Skip to content

docs(operations): clarify DSH transport and live continuation acceptance - #6453

Merged
huangruiteng merged 2 commits into
mainfrom
codex/operation-transport-remediation-20261015
Oct 15, 2026
Merged

huangruiteng merged 2 commits into
mainfrom
codex/operation-transport-remediation-20261015

Conversation

@loopx-agent

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

The operation RFC still said authenticated callbacks never launch a host, despite the separately qualified, default-off Codex delegation slice. It also left the DSH adapter requirement implicit, allowing model/runtime availability to be confused with native operation-tool support.

Update both language mirrors to distinguish existing synthetic continuation evidence from genuine confirmation and source-return acceptance. Document the current typed owner’s Codex-only transport, the unsupported-host remediation gap, and the DSH native identity/connection acceptance frontier.

Validation: reproduced ordinary DSH availability versus operation-host refusal against the installed runtime without a model or network request; 11 existing operation-transport tests passed; both source links resolve; diff check and scoped public-boundary scan passed. This PR changes documentation only. DSH operation tools, genuine confirmation, venue execution, and original-audience delivery remain unqualified; runtime remediation and adapter implementation remain separate Core work.

Signed-off-by: LoopX Agent <337587101+loopx-agent@users.noreply.github.com>

@loopx-agent loopx-agent left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Reviewer: model_agent; gpt-6.1-sol; OpenAI; runtime_reported; reasoning_effort=xhigh

Approval conclusion (author-owned PR; GitHub blocks formal self-approval)

Reviewed head: f5d052059bdc7f891b58ad1820ab36e57353aff0。

动机

配置受管执行器的维护者,需要知道模型可运行之后,确认操作还缺哪些运输和返回验收。 旧章节仍称回调不会启动宿主,且容易把模型回复、工具结果或卡片恢复当成真实续接和源会话送达;现在区分已实现的默认关闭启动请求与尚未完成的真实调用验收。 中英文说明与当前 typed transport 和绑定 owner 对齐,明确 DSH 的宿主运输尚不支持,以及原卡恢复和原受众返回需要各自读回。 本次交付文档澄清,不新增 DSH 操作 adapter、真实确认、模型调用、自动投递或金融执行权限。

改动思路

在原 RFC 同一节修正已过时的绝对否定,并并列保留真实续接与源返回的验收;DSH 继续复用现有 typed transport、Turn binding 和 canonical operation owner,不另设执行或身份权威。 默认关闭的 operator launch grant 只允许请求原受管 Codex 宿主;它不是新的领域操作授权。确认、原生连接身份、首次消费和结果返回各由现有 owner 承担,不能通过多开放 shell、复用源线程字符串或读完 Inbox 跳过。这个有界文档改动纠正当前认知即可,不要求同时实现整条 DSH 产品路径,也不将待验收能力称为已交付。

具体改动

英文 RFC和中文镜像共+82/-10,仅修改既有第13节。旧的“回调不会启动宿主”绝对描述,改为:显式 grant 下已能请求原 managed Codex;File/SQLite 合成证据尚不证明真实确认、本机 native acceptance 或金融执行。无 grant 仍只登记 claim/投影 handoff。原四行验收表继续保留启动、重启、源返回及原消费者验收,60秒明确为首轮目标而非实测保证。

关键内容讲解

Automatic continuation and original-audience return: qualification frontier 区分 report 在工具连接上的返回、Lark 原卡恢复及选定源会话投递;outcome_observed 已退出待办 Inbox,因此空 Inbox 无法证明送达。真正 host-start 需要原生 provider accepted Turn 与匹配连接元数据,不能用进程创建、本地时间或稍后 heartbeat 充数。

DSH model availability and operation transport are separate 对照现有 projectManagedOperationTransport:69:只接受 codex-cli,DSH 仍返回 operation_transport_host_unsupported。host_binding.py:_with_operation_transport 当前确实给 generic correct_execution_profile;更换受支持模型或再配同一凭据不会实现缺失运输。新文明确这是 typed owner 的待修复前沿,并保持选定宿主、不静默 fallback。turn_host_adapter.py:build_sdk_config 只接 SDK 模型配置,没有安装原生 loopx_operation 身份连接,SDK内置工具和 unrestricted 权限均不是替代品。

固定变更前 f43732cd7deaefe574d39b8449e9d5fc2ee41543 的同一 docs/architecture/rfcs/human-confirmed-domain-operations-v0.md:Problem and invariants 与 Qualification and remaining delivery 两个 criterion 在本次文档边界均 implemented,保留真实人类确认、一次消费和分别读回义务;DSH adapter、本机接续和真实受众投递继续 deferred 于既有 implementation owner。原规格读过后才与新文对照,没有用新写的前沿文字反证自己已完成。中英文逐项对齐:默认关闭、身份、profile漂移/撤销、重复/丢响应、先非金融验收和两类返回均保留。

对主干的风险

最强反例是合成 runtime 探针、模型响应或工具 report 通过,就把原消费者标成完成。现有16项 TS 测试全部通过,覆盖 callback launch fence、原生 start、绑定漂移/过期、公有调用者伪造拒绝、首次规范消费和历史核对;43项 Python binding 测试通过,其中8种 effort 的 opt-in 和3种不支持宿主用例验证配置/运输区别。单元中的 runtime存在性使用替身,不能认证真实安装。

独立使用当前源码的实际 binding、合成凭据字符串且不发网络/模型请求:当前解释器实际没有 DSH 模块,关闭操作工具时 runtime_unavailable,开启则 host_unsupported,仍保留 dsh 宿主;Codex 合法配置为 configuration_valid=true,但 runtime_qualified=false。本轮诚实保留 DSH 缺库事实,不把 synthetic credential 或 mock import 当成账号/宿主可用证明。三个相关 production owner 在原base、head与最新main873的blob完全相同;本 PR 无 runtime、自动加载指令、配置默认值或义务执行变化。

原生 premerge:3项直接检查和11项选中并执行检查全过,0失败/skip/timeout/manualhold;两份公开文档边界扫描干净。advisory先于全语义检查,空结果不声称证明语义等价。未查询、轮询、等待或启动 hosted CI。没有新增前台、Lark、CLI流程,没有真实模型、本机安装、真实确认或受众投递验收;这些明确仍缺,Finance只读checker也不授订单权限。相邻 #6459/#6466 是未合并提案,不被本文冒称为已安装的 operation transport。

我的整体评价

APPROVE,文档澄清的 goal_achieved;long_horizon 与 user_experience improved 在于减少无效凭据/profile重试,准确显示续接、一次消费和源返回各自的剩余证据,未称底层执行路径已完成。future-facing pass已把失效的绝对否定收拢为同一个资格前沿,既有 typed owner 和协议词汇 reuse_existing,无需新框架或平行路线图。强制确认/身份/一次消费是机器边界,60秒和真实adapter步骤是明确待验收条件,未降为可忽略的建议。本COMMENTED结论不授合并或 bypass 权限,closeout/readiness另行回读。

English verdict: APPROVE - f5d0520; the bilingual RFC now distinguishes existing opt-in Codex launch requests from unqualified genuine/native execution and audience return, and separates DSH model readiness from unsupported owned operation transport.16TS and43Python tests plus3direct/11selected premerge checks pass. The actual local DSH module is absent and synthetic import/credential probes do not establish installation or authentication. No adapter, real confirmation, audience delivery or financial authority is shipped or certified here; no merge authority is granted.

@huangruiteng
huangruiteng merged commit ab7dc84 into main Oct 15, 2026
24 of 26 checks passed
@huangruiteng
huangruiteng deleted the codex/operation-transport-remediation-20261015 branch October 15, 2026 04:52
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants