Skip to content

Error in rewriting of nested biconditionals during parsing #46

Description

@thahmann

something is off, it seems like the outer universal quantifier is lost and then during PCNF creation, an existential is introduced (note that the original file contained a biconditional, though this is now changed to a conditional only):

C:\Users\torsten\GitHub\colore\ontologies\multidim_mereotopology_codi\definitions\areal_region.clif
Axiom: \forall x;[((~ArealRegion(x) | \forall y;[((~Curve(y) | Covers(x,y)) & (Covers(x,y) | Curve(y)))]) & (\forall y;[((~Curve(y) | Covers(x,y)) & (~Covers(x,y) | Curve(y)))] | ArealRegion(x)))] from C:\Users\torsten\GitHub\colore\ontologies\multidim_mereotopology_codi\definitions\areal_region.clif
((((~Covers(z,y) | Curve(y)) & (~Curve(y) | Covers(z,y))) | ~ArealRegion(z)) & ((Covers(z,x) & ~Curve(x)) | (Curve(x) & ~Covers(z,x)) | ArealRegion(z)))
FF-PCNF: \forall z,y;[\exists x;[((~ArealRegion(z) | ~Covers(z,y) | Curve(y)) & (~ArealRegion(z) | ~Curve(y) | Covers(z,y)) & (Covers(z,x) | ArealRegion(z) | Curve(x)) & (ArealRegion(z)) & (~Curve(x) | ArealRegion(z) | ~Covers(z,x)))]]

  • yielded: \forall y,z;[(~ArealRegion(z) | ~Covers(z,y) | Curve(y))]
    • pattern all_values
  • yielded: \forall y,z;[(~ArealRegion(z) | ~Curve(y) | Covers(z,y))]
  • yielded: \forall z;[\exists x;[(Covers(z,x) | ArealRegion(z) | Curve(x))]]
  • yielded: \forall z;[(ArealRegion(z))]
    • pattern universe
  • yielded: \forall z;[\exists x;[(~Curve(x) | ArealRegion(z) | ~Covers(z,x))]]

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Projects

No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions