Skip to content

Review Go AppHost compatibility and validation gaps #2533

Open

Description

@aaronpowell

Context

The Go AppHost parity work in #2438 documented potential incompatibilities and validation gaps. Review each item against the latest available Aspire 17.0 preview used by the Toolkit, recording the SDK/CLI version, reproduction, and whether it is still an issue. Preserve the TypeScript examples' resource graphs and explicit parameters; do not omit them just to make a Go example pass.

The original findings used Aspire 17.1.0-preview.1.26559.8. ActiveMQ, Flare, Keycloak, and Zitadel were also reproduced with 17.0.0-preview.1.26555.11; the remaining parameter-handle cases were not revalidated on that version. See the parity findings for reproduction details.

Optional resource-handle serialization

Generated Go options use pointers to parameter-resource interfaces. Passing explicit handles compiled, but model construction failed with INVALID_ARGUMENT / IResourceBuilder deserialization errors. Determine whether the underlying SDK issue still exists, whether it needs an upstream issue or fix, and what is needed to restore parity for each example.

  • ActiveMQ — review UserName; Go example exists but was compile-only.
  • Flare — review DashboardUrl; Go example exists but was compile-only.
  • Keycloak extensions — review PostgreSQL userName and password; Go example exists but was compile-only.
  • Zitadel — review Username, Password, and MasterKey; Go example exists but was compile-only.
  • RustFs — review AccessKey and SecretKey; Go example was absent.
  • Umami — review Secret; Go example was absent.
  • Meilisearch — review MasterKey; Go example was absent.
  • Redis extensions — review Password; Go example was absent.
  • SQL Server extensions — review Password; Go example was absent.
  • MCP Inspector — review ProxyToken; Go example was absent.

Other findings

  • Python extensions — review the publish-mode duplicate dashboard resource when AddStreamlitApp replaces a Python resource; run mode worked in the original investigation.
  • Floci — verify the Service Bus resource graph in run mode; WithServiceBus is run-only by design, so its publish-mode rejection is not by itself a Go incompatibility.
  • SQL Database Projects — review the reported Windows native hostfxr loading failure and verify current Windows and Linux model construction. Separately, Fix SQL polyglot AppHost test restore environment #2529 addressed inherited MSBuild paths in SQL polyglot tests; determine whether the original native-loading finding still applies rather than assuming these are the same failure.

For each finding, document the outcome and link any follow-up issues or fixes. Where applicable, restore or add the Go counterpart and model-validation coverage after the issue is resolved.

Activity

  1. added this to the 17.0 milestone on Nov 16, 2026
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions