Skip to content

feat: add org charts and guardrails for persistent teams - #10595

Closed
Zedmor wants to merge 1 commit into
mainfrom
feat/org-chart-guardrails
Closed

Zedmor wants to merge 1 commit into
mainfrom
feat/org-chart-guardrails

Conversation

@Zedmor

@Zedmor Zedmor commented Sep 13, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Problem / Motivation

An owner should be able to ask a conductor to deliver an outcome in chat and see which specialists do the work. A prompt alone does not require delegation, and temporary workers do not retain the same identity and accountability across assignments.

This organization prototype combines persistent members, reporting relationships, role limits, staffing, tracked assignments and explicit review. Chat task registration removes the extra trip to a separate task form.

Why it matters

Conductors and managers plan and review while engineers implement and researchers examine evidence. Each member keeps its own conversation and private memory. The owner can inspect the team, talk to any member, and accept the result.

What changed (motivation → approach → change)

Org Chart and Guardrails adds reporting relationships, fixed role limits, staffing, messages and assignment review to Capabilities and the member editor. Conductors and managers hire, delegate and review; engineers implement; researchers read and browse. Members communicate along manager/report relationships. Hiring reuses idle reports or creates private members within atomic headcount limits. Team size and simultaneous work have separate limits.

A gateway-owned, versioned store persists assignments, audit records and wakes. Existing prototype records are adopted in place; unsupported schema versions refuse before writes. Work runs in each member’s conversation, with role limits compiled before provider startup loses its original identity. org_start_task registers verified owner chat requests, including replacement text; guests, client metadata and stored-history regeneration cannot grant authority. Reports wake assigners, pending wakes coalesce, and completion requires review. Recovery follows listener bind. Update and shutdown admission preserve undispatched work and drain delivery before requeuing; interrupted dispatch requires deliberate retry. Organization errors retain redacted structured details and are audited as failed.

The UI protects drafts, distinguishes team staffing from member saves, labels reporting relationships, reflects runtime availability and confirms retirement. Peer operations reject internal callers before forwarding owner credentials. The SDK checks compiled roles through the project-first resolver. Atomic publication supports older glibc, and POSIX process cleanup uses portable ps column arguments. The public proposal explains ledger ownership and the supervised chess evidence; previews use existing pods. The build separates i18next from catalogs while preserving synchronous initialization. Test setup isolates advertised-model discovery.

flowchart TD
    H[Human owner] --> C[Conductor]
    C --> M[Engineering manager]
    C --> R[Researcher]
    M --> E1[Engineer 1]
    M --> E2[Engineer 2]
    classDef added fill:#DCFCE7,stroke:#16A34A
    classDef changed fill:#FEF3C7,stroke:#D97706
    classDef removed fill:#FEE2E2,stroke:#DC2626,stroke-dasharray:5 5
    classDef ctx fill:#E0F2FE,stroke:#0284C7
    class H ctx
    class C changed
    class M,R,E1,E2 added
    linkStyle 0 stroke:#0284C7
    linkStyle 1,2,3,4 stroke:#16A34A,stroke-width:2px
Loading

🟩 added · 🟨 changed · 🟥 removed · 🟦 unchanged

Area Purpose
src/kiro_crew/organization.py, organization_service.py Versioned durable assignments and audit records, relationships, atomic staffing and private member provisioning
organization_runtime.py, dashboard/server.py Deliver wakes into canonical member conversations; defer recovery until after bind and drain it on shutdown
monitoring/completion.py Retain pre-dispatch admission refusals through cleanup while preserving the accepted-turn boundary
dashboard/chat_handlers.py, dashboard/chat_delivery.py, dashboard/chat_runner.py, dashboard/chat_utils.py, dashboard/chat_rewind.py, dashboard/chat_regenerate.py, dashboard/slot_queue_repository.py, dashboard/state.py Verify owner provenance for new chat text, preserve it through queues and retries, recompute it for edits, exclude stored-history regeneration, and deny internal callers access to owner peer credentials
dashboard/handlers/organization.py Separate owner/member API authorization, retain explicit error codes and recursively redact outgoing organization text
organization_policy.py, src/kiro_crew/agent_sdk/drivers/acp.py, acp/client.py, providers/acp.py Compile and install role tool limits before provider startup; check resolved definitions through the SDK
organization_tools.py, mcp_work.py Stateless authenticated organization tools; redacted errors retain structured details and are audited as failed
agent_discovery.py, context.py Keep generated role agents out of the member catalog and teach the correct delegation tools
sandbox.py, security/paths.py, security_posture.py Hide organization authority from member processes and register MCP and HTTP response redaction boundaries
platform_compat.py Preserve atomic no-replace publication on older glibc and use separate ps column arguments in the POSIX process-tree cleanup helper
website/src/pages, website/src/api, website/src/components, website/src/surfaces, website/src/i18n Organization controls, member work summaries, navigation and translated strings
website/playwright/auth.setup.ts, website/playwright/settings.spec.ts Keep disposable browser scenarios independent of optional update notices
website/vite.config.ts, website/docs/i18n-catalog.md Separate the translation library from catalog data using the existing vendor chunk mechanism
test/conftest.py, docs/system-specs/common/testing-conventions.md Isolate advertised models between tests and document explicit warm-cache setup
docs/request-for-change/rfc-org-chart-and-guardrails.md, owning specs and indexes In-progress public proposal, ledger comparison, schema-adoption and runtime contracts, pod preview instructions

The Kiro backend and private-memory OS isolation are required. Roles are fixed; per-assignment network policy, custom roles and automatic project/worktree isolation remain outside this implementation. Cancelling an assignment closes its descendants but does not undo side effects or stop an already running conversation.

Tests

Tests cover owner-chat provenance, fixed role limits, private identity and peer boundaries, transactional staffing, schema adoption/refusal, audit outcomes, queued wake admission and shutdown delivery. Frontend tests cover organization actions, reporting labels, runtime availability, empty work states and retirement confirmation. website/src/test/KiroCrewAgentsPage.discardGuard.test.tsx verifies member-editor draft preservation.

All 50 original local gates passed on frozen source tree 981e54ecdf5a9beb04dd6aba5d009ada0beadba5, committed unchanged as 5007486300ce9587cb3ee217e6bbc7914532c195.

Suite Recorded result
Backend 103,780 passed; 269 skipped; 9 expected failures
Frontend 33,273 passed; 1 expected failure; 2 skipped
Electron 1,872 passed; 0 failed; 1 skipped
Browser E2E 266 expected; 0 unexpected; 1 flaky; 0 skipped

The browser gate exited 0; the render comparison ran in enforced mode against the pinned base.

Current-source attempt history (e568a6621cbb0a8afa654603eeb76436313f9be1): On the frozen repair tree before amendment, chat.spec.ts:62 passed on its configured retry after the first .msg-content matched a hidden user bubble. The retry also matched a user bubble; this assertion does not establish streaming behavior. The test and implicated chat rendering match the pinned base. Exact first-attempt timing remains unproven; no selector, timeout or retry setting was changed, and the suite was not rerun.

Manual verification

A real owner-chat request drove a conductor → manager → three-engineer build, with independent researcher review. The completed match scored 77.5/100 points (74 wins, 7 draws, 19 losses) against official Stockfish 11 at UCI_LimitStrength=true, UCI_Elo=1500, 300 ms/move for both engines, one thread and no pondering. All 100 games have unique global numbers and alternating colors; no failed games were omitted.

A separate verifier replayed all 8,306 plies through Stockfish’s depth-1 legal-move generator and verified every terminal result. Perft matched the initial position through depth 6, Kiwipete through depth 4, and en-passant and promotion reference positions through depth 5. The proposal records executable hashes and the version-specific limits of this result.

This was a supervised build: owner interventions selected a writable project child, tightened the harness, recovered missing perft evidence and split the final match into disjoint allocations. The missing progress wake was fixed during that run. Manager and researcher reports are accepted; the owner accepted the root assignment after independent replay.

An isolated gateway at 022d7359 verified the existing build from one real owner-chat request. Its conductor, manager, two engineers and researcher retained their identities and private conversations from an earlier verification. The conductor registered the owner assignment from chat. The manager assigned separate perft and match-record checks, accepted both engineers’ evidence, and reported back. The researcher independently cross-checked the new reports and saved logs. Reports woke the coordinators; the owner accepted the final result through the UI. All five assignments were accepted and all eleven delegated turns completed without failure or further owner instructions.

The engineers wrote verification-final/perft.txt and verification-final/match.json. An external read-only audit confirmed all 20 perft rows, the score, game numbering, alternating colors and binary hashes. All 119 supplied input hashes matched before and after. The video walks through this completed verification; it does not repeat the earlier 100-game match.

To try the prototype, check out this PR in a linked worktree named kirocrew-org-pr. From a KiroCrew checkout, use the existing pod lifecycle with an authenticated Kiro CLI and the platform's supported service controller (substitute your worktree name if different):

kirocrew pod up kirocrew-org-pr --provision --seed minimal --approval yolo
kirocrew pod token kirocrew-org-pr

The first command provisions the worktree and creates isolated pod data with automatic tool approval and no crons. Open its dashboard, select the Kiro member backend and enable private member provisioning. Open Capabilities → Org Chart and Guardrails, create a starter team, resume delegation and chat with the conductor. Create task files in a project subdirectory of the configured workspace and name that location in the request. The role ceilings still apply to automatically approved tools. Pod service prerequisites and lifecycle are documented in src/kiro_crew/pod/README.md.

Screenshots / video

Capture sources:

  • Capture 1: HEAD 5007486300ce9587cb3ee217e6bbc7914532c195, source tree 981e54ecdf5a9beb04dd6aba5d009ada0beadba5.
  • Capture 2: HEAD 040a56b4423e9d74532d604a30ed8be6a257d214, source tree 7a3e7cc23c6980ba0e6513f511032eca965840b3.

Edited walkthrough of the saved real team verification

Saved real state. Capture 1. Current UI over the real verification completed at 022d7359; edited walkthrough, no new match or agent run.

org-chart-guardrails-demo.mp4

Conductor, manager, two engineers and researcher

Saved real state. Capture 1. Current UI over the preserved real verification at 022d7359.

Conductor, manager, two engineers and researcher

Fixed role limits require coordinators to delegate implementation

Historical capture. Capture 2. Historical capture of the preserved real verification at 022d7359.

Fixed role limits require coordinators to delegate implementation

The manager’s continuing conversation and accepted assignments

Historical capture. Capture 2. Historical capture of the preserved real verification at 022d7359.

The manager’s continuing conversation and accepted assignments

Additional UI evidence

Separate headcount and simultaneous-work limits, with Save staffing

Saved real state. Capture 1. Current UI over the preserved real verification at 022d7359.

Separate headcount and simultaneous-work limits, with Save staffing

Team controls and member-save scope in the member editor

Saved real state. Capture 1. Current UI over the preserved real verification at 022d7359.

Team controls and member-save scope in the member editor

Saved assignments and accepted reports

Saved real state. Capture 1. Current UI over the preserved real verification at 022d7359.

Saved assignments and accepted reports

The conductor returns the reviewed chess evidence

Historical capture. Capture 2. Historical capture of the preserved real verification at 022d7359.

The conductor returns the reviewed chess evidence

Reporting relationships in the light theme

Saved real state. Capture 1. Current UI over the preserved real verification at 022d7359.

Reporting relationships in the light theme

Org chart at a 390 px viewport

Saved real state. Capture 1. Current UI over the preserved real verification at 022d7359.

Org chart at a 390 px viewport

Pause new work without removing team members

Live controls. Capture 1. Live controls over the saved team; work unchanged and temporary pause restored.

Pause new work without removing team members

Named retirement confirmation, cancelled without retiring a member

Historical capture. Capture 2. Historical live control capture; confirmation cancelled without retiring a member.

Named retirement confirmation, cancelled without retiring a member

Reports to identifies the member’s reporting relationship

Live controls. Capture 1. Live controls over the saved team; work unchanged and temporary pause restored.

Reports to identifies the member’s reporting relationship

An existing member outside the organization is identified explicitly

Live controls. Capture 1. Live controls over the saved team; work unchanged and temporary pause restored.

An existing member outside the organization is identified explicitly

Illustrative review decision and request-changes controls

UI illustration: simulated API response. Capture 1. Simulated API response; no work, message or member mutation.

Illustrative review decision and request-changes controls

Illustrative empty organization and starter-team action

Historical capture. Capture 2. Historical simulated API response; no members removed.

Illustrative empty organization and starter-team action

Illustrative interrupted turn with the production recovery message

UI illustration: simulated API response. Capture 1. Simulated API response; no work, message or member mutation.

Illustrative interrupted turn with the production recovery message

Illustrative message history attributes its sender and recipient

UI illustration: simulated API response. Capture 1. Simulated API response; no work, message or member mutation.

Illustrative message history attributes its sender and recipient

Illustrative unavailable runtime with its specific refusal reason

UI illustration: simulated API response. Capture 1. Simulated API response; no work, message or member mutation.

Illustrative unavailable runtime with its specific refusal reason

Related Issues

no linked issue: owner-requested organization prototype and chat task-intake improvement

Checklist

  • At most two commits (one is the norm), with a Conventional Commits title (feat|fix|docs|refactor|perf|test|chore|ci|build|revert: ...)
  • Existing tests pass and new tests added for new functionality
  • Self-review completed; code follows project style guidelines
  • Documentation updated (if applicable)
  • No secrets, credentials, or internal references in the diff

@Zedmor
Zedmor requested review from a team and iamwhatever September 13, 2026 17:47
@github-actions github-actions Bot added the readiness: checking Automated validation is still running label Sep 13, 2026
@github-actions

github-actions Bot commented Sep 13, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

GPT 5.6 Review — 🔴 changes requested (blocking)

GPT 5.6 found at least one blocking issue that must be resolved before merging 5007486300ce9587cb3ee217e6bbc7914532c195. 1 of 1 blocking finding(s) are security-class and were withheld from adjudication, so the blocking verdict stands.

This comment is updated in place on each push.

BLOCKING -- src/kiro_crew/dashboard/chat_runner.py:7818 -- Non-owner steers can borrow the live owner's task grant (origin: validation)

slot._organization_owner_request = (
Non-owner steer -> owner-started member turn -> unchanged grant authorizes org_start_task -> guest instruction becomes an owner assignment.
Anchor: residual/security
Fix: Queue non-owner steers as separate turns whenever the running turn holds an owner grant.
[BLOCK-MERGE] 5007486
[GPT-REVIEWED] 5007486

Adjudication (Opus 4.8) — is blocking on each finding proportionate?

The adjudicable block is empty; F1 is fenced (privilege-escalation / governance-ceiling class).

Verified: the owner grant slot._organization_owner_request is set at turn start (chat_runner.py:7818) keyed only to (session_key, uuid), and owner_chat_request authorizes org_start_task on that grant while the turn is merely running with a matching _active_turn_session_key (organization_service.py:16-23); it is cleared only in the turn's finally (chat_runner.py:13379). Nothing in that check binds the grant to the identity of a mid-turn steer. A non-owner steering an owner-started running turn is a plausible everyday operation in a shared team chat, not a contradictory/legacy-only condition combination — I cannot complete the rarity record FLAG requires, and this is exactly the unbounded class where a wrong clearance is unrecoverable.

[ADJUDICATION] 5007486 total=0 uphold=0 downgrade=0
[GPT-ADJUDICATED] 5007486
[ADJUDICATION-FENCED] 5007486 fenced=1 flagged=0
UPHOLD-FENCED F1 src/kiro_crew/dashboard/chat_runner.py:7818 -- The owner grant is keyed to the running turn's session, not to steer identity, so a non-owner steer riding an owner-started turn can escalate a guest instruction into an owner task assignment; steering a live turn is common, not extreme, so no rarity argument clears the unbounded harm.
[GPT-ADJUDICATED-FENCED] 5007486

False positive or not applicable? A repository writer can comment:
/ai-review override gpt 5007486300ce9587cb3ee217e6bbc7914532c195: <one-sentence reason>

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 13, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Intent: Let an owner assign work in chat to a persistent team whose roles require delegation, bound staffing and communication, and make assignments, evidence and reviews visible in Capabilities and member properties.
Not a goal: Custom role policies, per-assignment network restrictions, automatic project/worktree isolation, or organization execution on other providers.

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 13, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

The supervised chess-build validation completed with 100 saved games. This is a version- and time-control-specific benchmark, not a general playing-strength rating. No game was discarded from the final 100-game set. Lane summary files describe sub-batches; the counts below come from the complete individual game records.

The independent verifier replayed all moves through Stockfish’s depth-1 legal-move interface, checked checkmate and draw conditions, and checked unchanged executable hashes before and after replay. Stockfish did not select the custom engine’s moves.

{
  "scenario": "Earlier supervised prototype build, followed by independent move replay; separate from the final-revision UI verification demo",
  "roles": {
    "conductor": 1,
    "manager": 1,
    "engineer": 3,
    "researcher": 1
  },
  "opponent_options": {
    "version": "Stockfish 11 64 POPCNT",
    "UCI_LimitStrength": true,
    "UCI_Elo": 1500,
    "Threads": 1,
    "Ponder": false
  },
  "time_control": {
    "engine_movetime_ms": 300,
    "opponent_movetime_ms": 300
  },
  "score_definition": "(wins + draws / 2) / completed games",
  "verification": {
    "games": 100,
    "unique_global_numbers": true,
    "alternating_colors": true,
    "legal_plies_checked": 8306,
    "rules_oracle": "Stockfish 11 64 POPCNT",
    "oracle_operation": "perft depth 1 and position display on saved moves only; no search or move selection",
    "wins": 74,
    "draws": 7,
    "losses": 19,
    "score_points": 77.5,
    "score_fraction": 0.775,
    "invalid_moves": 0,
    "invalid_terminal_results": 0,
    "engine_sha256": "503b9d47ed94aad4f3aab93f3b6ba28f116892913b526a631ea0a16e65bcf7f3",
    "stockfish_sha256": "d44ee3d6506aeeaa2464989f363981cfa12400741ad0cd206742b7c0adc4d8bf",
    "records_sha256": "f2658e9bbad351cd2d126b9765a80380c6b95e508ac4ec9f9b14e7a91a10536b",
    "perft_report_sha256": "7f2358fb96cad102c712742ee16b76e5102c3f73bcff7252135c75236db161fb"
  },
  "owner_interventions": [
    "selected a writable project child",
    "requested match-harness corrections",
    "recovered missing perft evidence",
    "split the final match into disjoint allocations"
  ],
  "task_review": "Manager and researcher reports accepted; owner accepted the root assignment after independent replay.",
  "game_records": [
    {
      "game": 1,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 71,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "c4766a65a9aa438bb07114bc75763eb006c5d32dbd3e120fd5591d54dc4b157d"
    },
    {
      "game": 2,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 106,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "5c10ad300dbec370346b38ec62055b6ae7556d602cecf75fd0fd369ef779ef45"
    },
    {
      "game": 3,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "loss",
      "plies": 138,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "e1afd689d9757cdcce1d36e1a87b1f9058681f11ebe82540a63bb7486c857ca8"
    },
    {
      "game": 4,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 82,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "d05f7019baba9f7774ebfb7d7994e26a77fb6a57da22d248443c44ca8488d51e"
    },
    {
      "game": 5,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "loss",
      "plies": 54,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "f8049d98162e0ddd957e48556d544a983a4b90b33cd4a3c84b9e3c14fd4c4265"
    },
    {
      "game": 6,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "loss",
      "plies": 79,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "127b3b633556a34e71bf6446004e6e15f3b819c123106b1b0f39586e82f2aaf8"
    },
    {
      "game": 7,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "draw",
      "plies": 46,
      "reason": "threefold repetition",
      "record_sha256": "07b4f21c1100c1f89744d42c0c18bafe7647174ef2a9555028e62d420f49643e"
    },
    {
      "game": 8,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "draw",
      "plies": 69,
      "reason": "threefold repetition",
      "record_sha256": "8d7af30cefd0630f99ddc157415d07aa63de66ea2a91c36d3b82f26efe8ae85b"
    },
    {
      "game": 9,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "draw",
      "plies": 48,
      "reason": "threefold repetition",
      "record_sha256": "80adf79ca59f5b7777bc7f3fcb245567a017cdd015aceb822c31a0375a50b0b1"
    },
    {
      "game": 10,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "loss",
      "plies": 77,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "d632969e45e8666db1738ad4349522df683c4d72312513720baaa0eec91b16e7"
    },
    {
      "game": 11,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 49,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "38175cb8b7c34e4afd97b2e5e8f721d8d637cea8013fce800500f796668c9dc9"
    },
    {
      "game": 12,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "loss",
      "plies": 55,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "b18ba4fe7aa940ff14b581b8a616ffc61e3de86db025149fb5a93880c645fa0e"
    },
    {
      "game": 13,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 69,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "50f052235bac59312416b7b5e0483361a6de44c58f9136bae671d3b0a6856fd3"
    },
    {
      "game": 14,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 90,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "de92ac0ff643935baa49c96fea581713e0d4df169076dcc039fbfba273ce3e0f"
    },
    {
      "game": 15,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 83,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "fd7e4bcd7207e6f12017d3c5814795d8af0ee6f7e8766d38f7ad21331e5ac84b"
    },
    {
      "game": 16,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 60,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "0fb6c91bd746df4b259780eddd576c186872e95fbba84f198510fbb879031fb9"
    },
    {
      "game": 17,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 95,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "f1bb73a4f74a84a508fe0dfcee5af2cde60df9d88c1e7e4d2b7ad080c3eac930"
    },
    {
      "game": 18,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 76,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "5af9f8385efdbeedb66591b8909fb1786608216e923c6b2c51be476669c5867e"
    },
    {
      "game": 19,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 119,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "a746694cbadd258e577d665925a6a5919928fe2e52b06121e0bbe1dfa6fe0118"
    },
    {
      "game": 20,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "loss",
      "plies": 51,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "750809ade44f02102cb4f2b8a93700ff20fe1569b4bd72a90ed29ade4ccd3b8e"
    },
    {
      "game": 21,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 103,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "4df809d78075cf207fb63d80d1d959bfb24528664abc79d16fae34ff57f4de61"
    },
    {
      "game": 22,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "draw",
      "plies": 168,
      "reason": "threefold repetition",
      "record_sha256": "0e02e9490b26da7db09ecc2b7ab53932aca2c47b946cc60962e8021e15d28359"
    },
    {
      "game": 23,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 123,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "d6b49c2a67692cc32799dc23266c3f45317ee73111d49dad9c76a2ad260c8893"
    },
    {
      "game": 24,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 120,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "1c5e9762274b3dd3286d6f7a8d00ca922f3d490a927e4a206a6688b18cc87b45"
    },
    {
      "game": 25,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "loss",
      "plies": 42,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "ea9e6c25874ee664f091232133d7e05d9b6cb8e33a97f8334a6a960681b83de8"
    },
    {
      "game": 26,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 60,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "74482f7dfb29167ec6271ec2fa04c3cff596b54c4f5af4fc5055293a784bca73"
    },
    {
      "game": 27,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 75,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "eb61c293787b6c492c4f043c923958f7fc2b8c1b3648ab19f2ad59de39f8f20c"
    },
    {
      "game": 28,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 70,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "79204fb9539c2d57995028a2b7be09be3e6e458f9d21060fb17f329938dd1d9c"
    },
    {
      "game": 29,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 65,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "6da5cff5f5da11fd57d296665d184ed292c3e1771d4411e2dbd7c2df2397e3c7"
    },
    {
      "game": 30,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "loss",
      "plies": 41,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "0d9315398b09661fc84c114e926710ce04bbd6bfb692e48b75a5bd4cc668b982"
    },
    {
      "game": 31,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 79,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "0af4505d89c414aa6872db359f05b22c00dc9a79ed769376cdf332fdf01d32a6"
    },
    {
      "game": 32,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 100,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "1bea047a407984b700732fa3b772f451aee4f6c5b1391ac6caee7af9b4dde842"
    },
    {
      "game": 33,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "loss",
      "plies": 60,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "d6de09be175bb2908242bc81273da223346ae0c9b0f48e28c2bb17f79e6dd806"
    },
    {
      "game": 34,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 60,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "c1a038d33e26853eccc92797d528a4b444940914e14e6616121301e77b643b4f"
    },
    {
      "game": 35,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "draw",
      "plies": 60,
      "reason": "threefold repetition",
      "record_sha256": "3762523a7314690233c4bcb79b12a478dbb7160238a8d0b6fb3b9899bfb82410"
    },
    {
      "game": 36,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 90,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "3fd50812684b4eb0a8ac58a8c529ea26159a111803f16d70f56c53cf6dbb0246"
    },
    {
      "game": 37,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 105,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "b60b77c682c1ce008aa1feab2f7ebe5497cdaf5b74a39626f86c9f804b95c8f4"
    },
    {
      "game": 38,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 134,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "0b0d39781095cde02a621f90f09f8218ede827e38e7b4ee1b345d99319be68ca"
    },
    {
      "game": 39,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 69,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "7810eedcfa6cb15463fa7cab39dcaa681c412d9d734a663313d743791e5e6aa7"
    },
    {
      "game": 40,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "loss",
      "plies": 37,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "516964cfce154bba46713a8e7c0ab72749d540345a35fad037b2297c3d5dde5b"
    },
    {
      "game": 41,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 67,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "8d92616f404b0c952ac56ae294b65b1a6d6f62f05cb1ddc763aae125b2757ca6"
    },
    {
      "game": 42,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 76,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "4836fe910f59a16e4adb5fe6de5307a1fefb609b3215e582c5e79a65c4c5ff16"
    },
    {
      "game": 43,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 31,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "250aa18c87a482119f448b8a15f26b3389ff8101f034d1327b5e35497e57f531"
    },
    {
      "game": 44,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 116,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "dff33bf0f82ba15a5a518d9b803ad30daac88493b49de4b2d8205d0c90eccc9c"
    },
    {
      "game": 45,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 67,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "5e3ffdf6307868f8637f4bc48c136ef662f4b335e41c3691db68cf8c2955d10d"
    },
    {
      "game": 46,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 90,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "b7ad8173d5fce04c110548ea03f8a425ea276caea8c1145c404b6794220fafb9"
    },
    {
      "game": 47,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "loss",
      "plies": 44,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "e0c9c94cf9906918de92cbb595272b8e47711f4a74c944f49950b548b4509572"
    },
    {
      "game": 48,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 92,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "ebbdcee33dbc94a5f2e5131653ca8a13dd28eb5f707afcb9770a85923402ccf7"
    },
    {
      "game": 49,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 99,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "5d8f59d9e9787729d5613548dde982f6ceeba7ca64ae92108f7d3eb9ca352c41"
    },
    {
      "game": 50,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "loss",
      "plies": 59,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "e30774c4d848d02e170cb01968b80dff47a93eb46c66c71c9ccd9711faaf83e9"
    },
    {
      "game": 51,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 81,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "9dca758152bf65e1dd96b065ae628046ba368abc7e72c7d7f7172fd172850b8c"
    },
    {
      "game": 52,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 116,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "aaa604cf41fa57d56259654b6238bf4e8e6fc2191f33128955d34e8c2eb72c50"
    },
    {
      "game": 53,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 103,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "256f297fe4838865154bb812edbd0f0bac70d8052a08debcdfb14cbb52615b34"
    },
    {
      "game": 54,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "loss",
      "plies": 31,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "046f4477f15569d20dd396eb5cec4e0b6adbc6d0be92602e5709530560432046"
    },
    {
      "game": 55,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 55,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "b171e047a6b744782a6ef57db147854fc9410bdee849ad5c518fa69334d6d353"
    },
    {
      "game": 56,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "draw",
      "plies": 181,
      "reason": "insufficient material",
      "record_sha256": "af827ca3ef80806ce714c3461bf032c5f6daa1b861124a59a27f44a672cddf7d"
    },
    {
      "game": 57,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 49,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "8057883023604f55f40901e01b6a1d6930fc6c9c60a66117d1db65dbfbb49fc2"
    },
    {
      "game": 58,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "loss",
      "plies": 123,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "cc53778d97c4dc375923d9850bcea76f00e5d98cb8e35aad702072c36631dc6d"
    },
    {
      "game": 59,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "draw",
      "plies": 55,
      "reason": "threefold repetition",
      "record_sha256": "5908341312e6351cb73d9db81b058f761f70e07396d2026545f8577992829c6b"
    },
    {
      "game": 60,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 86,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "c4c2398ae0965cc59be41058b46867676cbd19b2af4b0d04f5bc914f243443f5"
    },
    {
      "game": 61,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 111,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "8cd3ebf3b13d6af8f3c6d37c74cf15d8faad007ffd71274b9fb9f3b90b0395bd"
    },
    {
      "game": 62,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 72,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "9a6e9c179e4352bd4f418e24a9491de8da7f8f1abf69e355e04bf46e950478d6"
    },
    {
      "game": 63,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 73,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "1f2c384e0860ab624e4191dc892801e4bcace4b8c6cc115ba41d1c67ecf5688c"
    },
    {
      "game": 64,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 104,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "0273e70fd75e210cbde62f2f8e009aefb623d768e9273a396cc7295d0f26d03e"
    },
    {
      "game": 65,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 83,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "8b732f1830960cec01e7653d61335ffacee321a28ba1fe008f86199b17038d89"
    },
    {
      "game": 66,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 80,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "d85a31a36026bd94b3e73de6331b653a1d7c979dd93fd8a6912f9f10dc5baaa4"
    },
    {
      "game": 67,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 59,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "55b3d6b637807a25b348f3350ff1c0b71d93ae4392d5edec4f41b2a6f2919b95"
    },
    {
      "game": 68,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "loss",
      "plies": 87,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "7dbc897d102b4434e37f8f6676ba9134dcbcab49163b1e0ff5cc91d6ecfb61a7"
    },
    {
      "game": 69,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 55,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "dfe9d597ab72cbbf7bd21bae0bd8ba89c54829b9dc1d4d8286a35f1968ca9e92"
    },
    {
      "game": 70,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 98,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "73a98fe5bdbebff33bd4f6f99461fba08a92ceae841f609fea007d8c386a6708"
    },
    {
      "game": 71,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 87,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "e97f2cf5560ba097be17aa1a69fcfe2f4f31f47325eefa3064acad3cbdd90acc"
    },
    {
      "game": 72,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 148,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "f3fc01196a465866e1fc281de9e16301e16e1a9ed73a8880a7fb95e38de5098b"
    },
    {
      "game": 73,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 91,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "1cf06651678a20f6fdabb45a9fe0434bd6f2e27653b8a368973c64544d7c7d20"
    },
    {
      "game": 74,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 80,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "aede44b2f9ba5f785741b23601452452db103d35ee5f61caa8048f6c3cbde931"
    },
    {
      "game": 75,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 97,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "3b95e9209b083df214f3a4985f561491e0c1eb367fd575573fc504b22da9795c"
    },
    {
      "game": 76,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 64,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "bbc06bdfcbe8a46863826cd5d055f09ba2f19cea09d7143658a51a89698dfdb2"
    },
    {
      "game": 77,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "loss",
      "plies": 52,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "a38a7d5baa4abc4ef8c0bd431c7e29ac3073d0b68dbaa2fc4c7a146bcc7fff75"
    },
    {
      "game": 78,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 90,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "3b6a04604d8ab068f5477091ad9019ce7edfdeaa388a549a2177393f6a0d83e2"
    },
    {
      "game": 79,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 161,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "461424c59981bbcbc115636b978465deb5c763c6b651571a6caafd22ad1556f6"
    },
    {
      "game": 80,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 210,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "07cf14bbb94964f2da12ff0e2c866713bbce025775e6cc876ba4ff7524eab2aa"
    },
    {
      "game": 81,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 35,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "c89d0901a090a0e9d7a3d91471a4419201402947f9e84adb1a52edbdc503fe9c"
    },
    {
      "game": 82,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 122,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "fe37ed11291813cd68e1fca1d2c18841237f735d710efb1bfdf8f17435afb5ab"
    },
    {
      "game": 83,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 99,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "aa70caaa64e4a2e026d5762fb21e587f104283d755270a5a33fb8a9b97b5b55f"
    },
    {
      "game": 84,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 112,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "ccd9d60143e7b72b679fdc5023ba3b682de90ea861524c4e28fd79792b720a1c"
    },
    {
      "game": 85,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 69,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "e33617ee354bf3297257d57f258b30cf7df85f72af7278723b2072db67bb754c"
    },
    {
      "game": 86,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 88,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "d2e3186c8c535eb4d87b5a8b6eb67021cfed382d2b79a5d407097358a88e74a7"
    },
    {
      "game": 87,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 71,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "90a4ed8fd199681625424d3d481bffaf371d0cbe3bd658b62fa39dc4dd2a8969"
    },
    {
      "game": 88,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "loss",
      "plies": 45,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "d5aa317b377073c4a3507fa3bf2cf2ca3cc7d81f167cc5c2e6e72bc7d28ccc31"
    },
    {
      "game": 89,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "loss",
      "plies": 70,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "a304c70cab86bcc33f89db0c7a6fdb5c9dd43b6d10a55d32fd6fd8c12d1efe02"
    },
    {
      "game": 90,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 102,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "6051007ae14d5555f3951348773cd4f0d72c9ecb71e64c2c6d5a811303dd8fcf"
    },
    {
      "game": 91,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 99,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "ce6ca5c3cdfd34bdb8f2d73ff88558548126a6a533ed8b13ccc68f6e244d3879"
    },
    {
      "game": 92,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 92,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "7c172c51773e0a913ab8feff90952af201e572ecbf29913c4b7a2c5ab9cebe25"
    },
    {
      "game": 93,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "loss",
      "plies": 84,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "038189883c425e6a6fc9c43bc685547635078da14089b21738afcb5fa47f798e"
    },
    {
      "game": 94,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 86,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "a7eea9af2cfc31605fcf072b7851a853dabefbac00f25026a9f3152f0f1fda44"
    },
    {
      "game": 95,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 55,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "878e69f3b5a0968050a6f2f66bac2894d710c495645ab0e4d44498e13d1b710b"
    },
    {
      "game": 96,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 70,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "e59742f627b575ee5454f8c7c1360f3cd9c95b0b8ecfa01821be13ec72a2961e"
    },
    {
      "game": 97,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 91,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "222595ae072aceaffe71e1cb2d9f376a7f5f0be79382a6a611dc8ea5ae73dc82"
    },
    {
      "game": 98,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 74,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "2991d2dcb89b1e24c6116b2e3c5ae942cc698a83d3c6fba7e95dc7683724fb5e"
    },
    {
      "game": 99,
      "color": "white",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 53,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "35d82957a16310a5fc17827c553544cc1bfb96b9554c0438fc96b554f1b979cc"
    },
    {
      "game": 100,
      "color": "black",
      "outcome": "win",
      "plies": 88,
      "reason": "checkmate",
      "record_sha256": "ece0591b3848dda255d6fca1495217fa44b43e78b5c05df38b307b25d36a8105"
    }
  ],
  "owner_chat_intake": {
    "task_id": "744ac799c4c34359b9c0bd65644b51c4",
    "recorded_sender": "owner",
    "recipient_role": "conductor",
    "creation_event": "start_task_from_owner_chat",
    "creation_event_sequence": 98,
    "created_utc": "2026-09-13T03:54:39.865417+00:00",
    "final_state": "accepted",
    "acceptance_event": "review:accept",
    "acceptance_event_sequence": 357,
    "evidence_source": "Read-only query of the gateway organization audit"
  }
}

Perft evidence from the build:

position(FEN) | depth | your_count | reference | result
Initial [rnbqkbnr/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPPP/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 1] | d1 | 20 | 20 | MATCH
Initial [rnbqkbnr/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPPP/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 1] | d2 | 400 | 400 | MATCH
Initial [rnbqkbnr/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPPP/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 1] | d3 | 8902 | 8902 | MATCH
Initial [rnbqkbnr/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPPP/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 1] | d4 | 197281 | 197281 | MATCH
Initial [rnbqkbnr/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPPP/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 1] | d5 | 4865609 | 4865609 | MATCH
Initial [rnbqkbnr/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPPP/RNBQKBNR w KQkq - 0 1] | d6 | 119060324 | 119060324 | MATCH
Kiwipete [r3k2r/p1ppqpb1/bn2pnp1/3PN3/1p2P3/2N2Q1p/PPPBBPPP/R3K2R w KQkq - 0 1] | d1 | 48 | 48 | MATCH
Kiwipete [r3k2r/p1ppqpb1/bn2pnp1/3PN3/1p2P3/2N2Q1p/PPPBBPPP/R3K2R w KQkq - 0 1] | d2 | 2039 | 2039 | MATCH
Kiwipete [r3k2r/p1ppqpb1/bn2pnp1/3PN3/1p2P3/2N2Q1p/PPPBBPPP/R3K2R w KQkq - 0 1] | d3 | 97862 | 97862 | MATCH
Kiwipete [r3k2r/p1ppqpb1/bn2pnp1/3PN3/1p2P3/2N2Q1p/PPPBBPPP/R3K2R w KQkq - 0 1] | d4 | 4085603 | 4085603 | MATCH
EnPassant [8/2p5/3p4/KP5r/1R3p1k/8/4P1P1/8 w - - 0 1] | d1 | 14 | 14 | MATCH
EnPassant [8/2p5/3p4/KP5r/1R3p1k/8/4P1P1/8 w - - 0 1] | d2 | 191 | 191 | MATCH
EnPassant [8/2p5/3p4/KP5r/1R3p1k/8/4P1P1/8 w - - 0 1] | d3 | 2812 | 2812 | MATCH
EnPassant [8/2p5/3p4/KP5r/1R3p1k/8/4P1P1/8 w - - 0 1] | d4 | 43238 | 43238 | MATCH
EnPassant [8/2p5/3p4/KP5r/1R3p1k/8/4P1P1/8 w - - 0 1] | d5 | 674624 | 674624 | MATCH
Promotion [n1n5/PPPk4/8/8/8/8/4Kppp/5N1N b - - 0 1] | d1 | 24 | 24 | MATCH
Promotion [n1n5/PPPk4/8/8/8/8/4Kppp/5N1N b - - 0 1] | d2 | 496 | 496 | MATCH
Promotion [n1n5/PPPk4/8/8/8/8/4Kppp/5N1N b - - 0 1] | d3 | 9483 | 9483 | MATCH
Promotion [n1n5/PPPk4/8/8/8/8/4Kppp/5N1N b - - 0 1] | d4 | 182838 | 182838 | MATCH
Promotion [n1n5/PPPk4/8/8/8/8/4Kppp/5N1N b - - 0 1] | d5 | 3605103 | 3605103 | MATCH
ALL MATCH

Persistent-team verification at 022d7359

A fresh owner request in the conductor’s existing conversation registered a new owner assignment and reused the same persistent manager, two engineers and researcher. The manager gave the engineers separate checks; it accepted their evidence before reporting to the conductor. The researcher independently cross-checked the reports and saved records. Progress and completion reports woke the assigning members. No extra owner instruction was sent during execution. The owner accepted the root result through the UI.

Assignment ID Final state
Conductor 262d40fb0953415886cfd82458778bf9 accepted
Engineering-manager 200fd1fe9a1747d1bc749eb58ef8c746 accepted
Engineer-1 fdd0b979abfe4a138b61a1fe19e22685 accepted
Engineer-fc6c9643 9461bea0ed6e4c3082a26be535c00712 accepted
Researcher 06b9b7e332bb4bf38842b779ba32782d accepted

All eleven delegated turns completed, with no failed or interrupted turn. The direct initiating owner chat is separate from the organization run ledger. This run verified the existing engine and saved match; it did not replay the 100 games. A previous verification at f241c57c exercised the manager’s hiring of the second engineer; the new run demonstrates reuse of that member and its continuing conversation.

The new perft report contains 20 passing reference rows, including Initial depth 6 = 119,060,324, Kiwipete depth 4 = 4,085,603, EnPassant depth 5 = 674,624 and Promotion depth 5 = 3,605,103. The engineer ran the existing perft executable from scratch storage so the supplied report remained unchanged. The independent read-only audit confirmed the new report values, unique game IDs 1–100, alternating colors, binary hashes and 74 wins / 7 draws / 19 losses = 77.5 points. All 119 supplied files matched their recorded hashes before and after execution.

New artifact SHA-256
verification-final/perft.txt 98645b47826982164d1e8a4f58a0d39c14a58ca03a1c22b51a1a6d5d77edae48
verification-final/match.json 3b98323e29fe1950046fcafe8d35270e43dcba86b20fa7ae6129d57f1b6c4c46

The published video and screenshots show 022d7359. The video is an edited walkthrough of the completed real run, with captions below the UI; no UI data was altered. Both the source recording and final MP4 passed full decoding. The isolated gateway used real Kiro ACP processes; the exact served model was not independently identified.

@github-actions

github-actions Bot commented Sep 13, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Design Review (Fable 5) — 🟡 CONCERNS

Design-level review of 5007486300ce9587cb3ee217e6bbc7914532c195 — updated in place on each push. A BLOCK verdict blocks PR readiness; PASS/CONCERNS are advisory.

Design-Verdict: CONCERNS

Sound, well-layered prototype under the existing governance ceiling; the residual risks are call-site-remembered role ceilings and public surface shipped ahead of its own RFC.

Watch

  • Role-ceiling installation is remembered at two call sites (acp/client.py:_prepare_work_dir and providers/acp.py — "The provider compiles the role before the unified runtime loses its original session key; direct private AcpClient starts also compile before spawn"). A future private-member spawn path that bypasses both silently runs an org member on the generic member spec — full member tools, no compiled ceiling — and nothing goes red; the tests exercise role_spec and shadow refusal but I found no pin that an org-bound session cannot start without a compiled kirocrew-org-* spec.
    Clears when: a fail-closed chokepoint test (or spawn-time assertion) that a private-memory provider start for an org-bound session refuses unless the compiled role spec is installed.
  • The implementation and its "in-progress public proposal" (docs/request-for-change/rfc-org-chart-and-guardrails.md) land in the same commit, so the org_* tool names, /api/organization-agent, and the Capabilities page (translated into 13 locales) become compatibility surface before the proposal can change the design; if RFC review reshapes roles or the ledger relationship, that surface must be deprecated rather than redesigned. Gating (Kiro backend + private memory + explicit enablement, starts paused) keeps this reversible, hence CONCERNS not BLOCK.
    Clears when: the spec/UI marks the organization API and tool surface experimental with no compat guarantee, or the RFC is accepted.

Suggestions

  • The version-0 "adopt existing prototype records in place" path in organization.py serves only pre-release stores from this PR's own verification runs; consider dropping it at RFC acceptance so the store's compat story starts at user_version = 1.

[DESIGN-REVIEWED] 5007486

@github-actions

github-actions Bot commented Sep 13, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

UX Review (Fable 5) — 🟡 CONCERNS

UX-level review of 5007486300ce9587cb3ee217e6bbc7914532c195 — updated in place on each push. A BLOCK verdict blocks PR readiness; PASS/CONCERNS are advisory.

The blind read reconciles well against the diff — every added control and state is screenshotted (18 shots covering empty, paused, unavailable, review, retire-confirm, mobile, light theme), a walkthrough recording is supplied, and the reader was sure and willing on the whole primary path (create team, tabs, assign, review, save staffing, pause/resume read as one control). No lens-13 hard swap exists in the code. Remaining findings are CONCERNS-level, grounded in the reader's own words.

UX-Verdict: CONCERNS

Core flow is comprehensible and fully evidenced; the embedded chart renders broken, the Unavailable state is jargon with a live Pause button, and “Conductor” names collide.

Watch

  • Squished embedded chart: break-words on member names in OrganizationPage.tsx's tree lets the narrow member-editor pane wrap names one letter per line — shot-13, which the reader called "a display mistake". Every unmanaged-member visit shows it; add a min-width/horizontal scroll for the embedded tree.
  • Unavailable state: "This runtime cannot run guarded members yet" + "requires the Kiro member backend" left the reader "no idea what I'd do about it", while "Pause new work" stays enabled beside "Unavailable" ("pointless to press"). Say it in task words, link to the backend setting, and disable Pause when the runtime is down.
  • Name collision: the org member "Conductor" vs the existing chat member "kirocrew-conductor" — the reader "assumed they were the same until shot 13 said otherwise". Distinguish the default name or badge org members in the chat list.
  • Discard-guard inconsistency: the member editor asks via its styled discard dialog for schedule drafts but native window.confirm (organization.discardChanges in KiroCrewAgentsPage.tsx) for org drafts — two confirm styles for one event in one surface.

Suggestions

  • The bare count on each tree box (fmtNumber(children.length)) is unlabeled — the reader could only guess "how many people report"; add a tooltip/aria label "N direct reports".
  • "Apply & Restart" (header) vs "Save staffing": the reader "could not tell which of my other edits need which" even with the no-restart note; state on the org page that its edits never need Apply & Restart.

[UX-REVIEWED] 5007486

@github-actions github-actions Bot added readiness: action required A blocking check or review needs attention and removed readiness: checking Automated validation is still running labels Sep 13, 2026
@github-actions

github-actions Bot commented Sep 13, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Security Scope Review -- 🟡 CONCERNS

Which legitimate operations does 5007486300ce9587cb3ee217e6bbc7914532c195 newly refuse? Updated in place on each push. A script-confirmed regression blocks; the model proposes candidates and never decides a refusal.

Verdict basis: the reviewer's own judgement; no confirmed regression.

Security scope review -- adjudicated candidates

  • macos-latest (platform posix): 8 classified, 0 newly refused, 8 still allowed.
  • ubuntu-latest (platform posix): 8 classified, 0 newly refused, 8 still allowed.
  • windows-latest (platform windows): 6 classified, 0 newly refused, 6 still allowed.

No candidate flipped from allowed to refused.

Scope-Verdict: CONCERNS

TIGHTENING: The shared read+write path fence (security/paths.py _CREW_SECRET_LEAVES) gains the directory leaf "organizations", expanded under both crew-home prefixes into _SENSITIVE_HOME_DIRS — refusing an agent shell or file tool reading or writing the gateway-owned organization store (~/.kiro/crew/organizations, legacy ~/.kirocrew/organizations), where reporting relationships, role ceilings and caller identities live: "Gateway-owned organization policy, assignments and caller identities. No in-sandbox reader: members use the authenticated organization tools."

ADJUDICATED: 13 candidates, 0 confirmed newly-refused
No confirmed regression rows were handed back for this run; per the mechanism, a regression without a script verdict is not a finding. The 13 candidates probe the new leaf's boundary: parent-directory listings and the documented-routine sibling reads (config.json, sessions.db) in both crew homes, the fenced word appearing as grep content and inside repo-relative paths (src/api/organizations/, test/test_organization*.py, git diff --stat argv), and the sanctioned test invocations aimed at this PR's own test files.

PLATFORM COVERAGE: posix (7 rows), windows (5 rows), any (1 row). The diff's platform assumption is a leaf declared with / separators and matched home-anchored; the windows rows cover the assumptions that matter there — %USERPROFILE%\.kiro\crew with backslash separators under both cmd (dir, type) and PowerShell (Get-ChildItem with $env:USERPROFILE) tokenizers, a backslashed repo-relative organizations path, and the .venv\Scripts\python.exe test lane. The posix rows cover the tilde-anchored spellings, the legacy .kirocrew prefix the expansion also adds, and the token-as-content case. No assumed platform was left without a candidate. Per-leg verdicts are the deterministic fold's to report, after this review is captured.

UNADJUDICATED: Four tightenings live outside the shell tool-call composite, so no verdict was available for them:

  • Sandbox bind-mask (sandbox.py): "organizations" added to _CREW_HIDDEN_LEAVES and _CREW_PRECREATE_HIDDEN_DIR_LEAVES. Call path: every sandboxed spawn builds bind masks over crew-home leaves, so a worker's shell loses the directory at the OS layer independent of the path fence. Candidate inputs I would have submitted: a sandboxed member process resolving its own inbox — by design there is no in-sandbox reader (members use the authenticated @kirocrew-work organization tools), so I can attribute no lost legitimate operation, but nothing could classify that claim.
  • Internal-caller denial on remote slots (dashboard/chat_handlers.py deny_non_owner_remote_operation): previously an X-Internal-Secret loopback caller fell through to deny_non_dashboard_caller, which returns None for internal_auth — the path every MCP call arrives on. The hunk now returns _owner_denial_response(request, "forbidden") for internal callers when slot.is_remote. Call path: POST /api/chat → deny_non_owner_remote_operation(request, slot, "chat_send") (also slot_stop, slot_{control}). Candidate legitimate inputs: a gateway-internal callback (monitor completion, cron follow-up, an MCP tool posting a follow-up turn) targeting a peer-bound slot — allowed at base, refused at head. Whether any shipped internal caller actually addresses a remote slot is exactly what I could not get a verdict for; if one does, the narrow fix is to admit named internal operations that do not spend the tunnel credential rather than refusing the caller class.
  • Backend admission for organization members (organization_policy.require_runtime, wired into providers/acp.py session prep): non-Kiro ACP backends now refuse to spawn an organization member (organization_backend_unsupported), and a project agent spec that shadows the compiled role refuses the spawn (organization_spec_shadowed). Call path: private-memory session start → prepare_agent → member_for_session/require_runtime/agent_spec_matches. Candidate legitimate inputs: an existing non-member private-memory session on any backend (must pass through as member_for_session → None), and a member session on a non-Kiro backend that worked before this PR — none exists, since membership is introduced here.
  • Roster filter (agent_discovery.py): agent specs named kirocrew-org-<32 hex> are skipped by list_agents. Call path: user-agents directory glob → _ORGANIZATION_AGENT_NAME_RE.fullmatch → skip. Candidate legitimate input: a user's own agent spec that happens to match that exact prefix-plus-32-hex shape would silently vanish from the roster; the collision is implausible but nothing adjudicated it.

[SCOPE-REVIEWED] 5007486

@github-actions

github-actions Bot commented Sep 13, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

First Principles Review (Fable 5) — 🟡 CONCERNS

Premise-level review of 5007486300ce9587cb3ee217e6bbc7914532c195 — why this exists and whether the shipped surface is the smallest honest version. Updated in place on each push. A BLOCK verdict blocks PR readiness; PASS/CONCERNS are advisory.

I have what I need. The change inventory is complete: the org feature core, the security/provenance plumbing, and several declared riders. One finding survives the kill-filter: the RFC's own text calls this a "first executable prototype", yet the UI entry ships ungated to everyone while the sibling Crew Members surface sits behind the existing Feature Previews gate. No product-shape trigger fires (everything is additive beside existing capabilities, no default flips, nothing removed), consumer counts on the new surface are healthy, deleted test pins were strengthened rather than dropped, and the RFC records a concrete four-contract reason the existing work ledger cannot host this.

First-Principles-Verdict: CONCERNS

A self-described "first executable prototype" ships as a permanent, ungated ninth Capabilities tab and rail entry — the existing Feature Previews gate was never considered.

Not justified as shipped

  • Item 3 — oversized: the RFC says "this first executable prototype", yet CapabilitiesPage.tsx and surfaces/builtins.tsx add the tab unconditionally, while the sibling Crew Members surface (where org members' conversations live) is behind the Feature Previews gate (developer.crew-members). Users without that preview see an org tab whose member threads surface is hidden.
  • Item 9 — rides along: E2E update-dialog dismissal; declared, doc updated.
  • Item 10 — rides along: i18next vendor chunk + per-test advertised-model isolation; declared, docs updated.

What this change ships

Inventory (10 items) — 7 justified

Intent: let an owner delegate an outcome to a persistent, accountable team of role-limited members from chat — an ADDITION.

  1. Persistent org: members, roles, reporting lines, hiring limits, assignments, review (store + APIs + editor pane) — justified
  2. Eight org_* tools listed to every kirocrew-work caller, dispatch-authenticated — justified
  3. Org tab and rail entry visible to everyone, no preview gate — oversized (prototype surface; sibling surface is preview-gated)
  4. Owner provenance travels with queued/edited/merged chat text; guest messages can't join an owner turn — justified
  5. Internal callers denied the owner's peer credentials on remote member operations — justified
  6. organizations store bind-masked from sandboxes; org responses registered as a redaction sink — justified
  7. Shutdown-refused monitor wakes stop recording session failures and are requeued — justified
  8. Atomic no-replace publication now works on glibc 2.26/2.27 via raw syscall (3 consumer modules at base: member_memory_auth.py, memory_stores.py, spec_builder/backend/repository.py) — justified
  9. E2E disposable gateway waits out the update check and dismisses optional update dialogs — rides along
  10. i18next split into its own vendor chunk; advertised-model cache isolated per test — rides along

More items exist (role agents filtered from the catalog, member-preamble suppression for org sessions, the [Organization work notice] envelope); these ride inside item 1.

Watch

  • Prototype permanence: the tab, two endpoints and eight tools are public surface that cannot be quietly withdrawn if the in-progress RFC changes course; the repo already has a mechanism for exactly this (Feature Previews, used by Crew Members).
    Clears when: the org entry rides an existing preview flag, or the RFC merges non-draft on the base covering an always-visible tab.

Subtractions

  • Defer the unconditional organization entries in CapabilitiesPage.tsx and builtins.tsx CAPABILITY_SUB_ITEMS behind the existing Feature Previews gate the Crew Members surface uses, until the RFC leaves in-progress.

[FIRST-PRINCIPLES-REVIEWED] 5007486

@github-actions

github-actions Bot commented Sep 13, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Opus 4.8 Review — ✅ no blocking findings

Reviewed 5007486300ce9587cb3ee217e6bbc7914532c195 — this comment is updated in place on each push.

Review details

No findings.

[OPUS-REVIEWED] 5007486

Verdict parsed from the review's SHA-scoped output markers for commit 5007486300ce9587cb3ee217e6bbc7914532c195.

False positive or not applicable? A repository writer can comment:
/ai-review override fable 5007486300ce9587cb3ee217e6bbc7914532c195: <one-sentence reason>

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 13, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author
  • Schema-version suggestion (span=56934f5f5168)

Rebutted. This prototype has one fixed schema and no schema-changing upgrade. An unconditional user_version=1 stamp would not provide migration or refusal of a future incompatible schema. Adding a migration framework solely for proposed custom roles would widen this PR; its first schema transition must define migration and compatibility together. The current source does not claim CREATE TABLE IF NOT EXISTS performs migrations.

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 13, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author
  • Idle polling tradeoff (span=5ddc4146e714)

Rebutted. The 0.5-second interval deliberately bounds dispatch delay when external messages arrive, including after an idle period. claim_run runs off the event loop, and an empty or paused claim does not change database bytes. A local 100-call empty/paused observation measured median 0.404ms and max 0.630ms; it is not a load benchmark and the reserved writer lock remains. No observed contention failure warrants a second wake/notification mechanism or longer dispatch latency in this prototype.

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 13, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author
  • SDK boundary comparison helper (span=213a3cdd946d)

Rebutted. organization_policy.py is application code. scripts/check_agent_sdk_boundary.py forbids new imports from kiro_crew.acp and kiro_crew.providers outside their existing boundary trees and offers no opt-out. Calling agent_spec_snapshot directly there would violate that gate. agent_spec_matches keeps backend resolution inside the allowed agent_sdk driver and returns only a Boolean. acp/client.py is itself inside the exempt ACP tree, so its direct import is not a precedent for the consumer.

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 13, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Updated video and screenshots for the persistent-team feature. Integration with the newer base is still being validated; these artifacts document the revision and real run identified below.

The UI was captured at 040a56b4423e9d74532d604a30ed8be6a257d214 from the isolated gateway. It displays the saved real verification at 022d7359, which used Kiro ACP and private-memory OS isolation. The exact served model was not independently identified. This is a 28-second edited walkthrough of that completed run; it does not rerun the chess build or match. Video captions sit below the unchanged UI viewport. The 390-pixel layout had no horizontal overflow.

org-chart-guardrails-demo.mp4

Persistent reporting relationships:

Conductor, engineering manager, two engineers and researcher

Fixed role limits:

Fixed role limits for managers and specialists

The manager's conversation, assignments and activity:

Manager conversation with member assignments and activity

Staffing, member properties, review, owner chat and responsive layouts

Team staffing and simultaneous work limits

Team controls and save scope in the member editor

Saved assignments and accepted reports

Conductor returns the reviewed chess evidence

Org chart in the light theme

Org chart at a 390 px viewport

Live team controls and clearly labelled UI illustrations

The following three screenshots use the real idle team. Its execution setting was restored; retirement was cancelled and the manager selection was unchanged.

Live idle team paused temporarily, with its execution setting restored

Live named retirement confirmation, cancelled without retiring a member

Live manager choices, closed without changing the selection

The following four screenshots are UI illustrations using simulated API responses, labelled in each image. They show pending review, an empty team, interrupted work and a runtime refusal. They are not failures observed in the chess run, and no tasks, runs, members or messages were changed.

Simulated pending review with a required decision field; no assignment changed

Simulated empty organization; no member removed

Simulated interrupted work and retry control; no run changed

Simulated runtime refusal shown through the error surface; no policy changed

@Zedmor
Zedmor force-pushed the feat/org-chart-guardrails branch from 5c27f8a to e568a66 Compare September 14, 2026 04:26
@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 14, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author
  • span=3d6efd9bda08

Fixed in e568a6621cbb0a8afa654603eeb76436313f9be1. Behavioral tests cover direct AcpClient preparation and the unified-provider path before caller identity changes. Each asserts the compiled role and rejection of unsafe resolution. The SDK comparison itself remains inside prepare_agent, not a separate turn-admission assertion.

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 14, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author
  • span=255a1000b3e6

Fixed in e568a6621cbb0a8afa654603eeb76436313f9be1. Organization controls use work/activity wording instead of turn jargon, including pause, concurrency, retry and member activity labels; translations are updated through the catalog.

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 14, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author
  • span=e8d21653e34a

Fixed in e568a6621cbb0a8afa654603eeb76436313f9be1. The member editor explicitly identifies team-wide organization controls while retaining the selected member focus.

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 14, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author
  • span=ebd58d884b84

Fixed in e568a6621cbb0a8afa654603eeb76436313f9be1. Organization copy distinguishes staffing saves and immediate team actions from the surrounding agent-properties save; it does not change the global configuration apply/restart behavior.

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 14, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author
  • span=c60787414da2

Fixed in e568a6621cbb0a8afa654603eeb76436313f9be1. The Add a direct report header no longer displays the existing report count, removing the misleading capacity interpretation.

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 14, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author
  • span=1d091f133cd0

Fixed in e568a6621cbb0a8afa654603eeb76436313f9be1. A visible required Review decision label is associated with the textarea; the acceptance prerequisite is visible before pressing Accept.

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 14, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author
  • span=2b16a5bd406d

Fixed in e568a6621cbb0a8afa654603eeb76436313f9be1. Retirement requires a named confirmation using the shared dialog. Cancellation leaves the member active; confirmed retirement preserves memory/history without promising an undo.

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 14, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author
  • span=106081c139a3

Fixed in e568a6621cbb0a8afa654603eeb76436313f9be1. The proposal now compares four enforced contracts: one dispatch per child session ever, created_by ownership, a single implicitly addressed worker item, and reports without automatic prompt delivery. Persistent members need reusable conversations, relationship-based authority, explicit assignment selection, and atomic assignment/report plus wake state. Reusing the current ledger API would require changing all four; mirroring assignments across stores creates two authorities. Existing work_* semantics remain intact.

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 14, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author
  • span=25852a1d36bd

Fixed in e568a6621cbb0a8afa654603eeb76436313f9be1. The RFC maps the overlapping concepts to the actual work_* contracts. org_inbox/report address several authorized member assignments; org_assign/review use reporting relationships and owner authority; org_retry operates on durable run claims. Those operations cannot be aliases for the one-dispatch child-session API. They share the existing kirocrew-work MCP server and strict caller resolver.

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 14, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author
  • span=9beba8a2f857

Fixed in e568a6621cbb0a8afa654603eeb76436313f9be1. The checked-in run_organization_preview.py is removed. Reproduction instructions use the existing kirocrew pod provisioning, isolated home and token commands.

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 14, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author
  • span=7dbb4269b528

Fixed in e568a6621cbb0a8afa654603eeb76436313f9be1. The validation host is x86_64 Amazon Linux 2, glibc 2.26, without a libc renameat2 export. The published real-member verification at 022d7359 retained five canonical private conversations and completed eleven delegated turns. procps-ng 3.3.10 reproduces the combined-format defect: -o pid=,ppid= returns only PID under a custom ,ppid= header; separate -o pid= -o ppid= returns both columns. The owning platform spec names the versions and the binding/process-identity use; the fallback remains atomic and fails closed on unmapped hosts.

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 14, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author
  • span=4e636c4e0af5

Fixed in 5007486. Only the Task Input now uses block w-full, placing it below its visible label and filling the form column. The shared Input and global layout remain unchanged.
Evidence: website/src/pages/OrganizationPage.tsx:289

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 14, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author
  • span=b03265f86b7b

Rebutted. The cited sibling comma-format commands are not reached on Linux: orphan discovery returns its /proc result; RSS accounting returns from its Linux descendant path before _ps_process_table. The changed platform_compat parent-map helper does execute ps on that host and needs separate column arguments. This is a process-tree cleanup repair; the separate renameat2 fallback supports private-store publication. No Linux reproduction established a sibling defect.
Evidence: src/kiro_crew/session_pid.py:1421; src/kiro_crew/session_pid.py:1457; src/kiro_crew/acp/runtime.py:638; src/kiro_crew/platform_compat.py:2273

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 14, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author
  • span=7e0b407823a4

Rebutted. Permissions have a real model-facing consumer through snapshot -> authenticated member GET -> org_inbox, which the compiled prompt requires. They summarize capabilities; role_spec enforces tools. The events table deliberately commits actor/action/target/time audit records with each mutation, even though no application reader ships. The owning spec now explicitly distinguishes both purposes. Deleting either solely for lacking a website reader would remove intended behavior.
Evidence: src/kiro_crew/organization.py:275; src/kiro_crew/dashboard/handlers/organization.py:50; src/kiro_crew/organization_tools.py:157; src/kiro_crew/organization_policy.py:94; docs/system-specs/modules/crew-mode.md:45; docs/system-specs/modules/crew-mode.md:139

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 14, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author
  • span=6b61651f1f73

Rebutted. Neither cited ps sibling executes on the reported Linux platform: both take their /proc branch before the comma-format reader. The procps-ng reproduction applies to the shared POSIX parent-map helper that was repaired. There is no demonstrated sibling regression to fix or defer, so no speculative issue or unrelated command rewrite is proposed.
Evidence: src/kiro_crew/session_pid.py:1421; src/kiro_crew/session_pid.py:1457; src/kiro_crew/acp/runtime.py:638

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 14, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author
  • span=f9b5e2c6b5f7

Rebutted. ROLE_PERMISSIONS reaches the member model through snapshot, the authenticated member endpoint and org_inbox; the compiled role prompt requires reading that inbox. Its role is descriptive context, independent of the enforced tool list. The owning spec makes this explicit. No website read is required for this consumer.
Evidence: src/kiro_crew/organization.py:275; src/kiro_crew/dashboard/handlers/organization.py:50; src/kiro_crew/organization_tools.py:157; src/kiro_crew/organization_policy.py:94; docs/system-specs/modules/crew-mode.md:139

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 14, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author
  • span=a44bed329d7e

Rebutted. The events table is retained transactional audit evidence: actor, action, target and time are stored with the state mutation. The owning spec now explicitly says no application reader consumes it today. Removing the journal would discard audit evidence; adding a speculative UI reader is also unnecessary.
Evidence: src/kiro_crew/organization.py:148; src/kiro_crew/organization.py:169; docs/system-specs/modules/crew-mode.md:45

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 14, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author
  • span=e37d88c74d05

Fixed in 5007486. Organization GET and POST error payloads now receive Error: before the same redacted JSON, preserving code, field and structured details. Successful payloads remain JSON. The regression exercises real mcp_work -> shared audit wrapper -> organization dispatch and asserts failed for refusals and completed for success, including redaction.
Evidence: src/kiro_crew/organization_tools.py:157; test/test_organization_tools.py:542; test/test_organization_tools.py:590; docs/architecture/mcp.md:34

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 14, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

security-scope review acknowledgement — judged e568a6621cbb0a8afa654603eeb76436313f9be1

Acknowledged. This judged-head review reports zero confirmed newly refused shell-composite candidates. The organizations leaf is the intended authority boundary; that classifier does not prove live OS masking. Non-members return before organization role compilation, coordinators retain fs_read/grep/glob, and an unaccepted wake refused during restart returns to queued work. These are source contracts, not a claim of a new live sandbox run.
Evidence: src/kiro_crew/security/paths.py:363; src/kiro_crew/organization_policy.py:22; src/kiro_crew/organization_policy.py:127; src/kiro_crew/organization_runtime.py:207

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 14, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

opus review acknowledgement — judged e568a6621cbb0a8afa654603eeb76436313f9be1

Acknowledged the no-findings review of the judged e568 commit. Its context candidate was falsified by the preceding private-member memory guard and the outer exception handler. This acknowledges the historical review; it does not claim an Opus review of 5007486.
Evidence: src/kiro_crew/dashboard/chat_runner.py:7515; src/kiro_crew/dashboard/chat_runner.py:13364

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 14, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

UX evidence gap: non-organization member editor

Added current-source evidence for the existing non-organization member pane in 5007486; the capture is identified separately from the managed-member screenshots. Evidence. Live controls over the saved team; work unchanged and temporary pause restored.

@Zedmor

Zedmor commented Sep 14, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

UX evidence gap: sent-message history

Added a clearly labelled simulated sent-message history illustration for 5007486. It demonstrates the card presentation and is not evidence that a new live message was delivered. Evidence. Simulated API response; no work, message or member mutation.

@Zedmor
Zedmor force-pushed the feat/org-chart-guardrails branch from e568a66 to 5007486 Compare September 14, 2026 07:31
@github-actions github-actions Bot added readiness: checking Automated validation is still running readiness: action required A blocking check or review needs attention and removed readiness: action required A blocking check or review needs attention readiness: checking Automated validation is still running labels Sep 14, 2026

@CrysisDeu CrysisDeu left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

this is a demonstration, we don't plan to merge it today

@github-actions github-actions Bot added the merge conflict Branch has merge conflicts with its base — author must resolve before merge label Sep 14, 2026
@NicholasRBowers NicholasRBowers added needs-pr-triage PR scanner: awaiting automated triage needs-author-decision PR blocked on author input and removed needs-pr-triage PR scanner: awaiting automated triage labels Sep 17, 2026
@NicholasRBowers

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

🤖 Kiro Crew [operator: NicholasRBowers#a942f9ca]: Automated triage reached this PR. It is out of scope for automated drive-to-green and I am taking no action on it — recording why, plus the diagnosis, so the next pass doesn't re-litigate it:

  • A maintainer already ruled. @CrysisDeu requested changes on 2026-09-14 with "this is a demonstration, we don't plan to merge it today." That settles it ahead of everything below; nothing automated should be pushing this toward merge.
  • Scope exceeds the automation threshold. +7650/-87 across 94 files introducing a genuinely new subsystem — six new backend modules (organization.py, organization_service.py, organization_runtime.py, organization_policy.py, organization_tools.py, dashboard/handlers/organization.py), a new persistent SQLite store, new /api/organization* routes, eight org_* MCP tools and a new Capabilities page. About 2,700 lines of new hand-written production code, so this is not wide-but-shallow padding.

Decisions that are yours, not mechanical:

  • The upheld security block. GPT blocks at src/kiro_crew/dashboard/chat_runner.py:7818 and Opus upheld it: the owner grant slot._organization_owner_request is keyed only to (session_key, uuid) and owner_chat_request authorizes org_start_task while the turn is merely running, so a non-owner steer landing mid-turn inherits the live owner's grant and a guest instruction becomes an owner assignment. GPT's remedy is to queue non-owner steers as separate turns whenever the running turn holds an owner grant. That is a change to how provenance is bound, in the subsystem's core seam — a design decision.
  • Shipping ahead of your own RFC. Design, First Principles and UX all raise CONCERNS on the same theme: the implementation and its in-progress proposal (docs/request-for-change/rfc-org-chart-and-guardrails.md) land in one commit, so org_* tool names, /api/organization-agent and a 13-locale-translated page become compatibility surface before the proposal can change the design. First Principles adds that a self-described "first executable prototype" ships as a permanent ungated ninth Capabilities tab while the sibling Crew Members surface sits behind developer.crew-members — the Feature Previews gate was never considered.

Diagnosis on the CI reds, which are not what is blocking this:

  • Every backend shard, E2E, Coverage Combine and SAST was cancelled, not failed. Run 34818270419 has conclusion cancelled; all of those jobs end at 07:51:42-50Z with ##[error]The operation was canceled. Both shard logs I read were mid-pytest with only passing dots and skips and zero FAILED/ERROR lines about 20 minutes in. Coverage Gate then failed closed on the derived reason (backend-test=cancelled -- failing closed). There is no collection error, no import error and no failing test node id, so the real backend status is simply unknown until a rerun. Every job that was allowed to finish passed.
  • The branch is 322 commits behind main and conflicts in 18 files, including chat_runner.py and chat_handlers.py — the same files the security fix would touch, so a rebase and that fix overlap rather than being independent.

When you've addressed these, the pipeline will re-assess on its next cycle.

@bolichen97

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Maintainer note: PR #11780 (merged 2026-09-19, bc0d2b0cf, "simplify member memory to one SQLite store") removed the protected-binding / private-execution member memory model. Two PRs written against the old model merged after it with a textually clean merge and broke main at import time (#11947, #11960); both are now reverted. This PR carries the same hazard.

Already conflicting; when rebasing please also drop the dead references, otherwise the rebased PR fails at import: organization_policy.py:28,31 require_private_memory_execution; organization_service.py:81,132 retire_unpublished_member_memory_store; test_organization_runtime.py:14,45 patch_private_memory_supported; test_organization_tools.py:322 provider.prepare_private_memory().

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Open-PR triage (2026-10-05). Checked against origin/main @ a97659dfc3. Nothing in this comment repeats a blocker as new; it records where the existing ones stand today.

Classification: DISTINCT. main has no organization store, no org_* tools and no /api/organization* routes. The six new modules (organization*.py, dashboard/handlers/organization.py) and OrganizationPage.tsx are all absent from main, and no merged PR covers them. Recommendation: REBASE / CONTINUE-DEVELOPMENT. Not a closure candidate.

Still blocking at head 50074863:

  • The owner-grant steer escalation that GPT raised and Opus upheld is still unfixed. chat_runner.py:7818 sets slot._organization_owner_request = (session_key, uuid). organization_service.owner_chat_request (lines 12-29) accepts that grant whenever the slot is running on the same session key, and nothing binds it to whoever sent a mid-turn steer.
  • @CrysisDeu's CHANGES_REQUESTED ("demonstration, not planned to merge") still stands.

Rebase status: 2,823 commits behind main; mergeable_state is dirty. I confirmed @bolichen97's import-time hazard on current main. member_memory_auth.require_private_memory_execution and retire_unpublished_member_memory_store no longer exist there; they were removed by #11780 (PR, merged as bc0d2b0cf). The PR imports them at organization_policy.py:28,31, organization_service.py:81,132 and context.py:243. The same pattern broke main through #11947 and #11960 (both PRs, both reverted). A rebase that resolves cleanly as text will still fail when the module is imported.

Behaviour tightening to note for the Reader: list: deny_non_owner_remote_operation now refuses every internal_auth caller on a remote slot, for chat_send, slot_stop and slot controls. On main those callbacks fall through to deny_non_dashboard_caller. Per take-away-changes, this needs a named reader before it lands.

Merge discussion: this PR overlaps with #10175 (PR, same author, member task snapshot panel). Both add registrations in mcp_work.py, sandbox.py hidden leaves, security/paths.py, security_posture.py, context.py, dashboard/server.py and MembersPage.tsx. The goals are different and could complement each other. Agree which one lands first, so the second rebases onto the first one's sandbox and MCP registration shape.

@bolichen97 bolichen97 mentioned this pull request Oct 5, 2026
5 of 6 tasks
@Zedmor Zedmor closed this Oct 31, 2026
@github-actions github-actions Bot removed the readiness: action required A blocking check or review needs attention label Oct 31, 2026
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

merge conflict Branch has merge conflicts with its base — author must resolve before merge needs-author-decision PR blocked on author input

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

4 participants