Repository navigation
docs(rfc): re-audit 102 RFC statuses against main - #39909
Conversation
First Principles Review (Opus 5.5) — ⏭️ skippedRevision |
UX Review (Opus 5.5) — ⏭️ skippedRevision |
Design Review (Opus 5.5) — ✅ PASSDesign-level review of Design-Verdict: PASS Nothing blocks: the diff only changes RFC status metadata, and a later audit can undo any wrong status. Notes
[DESIGN-REVIEWED] 62eeda1 Description read[DESCRIPTION-READ] ccac10b496dc1e6dc87e3a1710a173bd64a4691d61f8beeb6931f9bfe05f64a7 That sha256 names everything this verdict read: the PR description, plus the 1 evidence file(s) the workflow collected from it and handed this review. It covers that evidence because the media strip replaces every attachment URL with the same placeholder, so an edit swapping one attachment for another would leave the description's captured text identical while what this review judged changed. Recompute it with |
Opus 5.5 Review — ✅ no blocking findingsReviewed Review detailsNo findings. Notes:
[OPUS-REVIEWED] 62eeda1 Verdict parsed from the review's SHA-scoped output markers for commit False positive or not applicable? A repository writer can comment: |
GPT 6.1 Review — ✅ no blocking findingsGPT 6.1 completed its review of This comment is updated in place on each push. Review detailsNo findings. False positive or not applicable? A repository writer can comment: |
Problem / Motivation
Goal: Make the status of 102 RFCs that were last audited before 2026-11-19 match the code on main.
These RFCs carried a
status,implementation-prsor Index row that was last checked weeks ago. Some saydraftoracceptedfor work that has shipped, orin-progressfor work that is finished.Why it matters
The First Principles review reads RFC status from the base branch as the product decision record. A wrong status lets a change through, or blocks one, on a false premise.
Not a goal
- Status:line and the Index row change.acceptedwithout a recorded maintainer decision; RFCs with code on main but no acceptance staydraft.docs/request-for-change/. User docs are in docs: sync user docs with main #39884.What changed (motivation → approach → change)
For each RFC: its named deliverables were grepped for definition and callers on main, and every PR it names was read live with
gh.last-auditedis 2026-11-20 on all 102.Per-RFC table (old status, new status, evidence)
Worktree
wip/r1b-rfc. Batches 1-4 audited againstc157748343; after the rebase onto origin/main (steering), batches 5-7 againstcdb601611f../scripts/docs-lint.shexited 0 before every commit.Status changed: 11. Status kept, but the status line or Index row fixed because its facts were wrong: 7. Audit fields only: 84.
Status changes
draft(see batch 2)acceptedimplementeddashboard/mate_user_actions.pyqueued bymate_thread_wakes.pyacceptedpartialcli_chat_headless.pyandeval/tasks.pywired incli.py(#37768, #38187, #39317); harvest/admit/report not builtdraftimplementedcanvasinartifact_store/rules.pyacceptedimplementedgate.py_IDLE_LEDGER_QUIET_FLOOR = _MAX_QUIET_STREAK, plan reviewer/scout/budget ingoal-conductor/SKILL.mdin-progressimplementedresolve_parent_policy+_founding_sessioninsubagent_manager/turn_session.py); main also auto-approves when both chats have Trustacceptedpartialdraftimplementeddashboard/card_send.pybehinddashboard_card_send(default off); #22379 CLOSEDacceptedpartialimpact/nestedinErrorNotice.tsx); Phase 1b call sites open under #37262acceptedpartialsession.worker_context_capread bychat_turn/context_cap.py; worker seed §5.3 and §5.5 not builtin-progressimplementedWorkflowDefinitionLibrary.removetombstone +DELETE /api/workflows/definitions/{workflow_ref}Status kept, status line or Index row corrected
draftdraftacp_failover.pycalled inmessaging_api/spawn.py, #26123); no acceptance recorded; status line correcteddraftdrafttemp_reclaim.py,kirocrew tmp reclaim, #32853 merged 2026-11-12); notmp_reclaimtool; no acceptance recorded; index row correcteddraftdraftwork_ledger.remote_dispatchpreview (remote_dispatch.py,remote_batch_pull.py); no acceptance recorded; status line and row correctedpartialpartialdashboard/routes/local_authorization.py); no/v1route accepts its token; row and status line updateddraftdraftdraftdraftpower_source()+power.on_batteryread byknowledge/watcher.py(#21763) on main; not accepted; status line and row correcteddraftdraftcrew_log/fold_delta.py); change-mark base not built; no acceptance recorded; status line, row and implementation-prs correctedrfc-crew-api.mdandrfc-crew-projects.mdhad stale facts only (a newly merged PR and a closed one). The other five aredraftRFCs with code on main but no maintainer acceptance on record. Following the directory's convention (see therfc-central-governance-ceilingandrfc-browser-live-harnessrows), they staydraftso the First Principles lane does not read them as decided. A maintainer should rule on each one.Audit fields only (status unchanged)
partialpartialmilestones.py, #26512/#26488); nomilestones_daily_nudgetask yetsupersededsupersededpartialpartialagent_plugins/on main (#33621); #28461 and #28686 still OPENpartialpartialchat_tagdirective on main (#7779, #12983); #7774 items openpartialpartialon_agent_turnon main; no "started by the agent" label in website/srcpartialpartialAgentIdentityProviderinplatform/interfaces.py; no AWS adapterdraftdraftagentRoutes/app_requestin src; #17015 OPENacceptedacceptedapps/app_agent_tools.pystill first-party only; #32727 OPENdraftdraft_adoption_provenance; #13650 CLOSED unmergeddraftdraftapps/app_frame.py,messageActions,composerActions#27718); no acceptance recordedpartialpartialdashboard/token_auth_app_scope.py; no process isolationdraftdraftctx.browser;api_browser_oponly doordraftdraftapps/manifest_contributes.py; nothing builtpartialpartialapps/job_sdk.pywired; nouseAppJobin website/srcimplementedimplementedwebsite/src/hooks/useSessionControls.ts(#7573)partialpartialcrew_log/on by default; legacy stores remainpartialpartialapps/official_catalog.py; signature verification absent; §4 divergedimplementedimplementeddashboard/arrival_folders.py, imported bysession_transfer.pydraftdraftbrowser_harness/, #26950) but no acceptance recordeddraftdraftpartialpartialmessaging/cards/Phase 1 (#35974); Phase 2 not builtpartialpartialChannelDescriptor; no manifest-loaded channelsdraftdraftsession_set_backendor slot backend routepartialpartialchat-core/transport/sendTurn.tson main; P5 not completedraftdraftdashboard/file_api/uploads.pystill does no text extractiondraftdraftdashboard/chat_rewind.pystill re-runs; no truncate-only rewinddraftdraftMarkdownPanel.tsx's editorpartialpartialwebsite/src/components/crew/layout/PRs 1 and 2a onlydraftdraftreadinesson the slots frameimplementedimplementedagent_parts/spec_prompts.py(#18608)draftdraftcloseConfirmPrompt.tshas no open-workers ask; #32788 CLOSEDimplementedimplementedautonudge_authz.admits_member_default_patrol,ensure_patrolon binddraftdraftgoal-conductor/SKILL.mdhas no evidence-file verifierdraftdraftforbidden_parentfence still skipped forrequest_app == ""supersededsupersededdraftdraftsession_cleanup._idle_exempt_keysunchanged; no patrol sessionwithdrawnwithdrawnprobes/work_ledger.pyreads no PR statesupersededsupersededimplementedimplementedreset_conversationin_CONDUCTOR_CORE_GRANTS(agent_parts/spec_grants.py, #18113)implementedimplementedMcpRedirectinwebsite/src/shell/routes.tsx(#34353, #36241)draftdraftsession-trustleaf insandbox_leaves.py; #15894 OPENpartialpartialagent_sdk/+scripts/check_agent_sdk_boundary.py; cleanup remainsdraftdraftpartialpartialedition.py,lts_gate.pyon main; remaining phases opendraftdraftconnections/crew_oauth.pydraftdrafton_grantedhook indashboard/handlers/connections.pyimplementedimplementedcrewFirstinwebsite/src/pages/chat/SidePanel.tsx(#25936)partialpartialdashboard_upkeep.py(#19069); rollout step 3 not builtpartialpartialdashboard_templates/on main; remaining phases openimplementedimplementedmember_goals.py,dashboard/goal_reminder.py(#19539, #22962)acceptedacceptedMembersPage.tsx; no message-form greeting builtacceptedacceptedmateGreeting.tsdeleted by #23829; warm brief now from rfc-delayed-task-brief.md (kept; needs owner ruling on superseded)implementedimplementedmcp_guide.py(#18301), first crewmate (#18317)partialpartialinherited_reason, Phase 1/3/7 openimplementedimplementeddashboard/goal_reminder.py(#21172)implementedimplementeddashboard_templates/page_look.py(#22533)implementedimplementeddashboard/crewmate_approval.py(#17836)draftdraftcrew_log/partialpartialmate_rootstamps, Sessions tab on main (#26952, #28931, #30220)acceptedacceptedimplementedimplementedagent.deny_overrideinconfig/sections_agent.py(#27574, #33626)implementedimplementedwebsite/src/pages/settings/developerSubs.ts(#24810)implementedimplementeditem_cap/MAX_GOAL_ITEM_CAPinwork_ledger_records.py(#33601)partialpartialdraftdraftdevicePosture/viewport-segmentin website/srcdraftdraftfolderConductor.tsbrowser guessimplementedimplementedwebsite/src/pages/chat/followupStartSends.ts(#25926)draftdraftdraftdraftpartialpartialimplementedimplementedkirocrew-prepare-pr/scripts/resolve_profile.py(#662)acceptedacceptednative/kc_nativeis #19628's redaction gate, not this RFC's stubdraftdraftagent_scratch._quarantinestill moves whole treedraftdraftimplementedimplemented_ask_question_blockinginmcp_tools/control.py(#13196, #15250)implementedimplementedmemory.recall_pool_processesinconfig/memory_sections.py(#26868)partialpartialimplementedimplemented_refuse_if_host_criticalinwork_ledger_writes.py(#36481, #37164)partialpartialwake_atonwork_report(#33477); nowait_duewake builtpartialpartialgoal-conductor/references/worker-debate.md(#33783); Phase 2 not rundraftdraftto/reply_to/message_idinmcp_work.pyimplementedimplementedworker_session_defaultsinconfig/sections_agent_fields.py(#19368)partialpartialconfig/sections_session.py; Phase 3 reversed; Phase 4 unstarteddraftdraftNotes
rfc-canvas-artifact-kind.md->implementedrests on dodgeblaster's/ai-review override first-principlesowner decision on feat: add a static canvas artifact kind #35618, not on an acceptance line in the document.rfc-dashboard-card-send.md->implementedrests on bolichen97's approving review of feat(dashboard): one-click send for Dashboard cards, behind an off-by-default preview #33203, which signed the direction. Its section 7 still reads "Not yet accepted"; that is body text, so it was left alone.rfc-conversation-trust-follows-founder.md: main (fix: tighten tool approval for continued runs #30632) is one step looser than the text. A continuation is still auto-approved when both chats have Trust on.rfc-crewmate-greeting.mdstaysaccepted, but feat(crew): remove the cold Recap greeting; the warm brief is the only return greeting #23829 deleted its hook. A maintainer may wantsuperseded(by rfc-delayed-task-brief.md).rfc-conductor-plan-review-hourly-check.md: the section 10 addendum's rule 4 on main is broader than the addendum says.audited-at: c157748343, the base before the rebase. They were not re-stamped withcdb601611f.gh.Backwards compatibility
Compatible: documentation only; no code, config or API changes.
Removes nothing: only doc wording changes; no file, key or function is removed.
Tests
Proof: not provable -- docs or config only
./scripts/docs-lint.shexits 0.Manual verification
Each status was checked against the symbols and PRs named in the table above.
Real-machine verification
N/A -- docs only: the diff changes Markdown front matter and index rows and runs nothing.
Related Issues
Follows #39879 and #39880. Open questions for a maintainer:
rfc-crewmate-greeting(hook deleted, maybesuperseded) and fivedraftRFCs with code on main.Checklist
feat|fix|docs|style|refactor|perf|test|chore|ci|build|revert: ...); PR Hygiene does not count commitsContribution License Agreement
Contributions are accepted under the project's Apache-2.0 license; see the Licensing section of CONTRIBUTING.md.