Skip to content

meter-closeup: consolidate nonblocking field-test and ranking review follow-ups #178

Open

Description

@SamGu-NRX

Nonblocking threads from Codex and Greptile on PR #16 at c8c666a, assessed under the 08:30Z standard. Each needs follow-up but has no verified false reported result, meaningful data loss, privacy leak, path escape, or realistic memory growth.

  • 4114894510: remove the unnecessary dataset HMAC-key requirement from standalone field tests. Missing key currently causes an explicit failure before processing.
  • 4114894516: add top-three tap success to field-test summary. Current counters accurately report exact OCR read status, not candidate-list success; rank is separately printed. Keep those metrics distinct.
  • 4115044766: evaluate barcode-only candidates. Current code requires a digit-bearing OCR line, reducing recall; the ranking evaluation counts the miss rather than falsely declaring identification successful.
  • 4115044770: evaluate stricter barcode promotion. Substring promotion can rank an unrelated identifier first, but the experiment evaluates it against labels and PORTING.md requires homeowner confirmation. No automatic correct-identity or clearance decision was established.
  • 4115044778: fix FIELD_TEST.md working-directory instructions so the experiment environment is selected. Current failure is visible module discovery, not a false result.
  • 4115044779: create ocr/ before a fresh standalone q45 run. The documented full sequence runs q1 first; direct q45 fails explicitly. This repeats the mkdir item in meter-closeup: follow-ups from Codex review 5328852981 #103.

Four distinct blocking defects remain in their PR threads: note scrubbing, rebuilt correction loss, stale sweep inputs, and field-test recompression. The cache-key item previously deferred in #103 is now escalated with a synthetic changed-input reproduction; it is not part of this nonblocking list.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions