Skip to content

Show Fork as a reply row button whenever it can run at once #32012

Open

Description

@Pearcekieser

Existing issues

  • I searched open issues and this is not already requested.

Problem

On almost every reply, Fork needs two clicks. The reply's action row shows Regenerate, Copy and More on the newest reply, and Quote, Copy and More on older ones. "Fork conversation from here" is the eighth item in More.

A reply gets the Fork row button only when it has no stable message id (meta.mid) and its whole window is loaded. Every reply written since #8047 has an id, so in practice the row button only shows on old history. In one chat, an old reply can show Fork in the row while a new reply hides it in More. The reader cannot see why.

Fork is the only item in that menu that starts a new chat. People who split long threads use it many times a day.

Proposed behaviour

Draw Fork as a row button, beside Copy and Regenerate, whenever the fork can run at once:

Reply Today Proposed
Newest reply Regenerate, Copy, More Regenerate, Copy, Fork, More
Older reply Quote, Copy, More Fork, Copy, More, with Quote still in More and the right-click menu
Tail-only Fork on both fork entries in More unchanged
Fork point not resolved yet Fork in More with its reason unchanged

The seat order and the four-control newest row are the ones #16977 already uses for index-addressed replies. This proposal applies them to replies that carry a message id.

While Tail-only Fork is on, Fork stays in More. #21961 put the two directions side by side there so the reader chooses at the moment of forking. A row button would also sit dimmed on every newest reply, because a tail fork of the newest message has nothing to copy.

Alternatives considered

  • Keep Fork in More. That costs an extra click and a menu scan on each fork.
  • Put Fork after Copy on every reply and keep Quote's seat. That gives four controls on every reply, where this proposal gives four only on the newest reply.
  • A row button that follows Tail-only Fork. With the setting on, it is a dimmed control on every newest reply, and it repeats an entry that More already lists.

Anything else

The newest reply's row has four controls. That is one more than the max-two-buttons-per-row ruling on #16960 allows (seat, Copy, More). It needs a maintainer ruling. #16977 already draws this row for index-addressed replies.

Activity

  1. added
    tier:T2Small additive feature; existing behaviour unchanged
    on Nov 7, 2026
  2. KiroCrewCaptain commented on Nov 7, 2026

    @KiroCrewCaptain
    Collaborator

    Thanks for the report. This issue has been triaged by Crew Captain and will be assigned to a maintainer, who will follow up here.

  3. bolichen97 commented on Nov 10, 2026

    @bolichen97
    Contributor

    [operator: bolichen97] Maintainer decision: this request moves to tier T3. A one-click Fork either moves Quote out of the first row button on older replies or adds a fourth button to a reply's row, and both change a row people already use.

    We keep this request open so that others can find it. It is not on the current plan. If you need it too, add a thumbs-up reaction to this issue; we look at the most requested items first.

  4. added
    tier:T3Changes an existing user experience; needs a one-pager
    parkedKept open as a request; not on the current plan
    and removed
    tier:T2Small additive feature; existing behaviour unchanged
    on Nov 10, 2026
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    parkedKept open as a request; not on the current plantier:T3Changes an existing user experience; needs a one-pager

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions