the production player is unchanged. All other changed replay ceilings tighten to the exact measurement. That replay calibration leaves browser and native ceilings unchanged. bursty-aac is the 2026-10-18 AAC bursty isolated capture, recorded with the observer subscribed at the decoder's 2 s budget, so it holds every group the player saw. The native rows are provisional: measured on a loaded developer host (x86_64 Linux, the private PulseAudio null sink, seed 7, 60 s a row) on 2026-10-17, three runs of every row from the debug build nightly uses plus three more of the AAC rows from a release build, which played alike. Each ceiling is the worst clean run times 1.25, plus one native hiccup sized from the unimpaired Opus row's worst run (20 underruns/min, 50 gap ms/min, 2.2 skips/min, 110 discarded ms/min, 0.01 stalled, 0.005 silence, one 20 ms bucket of target), rounded up to two significant figures. On that host the null sink's clock ran about 150 ppm slow against the monotonic clock, read within 5 ms at p95 per sample, and its output latency sat between 14 and 28 ms. Five of the 36 AAC rows (none of the 18 Opus rows) voided on the clock: the device stopped pulling for about two seconds mid-row, sometimes after a backend error and a stream restart, which is a native playback defect rather than noise, and the ceilings exclude those runs. Re-measure from the nightly runner's artifacts once it has a week of native rows.", "rows": [ { "runtime": "chromium", @@ -335,10 +335,10 @@ "profile": "local-aac", "player_underruns_per_min": 0, "player_skips_per_min": 0, - "underruns_per_min": 2, + "underruns_per_min": 0, "underrun_ms_per_min": 0, "skip_aheads_per_min": 2, - "discarded_ms_per_min": 82.5, + "discarded_ms_per_min": 85.3, "stalled_share": 0, "silence_share": 0.001, "target_ms_p95": 203.2 @@ -352,8 +352,8 @@ "player_skips_per_min": 0, "underruns_per_min": 0, "underrun_ms_per_min": 0, - "skip_aheads_per_min": 0, - "discarded_ms_per_min": 0, + "skip_aheads_per_min": 2, + "discarded_ms_per_min": 105, "stalled_share": 0, "silence_share": 0, "target_ms_p95": 223.2 @@ -367,8 +367,8 @@ "player_skips_per_min": 0, "underruns_per_min": 0, "underrun_ms_per_min": 0, - "skip_aheads_per_min": 0, - "discarded_ms_per_min": 0, + "skip_aheads_per_min": 4, + "discarded_ms_per_min": 201.7, "stalled_share": 0, "silence_share": 0, "target_ms_p95": 80 @@ -378,12 +378,12 @@ "codec": "opus", "rate": 48000, "profile": "relay-mic-rtt40", - "player_underruns_per_min": 1, + "player_underruns_per_min": 1.4, "player_skips_per_min": 0.3, "underruns_per_min": 0, "underrun_ms_per_min": 0, "skip_aheads_per_min": 1.4, - "discarded_ms_per_min": 213.5, + "discarded_ms_per_min": 214.2, "stalled_share": 0, "silence_share": 0, "target_ms_p95": 780 From b075e85f0a512f6ea0561465516a1986b81ce773 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Luke Curley Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2026 18:26:44 -0800 Subject: [PATCH 07/13] quest: record the clean MacBook Air listening run Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md | 46 +++++++-------------------- 1 file changed, 11 insertions(+), 35 deletions(-) diff --git a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md index a4f72b8bff3..b65b379178e 100644 --- a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md +++ b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md @@ -36,18 +36,17 @@ dry three times in its 175 s window; with it, twice, which the player counts as 1.4 underruns a minute, the quantum each ran dry in and its re-stall. Every replay row is budgeted at what it measures. The one difference from NetEq left, deciding on the ring's depth rather than NetEq's playout delay, is recorded in the shared spec, and the PR -lists it as a follow-up. What remains is proof outside the replay: - -- The 2026-11-03 rows re-run on real hardware, Chrome's at +40 ms and Safari's - on the direct path, under Waiting. -- A listening check of that run. The native player's 2026-11-05 listening in - [Native stretch](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md) still - holds: the band only changes when it stretches, not how. -- The nightly browser ceilings re-measured by `budgets.json`'s rule from seven - scheduled nightlies with the stretch. The lag heuristic behind - `skip_aheads` and `discarded_ms` reads a sustained accelerate as a skip, so - those can rise on rows whose target moves; `player_skips` counts the ring's - real re-anchors beside them. +lists it as a follow-up. What remains is the nightly browser ceilings, +re-measured by `budgets.json`'s rule from seven scheduled nightlies with the +stretch. The lag heuristic behind `skip_aheads` and `discarded_ms` reads a +sustained accelerate as a skip, so those can rise on rows whose target moves; +`player_skips` counts the ring's real re-anchors beside them. + +Decided 2026-11-07 (maintainer, /quest-unblock): listening run on the MacBook +Air sounds clean. It covered the live Chrome +40 ms RTT and Safari direct +rows, each with 20 and 100 ms groups. No Underruns or Skips numbers were +reported. The native player's 2026-11-05 listening in +[Native stretch](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md) still holds. Decided 2026-11-06 (maintainer, /quest-complete on [moq-dev/moq#8058](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/8058)): the Goal was @@ -121,29 +120,6 @@ replay row: 7.9 player underruns a minute on `main`, 1.4 with the stretch. ## Waiting -- Maintainer: re-run the 2026-11-03 rows on the MacBook Air and listen to - them, since an agent has no microphone, speaker, or Safari. Automation - considered: rendering speech through the ring offline, but the repository's - only speech clips are 0.4 s, and the live run exercises the same stretch on - a real voice. On a checkout of `main` once - [moq-dev/moq#8058](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/8058) merges, or of - its branch before: - 1. `just web serve https://cdn.moq.dev/anon`, and in its publish tab - publish the built-in microphone with 20 ms groups, the default. - 2. For the +40 ms RTT, `cargo run --release -p moq-shaper -- --listen - 127.0.0.1:443 --target "$(dig +short cdn.moq.dev | head -1):443" - --delay 20ms`, then open the watch page in a second Chrome profile: - `open -na "Google Chrome" --args --user-data-dir=/tmp/rtt40 - --host-resolver-rules="MAP cdn.moq.dev 127.0.0.1"`. - 3. Play the broadcast at the Real-time delay and talk for three minutes. - Note the stats panel's audio Underruns and Skips at 30 s and at the end, - and listen for warble or pitch wobble. - 4. Repeat with 100 ms groups, then both group sizes in Safari on the direct - path, with no shaper. - - Done when the stretch has no audible glitch in steady state and every row - reads zero Skips between 30 s and the end. Record the table of Underruns and - Skips per row here, beside the baseline. - moq-dev/moq: seven scheduled Nightly runs on `main` with the stretch. Then re-measure the chromium ceilings in `test/audio-quality/budgets.json` from their `audio-quality-run` artifacts by the note's rule, adding From e0af594c56e810041836fe0c22c52901ebcb5ab9 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Luke Curley Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2026 18:48:10 -0800 Subject: [PATCH 08/13] quest: judge js/watch's stretch on automated measurements alone Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md | 28 ++++++++++++--------------- 1 file changed, 12 insertions(+), 16 deletions(-) diff --git a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md index b65b379178e..1f99f0eed53 100644 --- a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md +++ b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/watch.md @@ -1,22 +1,20 @@ -# [M] js/watch: prove NetEq's audio time stretch on real hardware +# [M] js/watch: prove NetEq's audio time stretch on measured arrivals ## Goal -On the measured real-microphone rows, the "Real-time" (`"auto"`) preset +On the measured real-microphone arrivals, the "Real-time" (`"auto"`) preset converges on its target the way WebRTC NetEq does, with the estimator's `QUANTILE` left at 0.95: audio holds back or catches up by playing slightly slower or faster, through NetEq's preemptive expand and accelerate and its -decision band, rather than discarding buffered audio. It plays with no audible -glitch after convergence, judged by the maintainer's listening check, and no -row skips buffered audio in steady state. +decision band, rather than discarding buffered audio. No row skips buffered +audio in steady state. What still runs dry is what NetEq itself would conceal: a receive stall longer -than the target. The measured rows are the `relay-mic-rtt40` replay row, at -the 1.4 `player_underruns_per_min` NetEq measures there (7.9 on `main` without -the stretch), and a live re-run of the 2026-11-03 rows below with a real -microphone, Chrome's with 40 ms or more of added RTT and Safari's on the -direct path, read from the stats panel's audio Underruns and Skips beside -their 2026-11-03 baseline. Their underrun and skip ceilings are measured by +than the target. The bar is automated measurement alone: the replay rows, +including `relay-mic-rtt40` at the 1.4 `player_underruns_per_min` NetEq +measures there (7.9 on `main` without the stretch), and the chromium browser +rows re-measured from seven scheduled Nightlies with the stretch, adding +`player_skips_per_min`. Every underrun and skip ceiling is measured by `test/audio-quality/budgets.json`'s rule, like every other budget, rather than fixed at zero. @@ -42,11 +40,9 @@ stretch. The lag heuristic behind `skip_aheads` and `discarded_ms` reads a sustained accelerate as a skip, so those can rise on rows whose target moves; `player_skips` counts the ring's real re-anchors beside them. -Decided 2026-11-07 (maintainer, /quest-unblock): listening run on the MacBook -Air sounds clean. It covered the live Chrome +40 ms RTT and Safari direct -rows, each with 20 and 100 ms groups. No Underruns or Skips numbers were -reported. The native player's 2026-11-05 listening in -[Native stretch](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md) still holds. +Decided 2026-11-07 (maintainer, /quest-unblock): no maintainer listening run; +the Goal is judged by the replay and Nightly measurements alone. This +supersedes the listening check in the two decisions below. Decided 2026-11-06 (maintainer, /quest-complete on [moq-dev/moq#8058](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/8058)): the Goal was From 03f8e9e5dbf8c49d621bd9cc877d7e86a1ac75a0 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Luke Curley Date: Sat, 7 Nov 2026 15:08:37 -0800 Subject: [PATCH 09/13] js/watch: count a re-anchor that drops only the staged window as a skip Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts | 14 ++++++++++++++ js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts | 4 ++-- 2 files changed, 16 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts index 061c540d7d3..5130ea4cd9d 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts @@ -944,6 +944,20 @@ describe("time stretch", () => { expect(output.every((sample) => sample === 0.5)).toBe(true); }); + it("counts a re-anchor that drops only the staged window as a skip", () => { + const buffer = live(100); + // Four whole 30 ms windows, so once the playhead passes 90 ms the ring is empty and only the + // last window is left, staged. + write(buffer, 0 as Milli, frames(120), { value: 0.25 }); + while (Milli.fromMicro(buffer.timestamp) <= 90) read(buffer, QUANTUM, 1); + expect(buffer.length).toBeGreaterThan(0); + expect(buffer.length).toBeLessThan(frames(30)); + + write(buffer, 120 as Milli, frames(500), { value: 0.5 }); + expect(buffer.skips).toBe(1); + expect(buffer.length).toBe(frames(100)); + }); + // Past NetEq's fast threshold, four times the floor plus its band, or three quarters of the // headroom above the floor, whichever is lower, stretching back would take seconds, so the ring // re-anchors on its floor as moq-audio does. With 1000 ms of capacity, a 100 ms floor reaches the diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts index bc930d223fb..160c5f0b2b4 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts @@ -325,9 +325,9 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { if (!this.#anchored || (this.#stalled && this.length <= 0 && this.#ended())) this.#silent = true; } - // Move the read index forward to `index`, dropping any queued audio it passes. + // Move the read index forward to `index`, dropping any queued audio it passes, staged included. #skip(index: number): void { - if (index > this.#readIndex && this.#readIndex < this.#writeIndex) this.#skips++; + if (index > this.#readIndex && this.length > 0) this.#skips++; // The staged window lies behind the new index, so it is dropped with the rest, as moq-audio's // trim discards staged output first. if (index > this.#readIndex) { From e858f4dad6a000268f7dc62d9762907aafe246bf Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Luke Curley Date: Sat, 7 Nov 2026 15:40:06 -0800 Subject: [PATCH 10/13] js/watch: keep the declared-silence catch-up forward-only The catch-up counted the staged window toward the queued total but landed the read index from the ring's write end alone, so a ring below its floor behind a staged window rewound the read index and re-staged PCM. It now skips only the silence past the queued floor. Also: the stretch copies by index instead of allocating subarray views in the render path, the insert doc and write comment say samples behind the staged window are dropped, and budgets.json drops a stale local-aac sentence that contradicted its row. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- js/watch/src/audio/buffer.ts | 5 ++++- js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts | 26 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++ js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts | 7 +++++-- js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts | 13 +++++++++---- test/audio-quality/budgets.json | 2 +- 5 files changed, 45 insertions(+), 8 deletions(-) diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/buffer.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/buffer.ts index 75152819128..0a7d21a2184 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/buffer.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/buffer.ts @@ -359,7 +359,10 @@ export class AudioBuffer { this.#backpressure.dropped(); } - /** Insert audio samples at the given timestamp, transferring their buffers. Handles out-of-order writes. */ + /** + * Insert audio samples at the given timestamp, transferring their buffers. A write may land out of + * order, but samples behind what live playback already staged, up to 30 ms past the playhead, are dropped. + */ insert(timestamp: Micro, data: Float32Array[]): void { const end = (timestamp + Micro.fromSecond(((data[0]?.length ?? 0) / this.rate) as Second)) as Micro; this.#backpressure.inserted(timestamp, end); diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts index 5130ea4cd9d..64ab4c41a98 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts @@ -958,6 +958,32 @@ describe("time stretch", () => { expect(buffer.length).toBe(frames(100)); }); + // The ring past the read index holds less than the floor, but the staged window lifts the total a + // chunk above it, so the catch-up over the declared silence must count the staged output too. + it("catches up over a declared silence without rewinding behind a staged window", () => { + const buffer = live(100); + write(buffer, 0 as Milli, frames(120), { value: 0.25 }); + while (Milli.fromMicro(buffer.timestamp) <= 90) read(buffer, QUANTUM, 1); + const staged = buffer.length; + expect(staged).toBeGreaterThan(frames(20)); + + // The next utterance lands 80 ms after the last, 10 ms long: 90 ms of ring behind the window. + buffer.next(); + const playhead = buffer.timestamp; + write(buffer, 200 as Milli, frames(10), { value: 0.5 }); + expect(buffer.timestamp).toBeGreaterThanOrEqual(playhead); + expect(buffer.length).toBe(frames(100)); + expect(buffer.skips).toBe(0); + + // The staged window plays out once, then the rest of the silence, then the utterance. + const [output] = read(buffer, frames(100), 1); + expect(output.length).toBe(frames(100)); + const silence = output.findIndex((sample) => sample === 0); + expect(silence).toBe(staged); + expect(output.slice(silence).every((sample) => sample === 0 || sample === 0.5)).toBe(true); + expect(output.at(-1)).toBe(0.5); + }); + // Past NetEq's fast threshold, four times the floor plus its band, or three quarters of the // headroom above the floor, whichever is lower, stretching back would take seconds, so the ring // re-anchors on its floor as moq-audio does. With 1000 ms of capacity, a 100 ms floor reaches the diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts index 160c5f0b2b4..cfbdee414c8 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts @@ -188,7 +188,8 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { this.#anchored = true; } - // Ignore samples that are too old (before the read index) + // Ignore samples behind the read index, which runs ahead of the playhead by the staged window: + // that part is already staged to play, so a late write there is dropped too. let offset = this.#readIndex - start; if (offset > samples) { // All samples are too old, ignore them @@ -231,7 +232,9 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { if (end - this.#readIndex > this.capacity) { this.#skip(end - this.capacity); } else if (band && pause && pause.start <= this.#readIndex && queued > latency + this.#chunk) { - this.#readIndex = Math.min(pause.end, end - latency); + // Skip only the silence past the queued floor, which the staged window counts toward, so the + // read index only moves forward and never re-stages PCM the window already holds. + this.#readIndex = Math.min(pause.end, this.#readIndex + queued - latency); this.#prune(); } else if ( band && diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts index 60a91ee6ba0..4db35c75e91 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts @@ -82,8 +82,11 @@ export class Stretch { /** Copy staged frames into `output` from `offset`, as many as fit, and return how many. */ read(output: Float32Array[], offset: number): number { const frames = Math.min(output[0].length - offset, this.available); + // Index loops rather than `set(subarray(...))`, since each `subarray` allocates a view. for (let channel = 0; channel < output.length; channel++) { - output[channel].set(this.#output[channel].subarray(this.#position, this.#position + frames), offset); + const src = this.#output[channel]; + const dst = output[channel]; + for (let i = 0; i < frames; i++) dst[offset + i] = src[this.#position + i]; } this.#position += frames; this.cooldown = Math.max(0, this.cooldown - frames); @@ -103,7 +106,9 @@ export class Stretch { this.#length = frames; if (lag === 0) { for (let channel = 0; channel < this.input.length; channel++) { - this.#output[channel].set(this.input[channel].subarray(0, frames)); + const input = this.input[channel]; + const output = this.#output[channel]; + for (let i = 0; i < frames; i++) output[i] = input[i]; } return; } @@ -119,14 +124,14 @@ export class Stretch { for (let channel = 0; channel < this.input.length; channel++) { const input = this.input[channel]; const output = this.#output[channel]; - output.set(input.subarray(0, seam)); + for (let i = 0; i < seam; i++) output[i] = input[i]; // NetEq's AudioVector::CrossFade, in floating point. The endpoints stay inside the seam // rather than duplicating either neighbour. for (let i = 0; i < lag; i++) { const weight = (i + 1) / (lag + 1); output[seam + i] = input[first + i] * (1 - weight) + input[second + i] * weight; } - output.set(input.subarray(tail, frames), seam + lag); + for (let i = tail; i < frames; i++) output[seam + lag + i - tail] = input[i]; } this.cooldown = this.#rest; } diff --git a/test/audio-quality/budgets.json b/test/audio-quality/budgets.json index 3574bf9206a..a74f69d4fff 100644 --- a/test/audio-quality/budgets.json +++ b/test/audio-quality/budgets.json @@ -1,5 +1,5 @@ { - "note": "The browser rows are measured on the nightly runner (ubuntu-24.04-arm, headless Chromium, seed 7, 60 s a row), from the audio-quality-run artifacts of the seven scheduled Nightly runs on main from 2026-10-29 to 2026-11-04 (40885347517, 41065371094, 41204380716, 41313466339, 41483654426, 41656613559, 41852517544), the first after a fresh subscriber stopped receiving the relay's cached history. The AAC rows predate the TS importer publishing each PES as one group. Each ceiling is the worst of its seven nights times 1.25, plus one runner hiccup, rounded up to two significant figures. The hiccup is sized from the single gaps the 2026-10-08 night put on otherwise clean rows, the fixed-250 control among them: 250 underruns/min, 700 gap ms/min, 3.3 skips/min, 280 discarded ms/min, 0.01 stalled, 0.015 silence, and one 20 ms bucket of target. Budgeted this way, every night passes when it is held out of its row's measurement except one, and that row's own ceiling includes it: the 2026-11-03 Opus bursty row raised its target to 300 ms 2.6 s in and held it for one 20 s half-life before settling at 180. Such startup holds, Opus near-zero's 100 ms on 2026-10-30 and 10-31 among them, are budgeted as measured. These ceilings record today's player as the runner hears it, not target audio quality. To re-measure, download the same artifact from the latest scheduled nightlies (`gh run download -n audio-quality-run`), which keep every run, and apply the same rule. The replay rows are deterministic, so their ceilings are exactly what they measured, through the end of each recording, with no headroom: any regression fails them, and an improvement should be tightened in. They were last re-measured on 2026-10-22 using version 3 traces with encoded frame durations: AAC-LC uses its fixed 1024 samples, and relay-mic retains Opus packet TOC durations. relay-mic was re-recorded on 2026-11-03 from a real microphone, Chrome 156 on a MacBook Air publishing its built-in microphone through the public relay, recorded by headless Chromium on a Linux host (35 s, minimum RTT 2 ms), which raised its target ceiling from 60 to 80 ms and its silence from 0 to 0.001 as measured. The recording path itself has no added RTT. relay-mic-rtt40 is the 2026-11-03 Chrome row at 40 ms of added RTT on that laptop (180 s, minimum RTT 47 ms), kept as the baseline time stretch improves on; like every replay row, its player_underruns_per_min ceiling is what it measures, not a fixed zero. player_underruns_per_min, the player's own counter that its stats panel shows, is budgeted on the replay rows only; it counts the run-dry re-stalls the tap files as stalled time. On 2026-11-06 the player began time-stretching live playback with NetEq's accelerate and preemptive expand, their band above the target widened by NetEq's maximum delay, and every replay row was re-measured with it, the browser rows left to the nightly runner: player_underruns_per_min fell from 4.4, 12.1, 12.1, 6.1 and 7.9 to 2.2 on bursty-aac, 0 on local-aac, relay-bbb and relay-mic, and 1.4 on relay-mic-rtt40, and stalled and silence fell or held. relay-mic-rtt40's are two run-dries, 111.6 s and 162.5 s in, each counted twice, as the quantum it ran dry in and the re-stall, and each behind receive stalls of 100 to 125 ms against an 80 to 100 ms target, which NetEq would conceal rather than stretch through; bursty-aac's is one run-dry 6 s in, which the band does not change. player_skips_per_min, the ring's own count of re-anchors that dropped buffered audio, is budgeted beside it: 0 except relay-mic-rtt40's 0.3, one re-anchor 21.5 s in as the estimator released its 780 ms startup hold, which main makes too. The tap metrics that rose are none of them audio the player dropped. skip_aheads and discarded_ms infer skips from steps in the playhead's lag, which a sustained accelerate makes too: local-aac's, relay-bbb's and relay-mic's, one or two in each 30 s window at 40 to 52 ms, are the ring accelerating back onto its target after the band held it, and relay-mic-rtt40's rose from 0.3 to 1.4 a minute the same way. bursty-aac no longer re-stalls waiting on its missing groups (stalled 0.009 to 0, silence 0.013 to 0.003), so each hole plays as the gap it is and the tap counts it as underruns. The local-aac replay's stalled ceiling rises from 0.008 to 0.017 and silence from 0.015 to 0.020 because replay no longer stretches each frame to nearby timestamp gaps; the production player is unchanged. All other changed replay ceilings tighten to the exact measurement. That replay calibration leaves browser and native ceilings unchanged. bursty-aac is the 2026-10-18 AAC bursty isolated capture, recorded with the observer subscribed at the decoder's 2 s budget, so it holds every group the player saw. The native rows are provisional: measured on a loaded developer host (x86_64 Linux, the private PulseAudio null sink, seed 7, 60 s a row) on 2026-10-17, three runs of every row from the debug build nightly uses plus three more of the AAC rows from a release build, which played alike. Each ceiling is the worst clean run times 1.25, plus one native hiccup sized from the unimpaired Opus row's worst run (20 underruns/min, 50 gap ms/min, 2.2 skips/min, 110 discarded ms/min, 0.01 stalled, 0.005 silence, one 20 ms bucket of target), rounded up to two significant figures. On that host the null sink's clock ran about 150 ppm slow against the monotonic clock, read within 5 ms at p95 per sample, and its output latency sat between 14 and 28 ms. Five of the 36 AAC rows (none of the 18 Opus rows) voided on the clock: the device stopped pulling for about two seconds mid-row, sometimes after a backend error and a stream restart, which is a native playback defect rather than noise, and the ceilings exclude those runs. Re-measure from the nightly runner's artifacts once it has a week of native rows.", + "note": "The browser rows are measured on the nightly runner (ubuntu-24.04-arm, headless Chromium, seed 7, 60 s a row), from the audio-quality-run artifacts of the seven scheduled Nightly runs on main from 2026-10-29 to 2026-11-04 (40885347517, 41065371094, 41204380716, 41313466339, 41483654426, 41656613559, 41852517544), the first after a fresh subscriber stopped receiving the relay's cached history. The AAC rows predate the TS importer publishing each PES as one group. Each ceiling is the worst of its seven nights times 1.25, plus one runner hiccup, rounded up to two significant figures. The hiccup is sized from the single gaps the 2026-10-08 night put on otherwise clean rows, the fixed-250 control among them: 250 underruns/min, 700 gap ms/min, 3.3 skips/min, 280 discarded ms/min, 0.01 stalled, 0.015 silence, and one 20 ms bucket of target. Budgeted this way, every night passes when it is held out of its row's measurement except one, and that row's own ceiling includes it: the 2026-11-03 Opus bursty row raised its target to 300 ms 2.6 s in and held it for one 20 s half-life before settling at 180. Such startup holds, Opus near-zero's 100 ms on 2026-10-30 and 10-31 among them, are budgeted as measured. These ceilings record today's player as the runner hears it, not target audio quality. To re-measure, download the same artifact from the latest scheduled nightlies (`gh run download -n audio-quality-run`), which keep every run, and apply the same rule. The replay rows are deterministic, so their ceilings are exactly what they measured, through the end of each recording, with no headroom: any regression fails them, and an improvement should be tightened in. They were last re-measured on 2026-10-22 using version 3 traces with encoded frame durations: AAC-LC uses its fixed 1024 samples, and relay-mic retains Opus packet TOC durations. relay-mic was re-recorded on 2026-11-03 from a real microphone, Chrome 156 on a MacBook Air publishing its built-in microphone through the public relay, recorded by headless Chromium on a Linux host (35 s, minimum RTT 2 ms), which raised its target ceiling from 60 to 80 ms and its silence from 0 to 0.001 as measured. The recording path itself has no added RTT. relay-mic-rtt40 is the 2026-11-03 Chrome row at 40 ms of added RTT on that laptop (180 s, minimum RTT 47 ms), kept as the baseline time stretch improves on; like every replay row, its player_underruns_per_min ceiling is what it measures, not a fixed zero. player_underruns_per_min, the player's own counter that its stats panel shows, is budgeted on the replay rows only; it counts the run-dry re-stalls the tap files as stalled time. On 2026-11-06 the player began time-stretching live playback with NetEq's accelerate and preemptive expand, their band above the target widened by NetEq's maximum delay, and every replay row was re-measured with it, the browser rows left to the nightly runner: player_underruns_per_min fell from 4.4, 12.1, 12.1, 6.1 and 7.9 to 2.2 on bursty-aac, 0 on local-aac, relay-bbb and relay-mic, and 1.4 on relay-mic-rtt40, and stalled and silence fell or held. relay-mic-rtt40's are two run-dries, 111.6 s and 162.5 s in, each counted twice, as the quantum it ran dry in and the re-stall, and each behind receive stalls of 100 to 125 ms against an 80 to 100 ms target, which NetEq would conceal rather than stretch through; bursty-aac's is one run-dry 6 s in, which the band does not change. player_skips_per_min, the ring's own count of re-anchors that dropped buffered audio, is budgeted beside it: 0 except relay-mic-rtt40's 0.3, one re-anchor 21.5 s in as the estimator released its 780 ms startup hold, which main makes too. The tap metrics that rose are none of them audio the player dropped. skip_aheads and discarded_ms infer skips from steps in the playhead's lag, which a sustained accelerate makes too: local-aac's, relay-bbb's and relay-mic's, one or two in each 30 s window at 40 to 52 ms, are the ring accelerating back onto its target after the band held it, and relay-mic-rtt40's rose from 0.3 to 1.4 a minute the same way. bursty-aac no longer re-stalls waiting on its missing groups (stalled 0.009 to 0, silence 0.013 to 0.003), so each hole plays as the gap it is and the tap counts it as underruns. Neither replay calibration changed the browser or native ceilings. bursty-aac is the 2026-10-18 AAC bursty isolated capture, recorded with the observer subscribed at the decoder's 2 s budget, so it holds every group the player saw. The native rows are provisional: measured on a loaded developer host (x86_64 Linux, the private PulseAudio null sink, seed 7, 60 s a row) on 2026-10-17, three runs of every row from the debug build nightly uses plus three more of the AAC rows from a release build, which played alike. Each ceiling is the worst clean run times 1.25, plus one native hiccup sized from the unimpaired Opus row's worst run (20 underruns/min, 50 gap ms/min, 2.2 skips/min, 110 discarded ms/min, 0.01 stalled, 0.005 silence, one 20 ms bucket of target), rounded up to two significant figures. On that host the null sink's clock ran about 150 ppm slow against the monotonic clock, read within 5 ms at p95 per sample, and its output latency sat between 14 and 28 ms. Five of the 36 AAC rows (none of the 18 Opus rows) voided on the clock: the device stopped pulling for about two seconds mid-row, sometimes after a backend error and a stream restart, which is a native playback defect rather than noise, and the ceilings exclude those runs. Re-measure from the nightly runner's artifacts once it has a week of native rows.", "rows": [ { "runtime": "chromium", From a01e4c70529f023ea0641a639e9fa76e2882a561 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Luke Curley Date: Sun, 8 Nov 2026 09:45:26 -0800 Subject: [PATCH 11/13] fix(watch): the audio ring's stretch never settles audio behind the clock The stretch compared the ring's current depth with the target, and that depth drains between arrivals because the next frame has not landed, not because audio is ahead of the shared clock. Expanding into every trough, with a band widened by the arrivals' lateness, settled audio a burst behind video: A/V lag p50 rose from 1 to 289 ms on bursty-aac. The ring now decides on its depth right after the latest write, less what the stretch has removed since, which is how far the playhead trails the newest arrival. Any excess accelerates, one past 20 ms fast-accelerates, and the ring never expands, so it rests on its floor right after each arrival, where the trim left it. The decode gate releases a live frame by where its output ends, so the stretch cannot draw frames through a hold. The lateness band is reverted in both players, with the estimator's lateness and its corpus fields. Native keeps NetEq's decision. The harness records the shared clock and reports av_lag_ms, budgeted exactly on every replay row, and unit tests hold that a ring never expands, rests on its floor under flushes, and underruns rather than settling later when its target is short of the spread. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- doc/concept/audio-jitter.md | 116 +++---- doc/concept/audio-jitter/advertised.json | 2 +- doc/concept/audio-jitter/backlog.json | 2 +- doc/concept/audio-jitter/buildup.json | 2 +- doc/concept/audio-jitter/corpus.test.ts | 4 - doc/concept/audio-jitter/corpus.ts | 22 +- doc/concept/audio-jitter/fixed.json | 2 +- doc/concept/audio-jitter/flush.json | 2 +- doc/concept/audio-jitter/idle.json | 2 +- doc/concept/audio-jitter/paced.json | 2 +- doc/concept/audio-jitter/reference.ts | 17 - doc/concept/audio-jitter/reorder.json | 2 +- doc/concept/audio-jitter/silence.json | 2 +- doc/concept/audio-jitter/spike.json | 2 +- doc/concept/audio-jitter/straggler.json | 2 +- doc/concept/audio-jitter/stretch/corpus.json | 325 ------------------ doc/concept/audio-jitter/tunein.json | 2 +- doc/lib/js/watch.md | 4 +- js/hang/api/container.api.md | 1 - js/hang/src/container/consumer.ts | 10 - js/hang/src/container/jitter.test.ts | 23 -- js/hang/src/container/jitter.ts | 46 +-- js/watch/src/audio/buffer.ts | 22 +- js/watch/src/audio/decoder.ts | 19 +- js/watch/src/audio/playout.test.ts | 6 +- js/watch/src/audio/render-worklet.ts | 2 - js/watch/src/audio/render.ts | 8 +- js/watch/src/audio/replay.test.ts | 70 +++- js/watch/src/audio/replay.ts | 9 +- js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts | 90 +++-- js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts | 41 ++- js/watch/src/audio/stretch.test.ts | 72 +++- js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts | 69 ++-- quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/README.md | 21 +- .../audio-jitter-target/browser-ceilings.md | 19 +- .../m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md | 10 +- rs/moq-audio/src/decode/consumer.rs | 10 - rs/moq-audio/src/jitter.rs | 100 +----- rs/moq-audio/src/playback/sink.rs | 7 - rs/moq-audio/src/ring.rs | 51 +-- rs/moq-audio/src/stretch.rs | 25 +- rs/moq-cli/src/play/fake.rs | 3 - rs/moq-cli/src/play/media.rs | 19 +- rs/moq-cli/src/play/output.rs | 7 - test/audio-quality/README.md | 10 +- test/audio-quality/budgets.json | 68 ++-- test/audio-quality/clients/js/grade.ts | 2 + test/audio-quality/clients/js/replay.ts | 3 + .../clients/js/src/analyze.test.ts | 12 + test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/analyze.ts | 4 + test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/probe.ts | 1 + test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/schema.ts | 9 + 52 files changed, 457 insertions(+), 924 deletions(-) diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter.md b/doc/concept/audio-jitter.md index 12fd068cae7..a7d55b60b45 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter.md +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter.md @@ -127,12 +127,6 @@ fold(bucket): # prior starts at 1 target(): measured = upper edge of the first bucket whose cumulative weight exceeds QUANTILE return max(measured, advertised) + frame - -lateness(): # widens the time stretch's band, not the target - if history is empty: return 0 - fast = entry in history minimising (entry.arrival - entry.media), the oldest on a tie - slow = entry in history maximising (entry.arrival - entry.media), the oldest on a tie - return max(0, (slow.arrival - fast.arrival) - (slow.media - fast.media)) ``` ### Relative arrival delay @@ -166,8 +160,7 @@ shorter than `WINDOW` instead of growing without bound. The reference is a minimum over a prefix of the history, and the publisher chooses the prefix by reordering, so scanning for it lets every frame cost `MAX_HISTORY` comparisons. Keep the history in a structure that answers any -prefix's minimum in logarithmic time, such as a segment tree over a ring, and -the whole history's maximum for `lateness`, such as a monotonic queue. +prefix's minimum in logarithmic time, such as a segment tree over a ring. Keep the oldest entry on a tie: tied entries with a different `arrival` and `media` round `delay` differently. @@ -274,18 +267,6 @@ A quantile of an empirical distribution, rather than a mean plus k deviations, because network delay is heavy-tailed and one-sided. A Gaussian assumption sizes that tail wrong in both directions. -### Lateness - -`lateness` is how late the slowest frame in the history arrived against the -fastest: NetEq's `PacketArrivalHistory::GetMaxDelayMs`, over the same -two-second window and the same in-order frames, since a reordered frame never -joins the history. It is not part of the target. The -[time stretch](#received-audio-time-stretch) adds it to the band above the -target, as NetEq's `DecisionLogic` does, so a ring the last two seconds -refilled after a late burst keeps that cushion instead of accelerating it away -before the next one. It reads the window as it is now rather than a quantile -of its history, so it falls back as soon as the late frame leaves the window. - ## The frame duration One frame duration is added on top of `measured`. The buffer swings by the @@ -522,11 +503,10 @@ marker in its group, and they belong to the speech before the silence, not after ## Fixed targets An explicit delay **fixes the target and disables adaptation**. It is taken -literally: no advertised floor, no frame term, no estimate, and no lateness. +literally: no advertised floor, no frame term, no estimate. ``` target = delay -lateness = 0 ``` An impossible fixed target is refused, not silently adjusted. A negative delay, @@ -591,8 +571,7 @@ directly, so neither is graded against the other. "frame": 20, "arrival": [0, 10, 30], "media": [0, 14500, 14520], - "target": [[0, 120], [26, 80]], - "lateness": [[0, 0]] + "target": [[0, 120], [26, 80]] } ``` @@ -603,8 +582,7 @@ them, as is `ends`: the indices, ascending, of the frames observed right after a [declared end](#declared-silence), each of which calls `end()` before it is observed. `target` lists `[frame index, target]` at every frame where the target differs from the previous frame's, starting at frame 0, so an implementation folds the trace one frame at a time and compares its target at each listed -index. `lateness` lists the lateness the same way, zero throughout for the -`fixed` case. Tolerance is 1e-6 ms, which the `f64` rules above make generous. +index. Tolerance is 1e-6 ms, which the `f64` rules above make generous. | Case | Holds the implementation to | | --- | --- | @@ -636,12 +614,14 @@ the `bun doc/concept/audio-jitter/corpus.ts` command above. It runs in ## Received-audio time stretch -Both players adapt received PCM to the target with WebRTC NetEq's accelerate -and preemptive expand: native playback in `rs/moq-audio`, and the browser in the -AudioWorklet's ring in `js/watch`. Neither generates replacement audio for a -missing packet, so a hole in the media plays as a hole. The estimator above is -unchanged. Both conform to this same algorithm and -[PCM corpus](audio-jitter/stretch/corpus.json). The browser stretches only live +Both players adapt received PCM to the target with the seams of WebRTC +NetEq's time stretch: native playback in `rs/moq-audio` with its accelerate and +preemptive expand, and the browser in the AudioWorklet's ring in `js/watch` +with its accelerate alone. Neither generates replacement audio for a missing +packet, so a hole in the media plays as a hole. The estimator above is +unchanged. Both share the pitch search, admission, seams, and +[PCM corpus](audio-jitter/stretch/corpus.json) below; they differ only in +[what they decide on](#browser-decision). The browser stretches only live playback: buffered playback plays every sample it holds, as it always has. The source is WebRTC's @@ -667,12 +647,10 @@ is silence rather than an underrun, so nothing expands toward a target that no arrival will refill. `buffered` counts unread frames in the ring plus staged output. `target` is -the current playout target, and `lateness` the estimator's -[lateness](#lateness), NetEq's `GetMaxDelayMs`, which is zero for a -[fixed target](#fixed-targets). The state is `cooldown`, initially 60 ms +the current playout target. The state is `cooldown`, initially 60 ms (NetEq's six startup ticks), reduced -by each frame rendered, saturating at zero. At a window boundary, with -`high = target + lateness + 20 ms`, choose in this order: +by each frame rendered, saturating at zero. At a window boundary, native +playback chooses in this order, with `high = target + 20 ms`: 1. `buffered >= 4 * high`: fast accelerate, even during cooldown. 2. `cooldown > 0`: hold. @@ -682,19 +660,31 @@ by each frame rendered, saturating at zero. At a window boundary, with A successful stretch sets cooldown to 50 ms (NetEq's five 10 ms ticks). A rejected seam leaves it unchanged. This preserves NetEq's 20 ms adjustment -granularity, its maximum-delay term, its 4x fast threshold, and its minimum -interval. There is no concealment state. - -One difference from NetEq's `DecisionLogic` remains. NetEq compares its -playout delay, how far the playhead trails the fastest arrival in its packet -history, where this compares `buffered`. The two agree while frames arrive on -time. During a receive stall `buffered` drains while the playout delay holds, -so this expands into the stall, and once the stall's frames land together -`buffered` jumps while the playout delay holds, so this can accelerate away the -cushion they bring. Deciding on the playout delay instead cut the -`relay-mic-rtt40` replay's player underruns by about a third in a prototype, -but the browser's worklet would need the arrival clock mapped onto its render -clock to do it, so neither player does yet. +granularity, 4x fast threshold, and minimum interval. NetEq's extra +packet-history maximum-delay term is not added again: this controller sees the +already decoded PCM queue and its jitter target rather than an RTP playout +timestamp and packet-arrival history. There is no concealment state. + +### Browser decision + +The browser's ring starts on its target and plays at the shared clock video +plays from, so slowing it down only ever settles audio behind that clock. It +never expands. It decides on `peak`, the ring's length right after the latest +write less what the stretch has removed since: how far the playhead trails the +newest arrival, which is the playout delay NetEq's `DecisionLogic` compares. +`buffered` drains between arrivals because the next one has not landed, not +because audio is ahead of the clock, so deciding on it expands into every gap +and settles a burst behind. With `excess = peak - target`, choose in this order: + +1. `excess >= 20 ms`: fast accelerate, even during cooldown. +2. `cooldown > 0` or `excess <= 0`: hold. +3. Otherwise: accelerate, admitting only a lag `L <= excess`. + +So the ring rests within one pitch period of its target right after each +arrival, where dropping back to the target used to leave it, and a fast +accelerate after a refill catches up about as fast as that drop did. Arrivals that +outrun the target underrun instead: that is the cost of a target short of the +spread, and the estimator's to fix, not the stretch's. ### Pitch search and admission @@ -758,24 +748,24 @@ ring and staged output hold the target again. Padding never enters the pitch search. Finishing bypasses that wait so a short tail can drain. Trimming is emergency recovery at the ring's capacity watermark. The CLI's incoming-media trim is reserved for a distance at the fast threshold, -`4 * high`, not ordinary 20 ms drift. The browser's ring receives each decoded -frame as a write, so it re-anchors on its floor there, at the lower of the fast -threshold and three quarters of its headroom above the floor, and counts each -re-anchor as a skip in its stats. These bounds do not promise concealment of missing +not ordinary 20 ms drift. The browser's ring receives each decoded frame as a +write, so it re-anchors on its target there, at the lower of `4 * high` and +three quarters of its headroom above the target, and counts each re-anchor as +a skip in its stats. These bounds do not promise concealment of missing media or convergence of a signal whose seams continually fail admission. ### Stretch corpus `audio-jitter/stretch/corpus.json` holds literal interleaved input and expected -output PCM, device rate and channels, buffered, target, and lateness frame -counts (lateness is zero where a vector leaves it out), incoming cooldown, -requested decision, and admitted lag (zero means hold). Compare output within -1e-6 absolute sample amplitude. It includes hold, cooldown, fast-mode bypass, -linked stereo, passive noise, rejected active noise, 8/44.1/48 kHz seams, and -a lateness that holds a ring accelerate would otherwise shorten, accelerates -one above the widened band, and raises the fast threshold with it. Both -implementations consume these exact vectors; generating expected output from -the implementation under test is not conformance. +output PCM, device rate and channels, buffered and target frame counts, +incoming cooldown, requested decision, and admitted lag (zero means hold). +Compare output within 1e-6 absolute sample amplitude. It includes hold, +cooldown, fast-mode bypass, linked stereo, passive noise, rejected active +noise, and 8/44.1/48 kHz seams. Both implementations consume these exact +vectors; generating expected output from the implementation under test is +not conformance. The vectors decide as native playback does, so the browser +grades its accelerate and fast seams against them, at an excess inside and +past the 20 ms band, and holds wherever native expands. ## Comfort noise diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/advertised.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/advertised.json index 0f389e764aa..553a70accf8 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/advertised.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/advertised.json @@ -1 +1 @@ -{"name":"advertised","about":"The same even sender as `paced`, with a publisher advertising a 200 ms flush span. The advertised value is a floor on the measured term, not an addition to it, so the target holds there instead of converging down.","frame":20,"advertised":200,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980],"target":[[0,220]],"lateness":[[0,0]]} +{"name":"advertised","about":"The same even sender as `paced`, with a publisher advertising a 200 ms flush span. The advertised value is a floor on the measured term, not an addition to it, so the target holds there instead of converging down.","frame":20,"advertised":200,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980],"target":[[0,220]]} diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/backlog.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/backlog.json index 158f49f3ec5..a76a36ad91b 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/backlog.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/backlog.json @@ -1 +1 @@ -{"name":"backlog","about":"The live edge, then the 1.5 s backlog behind it delivered newest first, then 30 s of even audio, as a subscription's start arrives. The backlog precedes every frame observed, so it is not measured, and the target stays near the frame duration.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,50.25,50.5,50.75,51,51.25,51.5,51.75,52,52.25,52.5,52.75,53,53.25,53.5,53.75,54,54.25,54.5,54.75,55,55.25,55.5,55.75,56,56.25,56.5,56.75,57,57.25,57.5,57.75,58,58.25,58.5,58.75,59,59.25,59.5,59.75,60,60.25,60.5,60.75,61,61.25,61.5,61.75,62,62.25,62.5,62.75,63,63.25,63.5,63.75,64,64.25,64.5,64.75,65,65.25,65.5,65.75,66,66.25,66.5,66.75,67,67.25,67.5,67.75,68,68.25,68.5,68.75,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030,20050,20070,20090,20110,20130,20150,20170,20190,20210,20230,20250,20270,20290,20310,20330,20350,20370,20390,20410,20430,20450,20470,20490,20510,20530,20550,20570,20590,20610,20630,20650,20670,20690,20710,20730,20750,20770,20790,20810,20830,20850,20870,20890,20910,20930,20950,20970,20990,21010,21030,21050,21070,21090,21110,21130,21150,21170,21190,21210,21230,21250,21270,21290,21310,21330,21350,21370,21390,21410,21430,21450,21470,21490,21510,21530,21550,21570,21590,21610,21630,21650,21670,21690,21710,21730,21750,21770,21790,21810,21830,21850,21870,21890,21910,21930,21950,21970,21990,22010,22030,22050,22070,22090,22110,22130,22150,22170,22190,22210,22230,22250,22270,22290,22310,22330,22350,22370,22390,22410,22430,22450,22470,22490,22510,22530,22550,22570,22590,22610,22630,22650,22670,22690,22710,22730,22750,22770,22790,22810,22830,22850,22870,22890,22910,22930,22950,22970,22990,23010,23030,23050,23070,23090,23110,23130,23150,23170,23190,23210,23230,23250,23270,23290,23310,23330,23350,23370,23390,23410,23430,23450,23470,23490,23510,23530,23550,23570,23590,23610,23630,23650,23670,23690,23710,23730,23750,23770,23790,23810,23830,23850,23870,23890,23910,23930,23950,23970,23990,24010,24030,24050,24070,24090,24110,24130,24150,24170,24190,24210,24230,24250,24270,24290,24310,24330,24350,24370,24390,24410,24430,24450,24470,24490,24510,24530,24550,24570,24590,24610,24630,24650,24670,24690,24710,24730,24750,24770,24790,24810,24830,24850,24870,24890,24910,24930,24950,24970,24990,25010,25030,25050,25070,25090,25110,25130,25150,25170,25190,25210,25230,25250,25270,25290,25310,25330,25350,25370,25390,25410,25430,25450,25470,25490,25510,25530,25550,25570,25590,25610,25630,25650,25670,25690,25710,25730,25750,25770,25790,25810,25830,25850,25870,25890,25910,25930,25950,25970,25990,26010,26030,26050,26070,26090,26110,26130,26150,26170,26190,26210,26230,26250,26270,26290,26310,26330,26350,26370,26390,26410,26430,26450,26470,26490,26510,26530,26550,26570,26590,26610,26630,26650,26670,26690,26710,26730,26750,26770,26790,26810,26830,26850,26870,26890,26910,26930,26950,26970,26990,27010,27030,27050,27070,27090,27110,27130,27150,27170,27190,27210,27230,27250,27270,27290,27310,27330,27350,27370,27390,27410,27430,27450,27470,27490,27510,27530,27550,27570,27590,27610,27630,27650,27670,27690,27710,27730,27750,27770,27790,27810,27830,27850,27870,27890,27910,27930,27950,27970,27990,28010,28030,28050,28070,28090,28110,28130,28150,28170,28190,28210,28230,28250,28270,28290,28310,28330,28350,28370,28390,28410,28430,28450,28470,28490,28510,28530,28550,28570,28590,28610,28630,28650,28670,28690,28710,28730,28750,28770,28790,28810,28830,28850,28870,28890,28910,28930,28950,28970,28990,29010,29030,29050,29070,29090,29110,29130,29150,29170,29190,29210,29230,29250,29270,29290,29310,29330,29350,29370,29390,29410,29430,29450,29470,29490,29510,29530,29550,29570,29590,29610,29630,29650,29670,29690,29710,29730,29750,29770,29790,29810,29830,29850,29870,29890,29910,29930,29950,29970,29990,30010,30030,30050],"media":[1500,1480,1460,1440,1420,1400,1380,1360,1340,1320,1300,1280,1260,1240,1220,1200,1180,1160,1140,1120,1100,1080,1060,1040,1020,1000,980,960,940,920,900,880,860,840,820,800,780,760,740,720,700,680,660,640,620,600,580,560,540,520,500,480,460,440,420,400,380,360,340,320,300,280,260,240,220,200,180,160,140,120,100,80,60,40,20,0,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,20000,20020,20040,20060,20080,20100,20120,20140,20160,20180,20200,20220,20240,20260,20280,20300,20320,20340,20360,20380,20400,20420,20440,20460,20480,20500,20520,20540,20560,20580,20600,20620,20640,20660,20680,20700,20720,20740,20760,20780,20800,20820,20840,20860,20880,20900,20920,20940,20960,20980,21000,21020,21040,21060,21080,21100,21120,21140,21160,21180,21200,21220,21240,21260,21280,21300,21320,21340,21360,21380,21400,21420,21440,21460,21480,21500,21520,21540,21560,21580,21600,21620,21640,21660,21680,21700,21720,21740,21760,21780,21800,21820,21840,21860,21880,21900,21920,21940,21960,21980,22000,22020,22040,22060,22080,22100,22120,22140,22160,22180,22200,22220,22240,22260,22280,22300,22320,22340,22360,22380,22400,22420,22440,22460,22480,22500,22520,22540,22560,22580,22600,22620,22640,22660,22680,22700,22720,22740,22760,22780,22800,22820,22840,22860,22880,22900,22920,22940,22960,22980,23000,23020,23040,23060,23080,23100,23120,23140,23160,23180,23200,23220,23240,23260,23280,23300,23320,23340,23360,23380,23400,23420,23440,23460,23480,23500,23520,23540,23560,23580,23600,23620,23640,23660,23680,23700,23720,23740,23760,23780,23800,23820,23840,23860,23880,23900,23920,23940,23960,23980,24000,24020,24040,24060,24080,24100,24120,24140,24160,24180,24200,24220,24240,24260,24280,24300,24320,24340,24360,24380,24400,24420,24440,24460,24480,24500,24520,24540,24560,24580,24600,24620,24640,24660,24680,24700,24720,24740,24760,24780,24800,24820,24840,24860,24880,24900,24920,24940,24960,24980,25000,25020,25040,25060,25080,25100,25120,25140,25160,25180,25200,25220,25240,25260,25280,25300,25320,25340,25360,25380,25400,25420,25440,25460,25480,25500,25520,25540,25560,25580,25600,25620,25640,25660,25680,25700,25720,25740,25760,25780,25800,25820,25840,25860,25880,25900,25920,25940,25960,25980,26000,26020,26040,26060,26080,26100,26120,26140,26160,26180,26200,26220,26240,26260,26280,26300,26320,26340,26360,26380,26400,26420,26440,26460,26480,26500,26520,26540,26560,26580,26600,26620,26640,26660,26680,26700,26720,26740,26760,26780,26800,26820,26840,26860,26880,26900,26920,26940,26960,26980,27000,27020,27040,27060,27080,27100,27120,27140,27160,27180,27200,27220,27240,27260,27280,27300,27320,27340,27360,27380,27400,27420,27440,27460,27480,27500,27520,27540,27560,27580,27600,27620,27640,27660,27680,27700,27720,27740,27760,27780,27800,27820,27840,27860,27880,27900,27920,27940,27960,27980,28000,28020,28040,28060,28080,28100,28120,28140,28160,28180,28200,28220,28240,28260,28280,28300,28320,28340,28360,28380,28400,28420,28440,28460,28480,28500,28520,28540,28560,28580,28600,28620,28640,28660,28680,28700,28720,28740,28760,28780,28800,28820,28840,28860,28880,28900,28920,28940,28960,28980,29000,29020,29040,29060,29080,29100,29120,29140,29160,29180,29200,29220,29240,29260,29280,29300,29320,29340,29360,29380,29400,29420,29440,29460,29480,29500,29520,29540,29560,29580,29600,29620,29640,29660,29680,29700,29720,29740,29760,29780,29800,29820,29840,29860,29880,29900,29920,29940,29960,29980,30000,30020,30040,30060,30080,30100,30120,30140,30160,30180,30200,30220,30240,30260,30280,30300,30320,30340,30360,30380,30400,30420,30440,30460,30480,30500,30520,30540,30560,30580,30600,30620,30640,30660,30680,30700,30720,30740,30760,30780,30800,30820,30840,30860,30880,30900,30920,30940,30960,30980,31000,31020,31040,31060,31080,31100,31120,31140,31160,31180,31200,31220,31240,31260,31280,31300,31320,31340,31360,31380,31400,31420,31440,31460,31480,31500],"target":[[0,120],[150,100],[250,80],[300,60],[325,40]],"lateness":[[0,0]]} +{"name":"backlog","about":"The live edge, then the 1.5 s backlog behind it delivered newest first, then 30 s of even audio, as a subscription's start arrives. The backlog precedes every frame observed, so it is not measured, and the target stays near the frame duration.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,50.25,50.5,50.75,51,51.25,51.5,51.75,52,52.25,52.5,52.75,53,53.25,53.5,53.75,54,54.25,54.5,54.75,55,55.25,55.5,55.75,56,56.25,56.5,56.75,57,57.25,57.5,57.75,58,58.25,58.5,58.75,59,59.25,59.5,59.75,60,60.25,60.5,60.75,61,61.25,61.5,61.75,62,62.25,62.5,62.75,63,63.25,63.5,63.75,64,64.25,64.5,64.75,65,65.25,65.5,65.75,66,66.25,66.5,66.75,67,67.25,67.5,67.75,68,68.25,68.5,68.75,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030,20050,20070,20090,20110,20130,20150,20170,20190,20210,20230,20250,20270,20290,20310,20330,20350,20370,20390,20410,20430,20450,20470,20490,20510,20530,20550,20570,20590,20610,20630,20650,20670,20690,20710,20730,20750,20770,20790,20810,20830,20850,20870,20890,20910,20930,20950,20970,20990,21010,21030,21050,21070,21090,21110,21130,21150,21170,21190,21210,21230,21250,21270,21290,21310,21330,21350,21370,21390,21410,21430,21450,21470,21490,21510,21530,21550,21570,21590,21610,21630,21650,21670,21690,21710,21730,21750,21770,21790,21810,21830,21850,21870,21890,21910,21930,21950,21970,21990,22010,22030,22050,22070,22090,22110,22130,22150,22170,22190,22210,22230,22250,22270,22290,22310,22330,22350,22370,22390,22410,22430,22450,22470,22490,22510,22530,22550,22570,22590,22610,22630,22650,22670,22690,22710,22730,22750,22770,22790,22810,22830,22850,22870,22890,22910,22930,22950,22970,22990,23010,23030,23050,23070,23090,23110,23130,23150,23170,23190,23210,23230,23250,23270,23290,23310,23330,23350,23370,23390,23410,23430,23450,23470,23490,23510,23530,23550,23570,23590,23610,23630,23650,23670,23690,23710,23730,23750,23770,23790,23810,23830,23850,23870,23890,23910,23930,23950,23970,23990,24010,24030,24050,24070,24090,24110,24130,24150,24170,24190,24210,24230,24250,24270,24290,24310,24330,24350,24370,24390,24410,24430,24450,24470,24490,24510,24530,24550,24570,24590,24610,24630,24650,24670,24690,24710,24730,24750,24770,24790,24810,24830,24850,24870,24890,24910,24930,24950,24970,24990,25010,25030,25050,25070,25090,25110,25130,25150,25170,25190,25210,25230,25250,25270,25290,25310,25330,25350,25370,25390,25410,25430,25450,25470,25490,25510,25530,25550,25570,25590,25610,25630,25650,25670,25690,25710,25730,25750,25770,25790,25810,25830,25850,25870,25890,25910,25930,25950,25970,25990,26010,26030,26050,26070,26090,26110,26130,26150,26170,26190,26210,26230,26250,26270,26290,26310,26330,26350,26370,26390,26410,26430,26450,26470,26490,26510,26530,26550,26570,26590,26610,26630,26650,26670,26690,26710,26730,26750,26770,26790,26810,26830,26850,26870,26890,26910,26930,26950,26970,26990,27010,27030,27050,27070,27090,27110,27130,27150,27170,27190,27210,27230,27250,27270,27290,27310,27330,27350,27370,27390,27410,27430,27450,27470,27490,27510,27530,27550,27570,27590,27610,27630,27650,27670,27690,27710,27730,27750,27770,27790,27810,27830,27850,27870,27890,27910,27930,27950,27970,27990,28010,28030,28050,28070,28090,28110,28130,28150,28170,28190,28210,28230,28250,28270,28290,28310,28330,28350,28370,28390,28410,28430,28450,28470,28490,28510,28530,28550,28570,28590,28610,28630,28650,28670,28690,28710,28730,28750,28770,28790,28810,28830,28850,28870,28890,28910,28930,28950,28970,28990,29010,29030,29050,29070,29090,29110,29130,29150,29170,29190,29210,29230,29250,29270,29290,29310,29330,29350,29370,29390,29410,29430,29450,29470,29490,29510,29530,29550,29570,29590,29610,29630,29650,29670,29690,29710,29730,29750,29770,29790,29810,29830,29850,29870,29890,29910,29930,29950,29970,29990,30010,30030,30050],"media":[1500,1480,1460,1440,1420,1400,1380,1360,1340,1320,1300,1280,1260,1240,1220,1200,1180,1160,1140,1120,1100,1080,1060,1040,1020,1000,980,960,940,920,900,880,860,840,820,800,780,760,740,720,700,680,660,640,620,600,580,560,540,520,500,480,460,440,420,400,380,360,340,320,300,280,260,240,220,200,180,160,140,120,100,80,60,40,20,0,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,20000,20020,20040,20060,20080,20100,20120,20140,20160,20180,20200,20220,20240,20260,20280,20300,20320,20340,20360,20380,20400,20420,20440,20460,20480,20500,20520,20540,20560,20580,20600,20620,20640,20660,20680,20700,20720,20740,20760,20780,20800,20820,20840,20860,20880,20900,20920,20940,20960,20980,21000,21020,21040,21060,21080,21100,21120,21140,21160,21180,21200,21220,21240,21260,21280,21300,21320,21340,21360,21380,21400,21420,21440,21460,21480,21500,21520,21540,21560,21580,21600,21620,21640,21660,21680,21700,21720,21740,21760,21780,21800,21820,21840,21860,21880,21900,21920,21940,21960,21980,22000,22020,22040,22060,22080,22100,22120,22140,22160,22180,22200,22220,22240,22260,22280,22300,22320,22340,22360,22380,22400,22420,22440,22460,22480,22500,22520,22540,22560,22580,22600,22620,22640,22660,22680,22700,22720,22740,22760,22780,22800,22820,22840,22860,22880,22900,22920,22940,22960,22980,23000,23020,23040,23060,23080,23100,23120,23140,23160,23180,23200,23220,23240,23260,23280,23300,23320,23340,23360,23380,23400,23420,23440,23460,23480,23500,23520,23540,23560,23580,23600,23620,23640,23660,23680,23700,23720,23740,23760,23780,23800,23820,23840,23860,23880,23900,23920,23940,23960,23980,24000,24020,24040,24060,24080,24100,24120,24140,24160,24180,24200,24220,24240,24260,24280,24300,24320,24340,24360,24380,24400,24420,24440,24460,24480,24500,24520,24540,24560,24580,24600,24620,24640,24660,24680,24700,24720,24740,24760,24780,24800,24820,24840,24860,24880,24900,24920,24940,24960,24980,25000,25020,25040,25060,25080,25100,25120,25140,25160,25180,25200,25220,25240,25260,25280,25300,25320,25340,25360,25380,25400,25420,25440,25460,25480,25500,25520,25540,25560,25580,25600,25620,25640,25660,25680,25700,25720,25740,25760,25780,25800,25820,25840,25860,25880,25900,25920,25940,25960,25980,26000,26020,26040,26060,26080,26100,26120,26140,26160,26180,26200,26220,26240,26260,26280,26300,26320,26340,26360,26380,26400,26420,26440,26460,26480,26500,26520,26540,26560,26580,26600,26620,26640,26660,26680,26700,26720,26740,26760,26780,26800,26820,26840,26860,26880,26900,26920,26940,26960,26980,27000,27020,27040,27060,27080,27100,27120,27140,27160,27180,27200,27220,27240,27260,27280,27300,27320,27340,27360,27380,27400,27420,27440,27460,27480,27500,27520,27540,27560,27580,27600,27620,27640,27660,27680,27700,27720,27740,27760,27780,27800,27820,27840,27860,27880,27900,27920,27940,27960,27980,28000,28020,28040,28060,28080,28100,28120,28140,28160,28180,28200,28220,28240,28260,28280,28300,28320,28340,28360,28380,28400,28420,28440,28460,28480,28500,28520,28540,28560,28580,28600,28620,28640,28660,28680,28700,28720,28740,28760,28780,28800,28820,28840,28860,28880,28900,28920,28940,28960,28980,29000,29020,29040,29060,29080,29100,29120,29140,29160,29180,29200,29220,29240,29260,29280,29300,29320,29340,29360,29380,29400,29420,29440,29460,29480,29500,29520,29540,29560,29580,29600,29620,29640,29660,29680,29700,29720,29740,29760,29780,29800,29820,29840,29860,29880,29900,29920,29940,29960,29980,30000,30020,30040,30060,30080,30100,30120,30140,30160,30180,30200,30220,30240,30260,30280,30300,30320,30340,30360,30380,30400,30420,30440,30460,30480,30500,30520,30540,30560,30580,30600,30620,30640,30660,30680,30700,30720,30740,30760,30780,30800,30820,30840,30860,30880,30900,30920,30940,30960,30980,31000,31020,31040,31060,31080,31100,31120,31140,31160,31180,31200,31220,31240,31260,31280,31300,31320,31340,31360,31380,31400,31420,31440,31460,31480,31500],"target":[[0,120],[150,100],[250,80],[300,60],[325,40]]} diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/buildup.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/buildup.json index da61d5ef4ae..e082799c56e 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/buildup.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/buildup.json @@ -1 +1 @@ -{"name":"buildup","about":"A queue filling at 2 ms per frame for 2 s, then holding. An inter-arrival estimator reads a hundred tiny observations; this reads the delay climbing against the fastest recent frame.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5052,5074,5096,5118,5140,5162,5184,5206,5228,5250,5272,5294,5316,5338,5360,5382,5404,5426,5448,5470,5492,5514,5536,5558,5580,5602,5624,5646,5668,5690,5712,5734,5756,5778,5800,5822,5844,5866,5888,5910,5932,5954,5976,5998,6020,6042,6064,6086,6108,6130,6152,6174,6196,6218,6240,6262,6284,6306,6328,6350,6372,6394,6416,6438,6460,6482,6504,6526,6548,6570,6592,6614,6636,6658,6680,6702,6724,6746,6768,6790,6812,6834,6856,6878,6900,6922,6944,6966,6988,7010,7032,7054,7076,7098,7120,7142,7164,7186,7208,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030,20050,20070,20090,20110,20130,20150,20170,20190,20210,20230,20250,20270,20290,20310,20330,20350,20370,20390,20410,20430,20450,20470,20490,20510,20530,20550,20570,20590,20610,20630,20650,20670,20690,20710,20730,20750,20770,20790,20810,20830,20850,20870,20890,20910,20930,20950,20970,20990,21010,21030,21050,21070,21090,21110,21130,21150,21170,21190,21210,21230,21250,21270,21290,21310,21330,21350,21370,21390,21410,21430,21450,21470,21490,21510,21530,21550,21570,21590,21610,21630,21650,21670,21690,21710,21730,21750,21770,21790,21810,21830,21850,21870,21890,21910,21930,21950,21970,21990,22010,22030,22050,22070,22090,22110,22130,22150,22170,22190,22210,22230,22250,22270,22290,22310,22330,22350,22370,22390,22410,22430,22450,22470,22490,22510,22530,22550,22570,22590,22610,22630,22650,22670,22690,22710,22730,22750,22770,22790,22810,22830,22850,22870,22890,22910,22930,22950,22970,22990,23010,23030,23050,23070,23090,23110,23130,23150,23170,23190,23210,23230,23250,23270,23290,23310,23330,23350,23370,23390,23410,23430,23450,23470,23490,23510,23530,23550,23570,23590,23610,23630,23650,23670,23690,23710,23730,23750,23770,23790,23810,23830,23850,23870,23890,23910,23930,23950,23970,23990,24010,24030,24050,24070,24090,24110,24130,24150,24170,24190,24210,24230,24250,24270,24290,24310,24330,24350,24370,24390,24410,24430,24450,24470,24490,24510,24530,24550,24570,24590,24610,24630,24650,24670,24690,24710,24730,24750,24770,24790,24810,24830,24850,24870,24890,24910,24930,24950,24970,24990,25010,25030,25050,25070,25090,25110,25130,25150,25170,25190,25210,25230,25250,25270,25290,25310,25330,25350,25370,25390,25410,25430,25450,25470,25490,25510,25530,25550,25570,25590,25610,25630,25650,25670,25690,25710,25730,25750,25770,25790,25810,25830,25850,25870,25890,25910,25930,25950,25970,25990,26010,26030,26050,26070,26090,26110,26130,26150,26170,26190,26210,26230,26250,26270,26290,26310,26330,26350,26370,26390,26410,26430,26450,26470,26490,26510,26530,26550,26570,26590,26610,26630,26650,26670,26690,26710,26730,26750,26770,26790,26810,26830,26850,26870,26890,26910,26930,26950,26970,26990,27010,27030,27050,27070,27090,27110,27130,27150,27170,27190,27210,27230,27250,27270,27290,27310,27330,27350,27370,27390,27410,27430,27450,27470,27490,27510,27530,27550,27570,27590,27610,27630,27650,27670,27690,27710,27730,27750,27770,27790,27810,27830,27850,27870,27890,27910,27930,27950,27970,27990,28010,28030,28050,28070,28090,28110,28130,28150,28170,28190,28210,28230,28250,28270,28290,28310,28330,28350,28370,28390,28410,28430,28450,28470,28490,28510,28530,28550,28570,28590,28610,28630,28650,28670,28690,28710,28730,28750,28770,28790,28810,28830,28850,28870,28890,28910,28930,28950,28970,28990,29010,29030,29050,29070,29090,29110,29130,29150,29170,29190,29210,29230,29250,29270,29290,29310,29330,29350,29370,29390,29410,29430,29450,29470,29490,29510,29530,29550,29570,29590,29610,29630,29650,29670,29690,29710,29730,29750,29770,29790,29810,29830,29850,29870,29890,29910,29930,29950,29970,29990,30010,30030,30050,30070,30090,30110,30130,30150,30170,30190,30210,30230],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,20000,20020,20040,20060,20080,20100,20120,20140,20160,20180,20200,20220,20240,20260,20280,20300,20320,20340,20360,20380,20400,20420,20440,20460,20480,20500,20520,20540,20560,20580,20600,20620,20640,20660,20680,20700,20720,20740,20760,20780,20800,20820,20840,20860,20880,20900,20920,20940,20960,20980,21000,21020,21040,21060,21080,21100,21120,21140,21160,21180,21200,21220,21240,21260,21280,21300,21320,21340,21360,21380,21400,21420,21440,21460,21480,21500,21520,21540,21560,21580,21600,21620,21640,21660,21680,21700,21720,21740,21760,21780,21800,21820,21840,21860,21880,21900,21920,21940,21960,21980,22000,22020,22040,22060,22080,22100,22120,22140,22160,22180,22200,22220,22240,22260,22280,22300,22320,22340,22360,22380,22400,22420,22440,22460,22480,22500,22520,22540,22560,22580,22600,22620,22640,22660,22680,22700,22720,22740,22760,22780,22800,22820,22840,22860,22880,22900,22920,22940,22960,22980,23000,23020,23040,23060,23080,23100,23120,23140,23160,23180,23200,23220,23240,23260,23280,23300,23320,23340,23360,23380,23400,23420,23440,23460,23480,23500,23520,23540,23560,23580,23600,23620,23640,23660,23680,23700,23720,23740,23760,23780,23800,23820,23840,23860,23880,23900,23920,23940,23960,23980,24000,24020,24040,24060,24080,24100,24120,24140,24160,24180,24200,24220,24240,24260,24280,24300,24320,24340,24360,24380,24400,24420,24440,24460,24480,24500,24520,24540,24560,24580,24600,24620,24640,24660,24680,24700,24720,24740,24760,24780,24800,24820,24840,24860,24880,24900,24920,24940,24960,24980,25000,25020,25040,25060,25080,25100,25120,25140,25160,25180,25200,25220,25240,25260,25280,25300,25320,25340,25360,25380,25400,25420,25440,25460,25480,25500,25520,25540,25560,25580,25600,25620,25640,25660,25680,25700,25720,25740,25760,25780,25800,25820,25840,25860,25880,25900,25920,25940,25960,25980,26000,26020,26040,26060,26080,26100,26120,26140,26160,26180,26200,26220,26240,26260,26280,26300,26320,26340,26360,26380,26400,26420,26440,26460,26480,26500,26520,26540,26560,26580,26600,26620,26640,26660,26680,26700,26720,26740,26760,26780,26800,26820,26840,26860,26880,26900,26920,26940,26960,26980,27000,27020,27040,27060,27080,27100,27120,27140,27160,27180,27200,27220,27240,27260,27280,27300,27320,27340,27360,27380,27400,27420,27440,27460,27480,27500,27520,27540,27560,27580,27600,27620,27640,27660,27680,27700,27720,27740,27760,27780,27800,27820,27840,27860,27880,27900,27920,27940,27960,27980,28000,28020,28040,28060,28080,28100,28120,28140,28160,28180,28200,28220,28240,28260,28280,28300,28320,28340,28360,28380,28400,28420,28440,28460,28480,28500,28520,28540,28560,28580,28600,28620,28640,28660,28680,28700,28720,28740,28760,28780,28800,28820,28840,28860,28880,28900,28920,28940,28960,28980,29000,29020,29040,29060,29080,29100,29120,29140,29160,29180,29200,29220,29240,29260,29280,29300,29320,29340,29360,29380,29400,29420,29440,29460,29480,29500,29520,29540,29560,29580,29600,29620,29640,29660,29680,29700,29720,29740,29760,29780,29800,29820,29840,29860,29880,29900,29920,29940,29960,29980],"target":[[0,120],[75,100],[175,80],[225,60],[250,40],[273,80],[341,120],[365,160],[390,200],[415,160],[815,140],[1140,120],[1415,100]],"lateness":[[0,0],[250,2],[251,4],[252,6],[253,8],[254,10],[255,12],[256,14],[257,16],[258,18],[259,20],[260,22],[261,24],[262,26],[263,28],[264,30],[265,32],[266,34],[267,36],[268,38],[269,40],[270,42],[271,44],[272,46],[273,48],[274,50],[275,52],[276,54],[277,56],[278,58],[279,60],[280,62],[281,64],[282,66],[283,68],[284,70],[285,72],[286,74],[287,76],[288,78],[289,80],[290,82],[291,84],[292,86],[293,88],[294,90],[295,92],[296,94],[297,96],[298,98],[299,100],[300,102],[301,104],[302,106],[303,108],[304,110],[305,112],[306,114],[307,116],[308,118],[309,120],[310,122],[311,124],[312,126],[313,128],[314,130],[315,132],[316,134],[317,136],[318,138],[319,140],[320,142],[321,144],[322,146],[323,148],[324,150],[325,152],[326,154],[327,156],[328,158],[329,160],[330,162],[331,164],[332,166],[333,168],[334,170],[335,172],[336,174],[337,176],[338,178],[339,180],[340,182],[341,184],[342,186],[343,188],[344,190],[345,192],[346,194],[347,196],[348,198],[349,200],[350,198],[351,196],[352,194],[353,192],[354,190],[355,188],[356,186],[357,184],[358,182],[359,180],[360,178],[361,176],[362,174],[363,172],[364,170],[365,168],[366,166],[367,164],[368,162],[369,160],[370,158],[371,156],[372,154],[373,152],[374,150],[375,148],[376,146],[377,144],[378,142],[379,140],[380,138],[381,136],[382,134],[383,132],[384,130],[385,128],[386,126],[387,124],[388,122],[389,120],[390,118],[391,116],[392,114],[393,112],[394,110],[395,108],[396,106],[397,104],[398,102],[399,100],[400,98],[401,96],[402,94],[403,92],[404,90],[405,88],[406,86],[407,84],[408,82],[409,80],[410,78],[411,76],[412,74],[413,72],[414,70],[415,68],[416,66],[417,64],[418,62],[419,60],[420,58],[421,56],[422,54],[423,52],[424,50],[425,48],[426,46],[427,44],[428,42],[429,40],[430,38],[431,36],[432,34],[433,32],[434,30],[435,28],[436,26],[437,24],[438,22],[439,20],[440,18],[441,16],[442,14],[443,12],[444,10],[445,8],[446,6],[447,4],[448,2],[449,0]]} +{"name":"buildup","about":"A queue filling at 2 ms per frame for 2 s, then holding. An inter-arrival estimator reads a hundred tiny observations; this reads the delay climbing against the fastest recent frame.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5052,5074,5096,5118,5140,5162,5184,5206,5228,5250,5272,5294,5316,5338,5360,5382,5404,5426,5448,5470,5492,5514,5536,5558,5580,5602,5624,5646,5668,5690,5712,5734,5756,5778,5800,5822,5844,5866,5888,5910,5932,5954,5976,5998,6020,6042,6064,6086,6108,6130,6152,6174,6196,6218,6240,6262,6284,6306,6328,6350,6372,6394,6416,6438,6460,6482,6504,6526,6548,6570,6592,6614,6636,6658,6680,6702,6724,6746,6768,6790,6812,6834,6856,6878,6900,6922,6944,6966,6988,7010,7032,7054,7076,7098,7120,7142,7164,7186,7208,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030,20050,20070,20090,20110,20130,20150,20170,20190,20210,20230,20250,20270,20290,20310,20330,20350,20370,20390,20410,20430,20450,20470,20490,20510,20530,20550,20570,20590,20610,20630,20650,20670,20690,20710,20730,20750,20770,20790,20810,20830,20850,20870,20890,20910,20930,20950,20970,20990,21010,21030,21050,21070,21090,21110,21130,21150,21170,21190,21210,21230,21250,21270,21290,21310,21330,21350,21370,21390,21410,21430,21450,21470,21490,21510,21530,21550,21570,21590,21610,21630,21650,21670,21690,21710,21730,21750,21770,21790,21810,21830,21850,21870,21890,21910,21930,21950,21970,21990,22010,22030,22050,22070,22090,22110,22130,22150,22170,22190,22210,22230,22250,22270,22290,22310,22330,22350,22370,22390,22410,22430,22450,22470,22490,22510,22530,22550,22570,22590,22610,22630,22650,22670,22690,22710,22730,22750,22770,22790,22810,22830,22850,22870,22890,22910,22930,22950,22970,22990,23010,23030,23050,23070,23090,23110,23130,23150,23170,23190,23210,23230,23250,23270,23290,23310,23330,23350,23370,23390,23410,23430,23450,23470,23490,23510,23530,23550,23570,23590,23610,23630,23650,23670,23690,23710,23730,23750,23770,23790,23810,23830,23850,23870,23890,23910,23930,23950,23970,23990,24010,24030,24050,24070,24090,24110,24130,24150,24170,24190,24210,24230,24250,24270,24290,24310,24330,24350,24370,24390,24410,24430,24450,24470,24490,24510,24530,24550,24570,24590,24610,24630,24650,24670,24690,24710,24730,24750,24770,24790,24810,24830,24850,24870,24890,24910,24930,24950,24970,24990,25010,25030,25050,25070,25090,25110,25130,25150,25170,25190,25210,25230,25250,25270,25290,25310,25330,25350,25370,25390,25410,25430,25450,25470,25490,25510,25530,25550,25570,25590,25610,25630,25650,25670,25690,25710,25730,25750,25770,25790,25810,25830,25850,25870,25890,25910,25930,25950,25970,25990,26010,26030,26050,26070,26090,26110,26130,26150,26170,26190,26210,26230,26250,26270,26290,26310,26330,26350,26370,26390,26410,26430,26450,26470,26490,26510,26530,26550,26570,26590,26610,26630,26650,26670,26690,26710,26730,26750,26770,26790,26810,26830,26850,26870,26890,26910,26930,26950,26970,26990,27010,27030,27050,27070,27090,27110,27130,27150,27170,27190,27210,27230,27250,27270,27290,27310,27330,27350,27370,27390,27410,27430,27450,27470,27490,27510,27530,27550,27570,27590,27610,27630,27650,27670,27690,27710,27730,27750,27770,27790,27810,27830,27850,27870,27890,27910,27930,27950,27970,27990,28010,28030,28050,28070,28090,28110,28130,28150,28170,28190,28210,28230,28250,28270,28290,28310,28330,28350,28370,28390,28410,28430,28450,28470,28490,28510,28530,28550,28570,28590,28610,28630,28650,28670,28690,28710,28730,28750,28770,28790,28810,28830,28850,28870,28890,28910,28930,28950,28970,28990,29010,29030,29050,29070,29090,29110,29130,29150,29170,29190,29210,29230,29250,29270,29290,29310,29330,29350,29370,29390,29410,29430,29450,29470,29490,29510,29530,29550,29570,29590,29610,29630,29650,29670,29690,29710,29730,29750,29770,29790,29810,29830,29850,29870,29890,29910,29930,29950,29970,29990,30010,30030,30050,30070,30090,30110,30130,30150,30170,30190,30210,30230],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,20000,20020,20040,20060,20080,20100,20120,20140,20160,20180,20200,20220,20240,20260,20280,20300,20320,20340,20360,20380,20400,20420,20440,20460,20480,20500,20520,20540,20560,20580,20600,20620,20640,20660,20680,20700,20720,20740,20760,20780,20800,20820,20840,20860,20880,20900,20920,20940,20960,20980,21000,21020,21040,21060,21080,21100,21120,21140,21160,21180,21200,21220,21240,21260,21280,21300,21320,21340,21360,21380,21400,21420,21440,21460,21480,21500,21520,21540,21560,21580,21600,21620,21640,21660,21680,21700,21720,21740,21760,21780,21800,21820,21840,21860,21880,21900,21920,21940,21960,21980,22000,22020,22040,22060,22080,22100,22120,22140,22160,22180,22200,22220,22240,22260,22280,22300,22320,22340,22360,22380,22400,22420,22440,22460,22480,22500,22520,22540,22560,22580,22600,22620,22640,22660,22680,22700,22720,22740,22760,22780,22800,22820,22840,22860,22880,22900,22920,22940,22960,22980,23000,23020,23040,23060,23080,23100,23120,23140,23160,23180,23200,23220,23240,23260,23280,23300,23320,23340,23360,23380,23400,23420,23440,23460,23480,23500,23520,23540,23560,23580,23600,23620,23640,23660,23680,23700,23720,23740,23760,23780,23800,23820,23840,23860,23880,23900,23920,23940,23960,23980,24000,24020,24040,24060,24080,24100,24120,24140,24160,24180,24200,24220,24240,24260,24280,24300,24320,24340,24360,24380,24400,24420,24440,24460,24480,24500,24520,24540,24560,24580,24600,24620,24640,24660,24680,24700,24720,24740,24760,24780,24800,24820,24840,24860,24880,24900,24920,24940,24960,24980,25000,25020,25040,25060,25080,25100,25120,25140,25160,25180,25200,25220,25240,25260,25280,25300,25320,25340,25360,25380,25400,25420,25440,25460,25480,25500,25520,25540,25560,25580,25600,25620,25640,25660,25680,25700,25720,25740,25760,25780,25800,25820,25840,25860,25880,25900,25920,25940,25960,25980,26000,26020,26040,26060,26080,26100,26120,26140,26160,26180,26200,26220,26240,26260,26280,26300,26320,26340,26360,26380,26400,26420,26440,26460,26480,26500,26520,26540,26560,26580,26600,26620,26640,26660,26680,26700,26720,26740,26760,26780,26800,26820,26840,26860,26880,26900,26920,26940,26960,26980,27000,27020,27040,27060,27080,27100,27120,27140,27160,27180,27200,27220,27240,27260,27280,27300,27320,27340,27360,27380,27400,27420,27440,27460,27480,27500,27520,27540,27560,27580,27600,27620,27640,27660,27680,27700,27720,27740,27760,27780,27800,27820,27840,27860,27880,27900,27920,27940,27960,27980,28000,28020,28040,28060,28080,28100,28120,28140,28160,28180,28200,28220,28240,28260,28280,28300,28320,28340,28360,28380,28400,28420,28440,28460,28480,28500,28520,28540,28560,28580,28600,28620,28640,28660,28680,28700,28720,28740,28760,28780,28800,28820,28840,28860,28880,28900,28920,28940,28960,28980,29000,29020,29040,29060,29080,29100,29120,29140,29160,29180,29200,29220,29240,29260,29280,29300,29320,29340,29360,29380,29400,29420,29440,29460,29480,29500,29520,29540,29560,29580,29600,29620,29640,29660,29680,29700,29720,29740,29760,29780,29800,29820,29840,29860,29880,29900,29920,29940,29960,29980],"target":[[0,120],[75,100],[175,80],[225,60],[250,40],[273,80],[341,120],[365,160],[390,200],[415,160],[815,140],[1140,120],[1415,100]]} diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/corpus.test.ts b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/corpus.test.ts index 7020b299fc0..93f7a19e366 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/corpus.test.ts +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/corpus.test.ts @@ -36,10 +36,6 @@ describe("audio jitter corpus", () => { expect(actual.target[0]?.[0]).toBe(0); }); - test("names a lateness for the first frame", () => { - expect(actual.lateness[0]?.[0]).toBe(0); - }); - test("reports every target as a change", () => { let previous: number | undefined; let last = -1; diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/corpus.ts b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/corpus.ts index dac0cc35f25..299328f8170 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/corpus.ts +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/corpus.ts @@ -28,8 +28,6 @@ export interface Case { ends?: number[]; /** `[frame index, target]` wherever the target differs from the previous frame's. */ target: [number, number][]; - /** `[frame index, lateness]` wherever the lateness differs from the previous frame's. */ - lateness: [number, number][]; } type Trace = { arrival: number[]; media: number[] }; @@ -90,32 +88,32 @@ function paced(frames: number, frame: number, base: number): Trace { return flushed(frames, frame, 1, base); } -/** Replay a trace through the reference and keep only the frames where the target or lateness moved. */ +/** Replay a trace through the reference and keep only the frames where the target moved. */ function run( trace: Trace & { ends?: number[] }, config: { frame: number; advertised?: number; delay?: number }, -): Pick { - // A fixed target ignores the arrivals, so its band is not widened either. - if (config.delay !== undefined) return { target: [[0, config.delay]], lateness: [[0, 0]] }; +): [number, number][] { + if (config.delay !== undefined) return [[0, config.delay]]; const estimator = new Estimator({ frame: config.frame, advertised: config.advertised }); const target: [number, number][] = []; - const lateness: [number, number][] = []; + let previous: number | undefined; const ends = new Set(trace.ends); for (let i = 0; i < trace.arrival.length; i++) { if (ends.has(i)) estimator.end(); estimator.observe({ arrival: trace.arrival[i], media: trace.media[i] }); - if (estimator.target !== target.at(-1)?.[1]) target.push([i, estimator.target]); - if (estimator.lateness !== lateness.at(-1)?.[1]) lateness.push([i, estimator.lateness]); + const value = estimator.target; + if (value !== previous) target.push([i, value]); + previous = value; } - return { target, lateness }; + return target; } const FRAME = 20; -const traces: Omit[] = [ +const traces: Omit[] = [ { name: "paced", about: "A perfectly even sender for 60 s, long enough to leave the cold-start ramp. The target settles on one bucket plus one frame, which is the floor the estimator can report.", @@ -239,7 +237,7 @@ const traces: Omit[] = [ }, ]; -export const cases: Case[] = traces.map((trace) => ({ ...trace, ...run(trace, trace) })); +export const cases: Case[] = traces.map((trace) => ({ ...trace, target: run(trace, trace) })); if (import.meta.main) { const here = dirname(fileURLToPath(import.meta.url)); diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/fixed.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/fixed.json index 46de52fb57a..2c1309b6322 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/fixed.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/fixed.json @@ -1 +1 @@ -{"name":"fixed","about":"An explicit 250 ms target over the bursty trace. Adaptation is off: the target is what was asked for, whatever the arrivals say.","frame":20,"delay":250,"arrival":[130,130,130,130,130,230,230,230,230,230,330,330,330,330,330,430,430,430,430,430,530,530,530,530,530,630,630,630,630,630,730,730,730,730,730,830,830,830,830,830,930,930,930,930,930,1030,1030,1030,1030,1030,1130,1130,1130,1130,1130,1230,1230,1230,1230,1230,1330,1330,1330,1330,1330,1430,1430,1430,1430,1430,1530,1530,1530,1530,1530,1630,1630,1630,1630,1630,1730,1730,1730,1730,1730,1830,1830,1830,1830,1830,1930,1930,1930,1930,1930,2030,2030,2030,2030,2030,2130,2130,2130,2130,2130,2230,2230,2230,2230,2230,2330,2330,2330,2330,2330,2430,2430,2430,2430,2430,2530,2530,2530,2530,2530,2630,2630,2630,2630,2630,2730,2730,2730,2730,2730,2830,2830,2830,2830,2830,2930,2930,2930,2930,2930,3030,3030,3030,3030,3030,3130,3130,3130,3130,3130,3230,3230,3230,3230,3230,3330,3330,3330,3330,3330,3430,3430,3430,3430,3430,3530,3530,3530,3530,3530,3630,3630,3630,3630,3630,3730,3730,3730,3730,3730,3830,3830,3830,3830,3830,3930,3930,3930,3930,3930,4030,4030,4030,4030,4030,4130,4130,4130,4130,4130,4230,4230,4230,4230,4230,4330,4330,4330,4330,4330,4430,4430,4430,4430,4430,4530,4530,4530,4530,4530,4630,4630,4630,4630,4630,4730,4730,4730,4730,4730,4830,4830,4830,4830,4830,4930,4930,4930,4930,4930,5030,5030,5030,5030,5030,5130,5130,5130,5130,5130,5230,5230,5230,5230,5230,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5430,5430,5430,5430,5430,5530,5530,5530,5530,5530,5630,5630,5630,5630,5630,5730,5730,5730,5730,5730,5830,5830,5830,5830,5830,5930,5930,5930,5930,5930,6030,6030,6030,6030,6030,6130,6130,6130,6130,6130,6230,6230,6230,6230,6230,6330,6330,6330,6330,6330,6430,6430,6430,6430,6430,6530,6530,6530,6530,6530,6630,6630,6630,6630,6630,6730,6730,6730,6730,6730,6830,6830,6830,6830,6830,6930,6930,6930,6930,6930,7030,7030,7030,7030,7030,7130,7130,7130,7130,7130,7230,7230,7230,7230,7230,7330,7330,7330,7330,7330,7430,7430,7430,7430,7430,7530,7530,7530,7530,7530,7630,7630,7630,7630,7630,7730,7730,7730,7730,7730,7830,7830,7830,7830,7830,7930,7930,7930,7930,7930,8030,8030,8030,8030,8030,8130,8130,8130,8130,8130,8230,8230,8230,8230,8230,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8430,8430,8430,8430,8430,8530,8530,8530,8530,8530,8630,8630,8630,8630,8630,8730,8730,8730,8730,8730,8830,8830,8830,8830,8830,8930,8930,8930,8930,8930,9030,9030,9030,9030,9030,9130,9130,9130,9130,9130,9230,9230,9230,9230,9230,9330,9330,9330,9330,9330,9430,9430,9430,9430,9430,9530,9530,9530,9530,9530,9630,9630,9630,9630,9630,9730,9730,9730,9730,9730,9830,9830,9830,9830,9830,9930,9930,9930,9930,9930,10030,10030,10030,10030,10030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980],"target":[[0,250]],"lateness":[[0,0]]} +{"name":"fixed","about":"An explicit 250 ms target over the bursty trace. Adaptation is off: the target is what was asked for, whatever the arrivals say.","frame":20,"delay":250,"arrival":[130,130,130,130,130,230,230,230,230,230,330,330,330,330,330,430,430,430,430,430,530,530,530,530,530,630,630,630,630,630,730,730,730,730,730,830,830,830,830,830,930,930,930,930,930,1030,1030,1030,1030,1030,1130,1130,1130,1130,1130,1230,1230,1230,1230,1230,1330,1330,1330,1330,1330,1430,1430,1430,1430,1430,1530,1530,1530,1530,1530,1630,1630,1630,1630,1630,1730,1730,1730,1730,1730,1830,1830,1830,1830,1830,1930,1930,1930,1930,1930,2030,2030,2030,2030,2030,2130,2130,2130,2130,2130,2230,2230,2230,2230,2230,2330,2330,2330,2330,2330,2430,2430,2430,2430,2430,2530,2530,2530,2530,2530,2630,2630,2630,2630,2630,2730,2730,2730,2730,2730,2830,2830,2830,2830,2830,2930,2930,2930,2930,2930,3030,3030,3030,3030,3030,3130,3130,3130,3130,3130,3230,3230,3230,3230,3230,3330,3330,3330,3330,3330,3430,3430,3430,3430,3430,3530,3530,3530,3530,3530,3630,3630,3630,3630,3630,3730,3730,3730,3730,3730,3830,3830,3830,3830,3830,3930,3930,3930,3930,3930,4030,4030,4030,4030,4030,4130,4130,4130,4130,4130,4230,4230,4230,4230,4230,4330,4330,4330,4330,4330,4430,4430,4430,4430,4430,4530,4530,4530,4530,4530,4630,4630,4630,4630,4630,4730,4730,4730,4730,4730,4830,4830,4830,4830,4830,4930,4930,4930,4930,4930,5030,5030,5030,5030,5030,5130,5130,5130,5130,5130,5230,5230,5230,5230,5230,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5430,5430,5430,5430,5430,5530,5530,5530,5530,5530,5630,5630,5630,5630,5630,5730,5730,5730,5730,5730,5830,5830,5830,5830,5830,5930,5930,5930,5930,5930,6030,6030,6030,6030,6030,6130,6130,6130,6130,6130,6230,6230,6230,6230,6230,6330,6330,6330,6330,6330,6430,6430,6430,6430,6430,6530,6530,6530,6530,6530,6630,6630,6630,6630,6630,6730,6730,6730,6730,6730,6830,6830,6830,6830,6830,6930,6930,6930,6930,6930,7030,7030,7030,7030,7030,7130,7130,7130,7130,7130,7230,7230,7230,7230,7230,7330,7330,7330,7330,7330,7430,7430,7430,7430,7430,7530,7530,7530,7530,7530,7630,7630,7630,7630,7630,7730,7730,7730,7730,7730,7830,7830,7830,7830,7830,7930,7930,7930,7930,7930,8030,8030,8030,8030,8030,8130,8130,8130,8130,8130,8230,8230,8230,8230,8230,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8430,8430,8430,8430,8430,8530,8530,8530,8530,8530,8630,8630,8630,8630,8630,8730,8730,8730,8730,8730,8830,8830,8830,8830,8830,8930,8930,8930,8930,8930,9030,9030,9030,9030,9030,9130,9130,9130,9130,9130,9230,9230,9230,9230,9230,9330,9330,9330,9330,9330,9430,9430,9430,9430,9430,9530,9530,9530,9530,9530,9630,9630,9630,9630,9630,9730,9730,9730,9730,9730,9830,9830,9830,9830,9830,9930,9930,9930,9930,9930,10030,10030,10030,10030,10030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980],"target":[[0,250]]} diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/flush.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/flush.json index 42c6d3331cb..f649af7a2c8 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/flush.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/flush.json @@ -1 +1 @@ -{"name":"flush","about":"A sender flushing 100 ms of media at a time, then 200 ms from halfway. The measured term follows the flush span less one frame, which is what the round-trip formula could not see.","frame":20,"arrival":[130,130,130,130,130,230,230,230,230,230,330,330,330,330,330,430,430,430,430,430,530,530,530,530,530,630,630,630,630,630,730,730,730,730,730,830,830,830,830,830,930,930,930,930,930,1030,1030,1030,1030,1030,1130,1130,1130,1130,1130,1230,1230,1230,1230,1230,1330,1330,1330,1330,1330,1430,1430,1430,1430,1430,1530,1530,1530,1530,1530,1630,1630,1630,1630,1630,1730,1730,1730,1730,1730,1830,1830,1830,1830,1830,1930,1930,1930,1930,1930,2030,2030,2030,2030,2030,2130,2130,2130,2130,2130,2230,2230,2230,2230,2230,2330,2330,2330,2330,2330,2430,2430,2430,2430,2430,2530,2530,2530,2530,2530,2630,2630,2630,2630,2630,2730,2730,2730,2730,2730,2830,2830,2830,2830,2830,2930,2930,2930,2930,2930,3030,3030,3030,3030,3030,3130,3130,3130,3130,3130,3230,3230,3230,3230,3230,3330,3330,3330,3330,3330,3430,3430,3430,3430,3430,3530,3530,3530,3530,3530,3630,3630,3630,3630,3630,3730,3730,3730,3730,3730,3830,3830,3830,3830,3830,3930,3930,3930,3930,3930,4030,4030,4030,4030,4030,4130,4130,4130,4130,4130,4230,4230,4230,4230,4230,4330,4330,4330,4330,4330,4430,4430,4430,4430,4430,4530,4530,4530,4530,4530,4630,4630,4630,4630,4630,4730,4730,4730,4730,4730,4830,4830,4830,4830,4830,4930,4930,4930,4930,4930,5030,5030,5030,5030,5030,5130,5130,5130,5130,5130,5230,5230,5230,5230,5230,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5430,5430,5430,5430,5430,5530,5530,5530,5530,5530,5630,5630,5630,5630,5630,5730,5730,5730,5730,5730,5830,5830,5830,5830,5830,5930,5930,5930,5930,5930,6030,6030,6030,6030,6030,6130,6130,6130,6130,6130,6230,6230,6230,6230,6230,6330,6330,6330,6330,6330,6430,6430,6430,6430,6430,6530,6530,6530,6530,6530,6630,6630,6630,6630,6630,6730,6730,6730,6730,6730,6830,6830,6830,6830,6830,6930,6930,6930,6930,6930,7030,7030,7030,7030,7030,7130,7130,7130,7130,7130,7230,7230,7230,7230,7230,7330,7330,7330,7330,7330,7430,7430,7430,7430,7430,7530,7530,7530,7530,7530,7630,7630,7630,7630,7630,7730,7730,7730,7730,7730,7830,7830,7830,7830,7830,7930,7930,7930,7930,7930,8030,8030,8030,8030,8030,8130,8130,8130,8130,8130,8230,8230,8230,8230,8230,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8430,8430,8430,8430,8430,8530,8530,8530,8530,8530,8630,8630,8630,8630,8630,8730,8730,8730,8730,8730,8830,8830,8830,8830,8830,8930,8930,8930,8930,8930,9030,9030,9030,9030,9030,9130,9130,9130,9130,9130,9230,9230,9230,9230,9230,9330,9330,9330,9330,9330,9430,9430,9430,9430,9430,9530,9530,9530,9530,9530,9630,9630,9630,9630,9630,9730,9730,9730,9730,9730,9830,9830,9830,9830,9830,9930,9930,9930,9930,9930,10030,10030,10030,10030,10030,10230,10230,10230,10230,10230,10230,10230,10230,10230,10230,10430,10430,10430,10430,10430,10430,10430,10430,10430,10430,10630,10630,10630,10630,10630,10630,10630,10630,10630,10630,10830,10830,10830,10830,10830,10830,10830,10830,10830,10830,11030,11030,11030,11030,11030,11030,11030,11030,11030,11030,11230,11230,11230,11230,11230,11230,11230,11230,11230,11230,11430,11430,11430,11430,11430,11430,11430,11430,11430,11430,11630,11630,11630,11630,11630,11630,11630,11630,11630,11630,11830,11830,11830,11830,11830,11830,11830,11830,11830,11830,12030,12030,12030,12030,12030,12030,12030,12030,12030,12030,12230,12230,12230,12230,12230,12230,12230,12230,12230,12230,12430,12430,12430,12430,12430,12430,12430,12430,12430,12430,12630,12630,12630,12630,12630,12630,12630,12630,12630,12630,12830,12830,12830,12830,12830,12830,12830,12830,12830,12830,13030,13030,13030,13030,13030,13030,13030,13030,13030,13030,13230,13230,13230,13230,13230,13230,13230,13230,13230,13230,13430,13430,13430,13430,13430,13430,13430,13430,13430,13430,13630,13630,13630,13630,13630,13630,13630,13630,13630,13630,13830,13830,13830,13830,13830,13830,13830,13830,13830,13830,14030,14030,14030,14030,14030,14030,14030,14030,14030,14030,14230,14230,14230,14230,14230,14230,14230,14230,14230,14230,14430,14430,14430,14430,14430,14430,14430,14430,14430,14430,14630,14630,14630,14630,14630,14630,14630,14630,14630,14630,14830,14830,14830,14830,14830,14830,14830,14830,14830,14830,15030,15030,15030,15030,15030,15030,15030,15030,15030,15030,15230,15230,15230,15230,15230,15230,15230,15230,15230,15230,15430,15430,15430,15430,15430,15430,15430,15430,15430,15430,15630,15630,15630,15630,15630,15630,15630,15630,15630,15630,15830,15830,15830,15830,15830,15830,15830,15830,15830,15830,16030,16030,16030,16030,16030,16030,16030,16030,16030,16030,16230,16230,16230,16230,16230,16230,16230,16230,16230,16230,16430,16430,16430,16430,16430,16430,16430,16430,16430,16430,16630,16630,16630,16630,16630,16630,16630,16630,16630,16630,16830,16830,16830,16830,16830,16830,16830,16830,16830,16830,17030,17030,17030,17030,17030,17030,17030,17030,17030,17030,17230,17230,17230,17230,17230,17230,17230,17230,17230,17230,17430,17430,17430,17430,17430,17430,17430,17430,17430,17430,17630,17630,17630,17630,17630,17630,17630,17630,17630,17630,17830,17830,17830,17830,17830,17830,17830,17830,17830,17830,18030,18030,18030,18030,18030,18030,18030,18030,18030,18030,18230,18230,18230,18230,18230,18230,18230,18230,18230,18230,18430,18430,18430,18430,18430,18430,18430,18430,18430,18430,18630,18630,18630,18630,18630,18630,18630,18630,18630,18630,18830,18830,18830,18830,18830,18830,18830,18830,18830,18830,19030,19030,19030,19030,19030,19030,19030,19030,19030,19030,19230,19230,19230,19230,19230,19230,19230,19230,19230,19230,19430,19430,19430,19430,19430,19430,19430,19430,19430,19430,19630,19630,19630,19630,19630,19630,19630,19630,19630,19630,19830,19830,19830,19830,19830,19830,19830,19830,19830,19830,20030,20030,20030,20030,20030,20030,20030,20030,20030,20030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980],"target":[[0,120],[570,220]],"lateness":[[0,0],[1,20],[2,40],[3,60],[4,80],[500,180]]} +{"name":"flush","about":"A sender flushing 100 ms of media at a time, then 200 ms from halfway. The measured term follows the flush span less one frame, which is what the round-trip formula could not see.","frame":20,"arrival":[130,130,130,130,130,230,230,230,230,230,330,330,330,330,330,430,430,430,430,430,530,530,530,530,530,630,630,630,630,630,730,730,730,730,730,830,830,830,830,830,930,930,930,930,930,1030,1030,1030,1030,1030,1130,1130,1130,1130,1130,1230,1230,1230,1230,1230,1330,1330,1330,1330,1330,1430,1430,1430,1430,1430,1530,1530,1530,1530,1530,1630,1630,1630,1630,1630,1730,1730,1730,1730,1730,1830,1830,1830,1830,1830,1930,1930,1930,1930,1930,2030,2030,2030,2030,2030,2130,2130,2130,2130,2130,2230,2230,2230,2230,2230,2330,2330,2330,2330,2330,2430,2430,2430,2430,2430,2530,2530,2530,2530,2530,2630,2630,2630,2630,2630,2730,2730,2730,2730,2730,2830,2830,2830,2830,2830,2930,2930,2930,2930,2930,3030,3030,3030,3030,3030,3130,3130,3130,3130,3130,3230,3230,3230,3230,3230,3330,3330,3330,3330,3330,3430,3430,3430,3430,3430,3530,3530,3530,3530,3530,3630,3630,3630,3630,3630,3730,3730,3730,3730,3730,3830,3830,3830,3830,3830,3930,3930,3930,3930,3930,4030,4030,4030,4030,4030,4130,4130,4130,4130,4130,4230,4230,4230,4230,4230,4330,4330,4330,4330,4330,4430,4430,4430,4430,4430,4530,4530,4530,4530,4530,4630,4630,4630,4630,4630,4730,4730,4730,4730,4730,4830,4830,4830,4830,4830,4930,4930,4930,4930,4930,5030,5030,5030,5030,5030,5130,5130,5130,5130,5130,5230,5230,5230,5230,5230,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5430,5430,5430,5430,5430,5530,5530,5530,5530,5530,5630,5630,5630,5630,5630,5730,5730,5730,5730,5730,5830,5830,5830,5830,5830,5930,5930,5930,5930,5930,6030,6030,6030,6030,6030,6130,6130,6130,6130,6130,6230,6230,6230,6230,6230,6330,6330,6330,6330,6330,6430,6430,6430,6430,6430,6530,6530,6530,6530,6530,6630,6630,6630,6630,6630,6730,6730,6730,6730,6730,6830,6830,6830,6830,6830,6930,6930,6930,6930,6930,7030,7030,7030,7030,7030,7130,7130,7130,7130,7130,7230,7230,7230,7230,7230,7330,7330,7330,7330,7330,7430,7430,7430,7430,7430,7530,7530,7530,7530,7530,7630,7630,7630,7630,7630,7730,7730,7730,7730,7730,7830,7830,7830,7830,7830,7930,7930,7930,7930,7930,8030,8030,8030,8030,8030,8130,8130,8130,8130,8130,8230,8230,8230,8230,8230,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8430,8430,8430,8430,8430,8530,8530,8530,8530,8530,8630,8630,8630,8630,8630,8730,8730,8730,8730,8730,8830,8830,8830,8830,8830,8930,8930,8930,8930,8930,9030,9030,9030,9030,9030,9130,9130,9130,9130,9130,9230,9230,9230,9230,9230,9330,9330,9330,9330,9330,9430,9430,9430,9430,9430,9530,9530,9530,9530,9530,9630,9630,9630,9630,9630,9730,9730,9730,9730,9730,9830,9830,9830,9830,9830,9930,9930,9930,9930,9930,10030,10030,10030,10030,10030,10230,10230,10230,10230,10230,10230,10230,10230,10230,10230,10430,10430,10430,10430,10430,10430,10430,10430,10430,10430,10630,10630,10630,10630,10630,10630,10630,10630,10630,10630,10830,10830,10830,10830,10830,10830,10830,10830,10830,10830,11030,11030,11030,11030,11030,11030,11030,11030,11030,11030,11230,11230,11230,11230,11230,11230,11230,11230,11230,11230,11430,11430,11430,11430,11430,11430,11430,11430,11430,11430,11630,11630,11630,11630,11630,11630,11630,11630,11630,11630,11830,11830,11830,11830,11830,11830,11830,11830,11830,11830,12030,12030,12030,12030,12030,12030,12030,12030,12030,12030,12230,12230,12230,12230,12230,12230,12230,12230,12230,12230,12430,12430,12430,12430,12430,12430,12430,12430,12430,12430,12630,12630,12630,12630,12630,12630,12630,12630,12630,12630,12830,12830,12830,12830,12830,12830,12830,12830,12830,12830,13030,13030,13030,13030,13030,13030,13030,13030,13030,13030,13230,13230,13230,13230,13230,13230,13230,13230,13230,13230,13430,13430,13430,13430,13430,13430,13430,13430,13430,13430,13630,13630,13630,13630,13630,13630,13630,13630,13630,13630,13830,13830,13830,13830,13830,13830,13830,13830,13830,13830,14030,14030,14030,14030,14030,14030,14030,14030,14030,14030,14230,14230,14230,14230,14230,14230,14230,14230,14230,14230,14430,14430,14430,14430,14430,14430,14430,14430,14430,14430,14630,14630,14630,14630,14630,14630,14630,14630,14630,14630,14830,14830,14830,14830,14830,14830,14830,14830,14830,14830,15030,15030,15030,15030,15030,15030,15030,15030,15030,15030,15230,15230,15230,15230,15230,15230,15230,15230,15230,15230,15430,15430,15430,15430,15430,15430,15430,15430,15430,15430,15630,15630,15630,15630,15630,15630,15630,15630,15630,15630,15830,15830,15830,15830,15830,15830,15830,15830,15830,15830,16030,16030,16030,16030,16030,16030,16030,16030,16030,16030,16230,16230,16230,16230,16230,16230,16230,16230,16230,16230,16430,16430,16430,16430,16430,16430,16430,16430,16430,16430,16630,16630,16630,16630,16630,16630,16630,16630,16630,16630,16830,16830,16830,16830,16830,16830,16830,16830,16830,16830,17030,17030,17030,17030,17030,17030,17030,17030,17030,17030,17230,17230,17230,17230,17230,17230,17230,17230,17230,17230,17430,17430,17430,17430,17430,17430,17430,17430,17430,17430,17630,17630,17630,17630,17630,17630,17630,17630,17630,17630,17830,17830,17830,17830,17830,17830,17830,17830,17830,17830,18030,18030,18030,18030,18030,18030,18030,18030,18030,18030,18230,18230,18230,18230,18230,18230,18230,18230,18230,18230,18430,18430,18430,18430,18430,18430,18430,18430,18430,18430,18630,18630,18630,18630,18630,18630,18630,18630,18630,18630,18830,18830,18830,18830,18830,18830,18830,18830,18830,18830,19030,19030,19030,19030,19030,19030,19030,19030,19030,19030,19230,19230,19230,19230,19230,19230,19230,19230,19230,19230,19430,19430,19430,19430,19430,19430,19430,19430,19430,19430,19630,19630,19630,19630,19630,19630,19630,19630,19630,19630,19830,19830,19830,19830,19830,19830,19830,19830,19830,19830,20030,20030,20030,20030,20030,20030,20030,20030,20030,20030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980],"target":[[0,120],[570,220]]} diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/idle.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/idle.json index 59d020e2f34..a9bf341d439 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/idle.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/idle.json @@ -1 +1 @@ -{"name":"idle","about":"A 30 s gap in both clocks, as a suspended tab produces. The idle intervals relax the histogram back toward the prior rather than freezing it.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,40050,40070,40090,40110,40130,40150,40170,40190,40210,40230,40250,40270,40290,40310,40330,40350,40370,40390,40410,40430,40450,40470,40490,40510,40530,40550,40570,40590,40610,40630,40650,40670,40690,40710,40730,40750,40770,40790,40810,40830,40850,40870,40890,40910,40930,40950,40970,40990,41010,41030,41050,41070,41090,41110,41130,41150,41170,41190,41210,41230,41250,41270,41290,41310,41330,41350,41370,41390,41410,41430,41450,41470,41490,41510,41530,41550,41570,41590,41610,41630,41650,41670,41690,41710,41730,41750,41770,41790,41810,41830,41850,41870,41890,41910,41930,41950,41970,41990,42010,42030,42050,42070,42090,42110,42130,42150,42170,42190,42210,42230,42250,42270,42290,42310,42330,42350,42370,42390,42410,42430,42450,42470,42490,42510,42530,42550,42570,42590,42610,42630,42650,42670,42690,42710,42730,42750,42770,42790,42810,42830,42850,42870,42890,42910,42930,42950,42970,42990,43010,43030,43050,43070,43090,43110,43130,43150,43170,43190,43210,43230,43250,43270,43290,43310,43330,43350,43370,43390,43410,43430,43450,43470,43490,43510,43530,43550,43570,43590,43610,43630,43650,43670,43690,43710,43730,43750,43770,43790,43810,43830,43850,43870,43890,43910,43930,43950,43970,43990,44010,44030,44050,44070,44090,44110,44130,44150,44170,44190,44210,44230,44250,44270,44290,44310,44330,44350,44370,44390,44410,44430,44450,44470,44490,44510,44530,44550,44570,44590,44610,44630,44650,44670,44690,44710,44730,44750,44770,44790,44810,44830,44850,44870,44890,44910,44930,44950,44970,44990,45010,45030,45050,45070,45090,45110,45130,45150,45170,45190,45210,45230,45250,45270,45290,45310,45330,45350,45370,45390,45410,45430,45450,45470,45490,45510,45530,45550,45570,45590,45610,45630,45650,45670,45690,45710,45730,45750,45770,45790,45810,45830,45850,45870,45890,45910,45930,45950,45970,45990,46010,46030,46050,46070,46090,46110,46130,46150,46170,46190,46210,46230,46250,46270,46290,46310,46330,46350,46370,46390,46410,46430,46450,46470,46490,46510,46530,46550,46570,46590,46610,46630,46650,46670,46690,46710,46730,46750,46770,46790,46810,46830,46850,46870,46890,46910,46930,46950,46970,46990,47010,47030,47050,47070,47090,47110,47130,47150,47170,47190,47210,47230,47250,47270,47290,47310,47330,47350,47370,47390,47410,47430,47450,47470,47490,47510,47530,47550,47570,47590,47610,47630,47650,47670,47690,47710,47730,47750,47770,47790,47810,47830,47850,47870,47890,47910,47930,47950,47970,47990,48010,48030,48050,48070,48090,48110,48130,48150,48170,48190,48210,48230,48250,48270,48290,48310,48330,48350,48370,48390,48410,48430,48450,48470,48490,48510,48530,48550,48570,48590,48610,48630,48650,48670,48690,48710,48730,48750,48770,48790,48810,48830,48850,48870,48890,48910,48930,48950,48970,48990,49010,49030,49050,49070,49090,49110,49130,49150,49170,49190,49210,49230,49250,49270,49290,49310,49330,49350,49370,49390,49410,49430,49450,49470,49490,49510,49530,49550,49570,49590,49610,49630,49650,49670,49690,49710,49730,49750,49770,49790,49810,49830,49850,49870,49890,49910,49930,49950,49970,49990,50010,50030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,40000,40020,40040,40060,40080,40100,40120,40140,40160,40180,40200,40220,40240,40260,40280,40300,40320,40340,40360,40380,40400,40420,40440,40460,40480,40500,40520,40540,40560,40580,40600,40620,40640,40660,40680,40700,40720,40740,40760,40780,40800,40820,40840,40860,40880,40900,40920,40940,40960,40980,41000,41020,41040,41060,41080,41100,41120,41140,41160,41180,41200,41220,41240,41260,41280,41300,41320,41340,41360,41380,41400,41420,41440,41460,41480,41500,41520,41540,41560,41580,41600,41620,41640,41660,41680,41700,41720,41740,41760,41780,41800,41820,41840,41860,41880,41900,41920,41940,41960,41980,42000,42020,42040,42060,42080,42100,42120,42140,42160,42180,42200,42220,42240,42260,42280,42300,42320,42340,42360,42380,42400,42420,42440,42460,42480,42500,42520,42540,42560,42580,42600,42620,42640,42660,42680,42700,42720,42740,42760,42780,42800,42820,42840,42860,42880,42900,42920,42940,42960,42980,43000,43020,43040,43060,43080,43100,43120,43140,43160,43180,43200,43220,43240,43260,43280,43300,43320,43340,43360,43380,43400,43420,43440,43460,43480,43500,43520,43540,43560,43580,43600,43620,43640,43660,43680,43700,43720,43740,43760,43780,43800,43820,43840,43860,43880,43900,43920,43940,43960,43980,44000,44020,44040,44060,44080,44100,44120,44140,44160,44180,44200,44220,44240,44260,44280,44300,44320,44340,44360,44380,44400,44420,44440,44460,44480,44500,44520,44540,44560,44580,44600,44620,44640,44660,44680,44700,44720,44740,44760,44780,44800,44820,44840,44860,44880,44900,44920,44940,44960,44980,45000,45020,45040,45060,45080,45100,45120,45140,45160,45180,45200,45220,45240,45260,45280,45300,45320,45340,45360,45380,45400,45420,45440,45460,45480,45500,45520,45540,45560,45580,45600,45620,45640,45660,45680,45700,45720,45740,45760,45780,45800,45820,45840,45860,45880,45900,45920,45940,45960,45980,46000,46020,46040,46060,46080,46100,46120,46140,46160,46180,46200,46220,46240,46260,46280,46300,46320,46340,46360,46380,46400,46420,46440,46460,46480,46500,46520,46540,46560,46580,46600,46620,46640,46660,46680,46700,46720,46740,46760,46780,46800,46820,46840,46860,46880,46900,46920,46940,46960,46980,47000,47020,47040,47060,47080,47100,47120,47140,47160,47180,47200,47220,47240,47260,47280,47300,47320,47340,47360,47380,47400,47420,47440,47460,47480,47500,47520,47540,47560,47580,47600,47620,47640,47660,47680,47700,47720,47740,47760,47780,47800,47820,47840,47860,47880,47900,47920,47940,47960,47980,48000,48020,48040,48060,48080,48100,48120,48140,48160,48180,48200,48220,48240,48260,48280,48300,48320,48340,48360,48380,48400,48420,48440,48460,48480,48500,48520,48540,48560,48580,48600,48620,48640,48660,48680,48700,48720,48740,48760,48780,48800,48820,48840,48860,48880,48900,48920,48940,48960,48980,49000,49020,49040,49060,49080,49100,49120,49140,49160,49180,49200,49220,49240,49260,49280,49300,49320,49340,49360,49380,49400,49420,49440,49460,49480,49500,49520,49540,49560,49580,49600,49620,49640,49660,49680,49700,49720,49740,49760,49780,49800,49820,49840,49860,49880,49900,49920,49940,49960,49980],"target":[[0,120],[75,100],[175,80],[225,60],[250,40],[500,100],[575,80],[625,60],[675,40]],"lateness":[[0,0]]} +{"name":"idle","about":"A 30 s gap in both clocks, as a suspended tab produces. The idle intervals relax the histogram back toward the prior rather than freezing it.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,40050,40070,40090,40110,40130,40150,40170,40190,40210,40230,40250,40270,40290,40310,40330,40350,40370,40390,40410,40430,40450,40470,40490,40510,40530,40550,40570,40590,40610,40630,40650,40670,40690,40710,40730,40750,40770,40790,40810,40830,40850,40870,40890,40910,40930,40950,40970,40990,41010,41030,41050,41070,41090,41110,41130,41150,41170,41190,41210,41230,41250,41270,41290,41310,41330,41350,41370,41390,41410,41430,41450,41470,41490,41510,41530,41550,41570,41590,41610,41630,41650,41670,41690,41710,41730,41750,41770,41790,41810,41830,41850,41870,41890,41910,41930,41950,41970,41990,42010,42030,42050,42070,42090,42110,42130,42150,42170,42190,42210,42230,42250,42270,42290,42310,42330,42350,42370,42390,42410,42430,42450,42470,42490,42510,42530,42550,42570,42590,42610,42630,42650,42670,42690,42710,42730,42750,42770,42790,42810,42830,42850,42870,42890,42910,42930,42950,42970,42990,43010,43030,43050,43070,43090,43110,43130,43150,43170,43190,43210,43230,43250,43270,43290,43310,43330,43350,43370,43390,43410,43430,43450,43470,43490,43510,43530,43550,43570,43590,43610,43630,43650,43670,43690,43710,43730,43750,43770,43790,43810,43830,43850,43870,43890,43910,43930,43950,43970,43990,44010,44030,44050,44070,44090,44110,44130,44150,44170,44190,44210,44230,44250,44270,44290,44310,44330,44350,44370,44390,44410,44430,44450,44470,44490,44510,44530,44550,44570,44590,44610,44630,44650,44670,44690,44710,44730,44750,44770,44790,44810,44830,44850,44870,44890,44910,44930,44950,44970,44990,45010,45030,45050,45070,45090,45110,45130,45150,45170,45190,45210,45230,45250,45270,45290,45310,45330,45350,45370,45390,45410,45430,45450,45470,45490,45510,45530,45550,45570,45590,45610,45630,45650,45670,45690,45710,45730,45750,45770,45790,45810,45830,45850,45870,45890,45910,45930,45950,45970,45990,46010,46030,46050,46070,46090,46110,46130,46150,46170,46190,46210,46230,46250,46270,46290,46310,46330,46350,46370,46390,46410,46430,46450,46470,46490,46510,46530,46550,46570,46590,46610,46630,46650,46670,46690,46710,46730,46750,46770,46790,46810,46830,46850,46870,46890,46910,46930,46950,46970,46990,47010,47030,47050,47070,47090,47110,47130,47150,47170,47190,47210,47230,47250,47270,47290,47310,47330,47350,47370,47390,47410,47430,47450,47470,47490,47510,47530,47550,47570,47590,47610,47630,47650,47670,47690,47710,47730,47750,47770,47790,47810,47830,47850,47870,47890,47910,47930,47950,47970,47990,48010,48030,48050,48070,48090,48110,48130,48150,48170,48190,48210,48230,48250,48270,48290,48310,48330,48350,48370,48390,48410,48430,48450,48470,48490,48510,48530,48550,48570,48590,48610,48630,48650,48670,48690,48710,48730,48750,48770,48790,48810,48830,48850,48870,48890,48910,48930,48950,48970,48990,49010,49030,49050,49070,49090,49110,49130,49150,49170,49190,49210,49230,49250,49270,49290,49310,49330,49350,49370,49390,49410,49430,49450,49470,49490,49510,49530,49550,49570,49590,49610,49630,49650,49670,49690,49710,49730,49750,49770,49790,49810,49830,49850,49870,49890,49910,49930,49950,49970,49990,50010,50030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,40000,40020,40040,40060,40080,40100,40120,40140,40160,40180,40200,40220,40240,40260,40280,40300,40320,40340,40360,40380,40400,40420,40440,40460,40480,40500,40520,40540,40560,40580,40600,40620,40640,40660,40680,40700,40720,40740,40760,40780,40800,40820,40840,40860,40880,40900,40920,40940,40960,40980,41000,41020,41040,41060,41080,41100,41120,41140,41160,41180,41200,41220,41240,41260,41280,41300,41320,41340,41360,41380,41400,41420,41440,41460,41480,41500,41520,41540,41560,41580,41600,41620,41640,41660,41680,41700,41720,41740,41760,41780,41800,41820,41840,41860,41880,41900,41920,41940,41960,41980,42000,42020,42040,42060,42080,42100,42120,42140,42160,42180,42200,42220,42240,42260,42280,42300,42320,42340,42360,42380,42400,42420,42440,42460,42480,42500,42520,42540,42560,42580,42600,42620,42640,42660,42680,42700,42720,42740,42760,42780,42800,42820,42840,42860,42880,42900,42920,42940,42960,42980,43000,43020,43040,43060,43080,43100,43120,43140,43160,43180,43200,43220,43240,43260,43280,43300,43320,43340,43360,43380,43400,43420,43440,43460,43480,43500,43520,43540,43560,43580,43600,43620,43640,43660,43680,43700,43720,43740,43760,43780,43800,43820,43840,43860,43880,43900,43920,43940,43960,43980,44000,44020,44040,44060,44080,44100,44120,44140,44160,44180,44200,44220,44240,44260,44280,44300,44320,44340,44360,44380,44400,44420,44440,44460,44480,44500,44520,44540,44560,44580,44600,44620,44640,44660,44680,44700,44720,44740,44760,44780,44800,44820,44840,44860,44880,44900,44920,44940,44960,44980,45000,45020,45040,45060,45080,45100,45120,45140,45160,45180,45200,45220,45240,45260,45280,45300,45320,45340,45360,45380,45400,45420,45440,45460,45480,45500,45520,45540,45560,45580,45600,45620,45640,45660,45680,45700,45720,45740,45760,45780,45800,45820,45840,45860,45880,45900,45920,45940,45960,45980,46000,46020,46040,46060,46080,46100,46120,46140,46160,46180,46200,46220,46240,46260,46280,46300,46320,46340,46360,46380,46400,46420,46440,46460,46480,46500,46520,46540,46560,46580,46600,46620,46640,46660,46680,46700,46720,46740,46760,46780,46800,46820,46840,46860,46880,46900,46920,46940,46960,46980,47000,47020,47040,47060,47080,47100,47120,47140,47160,47180,47200,47220,47240,47260,47280,47300,47320,47340,47360,47380,47400,47420,47440,47460,47480,47500,47520,47540,47560,47580,47600,47620,47640,47660,47680,47700,47720,47740,47760,47780,47800,47820,47840,47860,47880,47900,47920,47940,47960,47980,48000,48020,48040,48060,48080,48100,48120,48140,48160,48180,48200,48220,48240,48260,48280,48300,48320,48340,48360,48380,48400,48420,48440,48460,48480,48500,48520,48540,48560,48580,48600,48620,48640,48660,48680,48700,48720,48740,48760,48780,48800,48820,48840,48860,48880,48900,48920,48940,48960,48980,49000,49020,49040,49060,49080,49100,49120,49140,49160,49180,49200,49220,49240,49260,49280,49300,49320,49340,49360,49380,49400,49420,49440,49460,49480,49500,49520,49540,49560,49580,49600,49620,49640,49660,49680,49700,49720,49740,49760,49780,49800,49820,49840,49860,49880,49900,49920,49940,49960,49980],"target":[[0,120],[75,100],[175,80],[225,60],[250,40],[500,100],[575,80],[625,60],[675,40]]} diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/paced.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/paced.json index 5a2e419079c..145e0658722 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/paced.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/paced.json @@ -1 +1 @@ -{"name":"paced","about":"A perfectly even sender for 60 s, long enough to leave the cold-start ramp. The target settles on one bucket plus one frame, which is the floor the estimator can report.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030,20050,20070,20090,20110,20130,20150,20170,20190,20210,20230,20250,20270,20290,20310,20330,20350,20370,20390,20410,20430,20450,20470,20490,20510,20530,20550,20570,20590,20610,20630,20650,20670,20690,20710,20730,20750,20770,20790,20810,20830,20850,20870,20890,20910,20930,20950,20970,20990,21010,21030,21050,21070,21090,21110,21130,21150,21170,21190,21210,21230,21250,21270,21290,21310,21330,21350,21370,21390,21410,21430,21450,21470,21490,21510,21530,21550,21570,21590,21610,21630,21650,21670,21690,21710,21730,21750,21770,21790,21810,21830,21850,21870,21890,21910,21930,21950,21970,21990,22010,22030,22050,22070,22090,22110,22130,22150,22170,22190,22210,22230,22250,22270,22290,22310,22330,22350,22370,22390,22410,22430,22450,22470,22490,22510,22530,22550,22570,22590,22610,22630,22650,22670,22690,22710,22730,22750,22770,22790,22810,22830,22850,22870,22890,22910,22930,22950,22970,22990,23010,23030,23050,23070,23090,23110,23130,23150,23170,23190,23210,23230,23250,23270,23290,23310,23330,23350,23370,23390,23410,23430,23450,23470,23490,23510,23530,23550,23570,23590,23610,23630,23650,23670,23690,23710,23730,23750,23770,23790,23810,23830,23850,23870,23890,23910,23930,23950,23970,23990,24010,24030,24050,24070,24090,24110,24130,24150,24170,24190,24210,24230,24250,24270,24290,24310,24330,24350,24370,24390,24410,24430,24450,24470,24490,24510,24530,24550,24570,24590,24610,24630,24650,24670,24690,24710,24730,24750,24770,24790,24810,24830,24850,24870,24890,24910,24930,24950,24970,24990,25010,25030,25050,25070,25090,25110,25130,25150,25170,25190,25210,25230,25250,25270,25290,25310,25330,25350,25370,25390,25410,25430,25450,25470,25490,25510,25530,25550,25570,25590,25610,25630,25650,25670,25690,25710,25730,25750,25770,25790,25810,25830,25850,25870,25890,25910,25930,25950,25970,25990,26010,26030,26050,26070,26090,26110,26130,26150,26170,26190,26210,26230,26250,26270,26290,26310,26330,26350,26370,26390,26410,26430,26450,26470,26490,26510,26530,26550,26570,26590,26610,26630,26650,26670,26690,26710,26730,26750,26770,26790,26810,26830,26850,26870,26890,26910,26930,26950,26970,26990,27010,27030,27050,27070,27090,27110,27130,27150,27170,27190,27210,27230,27250,27270,27290,27310,27330,27350,27370,27390,27410,27430,27450,27470,27490,27510,27530,27550,27570,27590,27610,27630,27650,27670,27690,27710,27730,27750,27770,27790,27810,27830,27850,27870,27890,27910,27930,27950,27970,27990,28010,28030,28050,28070,28090,28110,28130,28150,28170,28190,28210,28230,28250,28270,28290,28310,28330,28350,28370,28390,28410,28430,28450,28470,28490,28510,28530,28550,28570,28590,28610,28630,28650,28670,28690,28710,28730,28750,28770,28790,28810,28830,28850,28870,28890,28910,28930,28950,28970,28990,29010,29030,29050,29070,29090,29110,29130,29150,29170,29190,29210,29230,29250,29270,29290,29310,29330,29350,29370,29390,29410,29430,29450,29470,29490,29510,29530,29550,29570,29590,29610,29630,29650,29670,29690,29710,29730,29750,29770,29790,29810,29830,29850,29870,29890,29910,29930,29950,29970,29990,30010,30030,30050,30070,30090,30110,30130,30150,30170,30190,30210,30230,30250,30270,30290,30310,30330,30350,30370,30390,30410,30430,30450,30470,30490,30510,30530,30550,30570,30590,30610,30630,30650,30670,30690,30710,30730,30750,30770,30790,30810,30830,30850,30870,30890,30910,30930,30950,30970,30990,31010,31030,31050,31070,31090,31110,31130,31150,31170,31190,31210,31230,31250,31270,31290,31310,31330,31350,31370,31390,31410,31430,31450,31470,31490,31510,31530,31550,31570,31590,31610,31630,31650,31670,31690,31710,31730,31750,31770,31790,31810,31830,31850,31870,31890,31910,31930,31950,31970,31990,32010,32030,32050,32070,32090,32110,32130,32150,32170,32190,32210,32230,32250,32270,32290,32310,32330,32350,32370,32390,32410,32430,32450,32470,32490,32510,32530,32550,32570,32590,32610,32630,32650,32670,32690,32710,32730,32750,32770,32790,32810,32830,32850,32870,32890,32910,32930,32950,32970,32990,33010,33030,33050,33070,33090,33110,33130,33150,33170,33190,33210,33230,33250,33270,33290,33310,33330,33350,33370,33390,33410,33430,33450,33470,33490,33510,33530,33550,33570,33590,33610,33630,33650,33670,33690,33710,33730,33750,33770,33790,33810,33830,33850,33870,33890,33910,33930,33950,33970,33990,34010,34030,34050,34070,34090,34110,34130,34150,34170,34190,34210,34230,34250,34270,34290,34310,34330,34350,34370,34390,34410,34430,34450,34470,34490,34510,34530,34550,34570,34590,34610,34630,34650,34670,34690,34710,34730,34750,34770,34790,34810,34830,34850,34870,34890,34910,34930,34950,34970,34990,35010,35030,35050,35070,35090,35110,35130,35150,35170,35190,35210,35230,35250,35270,35290,35310,35330,35350,35370,35390,35410,35430,35450,35470,35490,35510,35530,35550,35570,35590,35610,35630,35650,35670,35690,35710,35730,35750,35770,35790,35810,35830,35850,35870,35890,35910,35930,35950,35970,35990,36010,36030,36050,36070,36090,36110,36130,36150,36170,36190,36210,36230,36250,36270,36290,36310,36330,36350,36370,36390,36410,36430,36450,36470,36490,36510,36530,36550,36570,36590,36610,36630,36650,36670,36690,36710,36730,36750,36770,36790,36810,36830,36850,36870,36890,36910,36930,36950,36970,36990,37010,37030,37050,37070,37090,37110,37130,37150,37170,37190,37210,37230,37250,37270,37290,37310,37330,37350,37370,37390,37410,37430,37450,37470,37490,37510,37530,37550,37570,37590,37610,37630,37650,37670,37690,37710,37730,37750,37770,37790,37810,37830,37850,37870,37890,37910,37930,37950,37970,37990,38010,38030,38050,38070,38090,38110,38130,38150,38170,38190,38210,38230,38250,38270,38290,38310,38330,38350,38370,38390,38410,38430,38450,38470,38490,38510,38530,38550,38570,38590,38610,38630,38650,38670,38690,38710,38730,38750,38770,38790,38810,38830,38850,38870,38890,38910,38930,38950,38970,38990,39010,39030,39050,39070,39090,39110,39130,39150,39170,39190,39210,39230,39250,39270,39290,39310,39330,39350,39370,39390,39410,39430,39450,39470,39490,39510,39530,39550,39570,39590,39610,39630,39650,39670,39690,39710,39730,39750,39770,39790,39810,39830,39850,39870,39890,39910,39930,39950,39970,39990,40010,40030,40050,40070,40090,40110,40130,40150,40170,40190,40210,40230,40250,40270,40290,40310,40330,40350,40370,40390,40410,40430,40450,40470,40490,40510,40530,40550,40570,40590,40610,40630,40650,40670,40690,40710,40730,40750,40770,40790,40810,40830,40850,40870,40890,40910,40930,40950,40970,40990,41010,41030,41050,41070,41090,41110,41130,41150,41170,41190,41210,41230,41250,41270,41290,41310,41330,41350,41370,41390,41410,41430,41450,41470,41490,41510,41530,41550,41570,41590,41610,41630,41650,41670,41690,41710,41730,41750,41770,41790,41810,41830,41850,41870,41890,41910,41930,41950,41970,41990,42010,42030,42050,42070,42090,42110,42130,42150,42170,42190,42210,42230,42250,42270,42290,42310,42330,42350,42370,42390,42410,42430,42450,42470,42490,42510,42530,42550,42570,42590,42610,42630,42650,42670,42690,42710,42730,42750,42770,42790,42810,42830,42850,42870,42890,42910,42930,42950,42970,42990,43010,43030,43050,43070,43090,43110,43130,43150,43170,43190,43210,43230,43250,43270,43290,43310,43330,43350,43370,43390,43410,43430,43450,43470,43490,43510,43530,43550,43570,43590,43610,43630,43650,43670,43690,43710,43730,43750,43770,43790,43810,43830,43850,43870,43890,43910,43930,43950,43970,43990,44010,44030,44050,44070,44090,44110,44130,44150,44170,44190,44210,44230,44250,44270,44290,44310,44330,44350,44370,44390,44410,44430,44450,44470,44490,44510,44530,44550,44570,44590,44610,44630,44650,44670,44690,44710,44730,44750,44770,44790,44810,44830,44850,44870,44890,44910,44930,44950,44970,44990,45010,45030,45050,45070,45090,45110,45130,45150,45170,45190,45210,45230,45250,45270,45290,45310,45330,45350,45370,45390,45410,45430,45450,45470,45490,45510,45530,45550,45570,45590,45610,45630,45650,45670,45690,45710,45730,45750,45770,45790,45810,45830,45850,45870,45890,45910,45930,45950,45970,45990,46010,46030,46050,46070,46090,46110,46130,46150,46170,46190,46210,46230,46250,46270,46290,46310,46330,46350,46370,46390,46410,46430,46450,46470,46490,46510,46530,46550,46570,46590,46610,46630,46650,46670,46690,46710,46730,46750,46770,46790,46810,46830,46850,46870,46890,46910,46930,46950,46970,46990,47010,47030,47050,47070,47090,47110,47130,47150,47170,47190,47210,47230,47250,47270,47290,47310,47330,47350,47370,47390,47410,47430,47450,47470,47490,47510,47530,47550,47570,47590,47610,47630,47650,47670,47690,47710,47730,47750,47770,47790,47810,47830,47850,47870,47890,47910,47930,47950,47970,47990,48010,48030,48050,48070,48090,48110,48130,48150,48170,48190,48210,48230,48250,48270,48290,48310,48330,48350,48370,48390,48410,48430,48450,48470,48490,48510,48530,48550,48570,48590,48610,48630,48650,48670,48690,48710,48730,48750,48770,48790,48810,48830,48850,48870,48890,48910,48930,48950,48970,48990,49010,49030,49050,49070,49090,49110,49130,49150,49170,49190,49210,49230,49250,49270,49290,49310,49330,49350,49370,49390,49410,49430,49450,49470,49490,49510,49530,49550,49570,49590,49610,49630,49650,49670,49690,49710,49730,49750,49770,49790,49810,49830,49850,49870,49890,49910,49930,49950,49970,49990,50010,50030,50050,50070,50090,50110,50130,50150,50170,50190,50210,50230,50250,50270,50290,50310,50330,50350,50370,50390,50410,50430,50450,50470,50490,50510,50530,50550,50570,50590,50610,50630,50650,50670,50690,50710,50730,50750,50770,50790,50810,50830,50850,50870,50890,50910,50930,50950,50970,50990,51010,51030,51050,51070,51090,51110,51130,51150,51170,51190,51210,51230,51250,51270,51290,51310,51330,51350,51370,51390,51410,51430,51450,51470,51490,51510,51530,51550,51570,51590,51610,51630,51650,51670,51690,51710,51730,51750,51770,51790,51810,51830,51850,51870,51890,51910,51930,51950,51970,51990,52010,52030,52050,52070,52090,52110,52130,52150,52170,52190,52210,52230,52250,52270,52290,52310,52330,52350,52370,52390,52410,52430,52450,52470,52490,52510,52530,52550,52570,52590,52610,52630,52650,52670,52690,52710,52730,52750,52770,52790,52810,52830,52850,52870,52890,52910,52930,52950,52970,52990,53010,53030,53050,53070,53090,53110,53130,53150,53170,53190,53210,53230,53250,53270,53290,53310,53330,53350,53370,53390,53410,53430,53450,53470,53490,53510,53530,53550,53570,53590,53610,53630,53650,53670,53690,53710,53730,53750,53770,53790,53810,53830,53850,53870,53890,53910,53930,53950,53970,53990,54010,54030,54050,54070,54090,54110,54130,54150,54170,54190,54210,54230,54250,54270,54290,54310,54330,54350,54370,54390,54410,54430,54450,54470,54490,54510,54530,54550,54570,54590,54610,54630,54650,54670,54690,54710,54730,54750,54770,54790,54810,54830,54850,54870,54890,54910,54930,54950,54970,54990,55010,55030,55050,55070,55090,55110,55130,55150,55170,55190,55210,55230,55250,55270,55290,55310,55330,55350,55370,55390,55410,55430,55450,55470,55490,55510,55530,55550,55570,55590,55610,55630,55650,55670,55690,55710,55730,55750,55770,55790,55810,55830,55850,55870,55890,55910,55930,55950,55970,55990,56010,56030,56050,56070,56090,56110,56130,56150,56170,56190,56210,56230,56250,56270,56290,56310,56330,56350,56370,56390,56410,56430,56450,56470,56490,56510,56530,56550,56570,56590,56610,56630,56650,56670,56690,56710,56730,56750,56770,56790,56810,56830,56850,56870,56890,56910,56930,56950,56970,56990,57010,57030,57050,57070,57090,57110,57130,57150,57170,57190,57210,57230,57250,57270,57290,57310,57330,57350,57370,57390,57410,57430,57450,57470,57490,57510,57530,57550,57570,57590,57610,57630,57650,57670,57690,57710,57730,57750,57770,57790,57810,57830,57850,57870,57890,57910,57930,57950,57970,57990,58010,58030,58050,58070,58090,58110,58130,58150,58170,58190,58210,58230,58250,58270,58290,58310,58330,58350,58370,58390,58410,58430,58450,58470,58490,58510,58530,58550,58570,58590,58610,58630,58650,58670,58690,58710,58730,58750,58770,58790,58810,58830,58850,58870,58890,58910,58930,58950,58970,58990,59010,59030,59050,59070,59090,59110,59130,59150,59170,59190,59210,59230,59250,59270,59290,59310,59330,59350,59370,59390,59410,59430,59450,59470,59490,59510,59530,59550,59570,59590,59610,59630,59650,59670,59690,59710,59730,59750,59770,59790,59810,59830,59850,59870,59890,59910,59930,59950,59970,59990,60010,60030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,20000,20020,20040,20060,20080,20100,20120,20140,20160,20180,20200,20220,20240,20260,20280,20300,20320,20340,20360,20380,20400,20420,20440,20460,20480,20500,20520,20540,20560,20580,20600,20620,20640,20660,20680,20700,20720,20740,20760,20780,20800,20820,20840,20860,20880,20900,20920,20940,20960,20980,21000,21020,21040,21060,21080,21100,21120,21140,21160,21180,21200,21220,21240,21260,21280,21300,21320,21340,21360,21380,21400,21420,21440,21460,21480,21500,21520,21540,21560,21580,21600,21620,21640,21660,21680,21700,21720,21740,21760,21780,21800,21820,21840,21860,21880,21900,21920,21940,21960,21980,22000,22020,22040,22060,22080,22100,22120,22140,22160,22180,22200,22220,22240,22260,22280,22300,22320,22340,22360,22380,22400,22420,22440,22460,22480,22500,22520,22540,22560,22580,22600,22620,22640,22660,22680,22700,22720,22740,22760,22780,22800,22820,22840,22860,22880,22900,22920,22940,22960,22980,23000,23020,23040,23060,23080,23100,23120,23140,23160,23180,23200,23220,23240,23260,23280,23300,23320,23340,23360,23380,23400,23420,23440,23460,23480,23500,23520,23540,23560,23580,23600,23620,23640,23660,23680,23700,23720,23740,23760,23780,23800,23820,23840,23860,23880,23900,23920,23940,23960,23980,24000,24020,24040,24060,24080,24100,24120,24140,24160,24180,24200,24220,24240,24260,24280,24300,24320,24340,24360,24380,24400,24420,24440,24460,24480,24500,24520,24540,24560,24580,24600,24620,24640,24660,24680,24700,24720,24740,24760,24780,24800,24820,24840,24860,24880,24900,24920,24940,24960,24980,25000,25020,25040,25060,25080,25100,25120,25140,25160,25180,25200,25220,25240,25260,25280,25300,25320,25340,25360,25380,25400,25420,25440,25460,25480,25500,25520,25540,25560,25580,25600,25620,25640,25660,25680,25700,25720,25740,25760,25780,25800,25820,25840,25860,25880,25900,25920,25940,25960,25980,26000,26020,26040,26060,26080,26100,26120,26140,26160,26180,26200,26220,26240,26260,26280,26300,26320,26340,26360,26380,26400,26420,26440,26460,26480,26500,26520,26540,26560,26580,26600,26620,26640,26660,26680,26700,26720,26740,26760,26780,26800,26820,26840,26860,26880,26900,26920,26940,26960,26980,27000,27020,27040,27060,27080,27100,27120,27140,27160,27180,27200,27220,27240,27260,27280,27300,27320,27340,27360,27380,27400,27420,27440,27460,27480,27500,27520,27540,27560,27580,27600,27620,27640,27660,27680,27700,27720,27740,27760,27780,27800,27820,27840,27860,27880,27900,27920,27940,27960,27980,28000,28020,28040,28060,28080,28100,28120,28140,28160,28180,28200,28220,28240,28260,28280,28300,28320,28340,28360,28380,28400,28420,28440,28460,28480,28500,28520,28540,28560,28580,28600,28620,28640,28660,28680,28700,28720,28740,28760,28780,28800,28820,28840,28860,28880,28900,28920,28940,28960,28980,29000,29020,29040,29060,29080,29100,29120,29140,29160,29180,29200,29220,29240,29260,29280,29300,29320,29340,29360,29380,29400,29420,29440,29460,29480,29500,29520,29540,29560,29580,29600,29620,29640,29660,29680,29700,29720,29740,29760,29780,29800,29820,29840,29860,29880,29900,29920,29940,29960,29980,30000,30020,30040,30060,30080,30100,30120,30140,30160,30180,30200,30220,30240,30260,30280,30300,30320,30340,30360,30380,30400,30420,30440,30460,30480,30500,30520,30540,30560,30580,30600,30620,30640,30660,30680,30700,30720,30740,30760,30780,30800,30820,30840,30860,30880,30900,30920,30940,30960,30980,31000,31020,31040,31060,31080,31100,31120,31140,31160,31180,31200,31220,31240,31260,31280,31300,31320,31340,31360,31380,31400,31420,31440,31460,31480,31500,31520,31540,31560,31580,31600,31620,31640,31660,31680,31700,31720,31740,31760,31780,31800,31820,31840,31860,31880,31900,31920,31940,31960,31980,32000,32020,32040,32060,32080,32100,32120,32140,32160,32180,32200,32220,32240,32260,32280,32300,32320,32340,32360,32380,32400,32420,32440,32460,32480,32500,32520,32540,32560,32580,32600,32620,32640,32660,32680,32700,32720,32740,32760,32780,32800,32820,32840,32860,32880,32900,32920,32940,32960,32980,33000,33020,33040,33060,33080,33100,33120,33140,33160,33180,33200,33220,33240,33260,33280,33300,33320,33340,33360,33380,33400,33420,33440,33460,33480,33500,33520,33540,33560,33580,33600,33620,33640,33660,33680,33700,33720,33740,33760,33780,33800,33820,33840,33860,33880,33900,33920,33940,33960,33980,34000,34020,34040,34060,34080,34100,34120,34140,34160,34180,34200,34220,34240,34260,34280,34300,34320,34340,34360,34380,34400,34420,34440,34460,34480,34500,34520,34540,34560,34580,34600,34620,34640,34660,34680,34700,34720,34740,34760,34780,34800,34820,34840,34860,34880,34900,34920,34940,34960,34980,35000,35020,35040,35060,35080,35100,35120,35140,35160,35180,35200,35220,35240,35260,35280,35300,35320,35340,35360,35380,35400,35420,35440,35460,35480,35500,35520,35540,35560,35580,35600,35620,35640,35660,35680,35700,35720,35740,35760,35780,35800,35820,35840,35860,35880,35900,35920,35940,35960,35980,36000,36020,36040,36060,36080,36100,36120,36140,36160,36180,36200,36220,36240,36260,36280,36300,36320,36340,36360,36380,36400,36420,36440,36460,36480,36500,36520,36540,36560,36580,36600,36620,36640,36660,36680,36700,36720,36740,36760,36780,36800,36820,36840,36860,36880,36900,36920,36940,36960,36980,37000,37020,37040,37060,37080,37100,37120,37140,37160,37180,37200,37220,37240,37260,37280,37300,37320,37340,37360,37380,37400,37420,37440,37460,37480,37500,37520,37540,37560,37580,37600,37620,37640,37660,37680,37700,37720,37740,37760,37780,37800,37820,37840,37860,37880,37900,37920,37940,37960,37980,38000,38020,38040,38060,38080,38100,38120,38140,38160,38180,38200,38220,38240,38260,38280,38300,38320,38340,38360,38380,38400,38420,38440,38460,38480,38500,38520,38540,38560,38580,38600,38620,38640,38660,38680,38700,38720,38740,38760,38780,38800,38820,38840,38860,38880,38900,38920,38940,38960,38980,39000,39020,39040,39060,39080,39100,39120,39140,39160,39180,39200,39220,39240,39260,39280,39300,39320,39340,39360,39380,39400,39420,39440,39460,39480,39500,39520,39540,39560,39580,39600,39620,39640,39660,39680,39700,39720,39740,39760,39780,39800,39820,39840,39860,39880,39900,39920,39940,39960,39980,40000,40020,40040,40060,40080,40100,40120,40140,40160,40180,40200,40220,40240,40260,40280,40300,40320,40340,40360,40380,40400,40420,40440,40460,40480,40500,40520,40540,40560,40580,40600,40620,40640,40660,40680,40700,40720,40740,40760,40780,40800,40820,40840,40860,40880,40900,40920,40940,40960,40980,41000,41020,41040,41060,41080,41100,41120,41140,41160,41180,41200,41220,41240,41260,41280,41300,41320,41340,41360,41380,41400,41420,41440,41460,41480,41500,41520,41540,41560,41580,41600,41620,41640,41660,41680,41700,41720,41740,41760,41780,41800,41820,41840,41860,41880,41900,41920,41940,41960,41980,42000,42020,42040,42060,42080,42100,42120,42140,42160,42180,42200,42220,42240,42260,42280,42300,42320,42340,42360,42380,42400,42420,42440,42460,42480,42500,42520,42540,42560,42580,42600,42620,42640,42660,42680,42700,42720,42740,42760,42780,42800,42820,42840,42860,42880,42900,42920,42940,42960,42980,43000,43020,43040,43060,43080,43100,43120,43140,43160,43180,43200,43220,43240,43260,43280,43300,43320,43340,43360,43380,43400,43420,43440,43460,43480,43500,43520,43540,43560,43580,43600,43620,43640,43660,43680,43700,43720,43740,43760,43780,43800,43820,43840,43860,43880,43900,43920,43940,43960,43980,44000,44020,44040,44060,44080,44100,44120,44140,44160,44180,44200,44220,44240,44260,44280,44300,44320,44340,44360,44380,44400,44420,44440,44460,44480,44500,44520,44540,44560,44580,44600,44620,44640,44660,44680,44700,44720,44740,44760,44780,44800,44820,44840,44860,44880,44900,44920,44940,44960,44980,45000,45020,45040,45060,45080,45100,45120,45140,45160,45180,45200,45220,45240,45260,45280,45300,45320,45340,45360,45380,45400,45420,45440,45460,45480,45500,45520,45540,45560,45580,45600,45620,45640,45660,45680,45700,45720,45740,45760,45780,45800,45820,45840,45860,45880,45900,45920,45940,45960,45980,46000,46020,46040,46060,46080,46100,46120,46140,46160,46180,46200,46220,46240,46260,46280,46300,46320,46340,46360,46380,46400,46420,46440,46460,46480,46500,46520,46540,46560,46580,46600,46620,46640,46660,46680,46700,46720,46740,46760,46780,46800,46820,46840,46860,46880,46900,46920,46940,46960,46980,47000,47020,47040,47060,47080,47100,47120,47140,47160,47180,47200,47220,47240,47260,47280,47300,47320,47340,47360,47380,47400,47420,47440,47460,47480,47500,47520,47540,47560,47580,47600,47620,47640,47660,47680,47700,47720,47740,47760,47780,47800,47820,47840,47860,47880,47900,47920,47940,47960,47980,48000,48020,48040,48060,48080,48100,48120,48140,48160,48180,48200,48220,48240,48260,48280,48300,48320,48340,48360,48380,48400,48420,48440,48460,48480,48500,48520,48540,48560,48580,48600,48620,48640,48660,48680,48700,48720,48740,48760,48780,48800,48820,48840,48860,48880,48900,48920,48940,48960,48980,49000,49020,49040,49060,49080,49100,49120,49140,49160,49180,49200,49220,49240,49260,49280,49300,49320,49340,49360,49380,49400,49420,49440,49460,49480,49500,49520,49540,49560,49580,49600,49620,49640,49660,49680,49700,49720,49740,49760,49780,49800,49820,49840,49860,49880,49900,49920,49940,49960,49980,50000,50020,50040,50060,50080,50100,50120,50140,50160,50180,50200,50220,50240,50260,50280,50300,50320,50340,50360,50380,50400,50420,50440,50460,50480,50500,50520,50540,50560,50580,50600,50620,50640,50660,50680,50700,50720,50740,50760,50780,50800,50820,50840,50860,50880,50900,50920,50940,50960,50980,51000,51020,51040,51060,51080,51100,51120,51140,51160,51180,51200,51220,51240,51260,51280,51300,51320,51340,51360,51380,51400,51420,51440,51460,51480,51500,51520,51540,51560,51580,51600,51620,51640,51660,51680,51700,51720,51740,51760,51780,51800,51820,51840,51860,51880,51900,51920,51940,51960,51980,52000,52020,52040,52060,52080,52100,52120,52140,52160,52180,52200,52220,52240,52260,52280,52300,52320,52340,52360,52380,52400,52420,52440,52460,52480,52500,52520,52540,52560,52580,52600,52620,52640,52660,52680,52700,52720,52740,52760,52780,52800,52820,52840,52860,52880,52900,52920,52940,52960,52980,53000,53020,53040,53060,53080,53100,53120,53140,53160,53180,53200,53220,53240,53260,53280,53300,53320,53340,53360,53380,53400,53420,53440,53460,53480,53500,53520,53540,53560,53580,53600,53620,53640,53660,53680,53700,53720,53740,53760,53780,53800,53820,53840,53860,53880,53900,53920,53940,53960,53980,54000,54020,54040,54060,54080,54100,54120,54140,54160,54180,54200,54220,54240,54260,54280,54300,54320,54340,54360,54380,54400,54420,54440,54460,54480,54500,54520,54540,54560,54580,54600,54620,54640,54660,54680,54700,54720,54740,54760,54780,54800,54820,54840,54860,54880,54900,54920,54940,54960,54980,55000,55020,55040,55060,55080,55100,55120,55140,55160,55180,55200,55220,55240,55260,55280,55300,55320,55340,55360,55380,55400,55420,55440,55460,55480,55500,55520,55540,55560,55580,55600,55620,55640,55660,55680,55700,55720,55740,55760,55780,55800,55820,55840,55860,55880,55900,55920,55940,55960,55980,56000,56020,56040,56060,56080,56100,56120,56140,56160,56180,56200,56220,56240,56260,56280,56300,56320,56340,56360,56380,56400,56420,56440,56460,56480,56500,56520,56540,56560,56580,56600,56620,56640,56660,56680,56700,56720,56740,56760,56780,56800,56820,56840,56860,56880,56900,56920,56940,56960,56980,57000,57020,57040,57060,57080,57100,57120,57140,57160,57180,57200,57220,57240,57260,57280,57300,57320,57340,57360,57380,57400,57420,57440,57460,57480,57500,57520,57540,57560,57580,57600,57620,57640,57660,57680,57700,57720,57740,57760,57780,57800,57820,57840,57860,57880,57900,57920,57940,57960,57980,58000,58020,58040,58060,58080,58100,58120,58140,58160,58180,58200,58220,58240,58260,58280,58300,58320,58340,58360,58380,58400,58420,58440,58460,58480,58500,58520,58540,58560,58580,58600,58620,58640,58660,58680,58700,58720,58740,58760,58780,58800,58820,58840,58860,58880,58900,58920,58940,58960,58980,59000,59020,59040,59060,59080,59100,59120,59140,59160,59180,59200,59220,59240,59260,59280,59300,59320,59340,59360,59380,59400,59420,59440,59460,59480,59500,59520,59540,59560,59580,59600,59620,59640,59660,59680,59700,59720,59740,59760,59780,59800,59820,59840,59860,59880,59900,59920,59940,59960,59980],"target":[[0,120],[75,100],[175,80],[225,60],[250,40]],"lateness":[[0,0]]} +{"name":"paced","about":"A perfectly even sender for 60 s, long enough to leave the cold-start ramp. The target settles on one bucket plus one frame, which is the floor the estimator can report.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030,20050,20070,20090,20110,20130,20150,20170,20190,20210,20230,20250,20270,20290,20310,20330,20350,20370,20390,20410,20430,20450,20470,20490,20510,20530,20550,20570,20590,20610,20630,20650,20670,20690,20710,20730,20750,20770,20790,20810,20830,20850,20870,20890,20910,20930,20950,20970,20990,21010,21030,21050,21070,21090,21110,21130,21150,21170,21190,21210,21230,21250,21270,21290,21310,21330,21350,21370,21390,21410,21430,21450,21470,21490,21510,21530,21550,21570,21590,21610,21630,21650,21670,21690,21710,21730,21750,21770,21790,21810,21830,21850,21870,21890,21910,21930,21950,21970,21990,22010,22030,22050,22070,22090,22110,22130,22150,22170,22190,22210,22230,22250,22270,22290,22310,22330,22350,22370,22390,22410,22430,22450,22470,22490,22510,22530,22550,22570,22590,22610,22630,22650,22670,22690,22710,22730,22750,22770,22790,22810,22830,22850,22870,22890,22910,22930,22950,22970,22990,23010,23030,23050,23070,23090,23110,23130,23150,23170,23190,23210,23230,23250,23270,23290,23310,23330,23350,23370,23390,23410,23430,23450,23470,23490,23510,23530,23550,23570,23590,23610,23630,23650,23670,23690,23710,23730,23750,23770,23790,23810,23830,23850,23870,23890,23910,23930,23950,23970,23990,24010,24030,24050,24070,24090,24110,24130,24150,24170,24190,24210,24230,24250,24270,24290,24310,24330,24350,24370,24390,24410,24430,24450,24470,24490,24510,24530,24550,24570,24590,24610,24630,24650,24670,24690,24710,24730,24750,24770,24790,24810,24830,24850,24870,24890,24910,24930,24950,24970,24990,25010,25030,25050,25070,25090,25110,25130,25150,25170,25190,25210,25230,25250,25270,25290,25310,25330,25350,25370,25390,25410,25430,25450,25470,25490,25510,25530,25550,25570,25590,25610,25630,25650,25670,25690,25710,25730,25750,25770,25790,25810,25830,25850,25870,25890,25910,25930,25950,25970,25990,26010,26030,26050,26070,26090,26110,26130,26150,26170,26190,26210,26230,26250,26270,26290,26310,26330,26350,26370,26390,26410,26430,26450,26470,26490,26510,26530,26550,26570,26590,26610,26630,26650,26670,26690,26710,26730,26750,26770,26790,26810,26830,26850,26870,26890,26910,26930,26950,26970,26990,27010,27030,27050,27070,27090,27110,27130,27150,27170,27190,27210,27230,27250,27270,27290,27310,27330,27350,27370,27390,27410,27430,27450,27470,27490,27510,27530,27550,27570,27590,27610,27630,27650,27670,27690,27710,27730,27750,27770,27790,27810,27830,27850,27870,27890,27910,27930,27950,27970,27990,28010,28030,28050,28070,28090,28110,28130,28150,28170,28190,28210,28230,28250,28270,28290,28310,28330,28350,28370,28390,28410,28430,28450,28470,28490,28510,28530,28550,28570,28590,28610,28630,28650,28670,28690,28710,28730,28750,28770,28790,28810,28830,28850,28870,28890,28910,28930,28950,28970,28990,29010,29030,29050,29070,29090,29110,29130,29150,29170,29190,29210,29230,29250,29270,29290,29310,29330,29350,29370,29390,29410,29430,29450,29470,29490,29510,29530,29550,29570,29590,29610,29630,29650,29670,29690,29710,29730,29750,29770,29790,29810,29830,29850,29870,29890,29910,29930,29950,29970,29990,30010,30030,30050,30070,30090,30110,30130,30150,30170,30190,30210,30230,30250,30270,30290,30310,30330,30350,30370,30390,30410,30430,30450,30470,30490,30510,30530,30550,30570,30590,30610,30630,30650,30670,30690,30710,30730,30750,30770,30790,30810,30830,30850,30870,30890,30910,30930,30950,30970,30990,31010,31030,31050,31070,31090,31110,31130,31150,31170,31190,31210,31230,31250,31270,31290,31310,31330,31350,31370,31390,31410,31430,31450,31470,31490,31510,31530,31550,31570,31590,31610,31630,31650,31670,31690,31710,31730,31750,31770,31790,31810,31830,31850,31870,31890,31910,31930,31950,31970,31990,32010,32030,32050,32070,32090,32110,32130,32150,32170,32190,32210,32230,32250,32270,32290,32310,32330,32350,32370,32390,32410,32430,32450,32470,32490,32510,32530,32550,32570,32590,32610,32630,32650,32670,32690,32710,32730,32750,32770,32790,32810,32830,32850,32870,32890,32910,32930,32950,32970,32990,33010,33030,33050,33070,33090,33110,33130,33150,33170,33190,33210,33230,33250,33270,33290,33310,33330,33350,33370,33390,33410,33430,33450,33470,33490,33510,33530,33550,33570,33590,33610,33630,33650,33670,33690,33710,33730,33750,33770,33790,33810,33830,33850,33870,33890,33910,33930,33950,33970,33990,34010,34030,34050,34070,34090,34110,34130,34150,34170,34190,34210,34230,34250,34270,34290,34310,34330,34350,34370,34390,34410,34430,34450,34470,34490,34510,34530,34550,34570,34590,34610,34630,34650,34670,34690,34710,34730,34750,34770,34790,34810,34830,34850,34870,34890,34910,34930,34950,34970,34990,35010,35030,35050,35070,35090,35110,35130,35150,35170,35190,35210,35230,35250,35270,35290,35310,35330,35350,35370,35390,35410,35430,35450,35470,35490,35510,35530,35550,35570,35590,35610,35630,35650,35670,35690,35710,35730,35750,35770,35790,35810,35830,35850,35870,35890,35910,35930,35950,35970,35990,36010,36030,36050,36070,36090,36110,36130,36150,36170,36190,36210,36230,36250,36270,36290,36310,36330,36350,36370,36390,36410,36430,36450,36470,36490,36510,36530,36550,36570,36590,36610,36630,36650,36670,36690,36710,36730,36750,36770,36790,36810,36830,36850,36870,36890,36910,36930,36950,36970,36990,37010,37030,37050,37070,37090,37110,37130,37150,37170,37190,37210,37230,37250,37270,37290,37310,37330,37350,37370,37390,37410,37430,37450,37470,37490,37510,37530,37550,37570,37590,37610,37630,37650,37670,37690,37710,37730,37750,37770,37790,37810,37830,37850,37870,37890,37910,37930,37950,37970,37990,38010,38030,38050,38070,38090,38110,38130,38150,38170,38190,38210,38230,38250,38270,38290,38310,38330,38350,38370,38390,38410,38430,38450,38470,38490,38510,38530,38550,38570,38590,38610,38630,38650,38670,38690,38710,38730,38750,38770,38790,38810,38830,38850,38870,38890,38910,38930,38950,38970,38990,39010,39030,39050,39070,39090,39110,39130,39150,39170,39190,39210,39230,39250,39270,39290,39310,39330,39350,39370,39390,39410,39430,39450,39470,39490,39510,39530,39550,39570,39590,39610,39630,39650,39670,39690,39710,39730,39750,39770,39790,39810,39830,39850,39870,39890,39910,39930,39950,39970,39990,40010,40030,40050,40070,40090,40110,40130,40150,40170,40190,40210,40230,40250,40270,40290,40310,40330,40350,40370,40390,40410,40430,40450,40470,40490,40510,40530,40550,40570,40590,40610,40630,40650,40670,40690,40710,40730,40750,40770,40790,40810,40830,40850,40870,40890,40910,40930,40950,40970,40990,41010,41030,41050,41070,41090,41110,41130,41150,41170,41190,41210,41230,41250,41270,41290,41310,41330,41350,41370,41390,41410,41430,41450,41470,41490,41510,41530,41550,41570,41590,41610,41630,41650,41670,41690,41710,41730,41750,41770,41790,41810,41830,41850,41870,41890,41910,41930,41950,41970,41990,42010,42030,42050,42070,42090,42110,42130,42150,42170,42190,42210,42230,42250,42270,42290,42310,42330,42350,42370,42390,42410,42430,42450,42470,42490,42510,42530,42550,42570,42590,42610,42630,42650,42670,42690,42710,42730,42750,42770,42790,42810,42830,42850,42870,42890,42910,42930,42950,42970,42990,43010,43030,43050,43070,43090,43110,43130,43150,43170,43190,43210,43230,43250,43270,43290,43310,43330,43350,43370,43390,43410,43430,43450,43470,43490,43510,43530,43550,43570,43590,43610,43630,43650,43670,43690,43710,43730,43750,43770,43790,43810,43830,43850,43870,43890,43910,43930,43950,43970,43990,44010,44030,44050,44070,44090,44110,44130,44150,44170,44190,44210,44230,44250,44270,44290,44310,44330,44350,44370,44390,44410,44430,44450,44470,44490,44510,44530,44550,44570,44590,44610,44630,44650,44670,44690,44710,44730,44750,44770,44790,44810,44830,44850,44870,44890,44910,44930,44950,44970,44990,45010,45030,45050,45070,45090,45110,45130,45150,45170,45190,45210,45230,45250,45270,45290,45310,45330,45350,45370,45390,45410,45430,45450,45470,45490,45510,45530,45550,45570,45590,45610,45630,45650,45670,45690,45710,45730,45750,45770,45790,45810,45830,45850,45870,45890,45910,45930,45950,45970,45990,46010,46030,46050,46070,46090,46110,46130,46150,46170,46190,46210,46230,46250,46270,46290,46310,46330,46350,46370,46390,46410,46430,46450,46470,46490,46510,46530,46550,46570,46590,46610,46630,46650,46670,46690,46710,46730,46750,46770,46790,46810,46830,46850,46870,46890,46910,46930,46950,46970,46990,47010,47030,47050,47070,47090,47110,47130,47150,47170,47190,47210,47230,47250,47270,47290,47310,47330,47350,47370,47390,47410,47430,47450,47470,47490,47510,47530,47550,47570,47590,47610,47630,47650,47670,47690,47710,47730,47750,47770,47790,47810,47830,47850,47870,47890,47910,47930,47950,47970,47990,48010,48030,48050,48070,48090,48110,48130,48150,48170,48190,48210,48230,48250,48270,48290,48310,48330,48350,48370,48390,48410,48430,48450,48470,48490,48510,48530,48550,48570,48590,48610,48630,48650,48670,48690,48710,48730,48750,48770,48790,48810,48830,48850,48870,48890,48910,48930,48950,48970,48990,49010,49030,49050,49070,49090,49110,49130,49150,49170,49190,49210,49230,49250,49270,49290,49310,49330,49350,49370,49390,49410,49430,49450,49470,49490,49510,49530,49550,49570,49590,49610,49630,49650,49670,49690,49710,49730,49750,49770,49790,49810,49830,49850,49870,49890,49910,49930,49950,49970,49990,50010,50030,50050,50070,50090,50110,50130,50150,50170,50190,50210,50230,50250,50270,50290,50310,50330,50350,50370,50390,50410,50430,50450,50470,50490,50510,50530,50550,50570,50590,50610,50630,50650,50670,50690,50710,50730,50750,50770,50790,50810,50830,50850,50870,50890,50910,50930,50950,50970,50990,51010,51030,51050,51070,51090,51110,51130,51150,51170,51190,51210,51230,51250,51270,51290,51310,51330,51350,51370,51390,51410,51430,51450,51470,51490,51510,51530,51550,51570,51590,51610,51630,51650,51670,51690,51710,51730,51750,51770,51790,51810,51830,51850,51870,51890,51910,51930,51950,51970,51990,52010,52030,52050,52070,52090,52110,52130,52150,52170,52190,52210,52230,52250,52270,52290,52310,52330,52350,52370,52390,52410,52430,52450,52470,52490,52510,52530,52550,52570,52590,52610,52630,52650,52670,52690,52710,52730,52750,52770,52790,52810,52830,52850,52870,52890,52910,52930,52950,52970,52990,53010,53030,53050,53070,53090,53110,53130,53150,53170,53190,53210,53230,53250,53270,53290,53310,53330,53350,53370,53390,53410,53430,53450,53470,53490,53510,53530,53550,53570,53590,53610,53630,53650,53670,53690,53710,53730,53750,53770,53790,53810,53830,53850,53870,53890,53910,53930,53950,53970,53990,54010,54030,54050,54070,54090,54110,54130,54150,54170,54190,54210,54230,54250,54270,54290,54310,54330,54350,54370,54390,54410,54430,54450,54470,54490,54510,54530,54550,54570,54590,54610,54630,54650,54670,54690,54710,54730,54750,54770,54790,54810,54830,54850,54870,54890,54910,54930,54950,54970,54990,55010,55030,55050,55070,55090,55110,55130,55150,55170,55190,55210,55230,55250,55270,55290,55310,55330,55350,55370,55390,55410,55430,55450,55470,55490,55510,55530,55550,55570,55590,55610,55630,55650,55670,55690,55710,55730,55750,55770,55790,55810,55830,55850,55870,55890,55910,55930,55950,55970,55990,56010,56030,56050,56070,56090,56110,56130,56150,56170,56190,56210,56230,56250,56270,56290,56310,56330,56350,56370,56390,56410,56430,56450,56470,56490,56510,56530,56550,56570,56590,56610,56630,56650,56670,56690,56710,56730,56750,56770,56790,56810,56830,56850,56870,56890,56910,56930,56950,56970,56990,57010,57030,57050,57070,57090,57110,57130,57150,57170,57190,57210,57230,57250,57270,57290,57310,57330,57350,57370,57390,57410,57430,57450,57470,57490,57510,57530,57550,57570,57590,57610,57630,57650,57670,57690,57710,57730,57750,57770,57790,57810,57830,57850,57870,57890,57910,57930,57950,57970,57990,58010,58030,58050,58070,58090,58110,58130,58150,58170,58190,58210,58230,58250,58270,58290,58310,58330,58350,58370,58390,58410,58430,58450,58470,58490,58510,58530,58550,58570,58590,58610,58630,58650,58670,58690,58710,58730,58750,58770,58790,58810,58830,58850,58870,58890,58910,58930,58950,58970,58990,59010,59030,59050,59070,59090,59110,59130,59150,59170,59190,59210,59230,59250,59270,59290,59310,59330,59350,59370,59390,59410,59430,59450,59470,59490,59510,59530,59550,59570,59590,59610,59630,59650,59670,59690,59710,59730,59750,59770,59790,59810,59830,59850,59870,59890,59910,59930,59950,59970,59990,60010,60030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,20000,20020,20040,20060,20080,20100,20120,20140,20160,20180,20200,20220,20240,20260,20280,20300,20320,20340,20360,20380,20400,20420,20440,20460,20480,20500,20520,20540,20560,20580,20600,20620,20640,20660,20680,20700,20720,20740,20760,20780,20800,20820,20840,20860,20880,20900,20920,20940,20960,20980,21000,21020,21040,21060,21080,21100,21120,21140,21160,21180,21200,21220,21240,21260,21280,21300,21320,21340,21360,21380,21400,21420,21440,21460,21480,21500,21520,21540,21560,21580,21600,21620,21640,21660,21680,21700,21720,21740,21760,21780,21800,21820,21840,21860,21880,21900,21920,21940,21960,21980,22000,22020,22040,22060,22080,22100,22120,22140,22160,22180,22200,22220,22240,22260,22280,22300,22320,22340,22360,22380,22400,22420,22440,22460,22480,22500,22520,22540,22560,22580,22600,22620,22640,22660,22680,22700,22720,22740,22760,22780,22800,22820,22840,22860,22880,22900,22920,22940,22960,22980,23000,23020,23040,23060,23080,23100,23120,23140,23160,23180,23200,23220,23240,23260,23280,23300,23320,23340,23360,23380,23400,23420,23440,23460,23480,23500,23520,23540,23560,23580,23600,23620,23640,23660,23680,23700,23720,23740,23760,23780,23800,23820,23840,23860,23880,23900,23920,23940,23960,23980,24000,24020,24040,24060,24080,24100,24120,24140,24160,24180,24200,24220,24240,24260,24280,24300,24320,24340,24360,24380,24400,24420,24440,24460,24480,24500,24520,24540,24560,24580,24600,24620,24640,24660,24680,24700,24720,24740,24760,24780,24800,24820,24840,24860,24880,24900,24920,24940,24960,24980,25000,25020,25040,25060,25080,25100,25120,25140,25160,25180,25200,25220,25240,25260,25280,25300,25320,25340,25360,25380,25400,25420,25440,25460,25480,25500,25520,25540,25560,25580,25600,25620,25640,25660,25680,25700,25720,25740,25760,25780,25800,25820,25840,25860,25880,25900,25920,25940,25960,25980,26000,26020,26040,26060,26080,26100,26120,26140,26160,26180,26200,26220,26240,26260,26280,26300,26320,26340,26360,26380,26400,26420,26440,26460,26480,26500,26520,26540,26560,26580,26600,26620,26640,26660,26680,26700,26720,26740,26760,26780,26800,26820,26840,26860,26880,26900,26920,26940,26960,26980,27000,27020,27040,27060,27080,27100,27120,27140,27160,27180,27200,27220,27240,27260,27280,27300,27320,27340,27360,27380,27400,27420,27440,27460,27480,27500,27520,27540,27560,27580,27600,27620,27640,27660,27680,27700,27720,27740,27760,27780,27800,27820,27840,27860,27880,27900,27920,27940,27960,27980,28000,28020,28040,28060,28080,28100,28120,28140,28160,28180,28200,28220,28240,28260,28280,28300,28320,28340,28360,28380,28400,28420,28440,28460,28480,28500,28520,28540,28560,28580,28600,28620,28640,28660,28680,28700,28720,28740,28760,28780,28800,28820,28840,28860,28880,28900,28920,28940,28960,28980,29000,29020,29040,29060,29080,29100,29120,29140,29160,29180,29200,29220,29240,29260,29280,29300,29320,29340,29360,29380,29400,29420,29440,29460,29480,29500,29520,29540,29560,29580,29600,29620,29640,29660,29680,29700,29720,29740,29760,29780,29800,29820,29840,29860,29880,29900,29920,29940,29960,29980,30000,30020,30040,30060,30080,30100,30120,30140,30160,30180,30200,30220,30240,30260,30280,30300,30320,30340,30360,30380,30400,30420,30440,30460,30480,30500,30520,30540,30560,30580,30600,30620,30640,30660,30680,30700,30720,30740,30760,30780,30800,30820,30840,30860,30880,30900,30920,30940,30960,30980,31000,31020,31040,31060,31080,31100,31120,31140,31160,31180,31200,31220,31240,31260,31280,31300,31320,31340,31360,31380,31400,31420,31440,31460,31480,31500,31520,31540,31560,31580,31600,31620,31640,31660,31680,31700,31720,31740,31760,31780,31800,31820,31840,31860,31880,31900,31920,31940,31960,31980,32000,32020,32040,32060,32080,32100,32120,32140,32160,32180,32200,32220,32240,32260,32280,32300,32320,32340,32360,32380,32400,32420,32440,32460,32480,32500,32520,32540,32560,32580,32600,32620,32640,32660,32680,32700,32720,32740,32760,32780,32800,32820,32840,32860,32880,32900,32920,32940,32960,32980,33000,33020,33040,33060,33080,33100,33120,33140,33160,33180,33200,33220,33240,33260,33280,33300,33320,33340,33360,33380,33400,33420,33440,33460,33480,33500,33520,33540,33560,33580,33600,33620,33640,33660,33680,33700,33720,33740,33760,33780,33800,33820,33840,33860,33880,33900,33920,33940,33960,33980,34000,34020,34040,34060,34080,34100,34120,34140,34160,34180,34200,34220,34240,34260,34280,34300,34320,34340,34360,34380,34400,34420,34440,34460,34480,34500,34520,34540,34560,34580,34600,34620,34640,34660,34680,34700,34720,34740,34760,34780,34800,34820,34840,34860,34880,34900,34920,34940,34960,34980,35000,35020,35040,35060,35080,35100,35120,35140,35160,35180,35200,35220,35240,35260,35280,35300,35320,35340,35360,35380,35400,35420,35440,35460,35480,35500,35520,35540,35560,35580,35600,35620,35640,35660,35680,35700,35720,35740,35760,35780,35800,35820,35840,35860,35880,35900,35920,35940,35960,35980,36000,36020,36040,36060,36080,36100,36120,36140,36160,36180,36200,36220,36240,36260,36280,36300,36320,36340,36360,36380,36400,36420,36440,36460,36480,36500,36520,36540,36560,36580,36600,36620,36640,36660,36680,36700,36720,36740,36760,36780,36800,36820,36840,36860,36880,36900,36920,36940,36960,36980,37000,37020,37040,37060,37080,37100,37120,37140,37160,37180,37200,37220,37240,37260,37280,37300,37320,37340,37360,37380,37400,37420,37440,37460,37480,37500,37520,37540,37560,37580,37600,37620,37640,37660,37680,37700,37720,37740,37760,37780,37800,37820,37840,37860,37880,37900,37920,37940,37960,37980,38000,38020,38040,38060,38080,38100,38120,38140,38160,38180,38200,38220,38240,38260,38280,38300,38320,38340,38360,38380,38400,38420,38440,38460,38480,38500,38520,38540,38560,38580,38600,38620,38640,38660,38680,38700,38720,38740,38760,38780,38800,38820,38840,38860,38880,38900,38920,38940,38960,38980,39000,39020,39040,39060,39080,39100,39120,39140,39160,39180,39200,39220,39240,39260,39280,39300,39320,39340,39360,39380,39400,39420,39440,39460,39480,39500,39520,39540,39560,39580,39600,39620,39640,39660,39680,39700,39720,39740,39760,39780,39800,39820,39840,39860,39880,39900,39920,39940,39960,39980,40000,40020,40040,40060,40080,40100,40120,40140,40160,40180,40200,40220,40240,40260,40280,40300,40320,40340,40360,40380,40400,40420,40440,40460,40480,40500,40520,40540,40560,40580,40600,40620,40640,40660,40680,40700,40720,40740,40760,40780,40800,40820,40840,40860,40880,40900,40920,40940,40960,40980,41000,41020,41040,41060,41080,41100,41120,41140,41160,41180,41200,41220,41240,41260,41280,41300,41320,41340,41360,41380,41400,41420,41440,41460,41480,41500,41520,41540,41560,41580,41600,41620,41640,41660,41680,41700,41720,41740,41760,41780,41800,41820,41840,41860,41880,41900,41920,41940,41960,41980,42000,42020,42040,42060,42080,42100,42120,42140,42160,42180,42200,42220,42240,42260,42280,42300,42320,42340,42360,42380,42400,42420,42440,42460,42480,42500,42520,42540,42560,42580,42600,42620,42640,42660,42680,42700,42720,42740,42760,42780,42800,42820,42840,42860,42880,42900,42920,42940,42960,42980,43000,43020,43040,43060,43080,43100,43120,43140,43160,43180,43200,43220,43240,43260,43280,43300,43320,43340,43360,43380,43400,43420,43440,43460,43480,43500,43520,43540,43560,43580,43600,43620,43640,43660,43680,43700,43720,43740,43760,43780,43800,43820,43840,43860,43880,43900,43920,43940,43960,43980,44000,44020,44040,44060,44080,44100,44120,44140,44160,44180,44200,44220,44240,44260,44280,44300,44320,44340,44360,44380,44400,44420,44440,44460,44480,44500,44520,44540,44560,44580,44600,44620,44640,44660,44680,44700,44720,44740,44760,44780,44800,44820,44840,44860,44880,44900,44920,44940,44960,44980,45000,45020,45040,45060,45080,45100,45120,45140,45160,45180,45200,45220,45240,45260,45280,45300,45320,45340,45360,45380,45400,45420,45440,45460,45480,45500,45520,45540,45560,45580,45600,45620,45640,45660,45680,45700,45720,45740,45760,45780,45800,45820,45840,45860,45880,45900,45920,45940,45960,45980,46000,46020,46040,46060,46080,46100,46120,46140,46160,46180,46200,46220,46240,46260,46280,46300,46320,46340,46360,46380,46400,46420,46440,46460,46480,46500,46520,46540,46560,46580,46600,46620,46640,46660,46680,46700,46720,46740,46760,46780,46800,46820,46840,46860,46880,46900,46920,46940,46960,46980,47000,47020,47040,47060,47080,47100,47120,47140,47160,47180,47200,47220,47240,47260,47280,47300,47320,47340,47360,47380,47400,47420,47440,47460,47480,47500,47520,47540,47560,47580,47600,47620,47640,47660,47680,47700,47720,47740,47760,47780,47800,47820,47840,47860,47880,47900,47920,47940,47960,47980,48000,48020,48040,48060,48080,48100,48120,48140,48160,48180,48200,48220,48240,48260,48280,48300,48320,48340,48360,48380,48400,48420,48440,48460,48480,48500,48520,48540,48560,48580,48600,48620,48640,48660,48680,48700,48720,48740,48760,48780,48800,48820,48840,48860,48880,48900,48920,48940,48960,48980,49000,49020,49040,49060,49080,49100,49120,49140,49160,49180,49200,49220,49240,49260,49280,49300,49320,49340,49360,49380,49400,49420,49440,49460,49480,49500,49520,49540,49560,49580,49600,49620,49640,49660,49680,49700,49720,49740,49760,49780,49800,49820,49840,49860,49880,49900,49920,49940,49960,49980,50000,50020,50040,50060,50080,50100,50120,50140,50160,50180,50200,50220,50240,50260,50280,50300,50320,50340,50360,50380,50400,50420,50440,50460,50480,50500,50520,50540,50560,50580,50600,50620,50640,50660,50680,50700,50720,50740,50760,50780,50800,50820,50840,50860,50880,50900,50920,50940,50960,50980,51000,51020,51040,51060,51080,51100,51120,51140,51160,51180,51200,51220,51240,51260,51280,51300,51320,51340,51360,51380,51400,51420,51440,51460,51480,51500,51520,51540,51560,51580,51600,51620,51640,51660,51680,51700,51720,51740,51760,51780,51800,51820,51840,51860,51880,51900,51920,51940,51960,51980,52000,52020,52040,52060,52080,52100,52120,52140,52160,52180,52200,52220,52240,52260,52280,52300,52320,52340,52360,52380,52400,52420,52440,52460,52480,52500,52520,52540,52560,52580,52600,52620,52640,52660,52680,52700,52720,52740,52760,52780,52800,52820,52840,52860,52880,52900,52920,52940,52960,52980,53000,53020,53040,53060,53080,53100,53120,53140,53160,53180,53200,53220,53240,53260,53280,53300,53320,53340,53360,53380,53400,53420,53440,53460,53480,53500,53520,53540,53560,53580,53600,53620,53640,53660,53680,53700,53720,53740,53760,53780,53800,53820,53840,53860,53880,53900,53920,53940,53960,53980,54000,54020,54040,54060,54080,54100,54120,54140,54160,54180,54200,54220,54240,54260,54280,54300,54320,54340,54360,54380,54400,54420,54440,54460,54480,54500,54520,54540,54560,54580,54600,54620,54640,54660,54680,54700,54720,54740,54760,54780,54800,54820,54840,54860,54880,54900,54920,54940,54960,54980,55000,55020,55040,55060,55080,55100,55120,55140,55160,55180,55200,55220,55240,55260,55280,55300,55320,55340,55360,55380,55400,55420,55440,55460,55480,55500,55520,55540,55560,55580,55600,55620,55640,55660,55680,55700,55720,55740,55760,55780,55800,55820,55840,55860,55880,55900,55920,55940,55960,55980,56000,56020,56040,56060,56080,56100,56120,56140,56160,56180,56200,56220,56240,56260,56280,56300,56320,56340,56360,56380,56400,56420,56440,56460,56480,56500,56520,56540,56560,56580,56600,56620,56640,56660,56680,56700,56720,56740,56760,56780,56800,56820,56840,56860,56880,56900,56920,56940,56960,56980,57000,57020,57040,57060,57080,57100,57120,57140,57160,57180,57200,57220,57240,57260,57280,57300,57320,57340,57360,57380,57400,57420,57440,57460,57480,57500,57520,57540,57560,57580,57600,57620,57640,57660,57680,57700,57720,57740,57760,57780,57800,57820,57840,57860,57880,57900,57920,57940,57960,57980,58000,58020,58040,58060,58080,58100,58120,58140,58160,58180,58200,58220,58240,58260,58280,58300,58320,58340,58360,58380,58400,58420,58440,58460,58480,58500,58520,58540,58560,58580,58600,58620,58640,58660,58680,58700,58720,58740,58760,58780,58800,58820,58840,58860,58880,58900,58920,58940,58960,58980,59000,59020,59040,59060,59080,59100,59120,59140,59160,59180,59200,59220,59240,59260,59280,59300,59320,59340,59360,59380,59400,59420,59440,59460,59480,59500,59520,59540,59560,59580,59600,59620,59640,59660,59680,59700,59720,59740,59760,59780,59800,59820,59840,59860,59880,59900,59920,59940,59960,59980],"target":[[0,120],[75,100],[175,80],[225,60],[250,40]]} diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/reference.ts b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/reference.ts index ceb57719220..ecd7a2fd3aa 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/reference.ts +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/reference.ts @@ -151,23 +151,6 @@ export class Estimator { if (this.#origin !== undefined) this.#ended = true; } - /** - * How late the slowest frame in the window arrived against the fastest, in milliseconds: - * NetEq's maximum delay, which widens the time stretch's band rather than the target. Each - * extreme is the oldest on a tie, as the reference is. - */ - get lateness(): number { - let fast: Arrival | undefined; - let slow: Arrival | undefined; - for (const entry of this.#history) { - const key = entry.arrival - entry.media; - if (fast === undefined || key < fast.arrival - fast.media) fast = entry; - if (slow === undefined || key > slow.arrival - slow.media) slow = entry; - } - if (fast === undefined || slow === undefined) return 0; - return Math.max(0, slow.arrival - fast.arrival - (slow.media - fast.media)); - } - /** The target the receiver holds, in milliseconds. */ get target(): number { let cumulative = 0; diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/reorder.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/reorder.json index 96777eac2f9..9db52a7e28f 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/reorder.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/reorder.json @@ -1 +1 @@ -{"name":"reorder","about":"Every other run of five frames delivered after the run that follows it, as newest-first delivery does to a sender's flush. Each held-back run is measured against the fastest frame before it, so the target covers waiting for it; the first one precedes every frame observed and is not measured.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030],"media":[100,120,140,160,180,0,20,40,60,80,300,320,340,360,380,200,220,240,260,280,500,520,540,560,580,400,420,440,460,480,700,720,740,760,780,600,620,640,660,680,900,920,940,960,980,800,820,840,860,880,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880],"target":[[0,120],[25,240]],"lateness":[[0,0]]} +{"name":"reorder","about":"Every other run of five frames delivered after the run that follows it, as newest-first delivery does to a sender's flush. Each held-back run is measured against the fastest frame before it, so the target covers waiting for it; the first one precedes every frame observed and is not measured.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030],"media":[100,120,140,160,180,0,20,40,60,80,300,320,340,360,380,200,220,240,260,280,500,520,540,560,580,400,420,440,460,480,700,720,740,760,780,600,620,640,660,680,900,920,940,960,980,800,820,840,860,880,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880],"target":[[0,120],[25,240]]} diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/silence.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/silence.json index 4be63e5455c..60df4c38167 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/silence.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/silence.json @@ -1 +1 @@ -{"name":"silence","about":"Even audio, a declared end and 60 s of silence, 5 s more, a declared 100 ms pause inside one interval, 5 s more, then an undeclared 30 s gap. Unlike `idle`, a declared silence is not evidence, so the target holds through both; the undeclared gap still relaxes it, since an end covers only the silence it declares.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,70050,70070,70090,70110,70130,70150,70170,70190,70210,70230,70250,70270,70290,70310,70330,70350,70370,70390,70410,70430,70450,70470,70490,70510,70530,70550,70570,70590,70610,70630,70650,70670,70690,70710,70730,70750,70770,70790,70810,70830,70850,70870,70890,70910,70930,70950,70970,70990,71010,71030,71050,71070,71090,71110,71130,71150,71170,71190,71210,71230,71250,71270,71290,71310,71330,71350,71370,71390,71410,71430,71450,71470,71490,71510,71530,71550,71570,71590,71610,71630,71650,71670,71690,71710,71730,71750,71770,71790,71810,71830,71850,71870,71890,71910,71930,71950,71970,71990,72010,72030,72050,72070,72090,72110,72130,72150,72170,72190,72210,72230,72250,72270,72290,72310,72330,72350,72370,72390,72410,72430,72450,72470,72490,72510,72530,72550,72570,72590,72610,72630,72650,72670,72690,72710,72730,72750,72770,72790,72810,72830,72850,72870,72890,72910,72930,72950,72970,72990,73010,73030,73050,73070,73090,73110,73130,73150,73170,73190,73210,73230,73250,73270,73290,73310,73330,73350,73370,73390,73410,73430,73450,73470,73490,73510,73530,73550,73570,73590,73610,73630,73650,73670,73690,73710,73730,73750,73770,73790,73810,73830,73850,73870,73890,73910,73930,73950,73970,73990,74010,74030,74050,74070,74090,74110,74130,74150,74170,74190,74210,74230,74250,74270,74290,74310,74330,74350,74370,74390,74410,74430,74450,74470,74490,74510,74530,74550,74570,74590,74610,74630,74650,74670,74690,74710,74730,74750,74770,74790,74810,74830,74850,74870,74890,74910,74930,74950,74970,74990,75010,75030,75050,75070,75090,75110,75130,75150,75170,75190,75210,75230,75350,75370,75390,75410,75430,75450,75470,75490,75510,75530,75550,75570,75590,75610,75630,75650,75670,75690,75710,75730,75750,75770,75790,75810,75830,75850,75870,75890,75910,75930,75950,75970,75990,76010,76030,76050,76070,76090,76110,76130,76150,76170,76190,76210,76230,76250,76270,76290,76310,76330,76350,76370,76390,76410,76430,76450,76470,76490,76510,76530,76550,76570,76590,76610,76630,76650,76670,76690,76710,76730,76750,76770,76790,76810,76830,76850,76870,76890,76910,76930,76950,76970,76990,77010,77030,77050,77070,77090,77110,77130,77150,77170,77190,77210,77230,77250,77270,77290,77310,77330,77350,77370,77390,77410,77430,77450,77470,77490,77510,77530,77550,77570,77590,77610,77630,77650,77670,77690,77710,77730,77750,77770,77790,77810,77830,77850,77870,77890,77910,77930,77950,77970,77990,78010,78030,78050,78070,78090,78110,78130,78150,78170,78190,78210,78230,78250,78270,78290,78310,78330,78350,78370,78390,78410,78430,78450,78470,78490,78510,78530,78550,78570,78590,78610,78630,78650,78670,78690,78710,78730,78750,78770,78790,78810,78830,78850,78870,78890,78910,78930,78950,78970,78990,79010,79030,79050,79070,79090,79110,79130,79150,79170,79190,79210,79230,79250,79270,79290,79310,79330,79350,79370,79390,79410,79430,79450,79470,79490,79510,79530,79550,79570,79590,79610,79630,79650,79670,79690,79710,79730,79750,79770,79790,79810,79830,79850,79870,79890,79910,79930,79950,79970,79990,80010,80030,80050,80070,80090,80110,80130,110150,110170,110190,110210,110230,110250,110270,110290,110310,110330,110350,110370,110390,110410,110430,110450,110470,110490,110510,110530,110550,110570,110590,110610,110630,110650,110670,110690,110710,110730,110750,110770,110790,110810,110830,110850,110870,110890,110910,110930,110950,110970,110990,111010,111030,111050,111070,111090,111110,111130,111150,111170,111190,111210,111230,111250,111270,111290,111310,111330,111350,111370,111390,111410,111430,111450,111470,111490,111510,111530,111550,111570,111590,111610,111630,111650,111670,111690,111710,111730,111750,111770,111790,111810,111830,111850,111870,111890,111910,111930,111950,111970,111990,112010,112030,112050,112070,112090,112110,112130,112150,112170,112190,112210,112230,112250,112270,112290,112310,112330,112350,112370,112390,112410,112430,112450,112470,112490,112510,112530,112550,112570,112590,112610,112630,112650,112670,112690,112710,112730,112750,112770,112790,112810,112830,112850,112870,112890,112910,112930,112950,112970,112990,113010,113030,113050,113070,113090,113110,113130,113150,113170,113190,113210,113230,113250,113270,113290,113310,113330,113350,113370,113390,113410,113430,113450,113470,113490,113510,113530,113550,113570,113590,113610,113630,113650,113670,113690,113710,113730,113750,113770,113790,113810,113830,113850,113870,113890,113910,113930,113950,113970,113990,114010,114030,114050,114070,114090,114110,114130,114150,114170,114190,114210,114230,114250,114270,114290,114310,114330,114350,114370,114390,114410,114430,114450,114470,114490,114510,114530,114550,114570,114590,114610,114630,114650,114670,114690,114710,114730,114750,114770,114790,114810,114830,114850,114870,114890,114910,114930,114950,114970,114990,115010,115030,115050,115070,115090,115110,115130,115150,115170,115190,115210,115230,115250,115270,115290,115310,115330,115350,115370,115390,115410,115430,115450,115470,115490,115510,115530,115550,115570,115590,115610,115630,115650,115670,115690,115710,115730,115750,115770,115790,115810,115830,115850,115870,115890,115910,115930,115950,115970,115990,116010,116030,116050,116070,116090,116110,116130,116150,116170,116190,116210,116230,116250,116270,116290,116310,116330,116350,116370,116390,116410,116430,116450,116470,116490,116510,116530,116550,116570,116590,116610,116630,116650,116670,116690,116710,116730,116750,116770,116790,116810,116830,116850,116870,116890,116910,116930,116950,116970,116990,117010,117030,117050,117070,117090,117110,117130,117150,117170,117190,117210,117230,117250,117270,117290,117310,117330,117350,117370,117390,117410,117430,117450,117470,117490,117510,117530,117550,117570,117590,117610,117630,117650,117670,117690,117710,117730,117750,117770,117790,117810,117830,117850,117870,117890,117910,117930,117950,117970,117990,118010,118030,118050,118070,118090,118110,118130,118150,118170,118190,118210,118230,118250,118270,118290,118310,118330,118350,118370,118390,118410,118430,118450,118470,118490,118510,118530,118550,118570,118590,118610,118630,118650,118670,118690,118710,118730,118750,118770,118790,118810,118830,118850,118870,118890,118910,118930,118950,118970,118990,119010,119030,119050,119070,119090,119110,119130,119150,119170,119190,119210,119230,119250,119270,119290,119310,119330,119350,119370,119390,119410,119430,119450,119470,119490,119510,119530,119550,119570,119590,119610,119630,119650,119670,119690,119710,119730,119750,119770,119790,119810,119830,119850,119870,119890,119910,119930,119950,119970,119990,120010,120030,120050,120070,120090,120110,120130],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,70000,70020,70040,70060,70080,70100,70120,70140,70160,70180,70200,70220,70240,70260,70280,70300,70320,70340,70360,70380,70400,70420,70440,70460,70480,70500,70520,70540,70560,70580,70600,70620,70640,70660,70680,70700,70720,70740,70760,70780,70800,70820,70840,70860,70880,70900,70920,70940,70960,70980,71000,71020,71040,71060,71080,71100,71120,71140,71160,71180,71200,71220,71240,71260,71280,71300,71320,71340,71360,71380,71400,71420,71440,71460,71480,71500,71520,71540,71560,71580,71600,71620,71640,71660,71680,71700,71720,71740,71760,71780,71800,71820,71840,71860,71880,71900,71920,71940,71960,71980,72000,72020,72040,72060,72080,72100,72120,72140,72160,72180,72200,72220,72240,72260,72280,72300,72320,72340,72360,72380,72400,72420,72440,72460,72480,72500,72520,72540,72560,72580,72600,72620,72640,72660,72680,72700,72720,72740,72760,72780,72800,72820,72840,72860,72880,72900,72920,72940,72960,72980,73000,73020,73040,73060,73080,73100,73120,73140,73160,73180,73200,73220,73240,73260,73280,73300,73320,73340,73360,73380,73400,73420,73440,73460,73480,73500,73520,73540,73560,73580,73600,73620,73640,73660,73680,73700,73720,73740,73760,73780,73800,73820,73840,73860,73880,73900,73920,73940,73960,73980,74000,74020,74040,74060,74080,74100,74120,74140,74160,74180,74200,74220,74240,74260,74280,74300,74320,74340,74360,74380,74400,74420,74440,74460,74480,74500,74520,74540,74560,74580,74600,74620,74640,74660,74680,74700,74720,74740,74760,74780,74800,74820,74840,74860,74880,74900,74920,74940,74960,74980,75000,75020,75040,75060,75080,75100,75120,75140,75160,75180,75300,75320,75340,75360,75380,75400,75420,75440,75460,75480,75500,75520,75540,75560,75580,75600,75620,75640,75660,75680,75700,75720,75740,75760,75780,75800,75820,75840,75860,75880,75900,75920,75940,75960,75980,76000,76020,76040,76060,76080,76100,76120,76140,76160,76180,76200,76220,76240,76260,76280,76300,76320,76340,76360,76380,76400,76420,76440,76460,76480,76500,76520,76540,76560,76580,76600,76620,76640,76660,76680,76700,76720,76740,76760,76780,76800,76820,76840,76860,76880,76900,76920,76940,76960,76980,77000,77020,77040,77060,77080,77100,77120,77140,77160,77180,77200,77220,77240,77260,77280,77300,77320,77340,77360,77380,77400,77420,77440,77460,77480,77500,77520,77540,77560,77580,77600,77620,77640,77660,77680,77700,77720,77740,77760,77780,77800,77820,77840,77860,77880,77900,77920,77940,77960,77980,78000,78020,78040,78060,78080,78100,78120,78140,78160,78180,78200,78220,78240,78260,78280,78300,78320,78340,78360,78380,78400,78420,78440,78460,78480,78500,78520,78540,78560,78580,78600,78620,78640,78660,78680,78700,78720,78740,78760,78780,78800,78820,78840,78860,78880,78900,78920,78940,78960,78980,79000,79020,79040,79060,79080,79100,79120,79140,79160,79180,79200,79220,79240,79260,79280,79300,79320,79340,79360,79380,79400,79420,79440,79460,79480,79500,79520,79540,79560,79580,79600,79620,79640,79660,79680,79700,79720,79740,79760,79780,79800,79820,79840,79860,79880,79900,79920,79940,79960,79980,80000,80020,80040,80060,80080,110100,110120,110140,110160,110180,110200,110220,110240,110260,110280,110300,110320,110340,110360,110380,110400,110420,110440,110460,110480,110500,110520,110540,110560,110580,110600,110620,110640,110660,110680,110700,110720,110740,110760,110780,110800,110820,110840,110860,110880,110900,110920,110940,110960,110980,111000,111020,111040,111060,111080,111100,111120,111140,111160,111180,111200,111220,111240,111260,111280,111300,111320,111340,111360,111380,111400,111420,111440,111460,111480,111500,111520,111540,111560,111580,111600,111620,111640,111660,111680,111700,111720,111740,111760,111780,111800,111820,111840,111860,111880,111900,111920,111940,111960,111980,112000,112020,112040,112060,112080,112100,112120,112140,112160,112180,112200,112220,112240,112260,112280,112300,112320,112340,112360,112380,112400,112420,112440,112460,112480,112500,112520,112540,112560,112580,112600,112620,112640,112660,112680,112700,112720,112740,112760,112780,112800,112820,112840,112860,112880,112900,112920,112940,112960,112980,113000,113020,113040,113060,113080,113100,113120,113140,113160,113180,113200,113220,113240,113260,113280,113300,113320,113340,113360,113380,113400,113420,113440,113460,113480,113500,113520,113540,113560,113580,113600,113620,113640,113660,113680,113700,113720,113740,113760,113780,113800,113820,113840,113860,113880,113900,113920,113940,113960,113980,114000,114020,114040,114060,114080,114100,114120,114140,114160,114180,114200,114220,114240,114260,114280,114300,114320,114340,114360,114380,114400,114420,114440,114460,114480,114500,114520,114540,114560,114580,114600,114620,114640,114660,114680,114700,114720,114740,114760,114780,114800,114820,114840,114860,114880,114900,114920,114940,114960,114980,115000,115020,115040,115060,115080,115100,115120,115140,115160,115180,115200,115220,115240,115260,115280,115300,115320,115340,115360,115380,115400,115420,115440,115460,115480,115500,115520,115540,115560,115580,115600,115620,115640,115660,115680,115700,115720,115740,115760,115780,115800,115820,115840,115860,115880,115900,115920,115940,115960,115980,116000,116020,116040,116060,116080,116100,116120,116140,116160,116180,116200,116220,116240,116260,116280,116300,116320,116340,116360,116380,116400,116420,116440,116460,116480,116500,116520,116540,116560,116580,116600,116620,116640,116660,116680,116700,116720,116740,116760,116780,116800,116820,116840,116860,116880,116900,116920,116940,116960,116980,117000,117020,117040,117060,117080,117100,117120,117140,117160,117180,117200,117220,117240,117260,117280,117300,117320,117340,117360,117380,117400,117420,117440,117460,117480,117500,117520,117540,117560,117580,117600,117620,117640,117660,117680,117700,117720,117740,117760,117780,117800,117820,117840,117860,117880,117900,117920,117940,117960,117980,118000,118020,118040,118060,118080,118100,118120,118140,118160,118180,118200,118220,118240,118260,118280,118300,118320,118340,118360,118380,118400,118420,118440,118460,118480,118500,118520,118540,118560,118580,118600,118620,118640,118660,118680,118700,118720,118740,118760,118780,118800,118820,118840,118860,118880,118900,118920,118940,118960,118980,119000,119020,119040,119060,119080,119100,119120,119140,119160,119180,119200,119220,119240,119260,119280,119300,119320,119340,119360,119380,119400,119420,119440,119460,119480,119500,119520,119540,119560,119580,119600,119620,119640,119660,119680,119700,119720,119740,119760,119780,119800,119820,119840,119860,119880,119900,119920,119940,119960,119980,120000,120020,120040,120060,120080],"ends":[500,760],"target":[[0,120],[75,100],[175,80],[225,60],[250,40],[1000,100],[1070,80],[1120,60],[1145,40]],"lateness":[[0,0]]} +{"name":"silence","about":"Even audio, a declared end and 60 s of silence, 5 s more, a declared 100 ms pause inside one interval, 5 s more, then an undeclared 30 s gap. Unlike `idle`, a declared silence is not evidence, so the target holds through both; the undeclared gap still relaxes it, since an end covers only the silence it declares.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,70050,70070,70090,70110,70130,70150,70170,70190,70210,70230,70250,70270,70290,70310,70330,70350,70370,70390,70410,70430,70450,70470,70490,70510,70530,70550,70570,70590,70610,70630,70650,70670,70690,70710,70730,70750,70770,70790,70810,70830,70850,70870,70890,70910,70930,70950,70970,70990,71010,71030,71050,71070,71090,71110,71130,71150,71170,71190,71210,71230,71250,71270,71290,71310,71330,71350,71370,71390,71410,71430,71450,71470,71490,71510,71530,71550,71570,71590,71610,71630,71650,71670,71690,71710,71730,71750,71770,71790,71810,71830,71850,71870,71890,71910,71930,71950,71970,71990,72010,72030,72050,72070,72090,72110,72130,72150,72170,72190,72210,72230,72250,72270,72290,72310,72330,72350,72370,72390,72410,72430,72450,72470,72490,72510,72530,72550,72570,72590,72610,72630,72650,72670,72690,72710,72730,72750,72770,72790,72810,72830,72850,72870,72890,72910,72930,72950,72970,72990,73010,73030,73050,73070,73090,73110,73130,73150,73170,73190,73210,73230,73250,73270,73290,73310,73330,73350,73370,73390,73410,73430,73450,73470,73490,73510,73530,73550,73570,73590,73610,73630,73650,73670,73690,73710,73730,73750,73770,73790,73810,73830,73850,73870,73890,73910,73930,73950,73970,73990,74010,74030,74050,74070,74090,74110,74130,74150,74170,74190,74210,74230,74250,74270,74290,74310,74330,74350,74370,74390,74410,74430,74450,74470,74490,74510,74530,74550,74570,74590,74610,74630,74650,74670,74690,74710,74730,74750,74770,74790,74810,74830,74850,74870,74890,74910,74930,74950,74970,74990,75010,75030,75050,75070,75090,75110,75130,75150,75170,75190,75210,75230,75350,75370,75390,75410,75430,75450,75470,75490,75510,75530,75550,75570,75590,75610,75630,75650,75670,75690,75710,75730,75750,75770,75790,75810,75830,75850,75870,75890,75910,75930,75950,75970,75990,76010,76030,76050,76070,76090,76110,76130,76150,76170,76190,76210,76230,76250,76270,76290,76310,76330,76350,76370,76390,76410,76430,76450,76470,76490,76510,76530,76550,76570,76590,76610,76630,76650,76670,76690,76710,76730,76750,76770,76790,76810,76830,76850,76870,76890,76910,76930,76950,76970,76990,77010,77030,77050,77070,77090,77110,77130,77150,77170,77190,77210,77230,77250,77270,77290,77310,77330,77350,77370,77390,77410,77430,77450,77470,77490,77510,77530,77550,77570,77590,77610,77630,77650,77670,77690,77710,77730,77750,77770,77790,77810,77830,77850,77870,77890,77910,77930,77950,77970,77990,78010,78030,78050,78070,78090,78110,78130,78150,78170,78190,78210,78230,78250,78270,78290,78310,78330,78350,78370,78390,78410,78430,78450,78470,78490,78510,78530,78550,78570,78590,78610,78630,78650,78670,78690,78710,78730,78750,78770,78790,78810,78830,78850,78870,78890,78910,78930,78950,78970,78990,79010,79030,79050,79070,79090,79110,79130,79150,79170,79190,79210,79230,79250,79270,79290,79310,79330,79350,79370,79390,79410,79430,79450,79470,79490,79510,79530,79550,79570,79590,79610,79630,79650,79670,79690,79710,79730,79750,79770,79790,79810,79830,79850,79870,79890,79910,79930,79950,79970,79990,80010,80030,80050,80070,80090,80110,80130,110150,110170,110190,110210,110230,110250,110270,110290,110310,110330,110350,110370,110390,110410,110430,110450,110470,110490,110510,110530,110550,110570,110590,110610,110630,110650,110670,110690,110710,110730,110750,110770,110790,110810,110830,110850,110870,110890,110910,110930,110950,110970,110990,111010,111030,111050,111070,111090,111110,111130,111150,111170,111190,111210,111230,111250,111270,111290,111310,111330,111350,111370,111390,111410,111430,111450,111470,111490,111510,111530,111550,111570,111590,111610,111630,111650,111670,111690,111710,111730,111750,111770,111790,111810,111830,111850,111870,111890,111910,111930,111950,111970,111990,112010,112030,112050,112070,112090,112110,112130,112150,112170,112190,112210,112230,112250,112270,112290,112310,112330,112350,112370,112390,112410,112430,112450,112470,112490,112510,112530,112550,112570,112590,112610,112630,112650,112670,112690,112710,112730,112750,112770,112790,112810,112830,112850,112870,112890,112910,112930,112950,112970,112990,113010,113030,113050,113070,113090,113110,113130,113150,113170,113190,113210,113230,113250,113270,113290,113310,113330,113350,113370,113390,113410,113430,113450,113470,113490,113510,113530,113550,113570,113590,113610,113630,113650,113670,113690,113710,113730,113750,113770,113790,113810,113830,113850,113870,113890,113910,113930,113950,113970,113990,114010,114030,114050,114070,114090,114110,114130,114150,114170,114190,114210,114230,114250,114270,114290,114310,114330,114350,114370,114390,114410,114430,114450,114470,114490,114510,114530,114550,114570,114590,114610,114630,114650,114670,114690,114710,114730,114750,114770,114790,114810,114830,114850,114870,114890,114910,114930,114950,114970,114990,115010,115030,115050,115070,115090,115110,115130,115150,115170,115190,115210,115230,115250,115270,115290,115310,115330,115350,115370,115390,115410,115430,115450,115470,115490,115510,115530,115550,115570,115590,115610,115630,115650,115670,115690,115710,115730,115750,115770,115790,115810,115830,115850,115870,115890,115910,115930,115950,115970,115990,116010,116030,116050,116070,116090,116110,116130,116150,116170,116190,116210,116230,116250,116270,116290,116310,116330,116350,116370,116390,116410,116430,116450,116470,116490,116510,116530,116550,116570,116590,116610,116630,116650,116670,116690,116710,116730,116750,116770,116790,116810,116830,116850,116870,116890,116910,116930,116950,116970,116990,117010,117030,117050,117070,117090,117110,117130,117150,117170,117190,117210,117230,117250,117270,117290,117310,117330,117350,117370,117390,117410,117430,117450,117470,117490,117510,117530,117550,117570,117590,117610,117630,117650,117670,117690,117710,117730,117750,117770,117790,117810,117830,117850,117870,117890,117910,117930,117950,117970,117990,118010,118030,118050,118070,118090,118110,118130,118150,118170,118190,118210,118230,118250,118270,118290,118310,118330,118350,118370,118390,118410,118430,118450,118470,118490,118510,118530,118550,118570,118590,118610,118630,118650,118670,118690,118710,118730,118750,118770,118790,118810,118830,118850,118870,118890,118910,118930,118950,118970,118990,119010,119030,119050,119070,119090,119110,119130,119150,119170,119190,119210,119230,119250,119270,119290,119310,119330,119350,119370,119390,119410,119430,119450,119470,119490,119510,119530,119550,119570,119590,119610,119630,119650,119670,119690,119710,119730,119750,119770,119790,119810,119830,119850,119870,119890,119910,119930,119950,119970,119990,120010,120030,120050,120070,120090,120110,120130],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,70000,70020,70040,70060,70080,70100,70120,70140,70160,70180,70200,70220,70240,70260,70280,70300,70320,70340,70360,70380,70400,70420,70440,70460,70480,70500,70520,70540,70560,70580,70600,70620,70640,70660,70680,70700,70720,70740,70760,70780,70800,70820,70840,70860,70880,70900,70920,70940,70960,70980,71000,71020,71040,71060,71080,71100,71120,71140,71160,71180,71200,71220,71240,71260,71280,71300,71320,71340,71360,71380,71400,71420,71440,71460,71480,71500,71520,71540,71560,71580,71600,71620,71640,71660,71680,71700,71720,71740,71760,71780,71800,71820,71840,71860,71880,71900,71920,71940,71960,71980,72000,72020,72040,72060,72080,72100,72120,72140,72160,72180,72200,72220,72240,72260,72280,72300,72320,72340,72360,72380,72400,72420,72440,72460,72480,72500,72520,72540,72560,72580,72600,72620,72640,72660,72680,72700,72720,72740,72760,72780,72800,72820,72840,72860,72880,72900,72920,72940,72960,72980,73000,73020,73040,73060,73080,73100,73120,73140,73160,73180,73200,73220,73240,73260,73280,73300,73320,73340,73360,73380,73400,73420,73440,73460,73480,73500,73520,73540,73560,73580,73600,73620,73640,73660,73680,73700,73720,73740,73760,73780,73800,73820,73840,73860,73880,73900,73920,73940,73960,73980,74000,74020,74040,74060,74080,74100,74120,74140,74160,74180,74200,74220,74240,74260,74280,74300,74320,74340,74360,74380,74400,74420,74440,74460,74480,74500,74520,74540,74560,74580,74600,74620,74640,74660,74680,74700,74720,74740,74760,74780,74800,74820,74840,74860,74880,74900,74920,74940,74960,74980,75000,75020,75040,75060,75080,75100,75120,75140,75160,75180,75300,75320,75340,75360,75380,75400,75420,75440,75460,75480,75500,75520,75540,75560,75580,75600,75620,75640,75660,75680,75700,75720,75740,75760,75780,75800,75820,75840,75860,75880,75900,75920,75940,75960,75980,76000,76020,76040,76060,76080,76100,76120,76140,76160,76180,76200,76220,76240,76260,76280,76300,76320,76340,76360,76380,76400,76420,76440,76460,76480,76500,76520,76540,76560,76580,76600,76620,76640,76660,76680,76700,76720,76740,76760,76780,76800,76820,76840,76860,76880,76900,76920,76940,76960,76980,77000,77020,77040,77060,77080,77100,77120,77140,77160,77180,77200,77220,77240,77260,77280,77300,77320,77340,77360,77380,77400,77420,77440,77460,77480,77500,77520,77540,77560,77580,77600,77620,77640,77660,77680,77700,77720,77740,77760,77780,77800,77820,77840,77860,77880,77900,77920,77940,77960,77980,78000,78020,78040,78060,78080,78100,78120,78140,78160,78180,78200,78220,78240,78260,78280,78300,78320,78340,78360,78380,78400,78420,78440,78460,78480,78500,78520,78540,78560,78580,78600,78620,78640,78660,78680,78700,78720,78740,78760,78780,78800,78820,78840,78860,78880,78900,78920,78940,78960,78980,79000,79020,79040,79060,79080,79100,79120,79140,79160,79180,79200,79220,79240,79260,79280,79300,79320,79340,79360,79380,79400,79420,79440,79460,79480,79500,79520,79540,79560,79580,79600,79620,79640,79660,79680,79700,79720,79740,79760,79780,79800,79820,79840,79860,79880,79900,79920,79940,79960,79980,80000,80020,80040,80060,80080,110100,110120,110140,110160,110180,110200,110220,110240,110260,110280,110300,110320,110340,110360,110380,110400,110420,110440,110460,110480,110500,110520,110540,110560,110580,110600,110620,110640,110660,110680,110700,110720,110740,110760,110780,110800,110820,110840,110860,110880,110900,110920,110940,110960,110980,111000,111020,111040,111060,111080,111100,111120,111140,111160,111180,111200,111220,111240,111260,111280,111300,111320,111340,111360,111380,111400,111420,111440,111460,111480,111500,111520,111540,111560,111580,111600,111620,111640,111660,111680,111700,111720,111740,111760,111780,111800,111820,111840,111860,111880,111900,111920,111940,111960,111980,112000,112020,112040,112060,112080,112100,112120,112140,112160,112180,112200,112220,112240,112260,112280,112300,112320,112340,112360,112380,112400,112420,112440,112460,112480,112500,112520,112540,112560,112580,112600,112620,112640,112660,112680,112700,112720,112740,112760,112780,112800,112820,112840,112860,112880,112900,112920,112940,112960,112980,113000,113020,113040,113060,113080,113100,113120,113140,113160,113180,113200,113220,113240,113260,113280,113300,113320,113340,113360,113380,113400,113420,113440,113460,113480,113500,113520,113540,113560,113580,113600,113620,113640,113660,113680,113700,113720,113740,113760,113780,113800,113820,113840,113860,113880,113900,113920,113940,113960,113980,114000,114020,114040,114060,114080,114100,114120,114140,114160,114180,114200,114220,114240,114260,114280,114300,114320,114340,114360,114380,114400,114420,114440,114460,114480,114500,114520,114540,114560,114580,114600,114620,114640,114660,114680,114700,114720,114740,114760,114780,114800,114820,114840,114860,114880,114900,114920,114940,114960,114980,115000,115020,115040,115060,115080,115100,115120,115140,115160,115180,115200,115220,115240,115260,115280,115300,115320,115340,115360,115380,115400,115420,115440,115460,115480,115500,115520,115540,115560,115580,115600,115620,115640,115660,115680,115700,115720,115740,115760,115780,115800,115820,115840,115860,115880,115900,115920,115940,115960,115980,116000,116020,116040,116060,116080,116100,116120,116140,116160,116180,116200,116220,116240,116260,116280,116300,116320,116340,116360,116380,116400,116420,116440,116460,116480,116500,116520,116540,116560,116580,116600,116620,116640,116660,116680,116700,116720,116740,116760,116780,116800,116820,116840,116860,116880,116900,116920,116940,116960,116980,117000,117020,117040,117060,117080,117100,117120,117140,117160,117180,117200,117220,117240,117260,117280,117300,117320,117340,117360,117380,117400,117420,117440,117460,117480,117500,117520,117540,117560,117580,117600,117620,117640,117660,117680,117700,117720,117740,117760,117780,117800,117820,117840,117860,117880,117900,117920,117940,117960,117980,118000,118020,118040,118060,118080,118100,118120,118140,118160,118180,118200,118220,118240,118260,118280,118300,118320,118340,118360,118380,118400,118420,118440,118460,118480,118500,118520,118540,118560,118580,118600,118620,118640,118660,118680,118700,118720,118740,118760,118780,118800,118820,118840,118860,118880,118900,118920,118940,118960,118980,119000,119020,119040,119060,119080,119100,119120,119140,119160,119180,119200,119220,119240,119260,119280,119300,119320,119340,119360,119380,119400,119420,119440,119460,119480,119500,119520,119540,119560,119580,119600,119620,119640,119660,119680,119700,119720,119740,119760,119780,119800,119820,119840,119860,119880,119900,119920,119940,119960,119980,120000,120020,120040,120060,120080],"ends":[500,760],"target":[[0,120],[75,100],[175,80],[225,60],[250,40],[1000,100],[1070,80],[1120,60],[1145,40]]} diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/spike.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/spike.json index 4267911d563..6a043a32acc 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/spike.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/spike.json @@ -1 +1 @@ -{"name":"spike","about":"A 300 ms stall every 5 s for the first 10 s, then 30 s of clean arrivals. The target rises to cover the stalls, then decays at the forget factor once they stop.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030,20050,20070,20090,20110,20130,20150,20170,20190,20210,20230,20250,20270,20290,20310,20330,20350,20370,20390,20410,20430,20450,20470,20490,20510,20530,20550,20570,20590,20610,20630,20650,20670,20690,20710,20730,20750,20770,20790,20810,20830,20850,20870,20890,20910,20930,20950,20970,20990,21010,21030,21050,21070,21090,21110,21130,21150,21170,21190,21210,21230,21250,21270,21290,21310,21330,21350,21370,21390,21410,21430,21450,21470,21490,21510,21530,21550,21570,21590,21610,21630,21650,21670,21690,21710,21730,21750,21770,21790,21810,21830,21850,21870,21890,21910,21930,21950,21970,21990,22010,22030,22050,22070,22090,22110,22130,22150,22170,22190,22210,22230,22250,22270,22290,22310,22330,22350,22370,22390,22410,22430,22450,22470,22490,22510,22530,22550,22570,22590,22610,22630,22650,22670,22690,22710,22730,22750,22770,22790,22810,22830,22850,22870,22890,22910,22930,22950,22970,22990,23010,23030,23050,23070,23090,23110,23130,23150,23170,23190,23210,23230,23250,23270,23290,23310,23330,23350,23370,23390,23410,23430,23450,23470,23490,23510,23530,23550,23570,23590,23610,23630,23650,23670,23690,23710,23730,23750,23770,23790,23810,23830,23850,23870,23890,23910,23930,23950,23970,23990,24010,24030,24050,24070,24090,24110,24130,24150,24170,24190,24210,24230,24250,24270,24290,24310,24330,24350,24370,24390,24410,24430,24450,24470,24490,24510,24530,24550,24570,24590,24610,24630,24650,24670,24690,24710,24730,24750,24770,24790,24810,24830,24850,24870,24890,24910,24930,24950,24970,24990,25010,25030,25050,25070,25090,25110,25130,25150,25170,25190,25210,25230,25250,25270,25290,25310,25330,25350,25370,25390,25410,25430,25450,25470,25490,25510,25530,25550,25570,25590,25610,25630,25650,25670,25690,25710,25730,25750,25770,25790,25810,25830,25850,25870,25890,25910,25930,25950,25970,25990,26010,26030,26050,26070,26090,26110,26130,26150,26170,26190,26210,26230,26250,26270,26290,26310,26330,26350,26370,26390,26410,26430,26450,26470,26490,26510,26530,26550,26570,26590,26610,26630,26650,26670,26690,26710,26730,26750,26770,26790,26810,26830,26850,26870,26890,26910,26930,26950,26970,26990,27010,27030,27050,27070,27090,27110,27130,27150,27170,27190,27210,27230,27250,27270,27290,27310,27330,27350,27370,27390,27410,27430,27450,27470,27490,27510,27530,27550,27570,27590,27610,27630,27650,27670,27690,27710,27730,27750,27770,27790,27810,27830,27850,27870,27890,27910,27930,27950,27970,27990,28010,28030,28050,28070,28090,28110,28130,28150,28170,28190,28210,28230,28250,28270,28290,28310,28330,28350,28370,28390,28410,28430,28450,28470,28490,28510,28530,28550,28570,28590,28610,28630,28650,28670,28690,28710,28730,28750,28770,28790,28810,28830,28850,28870,28890,28910,28930,28950,28970,28990,29010,29030,29050,29070,29090,29110,29130,29150,29170,29190,29210,29230,29250,29270,29290,29310,29330,29350,29370,29390,29410,29430,29450,29470,29490,29510,29530,29550,29570,29590,29610,29630,29650,29670,29690,29710,29730,29750,29770,29790,29810,29830,29850,29870,29890,29910,29930,29950,29970,29990,30010,30030,30050,30070,30090,30110,30130,30150,30170,30190,30210,30230,30250,30270,30290,30310,30330,30350,30370,30390,30410,30430,30450,30470,30490,30510,30530,30550,30570,30590,30610,30630,30650,30670,30690,30710,30730,30750,30770,30790,30810,30830,30850,30870,30890,30910,30930,30950,30970,30990,31010,31030,31050,31070,31090,31110,31130,31150,31170,31190,31210,31230,31250,31270,31290,31310,31330,31350,31370,31390,31410,31430,31450,31470,31490,31510,31530,31550,31570,31590,31610,31630,31650,31670,31690,31710,31730,31750,31770,31790,31810,31830,31850,31870,31890,31910,31930,31950,31970,31990,32010,32030,32050,32070,32090,32110,32130,32150,32170,32190,32210,32230,32250,32270,32290,32310,32330,32350,32370,32390,32410,32430,32450,32470,32490,32510,32530,32550,32570,32590,32610,32630,32650,32670,32690,32710,32730,32750,32770,32790,32810,32830,32850,32870,32890,32910,32930,32950,32970,32990,33010,33030,33050,33070,33090,33110,33130,33150,33170,33190,33210,33230,33250,33270,33290,33310,33330,33350,33370,33390,33410,33430,33450,33470,33490,33510,33530,33550,33570,33590,33610,33630,33650,33670,33690,33710,33730,33750,33770,33790,33810,33830,33850,33870,33890,33910,33930,33950,33970,33990,34010,34030,34050,34070,34090,34110,34130,34150,34170,34190,34210,34230,34250,34270,34290,34310,34330,34350,34370,34390,34410,34430,34450,34470,34490,34510,34530,34550,34570,34590,34610,34630,34650,34670,34690,34710,34730,34750,34770,34790,34810,34830,34850,34870,34890,34910,34930,34950,34970,34990,35010,35030,35050,35070,35090,35110,35130,35150,35170,35190,35210,35230,35250,35270,35290,35310,35330,35350,35370,35390,35410,35430,35450,35470,35490,35510,35530,35550,35570,35590,35610,35630,35650,35670,35690,35710,35730,35750,35770,35790,35810,35830,35850,35870,35890,35910,35930,35950,35970,35990,36010,36030,36050,36070,36090,36110,36130,36150,36170,36190,36210,36230,36250,36270,36290,36310,36330,36350,36370,36390,36410,36430,36450,36470,36490,36510,36530,36550,36570,36590,36610,36630,36650,36670,36690,36710,36730,36750,36770,36790,36810,36830,36850,36870,36890,36910,36930,36950,36970,36990,37010,37030,37050,37070,37090,37110,37130,37150,37170,37190,37210,37230,37250,37270,37290,37310,37330,37350,37370,37390,37410,37430,37450,37470,37490,37510,37530,37550,37570,37590,37610,37630,37650,37670,37690,37710,37730,37750,37770,37790,37810,37830,37850,37870,37890,37910,37930,37950,37970,37990,38010,38030,38050,38070,38090,38110,38130,38150,38170,38190,38210,38230,38250,38270,38290,38310,38330,38350,38370,38390,38410,38430,38450,38470,38490,38510,38530,38550,38570,38590,38610,38630,38650,38670,38690,38710,38730,38750,38770,38790,38810,38830,38850,38870,38890,38910,38930,38950,38970,38990,39010,39030,39050,39070,39090,39110,39130,39150,39170,39190,39210,39230,39250,39270,39290,39310,39330,39350,39370,39390,39410,39430,39450,39470,39490,39510,39530,39550,39570,39590,39610,39630,39650,39670,39690,39710,39730,39750,39770,39790,39810,39830,39850,39870,39890,39910,39930,39950,39970,39990,40010,40030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,20000,20020,20040,20060,20080,20100,20120,20140,20160,20180,20200,20220,20240,20260,20280,20300,20320,20340,20360,20380,20400,20420,20440,20460,20480,20500,20520,20540,20560,20580,20600,20620,20640,20660,20680,20700,20720,20740,20760,20780,20800,20820,20840,20860,20880,20900,20920,20940,20960,20980,21000,21020,21040,21060,21080,21100,21120,21140,21160,21180,21200,21220,21240,21260,21280,21300,21320,21340,21360,21380,21400,21420,21440,21460,21480,21500,21520,21540,21560,21580,21600,21620,21640,21660,21680,21700,21720,21740,21760,21780,21800,21820,21840,21860,21880,21900,21920,21940,21960,21980,22000,22020,22040,22060,22080,22100,22120,22140,22160,22180,22200,22220,22240,22260,22280,22300,22320,22340,22360,22380,22400,22420,22440,22460,22480,22500,22520,22540,22560,22580,22600,22620,22640,22660,22680,22700,22720,22740,22760,22780,22800,22820,22840,22860,22880,22900,22920,22940,22960,22980,23000,23020,23040,23060,23080,23100,23120,23140,23160,23180,23200,23220,23240,23260,23280,23300,23320,23340,23360,23380,23400,23420,23440,23460,23480,23500,23520,23540,23560,23580,23600,23620,23640,23660,23680,23700,23720,23740,23760,23780,23800,23820,23840,23860,23880,23900,23920,23940,23960,23980,24000,24020,24040,24060,24080,24100,24120,24140,24160,24180,24200,24220,24240,24260,24280,24300,24320,24340,24360,24380,24400,24420,24440,24460,24480,24500,24520,24540,24560,24580,24600,24620,24640,24660,24680,24700,24720,24740,24760,24780,24800,24820,24840,24860,24880,24900,24920,24940,24960,24980,25000,25020,25040,25060,25080,25100,25120,25140,25160,25180,25200,25220,25240,25260,25280,25300,25320,25340,25360,25380,25400,25420,25440,25460,25480,25500,25520,25540,25560,25580,25600,25620,25640,25660,25680,25700,25720,25740,25760,25780,25800,25820,25840,25860,25880,25900,25920,25940,25960,25980,26000,26020,26040,26060,26080,26100,26120,26140,26160,26180,26200,26220,26240,26260,26280,26300,26320,26340,26360,26380,26400,26420,26440,26460,26480,26500,26520,26540,26560,26580,26600,26620,26640,26660,26680,26700,26720,26740,26760,26780,26800,26820,26840,26860,26880,26900,26920,26940,26960,26980,27000,27020,27040,27060,27080,27100,27120,27140,27160,27180,27200,27220,27240,27260,27280,27300,27320,27340,27360,27380,27400,27420,27440,27460,27480,27500,27520,27540,27560,27580,27600,27620,27640,27660,27680,27700,27720,27740,27760,27780,27800,27820,27840,27860,27880,27900,27920,27940,27960,27980,28000,28020,28040,28060,28080,28100,28120,28140,28160,28180,28200,28220,28240,28260,28280,28300,28320,28340,28360,28380,28400,28420,28440,28460,28480,28500,28520,28540,28560,28580,28600,28620,28640,28660,28680,28700,28720,28740,28760,28780,28800,28820,28840,28860,28880,28900,28920,28940,28960,28980,29000,29020,29040,29060,29080,29100,29120,29140,29160,29180,29200,29220,29240,29260,29280,29300,29320,29340,29360,29380,29400,29420,29440,29460,29480,29500,29520,29540,29560,29580,29600,29620,29640,29660,29680,29700,29720,29740,29760,29780,29800,29820,29840,29860,29880,29900,29920,29940,29960,29980,30000,30020,30040,30060,30080,30100,30120,30140,30160,30180,30200,30220,30240,30260,30280,30300,30320,30340,30360,30380,30400,30420,30440,30460,30480,30500,30520,30540,30560,30580,30600,30620,30640,30660,30680,30700,30720,30740,30760,30780,30800,30820,30840,30860,30880,30900,30920,30940,30960,30980,31000,31020,31040,31060,31080,31100,31120,31140,31160,31180,31200,31220,31240,31260,31280,31300,31320,31340,31360,31380,31400,31420,31440,31460,31480,31500,31520,31540,31560,31580,31600,31620,31640,31660,31680,31700,31720,31740,31760,31780,31800,31820,31840,31860,31880,31900,31920,31940,31960,31980,32000,32020,32040,32060,32080,32100,32120,32140,32160,32180,32200,32220,32240,32260,32280,32300,32320,32340,32360,32380,32400,32420,32440,32460,32480,32500,32520,32540,32560,32580,32600,32620,32640,32660,32680,32700,32720,32740,32760,32780,32800,32820,32840,32860,32880,32900,32920,32940,32960,32980,33000,33020,33040,33060,33080,33100,33120,33140,33160,33180,33200,33220,33240,33260,33280,33300,33320,33340,33360,33380,33400,33420,33440,33460,33480,33500,33520,33540,33560,33580,33600,33620,33640,33660,33680,33700,33720,33740,33760,33780,33800,33820,33840,33860,33880,33900,33920,33940,33960,33980,34000,34020,34040,34060,34080,34100,34120,34140,34160,34180,34200,34220,34240,34260,34280,34300,34320,34340,34360,34380,34400,34420,34440,34460,34480,34500,34520,34540,34560,34580,34600,34620,34640,34660,34680,34700,34720,34740,34760,34780,34800,34820,34840,34860,34880,34900,34920,34940,34960,34980,35000,35020,35040,35060,35080,35100,35120,35140,35160,35180,35200,35220,35240,35260,35280,35300,35320,35340,35360,35380,35400,35420,35440,35460,35480,35500,35520,35540,35560,35580,35600,35620,35640,35660,35680,35700,35720,35740,35760,35780,35800,35820,35840,35860,35880,35900,35920,35940,35960,35980,36000,36020,36040,36060,36080,36100,36120,36140,36160,36180,36200,36220,36240,36260,36280,36300,36320,36340,36360,36380,36400,36420,36440,36460,36480,36500,36520,36540,36560,36580,36600,36620,36640,36660,36680,36700,36720,36740,36760,36780,36800,36820,36840,36860,36880,36900,36920,36940,36960,36980,37000,37020,37040,37060,37080,37100,37120,37140,37160,37180,37200,37220,37240,37260,37280,37300,37320,37340,37360,37380,37400,37420,37440,37460,37480,37500,37520,37540,37560,37580,37600,37620,37640,37660,37680,37700,37720,37740,37760,37780,37800,37820,37840,37860,37880,37900,37920,37940,37960,37980,38000,38020,38040,38060,38080,38100,38120,38140,38160,38180,38200,38220,38240,38260,38280,38300,38320,38340,38360,38380,38400,38420,38440,38460,38480,38500,38520,38540,38560,38580,38600,38620,38640,38660,38680,38700,38720,38740,38760,38780,38800,38820,38840,38860,38880,38900,38920,38940,38960,38980,39000,39020,39040,39060,39080,39100,39120,39140,39160,39180,39200,39220,39240,39260,39280,39300,39320,39340,39360,39380,39400,39420,39440,39460,39480,39500,39520,39540,39560,39580,39600,39620,39640,39660,39680,39700,39720,39740,39760,39780,39800,39820,39840,39860,39880,39900,39920,39940,39960,39980],"target":[[0,120],[75,100],[175,80],[225,60],[250,40],[275,320],[1425,40]],"lateness":[[0,0],[250,280],[351,260],[352,240],[353,220],[354,200],[355,180],[356,160],[357,140],[358,120],[359,100],[360,80],[361,60],[362,40],[363,20],[364,0],[500,280],[601,260],[602,240],[603,220],[604,200],[605,180],[606,160],[607,140],[608,120],[609,100],[610,80],[611,60],[612,40],[613,20],[614,0]]} +{"name":"spike","about":"A 300 ms stall every 5 s for the first 10 s, then 30 s of clean arrivals. The target rises to cover the stalls, then decays at the forget factor once they stop.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030,20050,20070,20090,20110,20130,20150,20170,20190,20210,20230,20250,20270,20290,20310,20330,20350,20370,20390,20410,20430,20450,20470,20490,20510,20530,20550,20570,20590,20610,20630,20650,20670,20690,20710,20730,20750,20770,20790,20810,20830,20850,20870,20890,20910,20930,20950,20970,20990,21010,21030,21050,21070,21090,21110,21130,21150,21170,21190,21210,21230,21250,21270,21290,21310,21330,21350,21370,21390,21410,21430,21450,21470,21490,21510,21530,21550,21570,21590,21610,21630,21650,21670,21690,21710,21730,21750,21770,21790,21810,21830,21850,21870,21890,21910,21930,21950,21970,21990,22010,22030,22050,22070,22090,22110,22130,22150,22170,22190,22210,22230,22250,22270,22290,22310,22330,22350,22370,22390,22410,22430,22450,22470,22490,22510,22530,22550,22570,22590,22610,22630,22650,22670,22690,22710,22730,22750,22770,22790,22810,22830,22850,22870,22890,22910,22930,22950,22970,22990,23010,23030,23050,23070,23090,23110,23130,23150,23170,23190,23210,23230,23250,23270,23290,23310,23330,23350,23370,23390,23410,23430,23450,23470,23490,23510,23530,23550,23570,23590,23610,23630,23650,23670,23690,23710,23730,23750,23770,23790,23810,23830,23850,23870,23890,23910,23930,23950,23970,23990,24010,24030,24050,24070,24090,24110,24130,24150,24170,24190,24210,24230,24250,24270,24290,24310,24330,24350,24370,24390,24410,24430,24450,24470,24490,24510,24530,24550,24570,24590,24610,24630,24650,24670,24690,24710,24730,24750,24770,24790,24810,24830,24850,24870,24890,24910,24930,24950,24970,24990,25010,25030,25050,25070,25090,25110,25130,25150,25170,25190,25210,25230,25250,25270,25290,25310,25330,25350,25370,25390,25410,25430,25450,25470,25490,25510,25530,25550,25570,25590,25610,25630,25650,25670,25690,25710,25730,25750,25770,25790,25810,25830,25850,25870,25890,25910,25930,25950,25970,25990,26010,26030,26050,26070,26090,26110,26130,26150,26170,26190,26210,26230,26250,26270,26290,26310,26330,26350,26370,26390,26410,26430,26450,26470,26490,26510,26530,26550,26570,26590,26610,26630,26650,26670,26690,26710,26730,26750,26770,26790,26810,26830,26850,26870,26890,26910,26930,26950,26970,26990,27010,27030,27050,27070,27090,27110,27130,27150,27170,27190,27210,27230,27250,27270,27290,27310,27330,27350,27370,27390,27410,27430,27450,27470,27490,27510,27530,27550,27570,27590,27610,27630,27650,27670,27690,27710,27730,27750,27770,27790,27810,27830,27850,27870,27890,27910,27930,27950,27970,27990,28010,28030,28050,28070,28090,28110,28130,28150,28170,28190,28210,28230,28250,28270,28290,28310,28330,28350,28370,28390,28410,28430,28450,28470,28490,28510,28530,28550,28570,28590,28610,28630,28650,28670,28690,28710,28730,28750,28770,28790,28810,28830,28850,28870,28890,28910,28930,28950,28970,28990,29010,29030,29050,29070,29090,29110,29130,29150,29170,29190,29210,29230,29250,29270,29290,29310,29330,29350,29370,29390,29410,29430,29450,29470,29490,29510,29530,29550,29570,29590,29610,29630,29650,29670,29690,29710,29730,29750,29770,29790,29810,29830,29850,29870,29890,29910,29930,29950,29970,29990,30010,30030,30050,30070,30090,30110,30130,30150,30170,30190,30210,30230,30250,30270,30290,30310,30330,30350,30370,30390,30410,30430,30450,30470,30490,30510,30530,30550,30570,30590,30610,30630,30650,30670,30690,30710,30730,30750,30770,30790,30810,30830,30850,30870,30890,30910,30930,30950,30970,30990,31010,31030,31050,31070,31090,31110,31130,31150,31170,31190,31210,31230,31250,31270,31290,31310,31330,31350,31370,31390,31410,31430,31450,31470,31490,31510,31530,31550,31570,31590,31610,31630,31650,31670,31690,31710,31730,31750,31770,31790,31810,31830,31850,31870,31890,31910,31930,31950,31970,31990,32010,32030,32050,32070,32090,32110,32130,32150,32170,32190,32210,32230,32250,32270,32290,32310,32330,32350,32370,32390,32410,32430,32450,32470,32490,32510,32530,32550,32570,32590,32610,32630,32650,32670,32690,32710,32730,32750,32770,32790,32810,32830,32850,32870,32890,32910,32930,32950,32970,32990,33010,33030,33050,33070,33090,33110,33130,33150,33170,33190,33210,33230,33250,33270,33290,33310,33330,33350,33370,33390,33410,33430,33450,33470,33490,33510,33530,33550,33570,33590,33610,33630,33650,33670,33690,33710,33730,33750,33770,33790,33810,33830,33850,33870,33890,33910,33930,33950,33970,33990,34010,34030,34050,34070,34090,34110,34130,34150,34170,34190,34210,34230,34250,34270,34290,34310,34330,34350,34370,34390,34410,34430,34450,34470,34490,34510,34530,34550,34570,34590,34610,34630,34650,34670,34690,34710,34730,34750,34770,34790,34810,34830,34850,34870,34890,34910,34930,34950,34970,34990,35010,35030,35050,35070,35090,35110,35130,35150,35170,35190,35210,35230,35250,35270,35290,35310,35330,35350,35370,35390,35410,35430,35450,35470,35490,35510,35530,35550,35570,35590,35610,35630,35650,35670,35690,35710,35730,35750,35770,35790,35810,35830,35850,35870,35890,35910,35930,35950,35970,35990,36010,36030,36050,36070,36090,36110,36130,36150,36170,36190,36210,36230,36250,36270,36290,36310,36330,36350,36370,36390,36410,36430,36450,36470,36490,36510,36530,36550,36570,36590,36610,36630,36650,36670,36690,36710,36730,36750,36770,36790,36810,36830,36850,36870,36890,36910,36930,36950,36970,36990,37010,37030,37050,37070,37090,37110,37130,37150,37170,37190,37210,37230,37250,37270,37290,37310,37330,37350,37370,37390,37410,37430,37450,37470,37490,37510,37530,37550,37570,37590,37610,37630,37650,37670,37690,37710,37730,37750,37770,37790,37810,37830,37850,37870,37890,37910,37930,37950,37970,37990,38010,38030,38050,38070,38090,38110,38130,38150,38170,38190,38210,38230,38250,38270,38290,38310,38330,38350,38370,38390,38410,38430,38450,38470,38490,38510,38530,38550,38570,38590,38610,38630,38650,38670,38690,38710,38730,38750,38770,38790,38810,38830,38850,38870,38890,38910,38930,38950,38970,38990,39010,39030,39050,39070,39090,39110,39130,39150,39170,39190,39210,39230,39250,39270,39290,39310,39330,39350,39370,39390,39410,39430,39450,39470,39490,39510,39530,39550,39570,39590,39610,39630,39650,39670,39690,39710,39730,39750,39770,39790,39810,39830,39850,39870,39890,39910,39930,39950,39970,39990,40010,40030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,20000,20020,20040,20060,20080,20100,20120,20140,20160,20180,20200,20220,20240,20260,20280,20300,20320,20340,20360,20380,20400,20420,20440,20460,20480,20500,20520,20540,20560,20580,20600,20620,20640,20660,20680,20700,20720,20740,20760,20780,20800,20820,20840,20860,20880,20900,20920,20940,20960,20980,21000,21020,21040,21060,21080,21100,21120,21140,21160,21180,21200,21220,21240,21260,21280,21300,21320,21340,21360,21380,21400,21420,21440,21460,21480,21500,21520,21540,21560,21580,21600,21620,21640,21660,21680,21700,21720,21740,21760,21780,21800,21820,21840,21860,21880,21900,21920,21940,21960,21980,22000,22020,22040,22060,22080,22100,22120,22140,22160,22180,22200,22220,22240,22260,22280,22300,22320,22340,22360,22380,22400,22420,22440,22460,22480,22500,22520,22540,22560,22580,22600,22620,22640,22660,22680,22700,22720,22740,22760,22780,22800,22820,22840,22860,22880,22900,22920,22940,22960,22980,23000,23020,23040,23060,23080,23100,23120,23140,23160,23180,23200,23220,23240,23260,23280,23300,23320,23340,23360,23380,23400,23420,23440,23460,23480,23500,23520,23540,23560,23580,23600,23620,23640,23660,23680,23700,23720,23740,23760,23780,23800,23820,23840,23860,23880,23900,23920,23940,23960,23980,24000,24020,24040,24060,24080,24100,24120,24140,24160,24180,24200,24220,24240,24260,24280,24300,24320,24340,24360,24380,24400,24420,24440,24460,24480,24500,24520,24540,24560,24580,24600,24620,24640,24660,24680,24700,24720,24740,24760,24780,24800,24820,24840,24860,24880,24900,24920,24940,24960,24980,25000,25020,25040,25060,25080,25100,25120,25140,25160,25180,25200,25220,25240,25260,25280,25300,25320,25340,25360,25380,25400,25420,25440,25460,25480,25500,25520,25540,25560,25580,25600,25620,25640,25660,25680,25700,25720,25740,25760,25780,25800,25820,25840,25860,25880,25900,25920,25940,25960,25980,26000,26020,26040,26060,26080,26100,26120,26140,26160,26180,26200,26220,26240,26260,26280,26300,26320,26340,26360,26380,26400,26420,26440,26460,26480,26500,26520,26540,26560,26580,26600,26620,26640,26660,26680,26700,26720,26740,26760,26780,26800,26820,26840,26860,26880,26900,26920,26940,26960,26980,27000,27020,27040,27060,27080,27100,27120,27140,27160,27180,27200,27220,27240,27260,27280,27300,27320,27340,27360,27380,27400,27420,27440,27460,27480,27500,27520,27540,27560,27580,27600,27620,27640,27660,27680,27700,27720,27740,27760,27780,27800,27820,27840,27860,27880,27900,27920,27940,27960,27980,28000,28020,28040,28060,28080,28100,28120,28140,28160,28180,28200,28220,28240,28260,28280,28300,28320,28340,28360,28380,28400,28420,28440,28460,28480,28500,28520,28540,28560,28580,28600,28620,28640,28660,28680,28700,28720,28740,28760,28780,28800,28820,28840,28860,28880,28900,28920,28940,28960,28980,29000,29020,29040,29060,29080,29100,29120,29140,29160,29180,29200,29220,29240,29260,29280,29300,29320,29340,29360,29380,29400,29420,29440,29460,29480,29500,29520,29540,29560,29580,29600,29620,29640,29660,29680,29700,29720,29740,29760,29780,29800,29820,29840,29860,29880,29900,29920,29940,29960,29980,30000,30020,30040,30060,30080,30100,30120,30140,30160,30180,30200,30220,30240,30260,30280,30300,30320,30340,30360,30380,30400,30420,30440,30460,30480,30500,30520,30540,30560,30580,30600,30620,30640,30660,30680,30700,30720,30740,30760,30780,30800,30820,30840,30860,30880,30900,30920,30940,30960,30980,31000,31020,31040,31060,31080,31100,31120,31140,31160,31180,31200,31220,31240,31260,31280,31300,31320,31340,31360,31380,31400,31420,31440,31460,31480,31500,31520,31540,31560,31580,31600,31620,31640,31660,31680,31700,31720,31740,31760,31780,31800,31820,31840,31860,31880,31900,31920,31940,31960,31980,32000,32020,32040,32060,32080,32100,32120,32140,32160,32180,32200,32220,32240,32260,32280,32300,32320,32340,32360,32380,32400,32420,32440,32460,32480,32500,32520,32540,32560,32580,32600,32620,32640,32660,32680,32700,32720,32740,32760,32780,32800,32820,32840,32860,32880,32900,32920,32940,32960,32980,33000,33020,33040,33060,33080,33100,33120,33140,33160,33180,33200,33220,33240,33260,33280,33300,33320,33340,33360,33380,33400,33420,33440,33460,33480,33500,33520,33540,33560,33580,33600,33620,33640,33660,33680,33700,33720,33740,33760,33780,33800,33820,33840,33860,33880,33900,33920,33940,33960,33980,34000,34020,34040,34060,34080,34100,34120,34140,34160,34180,34200,34220,34240,34260,34280,34300,34320,34340,34360,34380,34400,34420,34440,34460,34480,34500,34520,34540,34560,34580,34600,34620,34640,34660,34680,34700,34720,34740,34760,34780,34800,34820,34840,34860,34880,34900,34920,34940,34960,34980,35000,35020,35040,35060,35080,35100,35120,35140,35160,35180,35200,35220,35240,35260,35280,35300,35320,35340,35360,35380,35400,35420,35440,35460,35480,35500,35520,35540,35560,35580,35600,35620,35640,35660,35680,35700,35720,35740,35760,35780,35800,35820,35840,35860,35880,35900,35920,35940,35960,35980,36000,36020,36040,36060,36080,36100,36120,36140,36160,36180,36200,36220,36240,36260,36280,36300,36320,36340,36360,36380,36400,36420,36440,36460,36480,36500,36520,36540,36560,36580,36600,36620,36640,36660,36680,36700,36720,36740,36760,36780,36800,36820,36840,36860,36880,36900,36920,36940,36960,36980,37000,37020,37040,37060,37080,37100,37120,37140,37160,37180,37200,37220,37240,37260,37280,37300,37320,37340,37360,37380,37400,37420,37440,37460,37480,37500,37520,37540,37560,37580,37600,37620,37640,37660,37680,37700,37720,37740,37760,37780,37800,37820,37840,37860,37880,37900,37920,37940,37960,37980,38000,38020,38040,38060,38080,38100,38120,38140,38160,38180,38200,38220,38240,38260,38280,38300,38320,38340,38360,38380,38400,38420,38440,38460,38480,38500,38520,38540,38560,38580,38600,38620,38640,38660,38680,38700,38720,38740,38760,38780,38800,38820,38840,38860,38880,38900,38920,38940,38960,38980,39000,39020,39040,39060,39080,39100,39120,39140,39160,39180,39200,39220,39240,39260,39280,39300,39320,39340,39360,39380,39400,39420,39440,39460,39480,39500,39520,39540,39560,39580,39600,39620,39640,39660,39680,39700,39720,39740,39760,39780,39800,39820,39840,39860,39880,39900,39920,39940,39960,39980],"target":[[0,120],[75,100],[175,80],[225,60],[250,40],[275,320],[1425,40]]} diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/straggler.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/straggler.json index e7b9bee2255..78eab34d46b 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/straggler.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/straggler.json @@ -1 +1 @@ -{"name":"straggler","about":"Even audio with a single 300 ms stall 8 s in, once the prior is spent. One interval of evidence is not enough to move the target, so the stall costs that one refill instead of raising the target and then dropping it, which skips buffered audio.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030,20050,20070,20090,20110,20130,20150,20170,20190,20210,20230,20250,20270,20290,20310,20330,20350,20370,20390,20410,20430,20450,20470,20490,20510,20530,20550,20570,20590,20610,20630,20650,20670,20690,20710,20730,20750,20770,20790,20810,20830,20850,20870,20890,20910,20930,20950,20970,20990,21010,21030,21050,21070,21090,21110,21130,21150,21170,21190,21210,21230,21250,21270,21290,21310,21330,21350,21370,21390,21410,21430,21450,21470,21490,21510,21530,21550,21570,21590,21610,21630,21650,21670,21690,21710,21730,21750,21770,21790,21810,21830,21850,21870,21890,21910,21930,21950,21970,21990,22010,22030,22050,22070,22090,22110,22130,22150,22170,22190,22210,22230,22250,22270,22290,22310,22330,22350,22370,22390,22410,22430,22450,22470,22490,22510,22530,22550,22570,22590,22610,22630,22650,22670,22690,22710,22730,22750,22770,22790,22810,22830,22850,22870,22890,22910,22930,22950,22970,22990,23010,23030,23050,23070,23090,23110,23130,23150,23170,23190,23210,23230,23250,23270,23290,23310,23330,23350,23370,23390,23410,23430,23450,23470,23490,23510,23530,23550,23570,23590,23610,23630,23650,23670,23690,23710,23730,23750,23770,23790,23810,23830,23850,23870,23890,23910,23930,23950,23970,23990,24010,24030,24050,24070,24090,24110,24130,24150,24170,24190,24210,24230,24250,24270,24290,24310,24330,24350,24370,24390,24410,24430,24450,24470,24490,24510,24530,24550,24570,24590,24610,24630,24650,24670,24690,24710,24730,24750,24770,24790,24810,24830,24850,24870,24890,24910,24930,24950,24970,24990,25010,25030,25050,25070,25090,25110,25130,25150,25170,25190,25210,25230,25250,25270,25290,25310,25330,25350,25370,25390,25410,25430,25450,25470,25490,25510,25530,25550,25570,25590,25610,25630,25650,25670,25690,25710,25730,25750,25770,25790,25810,25830,25850,25870,25890,25910,25930,25950,25970,25990,26010,26030,26050,26070,26090,26110,26130,26150,26170,26190,26210,26230,26250,26270,26290,26310,26330,26350,26370,26390,26410,26430,26450,26470,26490,26510,26530,26550,26570,26590,26610,26630,26650,26670,26690,26710,26730,26750,26770,26790,26810,26830,26850,26870,26890,26910,26930,26950,26970,26990,27010,27030,27050,27070,27090,27110,27130,27150,27170,27190,27210,27230,27250,27270,27290,27310,27330,27350,27370,27390,27410,27430,27450,27470,27490,27510,27530,27550,27570,27590,27610,27630,27650,27670,27690,27710,27730,27750,27770,27790,27810,27830,27850,27870,27890,27910,27930,27950,27970,27990,28010,28030,28050,28070,28090,28110,28130,28150,28170,28190,28210,28230,28250,28270,28290,28310,28330,28350,28370,28390,28410,28430,28450,28470,28490,28510,28530,28550,28570,28590,28610,28630,28650,28670,28690,28710,28730,28750,28770,28790,28810,28830,28850,28870,28890,28910,28930,28950,28970,28990,29010,29030,29050,29070,29090,29110,29130,29150,29170,29190,29210,29230,29250,29270,29290,29310,29330,29350,29370,29390,29410,29430,29450,29470,29490,29510,29530,29550,29570,29590,29610,29630,29650,29670,29690,29710,29730,29750,29770,29790,29810,29830,29850,29870,29890,29910,29930,29950,29970,29990,30010,30030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,20000,20020,20040,20060,20080,20100,20120,20140,20160,20180,20200,20220,20240,20260,20280,20300,20320,20340,20360,20380,20400,20420,20440,20460,20480,20500,20520,20540,20560,20580,20600,20620,20640,20660,20680,20700,20720,20740,20760,20780,20800,20820,20840,20860,20880,20900,20920,20940,20960,20980,21000,21020,21040,21060,21080,21100,21120,21140,21160,21180,21200,21220,21240,21260,21280,21300,21320,21340,21360,21380,21400,21420,21440,21460,21480,21500,21520,21540,21560,21580,21600,21620,21640,21660,21680,21700,21720,21740,21760,21780,21800,21820,21840,21860,21880,21900,21920,21940,21960,21980,22000,22020,22040,22060,22080,22100,22120,22140,22160,22180,22200,22220,22240,22260,22280,22300,22320,22340,22360,22380,22400,22420,22440,22460,22480,22500,22520,22540,22560,22580,22600,22620,22640,22660,22680,22700,22720,22740,22760,22780,22800,22820,22840,22860,22880,22900,22920,22940,22960,22980,23000,23020,23040,23060,23080,23100,23120,23140,23160,23180,23200,23220,23240,23260,23280,23300,23320,23340,23360,23380,23400,23420,23440,23460,23480,23500,23520,23540,23560,23580,23600,23620,23640,23660,23680,23700,23720,23740,23760,23780,23800,23820,23840,23860,23880,23900,23920,23940,23960,23980,24000,24020,24040,24060,24080,24100,24120,24140,24160,24180,24200,24220,24240,24260,24280,24300,24320,24340,24360,24380,24400,24420,24440,24460,24480,24500,24520,24540,24560,24580,24600,24620,24640,24660,24680,24700,24720,24740,24760,24780,24800,24820,24840,24860,24880,24900,24920,24940,24960,24980,25000,25020,25040,25060,25080,25100,25120,25140,25160,25180,25200,25220,25240,25260,25280,25300,25320,25340,25360,25380,25400,25420,25440,25460,25480,25500,25520,25540,25560,25580,25600,25620,25640,25660,25680,25700,25720,25740,25760,25780,25800,25820,25840,25860,25880,25900,25920,25940,25960,25980,26000,26020,26040,26060,26080,26100,26120,26140,26160,26180,26200,26220,26240,26260,26280,26300,26320,26340,26360,26380,26400,26420,26440,26460,26480,26500,26520,26540,26560,26580,26600,26620,26640,26660,26680,26700,26720,26740,26760,26780,26800,26820,26840,26860,26880,26900,26920,26940,26960,26980,27000,27020,27040,27060,27080,27100,27120,27140,27160,27180,27200,27220,27240,27260,27280,27300,27320,27340,27360,27380,27400,27420,27440,27460,27480,27500,27520,27540,27560,27580,27600,27620,27640,27660,27680,27700,27720,27740,27760,27780,27800,27820,27840,27860,27880,27900,27920,27940,27960,27980,28000,28020,28040,28060,28080,28100,28120,28140,28160,28180,28200,28220,28240,28260,28280,28300,28320,28340,28360,28380,28400,28420,28440,28460,28480,28500,28520,28540,28560,28580,28600,28620,28640,28660,28680,28700,28720,28740,28760,28780,28800,28820,28840,28860,28880,28900,28920,28940,28960,28980,29000,29020,29040,29060,29080,29100,29120,29140,29160,29180,29200,29220,29240,29260,29280,29300,29320,29340,29360,29380,29400,29420,29440,29460,29480,29500,29520,29540,29560,29580,29600,29620,29640,29660,29680,29700,29720,29740,29760,29780,29800,29820,29840,29860,29880,29900,29920,29940,29960,29980],"target":[[0,120],[75,100],[175,80],[225,60],[250,40]],"lateness":[[0,0],[400,280],[501,260],[502,240],[503,220],[504,200],[505,180],[506,160],[507,140],[508,120],[509,100],[510,80],[511,60],[512,40],[513,20],[514,0]]} +{"name":"straggler","about":"Even audio with a single 300 ms stall 8 s in, once the prior is spent. One interval of evidence is not enough to move the target, so the stall costs that one refill instead of raising the target and then dropping it, which skips buffered audio.","frame":20,"arrival":[50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030,20050,20070,20090,20110,20130,20150,20170,20190,20210,20230,20250,20270,20290,20310,20330,20350,20370,20390,20410,20430,20450,20470,20490,20510,20530,20550,20570,20590,20610,20630,20650,20670,20690,20710,20730,20750,20770,20790,20810,20830,20850,20870,20890,20910,20930,20950,20970,20990,21010,21030,21050,21070,21090,21110,21130,21150,21170,21190,21210,21230,21250,21270,21290,21310,21330,21350,21370,21390,21410,21430,21450,21470,21490,21510,21530,21550,21570,21590,21610,21630,21650,21670,21690,21710,21730,21750,21770,21790,21810,21830,21850,21870,21890,21910,21930,21950,21970,21990,22010,22030,22050,22070,22090,22110,22130,22150,22170,22190,22210,22230,22250,22270,22290,22310,22330,22350,22370,22390,22410,22430,22450,22470,22490,22510,22530,22550,22570,22590,22610,22630,22650,22670,22690,22710,22730,22750,22770,22790,22810,22830,22850,22870,22890,22910,22930,22950,22970,22990,23010,23030,23050,23070,23090,23110,23130,23150,23170,23190,23210,23230,23250,23270,23290,23310,23330,23350,23370,23390,23410,23430,23450,23470,23490,23510,23530,23550,23570,23590,23610,23630,23650,23670,23690,23710,23730,23750,23770,23790,23810,23830,23850,23870,23890,23910,23930,23950,23970,23990,24010,24030,24050,24070,24090,24110,24130,24150,24170,24190,24210,24230,24250,24270,24290,24310,24330,24350,24370,24390,24410,24430,24450,24470,24490,24510,24530,24550,24570,24590,24610,24630,24650,24670,24690,24710,24730,24750,24770,24790,24810,24830,24850,24870,24890,24910,24930,24950,24970,24990,25010,25030,25050,25070,25090,25110,25130,25150,25170,25190,25210,25230,25250,25270,25290,25310,25330,25350,25370,25390,25410,25430,25450,25470,25490,25510,25530,25550,25570,25590,25610,25630,25650,25670,25690,25710,25730,25750,25770,25790,25810,25830,25850,25870,25890,25910,25930,25950,25970,25990,26010,26030,26050,26070,26090,26110,26130,26150,26170,26190,26210,26230,26250,26270,26290,26310,26330,26350,26370,26390,26410,26430,26450,26470,26490,26510,26530,26550,26570,26590,26610,26630,26650,26670,26690,26710,26730,26750,26770,26790,26810,26830,26850,26870,26890,26910,26930,26950,26970,26990,27010,27030,27050,27070,27090,27110,27130,27150,27170,27190,27210,27230,27250,27270,27290,27310,27330,27350,27370,27390,27410,27430,27450,27470,27490,27510,27530,27550,27570,27590,27610,27630,27650,27670,27690,27710,27730,27750,27770,27790,27810,27830,27850,27870,27890,27910,27930,27950,27970,27990,28010,28030,28050,28070,28090,28110,28130,28150,28170,28190,28210,28230,28250,28270,28290,28310,28330,28350,28370,28390,28410,28430,28450,28470,28490,28510,28530,28550,28570,28590,28610,28630,28650,28670,28690,28710,28730,28750,28770,28790,28810,28830,28850,28870,28890,28910,28930,28950,28970,28990,29010,29030,29050,29070,29090,29110,29130,29150,29170,29190,29210,29230,29250,29270,29290,29310,29330,29350,29370,29390,29410,29430,29450,29470,29490,29510,29530,29550,29570,29590,29610,29630,29650,29670,29690,29710,29730,29750,29770,29790,29810,29830,29850,29870,29890,29910,29930,29950,29970,29990,30010,30030],"media":[0,20,40,60,80,100,120,140,160,180,200,220,240,260,280,300,320,340,360,380,400,420,440,460,480,500,520,540,560,580,600,620,640,660,680,700,720,740,760,780,800,820,840,860,880,900,920,940,960,980,1000,1020,1040,1060,1080,1100,1120,1140,1160,1180,1200,1220,1240,1260,1280,1300,1320,1340,1360,1380,1400,1420,1440,1460,1480,1500,1520,1540,1560,1580,1600,1620,1640,1660,1680,1700,1720,1740,1760,1780,1800,1820,1840,1860,1880,1900,1920,1940,1960,1980,2000,2020,2040,2060,2080,2100,2120,2140,2160,2180,2200,2220,2240,2260,2280,2300,2320,2340,2360,2380,2400,2420,2440,2460,2480,2500,2520,2540,2560,2580,2600,2620,2640,2660,2680,2700,2720,2740,2760,2780,2800,2820,2840,2860,2880,2900,2920,2940,2960,2980,3000,3020,3040,3060,3080,3100,3120,3140,3160,3180,3200,3220,3240,3260,3280,3300,3320,3340,3360,3380,3400,3420,3440,3460,3480,3500,3520,3540,3560,3580,3600,3620,3640,3660,3680,3700,3720,3740,3760,3780,3800,3820,3840,3860,3880,3900,3920,3940,3960,3980,4000,4020,4040,4060,4080,4100,4120,4140,4160,4180,4200,4220,4240,4260,4280,4300,4320,4340,4360,4380,4400,4420,4440,4460,4480,4500,4520,4540,4560,4580,4600,4620,4640,4660,4680,4700,4720,4740,4760,4780,4800,4820,4840,4860,4880,4900,4920,4940,4960,4980,5000,5020,5040,5060,5080,5100,5120,5140,5160,5180,5200,5220,5240,5260,5280,5300,5320,5340,5360,5380,5400,5420,5440,5460,5480,5500,5520,5540,5560,5580,5600,5620,5640,5660,5680,5700,5720,5740,5760,5780,5800,5820,5840,5860,5880,5900,5920,5940,5960,5980,6000,6020,6040,6060,6080,6100,6120,6140,6160,6180,6200,6220,6240,6260,6280,6300,6320,6340,6360,6380,6400,6420,6440,6460,6480,6500,6520,6540,6560,6580,6600,6620,6640,6660,6680,6700,6720,6740,6760,6780,6800,6820,6840,6860,6880,6900,6920,6940,6960,6980,7000,7020,7040,7060,7080,7100,7120,7140,7160,7180,7200,7220,7240,7260,7280,7300,7320,7340,7360,7380,7400,7420,7440,7460,7480,7500,7520,7540,7560,7580,7600,7620,7640,7660,7680,7700,7720,7740,7760,7780,7800,7820,7840,7860,7880,7900,7920,7940,7960,7980,8000,8020,8040,8060,8080,8100,8120,8140,8160,8180,8200,8220,8240,8260,8280,8300,8320,8340,8360,8380,8400,8420,8440,8460,8480,8500,8520,8540,8560,8580,8600,8620,8640,8660,8680,8700,8720,8740,8760,8780,8800,8820,8840,8860,8880,8900,8920,8940,8960,8980,9000,9020,9040,9060,9080,9100,9120,9140,9160,9180,9200,9220,9240,9260,9280,9300,9320,9340,9360,9380,9400,9420,9440,9460,9480,9500,9520,9540,9560,9580,9600,9620,9640,9660,9680,9700,9720,9740,9760,9780,9800,9820,9840,9860,9880,9900,9920,9940,9960,9980,10000,10020,10040,10060,10080,10100,10120,10140,10160,10180,10200,10220,10240,10260,10280,10300,10320,10340,10360,10380,10400,10420,10440,10460,10480,10500,10520,10540,10560,10580,10600,10620,10640,10660,10680,10700,10720,10740,10760,10780,10800,10820,10840,10860,10880,10900,10920,10940,10960,10980,11000,11020,11040,11060,11080,11100,11120,11140,11160,11180,11200,11220,11240,11260,11280,11300,11320,11340,11360,11380,11400,11420,11440,11460,11480,11500,11520,11540,11560,11580,11600,11620,11640,11660,11680,11700,11720,11740,11760,11780,11800,11820,11840,11860,11880,11900,11920,11940,11960,11980,12000,12020,12040,12060,12080,12100,12120,12140,12160,12180,12200,12220,12240,12260,12280,12300,12320,12340,12360,12380,12400,12420,12440,12460,12480,12500,12520,12540,12560,12580,12600,12620,12640,12660,12680,12700,12720,12740,12760,12780,12800,12820,12840,12860,12880,12900,12920,12940,12960,12980,13000,13020,13040,13060,13080,13100,13120,13140,13160,13180,13200,13220,13240,13260,13280,13300,13320,13340,13360,13380,13400,13420,13440,13460,13480,13500,13520,13540,13560,13580,13600,13620,13640,13660,13680,13700,13720,13740,13760,13780,13800,13820,13840,13860,13880,13900,13920,13940,13960,13980,14000,14020,14040,14060,14080,14100,14120,14140,14160,14180,14200,14220,14240,14260,14280,14300,14320,14340,14360,14380,14400,14420,14440,14460,14480,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,20000,20020,20040,20060,20080,20100,20120,20140,20160,20180,20200,20220,20240,20260,20280,20300,20320,20340,20360,20380,20400,20420,20440,20460,20480,20500,20520,20540,20560,20580,20600,20620,20640,20660,20680,20700,20720,20740,20760,20780,20800,20820,20840,20860,20880,20900,20920,20940,20960,20980,21000,21020,21040,21060,21080,21100,21120,21140,21160,21180,21200,21220,21240,21260,21280,21300,21320,21340,21360,21380,21400,21420,21440,21460,21480,21500,21520,21540,21560,21580,21600,21620,21640,21660,21680,21700,21720,21740,21760,21780,21800,21820,21840,21860,21880,21900,21920,21940,21960,21980,22000,22020,22040,22060,22080,22100,22120,22140,22160,22180,22200,22220,22240,22260,22280,22300,22320,22340,22360,22380,22400,22420,22440,22460,22480,22500,22520,22540,22560,22580,22600,22620,22640,22660,22680,22700,22720,22740,22760,22780,22800,22820,22840,22860,22880,22900,22920,22940,22960,22980,23000,23020,23040,23060,23080,23100,23120,23140,23160,23180,23200,23220,23240,23260,23280,23300,23320,23340,23360,23380,23400,23420,23440,23460,23480,23500,23520,23540,23560,23580,23600,23620,23640,23660,23680,23700,23720,23740,23760,23780,23800,23820,23840,23860,23880,23900,23920,23940,23960,23980,24000,24020,24040,24060,24080,24100,24120,24140,24160,24180,24200,24220,24240,24260,24280,24300,24320,24340,24360,24380,24400,24420,24440,24460,24480,24500,24520,24540,24560,24580,24600,24620,24640,24660,24680,24700,24720,24740,24760,24780,24800,24820,24840,24860,24880,24900,24920,24940,24960,24980,25000,25020,25040,25060,25080,25100,25120,25140,25160,25180,25200,25220,25240,25260,25280,25300,25320,25340,25360,25380,25400,25420,25440,25460,25480,25500,25520,25540,25560,25580,25600,25620,25640,25660,25680,25700,25720,25740,25760,25780,25800,25820,25840,25860,25880,25900,25920,25940,25960,25980,26000,26020,26040,26060,26080,26100,26120,26140,26160,26180,26200,26220,26240,26260,26280,26300,26320,26340,26360,26380,26400,26420,26440,26460,26480,26500,26520,26540,26560,26580,26600,26620,26640,26660,26680,26700,26720,26740,26760,26780,26800,26820,26840,26860,26880,26900,26920,26940,26960,26980,27000,27020,27040,27060,27080,27100,27120,27140,27160,27180,27200,27220,27240,27260,27280,27300,27320,27340,27360,27380,27400,27420,27440,27460,27480,27500,27520,27540,27560,27580,27600,27620,27640,27660,27680,27700,27720,27740,27760,27780,27800,27820,27840,27860,27880,27900,27920,27940,27960,27980,28000,28020,28040,28060,28080,28100,28120,28140,28160,28180,28200,28220,28240,28260,28280,28300,28320,28340,28360,28380,28400,28420,28440,28460,28480,28500,28520,28540,28560,28580,28600,28620,28640,28660,28680,28700,28720,28740,28760,28780,28800,28820,28840,28860,28880,28900,28920,28940,28960,28980,29000,29020,29040,29060,29080,29100,29120,29140,29160,29180,29200,29220,29240,29260,29280,29300,29320,29340,29360,29380,29400,29420,29440,29460,29480,29500,29520,29540,29560,29580,29600,29620,29640,29660,29680,29700,29720,29740,29760,29780,29800,29820,29840,29860,29880,29900,29920,29940,29960,29980],"target":[[0,120],[75,100],[175,80],[225,60],[250,40]]} diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/stretch/corpus.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/stretch/corpus.json index 5ad591f447e..e864b8552e1 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/stretch/corpus.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/stretch/corpus.json @@ -2437,330 +2437,5 @@ -0.360440731048584, -0.22026745975017548, -0.5599857568740845, -0.11384382098913193, -0.603949248790741, -0.10583518445491791, -0.32648566365242004, -0.4554884731769562, -0.27422934770584106, -0.09860859811306 ] - }, - { - "name": "hold-within-lateness", - "rate": 8000, - "channels": 1, - "input": [ - 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 1.6081226229577292e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 9.184850732644269e-17, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 3.2162452459154583e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 1.5308084995570108e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -1.8369701465288538e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -6.73865213880276e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 6.432490491830917e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 2.7554553521421787e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -3.0616169991140216e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -5.514005550915388e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466 - ], - "buffered": 800, - "target": 640, - "lateness": 160, - "cooldown": 0, - "decision": "Hold", - "lag": 0, - "output": [ - 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 1.6081226229577292e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 9.184850732644269e-17, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 3.2162452459154583e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 1.5308084995570108e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -1.8369701465288538e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -6.73865213880276e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 6.432490491830917e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 2.7554553521421787e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -3.0616169991140216e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -5.514005550915388e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466 - ] - }, - { - "name": "accelerate-above-lateness", - "rate": 8000, - "channels": 1, - "input": [ - 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 1.6081226229577292e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 9.184850732644269e-17, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 3.2162452459154583e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 1.5308084995570108e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -1.8369701465288538e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -6.73865213880276e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 6.432490491830917e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 2.7554553521421787e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -3.0616169991140216e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -5.514005550915388e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466 - ], - "buffered": 960, - "target": 640, - "lateness": 160, - "cooldown": 0, - "decision": "Accelerate", - "lag": 40, - "output": [ - 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 1.6081226229577292e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 9.184850732644269e-17, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 3.092996128738445e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -2.7047689005784813e-16, - -0.03910861536860466, -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, - -0.2022542506456375, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, - -0.2469220906496048, -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, - -0.14694631099700928, -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, - 6.432490491830917e-16, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, - 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 2.7554553521421787e-16, - -0.03910861536860466, -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, - -0.2022542506456375, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, - -0.2469220906496048, -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, - -0.14694631099700928, -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, - -3.0616169991140216e-16, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.1767766922712326, 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, - 0.2469220906496048, 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.14694631099700928, 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -5.514005550915388e-16, - -0.03910861536860466, -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, - -0.2022542506456375, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, - -0.2469220906496048, -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, - -0.14694631099700928, -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466 - ] - }, - { - "name": "hold-below-widened-fast", - "rate": 8000, - "channels": 1, - "input": [ - 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 1.6081226229577292e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 9.184850732644269e-17, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 3.2162452459154583e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 1.5308084995570108e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -1.8369701465288538e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -6.73865213880276e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 6.432490491830917e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 2.7554553521421787e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -3.0616169991140216e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -5.514005550915388e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466 - ], - "buffered": 3200, - "target": 640, - "lateness": 160, - "cooldown": 160, - "decision": "Hold", - "lag": 0, - "output": [ - 0.0, 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -8.040613114788646e-17, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 1.6081226229577292e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 9.184850732644269e-17, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 3.2162452459154583e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 1.5308084995570108e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -1.8369701465288538e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -6.73865213880276e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, 6.432490491830917e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, 2.7554553521421787e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466, -3.0616169991140216e-16, - 0.03910861536860466, 0.07725425064563751, 0.11349762231111526, 0.14694631099700928, 0.1767766922712326, - 0.2022542506456375, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2377641350030899, 0.2469220906496048, 0.25, 0.2469220906496048, - 0.2377641350030899, 0.22275163233280182, 0.2022542506456375, 0.1767766922712326, 0.14694631099700928, - 0.11349762231111526, 0.07725425064563751, 0.03910861536860466, -5.514005550915388e-16, -0.03910861536860466, - -0.07725425064563751, -0.11349762231111526, -0.14694631099700928, -0.1767766922712326, -0.2022542506456375, - -0.22275163233280182, -0.2377641350030899, -0.2469220906496048, -0.25, -0.2469220906496048, - -0.2377641350030899, -0.22275163233280182, -0.2022542506456375, -0.1767766922712326, -0.14694631099700928, - -0.11349762231111526, -0.07725425064563751, -0.03910861536860466 - ] } ] diff --git a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/tunein.json b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/tunein.json index 295c860ad4a..5b8ff6f9013 100644 --- a/doc/concept/audio-jitter/tunein.json +++ b/doc/concept/audio-jitter/tunein.json @@ -1 +1 @@ -{"name":"tunein","about":"One frame from a stale group, then the live edge 14.5 s later, then 30 s of even audio. The #3517 branch reported 14.56 s here; the target must stay near the frame duration.","frame":20,"arrival":[0,10,30,50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030,20050,20070,20090,20110,20130,20150,20170,20190,20210,20230,20250,20270,20290,20310,20330,20350,20370,20390,20410,20430,20450,20470,20490,20510,20530,20550,20570,20590,20610,20630,20650,20670,20690,20710,20730,20750,20770,20790,20810,20830,20850,20870,20890,20910,20930,20950,20970,20990,21010,21030,21050,21070,21090,21110,21130,21150,21170,21190,21210,21230,21250,21270,21290,21310,21330,21350,21370,21390,21410,21430,21450,21470,21490,21510,21530,21550,21570,21590,21610,21630,21650,21670,21690,21710,21730,21750,21770,21790,21810,21830,21850,21870,21890,21910,21930,21950,21970,21990,22010,22030,22050,22070,22090,22110,22130,22150,22170,22190,22210,22230,22250,22270,22290,22310,22330,22350,22370,22390,22410,22430,22450,22470,22490,22510,22530,22550,22570,22590,22610,22630,22650,22670,22690,22710,22730,22750,22770,22790,22810,22830,22850,22870,22890,22910,22930,22950,22970,22990,23010,23030,23050,23070,23090,23110,23130,23150,23170,23190,23210,23230,23250,23270,23290,23310,23330,23350,23370,23390,23410,23430,23450,23470,23490,23510,23530,23550,23570,23590,23610,23630,23650,23670,23690,23710,23730,23750,23770,23790,23810,23830,23850,23870,23890,23910,23930,23950,23970,23990,24010,24030,24050,24070,24090,24110,24130,24150,24170,24190,24210,24230,24250,24270,24290,24310,24330,24350,24370,24390,24410,24430,24450,24470,24490,24510,24530,24550,24570,24590,24610,24630,24650,24670,24690,24710,24730,24750,24770,24790,24810,24830,24850,24870,24890,24910,24930,24950,24970,24990,25010,25030,25050,25070,25090,25110,25130,25150,25170,25190,25210,25230,25250,25270,25290,25310,25330,25350,25370,25390,25410,25430,25450,25470,25490,25510,25530,25550,25570,25590,25610,25630,25650,25670,25690,25710,25730,25750,25770,25790,25810,25830,25850,25870,25890,25910,25930,25950,25970,25990,26010,26030,26050,26070,26090,26110,26130,26150,26170,26190,26210,26230,26250,26270,26290,26310,26330,26350,26370,26390,26410,26430,26450,26470,26490,26510,26530,26550,26570,26590,26610,26630,26650,26670,26690,26710,26730,26750,26770,26790,26810,26830,26850,26870,26890,26910,26930,26950,26970,26990,27010,27030,27050,27070,27090,27110,27130,27150,27170,27190,27210,27230,27250,27270,27290,27310,27330,27350,27370,27390,27410,27430,27450,27470,27490,27510,27530,27550,27570,27590,27610,27630,27650,27670,27690,27710,27730,27750,27770,27790,27810,27830,27850,27870,27890,27910,27930,27950,27970,27990,28010,28030,28050,28070,28090,28110,28130,28150,28170,28190,28210,28230,28250,28270,28290,28310,28330,28350,28370,28390,28410,28430,28450,28470,28490,28510,28530,28550,28570,28590,28610,28630,28650,28670,28690,28710,28730,28750,28770,28790,28810,28830,28850,28870,28890,28910,28930,28950,28970,28990,29010,29030,29050,29070,29090,29110,29130,29150,29170,29190,29210,29230,29250,29270,29290,29310,29330,29350,29370,29390,29410,29430,29450,29470,29490,29510,29530,29550,29570,29590,29610,29630,29650,29670,29690,29710,29730,29750,29770,29790,29810,29830,29850,29870,29890,29910,29930,29950,29970,29990],"media":[0,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,20000,20020,20040,20060,20080,20100,20120,20140,20160,20180,20200,20220,20240,20260,20280,20300,20320,20340,20360,20380,20400,20420,20440,20460,20480,20500,20520,20540,20560,20580,20600,20620,20640,20660,20680,20700,20720,20740,20760,20780,20800,20820,20840,20860,20880,20900,20920,20940,20960,20980,21000,21020,21040,21060,21080,21100,21120,21140,21160,21180,21200,21220,21240,21260,21280,21300,21320,21340,21360,21380,21400,21420,21440,21460,21480,21500,21520,21540,21560,21580,21600,21620,21640,21660,21680,21700,21720,21740,21760,21780,21800,21820,21840,21860,21880,21900,21920,21940,21960,21980,22000,22020,22040,22060,22080,22100,22120,22140,22160,22180,22200,22220,22240,22260,22280,22300,22320,22340,22360,22380,22400,22420,22440,22460,22480,22500,22520,22540,22560,22580,22600,22620,22640,22660,22680,22700,22720,22740,22760,22780,22800,22820,22840,22860,22880,22900,22920,22940,22960,22980,23000,23020,23040,23060,23080,23100,23120,23140,23160,23180,23200,23220,23240,23260,23280,23300,23320,23340,23360,23380,23400,23420,23440,23460,23480,23500,23520,23540,23560,23580,23600,23620,23640,23660,23680,23700,23720,23740,23760,23780,23800,23820,23840,23860,23880,23900,23920,23940,23960,23980,24000,24020,24040,24060,24080,24100,24120,24140,24160,24180,24200,24220,24240,24260,24280,24300,24320,24340,24360,24380,24400,24420,24440,24460,24480,24500,24520,24540,24560,24580,24600,24620,24640,24660,24680,24700,24720,24740,24760,24780,24800,24820,24840,24860,24880,24900,24920,24940,24960,24980,25000,25020,25040,25060,25080,25100,25120,25140,25160,25180,25200,25220,25240,25260,25280,25300,25320,25340,25360,25380,25400,25420,25440,25460,25480,25500,25520,25540,25560,25580,25600,25620,25640,25660,25680,25700,25720,25740,25760,25780,25800,25820,25840,25860,25880,25900,25920,25940,25960,25980,26000,26020,26040,26060,26080,26100,26120,26140,26160,26180,26200,26220,26240,26260,26280,26300,26320,26340,26360,26380,26400,26420,26440,26460,26480,26500,26520,26540,26560,26580,26600,26620,26640,26660,26680,26700,26720,26740,26760,26780,26800,26820,26840,26860,26880,26900,26920,26940,26960,26980,27000,27020,27040,27060,27080,27100,27120,27140,27160,27180,27200,27220,27240,27260,27280,27300,27320,27340,27360,27380,27400,27420,27440,27460,27480,27500,27520,27540,27560,27580,27600,27620,27640,27660,27680,27700,27720,27740,27760,27780,27800,27820,27840,27860,27880,27900,27920,27940,27960,27980,28000,28020,28040,28060,28080,28100,28120,28140,28160,28180,28200,28220,28240,28260,28280,28300,28320,28340,28360,28380,28400,28420,28440,28460,28480,28500,28520,28540,28560,28580,28600,28620,28640,28660,28680,28700,28720,28740,28760,28780,28800,28820,28840,28860,28880,28900,28920,28940,28960,28980,29000,29020,29040,29060,29080,29100,29120,29140,29160,29180,29200,29220,29240,29260,29280,29300,29320,29340,29360,29380,29400,29420,29440,29460,29480,29500,29520,29540,29560,29580,29600,29620,29640,29660,29680,29700,29720,29740,29760,29780,29800,29820,29840,29860,29880,29900,29920,29940,29960,29980,30000,30020,30040,30060,30080,30100,30120,30140,30160,30180,30200,30220,30240,30260,30280,30300,30320,30340,30360,30380,30400,30420,30440,30460,30480,30500,30520,30540,30560,30580,30600,30620,30640,30660,30680,30700,30720,30740,30760,30780,30800,30820,30840,30860,30880,30900,30920,30940,30960,30980,31000,31020,31040,31060,31080,31100,31120,31140,31160,31180,31200,31220,31240,31260,31280,31300,31320,31340,31360,31380,31400,31420,31440,31460,31480,31500,31520,31540,31560,31580,31600,31620,31640,31660,31680,31700,31720,31740,31760,31780,31800,31820,31840,31860,31880,31900,31920,31940,31960,31980,32000,32020,32040,32060,32080,32100,32120,32140,32160,32180,32200,32220,32240,32260,32280,32300,32320,32340,32360,32380,32400,32420,32440,32460,32480,32500,32520,32540,32560,32580,32600,32620,32640,32660,32680,32700,32720,32740,32760,32780,32800,32820,32840,32860,32880,32900,32920,32940,32960,32980,33000,33020,33040,33060,33080,33100,33120,33140,33160,33180,33200,33220,33240,33260,33280,33300,33320,33340,33360,33380,33400,33420,33440,33460,33480,33500,33520,33540,33560,33580,33600,33620,33640,33660,33680,33700,33720,33740,33760,33780,33800,33820,33840,33860,33880,33900,33920,33940,33960,33980,34000,34020,34040,34060,34080,34100,34120,34140,34160,34180,34200,34220,34240,34260,34280,34300,34320,34340,34360,34380,34400,34420,34440,34460,34480,34500,34520,34540,34560,34580,34600,34620,34640,34660,34680,34700,34720,34740,34760,34780,34800,34820,34840,34860,34880,34900,34920,34940,34960,34980,35000,35020,35040,35060,35080,35100,35120,35140,35160,35180,35200,35220,35240,35260,35280,35300,35320,35340,35360,35380,35400,35420,35440,35460,35480,35500,35520,35540,35560,35580,35600,35620,35640,35660,35680,35700,35720,35740,35760,35780,35800,35820,35840,35860,35880,35900,35920,35940,35960,35980,36000,36020,36040,36060,36080,36100,36120,36140,36160,36180,36200,36220,36240,36260,36280,36300,36320,36340,36360,36380,36400,36420,36440,36460,36480,36500,36520,36540,36560,36580,36600,36620,36640,36660,36680,36700,36720,36740,36760,36780,36800,36820,36840,36860,36880,36900,36920,36940,36960,36980,37000,37020,37040,37060,37080,37100,37120,37140,37160,37180,37200,37220,37240,37260,37280,37300,37320,37340,37360,37380,37400,37420,37440,37460,37480,37500,37520,37540,37560,37580,37600,37620,37640,37660,37680,37700,37720,37740,37760,37780,37800,37820,37840,37860,37880,37900,37920,37940,37960,37980,38000,38020,38040,38060,38080,38100,38120,38140,38160,38180,38200,38220,38240,38260,38280,38300,38320,38340,38360,38380,38400,38420,38440,38460,38480,38500,38520,38540,38560,38580,38600,38620,38640,38660,38680,38700,38720,38740,38760,38780,38800,38820,38840,38860,38880,38900,38920,38940,38960,38980,39000,39020,39040,39060,39080,39100,39120,39140,39160,39180,39200,39220,39240,39260,39280,39300,39320,39340,39360,39380,39400,39420,39440,39460,39480,39500,39520,39540,39560,39580,39600,39620,39640,39660,39680,39700,39720,39740,39760,39780,39800,39820,39840,39860,39880,39900,39920,39940,39960,39980,40000,40020,40040,40060,40080,40100,40120,40140,40160,40180,40200,40220,40240,40260,40280,40300,40320,40340,40360,40380,40400,40420,40440,40460,40480,40500,40520,40540,40560,40580,40600,40620,40640,40660,40680,40700,40720,40740,40760,40780,40800,40820,40840,40860,40880,40900,40920,40940,40960,40980,41000,41020,41040,41060,41080,41100,41120,41140,41160,41180,41200,41220,41240,41260,41280,41300,41320,41340,41360,41380,41400,41420,41440,41460,41480,41500,41520,41540,41560,41580,41600,41620,41640,41660,41680,41700,41720,41740,41760,41780,41800,41820,41840,41860,41880,41900,41920,41940,41960,41980,42000,42020,42040,42060,42080,42100,42120,42140,42160,42180,42200,42220,42240,42260,42280,42300,42320,42340,42360,42380,42400,42420,42440,42460,42480,42500,42520,42540,42560,42580,42600,42620,42640,42660,42680,42700,42720,42740,42760,42780,42800,42820,42840,42860,42880,42900,42920,42940,42960,42980,43000,43020,43040,43060,43080,43100,43120,43140,43160,43180,43200,43220,43240,43260,43280,43300,43320,43340,43360,43380,43400,43420,43440,43460,43480,43500,43520,43540,43560,43580,43600,43620,43640,43660,43680,43700,43720,43740,43760,43780,43800,43820,43840,43860,43880,43900,43920,43940,43960,43980,44000,44020,44040,44060,44080,44100,44120,44140,44160,44180,44200,44220,44240,44260,44280,44300,44320,44340,44360,44380,44400,44420,44440,44460,44480],"target":[[0,120],[76,100],[176,80],[226,60],[251,40]],"lateness":[[0,0]]} +{"name":"tunein","about":"One frame from a stale group, then the live edge 14.5 s later, then 30 s of even audio. The #3517 branch reported 14.56 s here; the target must stay near the frame duration.","frame":20,"arrival":[0,10,30,50,70,90,110,130,150,170,190,210,230,250,270,290,310,330,350,370,390,410,430,450,470,490,510,530,550,570,590,610,630,650,670,690,710,730,750,770,790,810,830,850,870,890,910,930,950,970,990,1010,1030,1050,1070,1090,1110,1130,1150,1170,1190,1210,1230,1250,1270,1290,1310,1330,1350,1370,1390,1410,1430,1450,1470,1490,1510,1530,1550,1570,1590,1610,1630,1650,1670,1690,1710,1730,1750,1770,1790,1810,1830,1850,1870,1890,1910,1930,1950,1970,1990,2010,2030,2050,2070,2090,2110,2130,2150,2170,2190,2210,2230,2250,2270,2290,2310,2330,2350,2370,2390,2410,2430,2450,2470,2490,2510,2530,2550,2570,2590,2610,2630,2650,2670,2690,2710,2730,2750,2770,2790,2810,2830,2850,2870,2890,2910,2930,2950,2970,2990,3010,3030,3050,3070,3090,3110,3130,3150,3170,3190,3210,3230,3250,3270,3290,3310,3330,3350,3370,3390,3410,3430,3450,3470,3490,3510,3530,3550,3570,3590,3610,3630,3650,3670,3690,3710,3730,3750,3770,3790,3810,3830,3850,3870,3890,3910,3930,3950,3970,3990,4010,4030,4050,4070,4090,4110,4130,4150,4170,4190,4210,4230,4250,4270,4290,4310,4330,4350,4370,4390,4410,4430,4450,4470,4490,4510,4530,4550,4570,4590,4610,4630,4650,4670,4690,4710,4730,4750,4770,4790,4810,4830,4850,4870,4890,4910,4930,4950,4970,4990,5010,5030,5050,5070,5090,5110,5130,5150,5170,5190,5210,5230,5250,5270,5290,5310,5330,5350,5370,5390,5410,5430,5450,5470,5490,5510,5530,5550,5570,5590,5610,5630,5650,5670,5690,5710,5730,5750,5770,5790,5810,5830,5850,5870,5890,5910,5930,5950,5970,5990,6010,6030,6050,6070,6090,6110,6130,6150,6170,6190,6210,6230,6250,6270,6290,6310,6330,6350,6370,6390,6410,6430,6450,6470,6490,6510,6530,6550,6570,6590,6610,6630,6650,6670,6690,6710,6730,6750,6770,6790,6810,6830,6850,6870,6890,6910,6930,6950,6970,6990,7010,7030,7050,7070,7090,7110,7130,7150,7170,7190,7210,7230,7250,7270,7290,7310,7330,7350,7370,7390,7410,7430,7450,7470,7490,7510,7530,7550,7570,7590,7610,7630,7650,7670,7690,7710,7730,7750,7770,7790,7810,7830,7850,7870,7890,7910,7930,7950,7970,7990,8010,8030,8050,8070,8090,8110,8130,8150,8170,8190,8210,8230,8250,8270,8290,8310,8330,8350,8370,8390,8410,8430,8450,8470,8490,8510,8530,8550,8570,8590,8610,8630,8650,8670,8690,8710,8730,8750,8770,8790,8810,8830,8850,8870,8890,8910,8930,8950,8970,8990,9010,9030,9050,9070,9090,9110,9130,9150,9170,9190,9210,9230,9250,9270,9290,9310,9330,9350,9370,9390,9410,9430,9450,9470,9490,9510,9530,9550,9570,9590,9610,9630,9650,9670,9690,9710,9730,9750,9770,9790,9810,9830,9850,9870,9890,9910,9930,9950,9970,9990,10010,10030,10050,10070,10090,10110,10130,10150,10170,10190,10210,10230,10250,10270,10290,10310,10330,10350,10370,10390,10410,10430,10450,10470,10490,10510,10530,10550,10570,10590,10610,10630,10650,10670,10690,10710,10730,10750,10770,10790,10810,10830,10850,10870,10890,10910,10930,10950,10970,10990,11010,11030,11050,11070,11090,11110,11130,11150,11170,11190,11210,11230,11250,11270,11290,11310,11330,11350,11370,11390,11410,11430,11450,11470,11490,11510,11530,11550,11570,11590,11610,11630,11650,11670,11690,11710,11730,11750,11770,11790,11810,11830,11850,11870,11890,11910,11930,11950,11970,11990,12010,12030,12050,12070,12090,12110,12130,12150,12170,12190,12210,12230,12250,12270,12290,12310,12330,12350,12370,12390,12410,12430,12450,12470,12490,12510,12530,12550,12570,12590,12610,12630,12650,12670,12690,12710,12730,12750,12770,12790,12810,12830,12850,12870,12890,12910,12930,12950,12970,12990,13010,13030,13050,13070,13090,13110,13130,13150,13170,13190,13210,13230,13250,13270,13290,13310,13330,13350,13370,13390,13410,13430,13450,13470,13490,13510,13530,13550,13570,13590,13610,13630,13650,13670,13690,13710,13730,13750,13770,13790,13810,13830,13850,13870,13890,13910,13930,13950,13970,13990,14010,14030,14050,14070,14090,14110,14130,14150,14170,14190,14210,14230,14250,14270,14290,14310,14330,14350,14370,14390,14410,14430,14450,14470,14490,14510,14530,14550,14570,14590,14610,14630,14650,14670,14690,14710,14730,14750,14770,14790,14810,14830,14850,14870,14890,14910,14930,14950,14970,14990,15010,15030,15050,15070,15090,15110,15130,15150,15170,15190,15210,15230,15250,15270,15290,15310,15330,15350,15370,15390,15410,15430,15450,15470,15490,15510,15530,15550,15570,15590,15610,15630,15650,15670,15690,15710,15730,15750,15770,15790,15810,15830,15850,15870,15890,15910,15930,15950,15970,15990,16010,16030,16050,16070,16090,16110,16130,16150,16170,16190,16210,16230,16250,16270,16290,16310,16330,16350,16370,16390,16410,16430,16450,16470,16490,16510,16530,16550,16570,16590,16610,16630,16650,16670,16690,16710,16730,16750,16770,16790,16810,16830,16850,16870,16890,16910,16930,16950,16970,16990,17010,17030,17050,17070,17090,17110,17130,17150,17170,17190,17210,17230,17250,17270,17290,17310,17330,17350,17370,17390,17410,17430,17450,17470,17490,17510,17530,17550,17570,17590,17610,17630,17650,17670,17690,17710,17730,17750,17770,17790,17810,17830,17850,17870,17890,17910,17930,17950,17970,17990,18010,18030,18050,18070,18090,18110,18130,18150,18170,18190,18210,18230,18250,18270,18290,18310,18330,18350,18370,18390,18410,18430,18450,18470,18490,18510,18530,18550,18570,18590,18610,18630,18650,18670,18690,18710,18730,18750,18770,18790,18810,18830,18850,18870,18890,18910,18930,18950,18970,18990,19010,19030,19050,19070,19090,19110,19130,19150,19170,19190,19210,19230,19250,19270,19290,19310,19330,19350,19370,19390,19410,19430,19450,19470,19490,19510,19530,19550,19570,19590,19610,19630,19650,19670,19690,19710,19730,19750,19770,19790,19810,19830,19850,19870,19890,19910,19930,19950,19970,19990,20010,20030,20050,20070,20090,20110,20130,20150,20170,20190,20210,20230,20250,20270,20290,20310,20330,20350,20370,20390,20410,20430,20450,20470,20490,20510,20530,20550,20570,20590,20610,20630,20650,20670,20690,20710,20730,20750,20770,20790,20810,20830,20850,20870,20890,20910,20930,20950,20970,20990,21010,21030,21050,21070,21090,21110,21130,21150,21170,21190,21210,21230,21250,21270,21290,21310,21330,21350,21370,21390,21410,21430,21450,21470,21490,21510,21530,21550,21570,21590,21610,21630,21650,21670,21690,21710,21730,21750,21770,21790,21810,21830,21850,21870,21890,21910,21930,21950,21970,21990,22010,22030,22050,22070,22090,22110,22130,22150,22170,22190,22210,22230,22250,22270,22290,22310,22330,22350,22370,22390,22410,22430,22450,22470,22490,22510,22530,22550,22570,22590,22610,22630,22650,22670,22690,22710,22730,22750,22770,22790,22810,22830,22850,22870,22890,22910,22930,22950,22970,22990,23010,23030,23050,23070,23090,23110,23130,23150,23170,23190,23210,23230,23250,23270,23290,23310,23330,23350,23370,23390,23410,23430,23450,23470,23490,23510,23530,23550,23570,23590,23610,23630,23650,23670,23690,23710,23730,23750,23770,23790,23810,23830,23850,23870,23890,23910,23930,23950,23970,23990,24010,24030,24050,24070,24090,24110,24130,24150,24170,24190,24210,24230,24250,24270,24290,24310,24330,24350,24370,24390,24410,24430,24450,24470,24490,24510,24530,24550,24570,24590,24610,24630,24650,24670,24690,24710,24730,24750,24770,24790,24810,24830,24850,24870,24890,24910,24930,24950,24970,24990,25010,25030,25050,25070,25090,25110,25130,25150,25170,25190,25210,25230,25250,25270,25290,25310,25330,25350,25370,25390,25410,25430,25450,25470,25490,25510,25530,25550,25570,25590,25610,25630,25650,25670,25690,25710,25730,25750,25770,25790,25810,25830,25850,25870,25890,25910,25930,25950,25970,25990,26010,26030,26050,26070,26090,26110,26130,26150,26170,26190,26210,26230,26250,26270,26290,26310,26330,26350,26370,26390,26410,26430,26450,26470,26490,26510,26530,26550,26570,26590,26610,26630,26650,26670,26690,26710,26730,26750,26770,26790,26810,26830,26850,26870,26890,26910,26930,26950,26970,26990,27010,27030,27050,27070,27090,27110,27130,27150,27170,27190,27210,27230,27250,27270,27290,27310,27330,27350,27370,27390,27410,27430,27450,27470,27490,27510,27530,27550,27570,27590,27610,27630,27650,27670,27690,27710,27730,27750,27770,27790,27810,27830,27850,27870,27890,27910,27930,27950,27970,27990,28010,28030,28050,28070,28090,28110,28130,28150,28170,28190,28210,28230,28250,28270,28290,28310,28330,28350,28370,28390,28410,28430,28450,28470,28490,28510,28530,28550,28570,28590,28610,28630,28650,28670,28690,28710,28730,28750,28770,28790,28810,28830,28850,28870,28890,28910,28930,28950,28970,28990,29010,29030,29050,29070,29090,29110,29130,29150,29170,29190,29210,29230,29250,29270,29290,29310,29330,29350,29370,29390,29410,29430,29450,29470,29490,29510,29530,29550,29570,29590,29610,29630,29650,29670,29690,29710,29730,29750,29770,29790,29810,29830,29850,29870,29890,29910,29930,29950,29970,29990],"media":[0,14500,14520,14540,14560,14580,14600,14620,14640,14660,14680,14700,14720,14740,14760,14780,14800,14820,14840,14860,14880,14900,14920,14940,14960,14980,15000,15020,15040,15060,15080,15100,15120,15140,15160,15180,15200,15220,15240,15260,15280,15300,15320,15340,15360,15380,15400,15420,15440,15460,15480,15500,15520,15540,15560,15580,15600,15620,15640,15660,15680,15700,15720,15740,15760,15780,15800,15820,15840,15860,15880,15900,15920,15940,15960,15980,16000,16020,16040,16060,16080,16100,16120,16140,16160,16180,16200,16220,16240,16260,16280,16300,16320,16340,16360,16380,16400,16420,16440,16460,16480,16500,16520,16540,16560,16580,16600,16620,16640,16660,16680,16700,16720,16740,16760,16780,16800,16820,16840,16860,16880,16900,16920,16940,16960,16980,17000,17020,17040,17060,17080,17100,17120,17140,17160,17180,17200,17220,17240,17260,17280,17300,17320,17340,17360,17380,17400,17420,17440,17460,17480,17500,17520,17540,17560,17580,17600,17620,17640,17660,17680,17700,17720,17740,17760,17780,17800,17820,17840,17860,17880,17900,17920,17940,17960,17980,18000,18020,18040,18060,18080,18100,18120,18140,18160,18180,18200,18220,18240,18260,18280,18300,18320,18340,18360,18380,18400,18420,18440,18460,18480,18500,18520,18540,18560,18580,18600,18620,18640,18660,18680,18700,18720,18740,18760,18780,18800,18820,18840,18860,18880,18900,18920,18940,18960,18980,19000,19020,19040,19060,19080,19100,19120,19140,19160,19180,19200,19220,19240,19260,19280,19300,19320,19340,19360,19380,19400,19420,19440,19460,19480,19500,19520,19540,19560,19580,19600,19620,19640,19660,19680,19700,19720,19740,19760,19780,19800,19820,19840,19860,19880,19900,19920,19940,19960,19980,20000,20020,20040,20060,20080,20100,20120,20140,20160,20180,20200,20220,20240,20260,20280,20300,20320,20340,20360,20380,20400,20420,20440,20460,20480,20500,20520,20540,20560,20580,20600,20620,20640,20660,20680,20700,20720,20740,20760,20780,20800,20820,20840,20860,20880,20900,20920,20940,20960,20980,21000,21020,21040,21060,21080,21100,21120,21140,21160,21180,21200,21220,21240,21260,21280,21300,21320,21340,21360,21380,21400,21420,21440,21460,21480,21500,21520,21540,21560,21580,21600,21620,21640,21660,21680,21700,21720,21740,21760,21780,21800,21820,21840,21860,21880,21900,21920,21940,21960,21980,22000,22020,22040,22060,22080,22100,22120,22140,22160,22180,22200,22220,22240,22260,22280,22300,22320,22340,22360,22380,22400,22420,22440,22460,22480,22500,22520,22540,22560,22580,22600,22620,22640,22660,22680,22700,22720,22740,22760,22780,22800,22820,22840,22860,22880,22900,22920,22940,22960,22980,23000,23020,23040,23060,23080,23100,23120,23140,23160,23180,23200,23220,23240,23260,23280,23300,23320,23340,23360,23380,23400,23420,23440,23460,23480,23500,23520,23540,23560,23580,23600,23620,23640,23660,23680,23700,23720,23740,23760,23780,23800,23820,23840,23860,23880,23900,23920,23940,23960,23980,24000,24020,24040,24060,24080,24100,24120,24140,24160,24180,24200,24220,24240,24260,24280,24300,24320,24340,24360,24380,24400,24420,24440,24460,24480,24500,24520,24540,24560,24580,24600,24620,24640,24660,24680,24700,24720,24740,24760,24780,24800,24820,24840,24860,24880,24900,24920,24940,24960,24980,25000,25020,25040,25060,25080,25100,25120,25140,25160,25180,25200,25220,25240,25260,25280,25300,25320,25340,25360,25380,25400,25420,25440,25460,25480,25500,25520,25540,25560,25580,25600,25620,25640,25660,25680,25700,25720,25740,25760,25780,25800,25820,25840,25860,25880,25900,25920,25940,25960,25980,26000,26020,26040,26060,26080,26100,26120,26140,26160,26180,26200,26220,26240,26260,26280,26300,26320,26340,26360,26380,26400,26420,26440,26460,26480,26500,26520,26540,26560,26580,26600,26620,26640,26660,26680,26700,26720,26740,26760,26780,26800,26820,26840,26860,26880,26900,26920,26940,26960,26980,27000,27020,27040,27060,27080,27100,27120,27140,27160,27180,27200,27220,27240,27260,27280,27300,27320,27340,27360,27380,27400,27420,27440,27460,27480,27500,27520,27540,27560,27580,27600,27620,27640,27660,27680,27700,27720,27740,27760,27780,27800,27820,27840,27860,27880,27900,27920,27940,27960,27980,28000,28020,28040,28060,28080,28100,28120,28140,28160,28180,28200,28220,28240,28260,28280,28300,28320,28340,28360,28380,28400,28420,28440,28460,28480,28500,28520,28540,28560,28580,28600,28620,28640,28660,28680,28700,28720,28740,28760,28780,28800,28820,28840,28860,28880,28900,28920,28940,28960,28980,29000,29020,29040,29060,29080,29100,29120,29140,29160,29180,29200,29220,29240,29260,29280,29300,29320,29340,29360,29380,29400,29420,29440,29460,29480,29500,29520,29540,29560,29580,29600,29620,29640,29660,29680,29700,29720,29740,29760,29780,29800,29820,29840,29860,29880,29900,29920,29940,29960,29980,30000,30020,30040,30060,30080,30100,30120,30140,30160,30180,30200,30220,30240,30260,30280,30300,30320,30340,30360,30380,30400,30420,30440,30460,30480,30500,30520,30540,30560,30580,30600,30620,30640,30660,30680,30700,30720,30740,30760,30780,30800,30820,30840,30860,30880,30900,30920,30940,30960,30980,31000,31020,31040,31060,31080,31100,31120,31140,31160,31180,31200,31220,31240,31260,31280,31300,31320,31340,31360,31380,31400,31420,31440,31460,31480,31500,31520,31540,31560,31580,31600,31620,31640,31660,31680,31700,31720,31740,31760,31780,31800,31820,31840,31860,31880,31900,31920,31940,31960,31980,32000,32020,32040,32060,32080,32100,32120,32140,32160,32180,32200,32220,32240,32260,32280,32300,32320,32340,32360,32380,32400,32420,32440,32460,32480,32500,32520,32540,32560,32580,32600,32620,32640,32660,32680,32700,32720,32740,32760,32780,32800,32820,32840,32860,32880,32900,32920,32940,32960,32980,33000,33020,33040,33060,33080,33100,33120,33140,33160,33180,33200,33220,33240,33260,33280,33300,33320,33340,33360,33380,33400,33420,33440,33460,33480,33500,33520,33540,33560,33580,33600,33620,33640,33660,33680,33700,33720,33740,33760,33780,33800,33820,33840,33860,33880,33900,33920,33940,33960,33980,34000,34020,34040,34060,34080,34100,34120,34140,34160,34180,34200,34220,34240,34260,34280,34300,34320,34340,34360,34380,34400,34420,34440,34460,34480,34500,34520,34540,34560,34580,34600,34620,34640,34660,34680,34700,34720,34740,34760,34780,34800,34820,34840,34860,34880,34900,34920,34940,34960,34980,35000,35020,35040,35060,35080,35100,35120,35140,35160,35180,35200,35220,35240,35260,35280,35300,35320,35340,35360,35380,35400,35420,35440,35460,35480,35500,35520,35540,35560,35580,35600,35620,35640,35660,35680,35700,35720,35740,35760,35780,35800,35820,35840,35860,35880,35900,35920,35940,35960,35980,36000,36020,36040,36060,36080,36100,36120,36140,36160,36180,36200,36220,36240,36260,36280,36300,36320,36340,36360,36380,36400,36420,36440,36460,36480,36500,36520,36540,36560,36580,36600,36620,36640,36660,36680,36700,36720,36740,36760,36780,36800,36820,36840,36860,36880,36900,36920,36940,36960,36980,37000,37020,37040,37060,37080,37100,37120,37140,37160,37180,37200,37220,37240,37260,37280,37300,37320,37340,37360,37380,37400,37420,37440,37460,37480,37500,37520,37540,37560,37580,37600,37620,37640,37660,37680,37700,37720,37740,37760,37780,37800,37820,37840,37860,37880,37900,37920,37940,37960,37980,38000,38020,38040,38060,38080,38100,38120,38140,38160,38180,38200,38220,38240,38260,38280,38300,38320,38340,38360,38380,38400,38420,38440,38460,38480,38500,38520,38540,38560,38580,38600,38620,38640,38660,38680,38700,38720,38740,38760,38780,38800,38820,38840,38860,38880,38900,38920,38940,38960,38980,39000,39020,39040,39060,39080,39100,39120,39140,39160,39180,39200,39220,39240,39260,39280,39300,39320,39340,39360,39380,39400,39420,39440,39460,39480,39500,39520,39540,39560,39580,39600,39620,39640,39660,39680,39700,39720,39740,39760,39780,39800,39820,39840,39860,39880,39900,39920,39940,39960,39980,40000,40020,40040,40060,40080,40100,40120,40140,40160,40180,40200,40220,40240,40260,40280,40300,40320,40340,40360,40380,40400,40420,40440,40460,40480,40500,40520,40540,40560,40580,40600,40620,40640,40660,40680,40700,40720,40740,40760,40780,40800,40820,40840,40860,40880,40900,40920,40940,40960,40980,41000,41020,41040,41060,41080,41100,41120,41140,41160,41180,41200,41220,41240,41260,41280,41300,41320,41340,41360,41380,41400,41420,41440,41460,41480,41500,41520,41540,41560,41580,41600,41620,41640,41660,41680,41700,41720,41740,41760,41780,41800,41820,41840,41860,41880,41900,41920,41940,41960,41980,42000,42020,42040,42060,42080,42100,42120,42140,42160,42180,42200,42220,42240,42260,42280,42300,42320,42340,42360,42380,42400,42420,42440,42460,42480,42500,42520,42540,42560,42580,42600,42620,42640,42660,42680,42700,42720,42740,42760,42780,42800,42820,42840,42860,42880,42900,42920,42940,42960,42980,43000,43020,43040,43060,43080,43100,43120,43140,43160,43180,43200,43220,43240,43260,43280,43300,43320,43340,43360,43380,43400,43420,43440,43460,43480,43500,43520,43540,43560,43580,43600,43620,43640,43660,43680,43700,43720,43740,43760,43780,43800,43820,43840,43860,43880,43900,43920,43940,43960,43980,44000,44020,44040,44060,44080,44100,44120,44140,44160,44180,44200,44220,44240,44260,44280,44300,44320,44340,44360,44380,44400,44420,44440,44460,44480],"target":[[0,120],[76,100],[176,80],[226,60],[251,40]]} diff --git a/doc/lib/js/watch.md b/doc/lib/js/watch.md index be3d2e1974c..d8a06bb91ea 100644 --- a/doc/lib/js/watch.md +++ b/doc/lib/js/watch.md @@ -242,8 +242,8 @@ them; nothing is retained without an open handle. ## Buffered playback By default the player minimizes latency: it time-stretches received audio -back onto the delay, playing it slightly faster or slower, and skips ahead only -when media piles up far past it. Content produced faster than real time, such as a TTS +that falls behind the delay back onto it, playing it slightly faster, and skips +ahead only when media piles up far past it. Content produced faster than real time, such as a TTS response emitted in one burst with future timestamps, wants the opposite. Set `lookahead` to how far ahead it may run and it plays through at the encoded pace: diff --git a/js/hang/api/container.api.md b/js/hang/api/container.api.md index 6b1f7b78a94..f2e81f7f2cb 100644 --- a/js/hang/api/container.api.md +++ b/js/hang/api/container.api.md @@ -20,7 +20,6 @@ export class Consumer { constructor(track: Net.Track.Subscriber, props: ConsumerProps); readonly buffered: Signals.Getter; close(): void; - readonly lateness: Signals.Getter; next(): Promise; readonly spread: Signals.Getter; } diff --git a/js/hang/src/container/consumer.ts b/js/hang/src/container/consumer.ts index dbca85924d0..dcb4913d254 100644 --- a/js/hang/src/container/consumer.ts +++ b/js/hang/src/container/consumer.ts @@ -231,15 +231,6 @@ export class Consumer { * floor. Starts at the predecessor's estimate, or the cold-start estimate without one. */ readonly spread: Getter; - #lateness = new Signal(Milli.zero); - /** - * How late the slowest frame of the last two seconds of media arrived against the fastest. - * - * NetEq's maximum delay, which widens the time stretch's band in doc/concept/audio-jitter.md - * rather than the target. Starts at zero, even after a predecessor: it measures this track's own - * arrivals. - */ - readonly lateness: Getter = this.#lateness; // The newest group opened by a declared end, until a later group's first frame tells the jitter // estimator the silence is over. Not at the marker itself: the stopped encoder's final packets may // follow it in its own group, and they belong to the speech before the silence. @@ -470,7 +461,6 @@ export class Consumer { } this.#jitter.observe(arrival, Milli.fromMicro(sample.timestamp)); this.#spread.set(this.#jitter.measured); - this.#lateness.set(this.#jitter.lateness); } else if (!group.media) { // Only a marker ahead of any media declares an end; one after it is a frame's endpoint. this.#declare(group); diff --git a/js/hang/src/container/jitter.test.ts b/js/hang/src/container/jitter.test.ts index c1321d77891..c346af8d378 100644 --- a/js/hang/src/container/jitter.test.ts +++ b/js/hang/src/container/jitter.test.ts @@ -18,7 +18,6 @@ interface Case { media: number[]; ends?: number[]; target: [number, number][]; - lateness: [number, number][]; } const cases: Case[] = readdirSync(CORPUS) @@ -54,10 +53,8 @@ describe("audio jitter conformance", () => { it(c.name, () => { const jitter = new Jitter(); const expected = new Map(c.target); - const late = new Map(c.lateness); const ends = new Set(c.ends); let current: number | undefined; - let lateness = 0; for (let i = 0; i < c.arrival.length; i++) { if (ends.has(i)) jitter.end(); jitter.observe(c.arrival[i] as Milli, c.media[i] as Milli); @@ -70,10 +67,6 @@ describe("audio jitter conformance", () => { expect(value).toBeCloseTo(current, 6); } current = value; - - // A fixed target ignores the arrivals, which the player applies on top of the estimator. - lateness = late.get(i) ?? lateness; - expect(c.delay !== undefined ? 0 : jitter.lateness).toBeCloseTo(lateness, 6); } }); } @@ -149,19 +142,6 @@ function scan(history: History, media: number): Entry | undefined { return reference; } -// The documented lateness: the slowest entry against the fastest, each the first on a tie. -function slowest(history: History): number { - if (history.length === 0) return 0; - let fast = history.at(0); - let slow = fast; - for (let i = 1; i < history.length; i++) { - const entry = history.at(i); - if (entry.arrival - entry.media < fast.arrival - fast.media) fast = entry; - if (entry.arrival - entry.media > slow.arrival - slow.media) slow = entry; - } - return Math.max(0, slow.arrival - fast.arrival - (slow.media - fast.media)); -} - describe("History", () => { // A tied entry with a different (arrival, media) rounds the delay differently, so the tree must // pick exactly the entry the scan would. @@ -182,7 +162,6 @@ describe("History", () => { for (const query of [media - 30, media - 10, media, media + 10, media + 1e6]) { expect(history.reference(query)).toEqual(scan(history, query)); } - expect(history.lateness()).toBe(slowest(history)); } }); @@ -195,10 +174,8 @@ describe("History", () => { for (const query of [media - 3, media - 0.5, media]) { expect(history.reference(query)).toEqual(scan(history, query)); } - expect(history.lateness()).toBe(slowest(history)); } } expect(history.length).toBe(8192); - expect(history.lateness()).toBe(slowest(history)); }); }); diff --git a/js/hang/src/container/jitter.ts b/js/hang/src/container/jitter.ts index a3e5315d0a7..257beda9c2d 100644 --- a/js/hang/src/container/jitter.ts +++ b/js/hang/src/container/jitter.ts @@ -140,14 +140,6 @@ export class Jitter { return fork; } - /** - * How late the slowest frame in the reference window arrived against its fastest: NetEq's - * maximum delay, which widens the time stretch's band rather than the target. - */ - get lateness(): Milli { - return this.#history.lateness() as Milli; - } - /** The measured term: the upper edge of the bucket holding the 95th percentile. */ get measured(): Milli { let cumulative = 0; @@ -185,14 +177,13 @@ export interface Entry { /** * The arrivals inside the reference window, in media order, answering any prefix's fastest arrival - * in logarithmic time and the whole window's slowest in constant time. + * in logarithmic time. * * A reordered frame is measured against the prefix at or before its timestamp, so a peer that sends * only reordered frames would otherwise force a scan per frame. Entries live in a ring indexed from * `#head`, and a segment tree over the ring's slots holds each node's fastest slot, the older on a * tie, as the scan would pick. A query never spans the ring's wrap point within one node, so a node - * fully inside it is in arrival order. The slowest is the front of a monotonic queue of entries, - * each slower than every later one, named by how many entries were pushed before it. + * fully inside it is in arrival order. * * @internal Exported for the equivalence test. */ @@ -207,11 +198,6 @@ export class History { #len = 0; /** Leaf `capacity + slot` holds `slot`; each parent holds the faster of its children. */ #tree = new Uint32Array(0); - /** Entries ever pushed, so `#pushed - #len` names the oldest one held. */ - #pushed = 0; - /** From `#slowHead`, the entries no later entry is as slow as, oldest first. */ - #slow: number[] = []; - #slowHead = 0; /** The entries held. */ get length(): number { @@ -241,34 +227,6 @@ export class History { for (let node = (capacity + slot) >> 1; node > 0; node >>= 1) { this.#tree[node] = this.#faster(this.#tree[2 * node], this.#tree[2 * node + 1]); } - - // Drop the queue's evicted front, then every entry this one is slower than, keeping the older - // on a tie the way the reference does. - const oldest = this.#pushed - this.#len + 1; - while (this.#slowHead < this.#slow.length && this.#slow[this.#slowHead] < oldest) this.#slowHead++; - const key = arrival - media; - while (this.#slow.length > this.#slowHead) { - const back = this.at(this.#slow[this.#slow.length - 1] - oldest); - if (back.arrival - back.media >= key) break; - this.#slow.pop(); - } - if (this.#slowHead > 1024 && this.#slowHead * 2 > this.#slow.length) { - this.#slow = this.#slow.slice(this.#slowHead); - this.#slowHead = 0; - } - this.#slow.push(this.#pushed); - this.#pushed++; - } - - /** - * How late the slowest entry arrived against the fastest, zero for an empty window: NetEq's - * `GetMaxDelayMs`, in the same arithmetic as a frame's delay. - */ - lateness(): number { - const fast = this.reference(Number.POSITIVE_INFINITY); - if (fast === undefined) return 0; - const slow = this.at(this.#slow[this.#slowHead] - (this.#pushed - this.#len)); - return Math.max(0, slow.arrival - fast.arrival - (slow.media - fast.media)); } /** The fastest entry with `entry.media <= media`, the oldest on a tie. */ diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/buffer.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/buffer.ts index 0a7d21a2184..a8b0c69ee8d 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/buffer.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/buffer.ts @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ import { Micro, Milli, type Second } from "@moq/clock"; import { Effect, type Getter, Signal } from "@moq/signals"; import { ringHold, ringSamples } from "./latency"; -import type { Data, End, Init, Latency, Lateness, Playing, Reset, State, Truncate } from "./render"; +import type { Data, End, Init, Latency, Playing, Reset, State, Truncate } from "./render"; /** * Decides when the decode loop may decode a frame, which is how the target delay is split between @@ -16,7 +16,8 @@ import type { Data, End, Init, Latency, Lateness, Playing, Reset, State, Truncat * stops once the PCM in the ring plus the frames still decoding reach the floor, since the ring * plays through and cannot shed what overflows it; * - while playing, once the playhead is within the floor of where its output lands, keeping the - * ring on its floor; + * ring on its floor. Live, that is where the output ends: the ring's time stretch measures its + * depth right after each write, and reads a tail past the floor as audio behind the clock; * - while playing live, also once the media queued behind it covers the hold, so media past the * target reaches the ring, whose skip band catches up to the live edge. Buffered mode plays * through instead. @@ -63,6 +64,10 @@ export class Backpressure { // ring compares a frame to its playhead where the output lands, or an offset past the floor would // drain it. #offset = 0; + // The duration of the latest output, which the next frame's is taken to match. A live frame released + // by where its output starts would land with its tail past the floor, and the stretch accelerating + // that away would only draw the next frame out sooner, playing through the hold. + #frame = 0 as Micro; #waiters: Array<{ timestamp: Micro; resolve: () => void }> = []; @@ -141,6 +146,7 @@ export class Backpressure { /** Note that PCM from `start` to `end` reached the ring. */ inserted(start: Micro, end: Micro): void { + this.#frame = (end - start) as Micro; const inserted = this.#inserted; this.#inserted = { start: inserted?.start ?? start, end: inserted && inserted.end > end ? inserted.end : end }; this.#release(); @@ -229,7 +235,8 @@ export class Backpressure { #due(timestamp: Micro): boolean { const playhead = this.#playhead; if (!this.#stalled && playhead !== undefined) { - if (timestamp - this.#offset - this.#headroom <= playhead) return true; + const tail = this.#buffered ? 0 : this.#frame; + if (timestamp + tail - this.#offset - this.#headroom <= playhead) return true; return !this.#buffered && this.#covered(timestamp); } @@ -386,15 +393,6 @@ export class AudioBuffer { this.#worklet.port.postMessage(msg); } - /** - * Widen the band the worklet's stretch holds above the floor by how late the slowest recent - * arrival was against the fastest, as NetEq does. See doc/concept/audio-jitter.md. - */ - setLateness(lateness: Milli): void { - const msg: Lateness = { type: "lateness", lateness }; - this.#worklet.port.postMessage(msg); - } - /** * Note the newest media timestamp queued ahead of the decoder, or undefined once none is. The * queue is what covers the part of the target held encoded, so it is what resumes a parked ring. diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/decoder.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/decoder.ts index 473674716b9..c32c642412c 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/decoder.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/decoder.ts @@ -177,9 +177,6 @@ export class Decoder { // The container consumer's arrival estimate, unset while nothing is subscribed. #measured = new Signal(undefined); - // How late the consumer's slowest recent arrival was against its fastest, which widens the band - // the ring's stretch holds above its floor. - #lateness = new Signal(Milli.zero); // The subscription's max delay: the shared budget, raised to the estimator's ceiling in "auto". #subscribeMaxDelay = new Signal(Milli.zero); @@ -261,7 +258,6 @@ export class Decoder { this.#signals.run(this.#runWorklet.bind(this)); this.#signals.run(this.#runEnabled.bind(this)); this.#signals.run(this.#runLatency.bind(this)); - this.#signals.run(this.#runLateness.bind(this)); this.#signals.run(this.#runDecoder.bind(this)); this.#signals.run(this.#runStalls.bind(this)); } @@ -479,16 +475,6 @@ export class Decoder { ring.setLatency(effect.get(this.sync.out.delay)); } - #runLateness(effect: Effect): void { - const ring = effect.get(this.#ring); - if (!ring) return; - - // NetEq's band above the target, from the arrivals the target was measured from. An explicit - // delay ignores the arrivals entirely, so it keeps the bare 20 ms band. - const auto = effect.get(this.sync.in.delay) === "auto"; - ring.setLateness(auto ? effect.get(this.#lateness) : Milli.zero); - } - #runDecoder(effect: Effect): void { // The reorder policy belongs to the playback mode, so a mode change starts a new reader. effect.get(this.sync.out.buffered); @@ -872,10 +858,8 @@ export class Decoder { }); // Feed the arrival estimate into the playout target. It outlives this consumer, so the target - // holds until the replacement takes over; see #retire. The stretch's band follows this - // consumer's own arrivals. + // holds until the replacement takes over; see #retire. effect.run((inner) => this.#measured.set(inner.get(consumer.spread))); - effect.run((inner) => this.#lateness.set(inner.get(consumer.lateness))); return { consumer, read }; } @@ -885,7 +869,6 @@ export class Decoder { if (failure) this.#phase.set({ kind: "failed", failure }); else if (this.#phase.peek().kind === "running") this.#phase.set({ kind: "stopped" }); this.#measured.set(undefined); - this.#lateness.set(Milli.zero); // Its arrivals stop holding the clock's reference. this.#track.reset(); } diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/playout.test.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/playout.test.ts index b999fb07f11..6694c6f246a 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/playout.test.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/playout.test.ts @@ -205,9 +205,9 @@ describe("ring replay", () => { it("still underruns when the target ignores the arrival spread, but drops nothing", () => { // 46ms is what the round-trip formula produced on the connection this was measured on: it // describes the network and says nothing about a sender that flushes five frames at once. - // Every flush's trough falls below it. Preemptive expand lengthens the ring by one pitch period - // a window at most, as NetEq's does, which cannot cover a 100 ms trough, so the ring runs dry - // on most flushes; accelerate brings each peak back down rather than skipping it. + // Every flush's trough falls below it, and the ring never slows down to cover one, since that + // would only settle audio behind the clock, so it runs dry on most flushes; accelerate brings + // each peak back down rather than skipping it. const t = trace(600, 5, 5); const result = replay(build(46), t, 2000); const flushes = (t.length - 2000 / CHUNK_MS) / 5; diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/render-worklet.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/render-worklet.ts index b720a064d25..e7c23e255b4 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/render-worklet.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/render-worklet.ts @@ -36,8 +36,6 @@ class Render extends AudioWorkletProcessor { this.#ring?.park(); this.#epoch = msg.park; } - } else if (msg.type === "lateness") { - this.#ring?.setLateness(msg.lateness); } else if (msg.type === "end") { this.#ring?.end(msg.timestamp); } else if (msg.type === "truncate") { diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/render.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/render.ts index 25ee1dac4fa..b3ac4dde878 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/render.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/render.ts @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ import type { Micro, Milli } from "@moq/clock"; /** Everything the main thread sends the render worklet over its port. */ -export type Message = Init | Data | Latency | Lateness | Reset | Truncate | Playing | End; +export type Message = Init | Data | Latency | Reset | Truncate | Playing | End; /** Create the worklet's ring. */ export interface Init { @@ -53,12 +53,6 @@ export interface Latency { park?: number; } -/** How late the slowest recent arrival was against the fastest, which widens the stretch's band. */ -export interface Lateness { - type: "lateness"; - lateness: Milli; -} - /** State update from the worklet back to the main thread. */ export interface State { type: "state"; diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/replay.test.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/replay.test.ts index e7568f790c0..6db5da84f7e 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/replay.test.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/replay.test.ts @@ -68,36 +68,33 @@ describe("replay", () => { }); it("counts each run-dry the way the player's stats do", async () => { - // One frame 200 ms late against a 60 ms target: the groups behind it wait longer than time - // stretch can spread the ring, so it runs dry part-way through a quantum, which counts, and - // re-stalls to refill on the next, which counts again. + // One frame 200 ms late against a 100 ms target: the ring runs dry once and re-stalls to refill. const trace = paced(10, (i) => (i === 250 ? 230 : 30)).sort((a, b) => a.at - b.at); const counted = async (arrivals: Arrival[]) => { let last = 0; for await (const { underruns } of replay(arrivals, { rate: RATE, config: CONFIG, - delay: Milli(60), + delay: Milli(100), duration: observed(10), })) last = underruns; return last; }; expect(await counted(paced(10, () => 30))).toBe(0); - expect(await counted(trace)).toBe(2); + expect(await counted(trace)).toBe(1); }); it("holds newer groups behind a missing one until the max delay gives up on it", async () => { const trace = paced(10, () => 30).filter((arrival) => arrival.group !== 250); - // The consumer delivers in group order, so the groups behind the missing one wait, longer than - // time stretch can spread a 60 ms ring, and it runs dry for longer than the missing frame. - // Writing arrivals straight into the ring would play only the frame's own 20 ms hole. + // The consumer delivers in group order, so the ring runs dry for longer than the missing frame + // while the groups behind it wait. Writing arrivals straight into the ring plays straight through. const frame = Math.ceil((20 / 1000) * (RATE / QUANTUM)); expect( await underruns(trace, { rate: RATE, config: CONFIG, - delay: Milli(60), + delay: Milli(100), duration: observed(10), }), ).toBeGreaterThan(frame); @@ -139,6 +136,61 @@ describe("replay", () => { }); }); +/** + * How far the playhead trails the shared clock video plays from, in ms, for each quantum played once + * the first `settle` ms have passed, with the underruns the ring counted by the end. + */ +async function lag(trace: Arrival[], options: Options, settle: number) { + const lags: number[] = []; + let underruns = 0; + for await (const quantum of replay(trace, options)) { + if (quantum.at >= settle && !quantum.stalled && quantum.clock !== undefined) { + lags.push(quantum.clock - quantum.timestamp); + } + underruns = quantum.underruns; + } + lags.sort((a, b) => a - b); + return { lags, median: lags[lags.length >> 1], underruns }; +} + +// Audio and video keep separate clocks that align once the delay covers the arrivals. Settling audio +// later than the clock would trade lip sync for fewer underruns, so these hold the line: at steady +// state the playhead rests on or just ahead of the clock, and a target short of the spread underruns +// rather than drifting behind it. +describe("replay against the shared clock", () => { + let warn: Mock; + beforeEach(() => { + warn = spyOn(console, "warn").mockImplementation(() => {}); + }); + afterEach(() => warn.mockRestore()); + + // The ring rests one frame ahead of the newest arrival's playout, as the trim that preceded the + // time stretch left it, so audio leads the clock by up to that frame and never trails it. + for (const [name, lateness] of [ + ["evenly paced", () => 30], + ["flushed five frames at a time", (i: number) => 30 + (4 - (i % 5)) * 20], + ] as const) { + it(`plays ${name} frames on the clock at auto, never behind it`, async () => { + const options: Options = { rate: RATE, config: CONFIG, delay: "auto", duration: observed(60) }; + const { lags } = await lag(paced(60, lateness), options, 30_000); + expect(lags.length).toBeGreaterThan(0); + expect(lags[0]).toBeGreaterThanOrEqual(-25); + expect(lags.at(-1)).toBeLessThanOrEqual(0); + }); + } + + it("underruns a target short of the spread rather than settling behind the clock", async () => { + // 80 ms of spread against a 40 ms target: every flush runs the ring dry. + const trace = paced(60, (i) => 30 + (4 - (i % 5)) * 20); + const options: Options = { rate: RATE, config: CONFIG, delay: Milli(40), duration: observed(60) }; + const { lags, median, underruns } = await lag(trace, options, 30_000); + expect(underruns).toBeGreaterThanOrEqual(trace.length / 5); + // Each refill catches back up within the frame after it, never by a whole flush. + expect(median).toBeLessThanOrEqual(20); + expect(lags.at(-1)).toBeLessThan(40); + }); +}); + describe("replay at auto", () => { /** The delay the replay resolved once `seconds` of {@link paced} frames played out. */ async function settled(seconds: number, lateness: (i: number) => number): Promise { diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/replay.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/replay.ts index 7fc326ccb34..6f7ace49450 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/replay.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/replay.ts @@ -81,6 +81,8 @@ export interface Quantum { stalled: boolean; /** The playhead after this quantum, on the media clock, in ms. */ timestamp: number; + /** Where the shared clock puts video as of this quantum (`Sync.now()`), on the media clock, in ms. */ + clock?: number; /** The delay `Sync` resolved as of this quantum, in ms: what the ring and the decode gate hold. */ delay: number; /** The ring's cumulative underruns, as the player's stats count them: each run-dry and each short quantum. */ @@ -161,12 +163,6 @@ export async function* replay(trace: Arrival[], options: Options): AsyncGenerato const ring = new AudioRingBuffer({ rate, channels: 1, latency: millis(rate, gate.floor) }); const observe = () => gate.observe(ring.anchored ? ring.timestamp : undefined, ring.stalled); - // The decoder widens the stretch's band by the consumer's lateness, unless the delay is explicit. - signals.run((effect) => { - const auto = effect.get(sync.in.delay) === "auto"; - ring.setLateness(auto ? effect.get(consumer.lateness) : Milli.zero); - }); - // Arrived but not yet decoded media, read or still in the consumer, is what covers the part of the // target held encoded, and what resumes a parked ring. const read = new Signal(undefined); @@ -285,6 +281,7 @@ export async function* replay(trace: Arrival[], options: Options): AsyncGenerato output, stalled: ring.stalled, timestamp: Milli.fromMicro(ring.timestamp), + clock: sync.now(), delay, underruns: ring.underruns, skips: ring.skips, diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts index 64ab4c41a98..4bb25240372 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.test.ts @@ -589,12 +589,13 @@ describe("declared end", () => { expect(read(buffer, 20, 1)[0].length).toBe(20); buffer.next(); - write(buffer, 50 as Milli, 40, { channels: 1, value: 2 }); + // One 20 ms frame, so the ring stays within a frame of its floor and plays it as received. + write(buffer, 50 as Milli, 20, { channels: 1, value: 2 }); // The rest of the tail, the short gap to the next utterance, then the utterance itself. - const [played] = read(buffer, 70, 1); + const [played] = read(buffer, 50, 1); expect([...played.slice(0, 20)]).toEqual(Array(20).fill(1)); expect([...played.slice(20, 30)]).toEqual(Array(10).fill(0)); - expect([...played.slice(30)]).toEqual(Array(40).fill(2)); + expect([...played.slice(30)]).toEqual(Array(20).fill(2)); // The gap is the declared silence, for the reader to fill with comfort noise. expect(buffer.quiet).toEqual([20, 30]); expect(buffer.underruns).toBe(0); @@ -844,7 +845,9 @@ describe("time stretch", () => { const live = (latency: number) => new AudioRingBuffer({ rate: RATE, channels: 1, latency: latency as Milli }); const frames = (ms: number) => (RATE * ms) / 1000; - it("expands a ring short of its floor, so it plays longer than it holds before running dry", () => { + // Slowing down only ever settles audio behind the shared clock, so a ring short of its floor plays + // what it holds at its own pace and runs dry: the underrun is the cost of arrivals running late. + it("never expands a ring short of its floor, so it plays only what it holds before running dry", () => { const buffer = live(100); write(buffer, 0 as Milli, frames(100), { value: 0.5 }); let played = 0; @@ -853,7 +856,7 @@ describe("time stretch", () => { played += output.length; if (output.length < QUANTUM) break; } - expect(played).toBeGreaterThan(frames(100)); + expect(played).toBe(frames(100)); expect(buffer.underruns).toBe(1); }); @@ -872,31 +875,44 @@ describe("time stretch", () => { expect(buffer.silent).toBe(true); }); - // Fed at the real-time rate, so only the stretch can move the ring's depth. - async function converge(buffer: AudioRingBuffer, start: number, seconds: number) { + // Fed `burst` ms of 20 ms frames at a time, at the real-time rate, so only the stretch can move the + // ring's depth. Returns the depth right after each burst lands, where it reads the clock. + async function converge(buffer: AudioRingBuffer, start: number, seconds: number, burst = 20) { const timestamps: number[] = []; + const peaks: number[] = []; let written = start; for (let rendered = 0; rendered < frames(seconds * 1000); rendered += QUANTUM) { - while (written < start + rendered + QUANTUM) { - write(buffer, ((written * 1000) / RATE) as Milli, frames(20), { value: 0.5 }); - written += frames(20); + if (written < start + rendered + QUANTUM) { + for (const end = written + frames(burst); written < end; written += frames(20)) { + write(buffer, ((written * 1000) / RATE) as Milli, frames(20), { value: 0.5 }); + } + peaks.push(buffer.length); } const [output] = read(buffer, QUANTUM, 1); - expect(output.length).toBe(QUANTUM); + if (burst === 20) expect(output.length).toBe(QUANTUM); timestamps.push(Milli.fromMicro(buffer.timestamp)); } - return { timestamps, written }; + return { timestamps, peaks, written }; } + // A constant signal accelerates by one 2.5 ms pitch period at a time, and only by a period that fits + // in the excess, so the ring rests within one period of its floor and never under it. + const PERIOD = frames(2.5); + const settled = (peaks: number[], floor: number) => { + for (const peak of peaks.slice(-20)) { + expect(peak).toBeGreaterThanOrEqual(frames(floor)); + expect(peak).toBeLessThan(frames(floor) + PERIOD); + } + }; + it("accelerates a ring above its floor back onto it, dropping nothing", async () => { const buffer = live(100); write(buffer, 0 as Milli, frames(300), { value: 0.5 }); - const { timestamps, written } = await converge(buffer, frames(300), 8); + const { timestamps, peaks, written } = await converge(buffer, frames(300), 8); - // Within the band above the floor, give or take the 20 ms frame just written. - expect(buffer.length).toBeGreaterThanOrEqual(frames(100) - frames(20)); - expect(buffer.length).toBeLessThan(frames(120) + frames(20)); + settled(peaks, 100); // Every sample written either played or is still buffered, so nothing was skipped. + expect(buffer.skips).toBe(0); expect(Math.round((Milli.fromMicro(buffer.timestamp) * RATE) / 1000) + buffer.length).toBeGreaterThan( written - frames(30), ); @@ -908,19 +924,28 @@ describe("time stretch", () => { expect(buffer.underruns).toBe(0); }); - it("holds a ring inside the band its arrivals' lateness widens, accelerating only past it", async () => { - const buffer = live(100); - buffer.setLateness(100 as Milli); - write(buffer, 0 as Milli, frames(300), { value: 0.5 }); - await converge(buffer, frames(300), 8); - - // Above the 100 ms floor but inside 100 ms of lateness plus the 20 ms band, give or take the - // 20 ms frame just written, where without the lateness it accelerates down to the floor. - expect(buffer.length).toBeGreaterThanOrEqual(frames(200) - frames(20)); - expect(buffer.length).toBeLessThan(frames(220) + frames(20)); + // Five 20 ms frames flushed at once, every 100 ms. Between bursts the ring drains a whole burst + // below its floor, which is arrivals running late rather than audio ahead of the clock, so steering + // on that depth would settle a burst behind it. + it("rests on its floor right after each burst, never a burst above it", async () => { + const buffer = live(120); + write(buffer, 0 as Milli, frames(120), { value: 0.5 }); + const { peaks } = await converge(buffer, frames(120), 8, 100); + settled(peaks, 120); expect(buffer.underruns).toBe(0); }); + // A floor short of the arrival spread underruns, and that is the cost of the floor: the ring must + // not grow its depth to stop underrunning, which only plays everything later. + it("underruns every burst that outruns its floor rather than settling later", async () => { + const buffer = live(60); + write(buffer, 0 as Milli, frames(60), { value: 0.5 }); + const { peaks } = await converge(buffer, frames(60), 8, 100); + // Each burst lands on an empty ring, never on audio left from the one before. + for (const peak of peaks.slice(-20)) expect(peak).toBe(frames(100)); + expect(buffer.underruns).toBeGreaterThanOrEqual(70); + }); + it("fast-accelerates a ring four times past the band, even straight after a stretch", async () => { const buffer = live(100); write(buffer, 0 as Milli, frames(600), { value: 0.5 }); @@ -987,16 +1012,13 @@ describe("time stretch", () => { // Past NetEq's fast threshold, four times the floor plus its band, or three quarters of the // headroom above the floor, whichever is lower, stretching back would take seconds, so the ring // re-anchors on its floor as moq-audio does. With 1000 ms of capacity, a 100 ms floor reaches the - // first at 480 ms, or 560 ms with 20 ms of lateness widening its band, and a 300 ms floor the - // second at 825 ms. - for (const [floor, lateness, threshold] of [ - [100, 0, 480], - [100, 20, 560], - [300, 0, 825], + // first at 480 ms, and a 300 ms floor the second at 825 ms. + for (const [floor, threshold] of [ + [100, 480], + [300, 825], ]) { - it(`re-anchors a ${floor} ms floor ${lateness} ms late only once the ring holds ${threshold} ms`, () => { + it(`re-anchors a ${floor} ms floor only once the ring holds ${threshold} ms`, () => { const buffer = live(floor); - buffer.setLateness(lateness as Milli); write(buffer, 0 as Milli, frames(floor), { value: 0.5 }); read(buffer, QUANTUM, 1); const playhead = buffer.timestamp; diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts index cfbdee414c8..7638b44ae37 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/ring-buffer.ts @@ -41,10 +41,15 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { // decode would otherwise widen the band for the life of the ring. #chunk = 0; - // Live playback converges on the floor by time-stretching each window of received PCM on its way - // out. The read index is past the staged window, which spans `#window` samples of the ring. + // Live playback converges on the floor by accelerating each window of received PCM on its way out. + // The read index is past the staged window, which spans `#window` samples of the ring. readonly #stretch: Stretch; #window = 0; + // The ring's length right after the latest write, less what the stretch has removed since. That + // is where depth reads the clock: a frame has just arrived. Between arrivals the ring drains + // toward the next one, which says nothing about how far behind the playhead is, so steering on + // the current length would expand into every gap and settle behind the shared clock. + #peak = 0; // Whether the staged window lies in a declared silence, which plays unstretched as comfort noise. #windowQuiet = false; @@ -52,9 +57,6 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { readonly #buffered: boolean; // Un-stall threshold in samples (how much to buffer before playback starts). #latencySamples: number; - // How late the slowest recent arrival was against the fastest, in samples, which widens the band - // the stretch holds above the floor. - #latenessSamples = 0; // Whether the read/write indices have been anchored to the first inserted sample. #anchored = false; @@ -156,11 +158,6 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { if (this.length >= latencySamples) this.#stalled = false; } - /** Widen the band above the floor by how late the slowest recent arrival was, as NetEq does. */ - setLateness(lateness: Milli): void { - this.#latenessSamples = Math.max(0, Math.floor(this.rate * Second.fromMilli(lateness))); - } - /** * Hold playback until the next floor update, keeping what is buffered. * @@ -214,10 +211,10 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { if (start > this.#writeIndex) this.#pauses.push({ start: this.#writeIndex, end: start }); } - // Bound the ring. While playing live, the read path stretches the ring back onto its floor, so + // Bound the ring. While playing live, the read path accelerates the ring back onto its floor, so // dropping the oldest audio and landing on the floor is an emergency re-anchor, as moq-audio - // does: at NetEq's fast threshold, four times the floor plus its band, or once the ring holds - // three quarters of its headroom above the floor, whichever comes first. While stalled the + // does: at NetEq's fast threshold, four times the floor plus 20 ms, or once the ring holds three + // quarters of its headroom above the floor, whichever comes first. While stalled the // reader is not consuming, so only the hard capacity applies; dropping would throw away the very // audio the refill is accumulating. Buffered mode plays through everything, so it is // capacity-bound too. @@ -240,7 +237,7 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { band && queued >= Math.min( - 4 * (latency + this.#latenessSamples + Math.floor((this.rate * 20) / 1000)), + 4 * (latency + Math.floor((this.rate * 20) / 1000)), latency + Math.floor(((this.capacity - latency) * 3) / 4), ) ) { @@ -281,6 +278,7 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { if (end > this.#writeIndex) { this.#writeIndex = end; } + this.#peak = this.length; // Start playback once we've buffered the latency target. This is the only way out of a // stall but a park, so an underrun mid-playback refills to the target before resuming rather @@ -299,6 +297,7 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { truncate(timestamp: Micro): void { const target = Math.round(Second.fromMicro(timestamp) * this.rate); if (target >= this.#writeIndex) return; + const length = this.length; // A staged window runs the read index ahead of the playhead. Unstage it so the successor // replaces whatever of it is still unplayed, resuming the ring at the sample now playing. const stretch = this.#stretch; @@ -314,6 +313,7 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { this.#pauses = this.#pauses.filter((pause) => pause.start < this.#writeIndex); const last = this.#pauses.at(-1); if (last) last.end = Math.min(last.end, this.#writeIndex); + this.#peak = Math.max(0, this.#peak - (length - this.length)); } /** @@ -333,11 +333,13 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { if (index > this.#readIndex && this.length > 0) this.#skips++; // The staged window lies behind the new index, so it is dropped with the rest, as moq-audio's // trim discards staged output first. + const length = this.length; if (index > this.#readIndex) { this.#stretch.clear(); this.#window = 0; } this.#readIndex = index; + this.#peak = Math.max(0, this.#peak - (length - this.length)); this.#prune(); } @@ -388,6 +390,7 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { this.#pauses = []; this.#stretch.clear(); this.#window = 0; + this.#peak = 0; } read(output: Float32Array[]): number { @@ -432,7 +435,7 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { return samples; } - // Move the next window off the ring into the stretch, which converges a live ring on its floor. + // Move the next window off the ring into the stretch, which accelerates a live ring onto its floor. // A window stops at the edge of a declared silence, which plays unstretched, so the stretch never // moves where one starts or ends. Whatever cannot stretch stages only the `need` this quantum // reads, so a write still lands anywhere past the playhead. Returns false once the ring is empty. @@ -443,8 +446,8 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { this.#prune(); const pause = this.#pauses[0]; const quiet = pause !== undefined && pause.start <= this.#readIndex; - // Audio before a declared end is a finite tail: running dry after it is silence, not an - // underrun, so it drains as received rather than expanding toward a target nothing will refill. + // Audio before a declared end is a finite tail: it drains as received, since the next utterance + // re-anchors the ring anyway. const end = this.#previous ?? this.#end; const ending = end !== undefined && this.#readIndex < end; const enabled = !quiet && !ending && !this.#buffered; @@ -456,7 +459,9 @@ export class AudioRingBuffer { const dst = this.#stretch.input[channel]; for (let i = 0; i < frames; i++) dst[i] = src[(this.#readIndex + i) % src.length]; } - this.#stretch.process(frames, buffered, this.#latencySamples, this.#latenessSamples, enabled); + const stretch = this.#stretch; + stretch.process(frames, this.#peak - this.#latencySamples, enabled); + this.#peak -= frames - stretch.length; this.#readIndex += frames; this.#window = frames; this.#windowQuiet = quiet; diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.test.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.test.ts index 84c60b0e323..9d6de528ad0 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.test.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.test.ts @@ -11,10 +11,9 @@ interface Vector { input: number[]; buffered: number; target: number; - /** The arrivals' lateness in frames, zero when the vector leaves it out. */ - lateness?: number; cooldown: number; - decision: Decision; + /** As native playback decides: it also expands, which this player never does. */ + decision: Decision | "Expand"; lag: number; output: number[]; } @@ -30,22 +29,34 @@ const vectors = JSON.parse(readFileSync(corpus, "utf8")) as Vector[]; const planar = (samples: number[], channels: number) => Array.from({ length: channels }, (_, channel) => samples.filter((_, i) => i % channels === channel)); +// The corpus decides as NetEq does, on the buffered depth against a band around the target. This +// player decides on the excess above the target alone and never expands, so the corpus grades its +// seams: an excess past the 20 ms band fast-accelerates, one inside it accelerates, and a ring at or +// short of its target, where NetEq holds or expands, plays its window unchanged. +const excess = (vector: Vector) => { + const band = Math.floor((vector.rate * 20) / 1000); + if (vector.decision === "Fast") return vector.buffered - vector.target; + if (vector.decision === "Accelerate") return band - 1; + return Math.min(0, vector.buffered - vector.target); +}; + for (const vector of vectors) { it(`stretches the corpus PCM: ${vector.name}`, () => { const stretch = new Stretch(vector.rate, vector.channels); - planar(vector.input, vector.channels).forEach((samples, channel) => { + const input = planar(vector.input, vector.channels); + input.forEach((samples, channel) => { stretch.input[channel].set(samples); }); stretch.cooldown = vector.cooldown; - const lateness = vector.lateness ?? 0; - expect(stretch.decide(vector.buffered, vector.target, lateness)).toBe(vector.decision); + const expand = vector.decision === "Expand"; + expect(stretch.decide(excess(vector))).toBe(vector.decision === "Expand" ? "Hold" : vector.decision); - stretch.process(stretch.window, vector.buffered, vector.target, lateness, true); - expect(Math.abs(stretch.available - stretch.window)).toBe(vector.lag); + stretch.process(stretch.window, excess(vector), true); + expect(stretch.window - stretch.available).toBe(expand ? 0 : vector.lag); const output = Array.from({ length: vector.channels }, () => new Float32Array(stretch.available)); expect(stretch.read(output, 0)).toBe(output[0].length); - const expected = planar(vector.output, vector.channels); + const expected = expand ? input : planar(vector.output, vector.channels); for (let channel = 0; channel < vector.channels; channel++) { expect(output[channel].length).toBe(expected[channel].length); output[channel].forEach((sample, i) => { @@ -55,23 +66,54 @@ for (const vector of vectors) { }); } -it("passes a short, disabled, or exhausted window through unchanged", () => { +it("decides on the excess above the target, and never to slow down", () => { + const stretch = new Stretch(48000, 1); + stretch.cooldown = 0; + // At or short of the target is audio on the clock or arrivals running late: either way, hold. + expect(stretch.decide(0)).toBe("Hold"); + expect(stretch.decide(-48000)).toBe("Hold"); + // Any excess accelerates, so the ring rests on its target rather than in a band above it. + expect(stretch.decide(1)).toBe("Accelerate"); + expect(stretch.decide(959)).toBe("Accelerate"); + // From NetEq's 20 ms granularity, fast-accelerate, even straight after a stretch. + expect(stretch.decide(960)).toBe("Fast"); + stretch.cooldown = 1; + expect(stretch.decide(959)).toBe("Hold"); + expect(stretch.decide(960)).toBe("Fast"); +}); + +it("passes a short, disabled, exhausted, or late window through unchanged", () => { for (const rate of [8000, 44100, 48000, 96000]) { const stretch = new Stretch(rate, 2); for (const channel of stretch.input) channel.fill(0.25); stretch.cooldown = 0; - // A ring well short of its target expands a full window of received PCM. - stretch.process(stretch.window, stretch.window, rate, 0, true); - expect(stretch.available).toBeGreaterThan(stretch.window); + // A ring well above its target accelerates a full window of received PCM. + stretch.process(stretch.window, stretch.window, true); + expect(stretch.available).toBeLessThan(stretch.window); const output = [new Float32Array(rate), new Float32Array(rate)]; expect(stretch.read(output, 0)).toBe(stretch.length); expect(stretch.read(output, 0)).toBe(0); stretch.cooldown = 0; - stretch.process(stretch.window, stretch.window, rate, 0, false); + stretch.process(stretch.window, stretch.window, false); expect(stretch.available).toBe(stretch.window); - stretch.process(stretch.window >> 1, stretch.window, rate, 0, true); + stretch.process(stretch.window >> 1, stretch.window, true); expect(stretch.available).toBe(stretch.window >> 1); + // A ring a whole window short of its target still plays it as received. + stretch.process(stretch.window, -stretch.window, true); + expect(stretch.available).toBe(stretch.window); } }); + +it("accelerates only by a pitch period that fits in the excess", () => { + // A constant signal's shortest period is 2.5 ms: 120 frames at 48 kHz. + const stretch = new Stretch(48000, 1); + stretch.input[0].fill(0.25); + stretch.cooldown = 0; + stretch.process(stretch.window, 119, true); + expect(stretch.available).toBe(stretch.window); + stretch.cooldown = 0; + stretch.process(stretch.window, 120, true); + expect(stretch.available).toBe(stretch.window - 120); +}); diff --git a/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts b/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts index 4db35c75e91..31ad99d53f7 100644 --- a/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts +++ b/js/watch/src/audio/stretch.ts @@ -1,15 +1,16 @@ /*! - * Received-PCM adaptation of WebRTC NetEq's accelerate and preemptive expand, the shared algorithm - * doc/concept/audio-jitter.md specifies for this player and moq-audio's. + * Received-PCM adaptation of WebRTC NetEq's accelerate, the shared seams and pitch search + * doc/concept/audio-jitter.md specifies for this player and moq-audio's. This player never expands: + * its ring starts on its target, so slowing down only ever settles audio behind the shared clock. * * Copyright (c) 2012 The WebRTC project authors. All Rights Reserved. - * Ported from modules/audio_coding/neteq/{time_stretch,accelerate,preemptive_expand,dsp_helper, + * Ported from modules/audio_coding/neteq/{time_stretch,accelerate,dsp_helper, * audio_vector,decision_logic}. * @license BSD-3-Clause, with WebRTC's patent grant: see WEBRTC-LICENSE and WEBRTC-PATENTS in this package. */ /** What a window boundary decides, named as the shared corpus names it. */ -export type Decision = "Hold" | "Accelerate" | "Fast" | "Expand"; +export type Decision = "Hold" | "Accelerate" | "Fast"; // NetEq's 48 kHz Q12 FIR. Sampling its taps at fractional positions also admits other device rates // without altering the search domain. @@ -38,7 +39,7 @@ export class Stretch { readonly #rate: number; // 15 ms: the seam's position, and the longest pitch period. readonly #middle: number; - // 20 ms: NetEq's adjustment granularity, which the band above the target adds to the lateness. + // 20 ms: NetEq's adjustment granularity. An excess this large fast-accelerates. readonly #band: number; // 50 ms: NetEq's five 10 ms ticks between stretches. readonly #rest: number; @@ -60,7 +61,7 @@ export class Stretch { this.#rest = Math.floor((rate * 50) / 1000); this.cooldown = Math.floor((rate * 60) / 1000); this.input = Array.from({ length: channels }, () => new Float32Array(this.window)); - this.#output = Array.from({ length: channels }, () => new Float32Array(this.window + this.#middle)); + this.#output = Array.from({ length: channels }, () => new Float32Array(this.window)); } /** Output frames staged and not yet read. */ @@ -94,16 +95,15 @@ export class Stretch { } /** - * Stage the first `frames` of {@link input}, stretched toward `target` given `buffered` frames - * queued including them and the arrivals' `lateness`. Only a full window of received PCM can - * stretch, so a short block, or one that is not `enabled`, passes unchanged and a finite input - * never becomes concealment. + * Stage the first `frames` of {@link input}, accelerated by at most `excess` frames: how far the ring + * sits behind its target. Only a full window of received PCM can stretch, so a short block, or one + * that is not `enabled`, passes unchanged and a finite input never becomes concealment. */ - process(frames: number, buffered: number, target: number, lateness: number, enabled: boolean): void { - const decision = enabled && frames === this.window ? this.decide(buffered, target, lateness) : "Hold"; - const lag = decision === "Hold" ? 0 : this.#pitch(decision === "Fast"); + process(frames: number, excess: number, enabled: boolean): void { + const decision = enabled && frames === this.window ? this.decide(excess) : "Hold"; + const lag = decision === "Hold" ? 0 : this.#pitch(decision === "Fast", excess); this.#position = 0; - this.#length = frames; + this.#length = frames - lag; if (lag === 0) { for (let channel = 0; channel < this.input.length; channel++) { const input = this.input[channel]; @@ -113,14 +113,9 @@ export class Stretch { return; } - // Expand repeats one period after the seam; accelerate removes one, or fast as many as fit. + // Remove `lag` frames after the seam, crossfading the period before the middle into the one after. const middle = this.#middle; - const expand = decision === "Expand"; - const seam = expand ? middle : middle - lag; - const first = expand ? middle : middle - lag; - const second = expand ? middle - lag : middle; - const tail = expand ? middle : middle + lag; - this.#length += expand ? lag : -lag; + const seam = middle - lag; for (let channel = 0; channel < this.input.length; channel++) { const input = this.input[channel]; const output = this.#output[channel]; @@ -129,29 +124,32 @@ export class Stretch { // rather than duplicating either neighbour. for (let i = 0; i < lag; i++) { const weight = (i + 1) / (lag + 1); - output[seam + i] = input[first + i] * (1 - weight) + input[second + i] * weight; + output[seam + i] = input[seam + i] * (1 - weight) + input[middle + i] * weight; } - for (let i = tail; i < frames; i++) output[seam + lag + i - tail] = input[i]; + for (let i = middle + lag; i < frames; i++) output[i - lag] = input[i]; } this.cooldown = this.#rest; } /** - * What a full window with `buffered` frames queued decides against `target`, all in frames. The - * band above the target is NetEq's: its 20 ms granularity plus the arrivals' `lateness`. + * What a full window decides given the ring's `excess` frames above its target, measured where a + * frame has just arrived. Any excess accelerates, so the ring rests on its target rather than + * anywhere in a band above it, and one past NetEq's 20 ms granularity fast-accelerates, which + * catches up after a refill about as fast as dropping the backlog would. A ring at or below its + * target holds: that is either audio on the clock or arrivals running late, and slowing down for + * either adds latency. */ - decide(buffered: number, target: number, lateness: number): Decision { - const high = target + lateness + this.#band; - if (buffered >= high * 4) return "Fast"; - if (this.cooldown > 0) return "Hold"; - if (buffered >= high) return "Accelerate"; - if (buffered < target) return "Expand"; - return "Hold"; + decide(excess: number): Decision { + if (excess >= this.#band) return "Fast"; + if (this.cooldown > 0 || excess <= 0) return "Hold"; + return "Accelerate"; } // Search the first channel at 4 kHz, then admit the full-rate seam, returning its length or zero. - // Fast mode admits a weaker match and takes every whole period that fits before the middle. - #pitch(fast: boolean): number { + // Fast mode admits a weaker match and takes every whole period that fits before the middle. An + // ordinary accelerate removes one period, and only one that fits in the `excess`, so the ring never + // lands ahead of its target. + #pitch(fast: boolean, excess: number): number { const middle = this.#middle; if (middle === 0) return 0; @@ -202,7 +200,8 @@ export class Stretch { const passive = (energy1 + energy2) / (2 * lag) <= PASSIVE; const threshold = (fast ? 8192 : 14746) / 16384; if (!passive && cross <= threshold * Math.sqrt(energy1 * energy2)) return 0; - return fast ? Math.floor(middle / lag) * lag : lag; + if (fast) return Math.floor(middle / lag) * lag; + return lag <= excess ? lag : 0; } // The first channel at a fractional frame, linearly interpolated and clamped to the window. diff --git a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/README.md b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/README.md index 3d68b66836c..33d7b32a5b5 100644 --- a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/README.md +++ b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/README.md @@ -11,10 +11,12 @@ at once got a target far too shallow to play through the next flush. One written algorithm, cited by both implementations, produces the same target from the same arrival trace. -Boundaries: both players converge on the target by playing slightly faster -or slower, NetEq's time stretch. No packet loss concealment. Video keeps its -own target; the shared clock stays on local time, and the audio ring's stretch -converges on it. +Boundaries: both players converge on the target with NetEq's time stretch: +native playback by playing slightly faster or slower, and the browser only +faster, since its ring starts on the target and slowing down only settles audio +behind the shared clock. Underruns past the target are accepted, not covered +with latency. No packet loss concealment. Video keeps its own target; the +shared clock stays on local time, and the audio ring's stretch converges on it. ## Plan @@ -33,6 +35,15 @@ target, in both players from one algorithm and its vectors: [moq-dev/moq#7856](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/7856) natively and [moq-dev/moq#8058](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/8058) in the browser's ring. +Decided 2026-11-08 (maintainer, on +[moq-dev/moq#8058](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/8058)): never add +latency to chase zero underruns. Audio and video keep separate clocks, which +align at steady state once the delay is right, so the browser's stretch only +steers audio back onto the clock and never settles it later to absorb jitter. +Some underruns during congestion are expected. The replay rows budget +`av_lag_ms`, how far audio trails the shared clock, exactly as measured, so a +change that buys underruns with latency fails them. + Decided 2026-11-04 (maintainer), for push-to-talk's silence suppression ([moq-dev/moq#7942](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/7942)): a silence the publisher declares with an end marker is not idle, so the estimator folds no idle intervals for @@ -47,7 +58,7 @@ native playback against its budgets. ## Required - [Browser ceilings](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/browser-ceilings.md) - the chromium rows' ceilings re-measured from seven Nightlies with the browser's time stretch, budgeting `player_skips_per_min` -- [Native stretch](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md) - `moq play` copies NetEq's accelerate and preemptive expand, sharing the browser's algorithm and vectors, so its native rows reach zero steady-state underruns +- [Native stretch](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md) - `moq play` copies NetEq's accelerate and preemptive expand, sharing the browser's seams and vectors, so its native rows play with no audible glitch once the target settles - [Buffered converge](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/buffered-converge.md) - a buffered `` time-stretches its audio back onto the shared clock after a stall or drift, so lip sync returns and no audio group is dropped - [Capped budgets](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/capped-budgets.md) - the AAC browser budgets are re-measured from nightlies after the TS importer groups each PES diff --git a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/browser-ceilings.md b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/browser-ceilings.md index d066f0cb686..411b975b72b 100644 --- a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/browser-ceilings.md +++ b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/browser-ceilings.md @@ -5,7 +5,7 @@ `test/audio-quality/budgets.json` carries every chromium row's ceilings re-measured, by the rule in its note, from seven scheduled Nightly runs on `main` that all ran with the browser's NetEq time stretch, and budgets -`player_skips_per_min` on those rows beside the tap metrics. No chromium row +`player_skips_per_min` and `av_lag_ms` on those rows beside the tap metrics. No chromium row skips buffered audio in steady state: its `player_skips_per_min` stays at the startup re-anchors the estimator's hold releases, as on the replay rows. What still runs dry is what NetEq would conceal, a receive stall longer than the @@ -31,14 +31,17 @@ rows alone, with no maintainer listening run (decided 2026-11-07, /quest-unblock). [moq-dev/moq#8058](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/8058) budgeted every -replay row exactly as measured, `relay-mic-rtt40` at 1.4 -`player_underruns_per_min` (7.9 without the stretch), and left the browser -ceilings unchanged. Expect them to move both ways: stalled time and player -re-stalls should fall, while `skip_aheads` and `discarded_ms`, which infer a -skip from a step in the playhead's lag, read a sustained accelerate as a skip -and can rise on rows whose target moves. `player_skips` counts the ring's real +replay row exactly as measured, A/V lag included, and left the browser +ceilings unchanged. The browser's stretch never slows down, so underruns stay +where the trim had them (`relay-mic-rtt40` 10.6 `player_underruns_per_min` +against 8.2) while the audio the trim dropped plays faster instead, and the +A/V lag rests about one frame ahead of the clock. Expect the chromium rows +alike: re-stalls about as before, `player_skips` near zero, and +`skip_aheads` and `discarded_ms`, which infer a skip from a step in the +playhead's lag, reading a fast accelerate after a receive stall as a skip. `player_skips` counts the ring's real re-anchors, so a rise there is a regression worth reporting before budgeting -it. Rewrite the note's browser sentences to the new nights and say the stretch +it, as is an `av_lag_ms` p50 above zero, which is audio settling behind the +clock. Rewrite the note's browser sentences to the new nights and say the stretch is in them. ## Related diff --git a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md index ac3bbea5ecc..78e85a1fc9a 100644 --- a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md +++ b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md @@ -34,9 +34,13 @@ The port retains WebRTC's BSD notice and patent grant, 4 kHz analysis, 8192/16384 fast admission thresholds, passive-speech VAD, 20 ms decision band, 4x fast threshold, and 60 ms startup / 50 ms successful-stretch cooldowns. -[moq-dev/moq#8058](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/8058) widens that band -by NetEq's maximum delay in both players, from the decode consumer's new -`lateness`, and drains a declared end's tail unstretched, as finishing does. +[moq-dev/moq#8058](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/8058) drains a declared +end's tail unstretched, as finishing does. Its browser half decides on the +ring's depth right after each arrival and never expands, since expanding on +the depth between arrivals settled audio a burst behind the shared clock +(decided 2026-11-08). Native playback still decides on `buffered`, so +whether it settles behind its clock the same way is worth measuring once its +rows report A/V lag. Analysis samples NetEq's 48 kHz FIR on a virtual clock for other device rates and uses floating-point peak refinement and fades. Those arithmetic adaptations are documented, not claimed bit-identical to int16 diff --git a/rs/moq-audio/src/decode/consumer.rs b/rs/moq-audio/src/decode/consumer.rs index 661c454973a..80fee172773 100644 --- a/rs/moq-audio/src/decode/consumer.rs +++ b/rs/moq-audio/src/decode/consumer.rs @@ -301,16 +301,6 @@ impl Consumer { Duration::from_secs_f64(self.target.millis() / 1000.0) } - /// How late the slowest frame of the last two seconds of media arrived - /// against the fastest, from the same reads as [`delay`](Self::delay). Zero - /// for a fixed [`Delay::min`], which ignores the arrivals. - /// - /// NetEq's maximum delay: it widens the band a playback sink's `set_lateness` - /// holds above the target rather than the target itself. - pub fn lateness(&self) -> Duration { - Duration::from_secs_f64(self.target.lateness() / 1000.0) - } - /// Sample rate samples are actually delivered at, which is /// [`Output::sample_rate`] resolved against the catalog. pub fn sample_rate(&self) -> u32 { diff --git a/rs/moq-audio/src/jitter.rs b/rs/moq-audio/src/jitter.rs index 281db7bfc64..0aa2fda433b 100644 --- a/rs/moq-audio/src/jitter.rs +++ b/rs/moq-audio/src/jitter.rs @@ -9,7 +9,6 @@ //! Every value is `f64` milliseconds, evaluated in the order the page writes it, //! so both languages produce bit-identical targets from the same trace. -use std::collections::VecDeque; use std::time::Duration; /// Milliseconds of media time the reference search looks back over. @@ -85,15 +84,6 @@ impl Target { } } - /// How late the slowest recent arrival was against the fastest, in milliseconds. - /// A fixed target ignores the arrivals, so it reports zero. - pub(crate) fn lateness(&self) -> f64 { - match self { - Self::Fixed(_) => 0.0, - Self::Auto(estimator) => estimator.lateness(), - } - } - /// The target in milliseconds. pub(crate) fn millis(&self) -> f64 { match self { @@ -129,17 +119,14 @@ impl Entry { } /// The arrivals inside the reference window, in media order, answering any -/// prefix's fastest arrival in logarithmic time and the whole window's slowest in -/// constant time. +/// prefix's fastest arrival in logarithmic time. /// /// A reordered frame is measured against the prefix at or before its timestamp, /// so a peer that sends only reordered frames would otherwise force a scan per /// frame. Entries live in a ring indexed from `head`, and a segment tree over the /// ring's slots holds each node's fastest slot, the older on a tie, as the scan /// would pick. A query never spans the ring's wrap point within one node, so a -/// node fully inside it is in arrival order. The slowest is the front of a -/// monotonic queue of entries, each slower than every later one, named by how -/// many entries were pushed before it. +/// node fully inside it is in arrival order. #[derive(Default)] struct History { /// The ring, its length a power of two that grows up to `MAX_HISTORY`. @@ -150,10 +137,6 @@ struct History { len: usize, /// Leaf `ring.len() + slot` holds `slot`; each parent holds the faster of its children. tree: Vec, - /// Entries ever pushed, so `pushed - len` names the oldest one held. - pushed: usize, - /// The entries no later entry is as slow as, oldest first. - slow: VecDeque, } impl History { @@ -181,37 +164,6 @@ impl History { self.tree[node] = self.faster(self.tree[2 * node], self.tree[2 * node + 1]); node /= 2; } - - // Drop the queue's evicted front, then every entry this one is slower than, - // keeping the older on a tie the way the reference does. - let oldest = self.pushed + 1 - self.len; - while self.slow.front().is_some_and(|&index| index < oldest) { - self.slow.pop_front(); - } - let key = arrival - media; - while let Some(&back) = self.slow.back() { - if self.at(back - oldest).key() >= key { - break; - } - self.slow.pop_back(); - } - self.slow.push_back(self.pushed); - self.pushed += 1; - } - - /// The entry `index` places after the oldest. - fn at(&self, index: usize) -> Entry { - self.ring[(self.head + index) & (self.ring.len() - 1)] - } - - /// How late the slowest entry arrived against the fastest, zero for an empty - /// window: NetEq's `GetMaxDelayMs`, in the same arithmetic as a frame's delay. - fn lateness(&self) -> f64 { - let (Some(fast), Some(&slow)) = (self.reference(f64::INFINITY), self.slow.front()) else { - return 0.0; - }; - let slow = self.at(slow - (self.pushed - self.len)); - f64::max(0.0, slow.arrival - fast.arrival - (slow.media - fast.media)) } fn pop(&mut self) { @@ -402,13 +354,6 @@ impl Estimator { } } - /// How late the slowest frame in the reference window arrived against the - /// fastest: NetEq's maximum delay, which widens the time stretch's band rather - /// than the target. - fn lateness(&self) -> f64 { - self.history.lateness() - } - fn target(&self) -> f64 { let mut cumulative = 0.0; let mut measured = BUCKETS as f64 * BUCKET; @@ -464,22 +409,12 @@ pub(crate) mod tests { #[serde(default)] pub ends: Vec, pub target: Vec<(usize, f64)>, - pub lateness: Vec<(usize, f64)>, } impl Case { /// The expected target after each frame, expanded from the change list. pub fn series(&self) -> Vec { - self.expand(&self.target) - } - - /// The expected lateness after each frame, expanded from the change list. - pub fn lateness(&self) -> Vec { - self.expand(&self.lateness) - } - - fn expand(&self, changes: &[(usize, f64)]) -> Vec { - let mut changes = changes.iter().peekable(); + let mut changes = self.target.iter().peekable(); let mut current = f64::NAN; (0..self.arrival.len()) .map(|index| { @@ -538,7 +473,6 @@ pub(crate) mod tests { target.set_frame(case.frame); let series = case.series(); - let lateness = case.lateness(); for (index, (&arrival, &media)) in case.arrival.iter().zip(&case.media).enumerate() { if case.ends.contains(&index) { target.end(); @@ -550,12 +484,6 @@ pub(crate) mod tests { "{name}: frame {index} targets {actual}, expected {}", series[index] ); - let actual = target.lateness(); - assert!( - (actual - lateness[index]).abs() <= 1e-6, - "{name}: frame {index} is {actual} late, expected {}", - lateness[index] - ); } } } @@ -622,25 +550,6 @@ pub(crate) mod tests { reference.map(|entry| (entry.arrival, entry.media)) } - /// The documented lateness: the slowest entry against the fastest, each the - /// first on a tie. - fn slowest(history: &History) -> f64 { - let entries: Vec = (0..history.len).map(|index| history.at(index)).collect(); - let Some(&first) = entries.first() else { - return 0.0; - }; - let (mut fast, mut slow) = (first, first); - for &entry in &entries[1..] { - if entry.key() < fast.key() { - fast = entry; - } - if entry.key() > slow.key() { - slow = entry; - } - } - f64::max(0.0, slow.arrival - fast.arrival - (slow.media - fast.media)) - } - /// The tree must pick exactly the entry the documented scan would, ties included, /// since a tied entry with a different `(arrival, media)` rounds the delay differently. #[test] @@ -670,7 +579,6 @@ pub(crate) mod tests { let actual = history.reference(query).map(|entry| (entry.arrival, entry.media)); assert_eq!(actual, scan(history, query), "frame {index}, query {query}"); } - assert_eq!(history.lateness(), slowest(history), "frame {index}"); } } @@ -688,10 +596,8 @@ pub(crate) mod tests { let actual = history.reference(query).map(|entry| (entry.arrival, entry.media)); assert_eq!(actual, scan(history, query), "frame {index}, query {query}"); } - assert_eq!(history.lateness(), slowest(history), "frame {index}"); } } - assert_eq!(estimator.history.lateness(), slowest(&estimator.history)); assert_eq!(estimator.history.len, MAX_HISTORY); assert_eq!(estimator.history.ring.len(), MAX_HISTORY); assert!(estimator.target().is_finite()); diff --git a/rs/moq-audio/src/playback/sink.rs b/rs/moq-audio/src/playback/sink.rs index e42656bb748..87b8b2906bf 100644 --- a/rs/moq-audio/src/playback/sink.rs +++ b/rs/moq-audio/src/playback/sink.rs @@ -272,13 +272,6 @@ impl Sink { Ok(()) } - /// Widen the band the stretch holds above the target by how late the slowest - /// recent arrival was against the fastest, NetEq's maximum delay. The decode - /// consumer's [`lateness`](crate::decode::Consumer::lateness) is that value. - pub fn set_lateness(&mut self, lateness: Duration) { - self.channel.lock().unwrap().prod.set_lateness(lateness); - } - /// The PCM layout this sink was built with. pub fn input(&self) -> &Input { &self.input diff --git a/rs/moq-audio/src/ring.rs b/rs/moq-audio/src/ring.rs index a99d11ca248..aac9342b4f2 100644 --- a/rs/moq-audio/src/ring.rs +++ b/rs/moq-audio/src/ring.rs @@ -84,9 +84,6 @@ struct Shared { /// on opposite sides of a window transfer. consumed: AtomicUsize, target: AtomicUsize, - /// How late the slowest recent arrival was against the fastest, in output - /// frames, which widens the stretch's band above the target. - lateness: AtomicUsize, finished: AtomicBool, stretch: AtomicBool, /// Declared ends, counted. See [`Producer::end`]. @@ -320,13 +317,6 @@ impl Producer { flushed } - /// Widen the stretch's band above the target by how late the slowest recent - /// arrival was against the fastest, as NetEq does. - pub(crate) fn set_lateness(&mut self, lateness: Duration) { - let frames = (lateness.as_secs_f64() * self.rate as f64).floor() as usize; - self.shared.lateness.store(frames, Ordering::Relaxed); - } - /// Change the target without reallocating the queue. Leave one stretch window /// of headroom so the callback can still receive new PCM at the target. pub(crate) fn set_latency(&mut self, latency: Duration) -> bool { @@ -660,9 +650,7 @@ impl Consumer { let read = self.ring.pop_slice(&mut stretch.input[..frames * channels]); debug_assert_eq!(read, frames * channels); self.position = self.position.wrapping_add(frames); - let target = self.shared.target.load(Ordering::Relaxed); - let lateness = self.shared.lateness.load(Ordering::Relaxed); - stretch.process(frames, buffered, target, lateness, enabled); + stretch.process(frames, buffered, self.shared.target.load(Ordering::Relaxed), enabled); // The writer still counts the input while it is being analysed. // Publish only the resulting duration change, then the rendered // frames. Moving PCM into staging never makes it disappear. @@ -962,43 +950,6 @@ mod tests { } } - /// NetEq's band above the target widens by the arrivals' lateness, so a queue - /// inside it holds where it would otherwise accelerate down to the target. - #[test] - fn lateness_widens_the_band_above_the_target() { - for (lateness, low, high) in [(0, 80.0, 140.0), (100, 180.0, 240.0)] { - let (mut prod, mut cons) = channel( - 2, - 48_000, - 48_000, - Config { - latency: Duration::from_millis(100), - capacity: Duration::from_secs(3), - pad: false, - trim: false, - }, - ); - cons.stretch(48_000); - cons.start(); - prod.set_lateness(Duration::from_millis(lateness)); - // 200 ms on top of the 100 ms the queue primes with. - assert_eq!(prod.push(&vec![0.25; 9600 * 2]), Push::Ok); - let mut out = [0.0; 480 * 2]; - // Fed at the real-time rate, so only the stretch moves the depth. - for tick in 0..800 { - if tick % 2 == 0 { - assert_eq!(prod.push(&[0.25; 960 * 2]), Push::Ok); - } - assert_eq!(cons.read(&mut out), Read::Ok, "{lateness} ms late, tick {tick}"); - } - let buffered = prod.buffered().as_secs_f64() * 1000.0; - assert!( - (low..high).contains(&buffered), - "{lateness} ms late: {buffered} ms buffered" - ); - } - } - #[test] fn staged_audio_is_buffered_and_finish_drains_it() { let (mut prod, mut cons) = channel( diff --git a/rs/moq-audio/src/stretch.rs b/rs/moq-audio/src/stretch.rs index 22e87f3edab..e3496279b4a 100644 --- a/rs/moq-audio/src/stretch.rs +++ b/rs/moq-audio/src/stretch.rs @@ -62,11 +62,9 @@ impl Stretch { /// All input is new, received PCM. Short blocks and finished sinks cannot /// stretch, so a finite input never becomes concealment of an absent frame. - /// `lateness` widens the band above `target`, as `buffered` and `target` all - /// in frames. - pub fn process(&mut self, frames: usize, buffered: usize, target: usize, lateness: usize, enabled: bool) { + pub fn process(&mut self, frames: usize, buffered: usize, target: usize, enabled: bool) { let operation = if enabled && frames == self.window { - self.decide(buffered, target, lateness) + self.decide(buffered, target) } else { Operation::Hold }; @@ -111,10 +109,8 @@ impl Stretch { self.cooldown = self.rate as usize * 50 / 1000; } - /// NetEq's band above the target: its 20 ms granularity plus the arrivals' - /// lateness. - fn decide(&self, buffered: usize, target: usize, lateness: usize) -> Operation { - let high = target + lateness + self.rate as usize * 20 / 1000; + fn decide(&self, buffered: usize, target: usize) -> Operation { + let high = target + self.rate as usize * 20 / 1000; if buffered >= high * 4 { Operation::Fast } else if self.cooldown > 0 { @@ -211,9 +207,6 @@ mod tests { input: Vec, buffered: usize, target: usize, - /// The arrivals' lateness in frames, zero when the vector leaves it out. - #[serde(default)] - lateness: usize, cooldown: usize, decision: String, lag: usize, @@ -229,12 +222,12 @@ mod tests { stretch.input.copy_from_slice(&vector.input); stretch.cooldown = vector.cooldown; assert_eq!( - format!("{:?}", stretch.decide(vector.buffered, vector.target, vector.lateness)), + format!("{:?}", stretch.decide(vector.buffered, vector.target)), vector.decision, "{}", vector.name ); - stretch.process(stretch.window, vector.buffered, vector.target, vector.lateness, true); + stretch.process(stretch.window, vector.buffered, vector.target, true); assert_eq!(stretch.length.abs_diff(stretch.window), vector.lag, "{}", vector.name); assert_eq!(stretch.length * vector.channels, vector.output.len(), "{}", vector.name); for (index, (&actual, &expected)) in stretch.output[..vector.output.len()] @@ -257,7 +250,7 @@ mod tests { let mut stretch = Stretch::new(rate, 2); stretch.input.fill(0.25); stretch.cooldown = 0; - stretch.process(stretch.window, stretch.window, rate as usize, 0, true); + stretch.process(stretch.window, stretch.window, rate as usize, true); assert!(stretch.length > stretch.window); let mut output = vec![0.0; 2 * rate as usize]; let (_, allocations) = crate::allocation::measure(|| { @@ -265,9 +258,9 @@ mod tests { assert_eq!(stretch.read(&mut output), 0); }); assert_eq!(allocations.operations, 0); - stretch.process(stretch.window, stretch.window, rate as usize, 0, false); + stretch.process(stretch.window, stretch.window, rate as usize, false); assert_eq!(stretch.length, stretch.window, "a finished sink drains unchanged"); - stretch.process(stretch.window / 2, stretch.window, rate as usize, 0, true); + stretch.process(stretch.window / 2, stretch.window, rate as usize, true); assert_eq!(stretch.length, stretch.window / 2, "a short block drains unchanged"); } } diff --git a/rs/moq-cli/src/play/fake.rs b/rs/moq-cli/src/play/fake.rs index e1e3d89f731..e0707a582a6 100644 --- a/rs/moq-cli/src/play/fake.rs +++ b/rs/moq-cli/src/play/fake.rs @@ -158,9 +158,6 @@ impl Sink for FakeSink { Ok(()) } - // The fake plays at its target and never stretches, so there is no band to widen. - fn set_lateness(&mut self, _lateness: Duration) {} - async fn finish(mut self) { // A finite short tail drains even when it cannot refill the target. if self.prime.take().is_some() { diff --git a/rs/moq-cli/src/play/media.rs b/rs/moq-cli/src/play/media.rs index d30252ec0e0..402a8bd2eca 100644 --- a/rs/moq-cli/src/play/media.rs +++ b/rs/moq-cli/src/play/media.rs @@ -618,7 +618,6 @@ async fn play_audio( }; let ended = matches!(event, Ok(None)); let delay = consumer.delay(); - let lateness = consumer.lateness(); let crossing = match &event { Ok(Some(moq_audio::decode::Read::End { end })) => { ends.push_back((Duration::from(*end), role.declare())); @@ -657,7 +656,7 @@ async fn play_audio( received .lock() .unwrap() - .push_back((event, (delay, lateness), crossing, Instant::now())); + .push_back((event, delay, crossing, Instant::now())); arrived.notify_one(); if ended { return Ok::<_, anyhow::Error>(()); @@ -679,7 +678,7 @@ async fn play_audio( // The frame being written starts the utterance after a declared silence. let mut utterance = false; loop { - let (event, (delay, lateness), crossing, _) = loop { + let (event, delay, crossing, _) = loop { if let Some(event) = received.lock().unwrap().pop_front() { popped.notify_one(); break event; @@ -810,18 +809,10 @@ async fn play_audio( let held = input.latency; let target = samples(held); sink.set_latency(held)?; - sink.set_lateness(lateness); // Leave normal convergence to the callback. Only an excess at NetEq's - // fast threshold (four times target + lateness + granularity) is an - // emergency re-anchor; a 20 ms trim would compete with every pitch - // correction. - let fit = fit( - buffered, - target, - slack + samples(lateness), - timing.silence, - length as u64, - ); + // fast threshold (four times target + granularity) is an emergency + // re-anchor; a 20 ms trim would compete with every pitch correction. + let fit = fit(buffered, target, slack, timing.silence, length as u64); // The packet pays for the channel count; the catalog cannot allocate // a duration's worth of silence before any samples arrive. diff --git a/rs/moq-cli/src/play/output.rs b/rs/moq-cli/src/play/output.rs index 9b6e3e22db4..ec5435508fa 100644 --- a/rs/moq-cli/src/play/output.rs +++ b/rs/moq-cli/src/play/output.rs @@ -39,9 +39,6 @@ pub(super) trait Sink: Send + Sync + 'static { /// Update the callback's playout target without replacing the sink. fn set_latency(&mut self, latency: Duration) -> anyhow::Result<()>; - /// Widen the band the callback holds above the target by the arrivals' lateness. - fn set_lateness(&mut self, lateness: Duration); - /// How much audio is queued ahead of the speaker. fn buffered(&self) -> Duration; @@ -68,10 +65,6 @@ impl Sink for moq_audio::playback::Sink { Ok(moq_audio::playback::Sink::set_latency(self, latency)?) } - fn set_lateness(&mut self, lateness: Duration) { - moq_audio::playback::Sink::set_lateness(self, lateness) - } - fn write(&mut self, samples: &[u8]) -> anyhow::Result { Ok(moq_audio::playback::Sink::write(self, samples)?) } diff --git a/test/audio-quality/README.md b/test/audio-quality/README.md index af77be0dabe..9f9e822b894 100644 --- a/test/audio-quality/README.md +++ b/test/audio-quality/README.md @@ -224,9 +224,9 @@ and clock checks have nothing to void. Decoding is taken as instant. A replay is its budgets are exactly what it measured. The ring time-stretches live playback as the page's does, but the replay's audio is a constant, so -every seam admits at the shortest pitch period, 2.5 ms. Accelerate and expand therefore move less -per stretch than they would from speech; only fast accelerate, which takes every whole period that -fits, moves its most. `skip_aheads` also reads a sustained accelerate as a skip; `player_skips` counts only the ring's +every seam admits at the shortest pitch period, 2.5 ms. Accelerate therefore moves less per stretch +than it would from speech; only fast accelerate, which takes every whole period that fits, moves its +most. `skip_aheads` also reads a sustained accelerate as a skip; `player_skips` counts only the ring's own re-anchors. ```bash @@ -304,6 +304,10 @@ player's own count, which its stats panel shows, is read alongside: that starts within 60 ms of a stall is that stall, and is not an underrun. - `silence`: the share of rendered quanta under -60 dBFS at the output, whatever the cause. - `target_ms`: the resolved playout delay (`sync.out.delay`). +- `av_lag_ms`: how far the audio playhead trails the shared clock video plays from (`sync.now()`), + sampled while playing. Audio and video keep separate clocks that align once the delay covers the + arrivals, so this is the latency audio adds beyond the target: positive is audio late, negative + early. Its replay ceilings hold audio from settling later to buy fewer underruns. Unset natively. - `converge_ms`: from first audio to the last time the target moved more than one 20 ms bucket from its final value. - `render_load`: Chromium's render capacity, the share of each quantum's budget the graph used. diff --git a/test/audio-quality/budgets.json b/test/audio-quality/budgets.json index 62b7eac42dc..916e5d9bfcc 100644 --- a/test/audio-quality/budgets.json +++ b/test/audio-quality/budgets.json @@ -1,5 +1,5 @@ { - "note": "The browser rows are measured on the nightly runner (ubuntu-24.04-arm, headless Chromium, seed 7, 60 s a row), from the audio-quality-run artifacts of the seven scheduled Nightly runs on main from 2026-10-29 to 2026-11-04 (40885347517, 41065371094, 41204380716, 41313466339, 41483654426, 41656613559, 41852517544), the first after a fresh subscriber stopped receiving the relay's cached history. The AAC rows predate the TS importer publishing each PES as one group. Each ceiling is the worst of its seven nights times 1.25, plus one runner hiccup, rounded up to two significant figures. The hiccup is sized from the single gaps the 2026-10-08 night put on otherwise clean rows, the fixed-250 control among them: 250 underruns/min, 700 gap ms/min, 3.3 skips/min, 280 discarded ms/min, 0.01 stalled, 0.015 silence, and one 20 ms bucket of target. Budgeted this way, every night passes when it is held out of its row's measurement except one, and that row's own ceiling includes it: the 2026-11-03 Opus bursty row raised its target to 300 ms 2.6 s in and held it for one 20 s half-life before settling at 180. Such startup holds, Opus near-zero's 100 ms on 2026-10-30 and 10-31 among them, are budgeted as measured. These ceilings record today's player as the runner hears it, not target audio quality. To re-measure, download the same artifact from the latest scheduled nightlies (`gh run download -n audio-quality-run`), which keep every run, and apply the same rule. The replay rows are deterministic, so their ceilings are exactly what they measured, through the end of each recording, with no headroom: any regression fails them, and an improvement should be tightened in. They were last re-measured on 2026-10-22 using version 3 traces with encoded frame durations: AAC-LC uses its fixed 1024 samples, and relay-mic retains Opus packet TOC durations. relay-mic was re-recorded on 2026-11-03 from a real microphone, Chrome 156 on a MacBook Air publishing its built-in microphone through the public relay, recorded by headless Chromium on a Linux host (35 s, minimum RTT 2 ms), which raised its target ceiling from 60 to 80 ms and its silence from 0 to 0.001 as measured. The recording path itself has no added RTT. relay-mic-rtt40 is the 2026-11-03 Chrome row at 40 ms of added RTT on that laptop (180 s, minimum RTT 47 ms), kept as the baseline time stretch improves on; like every replay row, its player_underruns_per_min ceiling is what it measures, not a fixed zero. player_underruns_per_min, the player's own counter that its stats panel shows, is budgeted on the replay rows only; it counts the run-dry re-stalls the tap files as stalled time. On 2026-11-07, after the ordered read stopped delivering groups below its cursor (#8071) and took Rust's hole and age bounds (#8218), relay-bbb was re-measured at 16.1 player underruns/min, 0.025 stalled and 0.02 silence, and relay-mic-rtt40 at 8.2, its discarded audio at 70.9 ms/min and its target p95 at 320 ms rather than 780, since the stale backlog it never played no longer reaches the estimator; neither row lost audio the previous player heard. On 2026-11-08 the player began time-stretching live playback with NetEq's accelerate and preemptive expand, their band above the target widened by NetEq's maximum delay, and every replay row was re-measured with it, the browser rows left to the nightly runner: player_underruns_per_min fell from 4.4, 12.1, 16.1, 6.1 and 8.2 to 2.2 on bursty-aac, 0 on local-aac, relay-bbb and relay-mic, and 1 on relay-mic-rtt40, and stalled and silence fell or held. relay-mic-rtt40's are two run-dries, of 8 ms at 111.6 s and 5 ms at 162.5 s, three underruns between them, each behind a receive stall of 100 to 125 ms against an 80 to 120 ms target, which NetEq would conceal rather than stretch through; bursty-aac's is one run-dry 6 s in, which the band does not change. player_skips_per_min, the ring's own count of re-anchors that dropped buffered audio, is budgeted beside it, at 0 on every row. The tap metrics that rose are none of them audio the player dropped. skip_aheads infers skips from steps in the playhead's lag, which a sustained accelerate makes too: relay-mic-rtt40's rose from 0.3 to 1.4 a minute as the ring accelerated back onto its target after the band held it. bursty-aac no longer re-stalls waiting on its missing groups (stalled 0.009 to 0, silence 0.010 to 0.003), so each hole plays as the gap it is, and the tap counts it as underruns: 6.6 a minute, 0.3 ms of missing audio a minute. Neither replay calibration changed the browser or native ceilings. bursty-aac is the 2026-10-18 AAC bursty isolated capture, recorded with the observer subscribed at the decoder's 2 s budget, so it holds every group the player saw. The native rows are provisional: measured on a loaded developer host (x86_64 Linux, the private PulseAudio null sink, seed 7, 60 s a row) on 2026-10-17, three runs of every row from the debug build nightly uses plus three more of the AAC rows from a release build, which played alike. Each ceiling is the worst clean run times 1.25, plus one native hiccup sized from the unimpaired Opus row's worst run (20 underruns/min, 50 gap ms/min, 2.2 skips/min, 110 discarded ms/min, 0.01 stalled, 0.005 silence, one 20 ms bucket of target), rounded up to two significant figures. On that host the null sink's clock ran about 150 ppm slow against the monotonic clock, read within 5 ms at p95 per sample, and its output latency sat between 14 and 28 ms. Five of the 36 AAC rows (none of the 18 Opus rows) voided on the clock: the device stopped pulling for about two seconds mid-row, sometimes after a backend error and a stream restart, which is a native playback defect rather than noise, and the ceilings exclude those runs. Re-measure from the nightly runner's artifacts once it has a week of native rows.", + "note": "The browser rows are measured on the nightly runner (ubuntu-24.04-arm, headless Chromium, seed 7, 60 s a row), from the audio-quality-run artifacts of the seven scheduled Nightly runs on main from 2026-10-29 to 2026-11-04 (40885347517, 41065371094, 41204380716, 41313466339, 41483654426, 41656613559, 41852517544), the first after a fresh subscriber stopped receiving the relay's cached history. The AAC rows predate the TS importer publishing each PES as one group. Each ceiling is the worst of its seven nights times 1.25, plus one runner hiccup, rounded up to two significant figures. The hiccup is sized from the single gaps the 2026-10-08 night put on otherwise clean rows, the fixed-250 control among them: 250 underruns/min, 700 gap ms/min, 3.3 skips/min, 280 discarded ms/min, 0.01 stalled, 0.015 silence, and one 20 ms bucket of target. Budgeted this way, every night passes when it is held out of its row's measurement except one, and that row's own ceiling includes it: the 2026-11-03 Opus bursty row raised its target to 300 ms 2.6 s in and held it for one 20 s half-life before settling at 180. Such startup holds, Opus near-zero's 100 ms on 2026-10-30 and 10-31 among them, are budgeted as measured. These ceilings record today's player as the runner hears it, not target audio quality. To re-measure, download the same artifact from the latest scheduled nightlies (`gh run download -n audio-quality-run`), which keep every run, and apply the same rule. The replay rows are deterministic, so their ceilings are exactly what they measured, through the end of each recording, with no headroom: any regression fails them, and an improvement should be tightened in. They were last re-measured on 2026-10-22 using version 3 traces with encoded frame durations: AAC-LC uses its fixed 1024 samples, and relay-mic retains Opus packet TOC durations. relay-mic was re-recorded on 2026-11-03 from a real microphone, Chrome 156 on a MacBook Air publishing its built-in microphone through the public relay, recorded by headless Chromium on a Linux host (35 s, minimum RTT 2 ms), which raised its target ceiling from 60 to 80 ms and its silence from 0 to 0.001 as measured. The recording path itself has no added RTT. relay-mic-rtt40 is the 2026-11-03 Chrome row at 40 ms of added RTT on that laptop (180 s, minimum RTT 47 ms), kept as the baseline time stretch improves on; like every replay row, its player_underruns_per_min ceiling is what it measures, not a fixed zero. player_underruns_per_min, the player's own counter that its stats panel shows, is budgeted on the replay rows only; it counts the run-dry re-stalls the tap files as stalled time. On 2026-11-07, after the ordered read stopped delivering groups below its cursor (#8071) and took Rust's hole and age bounds (#8218), relay-bbb was re-measured at 16.1 player underruns/min, 0.025 stalled and 0.02 silence, and relay-mic-rtt40 at 8.2, its discarded audio at 70.9 ms/min and its target p95 at 320 ms rather than 780, since the stale backlog it never played no longer reaches the estimator; neither row lost audio the previous player heard. On 2026-11-08 the player began time-stretching live playback with NetEq's accelerate, deciding on the ring's depth right after each arrival and never expanding, and every replay row was re-measured with it, the browser rows left to the nightly runner. Each row's av_lag_ms ceilings, how far the playhead trails the shared clock video plays from, are what it measured: the ring rests one frame ahead of the newest arrival's playout, as the trim it replaces left it, so audio leads the clock by 19 to 23 ms at p50, and any change that settles audio later to buy fewer underruns fails them. Against the trim, the A/V lag p50 fell from 0.7, -17.5, -21.5, -18.2 and -15.6 ms to -22.4 on bursty-aac, -22.2 on local-aac, -22.7 on relay-bbb, -19 on relay-mic and -20.1 on relay-mic-rtt40, and its p95 fell on every row, most on relay-bbb (10.5 to -4.2) and relay-mic-rtt40 (-0.9 to -13.4). Underruns stayed where the trim had them, as the latency they would cost is not spent: player_underruns_per_min held at 4.4, 12.1, 16.1 and 6.1 and rose from 8.2 to 10.6 on relay-mic-rtt40, and relay-mic's tap now files 2 short quanta a minute, 2 ms of missing audio, where it filed none. What the stretch buys is the audio the trim dropped: discarded_ms_per_min fell from 87.8 to 0 on relay-bbb and from 127.5 to 100.6 on local-aac, whose remainder drops nothing: two receive stalls 14 and 15.3 s in leave audio 159 and 132 ms behind the clock, and the fast accelerate that brings it back within half a second steps the playhead's lag the way skip_aheads reads as a skip. player_skips_per_min, the ring's own count of re-anchors that dropped buffered audio, is budgeted beside it, at 0 on every row. Neither replay calibration changed the browser or native ceilings. bursty-aac is the 2026-10-18 AAC bursty isolated capture, recorded with the observer subscribed at the decoder's 2 s budget, so it holds every group the player saw. The native rows are provisional: measured on a loaded developer host (x86_64 Linux, the private PulseAudio null sink, seed 7, 60 s a row) on 2026-10-17, three runs of every row from the debug build nightly uses plus three more of the AAC rows from a release build, which played alike. Each ceiling is the worst clean run times 1.25, plus one native hiccup sized from the unimpaired Opus row's worst run (20 underruns/min, 50 gap ms/min, 2.2 skips/min, 110 discarded ms/min, 0.01 stalled, 0.005 silence, one 20 ms bucket of target), rounded up to two significant figures. On that host the null sink's clock ran about 150 ppm slow against the monotonic clock, read within 5 ms at p95 per sample, and its output latency sat between 14 and 28 ms. Five of the 36 AAC rows (none of the 18 Opus rows) voided on the clock: the device stopped pulling for about two seconds mid-row, sometimes after a backend error and a stream restart, which is a native playback defect rather than noise, and the ceilings exclude those runs. Re-measure from the nightly runner's artifacts once it has a week of native rows.", "rows": [ { "runtime": "chromium", @@ -318,75 +318,85 @@ "codec": "aac", "rate": 44100, "profile": "bursty-aac", - "player_underruns_per_min": 2.2, + "player_underruns_per_min": 4.4, "player_skips_per_min": 0, - "underruns_per_min": 6.6, - "underrun_ms_per_min": 0.3, + "underruns_per_min": 0, + "underrun_ms_per_min": 0, "skip_aheads_per_min": 0, "discarded_ms_per_min": 0, - "stalled_share": 0, - "silence_share": 0.003, - "target_ms_p95": 343.2 + "stalled_share": 0.009, + "silence_share": 0.012, + "target_ms_p95": 343.2, + "av_lag_ms_p50": -22.4, + "av_lag_ms_p95": -22.4 }, { "runtime": "replay", "codec": "aac", "rate": 44100, "profile": "local-aac", - "player_underruns_per_min": 0, + "player_underruns_per_min": 12.1, "player_skips_per_min": 0, "underruns_per_min": 0, "underrun_ms_per_min": 0, "skip_aheads_per_min": 2, - "discarded_ms_per_min": 85.3, - "stalled_share": 0, - "silence_share": 0.001, - "target_ms_p95": 203.2 + "discarded_ms_per_min": 100.6, + "stalled_share": 0.017, + "silence_share": 0.021, + "target_ms_p95": 203.2, + "av_lag_ms_p50": -22.2, + "av_lag_ms_p95": -4.2 }, { "runtime": "replay", "codec": "aac", "rate": 44100, "profile": "relay-bbb", - "player_underruns_per_min": 0, + "player_underruns_per_min": 16.1, "player_skips_per_min": 0, "underruns_per_min": 0, "underrun_ms_per_min": 0, "skip_aheads_per_min": 0, "discarded_ms_per_min": 0, - "stalled_share": 0, - "silence_share": 0, - "target_ms_p95": 223.2 + "stalled_share": 0.025, + "silence_share": 0.02, + "target_ms_p95": 223.2, + "av_lag_ms_p50": -22.7, + "av_lag_ms_p95": -4.2 }, { "runtime": "replay", "codec": "opus", "rate": 48000, "profile": "relay-mic", - "player_underruns_per_min": 0, + "player_underruns_per_min": 6.1, "player_skips_per_min": 0, - "underruns_per_min": 0, - "underrun_ms_per_min": 0, + "underruns_per_min": 2, + "underrun_ms_per_min": 2, "skip_aheads_per_min": 0, "discarded_ms_per_min": 0, "stalled_share": 0, - "silence_share": 0, - "target_ms_p95": 80 + "silence_share": 0.002, + "target_ms_p95": 80, + "av_lag_ms_p50": -19, + "av_lag_ms_p95": -18.5 }, { "runtime": "replay", "codec": "opus", "rate": 48000, "profile": "relay-mic-rtt40", - "player_underruns_per_min": 1, + "player_underruns_per_min": 10.6, "player_skips_per_min": 0, - "underruns_per_min": 0, - "underrun_ms_per_min": 0, - "skip_aheads_per_min": 1.4, - "discarded_ms_per_min": 67.7, - "stalled_share": 0, - "silence_share": 0, - "target_ms_p95": 320 + "underruns_per_min": 0.7, + "underrun_ms_per_min": 0.5, + "skip_aheads_per_min": 0.3, + "discarded_ms_per_min": 72, + "stalled_share": 0.003, + "silence_share": 0.004, + "target_ms_p95": 320, + "av_lag_ms_p50": -20.1, + "av_lag_ms_p95": -13.4 } ] } diff --git a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/grade.ts b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/grade.ts index 35a19defa98..160603849d0 100644 --- a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/grade.ts +++ b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/grade.ts @@ -74,6 +74,8 @@ const COLUMNS: [string, string][] = [ ["discarded ms/min", "discarded_ms_per_min"], ["stalled", "stalled_share"], ["silence", "silence_share"], + ["A/V lag p50", "av_lag_ms_p50"], + ["A/V lag p95", "av_lag_ms_p95"], ["target p95", "target_ms_p95"], ["converge ms", "converge_ms_last"], ]; diff --git a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/replay.ts b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/replay.ts index 69e9a208b96..16cf26cd019 100644 --- a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/replay.ts +++ b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/replay.ts @@ -88,6 +88,7 @@ const { replay } = await import("../../../../js/watch/src/audio/replay.ts"); interface Reading { at: number; timestamp: number; + clock?: number; stalled: boolean; delay: number; underruns: number; @@ -119,6 +120,7 @@ for (const { row, trace } of rows) { at: quantum.at, render: quantum.at, timestamp: quantum.timestamp, + clock: quantum.clock, stalled: quantum.stalled, delay: quantum.delay, playerUnderruns: quantum.underruns, @@ -149,6 +151,7 @@ for (const { row, trace } of rows) { last = { at: quantum.at, timestamp: quantum.timestamp, + clock: quantum.clock, stalled: quantum.stalled, delay: quantum.delay, underruns: quantum.underruns, diff --git a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/analyze.test.ts b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/analyze.test.ts index c2ffd3a81d8..cd5279b5be6 100644 --- a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/analyze.test.ts +++ b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/analyze.test.ts @@ -110,6 +110,18 @@ describe("analyze", () => { expect(analyze(input(clean())).metrics.player_skips_total).toBeNull(); }); + test("the A/V lag is how far the playhead trails the shared clock while playing", () => { + const samples = clean().map((s, i) => ({ + ...s, + clock: s.timestamp - 20 + (i % 4 === 3 ? 10 : 0), + stalled: i === 50 ? true : s.stalled, + })); + // A stalled sample's playhead is frozen, so it is left out. + samples[50] = { ...samples[50], clock: samples[50].timestamp + 500 }; + expect(analyze(input(samples)).metrics).toMatchObject({ av_lag_ms_p50: -20, av_lag_ms_p95: -10 }); + expect(analyze(input(clean())).metrics.av_lag_ms_p50).toBeNull(); + }); + test("a gap that is the ring stalling is not an underrun", () => { const samples = clean(); samples[100] = { diff --git a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/analyze.ts b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/analyze.ts index 41d68c03ec6..6d97a51aa71 100644 --- a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/analyze.ts +++ b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/analyze.ts @@ -229,6 +229,8 @@ export function analyze(input: Input): Summary { s.timestamp === undefined || s.stalled ? undefined : s.at - s.timestamp - (mediaRate ?? 0) * (s.at - base), ); const skips = skipAheads(lags); + // Both on the media clock, read at one instant, so no reduction to the viewer's is needed. + const behind = playing.flatMap((s) => (s.clock === undefined ? [] : [s.clock - (s.timestamp as Ms)])); const stalledShare = window.length > 0 ? window.filter((s) => s.stalled).length / window.length : null; // ── the target ────────────────────────────────────────────────────────── @@ -269,6 +271,8 @@ export function analyze(input: Input): Summary { discarded_ms_per_min: perMin(skips.ms), stalled_share: round(stalledShare, 3), silence_share: round(silence, 3), + av_lag_ms_p50: round(percentile(behind, 50)), + av_lag_ms_p95: round(percentile(behind, 95)), target_ms_p50: round(percentile(targets, 50)), target_ms_p95: round(percentile(targets, 95)), target_ms_max: round(percentile(targets, 100)), diff --git a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/probe.ts b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/probe.ts index d72a67ae9db..412fde6ecc7 100644 --- a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/probe.ts +++ b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/probe.ts @@ -126,6 +126,7 @@ export function probe(watch: MoqWatch, capture = false): Probe { render: context ? context.currentTime * 1000 : undefined, timestamp: audio.out.timestamp.peek(), stalled: audio.out.stalled.peek(), + clock: sync.now(), delay: sync.out.delay.peek(), playerUnderruns: audio.out.stats.peek()?.underruns, playerSkips: audio.out.stats.peek()?.skips, diff --git a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/schema.ts b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/schema.ts index 00572851ca3..83fa67dd1e7 100644 --- a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/schema.ts +++ b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/schema.ts @@ -139,6 +139,13 @@ export const METRICS = { description: "Share of rendered quanta under the silence floor at the player's output, whatever the cause. The published tone is never quiet, so any of it is a gap or a stall.", }, + av_lag_ms: { + unit: "ms", + clock: "media", + aggregations: ["p50", "p95"], + description: + "How far the audio playhead trails the shared clock video plays from (`sync.now()`), sampled while playing: latency audio adds beyond the resolved target. Negative is audio ahead. Unset natively.", + }, target_ms: { unit: "ms", clock: "viewer", @@ -390,6 +397,8 @@ export type Sample = { * is only a sink with nothing written yet, or none at all. */ stalled?: boolean; + /** `sync.now()`: where the shared clock puts video, on the `media` clock. Unset natively. */ + clock?: Ms; /** `sync.out.delay`: the resolved playout target. Natively, the target the speaker is held on. */ delay?: Ms; /** From 683d964924fa9c5a1760d6c4c00e06f75f4ade02 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Luke Curley Date: Sun, 8 Nov 2026 09:58:18 -0800 Subject: [PATCH 12/13] test(audio-quality): the probe's fake sync reads a clock, and the lag test types its playhead Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/analyze.test.ts | 14 +++++++------- test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/probe.test.ts | 2 +- 2 files changed, 8 insertions(+), 8 deletions(-) diff --git a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/analyze.test.ts b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/analyze.test.ts index cd5279b5be6..05b3683eb87 100644 --- a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/analyze.test.ts +++ b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/analyze.test.ts @@ -111,13 +111,13 @@ describe("analyze", () => { }); test("the A/V lag is how far the playhead trails the shared clock while playing", () => { - const samples = clean().map((s, i) => ({ - ...s, - clock: s.timestamp - 20 + (i % 4 === 3 ? 10 : 0), - stalled: i === 50 ? true : s.stalled, - })); - // A stalled sample's playhead is frozen, so it is left out. - samples[50] = { ...samples[50], clock: samples[50].timestamp + 500 }; + // Three in four samples 20 ms ahead of the clock, the rest 10 ms; a stalled sample's playhead is + // frozen, so it is left out however far the clock has run. + const samples = clean().map((s, i) => { + const timestamp = s.timestamp ?? 0; + if (i === 50) return { ...s, stalled: true, clock: timestamp + 500 }; + return { ...s, clock: timestamp - 20 + (i % 4 === 3 ? 10 : 0) }; + }); expect(analyze(input(samples)).metrics).toMatchObject({ av_lag_ms_p50: -20, av_lag_ms_p95: -10 }); expect(analyze(input(clean())).metrics.av_lag_ms_p50).toBeNull(); }); diff --git a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/probe.test.ts b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/probe.test.ts index 0cac89a67ef..0b642f88e63 100644 --- a/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/probe.test.ts +++ b/test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/probe.test.ts @@ -23,7 +23,7 @@ test("audio-only sampling holds probe demand until its final RTT sample", async out: { stalled: new Signal(false), context: empty, root: empty, timestamp: empty, stats: empty }, source: { out: { config: empty } }, }, - sync: { out: { delay: empty, jitter: empty } }, + sync: { out: { delay: empty, jitter: empty }, now: () => undefined }, broadcast: { out: { catalog: empty } }, }, } as unknown as MoqWatch; From 77fce72f6b27357d69937c5eefa68773880dec01 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Luke Curley Date: Sun, 8 Nov 2026 17:16:58 -0800 Subject: [PATCH 13/13] quest: plan native A/V lag reporting and its expand decision Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/README.md | 1 + quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-av-lag.md | 56 +++++++++++++++++++ 2 files changed, 57 insertions(+) create mode 100644 quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-av-lag.md diff --git a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/README.md b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/README.md index 44ff0356761..df803e1127d 100644 --- a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/README.md +++ b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/README.md @@ -61,6 +61,7 @@ native playback against its budgets. - [Native stretch](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md) - `moq play` copies NetEq's accelerate and preemptive expand, sharing the browser's seams and vectors, so its native rows play with no audible glitch once the target settles - [Buffered converge](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/buffered-converge.md) - a buffered `` time-stretches its audio back onto the shared clock after a stall or drift, so lip sync returns and no audio group is dropped - [Capped budgets](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/capped-budgets.md) - the AAC browser budgets are re-measured from nightlies after the TS importer groups each PES +- [Native A/V lag](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-av-lag.md) - `moq play` reports how far audio trails its presentation clock, and native stops expanding into the gap between arrivals if it settles audio late - [Native rendition delay](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-rendition-delay.md) - `moq play` holds each subscribed rendition's catalog `delay` plus its target, as the browser does ## Closes diff --git a/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-av-lag.md b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-av-lag.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000000..e7b0af6ea4d --- /dev/null +++ b/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-av-lag.md @@ -0,0 +1,56 @@ +# [M] Native audio never settles behind its presentation clock + +## Goal + +`moq play --metrics` reports how far the native audio playhead trails the +presentation clock video plays from, so every native row in +`test/audio-quality` grades `av_lag_ms` (p50, p95) as the replay rows do. If +native's time stretch settles audio behind that clock, as the browser's did +before [moq-dev/moq#8058](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/8058), native +stops spending latency on it: at steady state its p50 lag is at or below zero +on every native row, and its ceilings guard that. + +Boundaries: the jitter estimator and its target stay as +`doc/concept/audio-jitter.md` specifies them. Underruns during congestion are +accepted, never bought down with latency. Native keeps compensating clock +drift between publisher and device, which the browser's ring cannot. + +## Plan + +Decided 2026-11-08 (maintainer, on +[moq-dev/moq#8058](https://github.com/moq-dev/moq/pull/8058)): never add +latency to chase zero underruns; audio and video keep separate clocks that +align at steady state once the delay is right. The browser's ring now decides +on its depth right after each arrival and never expands, because expanding on +the depth between arrivals settled audio a burst behind the shared clock +(`bursty-aac` lag p50 1 to 289 ms). Native's `Stretch::decide` +(`rs/moq-audio/src/stretch.rs`) still decides on `buffered` at each callback, +so it may do the same. + +1. Report the lag. The metrics writer (`rs/moq-cli/src/play/metrics.rs`) + already holds the presentation `moq_mux::sync::Consumer` and the + `Playhead`. Write each sample's `clock`, the presentation clock's media + time at the instant the playhead is read, with the field and meaning + `test/audio-quality/clients/js/src/schema.ts` gives the browser's, so + `analyze.ts` reduces native samples to `av_lag_ms` unchanged. Leave it out + while nothing is mapped, as other unreadable fields are. +2. Measure. Run the native rows locally against `main`'s decision, then read + the scheduled Nightlies. Lag p50 near or below zero means native already + aligns: budget `av_lag_ms` by the native rule and finish. +3. If p50 sits above zero on any row, decide on the depth right after each + arrival, less what the stretch removed since, as the browser's + `AudioRingBuffer` does, and expand only to follow a publisher clock + slower than the device's, not to fill the gap between arrivals. Hold the + listened drift case (media per render second about 0.998 against a 0.998 + publisher) and the shared stretch corpus, and update the spec's native + decision in the same PR. + +[Native stretch](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md) is +calibrating the native ceilings from seven Nightlies of today's decision. +Step 3 moves those ceilings, so a decision change re-measures them by the +same rule rather than stacking on the old calibration. + +## Related + +- [Native stretch](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/native-stretch.md) - the native ceilings this lag joins, calibrated from the current decision +- [Browser ceilings](/quest/m1/audio-jitter-target/browser-ceilings.md) - budgets `av_lag_ms` on the chromium rows the same way